Comparing instrumental and deliberative paradigms underpinning the assessment of social values for cultural ecosystem services

Ecological Economics

Volumn 107, Issue , 2014, Pages 145-156

  Raymond, Christopher M ^a,b   Kenter, Jasper O ^c   Plieninger, Tobias ^d   Turner, Nancy J ^e   Alexander, Karen A ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA   (Australia)

^b Enviroconnect Pty Ltd   (Australia)

^c SCOTTISH MARINE INSTITUTE   (United Kingdom)

^d UNIVERSITY OF COPENHAGEN   (Denmark)

^e UNIVERSITY OF VICTORIA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Deliberative valuation; Ecosystem services; Instrumental valuation; Non economic valuation; Non monetary valuation; Participatory mapping; Social values

Indexed keywords

COMPARATIVE STUDY; DECISION MAKING; ECOSYSTEM SERVICE; ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT; PARTICIPATORY APPROACH; VALUATION; ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS; PARADIGM SHIFT;

EID: 84906767649     PISSN: 09218009     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2014.07.033     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. Alessa L., Kliskey A., Brown G. Social-ecological hotspots mapping: A spatial approach for identifying coupled social-ecological space. Landsc. Urban Plan. 2008, 85:27-39.
2. Alexander K.A., Janssen R., Arciniegas G., O'Higgins T.G., Eikelboom T., Wilding T.A. Interactive marine spatial planning: Siting tidal energy arrays around the Mull of Kintyre. PLoS ONE 2012, 7(1):e30031.
3. Bang H.P. Culture governance: Governing self-reflexive modernity. Public Adm. 2004, 82:157-190.
4. Bauer M.W., Gaskell G. Social representations Theory: A progressive research programme for Social Psychology. J. Theory Soc. Behav. 2008, 38:335-353.
5. Beierle T.C. The quality of stakeholder-based decisions. Risk Anal. 2002, 22:739-749.
6. Bieling C., Plieninger T., Pirker H., Vogl C.R. Linkages between landscapes and human well-being: An empirical exploration with short interviews. Ecol. Econ. 2014, 105:19-30.
7. Bocking R., Demarchi M., Plate E., Holst M., Muir J. Review of the Enbridge Northern Gateway Project. Unpublished Report. Submission to the Joint Review Panel for Review of the Enbridge Northern Gateway Project, on behalf of the Gitga'at First Nation 2011, (Hartley Bay, BC).
8. Brown G. Public Participation GIS (PPGIS) for regional and environmental planning: Reflections on a decade of empirical research. URISA J. 2012, 24:7-18.
9. Brown G., Raymond C.M. Methods for identifying land use conflict potential using participatory mapping. Landsc. Urban Plan. 2014, 122:196-208.
10. Brown G., Montag J.M., Lyon K. Public Participation GIS: A method for identifying ecosystem services. Soc. Nat. Resour. 2011, 25:633-651.
11. Bryan B.A., Raymond C.M., Crossman N.D., Macdonald D.H. Targeting the management of ecosystem services based on social values: Where, what, and how?. Landsc. Urban Plan. 2010, 97:111-122.
12. Bryan B.A., Raymond C.M., Crossman N.D., King D. Comparing spatially explicit ecological and social values for natural areas to identify effective conservation strategies. Conserv. Biol. 2011, 25:172-181.
13. Calhoun C. Habermas and the public sphere 1992, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
14. CBC (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation), 2014. Northern Gateway Pipeline Approved with 209 Conditions. CBCnews. June 17, 2014. Available from: . http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/northern-gateway-pipeline-approved-with-209-conditions-1.2678285.
15. Chan K.M.A., Guerry A.D., Balvanera P., Klain S., Satterfield T., Basurto X., Bostrom A., Chuenpagdee R., Gould R., Halpern B.S., Levine J., Norton B., Ruckelshaus M., Russell R., Tam J. Where are cultural and social in ecosystem services? A framework for constructive engagement. Bioscience 2012, 62:744-756.
16. Chan K.M.A., Satterfield T., Goldstein J. Rethinking ecosystem services to better address and navigate cultural values. Ecol. Econ. 2012, 74:8-18.
17. Church A., Fish R., Haines-Young R., Mourato S., Tratalos J., Stapleton L., Willis C., Coates P., Gibbons S., Leyshon C., Potschin M., Ravenscroft N., Sanchis-Guarner R., Winter M., Kenter J. UK National Ecosystem Assessment Follow-on. Work Package Report 5: Cultural ecosystem services and indicators 2014, UNEP-WCMC, LWEC, UK.
