Diagnostic Issues and Controversies in DSM-5: Return of the False Positives Problem

Annual Review of Clinical Psychology

Volumn 12, Issue , 2016, Pages 105-132

  Wakefield, Jerome C ^a,b  

^a NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b NEW YORK UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

Diagnosis; False positives; Harmful dysfunction; Mental disorder; Validity

Indexed keywords

DIAGNOSIS; DSM-5; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; CLASSIFICATION; DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS; HUMAN; MENTAL DISORDERS;

DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS; HUMANS; MENTAL DISORDERS;

EID: 84962162073     PISSN: 15485943     EISSN: 15485951     Source Type: Book Series    
DOI: 10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-032814-112800     Document Type: Article

References (118)

1. Abramowitz JS, Jacoby RJ. 2014. Obsessive-compulsive disorder in the DSM-5. Clin. Psychol. Sci. Pract. 21:221-35
2. Accad M, Fred HL. 2010. Risk-factor medicine: an industry out of control? Cardiology 117:64-67
3. Am. Psychiatr. Assoc. 1980. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Washington, DC: Am. Psychiatr. Publ. 3rd ed.
4. Am. Psychiatr. Assoc. 1994. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Washington, DC: Am. Psychiatr. Publ. 4th ed.
5. Am. Psychiatr. Assoc. 2013. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Washington, DC: Am. Psychiatr. Publ. 5th ed.
6. Axelson D, Findling RL, Fristad MA, Kowatch RA, Youngstrom EA, et al. 2012. Examining the proposed disruptive mood dysregulation disorder diagnosis in children in the Longitudinal Assessment of Manic Symptoms Study. J. Clin. Psychiatry 73(10):1342-50
7. Biederman J, Petty CR, Evans M, Small J, Faraone SV. 2010. How persistent is ADHD? A controlled 10-year follow-up study of boys with ADHD. Psychiatry Res. 177(3):299-304
8. Coccaro EF. 2011. Intermittent explosive disorder: development of integrated research criteria for Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition. Compr. Psychiatry 5:119-25
9. Coccaro EF, Kavoussi RJ, BermanME, Lish JD. 1998. Intermittent explosive disorder-revised: development, reliability, and validity of research criteria. Compr. Psychiatry 39:368-76
10. Coccaro EF, Schmidt C, Samuels J, Nestadt G. 2004. Lifetime and 1-month prevalence rates of intermittent explosive disorder in a community sample. J. Clin. Psychiatry 65:820-24
11. Ding YC, Chi HC, Grady DL, Morishima A, Kidd JR, et al. 2002. Evidence of positive selection acting at the human dopamine receptor D4 gene locus. PNAS 99:309-14
12. Dunner DL. 1993. A review of the diagnostic status of "bipolar II" for the DSM-IV work group on mood disorders. Depression 1:2-10
13. Eisenberg DTA, Campbell B, Gray PB, Sorenson MD. 2008. Dopamine receptor genetic polymorphisms and body composition in undernourished pastoralists: an exploration of nutrition indices among nomadic and recently settled Ariaal men of northern Kenya. BMC Evol. Biol. 8:173. http://bmcevolbiol. biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1471-2148-8-173
14. Elder TE. 2010. The importance of relative standards in ADHD diagnoses: evidence based on exact birth dates. J. Health Econ. 29:641-56
15. Evans WN, Morrill MS, Parente ST. 2010. Measuring inappropriate medical diagnosis and treatment in survey data: The case of ADHD among school-age children. J. Health Econ. 29:657-73
16. First MB, Wakefield JC. 2013. Diagnostic criteria as dysfunction indicators: bridging the chasm between the definition of mental disorder and diagnostic criteria for specific disorders. Can. J. Psychiatry 58(12):663-69
17. First MB, Wakefield JC. 2010. Defining "mental disorder" in DSM-V. Psychol. Med. 40(11):1779-82
18. Frances A. 1998. Problems in defining clinical significance in epidemiological studies. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 55(2):119
19. Frances A. 2009. A warning sign on the road to DSM-V: beware of its unintended consequences. Psychiatr. Times, June 26. http://www.psychiatrictimes.com/articles/warning-sign-road-dsm-v-beware-itsunintended-consequences
20. Frances AJ. 2010. DSM5 should not expand bipolar II disorder. Psychology Today, Apr. 23. https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/dsm5-in-distress/201004/dsm5-should-not-expand-bipolar-iidisorder
