Pattern and polarity in the development and evolution of the gnathostome jaw: Both conservation and heterotopy in the branchial arches of the shark, Scyliorhinus canicula

Developmental Biology

Volumn 377, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 428-448

  Compagnucci, Claudia ^a,i,j   Debiais Thibaud, Melanie ^b,k   Coolen, Marion ^c   Fish, Jennifer ^a,d   Griffin, John N ^a   Bertocchini, Federica ^e   Minoux, Maryline ^f,g   Rijli, Filippo M ^f,h   Borday Birraux, Véronique ^b   Casane, Didier ^b   Mazan, Sylvie ^c   Depew, Michael J ^a,d  

^a KING'S COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^b CNRS   (France)

^c UNIVERSITÉ D'ORLÉANS   (France)

^d UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^e UNIVERSITY OF CANTABRIA   (Spain)

^f FRIEDRICH MIESCHER INSTITUTE FOR BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH   (Switzerland)

^g UNIVERSITÉ DE STRASBOURG   (France)

^h UNIVERSITY OF BASEL   (Switzerland)

ⁱ UNIVERSITY OF ROME TOR VERGATA   (Italy)

^j IRCCS FONDAZIONE SANTA LUCIA   (Italy)

^k INSTITUT DES SCIENCES DE L EVOLUTION   (France)

more..

Author keywords

Branchial arch; Evolution; Heterotopy; Jaws; Shark

Indexed keywords

AMNIOTE; ANIMAL TISSUE; ARTICLE; BRANCHIAL ARCH; CONTROLLED STUDY; DEVELOPMENT; DLX GENE; DLX1 GENE; DLX2 GENE; DLX3 GENE; DLX4 GENE; DLX5 GENE; ELASMOBRANCH; EMBRYO; EMBRYO POLARITY; EVOLUTION; GENE; GENE EXPRESSION; JAW; NONHUMAN; PRIMORDIUM; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SCYLIORHINUS CANICULA; SHARK;

AMNIOTA; CHONDRICHTHYES; DANIO RERIO; MUS; PETROMYZONTIDAE; SCYLIORHINUS CANICULA; SQUALIDAE; VERTEBRATA;

EID: 84876990978     PISSN: 00121606     EISSN: 1095564X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ydbio.2013.02.022     Document Type: Article

References (190)

