Working memory training in healthy young adults: Support for the null from a randomized comparison to active and passive control groups

PLoS ONE

Volumn 12, Issue 5, 2017, Pages

  Clark, Cameron M ^a   Lawlor Savage, Linette ^a   Goghari, Vina M ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; BAYES THEOREM; COGNITION; COMMUNITY SAMPLE; CONTROLLED STUDY; EXPECTATION; FEMALE; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; MALE; MENTAL PERFORMANCE; MOTIVATION; NORMAL HUMAN; NULL HYPOTHESIS; PERSONALITY; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; WORKING MEMORY; WORKING MEMORY TRAINING; YOUNG ADULT; COMPARATIVE STUDY; REACTION TIME; SHORT TERM MEMORY; TASK PERFORMANCE;

ADULT; COGNITION; FEMALE; HEALTHY VOLUNTEERS; HUMANS; MALE; MEMORY, SHORT-TERM; REACTION TIME; TASK PERFORMANCE AND ANALYSIS; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 85020021206     PISSN: None     EISSN: 19326203     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0177707     Document Type: Article

References (98)

1. Baddeley A. Working memory. Science 1992;255:556-9. pmid:1736359
2. Repovs G, Baddeley A. The multi-component model of working memory: Explorations in experimental cognitive psychology. Neuroscience 2006;139:5-121. pmid:16517088
3. Engle RW, Kane MJ, Tuholski SW. Individual differences in working memory capacity and what they tell us about controlled attention, general fluid intelligence and functions of the prefrontal cortex. In: Miyake A, Shah P, editors. Models of working memory: Mechanisms of active maintenance and executive control, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1999, p. 102-34.
4. Cowan N. The magical number 4 in short-term memory: A reconsideration of mental storage capacity. Behavioral and Brain Sciences Behav Brain Sci 2001;24:87-114 pmid:11515286
5. Engle RW, Tuholski SW, Laughlin JE, Conway ARA. Working memory, short-term memory, general fluid intelligence: A latent-variable approach. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 1999;128:309-31.
6. Jaeggi SM, Buschkuehl M, Shah P, Jonides J. The role of individual differences in cognitive training and transfer. Memory & Cognition 2014;42:464-80. pmid:24081919
7. Eriksson J, Vogel EK, Lansner A, Bergström F, Nyberg L Neurocognitive Architecture of Working Memory. Neuron 2015;88:33-46. pmid:26447571
8. Cattell RB. Theory of fluid and crystallized intelligence: A critical experiment. Journal of Educational Psychology 1963;54:1-22.
9. Carroll JB. A three-stratum theory of intelligence: Spearman's contribution. In: Dennis I, Tapsfield P, editors. Human abilities: Their nature and measurement, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1996, p. 1-18.
10. McGrew K. CHC theory and the human cognitive abilities project: Standing on the shoulders of the giants of psychometric intelligence research. Intelligence 2009;37:1-10.
11. Carpenter PA, Just MA, Shell P. What one intelligence test measures: A theoretical account of the processing in the Raven Progressive Matrices Test. Psychological Review 1990;97:404-31. pmid:2381998
12. Conway AR, Kane MJ, Engle RW. Working memory capacity and its relation to general intelligence. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2003;7:547-52. pmid: 14643371
13. Colom R, Rebollo I, Palacios A, Juan-Espinosa M, Kyllonen PC. Working memory is (almost) perfectly predicted by g. Intelligence 2004;32:277-96.
14. Burgess GC, Gray JR, Conway ARA, Braver TS. Neural mechanisms of interference control underlie the relationship between fluid intelligence and working memory span. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2011;140:674-92. pmid:21787103
15. Martínez K, Burgaleta M, Román FJ, Escorial S, Shih PC, Quiroga MÁ, et al. Can fluid intelligence be reduced to 'simple' short-term storage Intelligence 2011;39:473-80.
16. Chuderski A. When are fluid intelligence and working memory isomorphic and when are they not Intelligence 2013;41:244-62.
17. Neisser U, Boodoo G, Bouchard TJJ, Boykin AW, Brody N, Ceci SJ, et al. Intelligence: Knowns and unknowns. American Psychologist 1996;51:77-101.
18. Watkins MW, Lei P-W, Canivez GL Psychometric intelligence and achievement: A cross-lagged panel analysis. Intelligence 2007;35:59-68.
19. Schmidt FL, Hunter JE. The validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology: Practical and theoretical implications of 85 years of research findings. Psychological Bulletin 1998;124:262-74
20. Ceci SJ, Williams WM. Schooling, intelligence, income. American Psychologist 1997;52:1051-8.
21. Strenze T. Intelligence and socioeconomic success: A meta-analytic review of longitudinal research. Intelligence 2007;35:401-26.
