The DSM-5 debate over the bereavement exclusion: Psychiatric diagnosis and the future of empirically supported treatment

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 33, Issue 7, 2013, Pages 825-845

  Wakefield, Jerome C ^a  

^a NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Bereavement exclusion; Depression; DSM 5; Empirical supported treatment; Harmful dysfunction; Validity of diagnosis

Indexed keywords

ANXIETY DISORDER; BEREAVEMENT; CONCURRENT VALIDITY; CONSTRUCT VALIDITY; DSM-5; DSM-III-R; DSM-IV; FOLLOW UP; HUMAN; MAJOR DEPRESSION; MENTAL HEALTH; PREDICTIVE VALIDITY; PSYCHIATRIC DIAGNOSIS; REVIEW; SOCIAL ADAPTATION; SOCIAL INTERACTION; SUBSTANCE ABUSE;

BEREAVEMENT EXCLUSION; DEPRESSION; DSM-5; EMPIRICAL SUPPORTED TREATMENT; HARMFUL DYSFUNCTION; VALIDITY OF DIAGNOSIS;

BEREAVEMENT; DEPRESSIVE DISORDER, MAJOR; DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS; EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE; HUMANS; MENTAL DISORDERS;

EID: 84883169958     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: 18737811     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2013.03.007     Document Type: Review

References (112)