18. Cooke The Social Psychological Limits of Participation?. Participation: The New Tyranny? 2001, 102-121. Zed Books, London. B. Cooke, U.K. (Eds.).
19. Davies B.B., Hodge I.D. Shifting environmental perspectives in agriculture: Repeated Q analysis and the stability of preference structures. Ecol. Econ. 2012, 83:51-57.
20. Dietz T., Stern P.C., Dan A. How deliberation affects stated willingness to pay for mitigation of carbon dioxide emissions: An experiment. Land Econ. 2009, 85:329-347.
21. Douglas M., Wildavsky A. Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers 1983, University of California Press, London.
22. Edwards D.M., Jay M., Jensen F.S., Lucas B., Marzano M., Montagne C., Peace A., Weiss G. Public preferences across Europe for different forest stand types as sites for recreation. Ecol. Soc. 2012, 17.
23. Enbridge Northern Gateway Piplelines Environmental and Socio-Economic Assessment (ESA) - Human Environment 2010, Vancouver, BC.
24. Fagerholm N., Käyhkö N. Participatory mapping and geographical patterns of the social landscape values of rural communities in Zanzibar, Tanzania. Int. J. Geogr. 2009, 187(1):43-60.
25. Fagerholm N., Käyhkö N., Ndumbaro F., Khamis M. Community stakeholders' knowledge in landscape assessments - Mapping indicators for landscape services. Ecol. Indic. 2012, 18:421-433.
26. Fazey I., Bunse L., Msika J., Pinke M., Preedy K., Evely A.C., Lambert E., Hastings E., Morris S., Reed M.S. Evaluating knowledge exchange in interdisciplinary and multi-stakeholder research. Glob. Environ. Chang. 2014, 25:204-220.
27. Fischer J., Dyball R., Fazey I., Gross C., Dovers S., Ehrlich P.R., Brulle R.J., Christensen C., Borden R.J. Human behavior and sustainability. Front. Ecol. Environ. 2012, 10:153-160.
28. Flint C.G., Kunze I., Muhar A., Yoshida Y., Penker M. Exploring empirical typologies of human-nature relationships and linkages to the ecosystem services concept. Landsc. Urban Plan. 2013, 120:208-217.
29. Forrester J. The deliberative practitioner: Encouraging participatory planning process 1999, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
30. Frame B., Brown J. Developing post-normal technologies for sustainability. Ecol. Econ. 2008, 65:225-241.
31. Frame B., O'Connor M. Integrating valuation and deliberation: the purposes of sustainability assessment. Environ. Sci. Policy 2011, 14:1-10.
32. Funtowicz S.O., Ravetz J.R. Uncertainty and Quality in Science for Policy 1990, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
33. Funtowicz S.O., Ravetz J.R. A new scientific methodology for global environmental issues. Ecological Economics: The Science and Management of Sustainability 1991, Columbia University Press, New York. R. Costanza (Ed.).
34. Funtowicz S.O., Ravetz J.R. Science for the post-normal age. Futures 1993, 25:739-755.
35. Funtowicz S.O., Ravetz J.R. The worth of a songbird: ecological economics as a post-normal science. Ecol. Econ. 1994, 10:197-207.
36. Gaskell G. Attitudes, social representations and beyond. Representations of the Social: Bridging Theoretical Traditions 2001, 228-241. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford. K. Deaux, G. Philogene (Eds.).
37. Gill D.A., Ritchie L.A. A Social Impact Assessment of the Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipeline Project on the Gitga'at First Nation. Unpublished Report. Submission to the Joint Review Panel for Review of the Enbridge Northern Gateway Project, on behalf of the Gitga'at First Nation 2011, (Hartley Bay, BC).
38. Habermas J. The Theory of Communicative Action 1984, Beacon Press, Boston, MA.
39. Hernandez-Morcillo M., Plieninger T., Bieling C. An empirical review of cultural ecosystem service indicators. Ecol. Indic. 2013, 29:434-444.
40. Hockley N. Cost-benefit analysis: A decision-support tool or a venue for contesting ecosystem knowledge?. Environ. Plan. C 2014, 32(2):283-300.
41. Howarth R.B., Wilson M.A. A theoretical approach to deliberative valuation: Aggregation by mutual consent. Land Econ. 2006, 82:1-16.
42. Ives C.D., Kendal D. The role of social values in the management of ecological systems. J. Environ. Manag. 2014, 144C:67-72.
43. Janis I.L. Victims of groupthink: A psychological study of foreign-policy decisions and fiascoes 1972, Houghton Mifflin, Oxford, UK.
