Use of minimal extracorporeal circulation improves outcome after heart surgery; A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

International Journal of Cardiology

Volumn 164, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 158-169

  Anastasiadis, Kyriakos ^a   Antonitsis, Polychronis ^a   Haidich, Anna Bettina ^a   Argiriadou, Helena ^a   Deliopoulos, Apostolos ^a   Papakonstantinou, Christos ^a  

^a ARISTOTLE UNIVERSITY OF THESSALONIKI   (Greece)

Author keywords

Cardiopulmonary bypass; Coronary artery bypass grafting; Meta analysis; Minimal extracorporeal circulation

Indexed keywords

CREATININE; LEUKOCYTE ELASTASE; TROPONIN; ELASTASE; INOTROPIC AGENT;

ARTIFICIAL VENTILATION; BRAIN ISCHEMIA; CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE; CREATININE BLOOD LEVEL; ERYTHROCYTE TRANSFUSION; EXTRACORPOREAL CIRCULATION; FORWARD HEART FAILURE; HEART ATRIUM FIBRILLATION; HEART INFARCTION; HEART SURGERY; HEMATOCRIT; HEMODILUTION; HOSPITAL DISCHARGE; HUMAN; INFLAMMATION; INOTROPISM; INTENSIVE CARE; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LENGTH OF STAY; META ANALYSIS; MINIMALLY INVASIVE PROCEDURE; MORBIDITY; NERVOUS SYSTEM INJURY; NEUTROPHIL; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SURGICAL MORTALITY; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; SYSTEMIC INFLAMMATORY RESPONSE; TREATMENT OUTCOME; AORTA VALVE REPLACEMENT; AORTIC ROOT SURGERY; ARTICLE; ATRIAL FIBRILLATION; CARDIOVASCULAR MORTALITY; CARDIOVASCULAR RISK; CONVENTIONAL EXTRACORPOREAL CIRCULATION; CORONARY ARTERY BYPASS GRAFT; EXTRACORPOREAL MEMBRANE OXYGENATION DEVICE; EXTRACORPOREAL OXYGENATION; HEART DISEASE; INTENSIVE CARE UNIT; MINIMAL EXTRACORPOREAL CIRCULATION; NEUROLOGIC DISEASE; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PROTEIN SECRETION; RISK ASSESSMENT; TREATMENT DURATION;