1. Ajdacic-Gross V., Ring M., Gadola E., Lauber C., Bopp M., Gutzwiller F., et al. Suicide after bereavement: An overlooked problem. Psychological Medicine 2008, 38:673-676.
2. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 1980, American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DC. 3rd ed.
3. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: DSM-IV-TR 2000, American Psychiatric Association, Washington. 4th ed.
4. Andrews P.W., Thomson J.A. The bright side of being blue: Depression as an adaptation for analyzing complex problems. Psychological Review 2009, 116(3):620-654.
5. Angermeyer M.C., Matschinger H. Causal beliefs and attitudes to people with schizophrenia: Trend analysis based on data from two population surveys in Germany. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2005, 186:331-334.
6. Bayer R. Homosexuality and American psychiatry: The politics of diagnosis 1981, Basic Books, New York.
7. Bockting C.L., Schene A.H., Spinhoven P., Koeter M.W.J., Wouters L.F., Huyser J., et al. Preventing relapse/recurrence in recurrent depression with cognitive therapy: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2005, 73(4):647-657.
8. Burcusa S.L., Iacono W.G. Risk for recurrence in depression. Clinical Psychology Review 2007, 27:959-985.
9. Clayton P., Desmarais L., Winokur G. A study of normal bereavement. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1968, 125:168-178.
10. Colman I., Naicker K., Zeng Y., Ataullahjan A., Senthilselvan A., Patten S.B. Predictors of long-term prognosis of depression. Canadian Medical Association Journal 2011, 183:1969-1976.
11. Coryell W., Endicott J., Keller M.B. Predictors of relapse into major depressive disorder in a nonclinical population. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1991, 148:1353-1358.
12. Cross-Disorder Group of the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium Identification of risk loci with shared effects on five major psychiatric disorders: A genome-wide analysis 2013, Published online February 28, 2013. 10.1016/S0140-6736(12)62129-1.
13. Editorial Living with grief. Lancet 2012, 379:589.
14. Fawcett J. An overview of mood disorders in the DSM-5. Current Psychiatry Report 2010, 12:531-538.
15. Fawcett J. DSM-5: A 'living document' that may impact practice, patients health. Psychiatric Annals 2012, December 21, (Accessed January 17, 2013 at http://www.healio.com/psychiatry/practice-management/news/online/%7B48A37EECE45848A7-8A02-A932D35FD4EA%7D/DSM-5-a-living-document-that-may-impactpractice-patients-health).
16. Foucault M. Madness and civilization: A history of insanity in the Age of Reason (R. Howard, Trans.) 1965, Pantheon, New York, (Original work published 1964).
17. Frances A. DSM-5 suggests opening the door to behavioral addictions: Behavioral addictions are a slippery slope. Psychology Today 2010, (Blog accessed 3/23/13 at http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/dsm5-in-distress/201003/dsm5-suggests-opening-the-door-behavioral-addictions).
18. Frances A. DSM-5 is a guide, not a Bible: Simply ignore its 10 worst changes Accessed 12/03/2012 at:, (2012). http://www.huffingtonpost.com/allen-frances/dsm-5_b_2227626.html.
19. Frances A.J., Widiger T. Psychiatric diagnosis: Lessons from the DSM-IV past and cautions for the DSM-5 future. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 2012, 8:109-130.
20. Frank E., Prien R.F., Jarrett R.B., Keller M.B., Kupfer D.J., Lavori P.W., et al. Conceptualization and rationale for consensus definitions of terms in major depressive disorder: Remission, recovery, relapse, and recurrence. Archives of General Psychiatry 1991, 48:851-855.
21. Friedman R.A. Grief, depression, and the DSM-5. The New England Journal of Medicine 2012, 366:1855-1857.
22. Geddes J.R., Carney S.M., Davies C., Furukawa T.A., Kupfer D.J., Frank E., et al. Relapse prevention with antidepressant drug treatment in depressive disorders: A systematic review. Lancet 2003, 361:653-661.
23. Gilman S.E., Breslau J., Trinh N.H., Fava M., Murphy J.M., Smoller J.W. Bereavement and the diagnosis of major depressive episode in the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 2012, 73:208-215.
24. Greenberg G. Inside the battle to define mental illness. Wired 2011, (January 2010).
25. Hensley P.L., Slonimski C.K., Uhlenhuth E.H., Claton P.J. Escitalopram: An open label study of bereavement-related depression and grief. Journal of Affective Disorders 2009, 113(1-2):142-149.
26. Horwitz A.V., Wakefield J.C. The loss of sadness: How psychiatry transformed normal sorrow into depressive disorder 2007, Oxford University Press, New York.
27. Horwitz A.V., Wakefield J.C. All we have to fear: Psychiatry's transformation of natural anxieties into mental disorders 2012, Oxford University Press, New York.
28. Hyman S.E. The diagnosis of mental disorders: The problem of reification. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 2010, 6:155-179.
