Review: A survey of performance and techniques for automatic epilepsy detection

Journal of Medical and Biological Engineering

Volumn 33, Issue 6, 2013, Pages 526-537

  Orosco, Lorena ^a   Correa, Agustina Garcés ^a   Laciar, Eric ^a  

^a UNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL DE SAN JUAN   (Argentina)

Author keywords

Epilepsy; Performance; Seizure detection algorithm

Indexed keywords

ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM SIGNALS; EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION; EPILEPSY; EPILEPTIC SEIZURE DETECTION; NEUROLOGICAL DISORDERS; PERFORMANCE; PERFORMANCE COMPARISON; SEIZURE DETECTION;

CHAOS THEORY; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; NEUROPHYSIOLOGY; SIGNAL DETECTION; SURVEYS;

DETECTORS;

ALGORITHM; CHAOS THEORY; CLASSIFICATION ALGORITHM; DATA BASE; DATA PROCESSING; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM; EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION; ENTROPY; EPILEPSY; HIDDEN MARKOV MODEL; HUMAN; INDEPENDENT COMPONENT ANALYSIS; INFORMATION PROCESSING; INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY; LYAPUNOV EXPONENT; MATCHING PURSUIT; MATHEMATICAL ANALYSIS; MATHEMATICAL MODEL; MULTIVARIATE ANALYSIS; REVIEW; SEIZURE; WAVELET ANALYSIS;

EID: 84891599531     PISSN: 16090985     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.5405/jmbe.1463     Document Type: Review

References (93)

