Living up to the past? Ideological sensemaking in organizational transition

Organization

Volumn 21, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 543-567

  Maclean, Mairi ^a   Harvey, Charles ^b   Sillince, John A A ^b   Golant, Benjamin D ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER BUSINESS SCHOOL   (United Kingdom)

^b NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY BUSINESS SCHOOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Historical narrative; ideological sensemaking; interpellation; longitudinal analysis; organizational transition; storytelling

Indexed keywords

EID: 84907068501     PISSN: 13505084     EISSN: 14617323     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1350508414527247     Document Type: Article

References (137)

1. Althusser L.Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays. Althusser L., ed. London: Monthly Review Press; 1971:85-126.
2. Alvesson M.Organizational Symbolism and Ideology.Journal of Management Studies. 1991;28 (3): 207-25
3. Alvesson M.Organizations as Rhetoric: Knowledge-Intensive Firms and the Struggle with Ambiguity.Journal of Management Studies. 2007;30 (6): 997-1015
4. Bakken T.,Hernes T.Organizing Is Both a Verb and a Noun: Weick Meets Whitehead.Organization Studies. 2006;27 (11): 1599-616
5. Barley S. R.,Kunda G.Design and Devotion: Surges of Rational and Normative Ideologies of Control in Managerial Discourse.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1992;37:363-99
6. Barry D.,Elmes M.Strategy Retold: Toward a Narrative View of Strategic Discourse.Academy of Management Review. 1997;22 (2): 429-52
7. Basbøll T.Softly Constrained Imagination: Plagiarism and Misprision in the Theory of Organizational Sensemaking.Culture and Organization. 2010;16 (2): 163-78
8. Basbøll T.,Graham H.Substitutes for Strategy Research: Notes on the Source of Karl Weick’s Anecdote of the Young Lieutenant and the Map of the Pyrenees.Ephemera. 2006;6 (2): 194-204
9. Bendix R.Work and Authority in Industry: Managerial Ideologies in the Course of Industrialization. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers; 1956:
10. Bendix R.Industrialization, Ideologies, and Social Structure.American Sociological Review. 1959;24 (5): 613-23
11. Berg B. L.Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences. (2009) Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences, 7th ed.London: Pearson.London: Pearson; 2009:
12. Bergson H.Creative Evolution. New York: Henry Holt; 1911/2009:
13. Bernheim B. D.,Whinston M. D.Incomplete Contracts and Strategic Ambiguity.American Economic Review. 1998;88 (4): 902-32
14. Bettelheim B.The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales. London: Penguin Books; 1975:
15. Beyer J. M.Handbook of Organizational Design. Nystrom P. C.Starbuck W. H., ed. London: Sage; 1981:166-202.
16. Beyer J. M.,Dunbar R. L.,Meyer A. D.Comment: The Concept of Ideology in Organizational Analysis.Academy of Management Review. 1988;13 (3): 483-89
17. Billig M.Ideology and Opinions: Studies in Rhetorical Psychology. London: Sage; 1991:
18. Boje D.Storytelling Organizations. London: Sage; 2008:
19. Booth C.,Clark P.,Delahaye A., et al.Accounting for the Dark Side of Corporate History: Organizational Culture Perspectives and the Bertelsmann Case.Critical Perspectives on Accounting. 2007;18 (6): 625-44
20. Brown A. D.,Humphreys M.Nostalgia and the Narrativization of Identity: A Turkish Case Study.British Journal of Management. 2002;13 (2): 141-59
21. Brown A. D.,Jones M.Honourable Members and Dishonourable Deeds: Sensemaking, Impression Management and Legitimation in the “Arms to Iraq Affair”.Human Relations. 2000;53 (5): 655-89
22. Brown A. D.,Stacey P.,Nandhakumar J.Making Sense of Sensemaking Narratives.Human Relations. 2008;61 (8): 1035-62
23. Brown R. H.Bureaucracy as Praxis: Toward a Political Phenomenology of Formal Organizations.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1978;23:365-82
24. Carlsen A.Organizational Becoming as Dialogic Imagination of Practice: The Case of the Indomitable Gauls.Organization Science. 2006;17 (1): 132-49
25. Casey A. J.,Olivera F.Reflections on Organizational Memory and Forgetting.Journal of Management Inquiry. 2011;20 (3): 305-10
26. Chreim S.The Continuity-Change Duality in Narrative Texts of Organizational Identity.Journal of Management Studies. 2005;42:567-93
27. Chreim S.Managerial Frames and Institutional Discourses of Change: Employee Appropriation and Resistance.Organization Studies. 2006;27 (9): 1261-87
28. Clegg S. R.Frameworks of Power. London: Sage; 1989:
29. Costea B.,Crump N.,Holm J.Conceptual History and the Interpretation of Managerial Ideologies.Management & Organizational History. 2006;1 (2): 159-75
30. Creed W. E. D.,Scully M. A.,Austin J. R.Clothes Make the Person? The Tailoring of Legitimating Accounts and the Social Construction of Identity.Organization Science. 2002;13 (5): 475-96
31. Czarniawska-Joerges B.Ideological Control in Nonideological Organizations. New York: Praeger; 1988:
