How should technology-mediated organizational change be explained? A comparison of the contributions of critical realism and activity theory

MIS Quarterly: Management Information Systems

Volumn 37, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 835-854

  Allen, David K ^a   Brown, Andrew ^a   Karanasios, Stan ^a   Norman, Alistair ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Activity theory; Critical realism; Evaluation; Information systems; Organization change; Theory

Indexed keywords

ACTIVITY COEFFICIENTS; INFORMATION SYSTEMS; MEDICAL COMPUTING; PATIENT TREATMENT;

ACTIVITY THEORY; CRITICAL REALISMS; EVALUATION; ORGANIZATION CHANGES; THEORY;

INFORMATION MANAGEMENT;

EID: 84887438659     PISSN: 02767783     EISSN: 21629730     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.25300/MISQ/2013/37.3.08     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Ackroyd, S., Harper, R., Hughes, J.A., Shapiro, D., and Soothill, K. 1992. New Technology and Practical Police Work: The Social Context of Technical Innovation, Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
2. Allen, D., and Karanasios, S. 2011. "Critical Factors and Patterns in the Innovation Process," Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice (5: 1), pp. 87-97.
3. Allen, D., Karanasios, S., and Slavova, M. 2011. "Working with Activity Theory: Context, Technology, and Information Behavior," Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology (62:4), pp. 776-788.
4. Allen , D. K., and Wilson, T. D. 2004. "Action, Interaction and the Role of Ambiguity in the Introduction of Mobile Information Systems in a UK Police Force," in Proceedings of the IFIP TC8 Working Conference on Mobile Information Systems, E. Lawrence, B. Pernici, and J. Krogstie (eds.), New York: Springer, pp. 15-37.
5. Archer, M. 1995. Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
6. Archer, M. 1996. Culture and Agency (2nd ed., rev.), Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
7. Archer, M., and Elder-Vass, D. 2012. "Cultural System or Norm Circles? An Exchange," European Journal of Social Theory (15:1), pp. 93-115.
8. Bakhurst, D. 1991. Consciousness and Revolution in Soviet Philosophy: From the Bolsheviks to Ilyenkov, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
9. Beynon-Davis, P. 1995. "Information System 'Failure' and Risk Assessment: The Case of the London Ambulance Service Computer Aided Despatch System," in Proceedings of the Third European Conference on Information Systems, G. I. Doukidis, B. Galliers, T. Jelassi, H. Krecmar, and F. Land (eds.), Athens, Greece, pp. 1153-1170.
10. Beynon-Davis, P. 1999. "Human Error and Information Systems Failure: The Case of the London Ambulance Service Computer- Aided Despatch System Project," Interacting with Computers (11), pp. 699-720.
11. Bhaskar, R. 1975. Realist theory of Science, London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
12. Bhaskar, R. 1979. The Possibility of Naturalism, Hemel Hempstead, UK: Harvester.
13. Blunden, A. 2010. An Interdisciplinary Theory of Activity, Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.
14. Brivot, M., and Gendron, Y. 2011. "Beyond Panopticism: On the Ramifications of Surveillance in a Contemporary Professional Setting," Accounting, Organizations and Society (36: 3), pp. 135-155.
15. Brooks, L., Atkinson, C., and Wainwright, D. 2008. "Adapting Structuration Theory to Understand the Role of Reflexivity: Problematization, Clinical Audit and Information Systems," International Journal of Information Management (28:6), pp. 453-460.
16. Brown, A. 2002. "Developing Realistic Philosophy: From Critical Realism to Materialist Dialectics," in Critical Realism and Marxism, A. Brown, S. Fleetwood, and J. M. Roberts (eds.). London: Routledge. pp.168-86
17. Brown, A., Slater, G., and Spencer, D. A. 2002. "Driven to Abstraction? Critical Realism and the Search for the 'Inner Connection' of Social Phenomena," Cambridge Journal of Economics (26:6), pp. 773-788.
18. Buckley, W. F. 1967. Sociology and Modern Systems Theory, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
19. Capper, P., and Williams, B. 2004. "Enhancing Evaluation Using Systems Concepts," American Evaluation Association, November (http://users.actrix.co.nz/bobwill/activity.doc; accessed February 27, 2012).
20. Carlsson, S. A. 2012. "The Potential of Critical Realism in IS Research," in Information Systems Theory, Y. K. Dwivedi, M. R. Wade, and S. L. Schneberger (eds.). New York: Springer, pp. 281-304.