21. Frances A. 2011. Should temper tantrums be made into a DSM-5 diagnosis? Psychiatr. Times, Oct. 13. http://www.psychiatrictimes.com/blog/couchincrisis/content/article/10168/1970399
22. Frances A. 2012. DSM-5 is a guide, not a bible: Simply ignore its 10 worst changes. Huffington Post, Dec. 3. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/allen-frances/dsm-5-b-2227626.html
23. Frances A. 2013. The new somatic symptom disorder in DSM-5 risks mislabeling many people as mentally ill. BMJ 346:f1580
24. Frances A, Jones KD. 2012. Bipolar disorder type II revisited. Bipolar Disord. 14:474-77
25. Fusar-Poli P, Van Os J. 2013. Lost in transition: setting the psychosis threshold in prodromal research. Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 127:248-52
26. Garvey M, Heinssein R, Pine DS, Quinn K, Sanislow C, Wang P. 2010. Research Domain Criteria (RDoC); toward a new classification framework for research on mental disorders. Am. J. Psychiatry 167:748-51
27. Gaudiano BA, Zimmerman M. 2013. Prevalence of attenuated psychotic symptoms and their relationship with DSM-IV diagnoses in a general psychiatric outpatient clinic. J. Clin. Psychiatry 74(2):149-55
28. Ghaemi N. 2010. DSM-5 and bipolar disorder: science versus politics. Psychology Today, Apr. 24. https://www. psychologytoday.com/blog/mood-swings/201004/dsm-5-and-bipolar-disorder-science-versuspolitics
29. Grossman R. 2008. Psychiatric manual's update needs openness, not secrecy, critics say: Edition is being prepared with strict oversight, officials counter. Chicago Tribune,Dec. 27. http://articles.chicagotribune. com/2008-12-27/news/0812260126-1-secrecy-dsm-manual
30. Hasin DS, O'Brien CP, Auriacombe M, Borges G, Bucholz K, et al. 2013. DSM-5 criteria for substance use disorders: recommendations and rationale. Am. J. Psychiatry 170(8):834-51
31. Hill JC, SchoenerEP. 1996. Age-dependent decline of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Am. J. Psychiatry 153(9):1143-46
32. Hinshaw SP, Scheffler RM. 2014. The ADHD Explosion. New York: Oxford
33. Hoge CW, Riviere LA, Wilk JE, Herrell RK, Weathers FW. 2014. The prevalence of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in US combat soldiers: A head-to-head comparison of DSM-5 versus DSM-IV-TR symptom criteria with the PTSD checklist. Lancet Psychiatry 1(4):269-77
34. Kendler KS. 2013. A history of the DSM-5 Scientific Review Committee. Psychol. Med. 43:1793-800
35. Kendler KS, Appelbaum PS, Bell CC, Fulford KWM, Ghaemi SN, et al. 2008. Issues for DSM-V: DSM-V should include a conceptual issues work group. Am. J. Psychiatry 165:174-75
36. Kendler KS, Gardner CO. 1998. Boundaries of major depression: an evaluation of DSM-IV criteria. Am. J. Psychiatry 155:172-77
37. Kessler RC, Coccaro EF, Fava M, Jaeger S, Jin R,Walters E. 2006. The prevalence and correlates of DSM-IV intermittent explosive disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 63:669-78
38. Kessler RC, Merikangas KR, Berglund P, Eaton WW, Koretz DS,Walters EE. 2003. Mild disorders should not be eliminated from the DSM-V. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 60:1117-22
39. Kessler RC, Merikangas KR, Berglund P, Eaton WW, Koretz DS, Walters EE. 2004. In reply. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 61:1051-52
40. Kessler RC, Rubinow D, Holmes C, Aberson J, Zhao S. 1997a. The epidemiology of DSM-III-R bipolar I disorder in a general population survey. Psychol. Med. 27:1079-89
41. Kessler RC, Zhao S, Blazer DG, Swartz M. 1997b. Prevalence, correlates, and course of minor depression and major depression in the National Comorbidity Survey. J. Affect. Disord. 45(1-2):19-30
42. Klein RG,Mannuzza S, Olazagasti MAR, Roizen E,Hutchison JA, et al. 2012. Clinical and functional outcome of childhood attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder 33 years later. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 69(12):1295-303
43. Lord C, Bishop SL. 2015. Recent advances in autism research as reflected in DSM-5 criteria for autism spectrum disorder. Annu. Rev. Clin. Psychol. 11:53-70
44. MajM. 2013. "Clinical judgment" and theDSM-5 diagnosis ofmajor depression. World Psychiatry 12(2):89-91
45. Mannuzza S, Klein RG. 2000. Long-term prognosis in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry Clin. North Am. 9(3):711-26