1. World Health Organization, 2011. Available: http://www.who.int /mediacentre/?factsheets/fs999/en/.
2. J. Gotman, "Automatic detection of seizures and spikes," J. Clin. Neurophysiol., 16: 130-140, 1999.
3. A. G. Stein, H. G Eder, D. E. Blum, A. Drachev and R. S. Fisher, "An automated drug delivery system for focal epilepsy," Epilepsy Res., 39: 103-114, 2000.
4. W Theodore and R. S. Fisher, "Brain stimulation for epilepsy," Lancet Neurol., 3: 111-118, 2004.
5. K. Schindler, C. E. Elger and K. Lehnertz, "Changes of EEG synchronization during low-frequency electric stimulation of the seizure onset zone," Epilepsy Res., 77: 108-119, 2007.
6. I. Osorio and M. Frei, "Real-time detection, quantification, warning, and control of epileptic seizures: The foundations for a scientific epileptology," Epilepsy Behav., 16: 391-396, 2009.
7. F. Mormann, T. Kreuz, R. G. Andrzejak, P. David, K. Lehnertz and C. E. Elger, "Epileptic seizures are preceded by a decrease in synchronization," Epilepsy Res., 53: 173-185, 2003.
8. L. D. Iasemidis, "Epileptic seizure prediction and control," IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., 50: 549-558, 2003.
9. J. C. Sackellares, "Seizure prediction," Epilepsy Curr., 8: 55-59, 2008.
10. L. Kuhlmann, D. Freestone, A. Lai, A. N. Burkitt, K. Fuller, D. B. Grayden, L. Seiderer, S. Vogrin, I. M. Y. Mareels and M. J. Cook, "Patient-specific bivariate-synchrony-based seizure prediction for short prediction horizons," Epilepsy Res., 91: 214-231, 2010.
11. L. Sornmo and P. Laguna, Bioelectrical signal processing in cardiac and neurological applications, USA: Elsevier, 2005.
12. S. Tong and N. V. Thakor (Ed.), Quantitative EEG Analysis Methods and Clinical Applications, Norwood: Artech House, 2009.
13. A. Aarabi, R. Fazel-Rezai and Y Aghakhani, "A fuzzy rule- based system for epileptic seizure detection in intracranial EEG," Clin. Neurophysiol., 120: 1648-1657, 2009.
14. H. Adeli, S. Ghosh-Dastidar and N. Dadmehr, "A Wavelet- Chaos methodology for analysis of EEGs and EEG subbands to detect seizure and epilepsy," IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., 54: 205-211, 2007.
15. S. Sanei and J. Chambers, EEG signal processing, Chichester: Wiley, 2007.
16. P. He, M. Kahle, G. Wilson and C. Russell, "Removal of ocular artifacts from EEG: A comparison of adaptive filtering method and regression method using simulated data," Conf. Proc. IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Soc., 2: 1110-1113, 2005.
17. P. Senthil Kumar, R. Arumuganathan and C. Vimal, "An adaptive method to remove ocular artifacts from EEG signals using Wavelet transform," J. Appl. Sci. Res., 5: 741-745, 2009.
18. N. Mourad, J. P. Reilly, H. de Bruin, G Hasey and D. MacCrimmon, "A simple and fast algorithm for automatic suppression of high-amplitude artifacts in EEG data," IEEE Int. Conf. on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing, 1: I393-I396, 2007.
19. A. Garces Correa, E. Laciar, H. D. Patino and M. E. Valentinuzzi, "Artifact removal from EEG signals using adaptive filters in cascade," J. Phys. Conf. Ser., 90: 012081.
20. E. Acar C A. Bingol, H. Bingol, R. Bro and B. Yener, "Multiway analysis of epilepsy tensors," Bioinformatics, 23: i10-i18, 2007.
21. A. Varsavsky, I., Mareels and M. Cook, Epileptic seizures and the EEG, Boca Raton: CRC Press, 2011.
22. L. Guo, D. Rivero, J. Dorado, J. R. Rabunal and A. Pazos, "Automatic epileptic seizure detection in EEGs based on line length feature and artificial neural networks," J. Neurosci. Methods, 191: 101-109, 2010.
23. Q. Yuan, W. Zhou, S. Li and D. Cai, "Epileptic EEG classification based on extreme learning machine and nonlinear features," Epilepsy Res., 96: 29-38, 2011.
24. W. Deburchgraeve, P. J. Cherian, M. De Vos, R. M. Swarte, J. H. Blok, G. H. Visser, P. Govaert and S. Van Huffel, "Automated neonatal seizure detection mimicking a human observer reading EEG," Clin. Neurophysiol., 119: 2447-2454, 2008.
25. R. Meier, H. Dittrich, A. Schulze-Bonhage and A. Aertsen, "Detecting epileptic seizures in long-term human EEG: A new approach to automatic online and real-time detection and classification of polymorphic seizure patterns," J. Clin. Neurophysiol., 25: 119-131, 2008.
26. G R. Minasyan, J. B. Chatten and R. N. Hamer, "Patient- specific early seizure detection from scalp EEG" J. Clin. Neurophysiol., 27: 163-178, 2010.
