Crystallographic model validation: From diagnosis to healing

Current Opinion in Structural Biology

Volumn 23, Issue 5, 2013, Pages 707-714

  Richardson, Jane S ^a   Prisant, Michael G ^a   Richardson, David C ^a  

^a DUKE UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

GLYCAN; LIGAND; MEMBRANE PROTEIN;

ACCESS TO INFORMATION; ACCURACY; AUTOMATION; CHEMICAL STRUCTURE; CRYSTAL STRUCTURE; CRYSTALLOGRAPHIC MODEL VALIDATION; DATA MINING; HUMAN; HYDROGEN BOND; INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDURES; MODEL DIAGNOSIS; MODEL HEALING; MOLECULAR INTERACTION; PARAGON STRUCTURE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROTEIN CONFORMATION; PROTEIN DATABASE; QUALITY CONTROL; REFERENCE DATABASE; REVIEW; STRUCTURE ACTIVITY RELATION; STRUCTURE ANALYSIS; SYSTEMATIC ERROR; VALIDATION PROCESS;

CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, X-RAY; DATABASES, PROTEIN; INTERNET; MODELS, MOLECULAR; PROTEINS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS;

EID: 84885868627     PISSN: 0959440X     EISSN: 1879033X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.sbi.2013.06.004     Document Type: Review

References (70)

