Nutrients in Urban Stormwater Runoff: Current State of the Science and Potential Mitigation Options

Current Pollution Reports

Volumn 4, Issue 2, 2018, Pages 112-127

  Yang, Yun Ya ^a   Lusk, Mary G ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA   (United States)

Author keywords

Nitrogen; Phosphorus; Stormwater management; Stormwater runoff; Urban water quality

Indexed keywords

EID: 85051080880     PISSN: None     EISSN: 21986592     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s40726-018-0087-7     Document Type: Review

References (117)

1. Guan MF, Sillanpaa N, Koivusalo H. Storm runoff response to rainfall pattern, magnitude and urbanization in a developing urban catchment. Hydrol Process. 2016;30:543–57
2. O'Driscoll M, Clinton S, Jefferson A, Manda A, McMillan S. Urbanization effects on watershed hydrology and in-stream processes in the Southern United States. Water. 2010;2:605–48
3. Brown LR, Cuffney TF, Coles JF, Fitzpatrick F, McMahon G, Steuer J, et al. Urban streams across the USA: lessons learned from studies in 9 metropolitan areas. J N Am Benthol Soc. 2009;28:1051–69
4. McGrane SJ. Impacts of urbanisation on hydrological and water quality dynamics, and urban water management: a review. Hydrol Sci J-J Sci Hydrol. 2016;61:2295–311
5. Walsh CJ, Roy AH, Feminella JW, Cottingham PD, Groffman PM, Morgan RP. The urban stream syndrome: current knowledge and the search for a cure. J N Am Benthol Soc. 2005;24:706–23
6. Schueler TR, Fraley-McNeal L, Cappiella K. Is impervious cover still important? Review of recent research. J Hydrol Eng. 2009;14:309–15
7. Conley DJ, Paerl HW, Howarth RW, Boesch DF, Seitzinger SP, Havens KE, et al. Controlling eutrophication: nitrogen and phosphorus. Science. 2009;323:1014–5
8. Howarth R, Paerl HW. Coastal marine eutrophication: control of both nitrogen and phosphorus is necessary. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008;105:E103-E103
9. Saraswat C, Kumar P, Mishra BK. Assessment of stormwater runoff management practices and governance under climate change and urbanization: an analysis of Bangkok, Hanoi and Tokyo. Environ Sci Pol. 2016;64:101–17
10. Sage J, Berthier E, Gromaire MC. Stormwater management criteria for on-site pollution control: a comparative assessment of international practices. Environ Manag. 2015;56:66–80
11. Tondera K, Blecken G-T, Tournebize J, Mander Ü, Tanner CC. Nutrient removal from variable stormwater flows. In Ecotechnologies for the treatment of variable stormwater and wastewater flows, Springer; 2018. pp. 31–55
12. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Results of the nationwide urban runoff program. volume III-data appendix. Washington, DC: Water Planning Division; 1983; WH-554, PB84e185578. p. 207
13. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The national stormwater quality database, version 1.1. A complication and analysis of NPDES stormwater monitoring information. Washington, DC. 2005
14. Smullen J, Cave KA. National stormwater runoff pollution database. In: Field R, Sullivan D, editors. Wet-weather flow in the urban watershed. Boca Raton: Lewis Publishers; 2002
15. Ma J, Ying GX, Sansalone JJ. Transport and distribution of particulate matter phosphorus fractions in rainfall-runoff from roadway source areas. J Environ Eng ASCE. 2010;136:1197–205
16. Bratt AR, Finlay JC, Hobbie SE, Janke BD, Worm AC, Kemmitt KL. Contribution of leaf litter to nutrient export during winter months in an urban residential watershed. Environ Sci Technol. 2017;51:3138–47