21. Cole, M., and Engeström, Y. 1993. "A Cultural-Historical Approach to Distributed Cognition," in Distributed Cognitions, Psychological and Educational Considerations, G. Salomon (ed.), Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 1-46.
22. Comfort, L. K. 1994. "Self-Organization in Complex Systems," Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory (4: 3), pp. 393-410.
23. Daniels, H. 2001. Vygotsky and Pedagogy, London: Routledge Falmer.
24. Davis, F. D. 1989. "Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, and User Acceptance of Information Technology," MIS Quarterly (13:3), pp. 319-340.
25. DeLone, W. H., and McLean, E. R. 2003. "The DeLone and McLean Model of Information Systems Success: A Ten-Year Update," Journal of Management Information Systems (19:4), pp. 9-30.
26. Dobson, P., Myles, J., and Jackson, P. 2007. "Making the Case for Critical Realism: Examining the Implementation of Automated Performance Management Systems," Information Resources Management Journal (20:2), pp. 138-152.
27. Doolin, B. 2003. "Narratives of Change: Discourse, Technology and Organization," Organization (10:4), pp. 751-770.
28. Eisenhardt, K. M. 1995. "Building Theories from Case Study Research," in Longitudinal Field Research Methods: Study Processes of Organizational Change, G. P. Huber and A. H. Van de Ven (eds.), London: Sage Publications, pp. 65-90.
29. Elder-Vass, D. 2010. The Causal Power of Social Structures: Emergence, Structure and Agency, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
30. Elmes, M. B., Strong, D. M., and Volkoff, O. 2005. "Panoptic Empowerment and Reflective Conformity in Enterprise Systems- Enabled Organizations," Information and Organization (15:1), pp. 1-37.
31. Engeström, Y. 1987. Learning by Expanding: An Activity- Theoretical Approach to Developmental Research, Helsinki: Orienta-Konsultit.
32. Engeström, Y. 1993. "Developmental Studies of Work as a Testbench of Activity Theory: The Case of Primary Care Medical Practice," in Understanding Practice: Perspectives on Activity and Context, S. Chaiklin and J. Lave (eds.), Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 64-103.
33. Engeström, Y. 2000. "Activity Theory as a Framework for Analyzing and Redesigning Work," Ergonomics (43:7), pp. 960-974.
34. Engeström, Y. 2001. "Expansive Learning at Work: Toward an Activity Theoretical Reonceptualization," Journal of Education and Work (14:1), pp. 133-156.
35. Fairclough, N., Jessop, B., and Sayer, A. 2004. "Critical Realism and Semiosis," in Realism, Discourse and Deconstruction, J. Joseph and J. M. Roberts (eds.), London: Routledge, pp. 23-42.
36. Faulkner, P., and Runde, J. 2009. "On the Identity of Technological Objects and User Innovations in Function," Academy of Management Review (34:3), pp. 442-462.
37. Faulkner, P., and Runde, J. 2011. "The Social, the Material, and the Ontology of Non-Material Technological Objects," in Proceedings of the 27th EGOS Colloquium, July 6-9, Gothenburg, Sweden, pp. 1-33.
38. Fitzgerald, G., and Russo, N. L. 2005. "The Turnaround of the London Ambulance Service Computer-Aided Despatch System (LASCAD)," European Journal of Information Systems (14), pp. 244-257.
39. Fleetwood, S. 2005. "Ontology in Organization and Management Studies: A Critical Realist Perspective," Organization (12:2), pp. 197-222.
40. Foot, K. A. 2001. "Cultural-Historical Activity Theory as Practice Theory: Illuminating the Development of Conflict-Monitoring Network," Communication Theory (11), pp. 56-83.
41. Fuentes, R., Gómez, J., Pavón, J., and Uden, L. 2004. "Activity Theory Applied to Requirements Elicitation of Multi-Agent Systems," in Proceedings of the First International Workshop on Activity Theory Based Practical Methods for IT-Design, O. W. Bertelsen, M. Korpela, and A. Mursu (eds.), September 2-3, Copenhagen, pp. 22-31.
42. Guy, E. S. 2005. "'...real, concrete facts about what works ...': Integrating Evaluation and Design Through Patterns," in Proceedings of the 2005 International ACM SIGGROUP Conference on Supporting Group Work, N. Pendergast, K. Schmidt, G. Mark, and M. Ackerman (eds.), New York: ACM Press, pp. 99-108.
43. Harvey, L. J., and Myers, M. D. 2002. "Scholarship and Practice: The Contribution of Ethnographic Research Methods to Bridging the Gap," in Qualitative Research in Information Systems: A Reader, M. D. Myers and D. E. Avison (eds.), London: Sage Publications, pp. 169-180.