CARDIAC SURGICAL PROCEDURES; EXTRACORPOREAL CIRCULATION; HUMANS; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84875219180     PISSN: 01675273     EISSN: 18741754     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijcard.2012.01.020     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. P.W. Serruys, M.C. Morice, and A.P. Kappetein SYNTAX investigators. Percutaneous coronary intervention versus coronary-artery bypass grafting for severe coronary artery disease N Engl J Med 360 2009 961 972
2. D.M. Shahian, F. Edwards, and F.L. Grover The Society of Thoracic Surgeons National Adult Cardiac Database: a continuing commitment to excellence J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 140 2010 955 959
3. J.G. Laffey, J.F. Boylan, and D.C. Cheng The systemic inflammatory response to cardiac surgery: implications for the anesthesiologist Anesthesiology 97 2002 215 252
4. P. Biglioli, A. Cannata, and F. Alamanni Biological effects of off-pump vs. on-pump coronary artery surgery: focus on inflammation, hemostasis and oxidative stress Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 24 2003 260 269
5. N.D. Desai, M.P. Pelletier, and H.R. Mallidi Why is off-pump coronary surgery uncommon in Canada? Results of a population-based survey of Canadian heart surgeons Circulation 110 Suppl. 1 2004 II7 II12
6. A.L. Shroyer, F.L. Grover, and B. Hattler Veterans Affairs Randomized On/Off Bypass (ROOBY) Study Group. On-pump versus off-pump coronary-artery bypass surgery N Engl J Med 361 2009 1827 1837
7. T. Puehler, A. Haneya, and A. Philipp Minimal extracorporeal circulation: an alternative for on-pump and off-pump coronary revascularization Ann Thorac Surg 87 2009 766 772
8. A. Castiglioni, A. Verzini, and F. Pappalardo Minimally invasive closed circuit versus standard extracorporeal circulation for aortic valve replacement Ann Thorac Surg 83 2007 586 591
9. K. Anastasiadis, O. Chalvatzoulis, and P. Antonitsis Use of minimized extracorporeal circulation system in non-coronary and valve cardiac surgical procedures - a case series Artif Organs 2011 10.1111/j.1525-1594.2010.01183.x
10. A. Liberati, D.G. Altman, and J. Tetzlaff The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration J Clin Epidemiol 62 2009 e1 e34
11. J.P.T. Higgins, and D.G. Altman Assessing risk of bias in included studies J.P.T. Higgins, S. Green, Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 5.0.0. The Cochrane Collaboration 2008 updated February 2008
12. R. DerSimonian, and N. Laird Meta-analysis in clinical trials Control Clin Trials 7 1986 177 188
13. J.P. Higgins, S.G. Thompson, J.J. Deeks, and D.G. Altman Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses BMJ 327 2003 557 560
14. M. Egger, G. Davey Smith, M. Schneider, and C. Minder Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test BMJ 315 1997 629 634
15. G. Rücker, G. Schwarzer, and J. Carpenter Arcsine test for publication bias in meta-analyses with binary outcomes Stat Med 27 2008 746 763
16. G. Schwarzer meta 2010. R package version 1.6-1 http://www.R-project.org
17. A. Yilmaz, J. Sjatskig, and W.J. van Boven Combined coronary artery bypass grafting and aortic valve replacement with minimal extracorporeal closed circuit circulation versus standard cardiopulmonary bypass Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 11 2010 754 757
18. Y. Kobayashi, M. Mitsuno, and M. Yamamura Evaluation of closed cardiopulmonary bypass circuit for aortic valve replacement ASAIO J 56 2010 309 312
19. C.A. Lezama Urtecho, E. de Leon Lagunas, and G. Careaga Reyna Coronary artery bypass grafting surgery with minimal extracorporeal circulation system Cir Cir 78 2010 121 125
20. D. Reber, R. Brouwer, and D. Buchwald Beating-heart coronary artery bypass grafting with miniaturized cardiopulmonary bypass results in a more complete revascularization when compared to off-pump grafting Artif Organs 34 2010 179 184
21. S.P. Koivisto, J.O. Wistbacka, and R. Rimpiläinen Miniaturized versus conventional cardiopulmonary bypass in high-risk patients undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery Perfusion 25 2010 65 70
22. N. Rahe-Meyer, C. Solomon, and M.L. Tokuno Comparative assessment of coagulation changes induced by two different types of heart-lung machine Artif Organs 34 2010 3 12
23. A. Haneya, A. Philipp, and C. Diez Comparison of two different minimized extracorporeal circulation systems: hematological effects after coronary surgery ASAIO J 55 2009 592 597
24. M. Kolackova, V. Lonsky, and M. Trojackova Kudlova Serum level of sCD163, a soluble receptor for hemoglobin, is influenced by cardiac surgery Perfusion 24 2009 263 269
25. C. Diez, A. Haneya, and F. Brünger Minimized extracorporeal circulation cannot prevent acute kidney injury but attenuates early renal dysfunction after coronary bypass grafting ASAIO J 55 2009 602 607
26. G.F. Panday, S. Fischer, and A. Bauer Minimal extracorporeal circulation and off-pump compared to conventional cardiopulmonary bypass in coronary surgery Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 9 2009 832 836