17. •• Lusk MG, Toor GS. Biodegradability and molecular composition of dissolved organic nitrogen in urban stormwater runoff and outflow water from a stormwater retention pond. Environ Sci Technol. 2016;50:3391–8. This article provides a novel approach to investigating the biodegradability and molecular composition of organic nitrogen in urban stormwater runoff and retention ponds
18. Lusk MG, Toor GS. Dissolved organic nitrogen in urban streams: biodegradability and molecular composition studies. Water Res. 2016;96:225–35
19. 18O reveal the sources of nitrate-nitrogen in urban residential stormwater runoff. Environ Sci Technol. 2016;50:2881–9
20. Yang Y-Y, Toor GS. Sources and mechanisms of nitrate and orthophosphate transport in urban stormwater runoff from residential catchments. Water Res. 2017;112:176–84
21. Hall SJ, Weintraub SR, Eiriksson D, Brooks PD, Baker MA, Bowen GJ, et al. Stream nitrogen inputs reflect groundwater across a snowmelt-dominated montane to urban watershed. Environ Sci Technol. 2016;50:1137–46
22. Kaushal SS, Groffman PM, Band LE, Elliott EM, Shields CA, Kendall C. Tracking nonpoint source nitrogen pollution in human-impacted watersheds. Environ Sci Technol. 2011;45:8225–32
23. Divers MT, Elliott EM, Bain DJ. Quantification of nitrate sources to an urban stream using dual nitrate isotopes. Environ Sci Technol. 2014;48:10580–7
24. Pennino MJ, Kaushal SS, Murthy SN, Blomquist JD, Cornwell JC, Harris LA. Sources and transformations of anthropogenic nitrogen along an urban river-estuarine continuum. Biogeosciences. 2016;13:6211–28
25. Mueller C, Zink M, Samaniego L, Krieg R, Merz R, Rode M, et al. Discharge driven nitrogen dynamics in a mesoscale river basin as constrained by stable isotope patterns. Environ Sci Technol. 2016;50:9187–96
26. Yi Q, Chen Q, Hu L, Shi W. Tracking nitrogen sources, transformation, and transport at a basin scale with complex plain river networks. Environ Sci Technol. 2017;51:5396–403
27. 18O to determine nitrate sources in the Yellow River, China. Environ Sci Technol. 2013;47:13412–21
28. Groffman PM, Law NL, Belt KT, Band LE, Fisher GT. Nitrogen fluxes and retention in urban watershed ecosystems. Ecosystems. 2004;7:393–403
29. Janke BD, Finlay JC, Hobbie SE. Trees and streets as drivers of urban stormwater nutrient pollution. Environ Sci Technol. 2017;51:9569–79
30. •• Hobbie SE, Finlay JC, Janke BD, Nidzgorski DA, Millet DB, Baker LA. Contrasting nitrogen and phosphorus budgets in urban watersheds and implications for managing urban water pollution. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2017;114:4177–82. This article shows a comparsion of urban watershed N and P budgets and describes the ways to reduce nutrient pollution from urban landscapes
31. Kojima K, Murakami M, Yoshimizu C, Tayasu I, Nagata T, Furumai H. Evaluation of surface runoff and road dust as sources of nitrogen using nitrate isotopic composition. Chemosphere. 2011;84:1716–22
32. Anisfeld SC, Barnes RT, Altabet MA, Wu T. Isotopic apportionment of atmospheric and sewage nitrogen sources in two Connecticut rivers. Environ Sci Technol. 2007;41:6363–9
33. Riha KM, Michalski G, Gallo EL, Lohse KA, Brooks PD, Meixner T. High atmospheric nitrate inputs and nitrogen turnover in semi-arid urban catchments. Ecosystems. 2014;17:1309–25
34. Hale RL, Turnbull L, Earl S, Grimm N, Riha K, Michalski G, et al. Sources and transport of nitrogen in arid urban watersheds. Environ Sci Technol. 2014;48:6211–9
35. Waschbusch RJ, Selbig WR, Bannerman RT. Sources of phosphorus in stormwater and street dirt from two urban residential basins in Madison, Wisconsin, 1994–95: U.S. Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report. 1999;99–4021. p. 47
36. Toor GS, Occhipinti ML, Yang Y-Y, Majcherek T, Haver D, Oki L. Managing urban runoff in residential neighborhoods: nitrogen and phosphorus in lawn irrigation driven runoff. PLoS One. 2017;12:e0179151