1. Abu-Issa R., Smyth G., Smoak I., Yamamura K., Meyers E.N. Fgf8 is required for pharyngeal arch and cardiovascular development in the mouse. Development 2002, 129:4613-4625.
2. Abzhanov A., Protas M., Grant B.R., Grant P.R., Tabin C.J. Bmp4 and morphological variation of beaks in Drawin's finches. Science 2004, 305:1462-1465.
3. Abzhanov A., Tabin C.J. Shh and Fgf8 act synergistically to drive cartilage outgrowth during cranial development. Dev. Biol. 2004, 273:134-148.
4. Allin E.F., Hopson J.A. Evolution of the auditory system in synapsida ("mammal-like reptiles" and primitive mammals) as seen in the fossil record. The Evolutionary Biology of Hearing 1992, 587-614. Springer-Verlag, New York, US. Eds. D.B. Webster, R.R. Fay, A.N. Popper (Eds.).
5. Arnason U., Gullberg A., Janke A. Molecular phylogenetics of gnathostomous (jawed) fishes: old bones, new cartilage. Zool. Scripta 2001, 30:249-255.
6. Ashique A.M., Fu K., Richman J.M. Endogenous bone morphogenetic proteins regulate outgrowth and epithelial survival during avian lip fusion. Development 2002, 129:4647-4660.
7. Balfour F.M. A Monograph on the Development of Elasmobranch Fishes 1878, McMillan and Co, London.
8. Ballard W.W., Mellinger J., Lechenault H. A series of normal stages for development of Scyliorhinus canicula, the lesser spotted dogfish (Chondrichthyes: Scylorhinidae). J. Exp. Zool. 1993, 267:318-336.
9. Barghusen H.R., Hopson A. The endoskeleton: the comparative anatomy of the skull and visceral skeleton. Hyman's Comparative Anatomy 1979, 265-326. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US. M. Wake (Ed.).
10. Barlow A.J., Francis-West P.H. Ectopic application of recombinant BMP-2 and BMP-4 can change patterning of developing chick facial primordia. Development 1997, 124:391-398.
11. de Beer G.R. Studies on the vertebrate head. II. The orbito-temporal region of the skull. Q. J. Microsc. Sci. 1926, 278:263-370.
12. de Beer G.R. The development of the skull of scyllium (Scyliorhinus canicula) L. Q. J. Microsc. Sci. 1931, 74. 591-564.
13. de Beer G.R. The Development of the Vertebrate Skull 1985, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, USA.
14. Bei M., Mass R. FGFs and BMP4 induce both Msx1-independent and Msx1-dependent signaling pathways in early tooth development. Development 1998, 125:4325-4333.
15. Bell E., Ensini M., Gulisano M., Lumsden A. Dynamic domains of gene expression in the early avian forebrain. Dev. Biol. 2001, 236:76-88.
16. Bellairs A., Kamal A.M. The chondrocranium and the development of the skull in recent reptiles. The Biology of the Reptilia 1981, 11. Academic Press, London, UK.
17. Beverdam A., Brouwer A., Reijnen M., Korving J., Meijlink F. Severe nasal clefting and abnormal embryonic apoptosis in Alx3/Alx4 double mutant mice. Development 2001, 128:3975-3986.
18. Beverdam A., Merlo G.R., Paleari L., Paleari L., Mantero S., Genova F., Barbieri O., Janvier P., Levi G. Jaw transformation with gain of symmetry after Dlx5/Dlx6 inactivation: mirror of the past?. Genesis 2002, 34:221-227.
19. Blentic A., Panna T., Payton S., Walshe J., Carney T., Kelsh R.N., Mason I., Graham A. The emergence of ectomesenchyme. Dev. Dyn. 2008, 237:592-601.
20. Brickell P., Thorogood P. Retinoic acid and retinoic acid receptors in craniofacial development. Semin. Cell Dev. Biol. 1997, 8:437-443.
21. Brazeau M.D., Ahlberg P.E. Tetrapod-like middle ear architecture in a Devonian fish. Nature 2006, 439:318-321.
22. Brazeau, M.D., 2009. The braincase and jaws of a Devonian 'acanthodian' and modern gnathostome origins. Nature. 457, 305-308.
23. Bulfone A., Kim H.J., Puelles L., Porteus M.H., Grippo J.F., Rubenstein J.L. The mouse Dlx-2 (Tes-1) gene is expressed in spatially restricted domains of the forebrain, face and limbs in midgestation mouse embryos. Mech. Dev. 1993, 40:129-140.
24. Carroll R.L. Vertebrate Paleontology and Evolution 1988, W. H. Freeman and Company, New York, USA.
25. Carroll R.L. The primary radiation of terrestrial vertebrates. Annu. Rev. Ecol., Evol. Syst. 1992, 20:45-84.
26. Cerny R., Cattell M., Sauka-Spengler T., Bronner-Fraser M., Yu F., Meulemans Medeiros D. Evidence for the prepattern/cooption model of vertebrate jaw evolution. PNAS 2010, 107:17262-17267.
27. Chesterman E.S., Kern M.J. Comparative analysis of Prx1 and Prx2 expression in mice provides evidence for incomplete compensation. Anat. Rec. 2002, 266:1-4.
28. Compagnucci C., Fish J.L., Schwark M., Tarabyki V., Depew M.J. Pax6 regulates craniofacial form through its control of an essential cephalic ectodermal patterning center. Genesis 2011, 49:307-325.
