Developing the Publicness of Public International Law: Towards a Legal Framework for Global Governance Activities

German Law Journal

Volumn 9, Issue 11, 2008, Pages 1375-1400

  Von Bogdandy, Armin ^a   Dann, Philipp ^a   Goldmann, Matthias ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 85178212178     PISSN: None     EISSN: 20718322     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S2071832200000511     Document Type: Article

References (104)

1. ECJ, Case C-117/06, Möllendorf, 2007 ECR, forthcoming. On the Al-Qaida and Taliban Sanctions Committee see Clemens Feinäugle, in this issue.
2. Sächsisches Oberverwaltungsgericht, Case 4 BS 216/06, decision of 9 March 2007, published in 60 DIE ÖFFENTLICHE VERWALTUNG 564 (2007);
3. Armin von Bogdandy & Matthias Goldmann, The Exercise of International Public Authority through National Policy Assessments. The OECD's PISA Policy as a Paradigm for a New Standard Instrument, 5 INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS LAW REVIEW (forthcoming 2008).
4. JÜRGEN HABERMAS, DIE POSTNATIONALE KONSTELLATION (1998);
5. MICHAEL HARDT & ANTONIO NEGRI, EMPIRE (2002);
6. ANNE-MARIE SLAUGHTER, A NEW WORLD ORDER (2004).
7. TRANSFORMING THE GOLDEN-AGE NATION STATE (Achim Hurrelmann, et al. eds., 2005).
8. Benedict Kingsbury, Nico Krisch & Richard Stewart, The Emergence of Global Administrative Law, 68 LAW AND CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS 15 (2005);
9. Sabino Cassese, Administrative Law Without the State? The Challenge of Global Regulation, 37 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND POLITICS 663 (2005);
10. Daniel C. Esty, Good Governance at the Supranational Scale: Globalizing Administrative Law, 115 YALE LAW JOURNAL 1490 (2006).
11. Jochen A. Frowein, Konstitutionalisierung des Völkerrechts, in 39 BERICHTE DER DEUTSCHEN GESELLSCHAFT FÜR VÖLKERRECHT, 427 (Klaus Dicke et al. eds., 2000);
12. Christian Walter, Constitutionalizing (Inter)national Governance, 44 GERMAN YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW 170 (2001);
13. Brun-Otto Bryde, International Democratic Constitutionalism, in TOWARDS WORLD CONSTITUTIONALISM 103 (Ronald Macdonald et al. eds., 2005);
14. Stefan Kadelbach and Thomas Kleinlein, Überstaatliches Verfassungsrecht, 44 ARCHIV DES VÖLKERRECHTS 235 (2006);
15. Matthias Kumm, The Legitimacy of International Law: A Constitutionalist Framework Analysis, 15 EJIL 907 (2004);
16. Anne Peters, Compensatory Constitutionalism: The Function and Potential of Fundamental International Norms and Structures, 19 LEIDEN JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW 579 (2006).
17. James N. Rosenau, Governance, Order, and Change in World Politics, in GOVERNANCE WITHOUT GOVERNMENT 1 (James N. Rosenau & Ernst-Otto Czempiel eds., 1992);
18. Jan Kooiman, Findings, Recommendations and Speculations, in MODERN GOVERNANCE: NEW GOVERNMENT-SOCIETY INTERACTIONS 249 (Jan Kooiman ed., 1993).
19. Oliver E. Williamson, The Economics of Governance: Framework and Implications, 140 ZEITSCHRIFT FÜR DIE GESAMTE STAATSWISSENSCHAFT 195 (1984).
20. Martin Hewson & Timothy J. Sinclair, The Emergence of Global Governance Theory, in GLOBAL GOVERNANCE THEORY 3 (Martin Hewson & Timothy J. Sinclair eds., 1999);
21. Renate Mayntz, Governance Theory als fortentwickelte Steuerungstheorie?, in GOVERNANCE-FORSCHUNG 11 (Gunnar F. Schuppert ed., 2006);
22. Arthur Benz, Governance - Modebegriff oder nützliches sozialwissenschaftliches Konzept?, in GOVERNANCE - REGIEREN IN KOMPLEXEN REGELSYSTEMEN 11 (Arthur Benz ed., 2004).
23. Michael Barnett & Raymond Duvall, Power in Global Governance, in POWER IN GLOBAL GOVERNANCE 1, 7 (Michael Barnett & Raymond Duvall eds., 2005);
24. Michael Zürn, Institutionalisierte Ungleichheit in der Weltpolitik. Jenseits der Alternative "Global Governance" versus "American Empire," 48 POLITISCHE VIERTELJAHRESSCHRIFT 680 (2007).