37. Carey RO, Hochmuth GJ, Martinez CJ, Boyer TH, Dukes MD, Toor GS, et al. Evaluating nutrient impacts in urban watersheds: challenges and research opportunities. Environ Pollut. 2013;173:138–49
38. Badruzzaman M, Pinzon J, Oppenheimer J, Jacangelo J. Sources of nutrients impacting surface waters in Florida: a review. J Environ Manag. 2012;109:80–92
39. Fissore C, Baker LA, Hobbie SE, King JY, McFadden JP, Nelson KC, et al. Carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus fluxes in household ecosystems in the Minneapolis-Saint Paul, Minnesota, urban region. Ecol Appl. 2011;21:619–39
40. Baker LA, Hope D, Xu Y, Edmonds J, Lauver L. Nitrogen balance for the Central Arizona-Phoenix (CAP) ecosystem. Ecosystems. 2001;4:582–602
41. Pennino MJ, Kaushal SS, Mayer PM, Utz RM, Cooper CA. Stream restoration and sewers impact sources and fluxes of water, carbon, and nutrients in urban watersheds. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci. 2016;20:3419–39
42. Selbig W. Evaluation of leaf removal as a means to reduce nutrient concentrations and loads in urban stormwater. Sci Total Environ. 2016;571:124–33
43. Xing J, Song J, Yuan H, Li X, Li N, Duan L, et al. Fluxes, seasonal patterns and sources of various nutrient species (nitrogen, phosphorus and silicon) in atmospheric wet deposition and their ecological effects on Jiaozhou Bay, North China. Sci Total Environ. 2017;576:617–27
44. Burns M, Fletcher T, Walsh C, Ladson A, Hatt B. Hydrologic shortcomings of conventional urban stormwater management and opportunities for reform. Landsc Urban Plan. 2012;105:230–40
45. Fletcher TD, Shuster W, Hunt WF, Ashley R, Butler D, Arthur S, et al. SUDS, LID, BMPs, WSUD and more—the evolution and application of terminology surrounding urban drainage. Urban Water J. 2015;12:525–42
46. Taylor A, Fletcher T. Nonstructural urban stormwater quality measures: building a knowledge base to improve their use. Environ Manag. 2007;39:663–77
47. Cousins JJ. Infrastructure and institutions: stakeholder perspectives of stormwater governance in Chicago. Cities. 2017;66:44–52
48. Kaplowitz MD, Lupi F. Stakeholder preferences for best management practices for non-point source pollution and stormwater control. Landsc Urban Plan. 2012;104:364–72
49. Monaghan P, Hu S, Hansen G, Ott E, Nealis C, Morera M. Balancing the ecological function of residential stormwater ponds with homeowner landscaping practices. Environ Manag. 2016;58:843–56
50. Baker L, Kalinosky P, Hobbie S, Bintner R, Buyarksi C. Quantifying nutrient removal by enhanced street sweeping. Stormwater. 2014;15:16–23
51. Hobbie S, Baker L, Buyarski C, Nidzgorski D, Finlay J. Decomposition of tree leaf litter on pavement: implications for urban water quality. Urban Ecosyst. 2014;17:369–85
52. Duan S, Delaney-Newcomb K, Kaushal S, Findlay S, Belt K. Potential effects of leaf litter on water quality in urban watersheds. Biogeochem. 2014;121:61–80
53. Fore LS. Effectiveness of public education and outreach programs for reducing impacts of stormwater on rivers and streams. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/769e/1020503d435102ecfc6c3df6131295764341.pdf. Accessed 15 Aug 2017
54. Bos DG, Brown H. Overcoming barriers to community participation in a catchment-scale experiment: building trust and changing behavior. Freshwater Sci. 2015;34:1169–75
55. Brown HL, Bos DG, Walsh CJ, Fletcher TD, RossRakesh S. More than money: how multiple factors influence householder participation in at-source stormwater management. J Environ Plan Manag. 2016;59:79–97
