Should prolonged grief be reclassified as a mental disorder in DSM-5?: Reconsidering the empirical and conceptual arguments for complicated grief disorder

Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease

Volumn 200, Issue 6, 2012, Pages 499-511

  Wakefield, Jerome C ^a,b,c,d  

^a NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b NEW YORK UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^c NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^d NONE   (United States)

Author keywords

bereavement; complicated grief; diagnosis; DSM 5; harmful dysfunction; prolonged grief; validity

Indexed keywords

ANGER; BEREAVEMENT; CLINICAL EVALUATION; CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK; DEATH; DISCRIMINANT VALIDITY; DISEASE CLASSIFICATION; DISEASE EXACERBATION; DISEASE SEVERITY; DSM-5; EMOTIONAL DISORDER; EMOTIONAL STRESS; EMOTIONALITY; FALSE POSITIVE RESULT; GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER; GRIEF; HUMAN; MAJOR DEPRESSION; MEDICAL SOCIETY; MENTAL DISEASE; MENTAL HEALTH; MORTALITY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PREDICTIVE VALUE; PROLONGED GRIEF DISORDER; PSYCHIATRIC DIAGNOSIS; QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS; QUALITY OF LIFE; RELIGION; REVIEW; SORROW; SUICIDAL IDEATION; SYMPTOM;

ADAPTATION, PSYCHOLOGICAL; ADJUSTMENT DISORDERS; BEREAVEMENT; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDIES; DIAGNOSIS, DIFFERENTIAL; DIAGNOSTIC AND STATISTICAL MANUAL OF MENTAL DISORDERS; GRIEF; HUMANS; LONGITUDINAL STUDIES; MENTAL DISORDERS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84862214365     PISSN: 00223018     EISSN: 1539736X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1097/NMD.0b013e3182482155     Document Type: Review

References (58)

