Managing the monsters of doubt: Liminality, threshold concepts and leadership learning

Management Learning

Volumn 46, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 24-43

  Hawkins, Beverley ^a   Edwards, Gareth ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER BUSINESS SCHOOL   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF ENGLAND   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

identity; Leadership; learning; liminality; threshold concepts

Indexed keywords

EID: 84922255215     PISSN: 13505076     EISSN: 14617307     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1350507613501736     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Alvesson M,Spicer AMetaphors We Lead By: Understanding Leadership in the Real World. Abingdon: Routledge; 2011:
2. Billsberry JDiscovering Leadership. Billsberry J, ed. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan; 2009:24-34.
3. Bolden R.Distributed leadership in organisations: A review of theory and research.International Journal of Management Reviews. 2011;13 (3): 251-269
4. Bolden R,Hawkins B,Taylor S, et alExploring Leadership: Individual, Organizational and Societal Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2011:
5. Brown MH,Hosking DM.Distributed leadership and skilled performance as successful organisation in social movements.Human Relations. 1986;39:65-79
6. Butler JBodies that Matter. New York: Routledge; 1993:
7. Campbell JThe Hero with a Thousand Faces. London: Fontana; 1993:
8. Carlisle TOn Heroes, Hero-Worship and the Heroic in History. New York: John Wiley & Sons; 1866:
9. Carroll B,Levy L.Leadership development as identity construction.Management Communication Quarterly. 2010;24:211-230
10. Collinson DLThe SAGE Handbook of Leadership. Bryman ACollinson DGrint K, ed. London: SAGE; 2011:181-194.
11. Cook-Sather A,Alter Z.What is and what can be: How a liminal position can change learning and teaching in higher education.Anthropology & Education Quarterly. 2011;42 (1): 37-53
12. Cunliffe AL.Reflexive dialogical practice in management learning.Management Learning. 2002;33 (1): 33-61
13. Cunliffe AL.The philosopher leader: On relationalism, ethics and reflexivity – A critical perspective to teaching leadership.Management Learning. 2009;40:87-101
14. Cunliffe AL,Eriksen M.Relational leadership.Human Relations. 2011;64:1425-1449
15. Currie G.Beyond our imagination: The voice of international students on the MBA.Management Learning. 2007;38 (5): 539-556
16. Czarniawska B,Mazza C.Consulting as liminal space.Human Relations. 2003;56 (3): 267-290
17. Davies POvercoming Barriers to Student Understanding: Threshold Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge. Meyer JHFLand R, ed. Abingdon: Routledge; 2006:70-84.
18. Delanty GCommunity. 2010) Community. 2nd edn.Abingdon: Routledge.Abingdon: Routledge; 2010:
19. Douglas MPurity and Danger: An Analysis of Concepts of Pollution and Taboo. London: Routledge; 1966:
20. Edwards GP.Concepts of community: A framework for contextualising distributed leadership.International Journal of Management Reviews. 2011;13 (3): 301-312
21. Ellis RJAmerican Political Cultures. New York: Oxford University Press; 1993:
22. Fairhurst GT.Considering context in discursive leadership research.Human Relations. 2009;62:1607-1633
23. Ford J.Studying leadership critically: A psychosocial lens on leadership identities.Leadership. 2010;6:47-66
24. Ford J,Harding N.Move over management: We are all leaders now.Management Learning. 2007;38 (5): 475-493
25. Ford J,Harding N,Learmonth MLeadership as Identity: Constructions and Deconstructions. Basingstoke: Palgrave; 2008:
26. Foucault MDiscipline and Punishment: The Birth of the Prison. Harmondsworth: Penguin; 1979:
27. Foucault MPower and Knowledge. New York: Pantheon; 1980:
28. Foucault MThe History of Sexuality: The use of Pleasure. London: Random House; 1990:
29. Fry L,Kriger M.Towards a theory of being-centered leadership: Multiple levels of being as context for effective leadership.Human Relations. 2009;62:1667-1696
30. Gosling J,Mintzberg H.The education of practicing managers.Sloan Management Review. 2004;45 (4): 19-22
31. Grint K.Problems, problems, problems: The social construction of leadership.Human Relations. 2005;58:1467-1494
32. Grint K.The sacred in leadership: Separation, sacrifice and silence.Organization Studies. 2010;31 (1): 89-107
33. Gronn P.Distributed leadership as a unit of analysis.Leadership Quarterly. 2002;13:423-451
34. Gronn P.The future of distributed leadership.Journal of Educational Administration. 2008;46:141-158
35. Harris A.Distributed leadership in schools: Leading or misleading.Educational Management and Administration. 2004;32:11-24
36. Hibbert P,Cunliffe AL.Responsible management: Engaging moral reflexive practice through threshold concepts.Journal of Business Ethics.:
37. Horvath A,Thomassen B.Mimetic errors in liminal schismogenesis: On the political anthropology of the trickster.International Political Anthropology. 2008;1 (1): 3-24
38. Jepson (now Schedlitzki) D.Leadership context: The importance of departments.Leadership & Organization Development Journal. 2009;30:36-52
39. Jepson (now Schedlitzki) D.The importance of national language as a level of discourse within individuals’ theorising of leadership – A qualitative study on German and English employees.Leadership. 2010;6 (4): 425-445
40. Kempster S,Stewart J.Becoming a leader: A co-produced autoethnographic exploration of situated learning of leadership practice.Management Learning. 2010;41 (2): 205-219
41. Korosteleva EA.Threshold concepts through enactive learning: How effective are they in the study of European politics.International Studies Perspectives. 2010;11:37-50
42. Land R,Cousin G,Meyer JHF, et alImproving Student Learning 12 – Diversity and Inclusivity. Rust C, ed. Oxford: OCSLD, Oxford Brookes University; 2005:53-64.
43. Leithwood K,Mascall B,Strauss TDistributed Leadership according to the Evidence. New York: Routledge; 2009:
44. Liden RC,Antonakis J.Considering context in psychological leadership research.Human Relations. 2009;62:1587-1605
45. Locke K,Golden-Biddle K,Feldman MS.Making doubt generative: Rethinking the role of doubt in the research process.Organization Science. 2008;19 (6): 907-918
46. Lü J.A comparative study of Sino-US festival culture.Canadian Social Science. 2010;6 (3): 123-132
47. Lucas U,Mladenovic ROvercoming Barriers to Student Understanding: Threshold Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge. Meyer JHFLand R, ed. Oxford: Routledge; 2006:148-159.
48. Maringe F,Carter S.International students’ motivations for studying in UK HE: Insights into the choice and decision making of African students.International Journal of Educational Marketing. 2007;21 (6): 459-475
49. Meindl JR,Ehrlich SB,Dukerich JM.The romance of leadership.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1985;30 (1): 78-102
50. Meyer JHF,Land RImproving Student Learning: Theory and Practice Ten Years On. Rust C, ed. Oxford: OCSLD, 412–424; 2003:
51. Meyer JHF,Land R.Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge: Epistemological considerations and a conceptual framework for teaching and learning.Higher Education. 2005;49:373-388
52. Overcoming Barriers to Student Understanding: Threshold Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge. Meyer JHFLand R, ed. Abingdon: Routledge; 2006:
53. Mezirow JTransformative Dimensions of Adult Learning. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass; 1991:
54. Osborn RN,Marion R.Contextual leadership, transformational leadership and the performance of international innovation seeking alliances.Leadership Quarterly. 2009;20:191-206