29. Jones K.D., Gill C., Ray S. Review of the proposed DSM-5 substance use disorder. Journal of Addictions & Offender Counseling 2012, 33(2):115-123.
30. Kendell R.E. The classification of depressions: A review of contemporary confusion. The British Journal of Psychiatry 1976, 129:15-28.
31. Kendler K.S. Towards a scientific psychiatric nosology: Strengths and limitations. Archives of General Psychiatry 1990, 47:969-973.
32. Kendler K.S. Major depression and generalised anxiety disorder. Same genes, (partly) different environments-revisited. The British Journal of Psychiatry. Supplement 1996, 30:68-75.
33. Kendler K.S. Statement on the proposal to eliminate the grief exclusion criterion from major depression Accessed October 16, 2010 at:. http://www.dsm5.org/about/Documents/grief%20exclusion_Kendler.pdf.
34. Kendler K.S. Levels of explanation in psychiatric and substance use disorders: Implications for the development of an etiologically based nosology. Molecular Psychiatry 2012, 17:11-21.
35. Kendler K.S., Appelbaum P.S., Bell C.C., Fulford K.W.M., Ghaemi S.N., Schaffner K.F., et al. Issues for DSM-V: DSM-V should include a conceptual issues work group. The American Journal of Psychiatry 2008, 165(2):174-175.
36. Kendler K.S., Myers J., Halberstadt L.J. Should the diagnosis of major depression be made independent of or dependent upon the psychosocial context?. Psychological Medicine 2010, 40(5):771-780.
37. Kendler K.S., Myers J., Zisook S. Does bereavement related major depression differ from major depression associated with other stressful life events?. The American Journal of Psychiatry 2008, 165:1449-1455.
38. Kendler K.S., Neale M.C., Kessler R.C., Heath A.C., Eaves L.J. Major depression and generalized anxiety disorder. Same genes, (partly) different environments?. Archives of General Psychiatry 1992, 49(9):716-722.
39. Kendler K., Zachar P., Craver C.F. What kinds of things are psychiatric disorders?. Psychological Medicine 2010, 41:1143-1150.
40. Kendler K.S., Zisook S. Drs. Kendler and Zisook reply (Letter). The American Journal of Psychiatry 2009, 166:491-492.
41. Klein D.F. Anxiety reconceptualized: Gleaning from pharmacological dissection-Early experience with imipramine and anxiety. Modern Problems of Pharmacopsychiatry 1987, 22:1-35.
42. Klein D.F., Fink M. Psychiatric reaction patterns to imipramine. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1962, 119:432-438.
43. Kramer P.D. Unreliable narrative: The aesthetics of depression Accessed on 10/27/12 at. http://kramerpresentations.blogspot.com/2008_03_01_archive.html.
44. Kupfer D., First M.B., Regier D.E. Introduction. A research agenda for DSM-V 2002, xv-xxiii. American Psychiatric Association, Washington, D.C. D.M. Kupfer, M.B. First, D.E. Regier (Eds.).
45. Lamb K., Pies R., Zisook S. The bereavement exclusion for the diagnosis of major depression: to be or not to be. Psychiatry 2010, 7:19-25.
46. Lewis A.J. Melancholia: A clinical survey of depressive states. Journal of Mental Science 1934, 80:1-43.
47. Malhi G.S., Adams D., Porter R., Wignall A., Lampe L., O'Connor N., et al. Clinical practice recommendations for depression. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2009, 119(Suppl. 439):8-26.
48. Marcus S.C., Olfson M. National trends in the treatment for depression from 1998 to 2007. Archives of General Psychiatry 2010, 67(12):1265-1273.
49. Marks I.M., Nesse R.M. Fear and fitness: An evolutionary analysis of anxiety disorders. Ethology and Sociobiology 1994, 15:247-261.
50. Mathers C.D., Loncar D. Projections of global mortality and burden of disease from 2002 to 2030. PLoS Medicine 2006, 3(11):e442. (PMID 17132052). 10.1371/journal.pmed.0030442.
51. Moffitt T.E., Caspi A., Taylor A., Kokaua J., Milne B.J., Polanczyk G., et al. How common are common mental disorders? Evidence that lifetime prevalence rates are doubled by prospective versus retrospective ascertainment. Psychological Medicine 2010, 40:899-909.
52. Mojtabai R. Bereavement-related depressive episodes: Characteristics, 3-year course, and implications for DSM-5. Archives of General Psychiatry 2011, 68:920-928.
53. Monroe S.M., Harkness K.L. Recurrence in major depression: A conceptual analysis. Psychological Review 2011, 118:655-674.
54. Narrow W.E., Rae D.S., Robins L.N., Regier D.A. Revised prevalence estimates of mental disorders in the United States: Using a clinical significance criterion to reconcile 2 survey's estimates. Archives of General Psychiatry 2002, 59:115-123.
55. Nesse R.M. Is depression an adaptation?. Archives of General Psychiatry 2000, 57:15-20.
56. Nesse R.M., Stein D.J. Towards a genuinely medical model for psychiatric nosology. BMC Medicine 2012, 10(5):1-9.
57. Padgett D.K. There's no place like (a) home: Ontological security among persons with serious mental illness in the United States. Social Science & Medicine 2007, 64(9):1925-1936.
58. Parkes C. Recent bereavement as a cause of mental illness. The British Journal of Psychiatry 1964, 110:198-204.
