Superposition of three sources of uncertainties in operational flood forecasting chains

Atmospheric Research

Volumn 100, Issue 2-3, 2011, Pages 246-262

  Zappa, Massimiliano ^a   Jaun, Simon ^a,b   Germann, Urs ^c   Walser, André ^c   Fundel, Felix ^a  

^a SWISS FEDERAL RESEARCH INSTITUTE WSL   (Switzerland)

^b Land Climate Dynamics Group   (Switzerland)

^c Climatology MeteoSwiss   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Atmospheric EPS; COST 731; Flood forecasting; MAP D PHASE; Model uncertainty; PREVAH; Uncertainty superposition; Weather radar ensemble

Indexed keywords

FLOOD FORECASTING; MODEL UNCERTAINTY; PREVAH; UNCERTAINTY SUPERPOSITION; WEATHER RADAR ENSEMBLE;

CLIMATE MODELS; COMPUTER SIMULATION; FLOOD CONTROL; FLOODS; METEOROLOGICAL RADAR; RADAR; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

WEATHER FORECASTING;

COMPUTER SIMULATION; ENSEMBLE FORECASTING; FLOOD FORECASTING; HYDROLOGICAL MODELING; RADAR; RUNOFF; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

ALPS; SWITZERLAND;

EID: 79954629525     PISSN: 01698095     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.atmosres.2010.12.005     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. Ahrens B., Jaun S. On evaluation of ensemble precipitation forecasts with observation-based ensembles. Advances in Geosciences 2007, 10:139-144.
2. Ahrens B., Walser A. Information-based skill scores for probabilistic forecasts. Monthly Weather Review 2008, 136(1):352-363.
3. Bartholmes J.C., Thielen J., Ramos M.H., Gentilini S. The european flood alert system EFAS - part 2: statistical skill assessment of probabilistic and deterministic operational forecasts. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 2009, 13(2):141-153.
4. Bellerby T.J., Sun J.Z. Probabilistic and ensemble representations of the uncertainty in an IR/microwave satellite precipitation product. Journal of Hydrometeorology 2005, 6(6):1032-1044.
5. Berenguer M., Corral C., Sanchez-Diezma R., Sempere-Torres D. Hydrological validation of a radar-based nowcasting technique. Journal of Hydrometeorology 2005, 6(4):532-549.
6. Beven K. Prophecy, reality and uncertainty in distributed hydrological modeling. Advances in Water Resources 1993, 16(1):41-51.
7. Beven K. On undermining the science?. Hydrological Processes 2006, 20(14):3141-3146.
8. Beven K.J., Freer J. Equifinality, data assimilation, and uncertainty estimation in mechanistic modelling of complex environmental systems. Journal of Hydrology 2001, 249:11-29.
9. Bosshard T., Zappa M. Regional parameter allocation and predictive uncertainty estimation of a rainfall-runoff model in the poorly gauged Three Gorges Area (PR China). Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 2008, 33(17-18):1095-1104.
10. Bowler N.E., Pierce C.E., Seed A.W. STEPS: A probabilistic precipitation forecasting scheme which merges an extrapolation nowcast with downscaled NWP. Quarterly Journal Royal Meteorological Society 2006, 132(620):2127-2155.
11. Brier G.W. Verification of forecasts expressed in terms of probability. Monthly Weather Review 1950, 78(1):1-3.
12. Brown J.D., Demargne J., Seo D.J., Liu Y.Q. The Ensemble Verification System (EVS): a software tool for verifying ensemble forecasts of hydrometeorological and hydrologic variables at discrete locations. Environmental Modelling and Software 2010, 25(7):854-872.
13. Bruen M., et al. Visualizing flood forecasting uncertainty: some current European EPS platforms-COST731 working group 3. Atmospheric Science Letters 2010, 11(2):92-99.
14. Clark M.P., Slater A.G. Probabilistic quantitative precipitation estimation in complex terrain. Journal of Hydrometeorology 2006, 7(1):3-22.
15. Cloke H.L., Pappenberger F. Ensemble flood forecasting: a review. Journal of Hydrology 2009, 375(3-4):613-626.
16. Collier C.G. Flash flood forecasting: What are the limits of predictability?. Quarterly Journal Royal Meteorological Society 2007, 133(622):3-23.
17. Cullmann J., Wriedt G. Joint application of event-based calibration and dynamic identifiability analysis in rainfall-runoff modelling: implications for model parametrisation. Journal of Hydroinformatics 2008, 10(4):301-316.