25. See e.g. Robert Latham, Politics in a Floating World, in GLOBAL GOVERNANCE THEORY 23 (Martin Hewson & Timothy J. Sinclair eds., 2000);
26. Martti Koskenniemi, Global Governance and Public International Law, 37 KRITISCHE JUSTIZ 241 (2004).
27. Michael Barnett & Martha Finnemore, The Power of Liberal International Organizations, in POWER IN GLOBAL GOVERNANCE 161, 163-169 (Michael Barnett & Raymond Duvall eds., 2005).
28. CONTENDING PERSPECTIVES ON GLOBAL GOVERNANCE (Alice D. Ba & Matthew J. Hoffmann eds., 2005).
29. Amichai Cohen, Bureaucratic Internalization: Domestic Governmental Agencies and the Legitimization of International Law, 30 GEORGETOWN JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW 1079 (2005);
30. Ruth W. Grant & Robert O. Keohane, Accountability and Abuses of Power in World Politics, 99 AMERICAN POLITICAL SCIENCE REVIEW 29 (2005);
31. Robert Howse & Kalypso Nicolaidis, Enhancing WTO Legitimacy: Constitutionalization or Global Subsidiarity?, 16 GOVERNANCE 73 (2003);
32. Anne-Marie Slaughter, The Accountability of Government Networks, 8 INDIANA JOURNAL OF GLOBAL LEGAL STUDIES 347 (2000-2001);
33. Rainer Wahl, Der einzelne in der Welt jenseits des Staates, in VERFASSUNGSSTAAT, EUROPÄISIERUNG, INTERNATIONALISIERUNG 53 (Rainer Wahl ed., 2003);
34. Joseph H. H. Weiler, The Geology of International Law - Governance, Democracy and Legitimacy, 64 ZEITSCHRIFT FÜR AUSLÄNDISCHES ÖFFENTLICHES RECHT UND VÖLKERRECHT (ZAÖRV) 547 (2004);
35. Michael Zürn, Global Governance and Legitimacy Problems, 39 GOVERNMENT AND OPPOSITION 260 (2004).
36. Armin von Bogdandy, Globalization and Europe: How to Square Democracy and Globalization, 15 EUR. J. INT'L LAW 885 (2004).
37. See EBERHARD SCHMIDT-AßMANN, DAS ALLGEMEINE VERWALTUNGSRECHT ALS ORDNUNGSIDEE 16-18 (2nd ed. 2004).
38. Benedict Kingsbury, International Law as Inter-Public Law (http://www.law.nyu.edu/kingsburyb/fall06/globalization/papers/ Kingsbury, NewJusGentiumandInter-PublicI1.pdf).
39. Jean d'Aspremont, Contemporary International Rulemaking and the Public Character of International Law, IILJ Working Paper 2006/12, http://www.iilj.org/publications/documents/2006-12-dAspremont-web.pdf.
40. HANS-JOACHIM KOCH & HELMUT RÜßMANN, JURISTISCHE BEGRÜNDUNGSLEHRE 75 (1982).
41. Myres McDougal & Harold Laswell, The Identification and Appraisal of Diverse Systems of Public Order, 53 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW 1, 9 (1959)
42. Christoph Möllers, GEWALTENGLIEDERUNG 81-93 (2005).
43. Ekkehart Reimer, Transnationales Steuerrecht, in INTERNATIONALES VERWALTUNGSRECHT 181 (Christoph Möllers, Andreas Voßkuhle & Christian Walter eds., 2007).
44. Kenneth W. Abbott und Duncan Snidal, Hard and Soft Law in International Governance, 54 INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION 421 (2000);
45. Charles Lipson, Why are some international agreements informal?, 45 INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION 495 (1991).
46. Matthias Ruffert, Perspektiven des Internationalen Verwaltungsrechts, in INTERNATIONALES VERWALTUNGSRECHT 395, 402 (Christoph Möllers & Andreas Voßkuhle & Christian Walter eds., 2007).
47. CARL J. FRIEDRICH, CONSTITUTIONAL GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS 247 et seq. (1950);
48. KARL LOEWENSTEIN, POLITICAL POWER AND THE GOVERNMENTAL PROCESS (1957);
49. Louis Henkin, A New Birth of Constitutionalism, in CONSTITUTIONALISM, IDENTITY, DIFFERENCE AND LEGITIMACY 39 (Michel Rosenfeld ed., 1994);
50. Andreas Fischer-Lescano, Transnationales Verwaltungsrecht, 63 JURISTENZEITUNG 373, 376 (2008).
51. Matthias Goldmann, The Accountability of Private vs. Public Governance "by Information": A Comparison of the Assessment Activities of the OECD and the IEA in the Field of Education, 58 RIVISTA TRIMESTRALE DI DIRITTO PUBBLICO 41 (2008).
