Out of Bounds? A Critique of the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female Athletes

American Journal of Bioethics

Volumn 12, Issue 7, 2012, Pages 3-16

  Karkazis, Katrina ^a   Jordan Young, Rebecca ^b   Davis, Georgiann ^c   Camporesi, Silvia ^d  

^a STANFORD UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^b Barnard College of Columbia University   (United States)

^c SOUTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY EDWARDSVILLE   (United States)

^d KING'S COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

feminist ethics; gender sexuality

Indexed keywords

ANDROGEN; TESTOSTERONE;

ARTICLE; ATHLETE; BLOOD; CONFIDENTIALITY; CONGENITAL ADRENAL HYPERPLASIA; CONGENITAL MALFORMATION; FEMALE; FEMALE GENITAL SYSTEM; HISTORY; HUMAN; HYPERANDROGENISM; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; LEGAL ASPECT; METHODOLOGY; POLICY; SEX DETERMINATION; SEX DIFFERENTIATION DISORDER; SPORT; STANDARD; X CHROMOSOME;

ADRENAL HYPERPLASIA, CONGENITAL; ANDROGENS; ATHLETES; CHROMOSOMES, HUMAN, X; CONFIDENTIALITY; DISORDERS OF SEX DEVELOPMENT; FEMALE; GENITALIA, FEMALE; HISTORY, 20TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 21ST CENTURY; HUMANS; HYPERANDROGENISM; INTERNATIONALITY; POLICY; SEX DETERMINATION ANALYSIS; SPORTS; TESTOSTERONE;

