Building process knowledge using inline spectroscopy, reaction calorimetry and reaction modeling - The integrated approach

Current Opinion in Drug Discovery and Development

Volumn 8, Issue 6, 2005, Pages 789-797

  Tummala, Srinivas ^a   Shabaker, John W ^a   Leung, Simon S W ^a  

^a BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB   (United States)

Author keywords

FTIR; Inline spectroscopy; Kinetic modeling; Raman; Reaction calorimetry; Reaction engineering

Indexed keywords

ANEMOMETRY; CALORIMETRY; CATALYSIS; CHEMOMETRICS; CROSS COUPLING REACTION; DECOMPOSITION; ENANTIOSELECTIVITY; GAS ANALYSIS; GRIGNARD REACTION; HEAT; HIGH PERFORMANCE LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY; HYDROGENATION; LOW TEMPERATURE; MICROCALORIMETRY; MOLECULAR MECHANICS; MOLECULAR MODEL; RAMAN SPECTROMETRY; REVIEW; SPECTROSCOPY; TEMPERATURE DEPENDENCE; THERMODYNAMICS;

CALORIMETRY; MODELS, CHEMICAL; ORGANIC CHEMICALS; SPECTRUM ANALYSIS; SYSTEMS INTEGRATION; TECHNOLOGY, PHARMACEUTICAL; UNITED STATES; UNITED STATES FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION;

EID: 27844472106     PISSN: 13676733     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (67)

