A meta-analysis of brain mechanisms of placebo analgesia: Consistent findings and unanswered questions

Handbook of Experimental Pharmacology

Volumn 225, Issue , 2014, Pages 37-69

  Atlas, Lauren Y ^a   Wager, Tor D ^b  

^a NATIONAL INSTITUTES OF HEALTH   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO   (United States)

Author keywords

Amygdala; Expectancy; fMRI; Meta analysis; MKDA; Neuroimaging; Opioid; Pain; Periaqueductal gray; PET; Placebo effect; Placebo response; Prefrontal cortex

Indexed keywords

PLACEBO; REMIFENTANIL;

AFFECT; AMYGDALOID NUCLEUS; ANALGESIA; ANTERIOR CINGULATE; ARTICLE; CORPUS STRIATUM; DRUG EFFECT; EMOTION; EXPECTATION; FIBROMYALGIA; HUMAN; INSULA; MESENCEPHALON; MYALGIA; NEUROMODULATION; NOCEBO EFFECT; NOCICEPTIVE STIMULATION; ORBITAL CORTEX; PAIN; PLACEBO EFFECT; PREFRONTAL CORTEX; STIMULUS RESPONSE; THALAMUS; VENTROMEDIAL PREFRONTAL CORTEX; VISCERAL PAIN; BRAIN; META ANALYSIS; NEUROIMAGING; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PHYSIOLOGY;

ANALGESIA; BRAIN; HUMANS; NEUROIMAGING; PAIN; PLACEBO EFFECT;

EID: 84907985359     PISSN: 01712004     EISSN: 18650325     Source Type: Book Series    
DOI: 10.1007/978-3-662-44519-8_3     Document Type: Article

References (118)

