'Ghost' experiments and the dissection of social learning in humans and animals

Biological Reviews

Volumn 85, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 685-701

  Hopper, Lydia M ^a  

^a GEORGIA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Emulation; End state condition; Experimental technique; Ghost condition; Imitation; Observational learning; Social learning

Indexed keywords

ANIMAL; ANIMAL BEHAVIOR; BIRD; CLASSIFICATION; DOG; HUMAN; IMITATION; LEARNING; METHODOLOGY; OBSERVATION; PHYSIOLOGY; PRIMATE; RAT; REVIEW; SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT; SPECIES DIFFERENCE; VISION;

ANIMALS; BEHAVIOR, ANIMAL; BIRDS; DOGS; HUMANS; IMITATIVE BEHAVIOR; LEARNING; OBSERVATION; PRIMATES; RATS; SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT; SPECIES SPECIFICITY; VISUAL PERCEPTION;

ANIMALIA; AVES; CANIS FAMILIARIS; PRIMATES; RATTUS;

EID: 78650388510     PISSN: 14647931     EISSN: 1469185X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1469-185X.2010.00120.x     Document Type: Review

References (125)

1. Akins, C.K., Klein, E.D. & Zentall, T. R. (2002). Imitative learning in Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica) using the bidirectional control procedure. Animal Learning and Behavior 30, 275-281.
2. Akins, C.K. & Zentall, T. R. (1996). Imitative learning in male Japanese quail(Coturnix japonica) using the two-action method. Journal of Comparative Psychology 110, 316-320.
3. Anderson, D. R. & Pempek, T. A. (2005). Television and very young children. American Behavioral Scientist, 48, 505-532.
4. Barr, R. (2002). Imitation as a learning mechanisms and research tool: how does imitation interact with other cognitive functions? Developmental Science 5, 16-18.
5. Bauer, P. J. & Kleinknecht, E. E. (2002). To 'ape' or to emulate? Young children's use of both strategies in a single study. Developmental Science 5, 18-20.
6. Bekkering, H. & Prinz, W. (2002). Goal representations in imitative actions. In Imitation in Animals and Artifacts (ed. K. Dautenhahn & C.L. Nehaniv), pp. 555-572. A Bradford Book: MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
7. Bekkering, H., Wohlschlager, A. & Gattis, M. (2000). Imitation of gestures in children is goal-directed. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 53, 153-164.
8. Bellagamba, F., Camaioni, L. & Calonnesi, C. (2006). Change in children's understanding of others' intentional actions. Developmental Science 9, 182-188.
9. Bellagamba, F. & Tomasello, M. (1999). Re-enacting intended acts: comparing 12- and 18-month-olds. Infant Behavior and Development 22, 277-282.
10. Biro, S., Csibra, G. & Gergely, G. (2007). The role of behavioral cues in understanding goal-directed actions in infancy. Progress in Brain Research 164, 303-322.
11. Biro, D., Inoue-Nakamura, N., Tanooka, R., Yamakoshi, G., Sousa, C. & Matsuzawa, T. (2003). Cultural innovation and transmission of tool use in wild chimpanzees: evidence from field experiments. Animal Cognition 6, 213-223.
12. Boyd, R. & Richerson, P. J. (1985). Culture and the Evolutionary Process. The University of Chicago Press, London, UK.
13. Boyd, R. & Richerson, P. J. (1996). Why culture is common, but cultural evolution is rare. Proceedings of the British Academy 88, 77-93.
14. Bugnyar, T. & Huber, L. (1997). Push or pull: an experimental study on imitation in marmosets. Animal Behaviour 54, 817-831.
15. Byrne, R. W. (1994). The evolution of intelligence. In Behavior and Evolution (ed. P. J. B. Slater & T.R. Halliday), pp. 223-265/Cambridge University Press, Cambridge UK.
16. Byrne, R. W. (1998). A comment on Boesch, C and Tomasello, M chimpanzee and human culture. Current Anthropology 39, 604-605.