1. Pharmaceutical CGMPs for the 21st century - a risk-based approach. Final report: US Food and Drug Administration, Rockville, MD, USA (2004). http://www.fda.gov/cder/gmp/gmp2004/CGMP%20report%20final04.pdf
2. Guidance for industry PAT - A framework for innovative pharmaceutical development, manufacturing and quality assurance: US Food and Drug Administration, Rockville, MD, USA (2004). http://www.fda.gov/cder/guidance/ 6419fnl.pdf
3. Santacesaria E: Fundamental chemical kinetics: The first step to reaction modelling and reaction engineering. Catalysis Today (1999) 52(2-3):113-123. Provides a generalized approach to a kinetic study.
4. Landau RN, McKenzie PF, Forman AL, Dauer RR, Futran M, Epstein AD: In-situ Fourier-transform Infrared and calorimetric studies of the preparation of a pharmaceutical intermediate. Proc Control Qual (1995) 7(3-4):133-142.
5. Landau RN: Expanding the role of reaction calorimetry. Thermochim Acta (1996) 289(2):101-126. A comprehensive review presenting several examples of the role of reaction calorimetry in process development.
6. Guldbaek KL, Villadsen J: Isothermal reaction calorimeters - I. A literature review. Chem Eng Sci (1987) 42(5):1153-1164.
7. Mettler-Toledo Ltd, Leicester, UK. www.mt.com/autochem
8. Singh UK, Landau RN, Sun Y, LeBlond C, Blackmond DG, Tanielyan SK, Augustine RL: Enantioselective catalysis: Influence of conversion and bulk diffusion limitations on selectivity in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate. J Catal (1995) 154(1):91-97.
9. Sun Y, Landau RN, Wang J, LeBlond C, Blackmond DG: A re-examination of pressure effects on enantioselectivity in asymmetric catalytic hydrogenation. J Am Chem Soc (1996) 118(6):1348-1353.
10. Wang J, Sun Y, Leblond C, Landau RN, Blackmond DG: Asymmetric hydrogen of ethyl pyruvate: Relationship between conversion and enantioselectivity. J Catal (1996) 161(2):752-758.
11. Sun Y, Wang J, LeBlond C, Landau RN, Blackmond DG: Asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate: Diffusion effects on enantioselectivity. J Catal (1996) 161(2):759-765.
12. Sun Y, Wang J, LeBlond C, Landau RN, Laquidara J, Sowa JR Jr, Blackmond DG: Kinetic influences on enantioselectivity in asymmetric catalytic hydrogenation. J Mol Catal A Chem (1997) 115(3):495-502.
13. LeBlond C, Wang J, Larsen RD, Orella CJ, Forman AL, Landau RN, Laquidara J. Sowa JR, Blackmond DG, Sun Y-K: Reaction calorimetry as an in-situ kinetic tool for characterizing complex reactions. Thermochim Acta (1996) 289(2):189-207.
14. Landau RN, Blackmond DG, Tung H-H: Calorimetric investigation of an exothermic reaction: Kinetic and heat flow modeling, Ind Eng Chem Res (1994) 33(4):814-820.
15. Zogg A, Stoessel F, Fischer U, Hungerbuehler K: Isothermal reaction calorimetry as a tool for kinetic analysis. Thermochim Acta (2004) 419(1-2):1-17. An exhaustive review describing the principles as well as the role of reaction calorimetry as a tool for kinetic analysis.
16. Green D, Fenwick P: Use of the ultra low temperature RC1e reaction calorimeter. Org Proc Res Dev (2003) 7(2):214-221. Illustrates the use of reaction calorimetry to study reactions carried out at temperatures as low as -70°C.
17. Lavanchy F, Fortini S, Meyer T: Reaction calorimetry as a new tool for supercritical fluids. Org Proc Res Dev (2004) 8(3):504-510. Illustrates the use of reaction calorimetry to study reactions carried out at 300°C and 350 bar.
18. Thibblin A: Microcalorimetry as a tool in mechanistic studies of organic reactions. J Phys Org Chem (2002) 15(4):233-241.
19. Gesthuisen R, Kraemer S, Niggemann G, Leiza JR, Asua JM: Determining the best reaction calorimetry technique: Theoretical development. Computers Chem Eng (2005) 29(2):349-365.
20. Milosevic M, Sting D, Rein A: Technical note: Diamond-composite sensor for ATR spectroscopy. Spectroscopy (1995) 10(4):44-49.
21. Grosse RL: In: Handbook of Raman Spectroscopy: From the Research Laboratory to the Process Line. Lewis IR, Edwards HGM (Eds), Marcel Dekker, New York, USA (2001).
22. am Ende DJ, Clifford PJ, DeAntonis DM, SantaMaria C, Brenek SJ: Preparation of Grignard reagents: FTIR and calorimetric investigation for safe scale-up. Org Proc Res Dev (1999) 3(5):319-329. Demonstrates the advantages of applying FTIR technology for monitoring the Grignard reaction.
23. Olzog M, Muslehlddinoglu J, Leung S, Pesti J, Chen CK: Safe scale-up of Grignard reactions using FTIR monitoring. American Institute of Chemical Engineers Annual Meeting, Austin, TX, USA (2004). Illustrates the use of inline FTIR monitoring on pilot plant-scale.
24. Wiss J, Laenzlinger M, Wermulh M: Safety improvement of a Grignard reaction using on-line NIR monitoring. Org Proc Res Dev (2005) 9(3):365-371. Describes the development of a quantitative NIR technique for monitoring the Grignard reaction and application on pilot plant-scale.
25. Zhang-Plasket F, Duda RJ, Childers JH, Hortenstine JT, Kenney BD, Villani FJ, Zhong H: Process Analytical Technology (PAT): Broad applications of in situ real-time FT-IR in chemical process research. 228th ACS Meeting, Philadelphia, PA, USA, (2004). Discusses the determination of the stability of a Grignard reagent and the potential thermal hazard of a chlorosulfonation reaction.