22. Gottfredson LS, Deary IJ. Intelligence predicts health and longevity, but why Current Directions in Psychological Science 2004;13:1-4.
23. Gottfredson LS. Intelligence: Is It the epidemiologists' elusive "fundamental cause" of social class inequalities in health Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2004;86:174-99. pmid: 14717635
24. Whalley LJ. Longitudinal cohort study of childhood IQ and survival up to age 76. BMJ 2001;322:819. pmid:11290633
25. Otoole BI, Stankov L. Ultimate validity of psychological tests. Personality and Individual Differences 1992;13:699-716.
26. Sprenger AM, Atkins SM, Bolger DJ, Harbison JI, Novick JM, Chrabaszcz JS, et al. Training working memory: Limits of transfer. Intelligence 2013;41:638-63.
27. Halford G, Cowan N, Andrews G. Separating cognitive capacity from knowledge: A new hypothesis. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2007;11:236-42. pmid: 17475538
28. Jaeggi SM, Buschkuehl M, Jonides J, Perrig WJ. Improving fluid intelligence with training on working memory. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2008;105:6829-33. pmid:18443283
29. Chein JM, Morrison AB. Expanding the mind's workspace: Training and transfer effects with a complex working memory span task. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 2010;17:193-9. pmid:20382919
30. Schmiedek F, Lovden M, Lindenberger U. Hundred days of cognitive training enhance broad cognitive abilities in adulthood: Findings from the COGITO study. Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience 2010;2. pmid:20725526
31. Jaeggi SM, Buschkuehl M, Jonides J, Shah P. Short-A nd long-term benefits of cognitive training. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2011;108:10081-6. pmid:21670271
32. Jaeggi SM, Studer-Luethi B, Buschkuehl M, Su Y, Jonides J, Perrig WJ. The relationship between n-back performance and matrix reasoning-implications for training and transfer. Intelligence 2010;38:625-35.
33. Schweizer S, Grahn J, Hampshire A, Mobbs D, Dalgleish T. Training the emotional brain: Improving affective control through emotional working memory training. The Journal of Neuroscience 2013;33:5301-11. pmid:23516294
34. Buschkuehl M, Hernandez-Garcia L, Jaeggi SM, Bernard JA, Jonides J. Neural effects of short-term training on working memory. Cognitive, Affective, Behavioral Neuroscience 2014;14:147-60. pmid:24496717
35. Hardy JL, Nelson RA, Thomason ME, Sternberg DA, Katovich K, Farzin F, et al. Enhancing Cognitive Abilities with Comprehensive Training: A Large, Online, Randomized, Active-Controlled Trial. PLOS ONE 2015;10. pmid:26333022
36. Bastian CCV, Eschen A. Does working memory training have to be adaptive Psychological Research 2016;80:181-94 pmid:25716189
37. Colom R, Quiroga MÁ, Shih PC, Martínez K, Burgaleta M, Martínez-Molina A, et al. Improvement in working memory is not related to increased intelligence scores. Intelligence 2010;38:497-505.
38. Owen AM, Hampshire A, Grahn JA, Stenton R, Dajani S, Burns AS, et al. Putting brain training to the test. Nature 2010;465:775-8. pmid:20407435
39. Chooi W, Thompson LA. Working memory does not improve intelligence in healthy young adults. Intelligence 2012;40:531-42.
40. Redick TS, Shipstead Z, Harrison TL, Hicks KL, Fried DE, Hambrick DZ, et al. No evidence of intelligence improvement after working memory training: A randomized, placebo-controlled study. Journal of Experimental Psychology 2013;142:359-79. pmid:22708717
41. Thompson TW, Waskom ML, Garel KA, Cardenas-Iniguez C, Reynolds GO, Winter R, et al. Failure of working memory training to enhance cognition or intelligence. PLOS One 2013;8:e63614 pmid:23717453
42. Harrison TL, Shipstead Z, Hicks KL, Hambrick DZ, Redick TS, Engle RW. Working Memory Training May Increase Working Memory Capacity but Not Fluid Intelligence. Psychological Science 2013;24:2409-19. pmid:24091548
43. Bastian CCV, Oberauer K. Distinct transfer effects of training different facets of working memory capacity. Journal of Memory and Language 2013;69:36-58.
44. Colom R, Román FJ, Abad FJ, Shih PC, Privado J, Froufe M, et al. Adaptive n-back training does not improve fluid intelligence at the construct level: Gains on individual tests suggest that training may enhance visuospatial processing. Intelligence 2013;41:712-27.