56. Hartman R, Alcock F, Pettit C. The spread of fertilizer ordinances in Florida. Sea Grant Law & Policy Journal. 2008;1:98–115
57. Persaud A, Alsharif K, Monaghan P, Akiwumi F, Morera MC, Ott E. Landscaping practices, community perceptions, and social indicators for stormwater nonpoint source pollution management. Sustain Cities Soc. 2016;27:377–85
58. Collins K, Lawrence T, Stander E, Jontos R, Kaushal S, Newcomer T, et al. Opportunities and challenges for managing nitrogen in urban stormwater: a review and synthesis. Ecol Eng. 2010;36:1507–19
59. Williams CJ, Frost PC, Xenopoulos MA. Beyond best management practices: pelagic biogeochemical dynamics in urban stormwater ponds. Ecol Appl. 2013;23:1384–95
60. Rosenzweig BR, Smith JA, Baeck ML, Jaffe PR. Monitoring nitrogen loading and retention in an urban strormwater detention pond. J Environ Qual. 2011;40:598–609
61. Koch BJ, Febria CM, Gevrey M, Wainger LA. Nitrogen removal by stormwater management structures: a data synthesis. J Am Water Resour Assoc. 2014;50:1594–607
62. Comings K, Booth D, Horner R. Storm water pollutant removal by two wet ponds in Bellevue, Washington. J Environ Eng Asce. 2000;126:321–30
63. Bettez ND, Groffman PM. Denitrification potential in stormwater control structures and natural riparian zones in an urban landscape. Environ Sci Technol. 2012;46:10909–17
64. Morse NR, McPhillips LE, Shapleigh JP, Walter MT. The role of denitrification in stormwater detention basin treatment of nitrogen. Environ Sci Technol. 2017;51:7928–35
65. Rosenquist S, Hession W, Eick M, Vaughan D. Variability in adsorptive phosphorus removal by structural stormwater best management practices. Ecol Eng. 2010;36:664–71
66. WERF International stormwater BMP database: 2016 summary statistics; 2017
67. Li L, Davis AP. Urban stormwater runoff nitrogen composition and fate in bioretention systems. Environ Sci Technol. 2014;48:3403–10
68. •• Liu J, Sample D, Bell C, Guan Y. Review and research needs of bioretention used for the treatment of urban stormwater. Water. 2014;6:1069–99. This review offers a thorough discussion of bioretention used for the urban stormwater treatment of numerous pollutants, as well as valuable insights into the future direction of bioretention design
69. Brown RA, Birgand F, Hunt WF. Analysis of consecutive events for nutrient and sediment treatment in field-monitored bioretention cells. Water Air Soil Pollut. 2013;224:1581
70. Lucas William C, Greenway M. Phosphorus retention by bioretention mesocosms using media formulated for phosphorus sorption: response to accelerated loads. JIrrig Drain Eng. 2011;137:144–53
71. Palmer ET, Poor CJ, Hinman C, Stark JD. Nitrate and phosphate removal through enhanced bioretention media: mesocosm study. Water Environ Res. 2013;85:823–32
72. Lopez EV, Lynn TJ, Peterson M, Ergas SJ, Trotz MA, In Mihelcic JR. Enhanced nutrient management of stormwater through a field demonstration of nitrogen removal in a modified bioretention system. World Environ Water Resour Congr. 2016:60–9
73. Lucke T, Mohamed M, Tindale N. Pollutant removal and hydraulic reduction performance of field grassed swales during runoff simulation experiments. Water. 2014;6:1887–904
74. Leroy M, Portet-Koltalo F, Legras M, Lederf F, Moncond’huy V, Polaert I, et al. Performance of vegetated swales for improving road runoff quality in a moderate traffic urban area. Sci Total Environ. 2016;566:113–21
75. Kachchu Mohamed MA, Lucke T, Boogaard F. Preliminary investigation into the pollution reduction performance of swales used in a stormwater treatment train. Water Sci Technol. 2014;69:1014–20
76. Stagge JH, Davis AP, Jamil E, Kim H. Performance of grass swales for improving water quality from highway runoff. Water Res. 2012;46:6731–42