27. F. Capuano, M. Goracci, and R. Luciani Neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin levels after use of mini-cardiopulmonary bypass system Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 9 2009 797 801
28. U. Benedetto, R. Luciani, and M. Goracci Miniaturized cardiopulmonary bypass and acute kidney injury in coronary artery bypass graft surgery Ann Thorac Surg 88 2009 529 535
29. A. Colli, C. Fernandez, L. Delgado, B. Romero, M.L. Camara, and X. Ruyra Aortic valve replacement with minimal extracorporeal circulation versus standard cardiopulmonary bypass Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 9 2009 583 587
30. R. Rimpiläinen, F. Biancari, and J.O. Wistbacka Outcome after coronary artery bypass surgery with miniaturized versus conventional cardiopulmonary bypass Perfusion 23 2008 361 367
31. L.K. Ti, B.L. Goh, P.S. Wong, P. Ong, S.G. Goh, and C.N. Lee Comparison of mini-cardiopulmonary bypass system with air-purge device to conventional bypass system Ann Thorac Surg 85 2008 994 1000
32. F.F. Immer, A. Ackermann, and E. Gygax Minimal extracorporeal circulation is a promising technique for coronary artery bypass grafting Ann Thorac Surg 84 2007 1515 1520
33. M. Stalder, E. Gygax, F.F. Immer, L. Englberger, H. Tevaearai, and T.P. Carrel Minimized cardiopulmonary bypass combined with a smart suction device: the future of cardiopulmonary bypass? Heart Surg Forum 10 2007 E235 E238
34. S. Agati, G. Ciccarello, and E.S. Trimarchi Extracorporeal circulation, optimized: a pilot study Artif Organs 31 2007 377 383
35. M. Ranucci, and G. Isgrò Minimally invasive cardiopulmonary bypass: does it really change the outcome? Crit Care 11 2007 R45
36. F.F. Immer, C. Pirovino, E. Gygax, L. Englberger, H. Tevaearai, and T.P. Carrel Minimal versus conventional cardiopulmonary bypass: assessment of intraoperative myocardial damage in coronary bypass surgery Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 28 2005 701 704
37. T. Murakami, H. Iwagaki, and S. Saito Equivalence of the acute cytokine surge and myocardial injury after coronary artery bypass grafting with and without a novel extracorporeal circulation system J Int Med Res 33 2005 133 149
38. C. Wiesenack, A. Liebold, and A. Philipp Four years' experience with a miniaturized extracorporeal circulation system and its influence on clinical outcome Artif Organs 28 2004 1082 1088
39. A.H. Kiessling, M. Khalil, O. Assaf, F. Isgro, K.U. Kretz, and W. Saggau Blood-air interface during cardiopulmonary bypass Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann 12 2004 198 201
40. H. Takai, K. Eishi, and S. Yamachika The efficacy of low prime volume completely closed cardiopulmonary bypass in coronary artery revascularization Ann Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 10 2004 178 182
41. M. Ranucci, G. Isgrò, G. Soro, A. Canziani, L. Menicanti, and A. Frigiola Reduced systemic heparin dose with phosphorylcholine coated closed circuit in coronary operations Int J Artif Organs 27 2004 311 319
42. C. Vaislic, O. Bical, and C. Farge Totally minimized extracorporeal circulation: an important benefit for coronary artery bypass grafting in Jehovah's witnesses Heart Surg Forum 6 2003 307 310
43. J. Fukada, K. Morishita, and A. Ingu Comparative study of the effect on clinical outcome of the use of an open circuit and the use of a closed circuit in cardiopulmonary bypass for a graft replacement of the descending thoracic or thoracoabdominal aorta Surg Today 34 2004 11 15
44. J. Skorpil, T. Hajek, and M. Staszko Minimized perfusion circuit ROCSAFE RX - no line on the horizon Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 10 Suppl. 1 2010 S95
45. F. Rosato, F. Barili, and E. Ardemagni Initial experience with minimized extracorporeal circulation in elective coronary artery bypass grafting surgery Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 8 Suppl. 1 2009 S39
46. T. Hajek, J. Skorpil, M. Urban, and M. Staszko Can minimized perfusion circuit reduce mortality/morbidity in comparison with conventional extracorporeal circulation system? Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 8 Suppl. 1 2009 S119
47. A. de la Fuente, J. Barado, and J.L. Frenandez MECC the best approach for CABG? Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 7 Suppl. 1 2008 S1
48. G.D. Trachiotis, D. Baldwin, E. Zena, and M. Greenberg Early experience with miniaturized cardiopulmonary bypass (mini-pump) in cardiac surgery Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 7 Suppl. 1 2008 S103
49. M.D. Harorstock, and B. Cinar Progressive experience with a miniaturized extracorporeal circuit Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 6 Suppl. 1 2007 S31
50. M.D. Harorstock Experience with a miniaturized extracorporeal circuit Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 6 Suppl. 1 2007 S59
51. P.J. Tomaszewski, J. Stupala, and P.B. Wypych Resting heart system - own experience Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 6 Suppl. 1 2007 S107