1. American Psychiatric Association (2000) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition-Text Revised (DSM-IV TR). Washington DC: American Psychiatric Association.
2. American Psychiatric Association (2011a) Criteria for major depressive episode, mood disorders: major depressive episode. Available at: http://www.dsm5. org/ProposedRevisions/Pages/proposedrevision.aspx?rid=427. Accessed May 7, 2012.
3. American Psychiatric Association (2011b) DSM-5 development, Adjustment disorders, proposed revision. Available at: http://www.dsm5.org/ ProposedRevision/Pages/proposedrevision.aspx?rid=367#. Accessed May 7, 2012.
4. American Psychiatric Association (2011c) DSM-5 development, Adjustment disorders, rationale. Available at: http://www.dsm5.org/ProposedRevision/Pages/ proposedrevision.aspx?rid=367#. Accessed May 7, 2012.
5. Bonanno GA, Kaltman S (1999) Toward an integrative perspective on bereavement. Psychol Bull. 126:760-776.
6. Bonanno GA, Papa A, Lalande K, Zhang N, Noll JG (2005) Grief processing and deliberate grief avoidance: A prospective comparison of bereaved spouses and parents in the United States and the People's Republic of China. J Consult Clin Psychol. 73:86-98.
7. Bonanno GA, Wortman, CB, Lehman DR, Tweed RG, Haring M, Sonnega J, Carr D, Nesse RM (2002) Resilience to loss and chronic grief: A prospective study from preloss to 18-months postloss. J Pers Soc Psychol. 83:1150-1164.
8. Bonanno GA, Wortman CB, Nesse R (2004) Prospective patterns of resilience and maladjustment during widowhood. Psychol Aging. 19:260-271.
9. Bowlby J (1980) Loss: Sadness and depression (Attachment and loss, Vol. 3). New York: Basic Books.
10. Buckley T, McKinley S, Tofler G, Bartrop R (2010) Cardiovascular risk in early bereavement: A literature review and proposed mechanisms. Int J Nursing Stud. 47:229-238.
11. Byrne GJA, Raphael DB (1994) A longitudinal study of bereavement phenomena in recently widowed elderly men. Psychol Med. 24:411-421.
12. Clayton P, Desmarais L, Winokur G (1968) A study of normal bereavement. Am J Psychiatry. 125:168-178.
13. Engel G (1961) Is grief a disease? A challenge for medical research. Psychosom Med. 23:18-22.
14. First MB (2011) DSM-5 proposals for mood disorders: A costYbenefit analysis. Curr Opin Psychiatry. 24:1-9.
15. Frances A (2010) Good grief. New York Times. August 15, 2010; p. WK9.
16. Holland JM, Neimeyer RA, Boelen PA, Prigerson HG (2009) The underlying structure of grief: A taxometric investigation of prolonged and normal reactions to loss. J Psychopathol Behav Assess. 31:190-231.
17. Horowitz MJ (2006) Meditating on complicated grief disorder as a diagnosis. Omega. 52:87-89.
18. Horowitz MJ, Siegel B, Holen A, Bonanno GA, Milbrath C, Stinson CH (1997) Diagnostic criteria for complicated grief disorder. Am J Psychiatry. 154: 904-910.
19. Horwitz AV, Wakefield JC (2007) The loss of sadness: How psychiatry transformed normal sorrow into depressive disorder. New York: Oxford University Press.
20. Kendler KS (2010) A statement from Kenneth S. Kendler, M.D., on the proposal to eliminate the grief exclusion criterion from major depression, by Kenneth S. Kendler, M.D., Member, DSM-5 Mood Disorder Work Group. Available at: Proposed draft revisions to DSM disorders and criteria, http://www.dsm5.org/ Pages/Default.aspx. Accessed October 16, 2010.
21. Lichtenthal W, Cruess D, Prigerson H (2004) A case for establishing complicated grief as a distinct mental disorder in DSM-V. Clin Psychol Rev. 24:637-662.
22. Maciejewski P, Zhang B, Block S, Prigerson H (2007) An empirical examination of the stage theory of grief. JAMA. 297:716-722.
23. Maj M (2008) Depression, bereavement, and 'understandable' intense sadness: Should the DSM-IV approach be revised? Am J Psychiatry. 165:1373-1375.
24. Middleton W, Raphael B, Martinek N, Misso V (1993) Pathological grief reactions. In: Stroebe MS, Stroebe W, Hansson RO (Eds), Handbook of bereavement: Theory, research and intervention (pp 44-61). New York: Cambridge University Press.
25. Parkes CM, Prigerson HG (2010) Bereavement. New York: Routledge.
26. Parkes CM,Weiss RS (1983) Recovery from bereavement. New York: Basic Books.
27. Prigerson HG, Bierhals AJ, Kasl SV, Reynolds CF III, Shear MK, Day N, Beery LC, Newsom JT, Jacobs S (1997) Traumatic grief as a risk factor for mental and physical morbidity. Am J Psychiatry. 154:616-623.
28. Prigerson HG, Frank E, Kasl SV, Reynolds CF III, Anderson B, Zubenko GS, Houck PR, George CJ, Kupfer DJ (1995) Complicated grief and bereavementrelated depression as distinct disorders: Preliminary empirical validation in elderly bereaved spouses. Am J Psychiatry. 152:22-30.
29. Prigerson HG, Horowitz MJ, Jacobs SC, Parkes CM, Aslan M, Goodkin K, Raphael B, Marwit SJ, Wortman C, Neimeyer RA, Bonanno G, Block SD, Kissane D, Boelen P, Maercker A, Litz BT, Johnson JG, First MB, Maciejewski PK (2009) Prolonged grief disorder: Psychometric validation of criteria proposed for DSM-V and ICD-11. PLoS Medicine. 6:e1000121.
