The role of delays in innate and adaptive immunity to intracellular bacterial infection

Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering

Volumn 4, Issue 2, 2007, Pages 261-286

  Marino, Simeone ^a   Beretta, Edoardo ^b   Kirschner, Denise E ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF URBINO   (Italy)

Author keywords

Bacterial infections; Delay differential equations model; Innate and adaptive immunity; Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis

Indexed keywords

BACTERIA (MICROORGANISMS);

EID: 34547327672     PISSN: 15471063     EISSN: 15510018     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3934/mbe.2007.4.261     Document Type: Article

References (71)

1. Abu-Amero K., TUBERCULOSIS INFORMATION ON THE WEB. J R Soc Health 122(2) 82 (2002)
2. S. Akira, K. Takeda, T. Kaisho, TOLL-LIKE RECEPTORS: CRITICAL PROTEINS LINKING INNATE AND ACQUIRED IMMUNITY. Nat.Immunol. 2(2001) 675.
3. R. Antia, C. T. Bergstrom, S. S. Pilyugin, S. M. Kaech, R. Ahmed, MODELS OF CD8+ RESPONSES: 1. WHAT IS THE ANTIGEN-INDEPENDENT PROLIFERATION PROGRAM, J. Theor. Biol., 221, 585 (2003)
4. C. T. H. Baker, N. Ford, CONVERGENCE OF LINEAR MULTISTEP METHODS FOR A CLASS OF DELAY-INTEGRO-DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS. In: International Series of Numerical Mathematics 86, (Birkhäuser Verlag Basel 1988) pp. 47-59.
5. Baker, C. T. H., G. A. Bocharov, J. M. Ford, P. M. Lumb, S. J. Norton, C. A. H. Paul, T. Junt, P. Krebs, and B. Ludewig, COMPUTATIONAL APPROACHES TO PARAMETER ESTIMATION AND MODEL SELECTION IN IMMUNOLOGY. , Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics., 184, 50 (2005)
6. E. Beretta, Y. Kuang, GEOMETRIC STABILITY SWITCH CRITERIA IN DELAY DIFFERENTIAL SYSTEMS WITH DELAY DEPENDENT PARAMETERS, SIAM J. Math. Anal., 33, 1144 (2002)
7. E. Beretta, M. Carletti, D. Kirschner and Marino S., STABILITY ANALYSIS OF A MATHEMATICAL MODEL OF IMMUNE RESPONSE WITH DELAYS. Springer Book Vol. 2: Mathematics for Life Science and Medicine, eds. Takeuchi, Sato and Iwasa, Chapter 8, pp. 177-206 (2007)
8. B. Beutler, INFERENCES, QUESTIONS AND POSSIBILITIES IN TOLL-LIKE RECEPTOR SIGNALLING, Nature, 430, 6996 (2004)
9. S. M. Blower and H. Dowlatabadi, SENSITIVITY AND UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS OF COMPLEX MODELS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION: AN HIV MODEL AS AN EXMPLE, Int. Stat. Review, 62, 229, (1994)
10. Bocharov, G., P. Klenerman, and S. Ehl, MODELLING THE DYNAMICS OF LCMV INFECTION IN MICE: II. COMPARTMENTAL STRUCTURE AND IMMUNOPATHOLOGY, Journal of Theoretical Biology., 226, 123 (2003)
11. S. V. Capuano, D. A. Croix, S. Pawar, A. Zinovik, A. Myers, P. L. Lin, S. Bissel, C. Fuhrman, E. Klein, J. L. Flynn, EXPERIMENTAL MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS INFECTION OF CYNOMOLGUS MACAQUES CLOSELY RESEMBLES THE VARIOUS MANIFESTATIONS OF HUMAN M. TUBERCULOSIS INFECTION. Infect. Immun., 71, 5831 (2003).
12. M.C. Carroll, THE COMPLEMENT SYSTEM IN REGULATION OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY. Nature Immunol., 5 (2004).
13. Collins, C. and Avissar, R. AN EVALUATION WITH THE FOURIER AMPLITUDE SENSITIVITY TEST (FAST) OF WHICH LAND SURFACE PARAMETERS ARE OF GREATEST IMPORTANCE IN ATMOSPHERIC MODELING , Journal of Climate., 7, 681-703 (1994)
