Do early warning indicators consistently predict nonlinear change in long-term ecological data?

Journal of Applied Ecology

Volumn 53, Issue 3, 2016, Pages 666-676

  Burthe, Sarah J ^a   Henrys, Peter A ^a   Mackay, Eleanor B ^a   Spears, Bryan M ^a   Campbell, Ronald ^b   Carvalho, Laurence ^a   Dudley, Bernard ^a   Gunn, Iain D M ^a   Johns, David G ^c   Maberly, Stephen C ^a   May, Linda ^a   Newell, Mark A ^a   Wanless, Sarah ^a   Winfield, Ian J ^a   Thackeray, Stephen J ^a   Daunt, Francis ^a  

^a CENTRE FOR ECOLOGY AND HYDROLOGY   (United Kingdom)

^b Tweed Foundation   (United Kingdom)

^c THE LABORATORY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

ecosystem resilience; food webs; nonlinearity; preventative management; regime shifts; time series data; tipping points

Indexed keywords

ABUNDANCE; ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT; ANTHROPOGENIC EFFECT; AUTOCORRELATION; BIODIVERSITY; CLIMATE CHANGE; CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT; EARLY WARNING SYSTEM; ECOSYSTEM MANAGEMENT; ECOSYSTEM RESILIENCE; ECOSYSTEM SERVICE; ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE; FOOD WEB; FRESHWATER ECOSYSTEM; MARINE ECOSYSTEM; NONLINEARITY; TIME SERIES ANALYSIS; TROPHIC LEVEL;

CONSISTENCY; DATA; ECOSYSTEMS; INDICATORS; MANAGEMENT; PROCESSES; SHIPPING CONTAINERS; VARIANCE;