52. M. Perthel, A. Bendisch, and J. Laas Clinical advantages of using mini bypass systems in terms of blood product use, post operative bleeding and air entrainment: an in vivo clinical perspective Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 5 Suppl. 2 2007 S231
53. A. de la Fuente, J. Barado, and R. Sánchez Off pump or minimal extracorporeal circulation? A comparative study Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 5 Suppl. 1 2006 S48
54. P. Stassano, L. Di Tommaso, and M. Monaco Myocardial revascularization by left ventricular assisted beating heart is associated with reduced systemic inflammatory response Ann Thorac Surg 87 2009 46 52
55. W.J. van Boven, W.B. Gerritsen, and A.H. Driessen Myocardial oxidative stress, and cell injury comparing three different techniques for coronary artery bypass grafting Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 34 2008 969 975
56. C. Prasser, M. Abbady, and C. Keyl Effect of a miniaturized extracorporeal circulation (MECC System) on liver function Perfusion 22 2007 245 250
57. S. Rex, S. Brose, and S. Metzelder Normothermic beating heart surgery with assistance of miniaturized bypass systems: the effects on intraoperative hemodynamics and inflammatory response Anesth Analg 102 2006 352 362
58. H. Kamiya, T. Kofidis, A. Haverich, and U. Klima Preliminary experience with the mini-extracorporeal circulation system (Medtronic resting heart system) Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 5 2006 680 682
59. G. Nollert, I. Schwabenland, and D. Maktav Miniaturized cardiopulmonary bypass in coronary artery bypass surgery: marginal impact on inflammation and coagulation but loss of safety margins Ann Thorac Surg 80 2005 2326 2332
60. J. Wippermann, J.M. Albes, and M. Hartrumpf Comparison of minimally invasive closed circuit extracorporeal circulation with conventional cardiopulmonary bypass and with off-pump technique in CABG patients: selected parameters of coagulation and inflammatory system Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 28 2005 127 132
61. H. Tanaka, T. Oshiyama, and T. Narisawa Clinical study of biocompatibility between open and closed heparin-coated cardiopulmonary bypass circuits J Artif Organs 6 2003 245 252
62. K. Anastasiadis, C. Asteriou, and A. Deliopoulos Haematological effects of minimized compared to conventional extracorporeal circulation after coronary revascularization procedures Perfusion 25 2010 197 203
63. A. Bauer, C. Diez, and J. Schubel Evaluation of hemodynamic and regional tissue perfusion effects of minimized extracorporeal circulation (MECC) J Extra Corpor Technol 42 2010 30 39
64. A. El-Essawi, T. Hajek, and J. Skorpil A prospective randomised multicentre clinical comparison of a minimised perfusion circuit versus conventional cardiopulmonary bypass Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 38 2010 91 97
65. S. Gunaydin, T. Sari, K. McCusker, U. Schonrock, and Y. Zorlutuna Clinical evaluation of minimized extracorporeal circulation in high-risk coronary revascularization: impact on air handling, inflammation, hemodilution and myocardial function Perfusion 24 2009 153 162
66. I. Kutschka, J. Skorpil, A. El Essawi, T. Hajek, and W. Harringer Beneficial effects of modern perfusion concepts in aortic valve and aortic root surgery Perfusion 24 2009 37 44
67. A. Castiglioni, A. Verzini, N. Colangelo, S. Nascimbene, G. Laino, and O. Alfieri Comparison of minimally invasive closed circuit versus standard extracorporeal circulation for aortic valve replacement: a randomized study Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 9 2009 37 41
68. M.P. Sakwa, R.W. Emery, and F.L. Shannon Coronary artery bypass grafting with a minimized cardiopulmonary bypass circuit: a prospective, randomized trial J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 137 2009 481 485
69. D. Camboni, S. Schmidt, and A. Philipp Microbubble activity in miniaturized and in conventional extracorporeal circulation ASAIO J 55 2009 58 62
70. F. Formica, F. Broccolo, and A. Martino Myocardial revascularization with miniaturized extracorporeal circulation versus off pump: evaluation of systemic and myocardial inflammatory response in a prospective randomized study J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 137 2009 1206 1212
71. T. Ohata, M. Mitsuno, and M. Yamamura Beneficial effects of mini-cardiopulmonary bypass on hemostasis in coronary artery bypass grafting: analysis of inflammatory response and hemodilution ASAIO J 54 2008 207 209
72. J. Schöttler, G. Lutter, and A. Böning Is there really a clinical benefit of using minimized extracorporeal circulation for coronary artery bypass grafting? Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 56 2008 65 70
73. T. Kofidis, H. Baraki, and H. Singh The minimized extracorporeal circulation system causes less inflammation and organ damage Perfusion 23 2008 147 151
74. V. Mazzei, G. Nasso, G. Salamone, F. Castorino, A. Tommasini, and A. Anselmi Prospective randomized comparison of coronary bypass grafting with minimal extracorporeal circulation system (MECC) versus off-pump coronary surgery Circulation 116 2007 1761 1767