46. Mataix-Cols D, Billotti D, Fernandez de laCruz L,Nordsletten AE. 2013. The London field trial for hoarding disorder. Psychol. Med. 43:837-47
47. McLaughlin KA, Green JG, Hwang I, Sampson NA, Zaslavsky AM, Kessler RC. 2012. Intermittent explosive disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication Adolescent Supplement. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 69(11):1131-39
48. McPartland JC, Reichow B, Volkmar FR. 2012. Sensitivity and specificity of proposed DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for autism spectrum disorder. J. Am. Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 51(4):368-83
49. Mechanic D. 2003. Is the prevalence of mental disorders a good measure of the need for services? Health Aff. 22:8-20
50. Moffitt TE, Caspi A, Taylor A, Kokaua J, Milne B, et al. 2010. How common are common mental disorders? Evidence that lifetime prevalence rates are doubled by prospective versus retrospective ascertainment. Psychol. Med. 40(6):899-909
51. Moffitt TE, Houts R, Asherson P, Belsky DW, Corcoran DL, et al. 2015. Is adult ADHD a childhood-onset neurodevelopmental disorder? Evidence from a four-decade longitudinal cohort study. Am. J. Psychiatry 172(10):967-77
52. Mojtabai R. 2011. Bereavement-related depressive episodes: characteristics, 3-year course, and implications for DSM-5. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 68:920-28
53. Moreno C, Laje G, Blanco C, Jiang H, Schmidt AB, Olfson M. 2007. National trends in the outpatient diagnosis and treatment of bipolar disorder in youth. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 64:1032-39
54. Narrow WE, Kuhl EA, Regier DA. 2009. DSM-V perspectives on disentangling disability from clinical significance. World Psychiatry 8(2):88-89
55. NarrowWE, Rae DS, Robins LN, Regier DA. 2002. Revised prevalence estimates of mental disorders in the United States: using a clinical significance criterion to reconcile 2 surveys' estimates. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 59:115-23
56. Nusslock R, Frank E. 2011. Subthreshold bipolarity: diagnostic issues and challenges. Bipolar Disord. 13(7-8):587-603
57. Parkes C. 1964. Recent bereavement as a cause of mental illness. Br. J. Psychiatry 110:198-204
58. Pratt LA, Brody DJ, Gu Q. 2011. Antidepressant use in persons aged 12 and over: United States, 2005-2008. NCHS Data Brief No. 76. Hyattsville, MD: Natl. Cent. Health Stat.
59. Prigerson HG, Horowitz MJ, Jacobs SC, Parkes CM, Aslan M, et al. 2009. Prolonged grief disorder: psychometric validation of criteria proposed for DSM-V and ICD-11. PLOS Med. 6:e1000121
60. Regier DA. 2003. Mental disorder diagnostic theory and practical reality: an evolutionary perspective. Health Aff. 22:21-27
61. Regier DA, Kaelber CT, Rae DS, Farmer ME, Knauper B, et al. 1998. Limitations of diagnostic criteria and assessment instruments for mental disorders: implications for research and policy. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 55:109-15
62. Regier DA, NarrowWE, Kuhl EA, Kupfer DJ. 2009. The conceptual development ofDSM-5. Am. J. Psychiatry 166(6):645-50
63. Regier DA, NarrowWE, RaeDS. 2004. ForDSM-V, it's the "disorder threshold," stupid. Arch.Gen. Psychiatry 61:1051
64. Rohde P,Lewinsohn PM, KleinDN,Seeley JR,Gau JM. 2013. Key characteristics of major depressive disorder occurring in childhood, adolescence, emerging adulthood, and adulthood. Clin. Psychol. Sci. 1(1):41-53
65. Ruggero CJ, Zimmerman M, Chelminski I, Young D. 2010. Borderline personality disorder and the misdiagnosis of bipolar disorder. J. Psychiatr. Res. 44(6):405-8
66. Schatzberg AF, Scully JH, Kupfer DJ, Regier DA. 2009. Setting the record straight: A response to Frances commentary on DSM-V. Psychiatr. Times, July 1. http://www.psychiatrictimes.com/dsm/content/article/10168/1425806
67. Schneider ME. 2009. DSM-V Task Force weighing changes. Clin. Psychiatry News 3:1-4
68. Schwartz PH. 2008. Risk and disease. Perspect. Biol. Med. 51:320-34
69. Shaw P, Eckstrand K, Sharp W, Blumenthal J, Lerch JP, et al. 2007. Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder is characterized by a delay in cortical maturation. PNAS 104:19649-54