55. Osborn RN,Hunt JG,Jauch LR.Toward a contextual theory of leadership.Leadership Quarterly. 2002;13:797-837
56. Parker M.Becoming manager: Or, the werewolf looks anxiously in the mirror, checking for unusual facial hair.Management Learning. 2004;35:45-59
57. Pedler M,Burgoyne J,Boydell TA Manager’s Guide to Leadership. London: McGraw-Hill Professional; 2010:
58. Perkins DNOvercoming Barriers to Student Understanding: Threshold Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge. Meyer JHFLand R, ed. Abingdon: Routledge; 2006:33-47.
59. Porter LW,McLaughlin GB.Leadership and the organizational context: Like the weather?.Leadership Quarterly. 2006;17:559-576
60. Pye A.Leadership and organising: Sense-making in action.Leadership. 2005;7:31-49
61. Radin PThe Trickster. New York: Schocken; 1972:
62. Ray T,Clegg S,Gordon RLeadership in Organizations: Current Issues and Key Trends. Storey J, ed. London: Routledge; 2004:319-336.
63. Reimann N,Jackson IOvercoming Barriers to Student Understanding: Threshold Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge. Meyer JHFLand R, ed. Oxford: Routledge; 2006:115-133.
64. Ryan J,Caroll JTeaching International Students: Improving Learning for All. Ryan JCaroll J, ed. Abingdon: Routledge, 3–10; 2005:
65. Schedlitzki D,Kempster S,Edwards G.Anxiety and desire in leader becoming.Paper presented at the Developing Leadership Capacity Conference, Bristol Business School; 2011Bristol, UK; 2011.
66. Shanahan M,Meyer JHFOvercoming Barriers to Student Understanding: Threshold Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge. Meyer JHFLand R, ed. Oxford: Routledge; 2006:100-114.
67. Sinclair A.Teaching leadership critically to MBAs: Experiences from heaven and hell.Management Learning. 2007;38:458-471
68. Sinclair AThe SAGE Handbook of Leadership. Bryman ACollinson DGrint K, ed. London: SAGE; 2011:508-517.
69. Sveningsson SF,Larsson M.Fantasies of leadership: Identity work.Leadership. 2006;2 (2): 203-224
70. Thorpe R,Gold J,Lawler J.Locating distributed leadership.International Journal of Management Reviews. 2011;13 (3): 239-250
71. Turner VThe Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. London: Routledge; 1969:
72. Turner V.Frame, flow and reflection: Ritual and drama in public liminality.Japanese Journal of Religious Studies. 1979;6 (4): 465-499
73. Turner VBetwixt and between: Patterns of Masculine and Feminine Initiation. Mahdi LCFoster SLittle M, ed. Chicago, IL: Open Court Publishing, 3–19; 1987:
74. Van Gennep AThe Rites of Passage. London: Routledge; 1960:
75. Varga-Atkins T,Ashcroft L.Information skills of undergraduate business students – A comparison of UK and international students.Library Management. 2004;25 (1): 39-55
76. Weick KEOrganizational Wisdom and Executive Courage. Srivasta SCooperrider DL, ed. San Francisco, CA: New Lexington Press, 40–64; 1998:
77. Weick KEThe Future of Leadership. Bennis WSpreitzer GMCummings TG, ed. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass; 2001:91-102.
78. Weick KE,Sutcliffe K,Obstfeld D.Organizing and the process of sensemaking.Organization Science. 2005;16:409-421
79. Western SLeadership: A Critical Text. London: SAGE; 2008:
80. Wheatley MPracticing Servant-Leadership: Succeeding through Trust, Bravery, and Forgiveness. Spears LCLawrence M, ed. Indianapolis, IN: Jossey-Bass; 2004:241-268.
81. Wright AL,Gilmore A.Threshold concepts and conceptions: Student learning in introductory management courses.Journal of Management Education. 2012;36:614-635
82. Yip J,Raelin JA.Threshold concepts and modalities for teaching leadership practice.Management Learning. 2012;43:333-354
83. Zoller HM,Fairhurst GT.Resistance as leadership: A critical, discursive perspective.Human Relations. 2007;60:1331-1360