44. Helle, M. 2000. "Disturbances and Contradictions as Tools for Understanding Work in the Newsroom," Scandinavian Journal of Information Systems (12:1), pp. 81-113.
45. Hougham, M. 1996. "London Ambulance Computer Aided Dispatch System," International Journal of Project Management (14: 2), pp. 103-110.
46. Ilyenkov, E. V. 1977. Dialectical Logic: Essays on its Theory and History, Moscow: Progress.
47. Ilyenkov, E. V. 1982. The Dialectics of the Abstract and the Concrete in Marx's "Capital", Moscow: Progress.
48. Jones, P. E. 2009. "Breaking Away from Capital? Theorising Activity in the Shadow of Marx," Outlines (11:1), pp. 45-58.
49. Jones, R. A., Jimmieson, N. L., and Griffiths, A. 2005. "The Impact of Organizational Culture and Reshaping Capabilities on Change Implementation Success: The Mediating Role of Readiness for Change," Journal of Management Studies (42:2), pp. 361-386.
50. Kaptelinin, V., Nardi, B. A., and Macaulay, C. 1999. "The Activity Checklist: A Tool for Representing the 'Space' of Context," Interactions (6:4), pp. 27-39.
51. Karanasios, S., Allen, D., and Vardaxoglou, G. 2009. "Innovation in UK Law Enforcement: The Emergence of Mobile Data," in Proceedings of the 15th Americas Conference on Information Systems, August 6-9, San Francisco.
52. Khoo, H. M., and Robey, D. 2007. "Deciding to Upgrade Packaged Software: A Comparative Case Study of Motives, Contingencies and Dependencies," European Journal of Information Systems (16:5), pp. 555-567.
53. Kim, H.-W., and Kankanhalli, A. 2009. "Investigating User Resistance to Information Systems Implementation: A Status Quo Bias Perspective," MIS Quarterly (33: 3), pp. 567-582.
54. Kuutti, K. 1999. "Activity Theory, Transformation of Work, and Information Systems Design," in Perspectives on Activity Theory-Learning in Doing: Social, Cognitive and Computational Perspectives, Y. Engeström, R. Miettinen, and R.-L. Punamäki-Gitai (eds.), Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 360-376.
55. Leont'ev, A. N. 1978. Activity, Consciousness, and Personality, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
56. Levins, R. 1998. "Dialectics and Systems Theory," Science and Society (62:3), pp. 375-399.
57. Licoppe, C., and Smoreda, Z. 2005. "Are Social Networks Technologically Embedded? How Networks Are Changing Today with Changes in Communication Technology," Social Networks (27:4), pp. 317-335.
58. Lyytinen, K., and Newman, M. 2008. "Explaining Information Systems Change: A Punctuated Socio-Technical Change Model," European Journal of Information Systems (17), pp. 589-613.
59. Manning, P. K. 1996. "Information Technology in the Police Context: The 'Sailor' Phone," Information Systems Research (7:1), pp. 52-62.
60. McGrath, K. 2002. "The Golden Circle: A Way of Arguing and Acting About Technology in the London Ambulance Service," European Journal of Information Systems, (11), pp. 251-266.
61. Mingers, J. 2001. "Combining IS Research Methods: Towards a Pluralist Methodology," Information Systems Research (12:3), pp. 240-259.
62. Mingers, J. 2006. Realizing Systems Thinking: Knowledge and Action in Management Science, New York: Springer.
63. Mingers, J. 2011. "The Contribution of Systemic Thought to Critical Realism," Journal of Critical Realism (10: 3), pp. 303-330.
64. Murphy, E., and Rodriguez-Manzanares, M. A. 2008a. "Contradictions Between the Virtual and Physical High School Classroom: A Third-Generation Activity Theory Perspective," British Journal of Educational Technology (39:6), pp. 1061-1072.
65. Murphy, E., and Rodriguez-Manzanares, M. A. 2008b. "Using Activity Theory and its Principle of Contradictions to Guide Research in Educational Technology," Australasian journal of Educational Technology (24:4), pp. 442-457.
66. Mutch, A. 2010. "Technology, Organization and Structure: A Morphogenetic Approach," Organization Science (21:2), pp. 507-520.
67. Nardi, B., and O'Day, V. 1999. Information Ecologies, Using Technology with Heart, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
68. Nelhaus, T. 2007. "Culture, Cultural Analysis," in Dictionary of Critical Realism, M. Hartwig (ed.), London: Routledge, pp. 109-111.
69. Nelson, C. 2002. " Contradictions in Learning to Write in a Second Language Classroom: Insights from Radical Constructivism, Activity Theory, and Complexity Theory," unpublished doctoral dissertation, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX.