70. Shaw P,MalekM,Watson B,GreensteinD, de Rossi P, Sharp W. 2013. Trajectories of cerebral cortical development in childhood and adolescence and adult attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Biol. Psychiatry 74:599-606
71. Shear MK, Simon N, Wall M, Zisook S, Neimeyer R, et al. 2011. Complicated grief and related bereavement issues for DSM-5. Depress. Anxiety 28:103-17
72. Simon AE, Riecher-Rössler A, Lang UE, Borgwardt S. 2013. The attenuated psychosis syndrome in DSM-5. Schizophr. Res. 151:295
73. Spitzer RL. 2008. DSM-V: open and transparent? Psychiatr. News 43(14):26
74. Spitzer RL. 2009a. DSM-V transparency: fact or rhetoric? Psychiatr. Times, March 6. http://www. psychiatrictimes.com/articles/dsm-v-transparency-fact-or-rhetoric
75. Spitzer RL. 2009b. APA andDSM-V: empty promises. Psychiatr. Times, July 2. http://www.psychiatrictimes.com/articles/apa-and-dsm-v-empty-promises
76. Spitzer RL, Wakefield JC. 1999. DSM-IV diagnostic criterion for clinical significance: Does it help solve the false positives problem? Am. J. Psychiatry 156:1856-64
77. Sripada CS, Kessler D, Angstadt M. 2014. Lag in maturation of the brain's intrinsic functional architecture in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. PNAS 111(39):14259-64
78. Stotland N. 2009. Here's a secret: The DSM process isn't. Psychiatr. News, Feb. 6. http://psychnews. psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/pn.44.3.0003
79. Ustun B, Kennedy C. 2009. What is "functional impairment"? Disentangling disability from clinical significance. World Psychiatry 8:82-85
80. Visser SN, Danielson ML, Bitsko RH, Holbrook JR, Kogan MD, et al. 2014. Trends in the parent-report of health care provider-diagnosed and medicated attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: United States, 2003-2011. J. Am. Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 53(1):34-46.e2
81. Wakefield JC. 1992a. The concept of mental disorder: on the boundary between biological facts and social values. Am. Psychol. 47:373-88
82. Wakefield JC. 1992b. Disorder as harmful dysfunction: A conceptual critique of DSM-III-R's definition of mental disorder. Psychol. Rev. 99:232-47
83. Wakefield JC. 1993. Limits of operationalization: A critique of Spitzer and Endicott's 1978 proposed operational criteria for mental disorder. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 102:160-72
84. Wakefield JC. 1996. DSM-IV: Are we making diagnostic progress? Contemp. Psychol. 41:646-52
85. Wakefield JC. 1997a. Diagnosing DSM-IV, part 1: DSM-IV and the concept of mental disorder. Behav. Res. Ther. 35:633-50
86. Wakefield JC. 1997b. Diagnosing DSM-IV, part 2: Eysenck 1986 and the essentialist fallacy. Behav. Res. Ther. 35:651-66
87. Wakefield JC. 1999a. Evolutionary versus prototype analyses of the concept of disorder. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 108:374-99
88. Wakefield JC. 1999b. Disorder as a black box essentialist concept. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 108:465-72
89. Wakefield JC. 2006. The concept of mental disorder: Diagnostic implications of the harmful dysfunction analysis. World Psychiatry 6:149-56
90. Wakefield JC. 2009. Disability and diagnosis: Should role impairment be eliminated from DSM/ICD diagnostic criteria? World Psychiatry 8:87-88
91. Wakefield JC. 2010. False positives in psychiatric diagnosis: implications for human freedom. Theor. Med. Bioeth. 31(1):5-17
92. Wakefield JC. 2012. Should prolonged grief be reclassified as a mental disorder in DSM-5? Reconsidering the empirical and conceptual arguments for proposed grief disorders. J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. 200:499-511
93. Wakefield JC. 2013a.The DSM-5 debate over the bereavement exclusion: psychiatric diagnosis and the future of empirically supported practice. Clin. Psychol. Rev. 33:825-45
94. Wakefield JC. 2013b. DSM-5 and clinical social work: mental disorder and psychological justice as goals of clinical intervention. Clin. Soc. Work J. 41(2):131-38
95. Wakefield JC. 2013c.DSM-5 and the general definition of personality disorder. Clin. Soc.Work J. 41(2):168-83
96. Wakefield JC. 2014. Wittgenstein's nightmare: why the RDoC grid needs a conceptual dimension. World Psychiatry 13(1):38-40
97. Wakefield JC. 2015a. Psychological justice: DSM-5, false positive diagnosis, and fair equality of opportunity. Public Aff. Q. 29(1):32-75