1. Read R.J., Adams P.D., Arendall W.B., Brunger A.T., Emsley P., Joosten R.P., Kleywegt G.J., Krissinel E.B., Lütteke T., Otwinowski Z., et al. A new generation of crystallographic validation tools for the protein data bank. Structure 2011, 19:1395-1412.
2. Engh R.A., Huber R. Accurate bond and angle parameters for X-ray protein structure refinement. Acta Crystallogr 1991, A47:392-400.
3. Parkinson G., Vojtechovsky J., Clowney L., Brünger A.T., Berman H.M. New parameters for the refinement of nucleic acid containing structures. Acta Crystallogr 1996, D52:57-64.
4. Hooft R.W.W., Vriend G., Sander C., Abola E.E. Errors in crystal structures. Nature 1996, 381:272.
5. Lovell S.C., Davis I.W., Arendall W.B., de Bakker P.I.W., Word J.M., Prisant M.G., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. Structure validation by Cα geometry-ω, χ and Cβ deviation. Proteins: Struct Funct Genet 2003, 50:437-450.
6. Laskowski R.A., MacArthur M.W., Moss D.S., Thornton J.M. ProCheck-a program to check the stereochemical quality of protein structures. J Appl Crystallogr 1993, 26:283-291.
7. Dunbrack R.L. Rotamer libraries in the 21st century. Curr Opin Struct Biol 2002, 12:431-440.
8. Frank M., Lütteke T., von der Lieth C.W. GlycoMapsDB-a database of the accessible conformational space of glycosidic linkages. Nucleic Acids Res 2007, 35:287-290.
9. Richardson J.S., Schneider B., Murray L.W., Kapral G.J., Immormino R.M., Headd J.J., Richardson D.C., Ham D., Hershkovits E., Williams L.W., et al. RNA backbone-consensus all-angle conformers and modular string nomenclature (an RNA Ontology Consortium Contribution). RNA 2008, 14:465-481.
10. Word J.M., Lovell S.C., LaBean T.H., Zalis M., Presley B.K., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. Visualizing and quantitating molecular goodness-of-fit-small-probe contact dots with explicit hydrogens. J Mol Biol 1999, 285:1711-1733.
11. Vriend G., Sander C. Quality control of protein models-directional atomic contact analysis. J Appl Crystallogr 1993, 26:47-60.
12. Chen V.B., Arendall W.B., Headd J.J., Keedy D.A., Immormino R.M., Kapral G.J., Murray L.W., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. MolProbity-all-atom structure validation for macromolecular crystallography. Acta Crystallogr 2010, D66:12-21.
13. Lovell S.C., Word J.M., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. The penultimate rotamer library. Proteins: Struct Funct Genet 2000, 40:389-408.
14. McDonald I.K., Thornton N. Satisfying hydrogen bonding potential in proteins. J Mol Biol 1994, 238:777-793.
15. Hooft R.W.W., Sander C., Vriend G. Positioning hydrogen atoms by optimizing hydrogen-bond networks in protein structures. Proteins: Struct Funct Genet 1996, 26:363-376.
16. Word J.M., Lovell S.C., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. Asparagine and glutamine-using hydrogen atom contacts in the choice of side-chain amide orientation. J Mol Biol 1999, 285:1735-1747.
17. Richardson J.S., Prisant M.G. Fitting tip#3: histidine flips and protonation. Comput Crystallogr Newsletter 2012, 3:3-4.
18. Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. Doing molecular biophysics: Finding, naming, and picturing signal within complexity. Annu Rev Biophys 2013, 42:14.1-14.28. (available on-line).
19. Morris A.L., MacArthur M.W., Hutchinson E.G., Thornton J.M. Stereochemical quality of protein structure coordinates. Proteins: Struct Funct Genet 1992, 12:345-364.
20. Kleywegt G.J. Validation of protein crystal structures. Acta Crystallogr 2000, D56:249-265.
21. Berman H.M., Kleywegt G.J., Nakamura H., Markley J.L. The future of the Protein Data Bank. Biopolymers 2012, 99:218-222.
22. Zwart P.H., Grosse-Kunstleve R.W., Adams P.D. Xtriage and Fest-automatic assessment of X-ray data and substructure structure factor estimation. CCP4 Newsl 2005, 43:99-107.
23. Lebedev A.A., Vagin A.A., Murshudov G.N. Intensity statistics in twinned crystals with examples from the PDB. Acta Crystallogr 2006, D62:83-95.
24. Afonine P., Grosse-Kunstleve R.W., Chen V.B., Headd J.J., Moriarty N.W., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C., Urzhumtsev A., Zwart P.H., Adams P. phenix.model_vs_data: a high-level tool for the calculation of crystallographic model and data statistics. J Appl Crystallogr 2010, 43:677-685.