17. Byrne, R. W. (2002a). Emulation in apes: verdict 'not proven'. Developmental Science 5, 20-22.
18. Byrne, R. W. (2002b). Imitation of novel complex actions: what does the evidence from animals mean? Advances in the Study of Behavior 31, 77-105.
19. Byrne, R. W. & Russon, A. E. (1998). Learning by imitation: a hierarchical approach. Behavioural and Brain Sciences 21, 667-721.
20. Caldwell, C. A. & Whiten, A. (2003). Scrounging facilitates social learning in common marmosets, Callithrix jacchus. Animal Behaviour 65, 1085-1092.
21. Call, J. & Carpenter, M. (2002). Three sources of information in social learning. In Imitation in Animals and Artifacts (ed. K. Dautenhahn & C.L. Nehaniv), pp. 211-228. A Bradford Book:Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge MA.
22. Call, J. & Carpenter, M. (2003). On imitation in apes and children. Infancia y Aprendizaje 26, 325-349.
23. Call, J., Carpenter, M. & Tomasello, M. (2005). Copying results and copying actions in the process of social learning: chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and human children (Homo sapiens). Animal Cognition 8, 151-163.
24. Carpenter, M. (2006). Instrumental, social, and shared goals and intentions in imitation. In Imitation and the Social Mind: Autism and Typical Development (ED. S. J. Rogers & J.H.G.Williams), pp. 48-70. Guilford Press: New York NY.
25. Carpenter, M., Akhtar, N. & Tomasello, M. (1998). Fourteen- through 18-month-old infants differentially imitate intentional and accidental actions. Infant Behavior and Development 21, 315-330.
26. Carpenter, M., Call, J. & Tomasello, M. (2002). Understanding "prior intentions" enables two-year-olds to imitatively learn a complex task. Child Development 73, 1431-1441.
27. Charman, T. & Huang, C-T. (2002). Delineating the role of stimulus enhancement and emulation learning in the behavioural re-enactment paradigm. Developmental Science 5, 25-27.
28. Custance, D., Whiten, A. & Fredman, T. (1999). Social learning of an artificial fruit task in capuchin monkeys (Cebus appella). Journal of Comparative Psychology 113, 13-25.
29. Dawson, B. V. & Foss, B. M. (1965). Observational learning in budgerigars. Animal Behaviour 13, 47-474.
30. D'Eath, R. B. (1998). Can video images imitate real stimuli in animal behaviour experiments? Biological Reviews 73, 267-292.
31. Denny, M.R., Clos, C. F. & Bell, R. C. (1988). Learning in the rat of a choice response by observation of S-S contingencies. In Social Learning: Psychological and Biological Perspectives (ed. T. R. Zentall & B.G. Galef), pp. 207-223. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers, Hillsdale, NJ.
32. Eriksson, K., Enquist, M. & Ghirlanda, S. (2007). Critical points in current theory of conformist social learning. Journal of Evolutionary Psychology, 5, 67-87.
33. Fawcett, T.W., Skinner, A. M. J. & Goldsmith A. R. (2002). A test of imitative learning in starling using two-action method with an enhanced ghost control. Animal Behaviour 64, 547-556.
34. Flynn, E. & Whiten, A. (2008a). Cultural transmission of tool-use in young children: a diffusion chain study. Social Development 17, 699-718.
35. Flynn, E. & Whiten, A. (2008b). Imitation of hierarchical structure versus component details of complex actions by 3-and 5-year-olds. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 101, 228-240.
36. Galef, B. G., Manzig, L. A. & Field, R. M. (1986). Imitation learning in budgerigars: Dawson and Foss (1965) revisited. Behavioural Processes 13, 191-202.
37. Galef, B. G. & Whiskin, E. E. (2004). Effects of environmental stability and demonstrator age on social learning of food preferences by young Norway rats. Animal Behaviour 68, 897-902.