27. K. Polat and S. Gunes, "Classification of epileptiform EEG using a hybrid system based on decision tree classifier and fast Fourier transform," Appl. Math. Comput., 187: 1017-1026, 2007.
28. A. M. Chan, F. T. Sun, E. H. Boto and B. M. Wingeier, "Automated seizure onset detection for accurate onset Time Determination in Intracranial EEG;" Clin. Neurophysiol. 119: 2687-2696, 2008.
29. A. J. Gabor, R. R. Leach and F. U. Dowla, "Automated seizure detection using a self-organizing neural network," Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol., 99: 257-266, 1996.
30. A. J. Gabor, "Seizure detection using a self-organizing neural network: validation and comparison with other detection strategies," Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. , 107: 27-32, 1998.
31. J. J. Niederhauser, R. Esteller, J. Echauz, G. Vachtsevanos and B. Litt, "Detection of seizure precursors from depth-EEG using a sign periodogram transform," IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., 50: 449-458, 2003.
32. A. T. Tzallas, M. G. Tsipouras and D. I. Fotiadis, "Automatic seizure detection based on time-frequency analysis and artificial neural networks," Comput. Intell. Neurosci., 80510, 2007.
33. I. Guler and I. G Ubeyli, "Adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system for classification of EEG signals using wavelet coefficients," J. Neurosci. Methods, 148: 113-121, 2005.
34. A. Subasi, "EEG signal classification using wavelet feature extraction and a mixture of expert model," ExpertSyst. Appl., 32: 1084-1093, 2007.
35. B. Abibullaev, M. S. Kim and H. D. Seo, "Seizure detection in temporal lobe Epileptic EEGs using the best basis Wavelet functions," J. Med. Syst., 34: 755-765, 2010.
36. N. Kannathal, M. L. Choob, U. R. Acharya and P. K Sadasivana, "Entropies for detection of epilepsy in EEG," Comput. Meth. Programs Biomed., 80: 187-194, 2005.
37. E. Acar, C. A. Bingol, H. Bingol, R. Bro and B. Yener, "Seizure recognition on epilepsy feature tensor," Conf. Proc. IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Soc., 4273-4276, 2007.
38. E. Acar and B. Yener, "Unsupervised multiway data analysis: A literature survey," IEEE Trans. Knowl. Data Eng., 21: 6-20,2009.
39. M. De Vos, A. Vergult, L. De Lathauwer, W. De Clercq, S. Van Huffel, P. Dupont, A. Palmini and W. Van Paesschen, "Canonical decomposition of ictal scalp EEG reliably detects the seizure onset zone," Neuroimage, 37: 844-854, 2007.
40. M. De Vos, L. De Lathauwer, B. Vanrumste, S. Van Huffel and W. Van Paesschen, "Canonical decomposition of ictal scalp EEG and accurate source localisation: principles and simulation study," Comput. Intell. Neurosci., 58253, 2007.
41. J. Mitra, J. R. Glover, P. Y. Ktonas, A. T. Kumar, A. Mukherjee, N. B. Karayiannis, J. D. Frost Jr., R. A. Hrachovy and E. M. Mizrahi, "A multi-stage system for the automated detection of epileptic seizures in neonatal EEG;" J. Clin. Neurophysiol., 26: 218-226, 2009.
42. E. D. Ubeyli, "Analysis of EEG signals by implementing eigenvector methods/recurrent neural networks," Digit. Signal Prog., 19: 134-143, 2009.
43. H. Adeli and S. Ghosh-Dastidar, Automated EEG-based diagnosis of neurological disorders-inventing the future of neurology, Florida: CRC press, 2010.
44. J. Gotman, "Automatic recognition of epileptic seizures in the EEG;" Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 54: 530-540, 1982.
45. J. Gotman, "Automatic seizure detection: Improvements and evaluation," Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol., 76: 317-324, 1990.
46. M. E. Saab and J. Gotman, "A system to detect the onset of epileptic seizures in scalp EEG," Clin. Neurophysiol., 116: 427-442, 2005.
47. U. R. Acharya, S. V. Sree and J. S. Suri, "Automatic detection of epileptic EEG signals using higher order cumulant features," Int. J. Neural. Syst., 21: 403-414, 2011.
48. K. C. Chua, V. Chandran, U. R. Acharya and C. M. Lim, "Automatic identification of epilepsy by HOS and power spectrum parameters using EEG signals: A comparative study," Conf. Proc. IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Soc., 3824-3827, 2008.
49. K. C. Chua, V. Chandran, U. R. Acharya and C. M. Lim, "Application of higher order spectra to identify epileptic EEG," J. Med. Syst., 35: 1563-1571, 2011.