1. Amanzio M, Benedetti F, Porro CA, Palermo S, Cauda F (2011) Activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis of brain correlates of placebo analgesia in human experimental pain. Hum Brain Mapp 34:738–752.
2. Apkarian AV, Bushnell MC, Treede R-D, Zubieta J-K (2005) Human brain mechanisms of pain perception and regulation in health and disease. Eur J Pain (Lond) 9:463–484.
3. Atlas LY, Wager TD (2012) How expectations shape pain. Neurosci Lett 520:140–148.
4. Atlas LY, Wager TD (2013) Expectancies and beliefs: insights from cognitive neuroscience. In: Ochsner KN, Kosslyn SM (eds) Oxford handbook of cognitive neuroscience. Oxford University Press, Oxford, NY, pp 359–381.
5. Atlas LY, Bolger N, Lindquist MA, Wager TD (2010) Brain mediators of predictive cue effects on perceived pain. J Neurosci 30:12964–12977.
6. Atlas LY, Whittington RA, Lindquist MA, Wielgosz J, Sonty N, Wager TD (2012) Dissociable influences of opiates and expectations on pain. J Neurosci 32:8053–8064.
7. Atlas LY, Wielgosz J, Whittington RA, Wager TD (2014) Specifying the non-specific factors underlying opioid analgesia: expectancy, attention, and affect. Psychopharmacology 231:813–823.
8. Baliki MN, Geha PY, Apkarian AV (2009) Parsing pain perception between nociceptive representation and magnitude estimation. J Neurophysiol 101:875–887.
9. Barrett B, Muller D, Rakel D, Rabago D, Marchand L, Scheder JC (2006) Placebo, meaning, and health. Perspect Biol Med 49:178–198.
10. Baumgartner U, Iannetti GD, Zambreanu L, Stoeter P, Treede R-D, Tracey I (2010) Multiple somatotopic representations of heat and mechanical pain in the operculo-insular cortex: a highresolution fMRI study. J Neurophysiol 104:2863–2872.
11. Beecher HK (1955) The powerful placebo. J Am Med Assoc 159:1602–1606.
12. Benedetti F, Pollo A, Lopiano L, Lanotte M, Vighetti S, Rainero I (2003) Conscious expectation and unconscious conditioning in analgesic, motor, and hormonal placebo/nocebo responses. J Neurosci 23:4315–4323.
13. Bernard JF, Huang GF, Besson JM (1992) Nucleus centralis of the amygdala and the globus pallidus ventralis: electrophysiological evidence for an involvement in pain processes. J Neurophysiol 68:551–569.
14. Bingel U, Lorenz J, Glauche V, Knab R, Glascher J, Weiller C, Buchel C (2004) Somatotopic organization of human somatosensory cortices for pain: a single trial fMRI study. NeuroImage 23:224–232.
15. Bingel U, Lorenz J, Schoell E, Weiller C, Buchel C (2006) Mechanisms of placebo analgesia: rACC recruitment of a subcortical antinociceptive network. Pain 120:8–15.
16. Bingel U, Wanigasekera V, Wiech K, Mhuircheartaigh RN, Lee MC, Ploner M, Tracey I (2011) The effect of treatment expectation on drug efficacy: imaging the analgesic benefit of the opioid remifentanil. Sci Transl Med 3:70ra14.
17. Bornhovd K, Quante M, Glauche V, Bromm B, Weiller C, Buchel C (2002) Painful stimuli evoke different stimulus-response functions in the amygdala, prefrontal, insula and somatosensory cortex: a single-trial fMRI study. Brain 125:1326–1336.
18. Botvinick MM, Cohen JD, Carter CS (2004) Conflict monitoring and anterior cingulate cortex: an update. Trends Cogn Sci 8:539–546.
19. Bushnell MC, Ceko M, Low LA (2013) Cognitive and emotional control of pain and its disruption in chronic pain. Nat Rev Neurosci 14:502–511.
20. Clark WC (1969) Sensory-decision theory analysis of the placebo effect on the criterion for pain and thermal sensitivity. J Abnorm Psychol 74:363–371.
21. Craggs J, Price D, Perlstein W, Nicholas Verne G, Robinson M (2008) The dynamic mechanisms of placebo induced analgesia: evidence of sustained and transient regional involvement. Pain 139:660–669.
22. Craig AD (2002) How do you feel? Interoception: the sense of the physiological condition of the body. Nat Rev Neurosci 3:655–666.
23. Craig ADB (2009) How do you feel—now? The anterior insula and human awareness. Nat Rev Neurosci 10:12.