77. Winston RJ, Hunt WF, Kennedy SG, Merriman LS, Chandler J, Brown D. Evaluation of floating treatment wetlands as retrofits to existing stormwater retention ponds. Ecol Eng. 2013;54:254–65
78. White SA, Cousins MM. Floating treatment wetland aided remediation of nitrogen and phosphorus from simulated stormwater runoff. Ecol Eng. 2013;61:207–15
79. Lynch J, Fox LJ, Owen Jr JS, Sample DJ. Evaluation of commercial floating treatment wetland technologies for nutrient remediation of stormwater. Ecol Eng. 2015;75:61–9
80. Brown RA, Borst M. Nutrient infiltrate concentrations from three permeable pavement types. J Environ Manag. 2015;164:74–85
81. Bean EZ, Hunt WF, Bidelspach DA. Field survey of permeable pavement surface infiltration rates. J Irrig Drain Eng. 2007;133:249–55
82. Mullaney J, Lucke T. Practical review of pervious pavement designs. Clean Soil Air Water. 2014;42:111–24
83. Sansalone J, Kuang X, Ying G, Ranieri V. Filtration and clogging of permeable pavement loaded by urban drainage. Water Res. 2012;46:6763–74
84. Winston R, Al-Rubaei A, Blecken G-T, Hunt W. Maintenance measures for preservation and recovery of permeable pavement hydraulics: effects of vacuum cleaning, high pressure washing, street sweeping, and milling. J Environ Manag. 2016;169:132–44
85. James W, von Langsdorff H. Towards restoring infiltration in permeable pavers—initial demonstration of rapid clean-out concepts. J Water Manag Model. 2016; 10.14796/JWMM.C405
86. Li H, Li Z, Zhang X, Li Z, Liu D, Li T, et al. The effect of different surface materials on runoff quality in permeable pavement systems. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 2017;24:21103–10
87. Ahiablame LM, Engel BA, Chaubey I. Effectiveness of low impact development practices: literature review and suggestions for future research. Water Air Soil Pollut. 2012;223:4253–73
88. Bliss DJ, Neufeld RD, Ries RJ. Storm water runoff mitigation using a green roof. Environ Eng Sci. 2009;26:407–18
89. Gregoire BG, Clausen JC. Effect of a modular extensive green roof on stormwater runoff and water quality. Ecol Eng. 2011;37:963–9
90. Berndtsson JC. Green roof performance towards management of runoff water quantity and quality: a review. Ecol Eng. 2010;36:351–60
91. Sims AW, Robinson CE, Smart CC, Voogt JA, Hay GJ, Lundholm JT, et al. Retention performance of green roofs in three different climate regions. J Hydrol. 2016;542:115–24
92. Whittinghill LJ, Rowe DB, Andresen JA, Cregg BM. Comparison of stormwater runoff from sedum, native prairie, and vegetable producing green roofs. Urban Ecosyst. 2015;18:13–29
93. Vanuytrecht E, Van Mechelen C, Van Meerbeek K, Willems P, Hermy M, Raes D. Runoff and vegetation stress of green roofs under different climate change scenarios. Landsc Urban Plan. 2014;122:68–77
94. Volder A, Dvorak B. Event size, substrate water content and vegetation affect storm water retention efficiency of an un-irrigated extensive green roof system in Central Texas. Sustain Cities Soc. 2014;10:59–64
95. Silva SR, Ging PB, Lee RW, Ebbert JC, Tesoriero AJ, Inkpen EL. Forensic applications of nitrogen and oxygen isotopes in tracing nitrate sources in urban environments. Environ Forensic. 2002;3:125–30
96. Cettner A, Ashley R, Viklander M, Nilsson K. Stormwater management and urban planning: lessons from 40 years of innovation. J Environ Plan Manag. 2013;56:786–801
97. Jia H, Lu Y, Yu SL, Chen Y. Planning of LID–BMPs for urban runoff control: the case of Beijing Olympic Village. Sep Purif Technol. 2012;84:112–9
98. Krueger R, Buckingham S. Towards a ‘consensual’ urban politics? Creative planning, urban sustainability and regional development. Int J Urban Reg Res. 2012;36:486–503