50. X. Du, S. Dua, U. R. Acharya and K. C. Chua, "Classification of epilepsy using high-order spectra features and principle component analysis," J. Med. Syst., 36: 1731-1743, 2012.
51. A. Aarabi, F. Wallois and R. Grebe, "Automated neonatal seizure detection: A multistage classification system through feature selection based on relevance and redundancy analysis," Clin. Neurophysiol., 117: 328-340, 2006.
52. L. Orosco, A. Garces Correa and E. Laciar Leber, "Epileptic seizures detection based on empirical mode decomposition of EEG signals," in:Prof. Mintaze Kerem Gunel (Ed.), Management of Epilepsy-Research, Results and Treatment, 3-20, Austria: IN-TEcH Publishing, 2011.
53. J. L. Semmlow, Biosignal and biomedical image processing, New York: Marcel Dekker, 2004.
54. A. Subasi, "Epileptic seizure detection using dynamic wavelet network," Expert Syst. Appl., 29: 343-355, 2005.
55. A. Subasi, "Automatic detection of epileptic seizure using dynamic fuzzy neural networks," Expert Syst. Appl., 31: 320-328, 2006.
56. Y. U. Khan, O. Farooq and P. Sharma, "Automatic detection of seizure onset in pediatric EEQ" Int. J. Emb. Syst. Appl., 2: 81-89, 2012.
57. A. Shoeb, H. Edwards, J. Connolly, B. Bourgeois, S. T. Treves and J. Guttag, "Patient-specific seizure onset detection," Epilepsy Behav., 5: 483-498, 2004.
58. N. E. Huang, Z. Shen, S. R. Long, M. C. Wu, H. H. Shih, Q. Zheng, N. C. Yen, C. C. Tung and H. H. Liu, "The empirical mode decomposition and the Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and non-stationary time series analysis," Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 454: 903-995, 1998.
59. R. J. Oweis and E. W. Abdulhay, "Seizure classification in EEG signals utilizing Hilbert-Huang transform," Biomed. Eng. Online, 10: 38, 2011.
60. V. Bajaj and R. B. Pachori, "Epileptic seizure detection based on the instantaneous area of analytic intrinsic mode functions of EEG signals," Biomed. Eng. Lett., 3:17-21, 2013.
61. P. Durka, Matching pursuit and unification in EEG analysis, Norwood: Artech House, 2007.
62. S. B. Wilson, M. L. Scheuer, R. G. Emerson and A. J. Gabor, "Seizure detection: evaluation of the Reveal algorithm," Clin. Neurophysiol., 115: 2280-2291, 2004.
63. U. R. Acharya, S. V. Sree, S. Chattopadhyay, W. Yu and P. C. Ang, "Application of recurrence quantification analysis for the automated identification of epileptic EEG signals," Int. J. Neural Syst. 21: 199-211, 2011.
64. P. Grassberger and T. Schrieber, "Nonlinear time sequence analysis," Int. J. Bifurcation Chaos, 1: 512-547, 1991.
65. S. M. Pincus, "Approximate entropy (ApEn) as a complexity measure," Int. J. Bifurcation Chaos, 5: 110-117, 1991.
66. J. Stone, Independent Component Analysis: A tutorial introduction, Massachusetts: The MIT Press, 2004.
67. M. De Vos, W. Deburchgraeve, P. J. Cherian, V. Matic, R. M. Swarte, P. Govaert, G H. Visser and S. Van Huffel, "Automated artifact removal as preprocessing refines neonatal seizure detection," Clin. Neurophysiol., 122: 2345-2354, 2011.
68. H. Velez-Perez, R. Romo-Vazquez, R. Ranta, V. Louis-Dorr and L. Maillard, "EEG preprocessing for synchronization estimation and epilepsy lateralization," Conf. Proc. IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Soc., 5028-5031, 2011.
69. R. Romo-Vazquez, H. Velez-Perez, R. Ranta, V Louis-Dorr and L. Maillard, "Blind source separation, wavelet denoising and discriminant analysis for EEG artefacts and noise cancelling," Biomed. Signal Process. Control, 7: 389-400, 2012.
70. B. Yener, E. Acar, P. Aguis, K. Bennett, S. L. Vandenberg and G E. Plopper, "Multiway modeling and analysis in stem cell systems biology," BMCSyst. Biol., 2: 63, 2008.
71. H. Ocak, "Automatic detection of epileptic seizures in EEG using discrete wavelet transform and approximate entropy," Expert Syst. Appl., 36: 2027-2036, 2009.
72. E. D. Ubeyli, "Combined neural network model employing wavelet coefficients for EEG signals classification," Digit. Signal Prog., 19: 297-308, 2009.
73. E. D. Ubeyli, "Decision support systems for time-varying biomedical signals: EEG signals classification," Expert Syst. Appl., 36: 2275-2284, 2009.
74. S. M. Shafiul Alam and M. I. H. Bhuiyan, "Detection of seizure and epilepsy using higher order statistics in the EMD domain," IEEE J. Biomed. Health Inform., 17: 312-318, 2013.