24. Craig ADB, Chen K, Bandy D, Reiman EM (2000) Thermosensory activation of insular cortex. Nat Neurosci 3:184–190.
25. Critchley HD, Wiens S, Rotshtein P, Ohman A, Dolan RJ (2004) Neural systems supporting interoceptive awareness. Nat Neurosci 7:189–195.
26. Davis M, Whalen PJ (2001) The amygdala: vigilance and emotion. Mol Psychiatry 6:13–34
27. de Craen AJ, Tijssen JG, de Gans J, Kleijnen J (2000) Placebo effect in the acute treatment of migraine: subcutaneous placebos are better than oral placebos. J Neurol 247:183–188.
28. De Pascalis V, Chiaradia C, Carotenuto E (2002) The contribution of suggestibility and expectation to placebo analgesia phenomenon in an experimental setting. Pain 96:393–402.
29. Dosenbach NUF, Visscher KM, Palmer ED, Miezin FM, Wenger KK, Kang HC, Burgund ED, Grimes AL, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2006) A core system for the implementation of task sets. Neuron 50:799–812.
30. Duerden EG, Albanese M-C (2011) Localization of pain-related brain activation: a meta-analysis of neuroimaging data. Hum Brain Mapp 34:109–149.
31. Dum RP, Levinthal DJ, Strick PL (2009) The spinothalamic system targets motor and sensory areas in the cerebral cortex of monkeys. J Neurosci 29:14223–14235.
32. Eickhoff SB, Laird AR, Grefkes C, Wang LE, Zilles K, Fox PT (2009) Coordinate-based activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis of neuroimaging data: a random-effects approach based on empirical estimates of spatial uncertainty. Hum Brain Mapp 30:2907–2926.
33. Eippert F, Bingel U, Schoell ED, Yacubian J, Klinger R, Lorenz J, Buchel C (2009a) Activation of the opioidergic descending pain control system underlies placebo analgesia. Neuron 63:533–543.
34. Eippert F, Finsterbusch J, Bingel U, Buchel C (2009b) Direct evidence for spinal cord involvement in placebo analgesia. Science 326:404.
35. Fields HL (2000) Pain modulation: expectation, opioid analgesia and virtual pain. Prog Brain Res 122:245–253.
36. Fields HL (2004) State-dependent opioid control of pain. Nat Rev Neurosci 5:565–575.
37. Friebel U, Eickhoff S, Lotze M (2011) Coordinate-based meta-analysis of experimentally induced and chronic persistent neuropathic pain. NeuroImage 1–11.
38. Geuter S, Buchel C (2013) Facilitation of pain in the human spinal cord by nocebo treatment. J Neurosci 33:13784–13790.
39. Geuter S, Eippert F, Attar CH, Bühel C (2012) Cortical and subcortical responses to high and low effective placebo treatments. Neuroimage:1–10.
40. Goffaux P, Redmond WJ, Rainville P, Marchand S (2007) Descending analgesia–when the spine echoes what the brain expects. Pain 130:137–143.
41. Gracely RH, Dubner R, Deeter WR, Wolskee PJ (1985) Clinicians’ expectations influence placebo analgesia. Lancet 1:43.
42. Harris RE, Zubieta J-K, Scott DJ, Napadow V, Gracely RH, Clauw DJ (2009) Traditional Chinese acupuncture and placebo (sham) acupuncture are differentiated by their effects on mu-opioid receptors (MORs). NeuroImage 47:1077–1085.
43. Helmstetter FJ (1992) The amygdala is essential for the expression of conditional hypoalgesia. Behav Neurosci 106:518–528.
44. Jensen KB, Petrovic P, Kerr CE, Kirsch I, Raicek J, Cheetham A, Spaeth R, Cook A, Gollub RL, Kong J, Kaptchuk TJ (2013) Sharing pain and relief: neural correlates of physicians during treatment of patients. Mol Psychiatry 19:392–398.
45. Johnston NE, Atlas LY, Wager TD (2012) Opposing effects of expectancy and somatic focus on pain. PLoS ONE 7:e38854.
46. Kaptchuk TJ (2002) The placebo effect in alternative medicine: can the performance of a healing ritual have clinical significance? Ann Intern Med 136:817–825.
47. Kaptchuk TJ, Goldman P, Stone DA, Stason WB (2000) Do medical devices have enhanced placebo effects? J Clin Epidemiol 53:786–792.
48. Keltner J, Furst A, Fan C, Redfern R, Inglis B et al (2006) Isolating the modulatory effect of expectation on pain transmission: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study. J Neurosci 26:4437–4443.