18. Diezig R., Fundel F., Jaun S., Vogt S. Verification of runoff forecasts by the FOEN and the WSL. Advances in Flood Forecasting and the Implications for Risk Management 2010, 111-113. International Commission for the Hydrology of the Rhine Basin (CHR), Alkmaar. CHR (Ed.).
19. Draper D. Assessment and propagation of model uncertainty. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B: Methodological 1995, 57(1):45-97.
20. Ehrendorfer M. Predicting the uncertainty of numerical weather forecasts: a review. Meteorologische Zeitschrift 1997, 6(4):147-183.
21. Frick J., Hegg C. Can end-users' flood management decision making be improved by information about forecast uncertainty?. Atmospheric Research 2011, 100:296-302. (this issue).
22. Fundel F., Zappa M. Hydrological Ensemble Forecasting in Mesoscale Catchments: Sensitivity to Initial Conditions and Value of Reforecasts 2011, Water Resources Research, in review.
23. Gallus W.A. Impact of verification grid-box size on warm-season QPF skill measures. Weather and Forecasting 2002, 17(6):1296-1302.
24. Germann U., Galli G., Boscacci M., Bolliger M. Radar precipitation measurement in a mountainous region. Quarterly Journal Royal Meteorological Society 2006, 132(618):1669-1692.
25. Germann U., Berenguer M., Sempere-Torres D., Zappa M. REAL - ensemble radar precipitation estimation for hydrology in a mountainous region. Quarterly Journal Royal Meteorological Society 2009, 135(639):445-456.
26. Gurtz J., Baltensweiler A., Lang H. Spatially distributed hydrotope-based modelling of evapotranspiration and runoff in mountainous basins. Hydrological Processes 1999, 13(17):2751-2768.
27. Gurtz J., et al. A comparative study in modelling runoff and its components in two mountainous catchments. Hydrological Processes 2003, 17(2):297-311.
28. He Y., et al. Tracking the uncertainty in flood alerts driven by grand ensemble weather predictions. Meteorological Applications 2009, 16(1):91-101.
29. Jaun, S., 2008. Towards operational probabilistic runoff forecasts, Dissertation No. 17817, ETH Zurich, [available online at ]. http://e-collection.ethbib.ethz.ch/view/eth:41686.
30. Jaun S., Ahrens B. Evaluation of a probabilistic hydrometeorological forecast system. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences Discussions 2009, 6:1843-1877.
31. Jaun S., Ahrens B., Walser A., Ewen T., Schar C. A probabilistic view on the August 2005 floods in the upper Rhine catchment. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 2008, 8(2):281-291.
32. Koboltschnig G.R., Schoner W., Holzmann H., Zappa M. Glaciermelt of a small basin contributing to runoff under the extreme climate conditions in the summer of 2003. Hydrological Processes 2009, 23(7):1010-1018.
33. Laio F., Tamea S. Verification tools for probabilistic forecasts of continuous hydrological variables. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 2007, 11(4):1267-1277.
34. Lamb R. Calibration of a conceptual rainfall-runoff model for flood frequency estimation by continuous simulation. Water Resources Research 1999, 35(10):3103-3114.
35. Lee C.K., Lee G., Zawadzki I., Kim K.E. A preliminary analysis of spatial variability of raindrop size distributions during stratiform rain events. Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology 2009, 48(2):270-283.
36. Legates D.R., McCabe G.J. Evaluating the use of "Goodness-of-Fit" measures in hydrologic and hydroclimatic model validation. Water Resources Research 1999, 35:233-241.
37. Lorenz E.N. Deterministic nonperiodic flow. Journal of Atmospheric Sciences 1963, 20(2):130-141.
38. Madsen H. Automatic calibration of a conceptual rainfall-runoff model using multiple objectives. Journal of Hydrology 2000, 235(3-4):276-288.
39. Madsen H. Parameter estimation in distributed hydrological catchment modelling using automatic calibration with multiple objectives. Advances in Water Resources 2003, 26(2):205-216.