EID: 84862329917     PISSN: 15265161     EISSN: 15360075     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/15265161.2012.680533     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. Abdel-Rahman, M. Y. and Hurd, W. W. 2010. Androgen excess. MedScape Reference, August 5. Available at:http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/273153-overview
2. Adams, W. L. 2009. Could this women's world champ be a man?. Time, August 21. Available at:http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1917767,00.html-ixzz1hEXnRsSc
3. Archer, J. S. and Chang, R. J. 2004. Hirsutism and acne in polycystic ovary syndrome. Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 18(5): 737-754.
4. Bateup, H. S., Booth, A.Shirtcliff, E. A. 2002. Testosterone, cortisol, and women's competition. Evolution and Human Behavior, 23(3): 181-192.
5. BBC. 2009. SA chief suspended in Semenya row. BBC News, November 5, 2009. Available at:http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/athletics/8344591.stm
6. Bhasin, S., Storer, T. W.Berman, N. 1996. The effects of supraphysiologic doses of testosterone on muscle size and strength in normal men. New England Journal of Medicine, 335(1): 1-7.
7. Bhasin, S., Woodhouse, L.Casaburi, R. 2001. Testosterone dose-response relationships in healthy young men. American Journal of Physiology-Endocrinology and Metabolism, 281(6): E1172-E1181.
8. Braunstein, G. D. 2011. "Testes". In Greenspan's Basic & Clinical Endocrinology chap. 12. Available at:http://www.accessmedicine.com.laneproxy.stanford.edu/content.aspx?aID=8405050
9. Charmandari, E., Brook, C. G.Hindmarsh, P. C. 2004. Classic congenital adrenal hyperplasia and puberty. European Journal of Endocrinology/European Federation of Endocrine Societies, 151(suppl. 3): U77-U82.
10. Clarey, C. 2009. Gender test after a gold-medal finish. New York Times, August 19. Available at:http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/20/sports/20runner.html
11. Clemmons, A. K. 2008. 7 feet 7 and 360 pounds, with bigger feet than Shaq's. New York Times, January 9. Available at:http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/09/sports/ncaabasketball/09asheville.html
12. Cole, C. L. 2000. "One chromosome too many?". In The Olympics at the millennium: Power, politics and the games, Edited by: Schaffer, K. and Smith, S. 128-146. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
13. Cyphers, L. and Fagan, K. 2011. On homophobia and recruiting: Coaches will use a subtle vocabulary to qualify certain programs; It's become pollution. ESPN, January 26. Available at:http://sports.espn.go.com/ncw/news/story?id = 6060641
14. de la Chapelle, A. 1986. The use and misuse of sex chromatin screening for 'gender identification' of female athletes. Journal of the American Medical Association, 256(14): 1920-1923.
15. Dewey & LeBoeuf. 2010. Caster Semenya on track to return to athletics following IAAF settlement. July 6. Available at:http://www.deweyleboeuf.com/en/Firm/MediaCenter/PressReleases/2010/07/CasterSemenyaonTracktoReturntoAthletics.aspx
16. Dingeon, B. 1993. Gender verification and the next Olympic games. Journal of the American Medical Association, 269(3): 357-358.
17. Dolan, S., Wilkie, S.Aliabadi, N. 2004. Effects of testosterone administration in human immunodeficiency virus-infected women with low weight: A randomized placebo-controlled study. Archives of Internal Medicine, 164(8): 897-904.
18. Dreger, A. 1998. Hermaphrodites and the medical invention of sex, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
19. Dreger, A. 2010. Sex typing for sport. Hastings Center Report, 40(2): 22-24.
20. Drinkwater, B. L. and International Federation of Sports Medicine. 2000. Women in sport, Malden, MA: Blackwell Science.
21. Dworkin, S. L. and Messner, M. A. 2002. Introduction: Gender relations in sport. Sociological Perspectives, 45(4): 347-352.
22. Edwards, D. A. and O'Neal, J. L. 2009. Oral contraceptives decrease saliva testosterone but do not affect the rise in testosterone associated with athletic competition. Hormones and Behavior, 56(2): 195-198.
23. Elsas, L. J., Ljungqvist, A.Ferguson-Smith, M. A. 2000. Gender verification of female athletes. Genetics in Medicine, 2(4): 249-254.
24. Eugster, E. A., Dimeglio, L. A.Wright, J. C. 2001. Height outcome in congenital adrenal hyperplasia caused by 21-hydroxylase deficiency: A meta-analysis. Journal of Pediatrics, 138(1): 26-32.
25. Eynon, N., Birk, R.Meckel, Y. 2011. Physiological variables and mitochondrial-related genotypes of an athlete who excels in both short and long-distance running. Mitochondrion, 11(5): 774-777.
26. Eynon, N., Moran, M.Birk, R. 2011. The champions' mitochondria: Is it genetically determined? A review on mitochondrial DNA and elite athletic performance. Physiological Genomics, 43(13): 789-798.
27. Eynon, N., Ruiz, J. R.Meckel, Y. 2011. Mitochondrial biogenesis related endurance genotype score and sports performance in athletes. Mitochondrion, 11(1): 64-69.
28. Farquhar, G. 2009. New twist in Semenya gender saga. BBC News, August 25. Available at:http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/athletics/8219937.stm
29. Fausto-Sterling, A. 1985. Myths of gender: Biological theories about women and men, New York: Basic Books.