29. Coolen M., Menuet A., Chassoux D., Compagnucci C., Henry S., Lévèque L., Da Silva C., Gavory F., Samain S., Wincker P., Thermes C., D'Aubenton-Carafa Y., Rodríguez-Moldes I., Naylor G., Depew M., Sourdaine P., Mazan S. The dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula: a reference in jawed vertebrates. pp. 431-446. Emerging Model Organisms. A Laboratory Manual 2009, 1. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, New York, New York.
30. Coolen M., Sauka-Spengler T., Nicolle D., Le-Mentec C., Lallemand Y., Da Silva C., Plouhinec J.L., Robert B., Wincker P., Shi D.L., Mazan S. Evolution of axis specification mechanisms in jawed vertebrates: insights from a chondrichthyan. PLoS One 2007, 2:e374.
31. Crossley P.H., Martin G.R. The mouse Fgf8 gene encodes a family of polypeptides and is expressed in regions that direct outgrowth and patterning in the developing embryo. Development 1995, 121:439-451.
32. Cubbage C.C., Mabee P.M. Development of the cranium and paired fins in the zebrafish Danio rerio (Ostariophysi, Cyprinadae). J. Morphol. 1996, 229:121-160.
33. Daniel J.F. The Elasmobranch Fishes 1934, University of California Press, Berkeley, USA.
34. Davis S.P., Finarelli J.A., Coates M.I. Acanthodes and shark-like conditions in the last common ancestor of modern gnathostomes. Nature 2012, 486:247-250.
35. Dean B. Studies on fossil fish (Sharks, Chimaeroids and Arthrodires). Memoirs of the American Museum of Natural History IX 1909, 211-287.
36. Debiais-Thibaud M., Oulion S., Bourrat F., Laurenti P., Casane D., Borday-Birraux V. The homology of odontodes in gnathostomes: insights from Dlx gene expression in the dogfish, Scyliorhinus canicula. BMC Evol. Biol. 2011, 11:307.
37. Depew M.J. Analysis of skeletal ontogenesis through differential staining of bone and cartilage. Molecular Embryology-Methods and Protocols 2008, Humana Press, USA. P.T. Sharpe, I. Mason (Eds.).
38. Depew M.J., Compagnuicci C. Tweaking the hinge and caps: testing a model of the organization of jaws. J. Exp. Zool. 2008, 310:315-335.
39. Depew M.J., Liu J.K., Long J.E., Presley R., Meneses J.J., Pedersen R.A., Rubenstein J.L. Dlx5 regulates regional development of the branchial arches and sensory capsules. Development 1999, 126:3831-3846.
40. Depew M.J., Lufkin T., Rubenstein J.L.R. Specification of jaw subdivisions by Dlx genes. Science 2002, 298:381-385.
41. Depew M.J., Simpson C.A. 21st century neontology and the comparative development of the vertebrate skull. Dev. Dyn. 2006, 235:1256-1291.
42. Depew M.J., Simpson C.A., Morasso M., Rubenstein J.L. Reassessing the Dlx code: the genetic regulation of branchial arch skeletal pattern and development. J. Anat. 2005, 207:501-561.
43. Depew M.J., Tucker A., Sharpe P. Craniofacial development. Mouse Development: Patterning, Morphogenesis and Organogenesis 2002, 421-498. Academic Press, San Diego, USA. J. Rossant, P.P.L. Tam (Eds.).
44. Derobert Y., Plouhinec J.L., Sauka-Spengler T., Le Mentec C., Baratte B., Jaillard D., Mazan S. Structure and expression of three Emx genes in the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula: functional and evolutionary implications. Dev. Biol. 2002, 247:390-404.
45. Didier D.A., LeClair E.E., Vanbuskirk D.R. Embryonic staging and external features of development of the chimaeroid fish, Callorhinchus milii (Holocephali, Callorhinchidae). J. Morphol. 1998, 236:25-47.
46. Dolle P., Price M., Duboule D. Expression of the murine Dlx-1 homeobox gene during facial ocular and limb development. Differentiation 1992, 49:93-99.
47. Dupe V., Matt N., Garnier J.M., Chambon P., Mark M., Ghyselinck N.B. A newborn lethal defect due to inactivation of retinaldehyde dehydrogenase type 3 is prevented by maternal retinoic acid treatment. PNAS 2003, 100:14036-14041.
48. Ellies D.L., Langille R.M., Martin C.C., Akimenko M.A., Ekker M. Specific craniofacial cartilage dysmorphogenesis coincides with a loss of dlx gene expression in retinoic acid-treated zebrafish embryos. Mech. Dev. 1997, 61:23-36.
49. Ellies D.L., Stock D.W., Hatch G., Giroux G., Weiss K.M., Ekker M. Relationship between the genomic organization and the overlapping embryonic expression patterns of the zebrafish dlx genes. Genomics 1997, 45:580-590.
50. El-Toubi M.R. The development of the spiracular cartilages of the spiny dogfish, Acanthias vulgaris (Squalus acanthias). Biol Bull 1947, 93:237-295.
51. El-Toubi M.R. The development of the chondrocranium of the spiny dogfish, Acanthias vulgaris (Squalus acanthias) neurocranium, mandibular and hyoid arches. J. Morphol. 1949, 84:227-279.
52. Evans S.E. At the feet of the dinosaurs: the early history and radiation of lizards. Biol. Rev. 2003, 78:513-551.
53. Ferreiro-Galve S., Carrera I., Candal E., Villar-Cheda B., Anadon R., Mazan S., Rodriguez-Moldes I. The segmental organization of the developing shark brain based on neurochemical markers, with special attention to the prosencephalon. Brain Res. Bull. 2008, 75:236-240.