59. Peterson C., Seligman M. Character strengths and virtues: A handbook and classification 2004, Oxford University Press, New York.
60. Pies R. Depression and the pitfalls of causality: Implications for DSM-V. Journal of Affective Disorders 2009, 116:1-3.
61. Rachman S.J. Fear and courage: A psychological perspective. Social Research 2004, 71:149-176.
62. Reynolds C.F., Miller M.D., Pasternak R.E., Frank E., Perel J.M., Corbes C., et al. Treatment of bereavement-related major depressive episodes in later life: A controlled study of acute and continuation treatment with nortriptyline and interpersonal psychotherapy. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1999, 156(2):202-208.
63. Robins E., Guze S.B. Establishment of diagnostic validity in psychiatric illness: Its application to schizophrenia. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1970, 126:983-987.
64. Rush A.J. DSM-IV mood disorders: Final overview. DSM-IV sourcebook 1998, Volume 4:1019-1033. American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DC. T.A. Widiger, A.J. Frances, H.A. Pincus, R. Ross, M.B. First, M. Davis (Eds.).
65. Russell B. Sceptical essays 2004/1928, Routledge, New York.
66. Scheff T.J. Being mentally ill: A sociological theory 1966, Aldine, Chicago.
67. Labeling madness 1975, Prentice-Hall, Endlewood Cliffs, NJ. T.J. Scheff (Ed.).
68. Schomerus G., Schwahn C., Holzinger A., Corrigan P.W., Grabe H.J., Carta M.G., et al. Evolution of public attitudes about mental illness: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2012, 125:440-452.
69. Segal Z.V., Bieling P., Young T., MacQueen G., Cooke R., Martin L., et al. Antidepressant monotherapy vs sequential pharmacotherapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, or placebo, for relapse prophylaxis in recurrent depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 2010, 67(12):1256-1264.
70. Shear M.K. Bereavement and the DSM-5. Omega 2011, 64(2):101-118.
71. Shear M.K., Frank E., Houck P.R., Reynolds C.F. Treatment of complicated grief: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Association 2005, 293:2601-2608.
72. Shear M.K., Simon N., Wall M., Zisook S., Neimeyer R., Duan N., et al. Complicated grief and related bereavement issues for DSM-5. Depression and Anxiety 2011, 28:103-117.
73. Sokero T.P., Melartin T.K., Rytsälä H.J., Leskelä U.S., Lestelä-Mielonen P.S., Isometsä E.T. Prospective study of risk factors for attempted suicide among patients with DSM-IV major depressive disorder. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2005, 186:314-318.
74. Spitzer R.L., Wakefield J.C. DSM-IV diagnostic criterion for clinical significance: Does it help solve the false positives problem?. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1999, 156:1856-1864.
75. Stroebe M., Stroebe W., Abakoumkin G. The broken heart: Suicidal ideation in bereavement. The American Journal of Psychiatry 2005, 162:2178-2180.
76. Szasz T.S. The myth of mental illness: Foundations of a theory of personal conduct 1974, Harper & Row, New York. Rev. ed.
77. Vaillant G.E. Mental health. The American Journal of Psychiatry 2003, 160:1373-1384.
78. Venuto V., Lautin A. The lure of the context-dependent psychiatric diagnosis. Psychiatric Times 2009, 26(6). (Accessed 2/3/10 at: http://www.psychiatrictimes.com/display/article/10168/1413515?verify=0).
79. Wakefield J.C. Levels of explanation in personality theory. Personality psychology: Recent trends and emerging directions 1989, 333-346. Springer-Verlag, New York. D. Buss, N. Cantor (Eds.).
80. Wakefield J.C. The concept of mental disorder: On the boundary between biological facts and social values. American Psychologist 1992, 47:373-388.
81. Wakefield J.C. Disorder as harmful dysfunction: A conceptual critique of DSM-III-R's definition of mental disorder. Psychological Review 1992, 99:232-247.
82. Wakefield J.C. Limits of operationalization: A critique of Spitzer and Endicott's (1978) proposed operational criteria for mental disorder. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1993, 102:160-172.
83. Wakefield J.C. Evolutionary versus prototype analyses of the concept of disorder. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1999, 108:374-399.
84. Wakefield J.C. Disorder as a black box essentialist concept. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1999, 108:465-472.
85. Wakefield J.C. Il concetto di salute mentale: una critica a Vaillant. Psicoterapia E Scienze Umane 2005, 39(1):91-96. (in Italian).
86. Wakefield J.C. The concept of mental disorder: Diagnostic implications of the harmful dysfunction analysis. World Psychiatry 2006, 6:149-156.
87. Wakefield J.C. Personality disorder as harmful dysfunction: DSM's cultural deviance requirement reconsidered. Journal of Personality Disorders 2006, 20:157-169.
88. Wakefield J.C. Why psychology needs conceptual analysts: Wachtel's "discontents" revisited. Applied and Preventive Psychology 2007, 12:39-43.