38. Gattis, M. (2002). Imitation is mediated by many goals, not just one. Developmental Science 5, 27-29.
39. Gleissner, B., Meltzoff, A.N. & Bekkering, H. (2000). Children's coding of human action: cognitive factors influencing imitation in 3-year-olds. Developmental Science 3, 405-414.
40. Goldenberg, G. & Hagman, S. (1998). Tool use and mechanical problem solving in apraxia. Neuropsychologica 36, 581-589.
41. Groesbeck, R.W. & Duerfeldt, P. H. (1971). Some relevant variables in observational learning of the rat. Psychonomic Science 22, 41-43.
42. Heyes, C. M. (1993). Imitation, culture and cognition. Animal Behaviour 46, 999-1010.
43. Heyes, C. M. (1998). Theory of mind in nonhuman primates. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21, 101-148.
44. Heyes, C.M. & Dawson, G. R. (1990). A demonstration of observational learning in rats using a bidirectional control. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology B 42, 59-71.
45. Heyes, C.M., Jaldow, E., Nokes, T. & Dawson, G. R. (1994). Imitation in rats (Rattus norvegicus): the role of demonstrator action. Behavioural Processes 32, 173-182.
46. Hopper L. M. (2008). Dissection of observational learning among chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and children (Homo sapiens). Ph.D. Thesis, University of St Andrews, UK. [http://hdl.handle.net/10023/436].
47. Hopper, L.M., Lambeth, S. P., Schapiro, S. J. & Whiten, A. (2008). Observational learning in chimpanzees and children studied through 'ghost' conditions. Proceedings of the Royal Societies B 275, 835-840.
48. Hopper, L.M., Spiteri, A., Lambeth, S. P., Schapiro, S. J. & Whiten, A. (2007). Experimental studies of traditions and underlying transmission processes in chimpanzees. Animal Behaviour 73, 1021-1032.
49. Hopper, L.M., Flynn, E.G., Wood, L. A. N. & Whiten, A. (in press). Observational learning of tool use in children: investigating cultural spread through diffusion chains and learning mechanisms through ghost displays. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology.
50. Hoppitt, W., Blackburn, L. & Laland, K. N. (2007). Response facilitation in the domestic fowl. Animal Behaviour 73, 229-238.
51. Horner, V. & Whiten, A. (2005). Causal knowledge and imitation/emulation switching in chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and children (Homo sapiens). Animal Cognition 8, 164-181.
52. Horowitz, A. C. (2003). Do humans ape? Or do apes human? Imitation and intention in humans (Homo sapiens) and other animals. Journal of Comparative Psychology 117, 325-336.
53. Huang, C-T. & Charman, T. (2005). Gradations of emulation learning in infants' imitation of actions on objects. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 92, 276-302.
54. Huang, C-T., Heyes, C. & Charman, T. (2002). Infants' behavioral reenactment of "failed attempts": Exploring the roles of emulation learning, stimulus enhancement, and understanding of intentions. Developmental Science 38, 840-855.
55. Huang, C-T., Heyes, C. & Charman, T. (2006). Preschoolers' behavioural reenactment of "failed attempts": the roles of intention-reading, emulation and mimicry. Cognitive Development 21, 36-45.
56. Jacobson, J.M. & Sisemore, D. A. (1976). Observational learning of a lever pressing task. Southern Journal of Educational Research 10, 59-73.
57. Kaiser, D.H., Zentall, T. R. & Galef, B. G. (1997). Can imitation in pigeons be explained by local enhancement together with trial-and-error learning? Psychological Science, 8, 459-460.
58. Kendal, R. L., Coolen, I., Van Bergen, Y. & Laland, K. N. (2005). Trade-offs in the adaptive use of social and asocial learning. Advances in the Study of Behavior 35, 333-379.