49. Kirsch I (1985) Response expectancy as a determinant of experience and behavior. Am Psychol 40:1189–1202.
50. Kirsch I (1997) Response expectancy theory and application: a decennial review. Appl Prev Psychol 6:69–79.
51. Knutson B, Adams CM, Fong GW, Hommer D (2001) Anticipation of increasing monetary reward selectively recruits nucleus accumbens. J Neurosci 21:RC159.
52. Koban L, Ruzic L, Wager TD (2013) Brain predictors of individual differences in placebo responding. In: Colloca L, Flaten MA, Meissner K (eds) Placebo and pain (89–101). Elsevier/Academic Press, Burlington, MA
53. Kober H, Wager TD (2010) Meta-analysis of neuroimaging data. WIREs Cogn Sci 1:293–300.
54. Kong J, Gollub RL, Rosman IS, Webb JM, Vangel MG, Kirsch I, Kaptachuk TJ (2006) Brain activity associated with expectancy-enhanced placebo analgesia as measured by functional magnetic resonance imaging. J Neurosci 26:381–388.
55. Kong J, Kaptachuk T, Polich G, Kirsch I, Angel M, Zyloney C, Rosen B, Gollub R (2009a) An fMRI study on the interaction and dissociation between expectation of pain relief and acupuncture treatment. NeuroImage 47:1066–1076.
56. Kong J, Kaptachuk TJ, Polich G, Kirsch I, Vangel MG, Zyloney C, Rosen BR, Gollub RL (2009b) Expectancy and treatment interactions: a dissociation between acupuncture analgesia and expectancy evoked placebo analgesia. NeuroImage 45:940–949.
57. Kong J, Jensen K, Loiotile R, Cheetham A, Wey H-Y, Tan Y, Rosen B, Smoller JW, Kaptchuk TJ, Gollub RL (2013) Functional connectivity of the frontoparietal network predicts cognitive modulation of pain. Pain 154:459–467.
58. Koyama T, McHaffie JG, Laurienti P, Coghill RC (2005) The subjective experience of pain: where expectations become reality. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102:12950–12955.
59. Kross E, Berman MG, Mischel W, Smith EE, Wager TD (2011) Social rejection shares somatosensory representations with physical pain. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108:6270–6275.
60. Kulkarni B, Bentley DE, Elliott R, Youell P, Watson A, Derbyshire SW, Frackowiak RS, Friston KJ, Jones AK (2005) Attention to pain localization and unpleasantness discriminates the functions of the medial and lateral pain systems. Eur J Neurosci 21:3133–3142.
61. LaBar KS, Gatenby JC, Gore JC, LeDoux JE, Phelps EA (1998) Human amygdala activation during conditioned fear acquisition and extinction: a mixed-trial fMRI study. Neuron 20:937–945.
62. LeDoux JE (1995) Emotion: clues from the brain. Annu Rev Psychol 46:209–235.
63. Lee H-F, Hsieh J-C, Lu C-L, Yeh T-C, Tu C-H, Cheng C-M, Niddam DM, Lin H-C, Lee F-Y, Chang F-Y (2012) Enhanced affect/cognition-related brain responses during visceral placebo analgesia in irritable bowel syndrome patients. Pain 153:1301–1310.
64. Levine JD, Gordon NC (1984) Influence of the method of drug administration on analgesic response. Nature 312:755–756.
65. Levine JD, Gordon NC, Fields HL (1978) The mechanism of placebo analgesia. Lancet 2:654–657.
66. Liberman R (1964) An experimental study of the placebo response under three different situations of pain. J Psychiatr Res 33:233–246.
67. Lieberman MD, Jarcho JM, Berman S, Naliboff BD, Suyenobu B, Mandelkern M, Mayer EA (2004) The neural correlates of placebo effects: a disruption account. NeuroImage 22:447–455.
68. Liljeholm M, O’Doherty JP (2012) Contributions of the striatum to learning, motivation, and performance: an associative account. Trends Cogn Sci 16:467–475.
69. Lu H-C, Hsieh J-C, Lu C-L, Niddam DM, Wu Y-T, Yeh T-C, Cheng C-M, Chang F-Y, Lee S-D (2010) Neuronal correlates in the modulation of placebo analgesia in experimentally-induced esophageal pain: A 3.T-fMRI study. Pain 148:75–83.
70. Lui F, Colloca L, Duzzi D, Anchisi D, Benedetti F, Porro CA (2010) Neural bases of conditioned placebo analgesia. Pain 151:816–824.
71. Maihöfner C, Herzner B, Otto Handwerker H (2006) Secondary somatosensory cortex is important for the sensory-discriminative dimension of pain: a functional MRI study. Eur J Neurosci 23:1377–1383.