89. Wakefield J.C. Should uncomplicated bereavement-related depression be reclassified as a disorder in DSM-5? Response to Kenneth S. Kendler's statement defending the proposal to eliminate the bereavement exclusion. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorder 2011, 199:203-208.
90. Wakefield J.C., Baer J.C. Levels of meaning and the case for theoretical integration. Social Work Now: The Practice Journal of Child, Youth, and Family 2008, 39(April):21-28.
91. Wakefield J.C., Baer J.C. The cognitivization of psychoanalysis: Toward an integration of psychodynamic and cognitive theories. Reshaping theory in contemporary social work: Toward a critical pluralism in clinical practice 2010, 51-80. Columbia University Press, New York. W. Borden (Ed.).
92. Wakefield J.C., First M.B. Does the empirical evidence support the proposal to eliminate the major depression "bereavement exclusion" in DSM-5?. World Psychiatry 2012, 11:3-10.
93. Wakefield J.C., First M.B. Placing symptoms in context: The role of contextual criteria in reducing false positives in DSM diagnosis. Comprehensive Psychiatry 2012, 53:130-139.
94. Wakefield J.C., Horwitz A.V., Schmitz M. Are we overpathologizing social anxiety? Social phobia from a harmful dysfunction perspective. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 2005, 50:317-319.
95. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F. Recurrence of depression after bereavement-related depression: Evidence for the validity of the DSM-IV bereavement exclusion from the Epidemiologic Catchment Area Study. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2012, 200:480-485.
96. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F. Beyond reactive versus endogenous: Should uncomplicated stress-triggered depression be excluded from major depression diagnosis? A review of the evidence. Minerva Psichiatrica 2012, 53:251-276.
97. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F. Normal vs. disordered bereavement-related depression: Are the differences real or tautological?. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2013, 127:159-168.
98. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F. Can the DSM's major depression bereavement exclusion be validly extended to other stressors? Evidence from the NCS. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2013, (Publication online:). 10.1111/acps.12064.
99. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F. When does depression become a disorder? Using recurrence rates to evaluate the validity of proposed changes in major depression diagnostic thresholds. World Psychiatry 2013, 12:44-52.
100. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F., Baer J.C. Does the DSMIV clinical significance criterion for major depression reduce false positives? Evidence from the NCS-R. The American Journal of Psychiatry 2010, 167:298-304.
101. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F., Baer J.C. Relation between duration and severity in bereavement-related depression. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2011, 124:487-494.
102. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F., Baer J.C. Did narrowing the major depression bereavement exclusion from DSM-III-R to DSM-IV increase validity? Evidence from the National Comorbidity Survey. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2011, 199:66-73.
103. Wakefield J.C., Schmitz M.F., First M.B., Horwitz A.V. Should the bereavement exclusion for major depression be extended to other losses? Evidence from the National Comorbidity Survey. Archives of General Psychiatry 2007, 64:433-440.
104. Wittgenstein L. Philosophical investigations 1958, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, trans. Anscombe, G. E. M.
105. World Health Organization ICD-10: International statistical classification of diseases and related health problems, tenth revision 2004, World Health Org., Geneva. 2nd ed.
106. Zisook S. Today in your health: Bereavement. National Public Radio, Morning Edition 2010, August 2nd.
107. Zisook S. Getting past the grief over grief. Scientific American Blog 2013, February, (Accessed 3/25/13 at: http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/2013/02/25/getting-past-the-grief-over-grief/).
108. Zisook S., Kendler K.S. Is bereavement-related depression different than nonbereavement-related depression?. Psychological Medicine 2007, 37:779-794.
109. Zisook S., Shear K., Kendler K.S. Validity of the bereavement exclusion criterion for the diagnosis of major depressive episode. World Psychiatry 2007, 6:102-107.
110. Zisook S., Shuchter S.R. Depression through the first year after the death of a spouse. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1991, 148:1346-1352.
111. Zisook S., Shuchter S.R. Uncomplicated bereavement. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 1993, 54:365-372.
112. Zisook S., Shuchter S.R., Pedrelli P., Sable J., Deaciuc S.C. Bupropion sustained release for bereavement: Results of an open trial. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 2001, 62:227-230.