Validation and invalidation of systems biology models using robustness analysis

IET Systems Biology

Volumn 5, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 229-244

  Bates, D G ^a   Cosentino, C ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY MAGNA GRAECIA OF CATANZARO   (Italy)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

COMPETING MODELS; ENGINEERING CONTROL SYSTEMS; EXPLOSIVE GROWTH; ROBUSTNESS ANALYSIS; SYSTEMS BIOLOGY; TOOLS AND METHODS;

BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS; ROBUST CONTROL; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

ROBUSTNESS (CONTROL SYSTEMS);

ANIMAL; ARTICLE; BIOLOGICAL MODEL; COMPUTER PROGRAM; COMPUTER SIMULATION; HUMAN; VALIDATION STUDY;

ANIMALS; COMPUTER SIMULATION; HUMANS; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL; SOFTWARE; SOFTWARE VALIDATION; VALIDATION STUDIES AS TOPIC;

EID: 80053082267     PISSN: 17518849     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1049/iet-syb.2010.0072     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Csete, M.E., and Doyle, J.C.: 'Reverse engineering of biological complexity', Science, 2002, 295, p. 1664-166910.1126/science.1069981 0036-8075
2. Carlson, J.M., and Doyle, J.C.: 'Complexity and robustness', Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 2002, 99, (Suppl 1), p. 2538-254510.1073/pnas.012582499
3. Kitano, H.: 'Cancer robustness: tumour tactics', Nature, 2003, 426, p. 12510.1038/426125a 0028-0836
4. Kitano, H.: 'Biological robustness', Nat. Rev. Genet., 2004, 5, p. 826-83710.1038/nrg1471
5. Kitano, H., and Oda, K.: 'Robustness trade-offs and host-microbial symbiosis in the immune system', Mol. Syst. Biol., 2006, 2, p. 002210.1038/msb4100039
6. Kitano, H.: 'Towards a theory of biological robustness', Mol. Syst. Biol., 2007, 137, p. 1-710.1038/msb4100179
7. Kitano, H.: 'A robustness-based approach to system-oriented drug design', Nat. Rev. Drug Discov., 2007, 6, p. 202-21010.1038/nrd2195
8. Wagner, A.: 'Robustness and evolvibility in living systems', (Princeton University Press 2007)
9. Morohashi, M., Winnz, A.E., Borisuk, M.T., Bolouri, H., Doyle, J.C., and Kitano, H.: 'Robustness as a measure of plausibility in models of biochemical networks', J. Theor. Biol., 2002, 216, p. 19-3010.1006/jtbi.2002.2537
10. Anderson, J., and Papachristodoulou, A.: 'On validation and invalidation of biological models', BMC Bioinf., 2009, 10, p. 13210.1186/1471-2105-10-132
11. Khalil, H.K.: 'Nonlinear systems', 3rd(Prentice-Hall 2002)
12. Strogatz, S.H.: 'Nonlinear dynamics and chaos: with applications to physics, biology, chemistry, and engineering', (Westview Press 2001)
13. Ma, L., and Iglesias, P.A.: 'Quantifying robustness of biochemical network models', BMC Bioinf., 2002, 3, (38), p. 1-13
14. Battogtokh, D., and Tyson, J.J.: 'Bifurcation analysis of a model of the budding yeast cell cycle', Chaos, 2004, 14, p. 65310.1063/1.1780011 1054-1500
15. Ghaemi, R., Sun, J., Iglesias, P.A., and Del Vecchio, D.: 'A method for determining the robustness of bio-molecular oscillator models', BMC Syst. Biol., 2009, 3, p. 9510.1186/1752-0509-3-95
16. Saltelli, A., Ratto, M., Andres, T., Campolongo, F., and Cariboni, J.: 'Global sensitivity analysis: the primer', (Wiley-Interscience 2008)
17. Stelling, J., Gilles, E.D., and Doyle, F.J.: 'Robustness properties of circadian clock architectures', Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 2004, 101, (36), p. 13210-1321510.1073/pnas.0401463101
18. Mahdavi, A., Davey, R.E., Bhola, P., Yin, T., and Zandstra, P.W.: 'Sensitivity analysis of intracellular signaling pathway kinetics predicts targets for stem cell fate control', PLoS Comput. Biol., 2007, 3, (7), p. e13010.1371/journal.pcbi.0030130