54. Ferretti E., Li B., Zewdu R., Wells V., Hebert J.M., Karner C., Anderson M.J., Williams T., Dixon J., Dixon M.J., Depew M.J., Selleri L. A Conserved Pbx-Wnt-p63-Irf6 regulatory module controls face morphogenesis by promoting epithelial apoptosis. Dev. Cell 2011, 21:627-641.
55. Fish J.L., Villmoare B., Köbernick K., Compagnucci C., Britanova O., Tarabykin V., Depew M.J. Satb2, modularity, and the evolvability of the vertebrate jaw. Evol. Dev. 2011, 13:549-564.
56. Foppiano S., Hu D., Marcucio R.S. Signaling by bone morphogenetic proteins directs formation of an ectodermal signaling center that regulates craniofacial development. Dev. Biol. 2007, 312:103-114.
57. Forey P., Janvier P. Agnathans and the origin of jawed vertebrates. Nature 1993, 361:129-134.
58. Francis-West P.H., Robson L., Evans D.J. Craniofacial development: the tissue and molecular interactions that control development of the head. Adv. Anat. Embryol. Cell Biol. 2003, 169:1-138.
59. Freitas R., Cohn M.J. Analysis of EphA4 in the lesser spotted catshark identifies a primitive gnathostome expression pattern and reveals co-option during evolution of shark-specific morphology. Dev. Gene. Evol. 2004, 214:466-472.
60. Freitas R., Zhang G., Cohn M.J. Evidence that mechanisms of fin development evolved in the midline of early vertebrates. Nature 2006, 442:1033-1037.
61. Freitas R., Zhang G., Cohn M.J. Biphasic Hoxd gene expression in shark paired fins reveals an ancient origin of the distal limb domain. PLoS One 2007, 2:e754.
62. Furuta Y., Hogan B.L.M. BMP4 is essential for lens induction in the mouse embryo. Gene. Dev. 1998, 12:3764-3775.
63. Gai Z., Donoghue P.C., Zhu M., Janvier P., Stampanoni M. Fossil jawless fish from China foreshadows early jawed vertebrate anatomy. Nature 2011, 476:324-327.
64. Gans C. Craniofacial growth, evolutionary questions. Development 1988, 103:3-15. Suppl.
65. Gans C., Northcutt R.G. Neural crest and origin of vertebrates: a new head. Science 1983, 220:268-274.
66. Germot A., Lecointre G., Plouhinec J.L., Le Mentec C., Girardot F., Mazan S. Structural evolution of Otx genes in craniates. Mol. Biol. Evol. 2001, 18:1668-1678.
67. Ghanem N., Jarinova O., Amores A., Long Q., Hatch G., Park B.K., Rubenstein J.L., Ekker M. Regulatory roles of conserved intergenic domains in vertebrate Dlx bigene clusters. Genome Res. 2003, 13:533-543.
68. Gillis J.A., Dahn R.D., Shubin N.H. Shared developmental mechanisms pattern the gill arch and paired fin skeleton of vertebrates. PNAS 2009, 106:5720-5724.
69. Gillis J.A., Dahn R.D., Shubin N.H. Chondrogenesis and homology of the visceral skeleton in the little skate, Leucoraja erinacea (Chondrichthyes: Batoidea). J. Morphol. 2009, 270:628-643.
70. Gillis J.A., Rawlinson K.A., Bell J., Lyon W.S., Baker C.V., Shubin N.H. Holocephalan embryos provide evidence for gill arch appendage reduction and opercular evolution in cartilaginous fishes. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2011, 108:1507-1512.
71. Godard, B.G., Mazan, S. 2012. Early patterning in a chondrichthyan model, the small spotted dogfish: towards the gnathosotme ancestral state. J. Anat. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7580.2012.01552.x.
72. Goodrich E.S. Vertebrata craniata (first fascicle: cyclostomes and fishes). Treatise on Zollogy 1909, Part IX. Adam and Charles Black, London. R. Lankester (Ed.).
73. Goodrich E.S. On the development of the segments of the head in Scyllium. Q. J. Mic. Sci. 1918, 63:1-30.
74. Goodrich E.S. Studies on the Structure and Development of Vertebrates 1958, Dover Publications, New York, USA.
75. Gong S.G., Guo C. Bmp4 gene is expressed at the putative site of fusion in the midfacial region. Differentiation 2003, 71:228-236.
76. Gorski J.A., Talley T., Qiu M., Puelles L., Rubenstein J.L., Jones K.R. Cortical excitatory neurons and glia, but not GABAergic neurons, are produced in the Emx1-expressing lineage. J. Neurosci. 2002, 22:6309-6314.
77. Gregory W.K. Fish skulls: a study of the evolution of natural mechanisms. Trans. Amer. Philos. Soc. 1933, 23:75-481.
78. Griffin, J.N., Compagnucci, C., Hu, D., Fish, J., Klein, O., Marcucio, R., Depew, M.J., 2013. Fgf8 dosage determines midfacial integration and polarity within the nasal and optic capsules. Dev. Biol. 374, 185-197.
79. Grogan E.D., Lund R., Didier D. Description of the chimaerid jaw and its phylogenetic origins. J. Morphol. 1999, 239:45-59.
80. Halstead L.B. The Pattern of Vertebrate Evolution 1968, WH Freeman and Co, San Francisco, USA.
81. Hanken J., Hall B.K. Mechanisms of skull diversity and evolution. The Skull, Volume 3: Functional and Evolutionary Mechanisms 1993, 1-36. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US.
82. Hanken J., Thorogood P. Evolution and development of the vertebrate skull. TREE 1993, 8:9-15.