14. D.N. Cook, D.S. Pisetsky and D.A. Schwartz, TOLL-LIKE RECEPTORS IN THE PATHOGENESIS OF HUMAN DISEASE, Nature Immunol., 5, 975 (2004)
15. Cukier, R. I., Fortuin, C. M., Shuler, K. E., Petschek, A. G., and Schaibly,J. H. STUDY OF THE SENSITIVITY OF COUPLED REACTION SYSTEMS TO UNCERTAINTIES IN RATE COEFFICIENTS. I. THEORY., Journal of Chemical Physics, 59, 3873-3878 (1973)
16. Culshaw, R. V., and S. G. Ruan, A DELAY-DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION MODEL OF HIV INFECTION OF CD4(+) T-CELLS., Mathematical Biosciences., 165, 27 (2000)
17. Culshaw, R. V., S. G. Ruan, and G. Webb, A MATHEMATICAL MODEL OF CELL-TO-CELL SPREAD OF HIV-1 THAT INCLUDES A TIME DELAY., Journal of Mathematical Biology., 46, 425 (2003)
18. D.T. Fearon, R. M. Locksley, THE INSTRUCTIVE ROLE OF INNATE IMMUNITY IN THE ACQUIRED IMMUNE RESPONSE. Science, 272 50 (1996)
19. I. E. Flesch, S. H. Kaufmann, ACTIVATION OF TUBERCULOSTATIC MACROPHAGE FUNCTIONS BY GAMMA INTERFERON, INTERLEUKIN-4, AND TUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR, Infect. Immun., 58, 2675 (1990)
20. D. Gammack, C.R. Doering, D.E. Kirschner, MACROPHAGE RESPONSE TO Mycobacterium tuberculosis INFECTION, J. Math Biol, 48,218 (2004)
21. P. Guermonprez, J. Valladeau, L. Zitvogel, C. Thery, S. Amigorena, ANTIGEN PRESENTATION AND T CELL STIMULATION BY DENDRITIC CELLS, Annu. Rev. Immunol.., 20 621 (2002)
22. J. K. Hale, S. M. Verduyn Lunel, INTRODUCTION TO FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS, Springer Verlag, New York 1993
23. J. T. Harty, A. R. Tvinnereim, D. W. White, CD8+ T CELL EFFECTOR MECHANISMS IN RESISTANCE TO INFECTION, Annu. Rev. Immunol, 18, 275 (2000)
24. K. Hoebe, E. Janssen and B. Beutler, THE INTERFACE BETWEEN INNATE AND ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY, Nature Immunol., 5, 971 (2004)
25. C. A. Janeway, Jr., APPROACHING THE ASYMPTOTE? EVOLUTION AND REVOLUTION IN IMMUNOLOGY, Cold Spring Harb. Symp. Quant. Biol., 54 Pt 1, 1 (1989)
26. C. A. Janeway, Jr. IMMUNOBIOLOGY 5 : THE IMMUNE SYSTEM IN HEALTH AND DISEASE, Garland Pub., New York 2001.
27. C. A. Janeway, Jr., A TRIP THROUGH MY LIFE WITH AN IMMUNOLOGICAL THEME. Annu. Rev. Immunol., 20, 1 (2002)
28. C. A. Janeway, Jr., R. Medzhitov, INNATE IMMUNE RECOGNITION, Annu. Rev. Immunol., 20, 197 (2002).
29. M. K. Jenkins, A. Khoruts, E. Ingulli, D. L. Mueller, S. J. McSorley, R. L. Reinhardt, A. Itano, K.A. Pape, IN VIVO ACTIVATION OF ANTIGEN-SPECIFIC CD4 T CELLS. Annu. Rev. Immunol., 19, 23 (2001)
30. M. G. Kendall, RANK CORRELATION METHODS, 3rd edn Hafner, New York 1962.
31. P. G. Holt, M. A. Schon-Hegrad, LOCALIZATION OF T CELLS, MACROPHAGES AND DENDRITIC CELLS IN RAT RESPIRATORY TRACT TISSUE: IMPLICATIONS FOR IMMUNE FUNCTION STUDIES. Immunology, 62, 349 (1987)
32. P.G. Holt, ANTIGEN PRESENTATION IN THE LUNG. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., 162, 151 (2000)
33. Y. Kuang, DELAY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS : WITH APPLICATIONS IN POPULATION DYNAMICS, Academic Press, Cambridge, Mass. 1993
34. M. B. Lurie, RESISTANCE TO TUBERCULOSIS : EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES IN NATIVE AND ACQUIRED DEFENSIVE MECHANISMS, Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, Mass. 1964