26. Koen DS, Jan van Dun, Bard S, Tom S, Christine S, Peter V B, Julien L, Dirk VC, Guy S, Jeroen D, Andras H, et al. Selectivity control by use of near-IR for a hydrogenation process. Org Proc Res Dev (2005) 9(3):344-347. Describes how NIR was used to define the endpoint of a hydrogenation reaction to prevent side-product formation.
27. Watson DJ, Dowdy ED, DePue JS, Kotnis AS, Leung S, O'Reilly BC: Development of a safe and scalable oxidation process for the preparation of 6-hydroxybuspirone: Application of inline monitoring for process ruggedness and product quality. Org Proc Res Dev (2004) 8(4):616-623. Describes the use of inline FTIR for defining the endpoint of a hydrogenation deprotonation to prevent excess base addition which can lead to impurity formation.
28. Workman J Jr, Koch M, Veltkamp D: Process analytical chemistry. Anal Chem (2005) 77(12):3789-3806. Provides a review of process analytical chemistry, which is the sixth in a series of review articles on this subject, and covers the period from March 2003 through March 2005.
29. Pelletier MJ: Quantitative analysis using Raman spectrometry. Appl Spectrosc (2003) 57(1):20A-42A. Discusses the techniques that are used to quantify information from Raman spectra.
30. Aamoutse PJ, Westerhuis JA: Quantitative Raman reaction monitoring using the solvent as internal standard. Anal Chem (2005) 77(5):1228-1236. Describes a method to correct for the inner filter effect.
31. Richards S, Ropic M, Blackmond D, Walmsley A: Quantitative determination of the catalysed asymmetric transfer hydrogenation of 1-methyl-67-dimethoxy-34- dihydroisoquinoline using in situ FTIR and multivariate curve resolution. Anal Chim Acta (2004) 519(1):1-9.
32. Strieter ER, Blackmond DG, Buchwald SL: The role of chelating diamine ligands in the Goldberg reaction: A kinetic study on the copper-catalyzed amidation of aryl iodides. J Am Chem Soc (2005) 127(12):4120-4121. Describes how kinetic expression is obtained from a proposed mechanism and how support for the kinetic expression is derived by comparing results in the limiting cases.
33. Molga E, Cherbanski R: Hybrid first-principle-neural-network approach to modelling of the liquid-liquid reacting system. Chem Eng Sci (1999) 54(13-14):2467-2473.
34. Galvan IM, Zaldivar JM, Hernandez H, Molga E: The use of neural networks for fitting complex kinetic data. Comput Chem Eng (1996) 20(12):1451-1465.
35. Landau RN, Penix SM, Donahue SM, Rein AJ: Process development utilizing advanced technologies: The RC1 reaction calorimeter the multi-functional SimuSolv software and the ReactIR reaction analysis system. Proc SPIE Int Soc Opt Eng (1992) 1681:356-373. Provides one of the earliest examples illustrating the application of the integrated approach to process development in the pharmaceutical industry.
36. Dyer UC, Henderson DA, Mitchell MB, Tiffin PD: Scale-up of a Vilsmeier formylation reaction: Use of HEL Auto-MATE and simulation techniques for rapid and safe transfer to pilot plant from laboratory. Org Proc Res Dev (2002) 6(3):311-316. Compares the performance of the HEL SIMULAR 1-1 reaction calorimeter with the much smaller HEL Auto-MATE for enthalpy measurement.
37. Aspen BatchCAD: Aspen Technology Inc, Cambridge, MA, USA. http://www.aspentech.com/product.cfm?ProductID=316
38. Chemstations Inc, Houston, TX, USA. www.chemstations.net
39. DynoChem: Performance Fluid Dynamics Ltd, Dublin, Ireland. www.scale-up.com
40. Bright R, Dale DJ, Dunn PJ, Hussain F, Kang Y, Mason C, Mitchell JC, Snowden MJ: Identification of new catalysts to promote imidazolide couplings and optimisation of reaction conditions using kinetic modelling. Org Proc Res Dev (2004) 8(6):1054-1058.
41. Gomez S, Peters JA, van der Waal JC, van den Brink PJ, Maschmeyer T: The rationalization of catalyst behaviour In the reductive amination of benzaldenyde with ammonia using a simple computer model. Appl Catal A Gen (2004) 261(1):119-125.
42. Iizuka Y, Surianarayanan M: Comprehensive kinetic model for adiabatic decomposition of di-tert-butyl peroxide using BatchCAD. Ind Eng Chem Res (2003) 42(13):2987-2995.
43. Lunghi A, Alos MA, Gigante L, Feixas J, Sironi E, Feliu JA, Cardillo P: Identification of the decomposition products in an industrial nitration process under thermal runaway conditions. Org Proc Res Dev (2002) 6(6):926-932.
44. Bourne JR: Mixing and the selectivity of chemical reactions. Org Proc Res Dev (2003) 7(4):471-508. Provides an introduction to the principles determining the influence of mixing and mass transfer on chemical reactions, especially on the selectivity of single- and two-phase reactions.
45. Forni L: Mass and heat transfer in catalytic reactions. Catalysis Today (1999) 52(2-3):147-152.
46. Ascanio G, Castro B, Galindo E: Measurement of power consumption in stirred vessels - A review. Chem Eng Res Des (2004) 82(A9):1282-1290.