EID: 84940945482     PISSN: 00218901     EISSN: 13652664     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1365-2664.12519     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Angeler, D.G., Allen, C.R., Rojo, C., Alvarez-Cobelas, M., Rodrigo, M.A. & Sanchez-Carrillo, S. (2013) Inferring the relative resilience of alternative states. PLoS ONE, 8, DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0077338.
2. Austin, G.E., Collier, M.P. & Rehfisch, M.M. (2008) Non-estuarine Coastal Waterbird Survey: Population estimates and broad comparisons with previous surveys. British Trust for Ornithology (BTO) Research Report No. 501. BTO, Thetford.
3. Batt, R.D., Brock, W.A., Carpenter, S.R., Cole, J.J., Pace, M.L. & Seekell, D.A. (2013) Asymmetric response of early warning indicators of phytoplankton transition to and from cycles. Theoretical Ecology, 6, 285–293.
4. Beaugrand, G. (2004) The North Sea regime shift: evidence, causes, mechanisms and consequences. Progress in Oceanography, 60, 245–262.
5. Biggs, R., Carpenter, S.R. & Brock, W.A. (2009) Turning back from the brink: detecting an impending regime shift in time to avert it. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 106, 826–831.
6. Burthe, S., Daunt, F., Butler, A., Elston, D.A., Frederiksen, M., Johns, D., Newell, M., Thackeray, S.J. & Wanless, S. (2012) Phenological trends and trophic mismatch across multiple levels of a North Sea pelagic food web. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 454, 119–133.
7. Carpenter, S.R. & Brock, W.A. (2006) Rising variance: a leading indicator of ecological transition. Ecology Letters, 9, 308–315.
8. Carpenter, S.R., Brock, W.A., Cole, J.J., Kitchell, J.F. & Pace, M.L. (2008) Leading indicators of trophic cascades. Ecology Letters, 11, 128–138.
9. Carpenter, S.R., Cole, J.J., Pace, M.L., Batt, R., Brock, W.A., Cline, T. et al. (2011) Early warnings of regime shifts: a whole-ecosystem experiment. Science, 332, 1079–1082.
10. Carvalho, L., Bailey-Watts, A.E. & Kirika, A. (2015) Loch Leven diatom counts 1968–2007. NERC-Environmental Information Data Centre doi: 10.5285/de5ca6cc-02e9-42bc-a39e-80ec8acbffba.
11. Carvalho, L., Miller, C., Spears, B.M., Gunn, I.D.M., Bennion, H., Kirika, A. & May, L. (2012) Water quality of Loch Leven: responses to enrichment, restoration and climate change. Hydrobiologia, 681, 35–47.
12. CEN (2004) Water quality – Guidance standard for the routine analysis of phytoplankton abundance and composition using inverted microscopy (Utermöhl technique) CEN TC 230/WG 2/TG 3/N83, May 2004.
13. Dakos, V., van Nes, E.H. & Scheffer, M. (2013) Flickering as an early warning signal. Theoretical Ecology, 6, 309–317.
14. Dakos, V., Scheffer, M., van Nes, E.H., Brovkin, V., Petoukhov, V. & Held, H. (2008) Slowing down as an early warning signal for abrupt climate change. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 105, 14308–14312.
15. Dakos, V., Kefi, S., Rietkerk, M., van Nes, E.H. & Scheffer, M. (2011) Slowing down in spatially patterned ecosystems at the brink of collapse. American Naturalist, 177, E153–E166.
16. Dakos, V., Carpenter, S.R., Brock, W.A., Ellison, A.M., Guttal, V., Ives, A.R. et al. (2012a) Methods for detecting early warnings of critical transitions in time series illustrated using simulated ecological data. PLoS ONE, 7, DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0041010.
17. Dakos, V., van Nes, E.H., D'Odorico, P. & Scheffer, M. (2012b) Robustness of variance and autocorrelation as indicators of critical slowing down. Ecology, 93, 264–271.
18. Daunt, F., Wanless, S., Greenstreet, S.P.R., Jensen, H., Hamer, K.C. & Harris, M.P. (2008) The impact of the sandeel fishery closure on seabird food consumption, distribution, and productivity in the northwestern North Sea. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 65, 362–381.
19. Ditlevsen, P.D. & Johnsen, S.J. (2010) Tipping points: early warning and wishful thinking. Geophysical Research Letters, 37, DOI: 10.1029/2010GL044486.
20. Dong, X.H., Bennion, H., Maberly, S.C., Sayer, C.D., Simpson, G.L. & Battarbee, R.W. (2012) Nutrients exert a stronger control than climate on recent diatom communities in Esthwaite Water: evidence from monitoring and palaeolimnological records. Freshwater Biology, 57, 2044–2056.
21. Drake, J.M. & Griffen, B.D. (2010) Early warning signals of extinction in deteriorating environments. Nature, 467, 456–459.
22. Eason, T., Garmestani, A.S. & Cabezas, H. (2014) Managing for resilience: early detection of regime shifts in complex systems. Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy, 16, 773–783.
23. Feuchtmayr, H., Thackeray, S.J., Jones, I.D., De Ville, M., Fletcher, J., James, B. & Kelly, J. (2012) Spring phytoplankton phenology – are patterns and drivers of change consistent among lakes in the same climatological region? Freshwater Biology, 57, 331–344.
24. Fewster, R.M., Buckland, S.T., Siriwardena, G.M., Baillie, S.R. & Wilson, J.D. (2000) Analysis of population trends for farmland birds using generalized additive models. Ecology, 81, 1970–1984.