59. Klein, E.D. & Zentall, T. R. (2003). Imitation and affordance learning by pigeons (Columba livia). Journal of Comparative Psychology 117, 414-419.
60. Laland, K. N. (2004). Social learning strategies. Learning and Behavior 32, 4-14.
61. Laland, K. N. & Galef, B. G. 2009. The Question of Animal Culture. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
62. Leca, J-B., Gunst, N. & Huffman, M. A. (2007). Food provisioning and stone handling tradition in Japanese macaques: a comparative study of ten troops. American Journal of Primatology 70, 803-813.
63. Leca, J-B., Gunst, N. & Huffman, M. A. (2008). Japanese macaque cultures: interand intra-troop behavioural variability of stone handling patterns across 10 troops. Behaviour 114, 251-281.
64. Maestripieri, D., Ross, S.K. & Megna, N. L. (2002).Mother-infant interactions in western lowland gorillas (Gorilla gorilla gorilla): spatial relationships, communication and opportunities for social learning. Journal of Comparative Psychology 116, 219-227.
65. Matsuzawa, T., Tomonaga, M. & Tanaka, M. (2006). Cognitive Development in Chimpanzees Springer: New York.
66. Mcguigan, N., Whiten, A., Flynn, E. & Horner, V. (2007). Imitation of causally opaque versus causally transparent tool use by 3- and 5-year-old children. Cognitive Development 22, 353-364.
67. Meltzoff, A. N. (1985). Immediate and deferred imitation in fourteen- and twentyfour-month-old infants. Child Development 56, 62-72.
68. Meltzoff, A. N. (1988). The human infant as Homo Imitans. In Social Learning: Psychological and Biological Perspectives (ed. T. R. Zentall & B.G.Galef), pp. 319-341, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers, Hillsdale, NJ.
69. Meltfoff, A. N. (1995). Understanding the intentions of others: re-enactment of intended acts by 18-month-old children. Developmental Psychology 31, 838-850.
70. Meltzoff, A. N. & Moore, M. K. (1977). Imitation of facial and manual gestures by human neonates. Science 198, 75-78.
71. Mesoudi, A. & Whiten, A. (2004). The hierarchical transformation of event knowledge in human cultural transmission. Journal of Cognition and Culture 4, 1-24.
72. Mesoudi, A. & Whiten, A. (2008). The multiple roles of cultural transmission experiments in understanding human cultural evolution. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 363, 3489-3501.
73. Miller, H. C., Rayburn-Reeves, R. & Zentall, T. R. (2009). Imitation and emulation by dogs using a bidirectional control procedure. Behavioural Processes, 80, 109-114.
74. Mitchell, C. J., Heyes, C. M., Gardener, M.R. & Dawson, G. R. (1999). Limitations of a bidirectional control procedure for the investigation of imitation in rats: odour cues on the manipulandum. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology: B 52, 193-202.
75. Myowa-Yamakoshi, M. & Matsuzawa, T. (2000). Imitation of intentional manipulatory actions in chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes). Journal of Comparative Psychology 114, 381-391.
76. Nadel, J., Guerini, C., Peze, A. & Rivet, C. (1999). The evolving nature of imitation as a format for communication. In Imitation in Infancy (ed. J. Nadel & G. Butterworth), pp. 209-234. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK.
77. Nagell, K., Olguin, R. S. & Tomasello, M. (1993). Processes of social learning in the tool use of chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and human children (Homo sapiens). Journal of Comparative Psychology 107, 174-186.
78. Nicol, C. J. (1995). The social transmission of information and behaviour. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 44, 79-98.
79. Nielsen, M. (2006). Copying actions and copying outcomes: Social learning through the second year. Developmental Psychology 42, 555-565.