40. Marsigli C., Boccanera F., Montani A., Paccagnella T. The COSMO-LEPS mesoscale ensemble system: validation of the methodology and verification. Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics 2005, 12(4):527-536.
41. Matott L.S., Babendreier J.E., Purucker S.T. Evaluating uncertainty in integrated environmental models: a review of concepts and tools. Water Resources Research 2009, 45.
42. Merz R., Bloschl G. Flood frequency hydrology: 1. temporal, spatial, and causal expansion of information. Water Resources Research 2008, 44(8).
43. Molteni F., Buizza R., Palmer T.N., Petroliagis T. The ECMWF ensemble prediction system: methodology and validation. Quarterly Journal Royal Meteorological Society 1996, 122(529):73-119.
44. Moulin L., Gaume E., Obled C. Uncertainties on mean areal precipitation: assessment and impact on streamflow simulations. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 2009, 13(2):99-114.
45. Naef F., Schmocker-Fackel P., Margreth M., Kienzler P., Scherrer S. Die Häufung der Hochwasser der letzten Jahre. Ereignisanalyse der Hochwasser 2005-Teil 2, Analyse von Prozessen, Massnahmen und Gefahrengrundlagen in Umwelt 2008, 429. Umwelt-Wissen, 08025. G.R. Bezzola, C. Hegg (Eds.).
46. Nash J.E., Sutcliffe J.V. River flow forecasting through conceptual models (1), a discussion of principles. Journal of Hydrology 1970, 10:282-290.
47. Palmer T.N. Predicting uncertainty in forecasts of weather and climate. Reports on Progress in Physics 2000, 63(2):71-116.
48. Pappenberger F., Beven K.J. Functional classification and evaluation of hydrographs based on Multicomponent Mapping (Mx). International Journal of River Basin Management 2004, 2(2):89-100.
49. Pappenberger F., Beven K.J. Ignorance is bliss: or seven reasons not to use uncertainty analysis. Water Resources Research 2006, 42(5).
50. Pappenberger F., et al. Cascading model uncertainty from medium range weather forecasts (10days) through a rainfall-runoff model to flood inundation predictions within the European Flood Forecasting System (EFFS). Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 2005, 9(4):381-393.
51. Pappenberger F., Ghelli A., Buizza R., Bodis K. The skill of probabilistic precipitation forecasts under observational uncertainties within the generalized likelihood uncertainty estimation framework for hydrological applications. Journal of Hydrometeorology 2009, 10(3):807-819.
52. Quiby J., Denhard M. SRNWP-DWD Poor-Man Ensemble Prediction System: the PEPS Project 2003, 9-12. Eumetnet Newsletter.
53. Ranzi R., Zappa M., Bacchi B. Hydrological aspects of the Mesoscale Alpine Programme: findings from field experiments and simulations. Quarterly Journal Royal Meteorological Society 2007, 133(625):867-880.
54. Romang H., et al. IFKIS-Hydro - early warning and information system for floods and debris flows. Natural Hazards 2011, 56(2):509-527. (19).
55. Romanowicz R.J., Young P.C., Beven K.J. Data assimilation and adaptive forecasting of water levels in the river Severn catchment, United Kingdom. Water Resources Research 2006, 42(6).
56. Romanowicz R.J., Young P.C., Beven K.J., Pappenberger F. A data based mechanistic approach to nonlinear flood routing and adaptive flood level forecasting. Advances in Water Resources 2008, 31(8):1048-1056.
57. Rossa A., Liechti K., Zappa M., Bruen M., Germann U., Haase G., Keil C., Krahe P. The COST 731 Action: A review on uncertainty propagation in advanced hydro-meteorological forecast systems. Atmospheric Research 2011, 100:150-167. (this issue).
58. Rotach M.W., et al. MAP D-PHASE real-time demonstration of weather forecast quality in the Alpine region. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 2009, 90(9). 1321-+.
59. Roulin E. Skill and relative economic value of medium-range hydrological ensemble predictions. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 2007, 11(2):725-737.
60. Roulin E., Vannitsem S. Skill of medium-range hydrological ensemble predictions. Journal of Hydrometeorology 2005, 6(5):729-744.
61. Schaefli B., Gupta H.V. Do Nash values have value?. Hydrological Processes 2007, 21(15):2075-2080.