52. PHILIPPE SANDS & PIERRE KLEIN, BOWETT'S LAW OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION 16-7 (2001);
53. Jan Klabbers, The Changing Image of International Organizations, in THE LEGITIMACY OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS 221, 236 (Jean-Marc Coicaud & Veijo Heiskanen eds., 2001).
54. Armin von Bogdandy, The Legal Case for Unity: The European Union as a Single Organization with a Single Legal System, 36 COMMON MARKET LAW REVIEW 887 (1999).
55. Christoph Möllers, Verfassungs- und völkerrechtliche Probleme transnationaler administrativer Standardsetzung, ZAÖRV 65 (2005), 351-389;
56. Eyal Benvenisti, Coalitions of the Willing and the Evolution of Informal International Law, in COALITIONS OF THE WILLING - AVANTGARDE OR THREAT? 1 (Christian Calliess, Georg Nolte & Peter-Tobias Stoll, 2007).
57. MAX HUBER, DIE SOZIOLOGISCHEN GRUNDLAGEN DES VÖLKERRECHTS (1928);
58. Anne-Marie Slaughter, International law and international relations, 285 RECUEIL DES COURS 13 (2000).
59. Harold Hongju Koh, Transnational Legal Process, 75 NEBRASKA LAW REVIEW 181 (1996);
60. Michael W. Reisman, The Democratization of Contemporary International Law-Making Processes and the Differentiation of Their Application, in DEVELOPMENTS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW IN TREATY MAKING 15, 24-26 (Rüdiger Wolfrum & Volker Röben eds., 2005).
61. Felix Hanschmann, Theorie transnationaler Rechtsprozesse, in NEUE THEORIEN DES RECHTS 347, 357 (Sonja Buckel, Ralph Christensen & Andreas Fischer-Lescano eds., 2006).
62. Abraham Chayes and Antonia Handler Chayes, On Compliance, 47 INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION 175-205 (1993);
63. Harold K. Jacobson and Edith Brown Weiss, Compliance with International Environmental Accords, 1 GLOBAL GOVERNANCE 119-48 (1995);
64. COMMITMENT AND COMPLIANCE: THE ROLE OF NONBINDING NORMS IN THE INTERNATIONAL LEGAL SYSTEM (Dinah Shelton ed., 2000).
65. David M. Trubek & Louise G. Trubek, New Governance & Legal Regulation: Complementarity, Rivalry, and Transformation, 13 COLUMBIA JOURNAL OF EUROPEAN LAW 1-26 (2006);
66. HARD CHOICES, SOFT LAW (John Kirton & Michael Trebilcock eds., 2004).
67. JOSÉ E. ALVAREZ, INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS AS LAW-MAKERS 17 et seq. (2005).
68. ANNE-MARIE SLAUGHTER, A NEW WORLD ORDER (2004).
69. GUNTER TEUBNER & ANDREAS FISCHER-LESCANO, REGIME-KOLLISIONEN (2006).
70. Andreas Paulus, Zur Zukunft der Völkerrechtswissenschaft in Deutschland: Zwischen Konstitutionalisierung und Fragmentierung des Völkerrechts, 67 ZAÖRV 695, 708-15 (2007).
71. Eyal Benvenisti, The Empire's New Clothes: Political Economy and the Fragmentation of International Law, 60 STANFORD LAW REVIEW 595 (2007).
72. Matthias Goldmann, Der Widerspenstigen Zähmung, in NETZWERKE 225 (Sigrid Boysen et al. eds., 2007).
73. Sabino Cassese, Global Standards for National Administrative Procedure, 68 LAW AND CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS 109-26 (2005).
74. DEBORAH CASS, THE CONSTITUTIONALIZATION OF THE WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION (2005);
75. Ernst- Ulrich Petersmann, Multilevel Trade Governance in the WTO Requires Multilevel Constitutionalism, in CONSITTUTIONALISM, MULTILEVEL TRADE GOVERNANCE AND SOCIAL REGULATION 5 (Christian Joerges & Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann eds., 2006).
76. In detail Armin von Bogdandy, Constitutionalism in International Law: Comment on a Proposal from Germany, 47 HARVARD INTERNATIONAL LAW JOURNAL 223-242 (2006).
77. Martti Koskenniemi, Constitutionalism as Mindset: Reflections on Kantian Themes about International Law and Globalization, 8 THEORETICAL INQUIRIES 22 (2007).
78. INTERNATIONAL LAW ASSOCIATION, ACCOUNTABILITY OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATIONS, Final Report, 2004, available at: http://www.ila-hq.org/html/layout_committee.htm.
79. Restructuring Iraq. Possible Models based upon experience gained under the Authority of the League of Nations and the United Nations, 9 MAX PLANCK YEARBOOK OF UNITED NATIONS LAW (2005).