44. Kallis G., Gómez-Baggethun E., Zografos C. To value or not to value? That is not the question. Ecol. Econ. 2013, 94:97-105.
45. Kaplowitz M.D., Hoehn J.P. Do focus groups and individual interviews reveal the same information for natural resource valuation?. Ecol. Econ. 2001, 36:237-247.
46. Karjalainen T.P., Marttunen M., Sarkki S., Rytkonen A.-M. Integrating ecosystem services into environmental impact assessment: An analytic-deliberative approach. Environ. Impact Assess. Rev. 2013, 40:54-64.
47. Kenter J.O., Hyde T., Christie M., Fazey I. The importance of deliberation in valuing ecosystem services in developing countries-Evidence from the Solomon Islands. Glob. Environ. Chang. 2011, 21:505-521.
48. Kenter J.O., O'Brien L., Hockley N., Ravenscroft N., Fazey I., Irvine K.N., Reed M.S., Christie M., Brady E., Bryce R., Church A., Cooper N., Davies A., Evely A., Everard M., Fish R., Fisher J.A., Jobstvogt N., Molloy C., Orchard-Webb J., Ranger S., Ryan M., Watson V., Williams S. What are shared and social values of ecosystems?. Ecol. Econ. 2014, (submitted for publication).
49. Kenter J.O., Reed M.S., Irvine K.N., O'Brien E., Brady E., Bryce R., Christie M., Church A., Cooper N., Davies A., Hockley N., Fazey I., Jobstvogt N., Molloy C., Orchard-Webb J., Ravenscroft N., Ryan M., Watson V. UK National Ecosystem Assessment Follow-on. Work Package Report 6: Shared, Plural and Cultural Values of Ecosystems 2014, UNEP-WCMC, LWEC, UK, (Available from: http://www.lwec.org.uk/sharedvalues).
50. Kerr G.N., Swaffield S.R. Identifying cultural service values of a small river in the agricultural landscape of Canterbury, New Zealand, using combined methods. Soc. Nat. Resour. 2012, 25:1330-1339.
51. Klain S.C., Chan K.M.A.A. Navigating coastal values: Participatory mapping of ecosystem services for spatial planning. Ecol. Econ. 2012, 82:104-113.
52. Kothari U. Power, Knowledge and Social Control in Participatory Development. Participation: The New Tyranny? 2001, 139-152. Zed Books, London. B. Cooke, U. Kothari (Eds.).
53. Maes J., Paracchini M.L., Zulian G., Dunbar M.B., Alkemade R. Synergies and trade-offs between ecosystem service supply, biodiversity, and habitat conservation status in Europe. Biol. Conserv. 2012, 155:1-12.
54. Maier N.R. Assets and liabilities in group problem solving: The need for an integrative function. Psychol. Rev. 1967, 74:239-249.
55. Martín-López B., Iniesta-Arandia I., García-Llorente M., Palomo I., Casado-Arzuaga I., Amo D.G.Del, Gómez-Baggethun E., Oteros-Rozas E., Palacios-Agundez I., Willaarts B., González J.A., Santos-Martín F., Onaindia M., López-Santiago C., Montes C. Uncovering ecosystem service bundles through social preferences. PLoS ONE 2012, 7(6):e38970.
56. MEA Ecosystems and human well-being. The Millennium Ecosystem Assessment Series 2005, Island Press, Washington, D.C.
57. Milcu A.I., Hanspach J., Abson D., Fischer J. Cultural ecosystem services: A literature review and prospects for future research. Ecol. Soc. 2013, 18(3):44-77.
58. Moscovici S. Theory and society in social psychology. The Context of Social Psychology: A Critical Assessment 1972, Academic Press, London, UK. J. Isreal, H. Tajfel (Eds.).
59. Moscovici S. The phenomenon of social representations. Social Representations 1984, 3-69. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. R. Farr, S. Moscovici (Eds.).
60. Moscovici S. Notes towards a description of social representations. Eur. J. Soc. Psychol. 1988, 18:211-250.
61. Nahuelhual L., Carmona A., Lozada P., Jaramillo A., Aguayo M. Mapping recreation and ecotourism as a cultural ecosystem service: An application at the local level in Southern Chile. Appl. Geogr. 2013, 40:71-82.
62. National Energy Board Update. Report of the Joint Review Panel for the Enbridge Northern Gateway Project 2013, Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, (December 19, www.gatewaypanel.review-examen.gc.ca/clf-nsi/hm-eng.html).
63. Nielsen-Pincus M., Goldberg C.S., Pocewicz A., Force J.E., Waits L.P., Morgan P., Vierling L. Predicted effects of residential development on a northern Idaho landscape under alternative growth management and land protection policies. Landsc. Urban Plan. 2010, 94:255-263.
64. Norgaard R.B. Ecosystem services: From eye-opening metaphor to complexity blinder. Ecol. Econ. 2010, 69:1219-1227.