83. Harrison F.W. Development of the cranium and paired fins in the zebrafish Danio rerio (Ostariophysi, Cyprinadae). J. Morphol. 1996, 229:121-160.
84. Hildebrand M. Analysis of Vertebrate Structure 1988, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Toronto, Canada.
85. Holmgren N. Studies on the head of fishes-embryological, morphological, and phylogenetic researches: Part I: Development of the skull in sharks and rays. Acta Zool. 1940, 21:51-267.
86. Holmgren N. Studies on the head of fishes. An embryological, morphological and phylogenetical study: Part III: The phylogeny of elasmobranch fishes. Acta Zool. 1942, 23:129-261.
87. Iglesias S.P., Lecointre G., Sellos D.Y. Extensive paraphylies within sharks of the order Carcharhiniformes inferred from nuclear and mitochondrial genes. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 2005, 34:569-583.
88. Janvier P. Patterns of diversity in the skull of jawless fishes. Patterns of Structural and Systematic Diversity 1993, 2:131-188. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US, In: The Skull.
89. Janvier P. Early Vertebrates 1996, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
90. Jarvik E. Basic Structure and Evolution of Vertebrates 1980, Academic Press, New York, USA.
91. Jollie M.T. The head skeleton of the chicken and remarks on the anatomy of this region in other birds. J. Morphol. 1957, 100:389-436.
92. Jollie M. Chordate Morphology 1962, Reinhold, New York, USA.
93. Jollie M. Some developmental aspects of the head skeleton of the 35-37mm Squalus acanthias foetus. J. Morphol. 1971, 133:17-40.
94. Kemp T.S. The Origin and Evolution of Mammals 2005, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
95. Kingsley J.S. The Dogfish (Acanthias): An Elasmobranch. Henry Holt and Co 1907.
96. Kingsley J.S. Comparative Anatomy of Vertebrates 1912, Blakiston's and Sons, Philedelphia, USA.
97. Kuraku S., Takio Y., Sugahara F., Takechi M., Kuratani S. Evolution of oropharyngeal patterning mechanisms involving Dlx and endothelins in vertebrates. Dev. Biol. 2010, 341:315-323.
98. Kuratani S. Evolution of the vertebrate jaw: comparative embryology and molecular developmental biology reveal the factors behind evolutionary novelty. J. Anat. 2004, 205:335-347.
99. Kuratani S. Developmental studies of the lamprey and hierarchical evolutionary steps towards the acquisition of the jaw. J. Anat. 2005, 207:489-499.
100. Kuratani S. Evolution of the vertebrate jaw from developmental perspectives. Evol. Dev. 2012, 14:76-92.
101. Kuratani S., Adachi N., Wada N., Oisi Y., Sugahara F. Develomental and evolutionary significance of the mandibular arch and prechordal/premandibular cranium in vertebrates: revising the heterotopy scenario of gnathostome jaw evolution. J. Anat. 2012, 10.1111/j.1469-7580.2012.01505.x.
102. Kuratani S., Horigome N. Developmental morphology of branchiomeric nerves in a cat shark, Scyliorhinus torazame, with special reference to rhombomeres, cephalic mesoderm, and distribution patterns of cephalic crest cells. Zool. Sci. 2000, 17:893-909.
103. Langille, R.M., Hall, B.K., 1989. Developmental processes, developmental sequences and early vertebrate phylogeny. Biol. Rev. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 64, 73-91.
104. Lee S.H., Fu K.K., Hui J.N., Richman J.M. Noggin and retinoic acid transform the identity of avian facial prominences. Nature 2001, 414:909-912.
105. Lettice L., Hecksher-Sorensen J., Hill R. The role of Bapx1 (Nkx3.2) in the development and evolution of the axial skeleton. J. Anat. 2001, 199:181-187.
106. Liu W., Selever J., Murali D., Sun X., Brugger S.M., Ma L., Schwartz R.J., Maxson R., Furuta Y., Martin J.F. Threshold-specific requirements for Bmp4 in mandibular development. Dev. Biol. 2005, 283:282-293.
107. Liu W., Sun X., Braut A., Mishina Y., Behringer R.R., Mina M., Martin J.F. Distinct functions for Bmp signaling in lip and palate fusion in mice. Development 2005, 132:1453-1461.
108. Maisey J.G. Remarks on the inner ear of elasmobranchs and its interpretation from skeletal labyrinth morphology. J. Morphol. 2001, 250:236-264.
109. Maisey J.G. The postorbital palatoquadrate articulation in elasmobranchs. J. Morphol. 2008, 269:1022-1040.
110. Mallatt J. Crossing a major morphological boundary: the origin of jaws in vertebrates. Zoology 1997, 100:128-140.
111. Matsuo I., Kuratani S., Kimura C., Takeda N., Aizawa S. Mouse Otx2 functions in the formation and patterning of rostral head. Genes Dev. 1995, 9:2646-2658.
112. McGonnell I.M., Graham A., Richardson J., Fish J.L., Depew M.J., Dee C.T., Holland P.W.H., Takahashie T. Evolution of the Alx homeobox gene family: parallel retention and independent loss of the vertebrate Alx3 gene. Evol. Dev. 2011, 13:343-351.
113. Medeiros, D.M., Crump, J.G. 2012. New perspectives on pharyngeal dorsoventral patterning in development and evolution of the vertebrate jaw. Dev. Biol. 371, 121-135.