19. Hafner, M., Koeppl, H., Hasler, M., and Wagner, A.: 'Glocal robustness analysis and model discrimination for circadian oscillators', PLoS Computational Biology, 2009, 5, (10), p. e100053410.1371/journal.pcbi.1000534
20. Doyle, J.C.: 'Analysis of feedback systems with structured uncertainty', IEE Proc., Control Theory Appl., D, 1982, 129, (6), p. 242-25010.1049/ip-d.1982.0053
21. Zhou, K., and Doyle, J.C.: 'Essentials of robust control', (Prentice Hall 1998)
22. Skogestad, S., and Postlethwaite, I.: 'Multivariable feedback control', 5th(John Wiley 2005)
23. Ferreres, G.: 'A practical approach to robustness analysis with aeronautical applications', (Kluwer Academic, New York 1999)
24. Packard, A., and Doyle, J.C.: 'The complex structured singular value', Automatica, 1993, 29, (1), p. 71-10910.1016/0005-1098(93)90175-S 0005-1098
25. Kim, J., Bates, D.G., and Postlethwaite, I.: 'A geometrical formulation of the μ-lower bound problem', IET Control Theory Appl., 2009, 3, (4), p. 465-47210.1049/iet-cta.2007.0391
26. Jacobsen, E.W., and Trane, C.: 'Structural robustness of biochemical networks', Ingalls, B., Iglesias, P., Control theory and systems biology, (MIT Press 2009)
27. Jacobsen, E.W., and Trane, C.: 'Using dynamic perturbations to identify fragilities in biochemical reaction networks', Int. J. Robust Nonlinear Control, 2010, 20, (9), p. 1027-1046 (Special Issue on Robustness Syst. Biol. Methods Appl.)10.1002/rnc.1590 1049-8923
28. Jacobsen, E.W., and Cedersund, G.: 'Structural robustness of biochemical network models-with application to the oscillatory metabolism of activated neutrophils', IET Syst. Biol., 2008, 2, (1), p. 39-4710.1049/iet-syb:20070008
29. Shinar, G., and Feinberg, M.: 'Structural sources of robustness in biochemical reaction networks', Science, 2010, 327, (5971), p. 1389-139110.1126/science.1183372 0036-8075
30. Uhr, M., and Stelling, J.: 'Structural sensitivity analysis of metabolic networks', Proc. 17th IFAC World Congress on Automatic Control, Seoul, Korea 2008
31. Hendrix, E.M.T., and Toth, B.G.: 'Introduction to nonlinear and global optimization', (Springer 2010)
32. Davis, L.: 'Handbook of genetic algorithms', (Van Nostrand Reinhold, NewYork 1991)
33. Jones, D.R., Perttunen, C.D., and Stuckman, B.E.: 'Lipschitzian optimization without the Lipschitz constant', J. Optim. Theory Appl., 1993, 79, p. 157-18110.1007/BF00941892 0022-3239
34. Menon, P.P., Postlethwaite, I., Bennani, S., Marcos, A., and Bates, D.G.: 'Robustness analysis of a reusable launch vehicle flight control law', Control Eng. Prac., 2009, 17, p. 751-76510.1016/j.conengprac.2008.12.002
35. Kim, J., Bates, D.G., Postlethwaite, I., Ma, L., and Iglesias, P.: 'Robustness analysis of biochemical network models', IET Syst. Biol., 2006, 152, (3), p. 96-10410.1049/ip-syb:20050024
36. Miller, J.H.: 'Active nonlinear tests (ANTs) of complex simulation models', Manage. Sci., 1998, 44, (6), p. 820-83010.1287/mnsc.44.6.820 0025-1909
37. Prajna, S.: 'Barrier certificates for nonlinear model validation', Automatica, 2006, 42, (2), p. 117-1260005-1098
38. El-Samad, H., Prajna, S., Papachristodoulou, A., Doyle, J.C., and Khammash, M.: 'Advanced methods and algorithms for biological network analysis', Proc. IEEE, 2006, 94, (4), p. 832-85310.1109/JPROC.2006.871776 0018-9219
39. Parillo, P.: 'Semidefinite programming relaxations for semialgebraic problems', Math. Program. Ser. B, 2003, 96, (2), p. 293-32010.1007/s10107-003-0387-5