75. M. Valtonen, T. Vähäsilta, T. Kaila-Keinänen, and K. Kuttila New mini-extracorporeal circulation system (ECC.O) is a safe technique in coronary surgery Scand Cardiovasc J 41 2007 345 350
76. R.A. Huybregts, A.M. Morariu, and G. Rakhorst Attenuated renal and intestinal injury after use of a mini-cardiopulmonary bypass system Ann Thorac Surg 83 2007 1760 1766
77. M. Perthel, L. El-Ayoubi, A. Bendisch, J. Laas, and M. Gerigk Clinical advantages of using mini-bypass systems in terms of blood product use, postoperative bleeding and air entrainment: an in vivo clinical perspective Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 31 2007 1070 1075
78. C.A. Skrabal, G. Steinhoff, and A. Liebold Minimizing cardiopulmonary bypass attenuates myocardial damage after cardiac surgery ASAIO J 53 2007 32 35
79. C. Beghi, F. Nicolini, and A. Agostinelli Mini-cardiopulmonary bypass system: results of a prospective randomized study Ann Thorac Surg 81 2006 1396 1400
80. O.M. Bical, Y. Fromes, and D. Gaillard Comparison of the inflammatory response between miniaturized and standard CPB circuits in aortic valve surgery Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 29 2006 699 702
81. J.P. Remadi, Z. Rakotoarivelo, P. Marticho, and A. Benamar Prospective randomized study comparing coronary artery bypass grafting with the new mini-extracorporeal circulation Jostra System or with a standard cardiopulmonary bypass Am Heart J 151 2006 198.e1 198.e7
82. U. Abdel-Rahman, F. Ozaslan, and P.S. Risteski Initial experience with a minimized extracorporeal bypass system: is there a clinical benefit? Ann Thorac Surg 80 2005 238 243
83. J.P. Remadi, Z. Rakotoarivello, and P. Marticho Aortic valve replacement with the minimal extracorporeal circulation (Jostra MECC System) versus standard cardiopulmonary bypass: a randomized prospective trial J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 128 2004 436 441
84. Y. Fromes, D. Gaillard, and O. Ponzio Reduction of the inflammatory response following coronary bypass grafting with total minimal extracorporeal circulation Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 22 2002 527 533
85. M. Abdel Aal Mini-cardiopulmonary bypass impact on blood conservation strategy in coronary artery bypass grafting Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 10 Suppl. 1 2010 S48
86. I. Ovcina, E. Beran, and L. Salaymeh MECC - any advantage in CABG patients? Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 8 Suppl. 1 2009 S62
87. J. Zeitani, S. Nardella, and D. Colella On-pump CABG surgery: mini vs. conventional extracorporeal circulation. A prospective randomised study Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 7 Suppl. 3 2008 S216
88. A. Zangrillo, F.A. Garozzo, and G. Biondi-Zoccai Miniaturized cardiopulmonary bypass improves short-term outcome in cardiac surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 139 2010 1162 1169
89. F. Biancari, and R. Rimpiläinen Meta-analysis of randomised trials comparing the effectiveness of miniaturised versus conventional cardiopulmonary bypass in adult cardiac surgery Heart 95 2009 964 969
90. L. Harling, O.J. Warren, and A. Martin Do miniaturized extracorporeal circuits confer significant clinical benefit without compromising safety? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials ASAIO J 57 2011 141 151
91. A. Mazzone, S. De Servi, and I. Mazzucchelli Increased concentrations of inflammatory mediators in unstable angina: correlation with serum troponin T Heart 85 2001 571 575
92. M. Westerberg, A. Bengtsson, and A. Jeppsson Coronary surgery without cardiotomy suction and autotransfusion reduces the postoperative systemic inflammatory response Ann Thorac Surg 78 2004 54 59
93. M.A. Grega, L.M. Borowicz, and W.A. Baumgartner Impact of single clamp versus double clamp technique on neurologic outcomes Ann Thorac Surg 75 2003 1387 1391
94. H.P. Wendel, and G. Ziemer Coating-techniques to improve the hemocompatibility of artificial devices used for extracorporeal circulation Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 16 1999 342 350
95. R.F. Brooker, W.R. Brown, and D.M. Moody Cardiotomy suction: a major source of brain lipid emboli during cardiopulmonary bypass Ann Thorac Surg 65 1998 1651 1655
96. A. Liebold, A. Khosravi, and B. Westphal Effect of closed minimized cardiopulmonary bypass on cerebral tissue oxygenation and microembolization J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 131 2006 268 276
97. K. Anastasiadis, H. Argiriadou, and M.H. Kosmidis Neurocognitive outcome after coronary bypass surgery using minimal versus conventional extracorporeal circulation: a randomized controlled pilot study Heart 97 2011 1082 1088
98. T. Puehler, A. Haneya, and A. Philipp Minimized extracorporeal circulation system in coronary artery bypass surgery: a 10-year single-center experience with 2243 patients Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 39 2011 459 464
99. J.P. Remadi, P. Marticho, and I. Butoi Clinical experience with the mini-extracorporeal circulation system: an evolution or a revolution? Ann Thorac Surg 77 2004 2172 2175