25. Frederiksen, M., Edwards, M., Richardson, A.J., Halliday, N.C. & Wanless, S. (2006) From plankton to top predators: bottom-up control of a marine food web across four trophic levels. Journal of Animal Ecology, 75, 1259–1268.
26. George, D.G., Maberly, S.C. & Hewitt, D.P. (2004) The influence of the North Atlantic Oscillation on the physical, chemical and biological characteristics of four lakes in the English Lake District. Freshwater Biology, 49, 760–774.
27. Gunn, I.D.M., O'Hare, M.T., Maitland, P.S. & May, L. (2012) Long-term trends in Loch Leven invertebrate communities. Hydrobiologia, 681, 59–72.
28. Gunn, I.D.M., George, D.G., Johnson, D., Jones, D.H. & May, L. (2015) Crustacean zooplankton data from Loch Leven, 1972–2007. NERC-Environmental Information Data Centre doi:10.5285/014f1c48-0838-49ca-b059-f084b13f4d5f.
29. Hastie, T. & Tibshirani, R. (1990) Exploring the nature of covariate effects in the proportional hazards model. Biometrics, 46, 1005–1016.
30. Hastings, A. & Wysham, D.B. (2010) Regime shifts in ecological systems can occur with no warning. Ecology Letters, 13, 464–472.
31. Holling, C.S. (1973) Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems. International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Austria.
32. Hsieh, C.H., Reiss, C.S., Hunter, J.R., Beddington, J.R., May, R.M. & Sugihara, G. (2006) Fishing elevates variability in the abundance of exploited species. Nature, 443, 859–862.
33. Johns, D. (2009) Monthly averaged data for phyto- and zooplankton (55–58°N, 3–0°W) 1958-2007 recorded by the Continuous Plankton Recorder [to 13/11/2009]. Sir Alister Hardy Foundation for Ocean Science, Plymouth.
34. Kefi, S., Dakos, V., Scheffer, M., Van Nes, E.H. & Rietkerk, M. (2013) Early warning signals also precede non-catastrophic transitions. Oikos, 122, 641–648.
35. Kenny, A.J., Skjoldal, H.R., Engelhard, G.H., Kershaw, P.J. & Reid, J.B. (2009) An integrated approach for assessing the relative significance of human pressures and environmental forcing on the status of Large Marine Ecosystems. Progress in Oceanography, 81, 132–148.
36. Krkosek, M. & Drake, J.M. (2014) On signals of phase transitions in salmon population dynamics. Proceedings of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 281, DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2013.3221.
37. Large, S.I., Fay, G., Friedland, K.D. & Link, J.S. (2013) Defining trends and thresholds in responses of ecological indicators to fishing and environmental pressures. Ices Journal of Marine Science, 70, 755–767.
38. Lindegren, M., Dakos, V., Groger, J.P., Gardmark, A., Kornilovs, G., Otto, S.A. & Mollmann, C. (2012) Early detection of ecosystem regime shifts: a multiple method evaluation for management application. PLoS ONE, 7, DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0038410.
39. Litzow, M.A., Mueter, F.J. & Urban, J.D. (2013) Rising catch variability preceded historical fisheries collapses in Alaska. Ecological Applications, 23, 1475–1487.
40. Litzow, M.A., Urban, J.D. & Laurel, B.J. (2008) Increased spatial variance accompanies reorganization of two continental shelf ecosystems. Ecological Applications, 18, 1331–1337.
41. Lund, J.W.G. (1949) Studies on Asterionella I. The origin and nature of the cells producing seasonal maxima. Journal of Ecology, 37, 389–419.
42. Maberly, S.C. & Elliott, J.A. (2012) Insights from long-term studies in the Windermere catchment: external stressors, internal interactions and the structure and function of lake ecosystems. Freshwater Biology, 57, 233–243.
43. May, L. & Spears, B.M. (2012) Managing ecosystem services at Loch Leven, Scotland, UK: actions, impacts and unintended consequences. Hydrobiologia, 681, 117–130.
44. McGowan, S., Barker, P., Haworth, E.Y., Leavitt, P.R., Maberly, S.C. & Pates, J. (2012) Humans and climate as drivers of algal community change in Windermere since 1850. Freshwater Biology, 57, 260–277.
45. Mitchell, N., Brooks, P., Squire, J., Wright, G. & Allison, A. (2015). Loch Leven Waterfowl 1968–2007. NERC Environmental Information Data Centre. http://doi.org/10.5285/39da2334-0952-4d4d-b634-5f7f2115ac90
46. Monteith, K.L., Long, R.A., Bleich, V.C., Heffelfinger, J.R., Krausman, P.R. & Bowyer, R.T. (2013) Effects of harvest, culture, and climate on trends in size of horn-like structures in trophy ungulates. Wildlife Monographs, 183, 1–28.
47. Moss, R.H., Meehl, G.A., Lemos, M.C., Smith, J.B., Arnold, J.R., Arnott, J.C. et al. (2013) Hell and high water: practice-relevant adaptation science. Science, 342, 696–698.
48. van Nes, E.H. & Scheffer, M. (2007) Slow recovery from perturbations as a generic indicator of a nearby catastrophic shift. American Naturalist, 169, 738–747.
49. Pace, M.L., Carpenter, S.R., Johnson, R.A. & Kurtzweil, J.T. (2013) Zooplankton provide early warnings of a regime shift in a whole lake manipulation. Limnology and Oceanography, 58, 525–532.
50. Parmesan, C. (2006) Ecological and evolutionary responses to recent climate change. Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and Systematics, 37, 637–669.