30. Foddy, B. and Savulescu, J. 2011. Time to re-evaluate gender segregation in athletics?. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 45(15): 1184-1188.
31. Foxnews.com. 2008. Michael Phelps unintentionally raises Marfan syndrome awareness. Foxnews.com, August 21. Available at:http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,408023,00.html
32. Genel, M. 2000. Gender verification no more?. Medscape Womens Health, 5(3): E2
33. Hajer, M. A. and Wagenaar, H., eds. 2003. Deliberative policy analysis; Understanding governance in a network society., Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
34. Hannagan, R. J. and Larimer, C. W. 2010. Does gender composition affect group decision outcomes? Evidence from a laboratory experiment. Political Behavior, 32(1): 51-67.
35. Haring, R., Hannemann, A.John, U. 2012. Age-specific reference ranges for serum testosterone and androstenedione concentrations in women measured by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 97(2): 408-415.
36. Hay, E. 1972. Sex determination in putative female athletes. Journal of the American Medical Association, 221(9): 998-999.
37. Hay, E. 1974. Femininity tests at the Olympic games. Olympic Review,: 119-123. 76-77(March-April)
38. Heggie, V. 2010. Testing sex and gender in sports; Reinventing, reimagining and reconstructing histories. Endeavour, 34(4): 157-163.
39. Hurst, M. 2009. Caster Semenya has male sex organs and no womb or ovaries. Daily Telegraph, September 11. Available at:http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/Semenya-has-no-womb-or-ovaries/story-e6frexni-1225771672245
40. IAAF. 2011a. 800 metres all time. August 16. Available at:http://www.iaaf.org/statistics/toplists/inout=o/age=n/season=0/sex=W/all=y/legal=A/disc=800/detail.html
41. IAAF. 2011b. 800 metres junior all time. August 3. Available at:http://www.iaaf.org/statistics/toplists/inout=o/age=j/season=0/sex=W/all=y/legal=A/disc=800/detail.html
42. IAAF. 2011c. IAAF regulations governing eligibility of females with hyperandrogenism to compete in women's competitions. Available at:http://www.iaaf.org/mm/Document/AboutIAAF/Publications/05/98/78/20110430054216_httppostedfile_HARegulations(Final)-Appendices-AMG-30.04.2011_24299.pdf
43. IOC. 2011. IOC addresses eligibility of female athletes with hyperandrogenism. April 5. Available at:http://www.Olympic.org/content/press-release/ioc-addresses-eligibility-of-female-athletes-with-hyperandrogenism
44. Jordan-Young, R. M. 2010. Brain storm: The flaws in the science of sex differences, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
45. Karkazis, K. 2008. Fixing sex: Intersex, medical authority, and lived experience, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
46. Kessler, S. 1998. Lessons from the intersexed, New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
47. Kessler, S. and McKenna, W. 1978. Gender: An ethnomethodological approach, New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons.
48. Kvorning, T., Andersen, M.Brixen, K. 2006. Suppression of endogenous testosterone production attenuates the response to strength training: A randomized, placebo-controlled, and blinded intervention study. American Journal of Physiology-Endocrinology and Metabolism, 291(6): E1325-1332.
49. Laby, D. M., Rosenbaum, A. L.Kirschen, D. G. 1996. The visual function of professional baseball players. American Journal of Ophthalmology, 122(4): 476-485.
50. Laqueur, T. W. 1990. Making sex: Body and gender from the Greeks to Freud, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
51. Levy, A. 2009. Either/or: Sports, sex, and the case of Caster Semenya. New Yorker, 1: 46-59. November
52. Ljungqvist, A., Martínez-Patiño, M. J.Martínez-Vidal, A. 2006. The history and current policies on gender testing in elite athletes. International SportMed Journal, 7(3): 225-230.
53. Longcope, C. 1986. Adrenal and gonadal androgen secretion in normal females. Clinics in Endocrinology and Metabolism, 15(2): 213-228.
54. MacLean, H. E., Chiu, W. S.Notini, A. J. 2008. Impaired skeletal muscle development and function in male, but not female, genomic androgen receptor knockout mice. FASEB Journal, 22(8): 2676-2689.
55. Mannix, C. 2007. High hopes: He's three inches taller than Yao Ming, but is pro hoops' biggest player ready for the NBA?. Sports Illustrated, Available at:http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1107021/index.htm
56. Martínez-Patiño, M. J. 2005. Personal account: A woman tried and tested. Lancet, 366(suppl. 1): S38
57. McCaul, K. D., Gladue, B. A. and Joppa, M. 1992. Winning, losing, mood, and testosterone. Hormones and Behavior, 26(4): 486-504.
58. Meyer-Bahlburg, H. F. 2011. Brain development and cognitive, psychosocial, and psychiatric functioning in classical 21-hydroxylase deficiency. Endocrine Development, 20: 88-95.
59. Miller, K. K., Biller, B. M.Beauregard, C. 2006. Effects of testosterone replacement in androgen-deficient women with hypopituitarism: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 91(5): 1683-1690.
60. Murray, T. H. 2009. "In search of an ethics of sport: Genetic hierarchies, handicappers general, and embodied excellence". In Performance-enhancing technologies in sports, Edited by: Murray, T. H., Maschke, K. J. and Wasunna, A. A. 225-238. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