80. Nielsen, M. (2008). The social motivation for social learning. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 31, 33.
81. Nielsen, M. (2009). 12-month-olds produce others' intended but unfulfilled acts. Infancy, 14, 377-389.
82. Nielsen, M., Simcock, G. & Jenkins, L. (2008). The effect of social engagement on 24-month-olds' imitation from live and televised models. Developmental Science 11, 722-731.
83. Perry, S. (2008). Manipulative Monkeys: The Capuchins of Lomas Barbudal. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
84. Pongrácz, P., Vida, V., Bánhegyi, P. & Miklósi, Á. (2008). How does dominance rank status affect individual and social learning performance in the dog (Canis familiaris)? Animal Cognition 11, 75-82.
85. Price, E. E., Lambeth, S.P., Schapiro, S. J. & Whiten, A. (2009). A potent effect of observational learning in chimpanzee construction. Proceedings of the Royal Society: B 276, 3377-3383.
86. Range, F., Viranyi, Z. & Huber, L. (2007). Selective imitation in domestic dogs. Current Biology, 17, 868-872.
87. Russon, A. E., Kuncoro, P., Ferisa, A. & Handayani, D. P. (2008). How Orangutans Produce Innovations. Proffered paper presented at the XXII Congress of the International Primatological Society, Edinburgh, UK.
88. Strouse, G. A. & Troseth, G. L. (2008). "Don't try this at home": Toddlers' imitation of new skills from people on video. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 101, 262-280.
89. Subiaul, F., Cantlon, J. F., Holloway, R. L. & Terrace, H. S. (2004). Cognitive imitation in rhesus macaques. Science 305, 407-410.
90. Subiaul, F., Lurie, H., Romansky, K., Klein, T., Holmes, D. & Terrace, H. (2007). Cognitive imitation in typically-developing 3-and 4-year olds and individuals with autism. Cognitive Development 22, 230-243.
91. Suddendorf, T., Simcock, G. & Nielsen, M. (2007). Visual self-recognition in mirrors and live videos: evidence for a developmental asynchrony. Cognitive Development 22, 185-196
92. Templeton, J. J. & Giraldeau, L-A. (1996). Vicarious sampling: the use of personal and public information by starlings foraging in a simple patchy environment. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 38, 105-114.
93. Tennie, C., Call, J. & Tomasello, M. (2006). Push or pull: imitation vs. emulation in great apes and human children. Ethology 112, 1159-1169.
94. Thompson, D. E. & Russell, J. (2004). The ghost condition: imitation versus emulation in young children's observational learning. Developmental Psychology 40, 882-889.
95. Thorpe, W. H. (1963). Learning and Instinct in Animals. Methuen, London, UK.
96. Tolman, C. W. (1964). Social facilitation of feeding behaviour in the domestic chick. Animal Behaviour 12, 245-251.
97. Tomasello, M. (1990). Cultural transmission in the tool use and communicatory signaling of chimpanzees. In "Language" and Intelligence in Monkeys and Apes: Comparative Developmental Perspectives (ed. S. T. Parker & K.R. Gibson), pp. 274-311. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
98. Tomasello, M. (1999). The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
99. Tomasello, M., Davis-Dasilva, M., Camak, L. & Bard, K. (1987). Observational learning of tool-use by young chimpanzees. Human Evolution 2, 175-183.
100. Topál, J., Gergely, G., Miklosi, A., Erdohegyi, A. & Csibra, G. (2008). Infants' perseverative search errors are induced by pragmatic misinterpretation. Science, 321, 1831-1834.
101. Troseth, G. L. & Deloache, J. S. (1998). The medium can obscure the message: young children's understanding of video. Child Development 69, 950-965
102. Uzgiris, I. (1981). Two functions of imitation during infancy. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 4, 1-12.