30. Prigerson HG, Maciejewski PK (2006) A call for sound empirical testing and evaluation of criteria for complicated grief proposed for DSM-V. Omega. 52:9-19.
31. Prigerson HG, Shear MK, Jacobs SC, Reynolds CF, Maciejewski PK, Davidson JRT, Rosenheck R, Pilkonis PA, Wortman CB, Williams JBW, Widiger TA, Frank E, Kupfer DJ, Zisook S (1999) Consensus criteria for traumatic grief: A preliminary empirical test. Br J Psychiatry. 174:67-73.
32. Prigerson HG, Vanderwerker LC, Maciejewski PK (2008) Prolonged grief disorder: A case for inclusion in DSM-V. In: Stroebe MS, Hansson RO, Schut H, Stroebe W (Eds), Handbook of bereavement research and practice: Advances in theory and intervention (pp 165-186). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
33. Russell B (2004/1928) Sceptical essays. New York: Routledge.
34. Shaffer D, Scott M, Wilcox H, Maslow C, Hicks R, Lucas CP, Garfinkel R, Greenwald S (2004) The Columbia SuicideScreen: Validity and reliability of a screen for youth suicide and depression. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 43:71-79.
35. Shear K, Clayton PJ (2008) Bereavement-related depression: Guest editorial. Psychiatr Ann. 38:643-645.
36. Shear K, Frank E, Houck PR, Reynolds CF III (2005) Treatment of complicated grief: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA. 293:2601-2608.
37. Shear K, Monk T, Houck P, Melhem N, Frank E, Reynolds C, Sillowash R (2007) An attachment-based model of complicated grief including the role of avoidance. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci. 257:453-461.
38. Shear K, Mulhare E (2008) Complicated grief. Psychiatr Ann. 38:662-670.
39. Shear K, Shair H (2005) Attachment, loss, and complicated grief. Dev Psychobiol. 47:253-267.
40. Shear MK, Simon N, Wall M, Zisook S, Neimeyer R, Duan N, Reynolds C, Lebowitz B, Sung S, Ghesquiere A, Gorscak B, Clayton P, Ito M, Nakajima S, Konishi T, Melhem N, Meert K, Schiff M, O'Connor MF, First M, Sareen J, Bolton J, Skritskaya N, Mancini AD, Keshaviah A (2011) Complicated grief and related bereavement issues for DSM-5. Depress Anxiety. 28:103-117.
41. Simon NM, Wall MM, Keshaviah A, Dryman MT, LeBlanc NJ, Shear MK (2011) Informing the symptom profile of complicated grief. Depress anxiety. 28:118-126.
42. Stein DJ, Phillips KA, Bolton D, Fulford KWM, Sadler JZ, Kendler KS (2010) What is a mental/psychiatric disorder? From DSM-IV to DSM-V. Psychol Med. 40:1759-1765.
43. Strain JS, Friedman MJ (2011) Considering adjustment disorders as stress response syndromes. Depress Anxiety. 28:818-823.
44. Stroebe M, Schut H (1999) The dual process model of coping with bereavement: Rationale and description. Death Stud. 23:197-224.
45. Thompson LW, Gallagher-Thompson D, Futterman A, Gilewski MJ, Peterson J (1991) The effects of late-life spousal bereavement over 30-month interval. Psychol Aging. 6:434-441.
46. Viederman M (1995) Grief: Normal and pathological variants. Am J Psychiatry. 152:1-4.
47. Wakefield JC (1992a) The concept of mental disorder: On the boundary between biological facts and social values. Am Psychol. 47:373-388.
48. Wakefield JC (1992b) Disorder as harmful dysfunction: A conceptual critique of DSM-III-R's definition of mental disorder. Psychol Rev. 99:232-247.
49. Wakefield JC (1993) Limits of operationalization: A critique of Spitzer and Endicott's (1978) proposed operational criteria for mental disorder. J Abnorm Psychol. 102:160-172.
50. Wakefield JC (1999) Evolutionary versus prototype analyses of the concept of disorder. J Abnorm Psychol. 108:374-399.
51. Wakefield JC (2006) The concept of mental disorder: Diagnostic implications of the harmful dysfunction analysis. World Psychiatry. 6:149-156.
52. Wakefield JC (2010) Taking disorder seriously: A critique of psychiatric criteria for mental disorders from the harmful-dysfunction perspective. In: Millon T, Krueger RF, Simonsen E (Eds), Contemporary directions in psychopathology: Scientific foundations of the DSM-V and ICD-11 (pp 275-302). New York: Guilford Press.
53. Wakefield JC (2011) Should uncomplicated bereavement-related depression be reclassified as a disorder in DSM-5? Response to Kenneth S. Kendler's statement defending the proposal to eliminate the bereavement exclusion. J Nerv Ment Dis. 199:203-208.
54. Wakefield JC, First MD (2012) Validity of the bereavement exclusion to major depression: Does the empirical evidence support the proposal to eliminate the exclusion in DSM-5? World Psychiatry. 11:3-10.
55. Wakefield JC, Schmitz MF (2011) Recurrence of bereavement-related depression: Evidence for the validity of the DSM-IV bereavement exclusion from the Epidemiologic Catchment Area Study. J Nerv Ment Dis. 200: 480-485.
56. Walter T (2006) What is complicated grief? A social constructionist perspective. Omega. 52:71-79.
57. Wilkinson S (2000) Is 'normal grief ' a mental disorder? Philos Q. 50:289-304.
58. Zisook S, Shear K (2009) Grief and bereavement: What psychiatrists need to know. World Psychiatry. 8:67-74.