25. Branden C.-I., Jones T.A. Between objectivity and subjectivity. Nature 1990, 343:687-689.
26. Baker E.N., Dauter Z., Einspahr H., Weiss M.S. In defence of our science-validation now!. Acta Crystallogr 2010, D66:115.
27. Chang G., Roth C.B., Reyes C.L., Pornillos O., Chen Y.-J., Chen A.P. Retraction. Science 2006, 314:1875.
28. Janssen B.J.C., Read R.J., Brunger A.T., Gros P. Crystallography: crystallographic evidence for deviating C3b structure. Nature 2007, 448:E1-E3.
29. Gore S., Velankar S., Kleywegt G.J. Implementing an X-ray validation pipeline for the Protein Data Bank. Acta Crystallogr 2012, D68:478-483.
30. Hanson M.A., Stevens R.C. Retraction: cocrystal structure of synaptobrevin-II bound to botulinum neurotoxin type B at 2.0Å resolution. Nat Struct Mol Biol 2009, 16:795.
31. Kleywegt G.J., Harris M.R., Zou J.Y., Taylor T.C., Wahlby A., Jones T.A. The Uppsala electron-density server. Acta Crystallogr 2004, D60:2240-2249.
32. Karplus P.A. Experimentally observed conformation-dependent geometry and hidden strain in proteins. Protein Sci 1996, 5:1406-1420.
33. Berkholz D.S., Shapalov M.V., Dunbrack R.L., Karplus P.A. Conformation dependence of backbone geometry in proteins. Structure 2009, 17:1316-1325.
34. Adams P.D., Afonine P.V., Bunkóczi G., Chen V.B., Davis I.W., Echols N., Headd J.J., Hung L.-W., Kapral G.J., Grosse-Kunstleve R.W., et al. PHENIX-a comprehensive Python-based system for macromolecular structure solution. Acta Crystallogr 2010, D66:213-221.
35. Deis L.N., Verma V., Videau L.L., Prisant M.G., Moriarty N.W., Headd J.J., Chen V.B., Adams P.D., Snoeyink J., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. Phenix/MolProbity hydrogen parameter update. Comput Crystallogr Newsletter 2013, 4:9-10.
36. Allen F.H. The Cambridge Structural Database: a quarter of a million crystal structures and rising. Acta Crystallogr 2002, B58:380-388.
37. Grazulis S., Chateigner D., Downs R.T., Yokochi A.T., Quiros M., Lutterotti L., Manakova E., Butkus J., Moeck P., Le Bail A. Crystallography Open Database-an open-access collection of crystal structures. J Appl Crystallogr 2009, 42:726-729.
38. Esque J., Oguey C., de Brevern A.G. A novel evaluation of residue and protein volumes by means of Laguerre tesselation. J Chem Inf Model 2010, 50:947-960.
39. Sheffler W., Baker D. RosettaHoles-rapid assessment of protein core packing for structure prediction, refinement, design, and validation. Protein Sci 2009, 18:229-239.
40. Tronrud D.E., Matthews B.W. Sorting the chaff from the wheat at the PDB. Protein Sci 2009, 18:2-5.
41. Zhou H.-F., Cross T.A. Influences of membrane mimetic environments on membrane protein structures. Annu Rev Biophys 2013, 42. (available on-line).
42. Nakahara T., Hashimoto R., Nakagawa H., Monde K., Miura N., Nishimura S. Glycoconjugate data bank: structures-an annotated glycan structure database and N-glycan primary structure verification service. Nucleic Acids Res 2008, 36:D368-D371.
43. Lütteke T. Analysis and validation of carbohydrate three-dimensional structures. Acta Crystallogr 2009, D65:156-168.
44. Foley B.L., Tessier M.B., Woods R.J. Carbohydrate force fields. WIREs Comput Mol Sci 2012, 2. 10.1002/wcms89.
45. Jo S., Im W. Glycan fragment database: a database of PDB-based glycan 3D structures. Nucleic Acids Res 2013, 41:D470-D474.
46. Bruno I.J., Cole J.C., Kessler M., Luo J., Motherwell W.D.S., Purkis L.H., Smith B.R., Taylor R., Cooper R.I., Harris S.E., Orpen A.G. Retrieval of crystallographically-derived molecular geometry information. J Chem Inf Comput Sci 2004, 44:2133-2144.
47. Zheng H., Chruszcz M., Lasota P., Lebioda L., Minor W. Data mining of metal ion environments present in protein structures. J Inorg Biochem 2008, 102:1765-1776.
48. Headd J.J., Richardson J.S. Fitting tip#5: what's with water?. Comput Crystallogr Newsl 2013, 4:2-5.
49. van den Akker F., Hol W.G.J. Difference density quality (DDQ): a method to assess the global and local correctness of macromolecular crystal structure. Acta Crystallogr 1999, D55:206-218.