114. Meyer A., Zardoya R. Recent Advances in the (molecular) phylogeny of vertebrates. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 2003, 34:311-338.
115. Mihailescua D., Kury P., Monard D. An octamer-binding site is crucial for the activity of an enhancer active at the embryonic met-/mesencephalic junction. Mech. Dev. 1999, 84:55-67.
116. Miles R.S. A reinterpretation of the visceral skeleton of Acanthodes. Nature 1964, 204:457-459.
117. Miller C.T., Yelon D., Stainier D.Y.R., Kimmel C.B. Two endothelin 1 effectors, hand2 and bapx1, pattern ventral pharyngeal cartilage and the jaw joint. Development 2003, 130:1353-1365.
118. Minoux M., Rijli F.M. Molecular mechanisms of cranial neural crest cell migration and patterning in craniofacial development. Development 2010, 137:2605-2621.
119. Moore W.J. The Mammalian Skull 1981, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
120. Moy-Thomas J.A., Miles R.S. Palaeozoic fishes 1971, W. B. Saunders and Co. Philadelphia, US.
121. Mulley J.F., Zhong Y.-F., Holland P.W.H. Comparative genomics of chondrichthyan Hoxa clusters. BMC Evol. Biol. 2009, 9:218.
122. Myojin M., Ueki T., Sugahra F., Murakami Y., Shigetani Y., Aizawa S., Hirano S., Kuratani S. Isolation of Dlx and Emx gene cognates in an Agnathan species, Lampetra japonica, and their expression patterns during embryonic and larval development: conserved and diversified regulatory patterns of homeobox genes in vertebrate head evolution. J. Exp. Zool. (Mol. Dev. Evol.) 2001, 291:68-84.
123. Neidert A.H., Virupannavar V., Hooker G.W., Langeland J.A. Lamprey Dlx genes and early vertebrate evolution. PNAS 2001, 98:1665-1670.
124. Nelsen O.E. Comparative Embryology of the Vertebrates 1953, Blakiston Co, New York, USA.
125. Neubüser A., Peters H., Balling R., Martin G.R. Antagonistic interactions between FGF and BMP signaling pathways: a mechanism for positioning the sites of tooth formation. Cell 1997, 90:247-255.
126. Novacek M. Patterns of diversity in the mammalian skull. The Skull, Volume 2: Patterns of Structural and Systematic Diversity 1993, 438-545. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US.
127. O'Neill P., McCole R.B., Baker C.V.H. A molecular analysis of neurogenic placode and cranial sensory ganglion development in the shark, Scyliorhinus canicula. Dev. Biol. 2007, 304:156-181.
128. Oulion S., Borday-Birraux V., Debiais-Thibaud M., Mazan S., Laurenti P., Casane D. Evolution of repeated structures along the body axis of jawed vertebrates, insights from the Scyliorhinus canicula Hox code. Evol. Dev. 2011, 13:247-259.
129. Panchen A.L. The nostrils of choanate fishes and early tetrapods. Biol. Rev. 1967, 42:374-420.
130. Panganiban G., Rubenstein J.L. Developmental functions of the distal-less/Dlx homeobox genes. Development 2002, 129:4371-4386.
131. Parrington F.R. On the evolution of the human palate. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London 1940, 230:305-355.
132. Plouhinec J.L., Leconte L., Sauka-Spengler T., Bovolenta P., Mazan S., Saule S. Comparative analysis of gnathostome Otx gene expression patterns in the developing eye: implications for the functional evolution of the multigene family. Dev. Biol. 2005, 278:560-575.
133. Qiu M., Bulfone A., Ghattas I., Meneses J.J., Christensen L., Sharpe P.T., Presley R., Pedersen R.A., Rubenstein J.L. Role of the Dlx homeobox genes in proximodistal patterning of the branchial arches: mutations of Dlx-1, Dlx-2, and Dlx-1 and -2 alter morphogenesis of proximal skeletal and soft tissue structures derived from the first and second arches. Dev. Biol. 1997, 185:165-184.
134. Qiu M., Bulfone A., Martinez S., Meneses J.J., Shimamura K., Pedersen R.A., Rubenstein J.L. Null mutation of Dlx-2 results in abnormal morphogenesis of proximal first and second branchial arch derivatives and abnormal differentiation in the forebrain. Genes Dev. 1995, 9:2523-2538.
135. Qu S., Tucker S.C., Ehrlich J.S., Levorse J.M., Flaherty L.A., Wisdom R., Vogt T.F. Mutations in mouse aristaless-like4 cause strong's luxoid polydactyly. Development 1998, 126:359-369.
136. Qu S., Tucker S.C., Zhao Q., deCrombrugghe B., Wisdom R. Physical and genetic interactions between Alx4 and Cart1. Development 1999, 126:359-369.
137. Radinsky L.B. The Evolution of Vertebrate Design 1987, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
138. Ravi V., Lam K., Tay B.H., Tay A., Brenner S., Venkatesh B. Elephant shark (Callorhinchus milii) provides insights into the evolution of Hox gene clusters in gnathostomes. PNAS 2009, 106:16327-16332.
139. Reif W.E. Development of dentition and dermal skeleton in embryonic Scyliorhinus canicula. J. Morphol. 1980, 166:275-288.