99. Jarvie HP, Withers PJA, Bowes MJ, Palmer-Felgate EJ, Harper DM, Wasiak K, et al. Streamwater phosphorus and nitrogen across a gradient in rural - agricultural land use intensity. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2010;135:238–52
100. Taylor GD, Fletcher TD, Wong THF, Breen PF, Duncan HP. Nitrogen composition in urban runoff - implications for stormwater management. Water Res. 2005;39:1982–9
101. Vaze J, Chiew FHS. Nutrient loads associated with different sediment sizes in urban stormwater and surface pollutants. J Environ Eng ASCE. 2004;130:391–6
102. Wu JL, Ren YF, Wang XM, Wang XK, Chen LD, Liu GC. Nitrogen and phosphorus associating with different size suspended solids in roof and road runoff in Beijing, China. Environ Sci Pollut Res. 2015;22:15788–95
103. Arias ME, Brown MT, Sansalone JJ. Characterization of storm water-suspended sediments and phosphorus in an urban catchment in Florida. J Environ Eng ASCE. 2013;139:277–88
104. Li DY, Wan JQ, Ma YW, Wang Y, Huang MZ, Chen YM. Stormwater runoff pollutant loading distributions and their correlation with rainfall and catchment characteristics in a rapidly industrialized city. PLoS One. 2015;10:e0118776
105. Gallo EL, Brooks PD, Lohse KA, McLain JE. Land cover controls on summer discharge and runoff solution chemistry of semi-arid urban catchments. J Hydrol. 2013;485:37–53
106. Kaushal SS, Mayer PM, Vidon PG, Smith RM, Pennino MJ, Newcomer TA, et al. Land use and climate variability amplify carbon, nutrient, and comtaminant pulses: a review with management implications. J Am Water Resour Assoc. 2014;50:585–614
107. Lewis DB, Grimm NB. Hierarchical regulation of nitrogen export from urban catchments: interactions of storms and landscapes. Ecol Appl. 2007;17:2347–64
108. Beck SM, McHale MR, Hess GR. Beyond impervious: urban land-cover pattern variation and implications for watershed management. Environ Manag. 2016;58:15–30
109. Goonetilleke A, Thomas E, Ginn S, Gilbert D. Understanding the role of land use in urban stormwater quality management. J Environ Manag. 2005;74:31–42
110. Kaushal SS, Groffman PM, Band LE, Shields CA, Morgan RP, Palmer MA, et al. Interaction between urbanization and climate variability amplifies watershed nitrate export in Maryland. Environ Sci Technol. 2008;42:5872–8
111. • Hale RL, Turnbull L, Earl SR, Childers DL, Grimm NB. Stormwater infrastructure controls runoff and dissolved material export from arid urban watersheds. Ecosystems. 2015;18:62–75. This article describes how stormwater infrastructure design, land use, and storm characteristics affect nutrient loads from urban watershed ecosystems over time and space
112. Lee J, Bang K, Ketchum L, Choe J, Yu M. First flush analysis of urban storm runoff. Sci Total Environ. 2002;293:163–75
113. Taebi A, Droste RL. First flush pollution load of urban stormwater runoff. J Environ Eng Sci. 2004;3:301–9
114. Hathaway J, Tucker R, Spooner J, Hunt W. A traditional analysis of the first flush effect for nutrients in stormwater runoff from two small urban catchments. Water Air Soil Pollut. 2012;223:5903–15
115. Wijesiri B, Egodawatta P, McGree J, Goonetilleke A. Understanding the uncertainty associated with particle-bound pollutant build-up and wash-off: a critical review. Water Res. 2016;101:582–96
116. Miguntanna NP, Liu A, Egodawatta P, Goonetilleke A. Characterising nutrients wash-off for effective urban stormwater treatment design. J Environ Manag. 2013;120:61–7
117. Chow MF, Yusop Z, Abustan I. Relationship between sediment build-up characteristics and antecedent dry days on different urban road surfaces in Malaysia. Urban Water J. 2015;12:240–7