40. Vandenberghe, L., and Boyd, S.: 'Semidefinite programming', SIAM Rev., 1996, 38, p. 49-9510.1137/1038003 0036-1445
41. Yi, T.M., Fazel, M., and Liu, X.: et al. 'Application of robust model validation using SOSTOOLS to the study of G-protein signalling in yeast', Proc. FOSBE, 2005, p. 133-136
42. Melykuti, B., August, E., Papachristodoulou, A., and El-Samad, H.: 'Discriminating between rival biochemical network models: three approaches to optimal experiment design', BMC Syst. Biol., 2010, 4, p. 3810.1186/1752-0509-4-38
43. Chesi, G., and Hung, Y.S.: 'Stability analysis of uncertain genetic sum regulatory networks', Automatica, 2008, 44, (9), p. 2298-230510.1016/j.automatica.2008.01.030 0005-1098
44. Hasenauer, J., Waldherr, S., Wagner, K., and Allgower, F.: 'Parameter identification, experimental design and model falsification for biological network models using semidefinite programming', IET Syst. Biol., 2010, 4, (2), p. 119-13010.1049/iet-syb.2009.0030
45. Williams, P.S.: 'A Monte Carlo dispersion analysis of the X-33 simulation software', Proc. AIAA Conf. Guidance, Navigation and Control, 2001, p. 4067
46. Chernoff, H.: 'A measure of asymptotic efficiency for tests of a hypothesis based on the sum of observations', Ann. Math. Stat., 1952, 23, (4), p. 493-50710.1214/aoms/1177729330
47. Vidyasagar, M.: 'Statistical learning theory and randomised algorithms for control', IEEE Control Syst. Technol., 1998, 18, (6), p. 69-8510.1109/37.736014
48. Eissing, T., Allgower, F., and Bullinger, E.: 'Robustness properties of apoptosis models with respect to parameter variations and intrinsic noise', IET Syst. Biol., 2005, 152, (4), p. 221-22810.1049/ip-syb:20050046
49. Ryan, K.M., Phillips, A.C., and Vousden, K.H.: 'Regulation and function of the p53 tumor suppressor protein', Curr. Opin. Cell Biol., 2001, 13, (3), p. 332-33710.1016/S0955-0674(00)00216-7
50. Geva-Zatorsky, N., Rosenfeld, N., and Itzkovitz, S.: et al. 'Oscillations and variability in the p53 system', Mol. Syst. Biol., 2006, 10.1038/msb4100068
51. Ma, L., Wagner, J., Rice, J.J., Hu, W., Levine, A.J., and Stolovitzky, G.A.: 'A plausible model for the digital response of p53 to DNA damage', Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 2005, 102, (4), p. 14266-1427110.1073/pnas.0501352102
52. Dartnell, L., Simeonidis, E., Hubank, M., Tsoka, S., Bogle, I.D.L., and Papageorgiou, L.G.: 'Robustness of the p53 network and biological hackers', FEBS Lett., 2005, 579, (14), p. 3037-304210.1016/j.febslet.2005.03.101
53. Yi, T.-M., Huang, Y., Simon, M.I., and Doyle, J.C.: 'Robust perfect adaptation in bacterial chemotaxis through integral feedback control', Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 2000, 97, (9), p. 4649-465310.1073/pnas.97.9.4649
54. Alon, U., Surette, M.G., Barkai, N., and Leibler, S.: 'Robustness in bacterial chemotaxis', Nature, 1999, 397, p. 168-17110.1038/16483 0028-0836
55. Locke, J.C.W., Southern, M.M., and Kozma-Bognár, L.: et al. 'Extension of a genetic network model by iterative experimentation and mathematical analysis', Mol. Syst. Biol., 2005, 1, 2005.001310.1038/msb4100018
56. Ueda, H.R., Hagiwara, M., and Kitano, H.: 'Robust oscillations within the interlocked feedback model of Drosophila circadian rhythm', J. Theor. Biol., 2001, 210, (4), p. 401-41610.1006/jtbi.2000.2226
57. Wagner, A.: 'Circuit topology and the evolution of robustness in two-gene circadian oscillators', Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 2005, 102, (33), p. 11775-1178010.1073/pnas.0501094102
58. Akman, O.E., Rand, D.A., Brown, P.E., and Millar, A.J.: 'Robustness from flexibility in the fungal circadian clock', BMC Syst. Biol., 2010, 4, p. 8810.1186/1752-0509-4-88