65. Oteros-Rozas E., Martín-López B., González J.A., Plieninger T., López C.A., Montes C. Socio-cultural valuation of ecosystem services in a transhumance social-ecological network. Reg. Environ. Chang. 2014, 14:1269-1289.
66. Pacific Wild Enbridge and the JRP http://pacificwild.org/site/our-work/no-tankers/enbridge-joint-review-panel.html.
67. Pielke R. The Honest Broker 2007, Cambridge University Press, New York.
68. Resilience and the Cultural Landscape: Understanding and Managing Change in Human-Shaped Environments 2012, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. T. Plieninger, C. Bieling (Eds.).
69. Plieninger T., Dijks S., Oteros-Rozas E., Bieling C. Assessing, mapping, and quantifying cultural ecosystem services at community level. Land Use Policy 2013, 33:118-129.
70. Ravetz J.R. Usable knowledge, usable ignorance: incomplete science with policy implications. Sustainable Development of the Biosphere 1987, 415-432. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. W.C. Clark, R.E. Munn (Eds.).
71. Raymond C.M., Brown G. A method for assessing protected area allocations using a typology of landscape values. J. Environ. Plan. Manag. 2006, 49:797-812.
72. Raymond C.M., Brown G. Assessing spatial associations between perceptions of landscape value and climate change risk for use in climate change planning. Clim. Change 2011, 104:653-678.
73. Raymond C.M., Bryan B.A., MacDonald D.H., Cast A., Strathearn S., Grandgirard A., Kalivas T. Mapping community values for natural capital and ecosystem services. Ecol. Econ. 2009, 68:1301-1315.
74. Raymond C.M., Fazey I., Reed M.S., Stringer L.C., Robinson G.M., Evely A.C. Integrating local and scientific knowledge for environmental management. J. Environ. Manag. 2010, 91:1766-1777.
75. Raymond C.M., Singh G.G., Benessaiah K., Bernhardt J.R., Levine J., Nelson H., Turner N.J., Norton B., Tam J., Chan K.M.A. Ecosystem services and beyond: Using multiple metaphors to understand human-environment relationships. Bioscience 2013, 63:536-546.
76. Reed M.S. Stakeholder participation for environmental management: A literature review. Biol. Conserv. 2008, 141:2417-2431.
77. Reed M.S., Graves A., Dandy N., Posthumus H., Hubacek K., Morris J., Prell C., Quinn C.H., Stringer L.C. Who's in and why? A typology of stakeholder analysis methods for natural resource management. J. Environ. Manag. 2009, 90:1933-1949.
78. Satterfield T., Robertson L., Turner N.J. Being Gitka'a'ata: A Baseline Report on Gitka'a'ata Way of Life, a Statement of Cultural Impacts Posed by the Northern Gateway Pipeline, and a Critique of the ENGP Assessment Regarding Cultural Impacts 2011.
79. Schaich H., Bieling C., Plieninger T., Biding C. Linking ecosystem services with cultural landscape research. GAIA 2010, 19:269-277.
80. Sherrouse B.C., Clement J.M., Semmens D.J. A GIS application for assessing, mapping, and quantifying the social values of ecosystem services. Appl. Geogr. 2011, 31:748-760.
81. Sherrouse B.C., Semmens D.J., Clement J.M. An application of Social Values for Ecosystem Services (SolVES) to three national forests in Colorado and Wyoming. Ecol. Indic. 2014, 36:68-79.
82. Spash C.L. Deliberative monetary valuation (DMV): Issues in combining economic and political processes to value environmental change. Ecol. Econ. 2007, 63:690-699.
83. Stein S.M., Harper T.L. Power, trust, and planning. J. Plan. Educ. Res. 2003, 23:125-139.
84. Sultana P., Abeyasekera S. Effectiveness of participatory planning for community management of fisheries in Bangladesh. J. Environ. Manag. 2008, 86:201-213.
85. UK NEA UK National Ecosystem Assessment, Follow on Phase: Synthesis Report 2014, (Cambridge, UK).
86. Van Riper C.J., Kyle G.T., Sutton S.G., Barnes M., Sherrouse B.C. Mapping outdoor recreationists' perceived social values for ecosystem services at Hinchinbrook Island National Park, Australia. Appl. Geogr. 2012, 35:164-173.
87. Verburg R., Rodrigues Filho S., Debortoli N., Lindoso D., Nesheim I., Bursztyn M. Evaluating sustainability options in an agricultural frontier of the Amazon using multi-criteria analysis. Land Use Policy 2014, 37:27-39.
88. Whitehead A.L., Kujala H., Ives C.D., Gordon A., Lentini P., Wintle B., Nicholson E., Raymond C.M. Integrating biological and social values when prioritising places for biodiversity conservation. Conserv. Biol. 2014, 10.1111/cobi.12257.