35. D. M. Lewinsohn, T. T. Bernent, J. Xu, D. H. Lynch, K. H. Grabstein, S. G. Reed, M. R. Alderson, HUMAN PURIFIED PROTEIN DERIVATIVE-SPECIFIC CD4+ T CELLS USE BOTH CD95-DEPENDENT AND CD95-INDEPENDENT CYTOLYTIC MECHANISMS. J. Immunol., 160, 2374 (1998)
36. S. Marino et al., DENDRITIC CELL TRAFFICKING AND ANTIGEN PRESENTATION IN THE HUMAN IMMUNE RESPONSE TO MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS. J. Immunol 173 1, 494 (2004).
37. S. Marino, D. E. Kirschner, THE HUMAN IMMUNE RESPONSE TO MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS IN LUNG AND LYMPH NODE. J. Theor. Biol. 227 4, 463 (2004).
38. McKay, M.D., R. J. Beckman and W.J. Conover, A COMPARISON OF THREE METHODS FOR SELECTING VALUES OF INPUT VARIABLES IN THE ANALYSIS OF OUTPUT FROM A COMPUTER CODE., Technometrics., 21(2), 239-245 (1979)
39. R. Medzhitov, C. A. Janeway, Jr., INNATE IMMUNITY: THE VIRTUES OF A NONCLONAL SYSTEM OF RECOGNITION. Cell, 91, 295 (1997)
40. R. Medzhitov, C. A. Janeway, Jr., INNATE IMMUNITY. N. Engl. J. Med., 343, 338 (2000)
41. R. Medzhitov, C. A. Janeway, Jr., DECODING THE PATTERNS OF SELF AND NONSELF BY THE INNATE IMMUNE SYSTEM. Science, 296, 298 (2002)
42. Jr. C. A. Janeway and R. Medzhitov, INNATE IMMUNE RECOGNITION, Annu. Rev. Immunol., 20, 197 (2002)
43. R. R. Mercer, M. L. Russell, V. L. Roggli, J. D. Crapo, CELL NUMBER AND DISTRIBUTION IN HUMAN AND RAT AIRWAYS. Am. J. Respir. Cell. Mol. Biol., 10, 613 (1994)
44. K. Murali-Krishna, L. L. Lau, S. Sambhara, F. Lemonnier, J. Altman, R. Ahmed, PERSISTENCE OF MEMORY CD8 T CELLS IN MHC CLASS I-DEFICIENT MICE. Science, 286, 1377 (1999)
45. J. D. Murray, MATHEMATICAL BIOLOGY, 3rd edn Springer, New York 2002.
46. Nelson, P. W., J. D. Murray, and A. S. Perelson, A MODEL OF HIV-1 PATHOGENESIS THAT INCLUDES AN INTRACELLULAR DELAY., Math. Biosc., 163, 201 (2000)
47. Nelson, P. W. and A. S. Perelson, MATHEMATICAL ANALYSIS OF DELAY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION MODELS OF HIV-1 INFECTION., Math. Biosc., 179, 73 (2002)
48. R. J. North, A. A. Izzo, MYCOBACTERIAL VIRULENCE. VIRULENT STRAINS OF MYCOBACTERIA TUBERCULOSIS HAVE FASTER IN VIVO DOUBLING TIMES AND ARE BETTER EQUIPPED TO RESIST GROWTH-INHIBITING FUNCTIONS OF MACROPHAGES IN THE PRESENCE AND ABSENCE OF SPECIFIC IMMUNITY. J. Exp. Med., 177, 1723 (1993)
49. S. S. Pilyugin and R. Antia, MODELING IMMUNE RESPONSES WITH HANDLING TIME. Bull. Math. Biol., 62, 869 (2000)
50. D.H. Raulet, INTERPLAY OF NATURAL KILLER CELLS AND THEIR RECEPTORS WITH THE ADAPTIVE IMMUNE RESPONSE, Nature Immunol., 5 (2004)
51. L.F. Shampine, S. Thompson, SOLVING DDEs WITH MATLAB, MANUSCRIPT. [URL:http://www.radford.edu/ thompson/webddes]
52. Saltelli, A., and R. Bolado. AN ALTERNATIVE WAY TO COMPUTE FOURIER AMPLITUDE SENSITIVITY TEST (FAST)., Computational Statistics & Data Analysis., 26, 445 (1998)
53. Saltelli, A., S. Tarantola, and K. P. S. Chan. A QUANTITATIVE MODEL-INDEPENDENT METHOD FOR GLOBAL SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF MODEL OUTPUT , Technometrics., 41, 39 (1999)
54. Saltelli, A., K. Chan, and E. M. Scott-.SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS, Chichester ; New York, (2000).