45. Lawlor-Savage L, Goghari VM. Dual n-back working memory training in healthy adults: A randomized comparison to processing speed training. PLOS ONE 2016;11. pmid:27043141
46. Buschkuehl M, Jaeggi SM. Improving intelligence: A literature review. Swiss Medical Weekly 2010;140:266-72.
47. Conway ARA, Getz SJ. Cognitive ability: Does working memory training enhance intelligence Current Biology 2010;20:R362-R364 pmid:21749957
48. Takeuchi H, Taki Y, Kawashima R. Effects of working memory training on cognitive functions and neural systems. Reviews in the Neurosciences 2010;21:427-49. pmid:21438192
49. Morrison AB, Chein JM. Does working memory training work The promise and challenges of enhancing cognition by training working memory. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 2011;18:46-60. pmid:21327348
50. Shipstead Z, Redick TS, Engle RW. Is working memory training effective Psychological Bulletin 2012;138:1-27.
51. Bastian CCV, Oberauer K. Effects and mechanisms of working memory training: A review Psychological Research 2013;78:803-20. pmid:24213250
52. Redick TS, Shipstead Z, Wiemers EA, Melby-Lervåg M, Hulme C. What's Working in Working Memory Training An Educational Perspective. Educational Psychology Review Educ Psychol Rev 2015;27:617-33. pmid:26640352
53. Melby-Lervåg M, Redick TS, Hulme C. Working memory training does not improve performance on measures of intelligence or other measures of "far transfer": Evidence from a meta-analytic review. Perspectives on Psychological Science 2016;11:512-34 pmid:27474138
54. Melby-Lervåg M, Hulme C. Is working memory training effective A meta-analytic review. Developmental Psychology 2013;49:270-91. pmid:22612437
55. Au J, Sheehan E, Tsai N, Duncan GJ, Buschkuehl M, Jaeggi SM. Improving fluid intelligence with training on working memory: A meta-analysis. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review; 2014;22:366-77. pmid:25102926
56. Schwaighofer M, Fischer F, Bühner M. Does Working Memory Training Transfer A Meta-Analysis Including Training Conditions as Moderators. Educational Psychologist 2015;50:138-66.
57. Weicker J, Villringer A, Thöne-Otto A. Can impaired working memory functioning be improved by training A meta-analysis with a special focus on brain injured patients. Neuropsychology 2016;30:190-212. pmid:26237626
58. Melby-Lervåg M, Hulme C. There is no convincing evidence that working memory training is effective: A reply to Au et al. (2014) and Karbach and Verhaeghen (2014). Psychonomic Bulletin & Review Psychon Bull Rev 2015.
59. Au J, Buschkuehl M, Duncan GJ, Jaeggi SM. There is no convincing evidence that working memory training is NOT effective: A reply to Melby-Lervåg and Hulme (2015). Psychonomic Bulletin & Review Psychon Bull Rev 2015. pmid:26518308
60. Urbánek T, Marek V. Investigating the effectiveness of working memory training in the context of Personality Systems Interaction theory. Psychological Research 2016;80:877-88. pmid:26208631
61. Sternberg RJ. Increasing fluid intelligence is possible after all. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2008;105:6791-2. pmid:18474863
62. Simmons JP, Nelson LD, Simonsohn U. False-positive psychology: Undisclosed flexibility in data collection and Analysis Allows presenting anything as significant. Psychological Science 2011;22:1359-66. pmid:22006061
63. Redick TS. Working memory training and interpreting interactions in intelligence intentions. Intelligence 2015;50:14-20.
64. Karbach J, Verhaeghen P. Making working memory work: A meta-analysis of executive-control and working memory training in older adults. Psychological Science 2014;25:2027-37. pmid:25298292
65. Wagenmakers E-J. A quartet of interactions. Cortex 2015;73:334-5. pmid:26323655
66. Takeuchi H, Kawashima R. Effects of processing speed training on cognitive fucntions and neural systems. Reviews in the Neurosciences 2012;23:289-301. pmid:22752786
67. Takeuchi H, Taki Y, Hashizume H, Sassa Y, Nagase T, Nouchi R, et al. Effects of training of processing speed on neural systems. Journal of Neuroscience 2011;31:12139-48. pmid:21865456
68. Lumos Labs Inc. Retrieved February, 2013 from www.lumosity.com
69. Wechsler D. Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Fourth Edition: Technical and interpretive manual. San Antonio, TX Pearson Assessment 2008
70. Raven JC. Advanced progressive matrices sets I and II: Plan and use of the scale with a report of experimental work. London: H.K. Lewis & Co. Ltd; 1975.
71. Raven JC, Raven J, Court JH. Advanced progressive matrices: Sets I & II: Background. Oxford: Oxford Psychologists Press; 1994
72. Cattell RB, Cattell AKS. Handbook for the culture fair intelligence test: A measure of "g", scale 3, forms A and B. Champaign, IL: Institute for Personality and Ability Testing 1959
73. Cattell RB, Cattell AKS. Measuring intelligence with the culture fair tests. Champaign, IL: Institute for Personality and Ability Testing 1973.