72. Matre D, Casey KL, Knardahl S (2006) Placebo-induced changes in spinal cord pain processing. J Neurosci 26:559–563.
73. Mazzola L, Isnard J, Peyron R, Mauguiere F (2011) Stimulation of the human cortex and the experience of pain: Wilder Penfield’s observations revisited. Brain 135:631–640.
74. Meissner K, Bingel U, Colloca L, Wager TD, Watson A, Flaten MA (2011) The placebo effect: advances from different methodological approaches. J Neurosci 31:16117–16124.
75. Miller EK (2000) The prefrontal cortex and cognitive control. Nat Rev Neurosci 1:59–65.
76. Miller EK, Cohen JD (2001) An integrative theory of prefrontal cortex function. Annu Rev Neurosci 24:167–202.
77. Moerman DE, Jonas WB (2002) Deconstructing the placebo effect and finding the meaning response. Ann Intern Med 136:471–476.
78. Montgomery G, Kirsch I (1996) Mechanisms of placebo pain reduction: an empirical investigation. Psychol Sci 7:174–176.
79. Montgomery GH, Kirsch I (1997) Classical conditioning and the placebo effect. Pain 72:107–113.
80. Murray EA, O’Doherty JP, Schoenbaum G (2007) What we know and do not know about the functions of the orbitofrontal cortex after 20 years of cross-species studies. J Neurosci 27:8166–8169.
81. Petrovic P, Kalso E, Petersson KM, Ingvar M (2002) Placebo and opioid analgesia– imaging a shared neuronal network. Science 295:1737–1740.
82. Petrovic P, Kalso E, Petersson KM, Andersson J, Fransson P, Ingvar M (2010) A prefrontal non-opioid mechanism in placebo analgesia. Pain 150:59–65.
83. Peyron R, Laurent B, Garcia-Larrea L (2000) Functional imaging of brain responses to pain. A review and meta-analysis. Clin Neurophysiol 30:263–288.
84. Phelps EA (2006) Emotion and cognition: insights from studies of the human amygdala. Annu Rev Psychol 57:27–53.
85. Price DD, Milling L, Kirsch I, Duff A (1999) An analysis of factors that contribute to the magnitude of placebo analgesia in an experimental paradigm. Pain 83:147–156.
86. Price DD, Craggs J, Verne G, Perlstein W, Robinson ME (2007) Placebo analgesia is accompanied by large reductions in pain-related brain activity in irritable bowel syndrome patients. Pain 127:63–72.
87. Rainville P (2002) Brain mechanisms of pain affect and pain modulation. Curr Opin Neurobiol 12:195–204.
88. Rainville P, Duncan GH, Price DD, Carrier B et al (1997) Pain affect encoded in human anterior cingulate but not somatosensory cortex. Science 277:968–971.
89. Rainville P, Carrier B, Hofbauer RK, Bushnell MC, Duncan GH (1999) Dissociation of sensory and affective dimensions of pain using hypnotic modulation. Pain 82:159–171.
90. Rogan MT, Sta¨ubli UV, LeDoux JE (1997) Fear conditioning induces associative long-term potentiation in the amygdala. Nature 390:604–607.
91. Rosen JB, Donley MP (2006) Animal studies of amygdala function in fear and uncertainty: relevance to human research. Biol Psychol 73:49–60.
92. Roy M, Shohamy D, Wager T (2012) Ventromedial prefrontal-subcortical systems and the generation of affective meaning. Trends Cogn Sci 16:147–156.
93. Schoenbaum G, Roesch MR, Stalnaker TA, Takahashi YK (2009) A new perspective on the role of the orbitofrontal cortex in adaptive behaviour. Nat Rev Neurosci 10:885–892.
94. Scott DJ, Stohler CS, Egnatuk C, Wang H et al (2007) Individual differences in reward responding explain placebo-induced expectations and effects. Neuron 55:325–336.
95. Scott DJ, Stohler C, Egnatuk C, Wang H, Koeppe R, Zubieta JK (2008) Placebo and nocebo effects are defined by opposite opioid and dopaminergic responses. Arch Gen Psychiatry 65:220–231.
96. Seeley WW, Menon V, Schatzberg AF, Keller J, Glover GH, Kenna H, Reiss AL, Greicius MD (2007) Dissociable intrinsic connectivity networks for salience processing and executive control. J Neurosci 27:2349–2356.
97. Seymour B, O’Doherty JP, Dayan P, Koltzenburg M et al (2004) Temporal difference models describe higher-order learning in humans. Nature 429:664–667.