80. Markus Glaser, Internationales Sozialverwaltungsrecht, in INTERNATIONALES VERWALTUNGSRECHT 73 (Andreas Voßkuhle, Christoph Möllers & Christian Walter eds., 2007);
81. Jürgen Bast, Internationalisierung und De-Internationalisierung der Migrationsverwaltung, in INTERNATIONALES VERWALTUNGSRECHT 279 (Andreas Voßkuhle, Christoph Möllers & Christian Walter eds., 2007);
82. CHRISTOPH OHLER, DIE KOLLISIONSORDNUNG DES ALLGEMEINEN VERWALTUNGSRECHTS (2005).
83. CHRISTIAN TIETJE, INTERNATIONALISIERTES VERWALTUNGSHANDELN (2001).
84. Benedict Kingsbury, Omnilateralism and Partial International Communities: Contributions of the Emerging Global Administrative Law, 104 JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND DIPLOMACY 98 (2005).
85. Richard Stewart, US Administrative Law: A Model for Global Administrative Law?, 68 LAW AND CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS 63 (2005);
86. Mario Savino, EU "Procedural" Supranationalism: On Models for Global Administrative Law, paper presented at the NYU Global Forum on 13 December 2006, on file with the authors.
87. Nico Krisch, The Pluralism of Global Administrative Law, 17 EJIL 247 (2006).
88. CHITTHARANJAN FELIX AMERASINGHE, I THE LAW OF INTERNATIONAL CIVIL SERVICE (2nd ed. 1994).
89. HENRY G. SCHERMERS & NIELS BLOKKER, INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTIONAL LAW (4th ed. 2003);
90. JAN KLABBERS, AN INTRODUCTION TO INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTIONAL LAW (2002);
91. NIGEL D. WHITE, THE LAW OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS (2nd ed. 2005);
92. IGNAZ SEIDL-HOHENFELDER & GERHARD LOIBL, DAS RECHT DER INTERNATIONALEN ORGANISATIONEN EINSCHLIEßLICH DER SUPRANATIONALEN GEMEINSCHAFTEN (7th ed. 2000);
93. PETER FISCHER & HERIBERT KÖCK, DAS RECHT DER INTERNATIONALEN ORGANISATIONEN (3rd ed. 1997);
94. HANDBOOK ON INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS (René-Jean Dupuy ed., 1988)
95. Id. See also ALAN BOYLE & CHRISTINE CHINKIN, THE MAKING OF INTERNATIONAL LAW (2007);
96. JURIJ D. ASTON, SEKUNDÄRGESETZGEBUNG INTERNATIONALER ORGANISATIONEN ZWISCHEN MITGLIEDSGTAATLICHER SOUVERÄNITÄT UND GEMEINSCHAFTSDISZIPLIN (2005).
97. Studies on individual instruments are too numerous to be mentioned. See the GAL bibliography (2006) compiled by Maurizia De Bellis, available at: http://www.iilj.org/GAL/documents/GALBibliographyMDeBellisJune2006.pdf.
98. Matthias Ruffert, Zuständigkeitsgrenzen internationaler Organisationen im institutionelllen Rahmen der internationalen Gemeinschaft, 38 ARCHIV DES VÖLKERRECHTS 129 (2000);
99. DANESH SAROOSHI, INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS AND THEIR EXERCISE OF SOVEREIGN POWERS (2005).
100. For a well argued book hinting in that direction see CHRISTIAN SEILER, DER SOUVERÄNE VERFASSUNGSSTAAT ZWISCHEN DEMOKRATISCHER RÜCKBINDUNG UND ÜBERSTAATLICHER EINBINDUNG (2005).
101. Richard Stewart, The Reformation of American Administrative Law, 88 HARVARD LAW REVIEW 1667 (1975).
102. Andreas Voßkuhle, The Reform Approach in the German Science of Administrative Law: The "Neue Verwaltungsrechtswissenschaft," in THE TRANSFORMATION OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW IN EUROPE 89 (Matthias Ruffert ed., 2007).
103. Wolfgang Hoffmann-Riem, Rechtsformen, Handlungsformen, Bewirkungsformen, in II GRUNDLAGEN DES VERWALTUNGSRECHTS 885 (Wolfgang Hoffmann-Riem, Eberhard Schmidt-Aßmann & Andreas Voßkuhle eds., 2007).
104. Oliver Lepsius, Was kann die deutsche Staatsrechtslehre von der amerikanischen Rechtswissenschaft lernen?, in STAATSLEHRE ALS WISSENSCHAFT (supplement to DIE VERWALTUNG) 330 (Helmut Schulze-Fielitz ed., 2007).