140. Rieppel O. Patterns of diversity in the reptilian skull. Patterns of Structural and Systematic Diversity 1993, 2:344-390. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US, In: The Skull.
141. Renz A.J., Gunter H.M., Fischer J.M.F., Qiu H., Meyer A., Kuraku S. Ancestral and derived attributes of the dlx gene repertoire, cluster structure and expression patterns in an African cichlid fish. EvoDevo 2011, 2:1-14.
142. Reynolds S.H. The Vertebrate Skeleton 1913, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, US.
143. Rijli F.M., Mark M., Lakkaraju S., Dierich A., Dollé P., Chambon P. A homeotic transformation is generated in the rostral branchial region of the head by disruption of Hoxa-2, which acts as a selector gene. Cell 1993, 75:1333-1349.
144. Robinson G.W., Mahon K.A. Differential and overlapping expression domains of Dlx-2 and Dlx-3 suggest distinct roles for Distal-less homeobox genes in craniofacial development. Mech. Dev. 1994, 48:199-215.
145. Rodriguez-Moldes I., Carrera I., Pose-Mendez S., Quintana-Urzainqui I., Candal E., Anadon R., Mazan S., Ferreiro-Galve S. Regionalization of the shark hindbrain: a survey of an ancestral organization. Front. Neuroanat. 2011, 5:16.
146. Romanoff A.L. The Avian Embryo: Structural and Functional Development 1960, MacMillan, New York, US.
147. Romer A.S. Vertebrate Paleontology 1966, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, USA.
148. Romer A.S. Major steps in vertebrate evolution. Science 1967, 158:1629-1637.
149. Rosen D.E., Forey P.L., Gardiner B.G., Patterson C. Lungfishes, tetrapods, paleontology, and plesiomorphy. Bull. Am. Mus.Nat. His. 1981, 167:159-276.
150. Sakamoto K., Onimaru K., Munakata K., Suda N., Tamura M., Ochi H., Tanaka M. Heterochronic shift in Hox-mediated activation of sonic hedgehog leads to morphological changes during fin development. PLoS One 2009, 4:e5121.
151. Santagati F., Minoux M., Ren S.-Y., Rijli F.M. Temporal requirement of Hoxa2 in cranial neural crest skeletal morphogenesis. Development 2005, 132:4927-4936.
152. Satokata I., Maas R. Msx1 deficient mice exhibit cleft palate and abnormalities of craniofacial and tooth development. Nat. Genet. 1994, 6:348-356.
153. Schaeffer B., Williams M. Relationships of fossil and living elasmobranchs. Am. Zool. 1977, 17:293-302.
154. Schmalhausen I.I. The Origin of Terrestrial Vertebrates 1968, Academic Press, New York.
155. Schultze H.P. Patterns of diversity in the skulls of jawed fishes. Patterns of Structural and Systematic Diversity 1993, 2:189-254. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US, In: The Skull.
156. Selleri L., Depew M.J., Jacobs Y., Chanda S.K., Tsang K.Y., Cheah K.S.E., Rubenstein J.L.R., O'Gorman S., Cleary M.L. Requirement for Pbx1 in skeletal patterning and programming chondrocyte proliferation and differentiation. Development 2001, 128:3543-3557.
157. Shigetani Y., Nobusada Y., Kuratani S. Ectodermally derived FGF8 defines the maxillomandibular region in the early chick embryo: epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in the specification of the craniofacial ectomesenchyme. Dev. Biol. 2000, 228:73-85.
158. Shigetani Y., Sugahara F., Kawakami Y., Murakami Y., Hirano S., Kuratani S. Heterotopic shift of epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in vertebrate jaw evolution. Science 2002, 296:1316-1319.
159. Shimeld S.M., Holland P.W. Vertebrate innovations. PNAS 2000, 97:4449-4452.
160. Smith K.K. The form of the feeding apparatus in terrestrial vertebrates: studies of adaptation and constraint. The Skull, Volume 3: Functional and Evolutionary Mechanisms 1993, 150-196. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US.
161. Smith M.M., Fraser G.J., Chaplin N., Hobbs C., Graham A. Reiterative pattern of sonic hedgehog expression in the catshark dentition reveals a phylogenetic template for jawed vertebrates. Proc. Biol. Sci. 2009, 276:1225-1233.
162. Song Y., Hui J.N., Fu K.K., Richman J.M. Control of retinoic acid synthesis and FGF expression in the nasal pit is required to pattern the craniofacial skeleton. Dev. Biol. 2004, 276:313-329.
163. Stock D.W. The Dlx gene complement of the leopard shark, Triakis semifasciata, resembles that of mammals: implications for genomic and morphological evolution of jawed vertebrates. Genetics 2005, 169:807-817.
164. Stock D.W., Ellies D.L., Zhao Z., Ekker M., Ruddle F.H., Weiss K.M. The evolution of the vertebrate Dlx gene family. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 1996, 93:10858-10863.
165. Sumiyama K., Ruddle F.H. Regulation of Dlx3 gene expression in visceral arches by evolutionarily conserved enhancer elements. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2003, 100:4030-4034.
166. Szabo-Rogers H.L., Geetha-Loganathan P., Nimmagadda S., Fu K.K., Richman J.M. FGF signals from the nasal pit are necessary for normal facial morphogenesis. Dev. Biol. 2008, 318:289-302.