75. S. Mihandoost M. Amirani1 M. Mazlaghani A. Mihandoost,"Automatic feature extraction using generalized autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity model: an application to electroencephalogram classification," IET Signal Process., 6: 829-838, 2012.
76. S. Sabesan, L. Iasemidis, K. Tsakalis, D. M. Treiman and J. Sirven, "Use of dynamical measures in prediction and control of focal and generalized epilepsy," in: I. Osorio, H. P. Zaveri, M. G Frei, S. Arthurs (Ed.), Epilepsy: The Intersection of Neurosciences, Biology, Mathematics, Engineering and Physics, Boca Raton: CRC Press, 307-319, 2011.
77. U. Orhan, M. Hekim and M. Ozer, "EEG signals classification using the K-means clustering and a multilayer perceptron neural network model," Expert Syst. Appl., 38: 13475-13481, 2011.
78. A. Schad, K. Schindler, B. Schelter, A. Brandt, T. Maiwald, J. Timmer and A. Schulze-Bonhage, "Application of a multivariate seizure detection and prediction method to non-invasive and intracranial long-term EEG recordings," Clin. Neurophysiol. 119: 197-211, 2008.
79. A. B. Gardner, G. Worrell, A. E. Marsh, D. Dlugos and B. Litt, "Human and automated detection of high-frequency oscillations in clinical intracranial EEG recordings," Clin. Neurophysiol., 118: 1134-1143, 2007.
80. A. Zandi, M. Javidan, G. A. Dumont and R. Tafreshi, "Automated real-time epileptic seizure detection in scalp EEG recordings using an algorithm based on wavelet packet transform," IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., 57: 1639-1651, 2010.
81. E. D. Marsh, B. Peltzer, M. W. Brown III, C. Wusthoff, P. B. Storm Jr., B. Litt and B. E. Porter, "Interictal EEG spikes identify the region of electrographic seizure onset in some, but not all, pediatric epilepsy patients," Epilepsia, 51: 592-601, 2010.
82. S. Raghunathan, A. Jaitli and P. P. Irazoqui, "Multistage seizure detection techniques optimized for low-power hardware platforms," Epilepsy Behav., 22: S61-S68, 2011.
83. A. B. Gardner, A. M. Krieger, G. Vachtsevanos and B. Litt, "One-class novelty detection for seizure analysis from intracranial EEG" J. Mach. Learn Res., 7: 1025-1044, 2006.
84. F. Cong, Y. Huang, I. Kalyakin, H. Li, T. Huttunen-Scott, H. Lyytinen and T. Ristaniemi1, "Frequency-response-based wavelet decomposition for extracting children's mismatch negativity elicited by uninterrupted sound," J. Med. Biol. Eng., 32: 205-214, 2012.
85. S. Sunderam, "How to Detect and Quantify Epileptic Seizures," in: I. Osorio, H. P. Zaveri, M. G Frei, S. Arthurs (Ed.), Epilepsy: The intersection of neurosciences, biology, mathematics, engineering and physics, Boca Raton: CRC Press, 139-164, 2011.
86. A. Temko, E. Thomas, W. Marnanea, G. Lightbody and G. Boylan, "Performance assessment for EEG-based neonatal seizure detectors," Clin. Neurophysiol., 122: 474-482, 2011.
87. A. Temko, E. Thomas, W. Marnanea, G. Lightbody and G. Boylan, "EEG-based neonatal seizure detection with Support Vector Machines," Clin. Neurophysiol., 122: 464-473, 2011.
88. D. E. Snyder, J. Echauz, D. B. Grimes and B. Litt, "The statistics of a practical seizure warning system," J. Neural Eng., 5: 392-401, 2008.
89. FSPEEG Database (with permission), Available: https:/ /epilepsy. uni-freiburg.de/freiburg-seizure-prediction-project/eeg-database, (Downloaded 2008).
90. R. G. Andrzejak, K. Lehnertz, F. Mormann, C. Rieke, P. David and C. E. Elger, "Indications of nonlinear deterministic and finite-dimensional structures in time series of brain electrical activity: Dependence on recording region and brain state," Phys. Rev. E, 64: 061907/1-061907/8, 2001.
91. A. T. Tzallas, M. G. Tsipouras, D. G Tsalikakis, E. C. Karvounis, L. Astrakas, S. Konitsiotis and M. Tzaphlidou, "Automated epileptic seizure detection methods: A review study," in: Dr. Dejan Stevanovic (Ed.), Epilepsy-Histological, Electro- encephalographic and Psychological Aspects, Croatia, 75-98, 2012.
92. CHB-MIT Scalp EEG Database. A. L. Goldberger, L. A. N. Amaral, L. Glass, J. M. Hausdorff, P. Ch. Ivanov, R. G. Mark, J. E. Mietus, G. B. Moody, C. K. Peng, H. E. Stanley, "PhysioBank, PhysioToolkit and PhysioNet: components of a new research resource for complex physiologic signals," Circulation, 101: E215-E220, 2000.
93. S. Grewal and J. Gotman, "An automatic warning system for epileptic seizures recorded on intracerebral EEGs," Clin. Neurophysiol., 116: 2460-2472, 2005.