47. Chaouki J, Larachi F, Dudukovic MP: Noninvasive tomographic and velocimetric monitoring of multiphase flows, Ind Eng Chem Res (1997) 36(11):4476-4503.
48. Sommerfeld M, Decker S: State of the art and future trends in CFD simulation of stirred vessel hydrodynamics. Chem Eng Tech (2004) 27(3):215-224.
49. Baldyga J, Makowski L: CFD modelling of mixing effects on the course of parallel chemical reactions carried out in a stirred tank. Chem Eng Tech (2004) 27(3):225-231.
50. Akiti O, Yeboah A, Bai G, Armenante PM: Hydrodynamic effects on mixing and competitive reactions in laboratory reactors. Chem Eng Sci (2005) 60(8-9):2341-2354.
51. Rudniak L, Machniewski PM, Milewska A, Molga E: CFD modelling of stirred tank chemical reactors: Homogeneous and heterogeneous reaction systems. Chem Eng Sci (2004) 59(22-23):5233-5239.
52. Nielsen LPC, Stevenson CP, Blackmond DG, Jacobsen EN: Mechanistic investigation leads to a synthetic improvement in the hydrolytic kinetic resolution of terminal epoxides. J Am Chem Soc (2004) 126(5):1360-1362.
53. Gigante L, Lunghi A, Martinelli S, Cardillo P, Picello L, Bortolaso R, Galvagni M, Rota R: Calorimetric approach and simulation for scaleup of a Friedel-Crafts reaction. Org Proc Res Dev (2003) 7(6):1079-1082. Discusses a kinetic study using reaction calorimetry and commercially available software.
54. LeBars J, Dini S, Hawkins JM, Blackmond DG: Mechanistic insights into anomalous kinetic behavior in the hydrogenation of a substituted nitrobenzene. Adv Synth Catal (2004) 346(8):943-946. Explains anomalous behavior by postulating that Rideal and Langmuir-Hinshelwood mechanisms are dominant during different phases of the reaction.
55. Furusjo E, Danielsson L-G: Target testing procedure for determining chemical kinetics from spectroscopic data with absorption shifts and baseline drift. Chemometr Intell Lab Syst (2000) 50(1):63-73. Introduces a target testing method for estimation of kinetic parameters from spectroscopic data in the presence of absorption peak shifts or baseline drift.
56. Furusjo E, Svensson O, Danielsson L-G: Estimation of kinetic parameters from non-isothermal batch experiments monitored by in situ vibrational spectroscopy. Chemometr Intell Lab Syst (2003) 66(1):1-14. Discusses the application of the target testing method for estimation of kinetic parameters from spectroscopic data, with several examples.
57. Pintar A, Malacea R, Pinel C, Fogassy G, Besson M: In situ monitoring of catalytic three-phase enantioselective hydrogenation using FTIR/ATR spectroscopy. Appl Catal A Gen (2004) 264(1):1-12. In situ FTIR was used to obtain a mechanistic insight into Pd/C catalyzed enantioselective hydrogenation of prochiral, exocyclic α,β-unsaturated ketones.
58. Pintar A, Batista J, Levee J: In situ Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy as an efficient tool for determination of reaction kinetics. Analyst (2002) 127(11):1535-1540.
59. Papadaki M: Use of reaction calorimetry in thermal risk assessment studies and safe design of batch reactions that can lead to a runaway: Application on hydrogen peroxide. Top Catalysis (2004) 29(3-4):207-213.
60. LeBlond C, Wang J, Larsen R, Orella C, Sun Y-K: A combined approach to characterization of catalytic reactions using in situ kinetic probes. Top Catalysis (1998) 5(1-4 Pt 2):149-158. Provides one of the earliest examples of the use of the integrated approach for catalytic reactions.
61. Leung S, Tummala S, Lo E, Wang S, Kiang S: Inline monitoring, kinetics and process development - how are they related? US Reaction Engineering Users Forum 2002, Newport, RI, USA (2002).
62. Tummala S, Leung S, Lobben P: Application of reaction engineering tools to solve a scale up problem: An integrated approach. American Institute of Chemical Engineers Annual Meeting, Reno, NV, USA (2001).
63. Lobben PC, Leung SS-W, Tummala S: Integrated approach to the development and understanding of the borane reduction of a carboxylic acid. Org Proc Res Dev (2004) 8(6):1072-1075. Provides an example of the use of the integrated approach coupled with off-gas measurement to elucidate the kinetic parameters of a five-step mechanism.
64. Zogg A, Fischer U, Hungerbuehler K: Identification of kinetic and thermodynamic reaction parameters from online calorimetric and IR-ATR data using a new combined evaluation algorithm. Chem Eng Sci (2004) 59(24):5795-5806. Provides an example of the application of the integrated approach and discusses potential pitfalls in relying on data from a single kinetic tool for a kinetic study.
65. Pastre J, Zogg A, Fischer U, Hungerbuehler K: Determination of reaction parameters using a small calorimeter with an integrated FT-IR probe and parameter fitting. Org Proc Res Dev (2001) 5(2):158-166.
66. Roberge OM: An integrated approach combining reaction engineering and design of experiments for optimizing reactions. Org Proc Res Dev (2004) 8(6):1049-1053.
67. McConnell JR, Barton KP, LaPack MA, Des Jardin MA: Streamlining process R&D using multidimensional analytical technology. Org Proc Res Dev (2002) 6(5):700-705.