50. Lang P.T., Ng H.-L., Fraser J.S., Corn J.E., Echols N., Sales M., Holton J.M., Alber T. Automated electron-density sampling reveals widespread conformational polymorphism in proteins. Protein Sci 2010, 19:120-1431.
51. Sobolev O.V., Lunin V.Y. Detection of alternative conformations by unrestrained refinement. Acta Crystallogr 2012, D68:1118-1127.
52. Ting D., Wang G., Shapovalov M., Mitra R., Jordan M.I., Dunbrack R.L. Neighbor-dependent Ramachandran probability distributions of amino acids developed from a hierarchical Dirichlet process model. PLoS Comput Biol 2010, 6:e1000763.
53. Lundgren M., Niemi A.J. Correlation between protein secondary structure, backbone angles, and sidechain orientations. Physical Review 2012, E86:021904.
54. Richardson J.S., Keedy D.A., Richardson D.C. The plot thickens-more data, more dimensions, more uses. Biomolecular Forms and Functions: A Celebration of 50 Years of the Ramachandran Map 2013, 13-29. World Scientific Publishing, Singapore. M. Bansal, N. Srinivasan (Eds.).
55. Emsley P., Lohkamp B., Scott W.G., Cowtan K. Features and development of coot. Acta Crystallogr 2010, D66:486-501.
56. Davis I.W., Arendall W.B., Richardson J.S., Richardson D.C. The backrub motion: how protein backbone shrugs when a sidechain dances. Structure 2006, 14:265-274.
57. Joosten R.P., Joosten K., Murshudov G.N., Perrakis A. PDB_REDO: constructive validation, more than just looking for errors. Acta Crystallogr 2012, D68:484-496.
58. Adams P.D., Baker D., Brunger A.T., Das R., DiMaio F., Read R.J., Richardson D.C., Richardson J.S., Terwilliger T.C. Advances, interactions, and future developments in the CNS, Phenix, and Rosetta structural biology software systems. Annu Rev Biophys 2013, 42:11.1-11.23. (available on-line).
59. Chou F.-C., Sripakdeevong P., Dibrov S.M., Hermann T., Das R. Correcting pervasive errors in RNA crystallography through enumerative structure prediction. Nat Methods 2013, 10:74-76.
60. Dunkle J.A., Wang L., Feldman M.B., Pulk A., Chen V.B., Kapral G.J., Noeske J., Richardson J.S., Blanchard S.C., Cate J.H.D. Structures of the bacterial ribosome in classical and hybrid states of tRNA binding. Science 2011, 332:981-984. (in supplemental on-line material).
61. Schroeder G.F., Levitt M., Brunger A.T. Super-resolution biomolecular crystallography with low-resolution data. Nature 2010, 464:1218-1222.
62. Terwilliger T.C., Read R.J., Adams P.D., Brunger A.T., Afonine P.V., Grosse-Kunstleve R.W., Hung L.-W. Improved crystallographic models through iterated local density-guided model deformation and reciprocal space refinement. Acta Crystallogr 2012, D68:861-870.
63. Smart O.S., Womack T.O., Flensburg C., Keller P., Paciorek W., Sharff A., Vonrhein C., Bricogne G. Exploiting structure similarity in refinement: automated NCS and target-structure restraints in Buster. Acta Crystallogr 2012, D68:368-380.
64. van den Bedem H., Dhanik A., Latombe J.-C., Deacon A.M. Modeling discrete heterogeneity in X-ray diffraction data by fitting multi-conformers. Acta Crystallogr 2009, D65:1107-1117.
65. Gipson B., Hsu D., Kavraki L.E., Latombe J.-C. Computational models of protein kinematics and dynamics: beyond simulation. Annu Rev Anal Chem 2012, 5:273-291.
66. Depristo M.A., de Bakker P.I.W., Blundell T.L. Heterogeneity and inaccuracy in protein structures solved by protein crystallography. Structure 2004, 12:831-838.
67. Terwilliger T.C., Grosse-Kunstleve R.W., Afonine P.V., Adams P.D., Moriarty N.W., Zwart P., Read R.J., Turk D., Hung L.W. Interpretation of ensembles created by multiple iterative rebuilding of macromolecular models. Acta Crystallogr 2007, D63:597-610.
68. Levin E.J., Kondrashov D.A., Wesenberg G.E., Phillips G.N. Ensemble refinement of protein crystal structures: validation and application. Structure 2007, 15:1040-1052.
69. Gros P., van Gunsteren W.F., Hol W.G. Inclusion of thermal motion in crystallographic structures by restrained molecular dynamics. Science 1990, 249:1149-1152.
70. Schwander P., Fung R., Phillips G.N., Ourmazd A. Mapping the conformations of biological assemblies. New J Phys 2010, 12:035007. (15pp.).