98. Wakefield JC. 2015b. DSM-5 substance use disorder: how conceptual missteps weakened the foundations of the addictive disorders field. Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 132(5):327-34
99. Wakefield JC, First MB. 2012a. Placing symptoms in context: The role of contextual criteria in reducing false positives in DSM diagnosis. Compr. Psychiatry 53:130-39
100. Wakefield JC, First MB. 2012b. Does the empirical evidence support the proposal to eliminate the major depression "bereavement exclusion" in DSM-5? World Psychiatry 11:3-10
101. Wakefield JC, First MB. 2013a. Clarifying the boundary between normality and disorder: A fundamental conceptual challenge for psychiatry. Can. J. Psychiatry 58(11):603-5
102. Wakefield JC, First MB. 2013b. Diagnostic validity and the definition of mental disorder: A program for conceptually advancing psychiatry. Can. J. Psychiatry 58(12):653-55
103. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2012. Recurrence of bereavement-related depression: evidence for the validity of the DSM-IV bereavement exclusion from the Epidemiologic Catchment Area Study. J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. 200:480-85
104. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2013a. Normal versus disordered bereavement-related depression: Are the differences real or tautological? Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 127:159-68
105. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2013b. Can the DSM's major depression bereavement exclusion be validly extended to other stressors? Evidence from the NCS. Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 128:294-305
106. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2013c. When does depression become a disorder? Using recurrence rates to evaluate the validity of proposed changes in major depression diagnostic thresholds. World Psychiatry 12:44-52
107. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2014a. Predictive validation of single-episode uncomplicated depression as a benign subtype of unipolar major depression. Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 129:445-57
108. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2014b.Uncomplicated depression, suicide attempt, and the DSM-5 bereavementexclusion debate: an empirical evaluation. Res. Soc. Work Pract. 24(1):37-49
109. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2014c.How many people have alcohol use disorders? Using the harmful dysfunction analysis to reconcile prevalence estimates in two community surveys. Front. Psychiatry 5:10
110. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF. 2015. The harmful dysfunction model of alcohol use disorder: revised criteria to improve the validity of diagnosis and prevalence estimates. Addiction 110(6):931-42
111. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF, Baer JC. 2010. Does the DSM-IV clinical significance criterion for major depression reduce false positives? Evidence from the NCS-R. Am. J. Psychiatry 167:298-304
112. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF, First MB, Horwitz AV. 2007. Should the bereavement exclusion for major depression be extended to other losses? Evidence from the National Comorbidity Survey. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 64:433-40
113. Wakefield JC, Spitzer RL. 2002. Lowered estimates-but of what? Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 59:129-30
114. Woods SW, Addington J, Cadenhead KS, Cannon TD, Cornblatt BA, et al. 2009. Validity of the prodromal risk syndrome for first psychosis: findings from the North American Prodrome Longitudinal Study. Schizophr. Bull. 35(5):894-908
115. WHO(World Health Organ.). 2004. International Statistical Classification ofDiseases and RelatedHealth Problems. Geneva:WHO. 10th rev., 2nd ed.
116. Zimmerman M, Chelminski I, Young D. 2004. On the threshold of disorder: A study of the impact of the DSM-IV clinical significance criterion on diagnosing depressive and anxiety disorders in clinical practice. J. Clin. Psychiatry 65(10):1400-5
117. Zimmerman M, Ruggero CJ, Chelminski I, Young D. 2008. Is bipolar disorder overdiagnosed? J. Clin. Psychiatry 69(6):935-40
118. ZoëgaH, Valdimarsdóttir UA, Hernández-Díaz S. 2012. Age, academic performance, and stimulant prescribing for ADHD: A nationwide cohort study. Pediatrics 130:1012-18