61. New, M. I. and Simpson, J. L. 2010. Program for 2nd World Conference Hormonal and Genetic Basis of Sexual Differentiation Disorders and Hot Topics in Endocrinology January 15-17. Available at:http://cme.med.miami.edu/documents/FIUbrochure.pdf
62. New, M. I. and Simpson, J. L. 2011. "Preface". In Hormonal and genetic basis of sexual differentiation disorders and hot topics in endocrinology: Proceedings of the 2nd world conference, Edited by: New, M. I. and Simpson, J. L. v-vii. New York, NY: Springer.
63. Oliveira, T., Gouveia, M. J. and Oliveira, R. F. 2009. Testosterone responsiveness to winning and losing experiences in female soccer players. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 34(7): 1056-1064.
64. Olsen-Acre, H. K. 2003. Sex and gender on the playing field: A feminist critique of drug testing in the Olympic games. Columbia College, New York, NY Undergraduate thesis
65. Olympic.org. n.d. When did women first compete in the Olympic games?. Available at:http://registration.Olympic.org/en/faq/detail/id/135
66. Ostrander, E. A., Huson, H. J.Ostrander, G. K. 2009. Genetics of athletic performance. Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics, 10: 407-429.
67. Oudshoorn, N. 1994. Beyond the natural body: An archeology of sex hormones, New York, NY: Routledge.
68. Pitsiladis, Y., Wang, G. and Wolfarth, B. 2011. "Genomics of aerobic capacity and endurance performance: Clinical implications". In Exercise genomics, Edited by: Pescatello, L. S. and Roth, S. M. 179-229. New York, NY: Springer.
69. Reaney, P. 2011. Female athletes judged by sex appeal. ABCnews.com, September 13. Available at:http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=119952&page=1-.TzBv7uNbWG4
70. Reis, E. 2009. Bodies in doubt: An American history of intersex, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
71. Ritchie, R., Reynard, J. and Lewis, T. 2008. Intersex and the Olympic games. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 101(8): 395-399.
72. Ronnestad, B. R., Nygaard, H. and Raastad, T. 2011. Physiological elevation of endogenous hormones results in superior strength training adaptation. European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology, 111(9): 2249-2259.
73. Rubin, G. 1975. "The traffic in women: Notes on the political economy of sex". In Toward an anthropology of women, Edited by: Reiter, R. R. 157-210. New York, NY: Monthly Review Press.
74. Russett, C. E. 1989. Sexual science: The Victorian construction of womanhood, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
75. Sapolsky, R. M. 1997. The trouble with testosterone: And other essays on the biology of the human predicament, New York, NY: Scribner.
76. Schiebinger, L. L. 1989. The mind has no sex?: Women in the origins of modern science, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
77. Simpson, J. L., Ljungqvist, A.de la Chapelle, A. 1993. Gender verification in competitive sports. Sports Medicine, 16(5): 305-315.
78. Simpson, J. L., Ljungqvist, A.Ferguson-Smith, M. A. 2000. Gender verification in the Olympics. Journal of the American Medical Association, 284(12): 1568-1569.
79. Smith, A. D. 2009. Fears for Caster Semenya over trauma of test results. The Guardian, September 12. Available at:http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2009/sep/13/caster-emenya-gender-test-results
80. Smith, D. 2009. Caster Semenya withdraws from race in South Africa. The Guardian, September 11, 2009. Available at:http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2009/sep/11/caster-emenya-withdraws-race-south-africa
81. Speiser, P. W. and White, P. C. 2003. Congenital adrenal hyperplasia. New England Journal of Medicine, 349(8): 776-788.
82. Stephenson, J. 1996. Female Olympians' sex tests outmoded. Journal of the American Medical Association, 276(3): 177-178.
83. Stikkelbroeck, N. M., Hermus, A. R.Braat, D. D. 2003. Fertility in women with congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to 21-hydroxylase deficiency. Obstetrical and Gynecological Survey, 58(4): 275-284.
84. Storer, T. W., Magliano, L.Woodhouse, L. 2003. Testosterone dose-dependently increases maximal voluntary strength and leg power, but does not affect fatigability or specific tension. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 88(4): 1478-1485.
85. Strauss, J. F. and Barbieri, R. L. 1999. Yen and Jaffe's reproductive endocrinology: Physiology, pathophysiology, and clinical management, Philadelphia, PA: Saunders/Elsevier.
86. Tian, Q., He, F.Zhou, Y. 2009. Gender verification in athletes with disorders of sex development. Gynecological Endocrinology, 25(2): 117-121.
87. Tucker, R. and Collins, M. 2010. The science of sex verification and athletic performance. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 5(2): 127-139.
88. Viloria, H. 2011. Opinion: Gender rules in sport-Leveling the playing field, or reversed doping?. Global Herald, April 11. Available at:http://theglobalherald.com/opinion-gender-rules-in-sport-leveling-the-playing-field-or-reversed-doping/14837
89. Volkl, T. M., Simm, D.Beier, C. 2006. Obesity among children and adolescents with classic congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to 21-hydroxylase deficiency. Pediatrics, 117(1): e98-105.
90. Wilson, D. R. 2000. Gender vs sex. Journal of the American Medical Association, 284(23): 2997-2998.