62. Siccardi F., Boni G., Ferraris L., Rudari R. A hydrometeorological approach for probabilistic flood forecast. Journal of Geophysical Research, [Atmospheres] 2005, 110(D5).
63. Stensrud D.J., Bao J.W., Warner T.T. Using initial condition and model physics perturbations in short-range ensemble simulations of mesoscale convective systems. Monthly Weather Review 2000, 128(7):2077-2107.
64. Szturc J., Osrodka K., Jurczyk A., Jelonek L. Concept of dealing with uncertainty in radar-based data for hydrological purpose. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 2008, 8(2):267-279.
65. Todini E. Predictive uncertainty assessment in real time flood forecasting. Uncertainties in Environmental Modelling and Consequences for Policy Making 2009, 205-228. NATO Science for Peace and Security Series C-Environmental Security. P.C. Baveye, M. Laba, J. Mysiak (Eds.).
66. Verbunt M., Zappa M., Gurtz J., Kaufmann P. Verification of a coupled hydrometeorological modelling approach for alpine tributaries in the Rhine basin. Journal of Hydrology 2006, 324(1-4):224-238.
67. Verbunt M., Walser A., Gurtz J., Montani A., Schar C. Probabilistic flood forecasting with a limited-area ensemble prediction system: selected case studies. Journal of Hydrometeorology 2007, 8(4):897-909.
68. Villarini G., Krajewski W.F. Empirically-based modeling of spatial sampling uncertainties associated with rainfall measurements by rain gauges. Advances in Water Resources 2008, 31(7):1015-1023.
69. Viviroli D., Zappa M., Gurtz J., Weingartner R. An introduction to the hydrological modelling system PREVAH and its pre- and post-processing-tools. Environmental Modelling and Software 2009, 24(10):1209-1222.
70. Viviroli D., Zappa M., Schwanbeck J., Gurtz J., Weingartner R. Continuous simulation for flood estimation in ungauged mesoscale catchments of Switzerland - part I: modelling framework and calibration results. Journal of Hydrology 2009, 377(1-2):191-207.
71. Vrugt J.A., Gupta H.V., Bouten W., Sorooshian S. A shuffled complex evolution metropolis algorithm for optimization and uncertainty assessment of hydrologic model parameters. Water Resources Research 2003, 39(8).
72. Vrugt J.A., Diks C.G.H., Gupta H.V., Bouten W., Verstraten J.M. Improved treatment of uncertainty in hydrologic modeling: combining the strengths of global optimization and data assimilation. Water Resources Research 2005, 41(1).
73. Walser A., Luthi D., Schar C. Predictability of precipitation in a cloud-resolving model. Monthly Weather Review 2004, 132(2):560-577.
74. Weigel A.P., Liniger M.A., Appenzeller C. Generalization of the discrete brier and ranked probability skill scores for weighted multimodel ensemble forecasts. Monthly Weather Review 2007, 135(7):2778-2785.
75. Wilks D. Statistical Methods in the Atmospheric sciences, vol. 91 of International Geophysics Series 2006, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
76. Wohling T., Lennartz F., Zappa M. Technical note: updating procedure for flood forecasting with conceptual HBV-type models. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 2006, 10(6):783-788.
77. Zappa, M., 2002. Multiple-response verification of a distributed hydrological model at different spatial scales, Dissertation No. 14895, ETH Zurich, [available online at: ] http://e-collection.ethbib.ethz.ch/show?type=diss&nr=14895.
78. Zappa M., Kan C. Extreme heat and runoff extremes in the Swiss Alps. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 2007, 7(3):375-389.
79. Zappa M., Pos F., Strasser U., Warmerdam P., Gurtz J. Seasonal water balance of an Alpine catchment as evaluated by different methods for spatially distributed snowmelt modelling. Nordic Hydrology 2003, 34(3):179-202.
80. Zappa M., et al. MAP D-PHASE: real-time demonstration of hydrological ensemble prediction systems. Atmospheric Science Letters 2008, 9(2):80-87.
81. Zappa M., et al. Propagation of uncertainty from observing systems and NWP into hydrological models: COST-731 Working Group 2. Atmospheric Science Letters 2010, 11(2):83-91.