59. Mayawala, K., Gelmi, C.A., and Edwards, J.S.: 'MAPK cascade possesses decoupled controllability of signal amplification and duration', Biophys. J., 2004, 87, p. L01-L0210.1529/biophysj.104.051888 0006-3495
60. Sasagawa, S., Ozaki, Y., Fujita, K., and Kuroda, S.: 'Prediction and validation of the distinct dynamics of transient and sustained ERK activation', Nat. Cell Biol., 2005, 7, p. 365-37310.1038/ncb1233
61. Thalhauser, C.J., and Komarova, N.L.: 'Specificity and robustness of the mammalian MAPK-IEG network', Biophys. J., 2009, 96, p. 3471-348210.1016/j.bpj.2008.10.076 0006-3495
62. Laub, M.T., and Loomis, W.F.: 'A molecular network that produces spontaneous oscillations in excitable cells of Dictyostelium', Mol. Biol. Cell, 1998, 9, p. 3521-3532
63. Kim, J., Heslop-Harrison, P., Postlethwaite, I., and Bates, D.G.: 'Stochastic noise and synchronisation during Dictyostelium aggregation make cAMP oscillations robust', PLoS Comput. Biol., 2007, 3, (11), p. 2190-219810.1371/journal.pcbi.0030218
64. Kim, J.-S., Valeyev, N.V., Postlethwaite, I., Heslop-Harrison, P., Cho, K.-W., and Bates, D.G.: 'Analysis and extension of a biochemical network model using robust control theory', Int. J. Robust Nonlinear Control, 2010, 20, (9), p. 1017-1026 (Special Issue on Robustness Syst. Biol. Methods Appl.), 10.1002/rnc.1528 1049-8923
65. Valeyev, N.V., Kim, J.-S., Heslop-Harrison, P., Postlethwaite, I., Kotov, N., and Bates, D.G.: 'Computational modelling suggests dynamic interactions between Ca2+, IP3 and G protein-coupled modules are key to achieving robust dictyostelium aggregation', Mol. BioSyst., 2009, 5, p. 612-62810.1039/b822074c
66. Das, A., Gao, Z., Menon, P.P., Hardman, J.G., and Bates, D.G.: 'A systems engineering approach to validation of a pulmonary physiology simulator for clinical applications', J. Royal Soc. Interface, 2010, 10.1098/rsif.2010.0224
67. Kwon, Y.-K., and Cho, K.-H.: 'Quantitative analysis of robustness and fragility in biological networks based on feedback dynamics', Bioinformatics, 2008, 24, (7), p. 987-99410.1093/bioinformatics/btn060
68. Chaves, M., Sengupta, A., and Sontag, E.D.: 'Geometry and topology of parameter space: investigating measures of robustness in regulatory networks', J. Math. Biol., 2009, 59, p. 315-35810.1007/s00285-008-0230-y 0303-6812
69. Dayarian, A., Chaves, M., Sontag, E.D., and Sengupta, A.: 'Shape, size and robustness: feasible regions in the parameter space of biochemical networks', PLoS Comput. Biol., 2009, 5, p. e1000025610.1371/journal.pcbi.1000256
70. Scott, M., Hwa, T., and Ingalls, B.: 'Deterministic characterization of stochastic genetic circuits', Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 2007, 104, (18), p. 7402-740710.1073/pnas.0610468104
71. Kim, J., Bates, D.G., and Postlethwaite, I.: 'Evaluation of stochastic effects on biomolecular networks using the generalised nyquist stability criterion', IEEE Trans. Autom. Control, 2008, 53, (8), p. 1937-194110.1109/TAC.2008.929463 0018-9286
72. Kirk, P.D., Toni, T., and Stumpf, M.P.: 'Parameter inference for biochemical systems that undergo a Hopf bifurcation', Biophys. J., 2008, 95, p. 540-54910.1529/biophysj.107.126086 0006-3495
73. Soyer, O.S., and Pfeiffer, T.: 'Evolution under fluctuating environments explains observed robustness in metabolic networks', PLoS Comput. Biol., 2010, 6, (8), p. e100090710.1371/journal.pcbi.1000907
74. Salathe, M., and Soyer, O.S.: 'Parasites lead to evolution of robustness against gene loss in host signaling networks', Mol. Syst. Biol., 2008, 4, p. 20210.1038/msb.2008.44