167. Talbot J.C., Johnson S.L., Kimmel C.B. hand2 and Dlx genes specify dorsal, intermediate and ventral domains within zebrafish pharyngeal arches. Development 2010, 137:2507-2517.
168. Tamarin A. The formation of the primitive choanae and the junction of the primary and secondary palates in the mouse. Am. J. Anat. 1982, 165:319-337.
169. Tamarin A., Boyde A. Facial and visceral arch development in the mouse embryo: a study by scanning electron microscopy. J. Anat. 1977, 124:563-580.
170. Tavares, A.L.P., Garcia, E.L., Kuhn, K., Woods, C.M., Williams, T., Clouthier, D.E. 2012. Ectodermal-derived Endothelin1 is required for patterning the distal and intermediate domains of the mouse mandibular arch. Dev. Biol. 371, 47-56.
171. ten Berge D., Brouwer A., Korving J., Martin J.F., Meijlink F. Prx1 and Prx2 in skeletogenesis: roles in the craniofacial region, inner ear and limbs. Development 1998, 125:3831-3842.
172. Thomas T., Kurihara H., Yamagishi H., Kurihara Y., Yazaki Y., Olson E.N., Srivastava D. A signaling cascade involving endothelin-1, dHAND and msx1 regulates development of neural-crest-derived branchial arch mesenchyme. Development 1998, 125:3005-3014.
173. Trueb L. Patterns of cranial diversity among the Lissamphibia. The Skull, Volume 2: Patterns of Structural and Systematic Diversity 1993, 255-343. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US.
174. Trumpp A., Depew M.J., Rubenstein J.L., Bishop J.M., Martin G.R. Cre-mediated gene inactivation demonstrates that FGF8 is required for cell survival and patterning of the first branchial arch. Genes Dev. 1999, 13:3136-3148.
175. Tucker A.S., Yamada G., Grigoriou M., Pachnis V., Sharpe P.T. Fgf-8 determines rostral-caudal polarity in the first branchial arch. Development 1999, 126:51-61.
176. Tucker A.S., Watson R.P., Lettice L.A., Yamada G., Hill R.E Bapx1 regulates patterning in the middle ear: altered regulatory rolein the transition from the proximal jaw during vertebrate evolution. Development 2004, 131:1235-1245.
177. Twigg S.R., Versnel S.L., Nürnberg G., Lees M.M., Bhat M., Hammond P., Hennekam R.C., Hoogeboom A.J., Hurst J.A., Johnson D., Robinson A.A., Scambler P.J., Gerrelli D., Nürnberg P., Mathijssen I.M., Wilkie A.O. Frontorhiny, a distinctive presentation of fronto- nasal dysplasia caused by recessive mutations in the ALX3 homeobox gene. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 2009, 84:698-705.
178. Walker M.B., Miller C.T., Coffin Talbot J., Stock D.W., Kimmel C.B. Zebrafish furin mutants reveal intricacies in regulating Endothelin1 signaling in craniofacial patterning. Dev. Biol. 2006, 295:194-205.
179. Wall N.A., Hogan B.L. Expression of bone morphogenetic protein-4 (BMP-4), bone morphogenetic protein-7 (BMP-7), fibroblast growth factor-8 (FGF-8) and Sonic hedgehog (SHH) during branchial arch development in the chick. Mech. Dev. 1995, 53:383-392.
180. Watson D.M.S Croonian lecture: the evolution and origin of the amphibia. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London 1926, 214:189-257.
181. Watson D.M.S. The aconthodian fishes. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London, Ser. B 228 1937, 49-146.
182. Wilga C.D. A functional analysis of jaw suspension in elasmobranchs. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 2002, 75:483-502.
183. Williams, J.A., Mann, F.M., Brown, N.A. 1997. Gene expression domains as markers in developmental toxicity studies using mammalian embryo culture. Int. J. Dev. Biol. 41, 359-364.
184. Wotton K.R., Mazet F., Shimeld S.M. Expression of FoxC, FoxF, FoxL1, and FoxQ1 genes in the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula defines ancient and derived roles for Fox genes in vertebrate development. Dev Dyn. 2008, 237:1590-1603.
185. Wu P., Jiang T., Suksaweang S., Widelitz R.B., Chuong C.M. Molecular shaping of the beak. Science 2004, 305:1465-1466.
186. Yanagisawa H., Hammer R.E., Richardson J.A., Emoto N., Williams S.C., Takeda S., Clouthier D.E., Yanagisawa M. Disruption of ECE-1 and ECE-2 reveals a role for endothelin-converting enzyme-2 in murine cardiac development. J. Clin. Invest. 2000, 105:1373-1382.
187. Young J.Z. The Life of Vertebrates 1981, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
188. Zhu M., Ahlberg P.E. The origin of the internal nostril of tetrapods. Nature 2004, 432:94-97.
189. Zirzowa S., Lüdtkea T.H.W., Bronsb J.F., Petrya M., Christoffelsb V.M., Kispert A. Expression and requirement of T-box transcription factors Tbx2 and Tbx3 during secondary palate development in the mouse. Dev. Biol. 2009, 336:145-155.
190. Zusi R.L. Patterns of diversity in the avian skull. The Skull, Volume 2: Patterns of Structural and Systematic Diversity 1993, 391-437. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, US.