70. O'Leary, D. E. 2010. "Enterprise Ontologies: Review and an Activity Theory Approach," International Journal of Accounting Information Systems (11:4), pp. 336-352.
71. Orlikowski, W. J. 2010. "The Sociomateriality of Organizational Life: Considering Technology in Management Research," Cambridge Journal of Economics (34:1), pp. 125-141.
72. Oroviogoicoechea, C., and Watson, R. 2009. "A Quantitative Analysis of the Impact of a Computerized Information System on Nurses' Clinical Practice Using a Realistic Evaluation Framework," International Journal of Medical Informatics (78:12), pp. 839-849.
73. Petter, S., DeLone, W., and McLean, E. 2008. "Measuring Information Systems Success: Models, Dimensions, Measures, and Interrelationships," European Journal of Information Systems (17:3), pp. 236-263.
74. Pica, D., Sørensen, C., and Allen , D. K. 2004. "On Mobility and Context of Work: Exploring Mobile Police Work," in Proceedings of the 37th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, January 5-8, Los Alamitos, CA: IEEE Computer Society Press.
75. Quek, A., and Shah, H. 2004. "The Activity Theoretical Iterative Evaluation Method," in Proceedings of the 1st International Workshop on Activity Theory Based Practical Methods for IT Design, O. W. Bertelsen, M. Korpela, and A. Mursu (eds.), Copenhagen, Denmark.
76. Rowley, J., and Urquhart, C. 2007. "Understanding Student Information Behavior in Relation to Electronic Information Services: Lessons from Longitudinal Monitoring and Evaluation, Part 1," Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology (58:8), pp. 1162-1174.
77. Sawyer, S., and Southwick, R. 2002. "Temporal Issues in Information and Communication Technology Enabled Organizational Change: Evidence from an Enterprise Systems Implementation," The Information Society (18), pp. 263-280.
78. Sayer, A. 1992. Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach, London: Routledge.
79. Shannon, C., and Weaver, W. 1949. The Mathematical Theory of Communication, Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.
80. Sintchenko, V., and Coiera, E. W. 2003. "Which Clinical Decisions Benefit from Automation? A Task Complexity Approach," International Journal of Medical Informatics (70), pp. 309-316.
81. Sørensen, C., and Pica, D. 2005. "Tales from the Police: Rhythms of Interaction with Mobile Technologies," Information and Organization (15:2), pp. 125-149.
82. Spasser, M. A. 1999. "Informing Information Science: The Case for Activity Theory," Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology (50:12), pp. 1136-1138.
83. Strong, D. M., and Volkoff, O. 2010. "Understanding Organization- Enterprise Fit: A Path to Theorizing the Information Technology Artifact," MIS Quarterly (34:4), pp. 731-756.
84. Venkatesh, V., Morris, M., Davis, G., and Davis, F. 2003. "User Acceptance of Information Technology: Toward a Unified View," MIS Quarterly (27:3), pp. 425-478.
85. Volkoff, O., Strong, D. M., and Elmes, M. B. 2007. "Technological Embeddedness and Organizational Change," Organization Science (18:5), pp. 832-848.
86. Von Bertalanffy, L. 1971. General Systems Theory, London: Penguin.
87. Vygotsky, L. 1978. Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
88. Wastell, D., and Newman, M. 1996. " Information Systems Design, Stress and Organisational Change in the Ambulance Services: A Tale of Two Cities.," Accounting, Management & Information Technology (6:4), pp. 283-299.
89. Wheelahan, L. 2007. "Blending Activity Theory and Critical Realism to Theorise the Relationship Between the Individual and Society and the Implications for Pedagogy," Studies in the Education of Adults (39:2), pp. 183-196.
90. Wiener, N. 1948. Cybernetics: Or Communication and Control in the Animal and the Machine, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
91. Wilson, T. D. 2008. "Activity Theory and Information Seeking," Annual Review of Information Science and Technology (42), pp. 119-161.
92. Wiredu, G. O. 2007. "User Appropriation of Mobile Technologies: Motives, Conditions and Design Properties," Information and Organization (17:2), pp. 110-129.
93. Wiredu, G. O., and Sørensen, C. 2006. "The Dynamics of Control and Mobile Computing in Distributed Activities," European Journal of Information Systems (15), pp. 307-319.
94. Zuboff, S. 1988. In the Age of the Smart Machine, New York: Basic Books