98. Seymour B, O’Doherty JP, Koltzenburg M, Wiech K et al (2005) Opponent appetitive-aversive neural processes underlie predictive learning of pain relief. Nat Neurosci 8:1234–1240.
99. Shackman AJ, Salomons TV, Slagter HA, Fox AS, Winter JJ, Davidson RJ (2011) The integration of negative affect, pain and cognitive control in the cingulate cortex. Nat Rev Neurosci 12:154–167.
100. Szczepanski SM, Pinsk MA, Douglas MM, Kastner S, Saalmann YB (2013) Functional and structural architecture of the human dorsal frontoparietal attention network. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110:15806–15811.
101. Tölle TR, Kaufmann T, Siessmeier T, Lautenbacher S, Berthele A, Munz F, Zieglgänsberger W, Willoch F, Schwaiger M, Conrad B, Bartenstein P (1999) Region-specific encoding of sensory and affective components of pain in the human brain: a positron emission tomography correlation analysis. Ann Neurol 45:40–47.
102. Wager TD, Atlas LY, Lindquist MA, Roy M, Choong-Wan W, Kross E (2013) An fMRI-based neurologic signature of physical pain. N Engl J Med 368:1388–1397.
103. Wager TD, Fields H (2013) Placebo analgesia. In: McMahon S, Koltzenburg M, Tracey I, and Turk DC (eds) Wall and Melzack’s Textbook of pain, pp 362–373.Philadelphia: Elsevier/ Saunders
104. Wager TD, Rilling JK, Smith EE, Sokolik A, Casey KL, Davidson RJ, Kosslyn SM, Rose RM, Cohen JD (2004) Placebo-induced changes in FMRI in the anticipation and experience of pain. Science 303:1162–1167.
105. Wager T, Lindquist M, Kaplan L (2007a) Meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging data: current and future directions. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci 2:150–158.
106. Wager TD, Scott DJ, Zubieta J-K (2007b) Placebo effects on human μ-opioid activity during pain. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104:11056–11061.
107. Wager TD, Lindquist MA, Nichols TE, Kober H, Snellenberg JXV (2009) Evaluating the consistency and specificity of neuroimaging data using meta-analysis. NeuroImage 45:S210– S221.
108. Wager TD, Atlas LY, Leotti LA, Rilling JK (2011) Predicting individual differences in placebo analgesia: contributions of brain activity during anticipation and pain experience. J Neurosci 31:439–452.
109. Watson A, El-Deredy W, Iannetti G, Lloyd D, Tracey I, Vogt B, Nadeau V, Jones A (2009) Placebo conditioning and placebo analgesia modulate a common brain network during pain anticipation and perception. Pain 145:24–30.
110. Whalen PJ (2007) The uncertainty of it all. Trends Cogn Sci 11:499–500.
111. Whalen PJ, Rauch SL, Etcoff NL, McInerney SC, Lee MB, Jenike MA (1998) Masked presentations of emotional facial expressions modulate amygdala activity without explicit knowledge. J Neurosci 18:411–418.
112. Whalen PJ, Kagan J, Cook RG, Davis FC, Kim H, Polis S, McLaren DG, Somerville LH, McLean AA, Maxwell JS, Johnstone T (2004) Human amygdala responsivity to masked fearful eye whites. Science 306:2061.
113. Wiech K, C-s L, Brodersen KH, Bingel U, Ploner M, Tracey I (2010) Anterior insula integrates information about salience into perceptual decisions about pain. J Neurosci 30:16324–16331.
114. Willis WD, Westlund KN (1997) Neuroanatomy of the pain system and of the pathways that modulate pain. J Clin Neurophysiol 14:2–31.
115. Yarkoni T, Poldrack RA, Nichols TE, Van Essen DC, Wager TD (2011) Large-scale automated synthesis of human functional neuroimaging data. Nat Methods 8:665–670.
116. Zhang W, Luo J (2009) The transferable placebo effect from pain to emotion: changes in behavior and EEG activity. Psychophysiology 46:626–634.
117. Zubieta JK, Smith YR, Bueller JA, Xu Y, Kilbourn MR, Jewett DM, Meyer CR, Koeppe RA, Stohler CS (2001) Regional μ opioid receptor regulation of sensory and affective dimensions of pain. Science 293:311–315.
118. Zubieta J-K, Bueller JA, Jackson L, Scott DJ et al (2005) Placebo effects mediated by endogenous opioid activity on μ-opioid receptors. J Neurosci 25:7754–7762