74. Unsworth N, Heitz RP, Schrock JC, Engle RW. An automated version of the operation span task. Behavior Research Methods 2005;37:498-505. pmid: 16405146
75. Glahn D, Kim J, Cohen M, Poutanen V-P, Therman S, Bava S, et al. Maintenance and manipulation in spatial working memory: Dissociations in the prefrontal cortex. NeuroImage 2002;17:201-13. pmid:12482077
76. Colom R, Garcia-Lopez O. Secular gains in fluid intelligence: Evidence from the Culture-Fair Intelligence Test. Journal of Biosocial Science 2003;35:33-9. pmid: 12537154
77. Ashton M, Lee K. The HEXACO-60: A short measure of the major dimensions of personality. Journal of Personality Assessment 2009;91:340-5. pmid:20017063
78. Cacioppo JT, Petty RE, Kao CF. The efficient assessment of Need for Cognition. Journal of Personality Assessment 1984;48:306-7. pmid:16367530
79. Duckworth AL, Quinn P. Development and validation of the short Grit Scale (Grit-S). Journal of Personality Assessment 2009;91:166-74 pmid:19205937
80. Eskes GA, Longman S, Brown AD, McMorris CA, Langdon KD, Hogan DB, et al. Contribution of physical fitness, cerebrovascular reserve and cognitive stimulation to cognitive function in post-menopausal women. Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience 2010;2:1-7.
81. Foroughi CK, Monfort SS, Paczynski M, Mcknight PE, Greenwood PM. Placebo effects in cognitive training. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2016;113:7470-4. pmid:27325761
82. Boot WR, Simons DJ, Stothart C, Stutts C. The pervasive problem with placebos in psychology: Why active control groups are not sufficient to rule out placebo effects. Perspectives on Psychological Science 2013;8:445-54 pmid:26173122
83. Love JP, Selker R, Verhagen AJ, Marsman M, Gronau QF, Jamil T, et al. APS Observer. APS Observer 2015;28.
84. JASP Team. JASP (version 0.8.0.0) [computer software] 2016. Retrieved from https://jasp-stats.org/
85. Masson MEJ. A tutorial on a practical Bayesian alternative to null-hypothesis significance testing. Behavior Research Methods 2011 ;43:679-90. pmid:21302025
86. Jarosz AF, Wiley J. What are the odds A practical guide to computing and reporting Bayes factors. The Journal of Problem Solving 2014;7.
87. Rouder JN, Morey RD, Verhagen J, Swagman AR, Wagenmakers E-J. Bayesian analysis of factorial designs. Psychological Methods 2016. pmid:27280448
88. Jeffreys H. Theory of probability. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1961.
89. Raftery AE. Bayesian model selection in social research. In: Marsden PV, editor. Sociological methodology 1995, Cambridge, MA: Blackwell; 1995.
90. Salthouse TA, Tucker-Drob EM. Implications of short-term retest effects for the interpretation of longitudinal change. Neuropsychology 2008;22:800-11. pmid: 18999354
91. Straus SE, Glasziou P, Richardson WS, Haynes RB. Evidence-based medicine: How to practice and teach it. Edinburgh: Elsevier Churchill Livingstone; 2011.
92. Double KS, Birney DP. The effects of personality and metacognitive beliefs on cognitive training adherence and performance. Personality and Individual Differences 2016;102:7-12.
93. Button KS, Ioannidis JPA, Mokrysz C, Nosek BA, Flint J, Robinson ESJ, et al. Power failure: Why small sample size undermines the reliability of neuroscience. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2013;14:365-76. pmid:23571845
94. Bogg T, Lasecki L. Reliable gains Evidence for substantially underpowered designs in studies of working memory training transfer to fluid intelligence. Frontiers in Psychology Front Psychol 2015;5. pmid:25657629
95. Moreau D, Kirk IJ, Waldie KE. Seven pervasive statistical flaws in cognitive training interventions. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience Front Hum Neurosci 2016;10. pmid:27148010
96. Bastian CCV, Locher A, Ruflin M. Tatool: A Java-based open-source programming framework for psychological studies. Behavior Research Methods 2012;45:108-15. pmid:22723043
97. McCabe JA, Redick TS, Engle RW. Brain-training pessimism, but applied-memory optimism. Psychological Science in the Public Interest 2016;17:187-91. pmid:27697852
98. Ansari S. The therapeutic potential of working memory training for treating mental disorders. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience Front Hum Neurosci 2015;9. pmid:26388759