51. Paxton, C.G.M., Winfield, I.J., Fletcher, J.M., George, D.G. & Hewitt, D.P. (2004) Biotic and abiotic influences on the recruitment of male perch in Windermere, U.K. Journal of Fish Biology, 65, 1622–1642.
52. Perretti, C.T. & Munch, S.B. (2012) Regime shift indicators fail under noise levels commonly observed in ecological systems. Ecological Applications, 22, 1772–1779.
53. R Core Team (2014) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. URL http://www.R-project.org/.
54. Richardson, A.J., Walne, A.W., John, A.W.G., Jonas, T.D., Lindley, J.A., Sims, D.W., Stevens, D. & Witt, M. (2006) Using continuous plankton recorder data. Progress in Oceanography, 68, 27–74.
55. Scheffer, M., Carpenter, S., Foley, J.A., Folke, C. & Walker, B. (2001) Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Nature, 413, 591–596.
56. Scheffer, M., Bascompte, J., Brock, W.A., Brovkin, V., Carpenter, S.R., Dakos, V. et al. (2009) Early-warning signals for critical transitions. Nature, 461, 53–59.
57. Seekell, D.A., Carpenter, S.R., Cline, T.J. & Pace, M.L. (2012) Conditional heteroskedasticity forecasts regime shift in a whole-ecosystem experiment. Ecosystems, 15, 741–747.
58. Spanbauer, T.L., Allen, C.R., Angeler, D.G., Eason, T., Fritz, S.C., Garmestani, A.S., Nash, K.L. & Stone, J.R. (2014) Prolonged instability prior to a regime shift. PLoS ONE, 9, DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0108936.
59. Spears, B.M. & Jones, I.D. (2010) The long-term (1979–2005) effects of the North Atlantic Oscillation on wind-induced wave mixing in Loch Leven (Scotland). Hydrobiologia, 646, 49–59.
60. Talling, J.F. (1974) Photosynthetic pigments. General Outline of Spectrophotometric methods; Specific Procedures A Manual on Methods for Measuring Primary Productivity in Aquatic Environments (ed R.A. Vollenweider), pp. 22–26. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford.
61. Talling, J.F. (2003) Phytoplankton-zooplankton seasonal timing and the ‘clear-water phase’ in some English lakes. Freshwater Biology, 48, 39–52.
62. Thackeray, S.J., Jones, I.D. & Maberly, S.C. (2008) Long-term change in the phenology of spring phytoplankton: species-specific responses to nutrient enrichment and climatic change. Journal of Ecology, 96, 523–535.
63. Thackeray, S.J., Henrys, P.A., Feuchtmayr, H., Jones, I.D., Maberly, S.C. & Winfield, I.J. (2013) Food web de-synchronization in England's largest lake: an assessment based on multiple phenological metrics. Global Change Biology, 19, 3568–3580.
64. Thackeray, S.J., De Ville, M.M., Fletcher, J.M., James, J.B., Maberley, S.C., Mackay, E.B. & Winfield, I.J. (2015) Cumbrian Lakes plankton and fish data (1940–2013). NERC-Environmental Information Data Centre doi:10.5285/1de49dab-c36e-4700-8b15-93a639ae4d55.
65. Van der Putten, W.H., Macel, M. & Visser, M.E. (2010) Predicting species distribution and abundance responses to climate change: why it is essential to include biotic interactions across trophic levels. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 365, 2025–2034.
66. Waite, W. (1831) Account of the Produce of the Fishery of Sandstell. History of the Berwick Naturalists Club. Berwick upon Tweed.
67. Walsh, P.M., Halley, D.J., Harris, M.P., del Nevo, A., Sim, L.M.W. & Tasker, M.L. (1995) Seabird Monitoring Handbook for Britain and Ireland: A Compilation of Methods for Survey and Monitoring of Breeding Seabirds. Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
68. Walther, G.R., Post, E., Convey, P., Menzel, A., Parmesan, C., Beebee, T.J.C., Fromentin, J.M., Hoegh-Guldberg, O. & Bairlein, F. (2002) Ecological responses to recent climate change. Nature, 416, 389–395.
69. Winfield, I.J., Fletcher, J.M. & James, J.B. (2008) The Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus) populations of Windermere, U.K.: population trends associated with eutrophication, climate change and increased abundance of roach (Rutilus rutilus). Environmental Biology of Fishes, 83, 25–35.
70. Winfield, I.J., Fletcher, J.M. & James, J.B. (2010) An overview of fish species introductions to the English Lake District, UK, an area of outstanding conservation and fisheries importance. Journal of Applied Ichthyology, 26, 60–65.
71. Wissel, C. (1984) A universal law of the characteristic return time near thresholds. Oecologia, 65, 101–107.
72. Wood, S.N. (2003) Thin plate regression splines. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B-Statistical Methodology, 65, 95–114.
73. Wood, S.N. (2011) Fast stable restricted maximum likelihood and marginal likelihood estimation of semiparametric generalized linear models. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B-Statistical Methodology, 73, 3–36.
74. Wouters, N., Dakos, V., Edwards, M., Serafim, M.P., Valayer, P.J. & Cabral, H.N. (2015) Evidencing a regime shift in the North Sea using early-warning signals as indicators of critical transitions. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science, 152, 65–72.