103. Uzgiris, I. C. (1991). The social context of infant imitation. In Social Influences and Socialization in Infancy (ed. M. Lewis & S. Feinman), pp. 215-251. Plenum Press, London.
104. Uzgiris, I. C. (1993). Interpersonal interaction as foundation for cultural learning. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16, 535-536.
105. Van Schaik, C. P., Ancrenaz, M., Borgen, G., Galdikas, B., Knott, C.D., Singleton, I., Suzuki, A., Utami, S. S. & Merrill, M. (2003). Orangutan cultures and the evolution of material culture. Science 299, 102-105.
106. Van Schaik, C. P. & Pradham, G. R. (2003). A model for tool-use in primates: implications for the coevolution of culture and cognition. Journal of Human Evolution 44, 645-664.
107. Voelkl, B. & Huber, L. (2000). True imitation in marmosets. Animal Behaviour, 60, 195-202.
108. Want, S. C. & Harris, P. L. (2001). Learning from other people's mistakes: causal understanding in learning to use a tool. Child Development 7, 431-443.
109. Want, S. C. & Harris, P. L. (2002). How do children ape? Applying concepts from the study of non-human primates to the developmental study of 'imitation' in children. Developmental Science 5, 1-13.
110. Whiten, A., Goodall, J.,Mcgrew,W.C., Nishida,T., Reynolds,V., Sugiyama, Y., Tutin, C. E. G., Wrangham, R.W. & Boesch, C. (2001). Charting cultural variation in chimpanzees. Behaviour 138, 1481-1516.
111. Whiten, A., Goodall, J.,Mcgrew,W.C., Nishida,T., Reynolds,V., Sugiyama, Y., Tutin, C. E. G., Wrangham, R. W. & Boesch, C. (1999). Cultures in chimpanzees. Nature 399, 682-685.
112. Whiten, A. & Ham, R. (1992). On the nature and evolution of imitation in the animal kingdom: reappraisal of a century of research. Advances in the Study of Behavior 21, 239-283.
113. Whiten, A., Mcguigan, N., Marhsall-Pescini, S. & Hopper, L. M. (2009). Emulation, Imitation, Over-imitation and the Scope of Culture for Child and Chimpanzee. Philosophical Transaction of the Royal Society B 364, 2417-2428.
114. Whiten, A., Horner, V. & De Waal, F. B.M. (2005). Conformity to cultural norms of tool use in chimpanzees. Nature, 437, 737-40.
115. Whiten, A., Horner, V., Litchfield, C. A. & Marshall-Pescini, S. (2004). How do apes ape? Learning and Behavior 32, 36-52.
116. Whiten, A. & Van Schaik, C. P. (2007). The evolution of animal 'cultures' and social intelligence. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B 363, 603-620.
117. Wohlschlager, A., Gattis, M. & Bekkering, H. (2003). Action generation and action perception in imitation: an instance of the ideomotor principle. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 358, 501-515.
118. Wood, D. (1989). Social interaction as tutoring. In Interaction in Human Development (ed. M. H. Bornstein & J. S. Bruner), pp. 59-80. Lawrence ErlbaumAssociates, Publishers, Hillsdale, NJ.
119. Wood, J. N., Glynn, D. D., Phillips, B. C. & Hauser, M. D. (2002). The perception of rational, goal-directed action in nonhuman primates. Science 317, 1402-1405.
120. Zajonc, R. B. (1965). Social facilitation. Science 149, 269-274.
121. Zentall, T. R. (2001). Imitation in animals: evidence, function, and mechanisms. Cybernetics and Systems 32, 53-96.
122. Zentall, T. R. (2003). Imitation by animals: how do they do it? Current Directions in Psychological Science 12, 91-95.
123. Zentall, T. R. (2006). Imitation: definitions, evidence, and mechanisms. Animal Cognition 9, 335-353.
124. Zentall, T. & Akins, C. (2001). Imitation in animals: evidence, function, and mechanisms. In Avian Visual Cognition [On-line] (ed. R. G. Cook). Available: www.pigeon.psy.tufts.edu/avc/zentall.
125. Zentall, T. R., Sutton, J. E. & Sherbourne, L. M. (1996).True imitative learning in pigeons. Psychological Science 7, 343-236.