55. Saltelli A. SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS IN PRACTICE. A GUIDE TO ASSESSING SCIENTIFIC MODELS, John Wiley & Sons Pub., Hoboken, NJ (2004).
56. Schaibly, J. H. and K. E. Shuler STUDY OF THE SENSITIVITY OF COUPLED REACTION SYSTEMS TO UNCERTAINTIES IN RATE COEFFICIENTS. II. APPLICATIONS, Journal of Chemical Physics, 59, 3879-3888 (1973)
57. J.L. Segovia-Juarez, S. Ganguli, D.E. Kirschner, Identifying control mechanisms of granuloma formation during M. tuberculosis infection using an agent-based model, J. Ther Biol, 231, 357 (2004)
58. R. F. Silver, Q. Li, W. H. Boom, J. J. Ellner, LYMPHOCYTE-DEPENDENT INHIBITION OF GROWTH OF VIRULENT MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS H37RV WITHIN HUMAN MONOCYTES: REQUIREMENT FOR CD4+ T CELLS IN PURIFIED PROTEIN DERIVATIVE-POSITIVE, BUT NOT IN PURIFIED PROTEIN DERIVATIVE-NEGATIVE SUBJECTS. J. Immunol., 160, 2408 (1998a)
59. R. F. Silver, Q. Li, J. J. Ellner, EXPRESSION OF VIRULENCE OF MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS WITHIN HUMAN MONOCYTES: VIRULENCE CORRELATES WITH INTRACELLULAR GROWTH AND INDUCTION OF TUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR ALPHA BUT NOT WITH EVASION OF LYMPHOCYTE-DEPENDENT MONOCYTE EFFECTOR FUNCTIONS. Inject. Immun., 66, 1190 (1998b)
60. J. Sprent, A. Basten, CIRCULATING T AND B LYMPHOCYTES OF THE MOUSE. II. LIFESPAN. Cell. Immunol., 7, 40 (1973)
61. J. Sprent, C. D. Surh, T CELL MEMORY. Annu. Rev. Immunol., 20, 551 (2002)
62. K. C. Stone, R. R. Mercer, P. Gehr, B. Stockstill, J. D. Crapo, ALLOMETRIC RELATIONSHIPS OF CELL NUMBERS AND SIZE IN THE MAMMALIAN LUNG. Am. J. Respir. Cell. Mol. Biol., 6, 235 (1992)
63. C. D. Surh, J. Sprent, REGULATION OF NAIVE AND MEMORY T-CELL HOMEOSTASIS. Microbes Infect., 4, 51 (2002)
64. S. L. Swain, H. Hu, G. Huston, CLASS II-INDEPENDENT GENERATION OF CD4 MEMORY T CELLS FROM EFFECTORS. Science, 286, 1381 (1999)
65. K. Takeda, T. Kaisho, S. Akira, TOLL-LIKE RECEPTORS. Annu. Rev. Immunol., 21, 335 (2003)
66. J. S. Tan, D. H. Canaday, W. H. Boom, K. N. Balaji, S. K. Schwander, E. A. Rich, HUMAN ALVEOLAR T LYMPHOCYTE RESPONSES TO MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS ANTIGENS: ROLE FOR CD4+ AND CD8+ CYTOTOXIC T CELLS AND RELATIVE RESISTANCE OF ALVEOLAR MACROPHAGES TO LYSIS. J. Immunol., 159, 290 (1997)
67. K. Tsukaguchi, K. N. Balaji, W. H. Boom, CD4+ ALPHA BETA T CELL AND GAMMA DELTA T CELL RESPONSES TO MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS. SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES IN AG RECOGNITION, CYTOTOXIC EFFECTOR FUNCTION, AND CYTOKINE PRODUCTION. J. Immunol., 154, 1786 (1995)
68. R. Van Furth, M. C. Diesselhoff-den Dulk, H. Mattie, QUANTITATIVE STUDY ON THE PRODUCTION AND KINETICS OF MONONUCLEAR PHAGOCYTES DURING AN ACUTE INFLAMMATORY REACTION, J. Exp. Med., 138, 1314 (1973)
69. J. E. Wigginton, D. E. Kirschner, A MODEL TO PREDICT CELL-MEDIATED IMMUNE REGULATORY MECHANISMS DURING HUMAN INFECTION WITH MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS, J. Immunol., 166, 1951 (2001)
70. P. Wong, E. G. Pamer, CD8 T CELL RESPONSES TO INFECTIOUS PATHOGENS. Annu. Rev. Immunol., 21, 29 (2003)
71. R. M. Zinkernagel, ON NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL VACCINATIONS, Annu. Rev. Immunol., 21, 515 (2003)