32. Davenport S.,Leitch S.Circuits of Power in Practice: Strategic Ambiguity as Delegation of Authority.Organization Studies. 2005;26 (11): 1603-23
33. Dellheim C.Business in Time: The Historian and Corporate Culture.Public Historian. 1986;8 (2): 9-22
34. Denison D. R.,Mishra A. K.Toward a Theory of Organizational Culture and Effectiveness.Organization Science. 1995;6 (2): 204-23
35. Dodgson M.,Gann D.,Salter A.The Role of Technology in the Shift towards Open Innovation: The Case of Procter & Gamble.R & D Management. 2006;36 (3): 333-46
36. Dutton J. E.,Dukerich J. M.Keeping an Eye on the Mirror: Image and Identity in Organizational Adaptation.Academy of Management Journal. 1991;34 (3): 517-54
37. Dyer D.,Dalzell F.,Olegario R.Rising Tide: Lessons from 165 Years of Brand Building at Procter & Gamble. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press; 2004:
38. Eisenberg E.Ambiguity as Strategy in Organizational Communication.Communication Monographs. 1984;51:227-42
39. Enteman W. F.Managerialism: The Emergence of a New Ideology. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press; 1993:
40. Feldman R. M.,Feldman S. P.What Links the Chain: An Essay on Organizational Remembering as Practice.Organization. 2006;13 (6): 861-87
41. Filby I.,Willmott H.Ideologies and Contradictions in a Public Relations Department: The Seduction and Impotence of Living Myth.Organization Studies. 1988;9 (3): 335-49
42. Fineman S.On Being Positive: Concerns and Counterpoints.Academy of Management Review. 2006;31 (2): 270-91
43. Gabriel Y.Storytelling in Organizations: Facts, Fictions and Fantasies. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2000:
44. Gabriel Y.Myths, Stories and Organizations: Premodern Narratives for Our Times. Gabriel Y., ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2004:17-31.
45. Giddens A.New Rules of Sociological Method. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press; 1993:
46. Gioia D. A.,Chittipeddi K.Sensemaking and Sensegiving in Strategic Change Initiation.Strategic Management Journal. 1991;12:433-48
47. Gioia D. A.,Schultz M.,Corley K. G.Organizational Identity, Image, and Adaptive Instability.Academy of Management Review. 2000;25 (1): 63-81
48. Halbwachs M.La mémoire Collective. Paris: PUF; 1950:
49. Hansen P. H.Organizational Culture and Organizational Change: The Transformation of Savings Banks in Denmark, 1965–1990.Enterprise & Society. 2007;8 (4): 920-53
50. Hansen P. H.Business History: A Cultural and Narrative Approach.Business History Review. 2012;86:693-717
51. Hardy C.,Palmer I.,Phillips N.Discourse as a Strategic Resource.Human Relations. 2000;53 (9): 1227-48
52. Harvey C.,Maclean M.,Gordon J., et al.Andrew Carnegie and the Foundations of Contemporary Entrepreneurial Philanthropy.Business History. 2011a;53 (3): 424-48
53. Harvey C.,Press J.,Maclean M.William Morris, Cultural Leadership and the Dynamics of Taste.Business History Review. 2011b;85 (2): 245-71
54. Heracleous L.,Barrett M.Organizational Change as Discourse: Communicative Actions and Deep Structures in the Context of Information Technology Implementation.Academy of Management Journal. 2001;44 (4): 755-78
55. Hobsbawm E.The Invention of Tradition. Hobsbawm E.Ranger T., ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1983:1-14.
56. Hollinshead G.,Park K. M.Logics and Limits in Ethical Outsourcing in the Global Financial Services Industry.Competition and Change. 2011;15 (3): 177-95
57. London, UK: C. Harvey and M. Maclean; 2008 2008:
58. Newcastle upon Tyne, UK: C. Harvey; 2011 2011:
59. Delhi, India: C. Harvey; 2011 2011:
60. Kieser A.Why Organization Theory Needs Historical Analyses—And How This Should Be Performed.Organization Science. 1994;5 (4): 608-20
61. Louis M.Surprise and Sensemaking: What Newcomers Experience in Entering Unfamiliar Organizational Settings.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1980;25:226-51
62. Lüscher L. S.,Lewis M. W.Organizational Change and Managerial Sensemaking: Working through Paradox.Academy of Management Journal. 2008;51 (2): 221-40
63. Maclean M.New Rules—Old Games? Social Capital and Privatisation in France, 1986–1998.Business History. 2008;50 (6): 795-810
64. Maclean M.,Harvey C.,Chia R.Sensemaking, Storytelling and the Legitimization of Elite Business Careers.Human Relations. 2012;65 (1): 17-40
65. Maclean M.,Harvey C.,Press J.Business Elites and Corporate Governance in France and the UK. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan; 2006:
66. Maclean M.,Harvey C.,Press J.Managerialism and the Postwar Evolution of the French National Business System.Business History. 2007;49 (4): 531-51
67. McPhee R. D.Text, Agency, and Organization in the Light of Structuration Theory.Organization. 2004;11 (3): 355-71
68. Marx K.The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte. New York: BiblioLife, LLC; 1852/1897:
69. Meyer A. D.How Ideologies Supplant Formal Structures and Shape Responses to Environments.Journal of Management Studies. 1982;19 (1): 45-61
70. Mills A. J.,Weatherbee T. G.,Durepos G.Reassembling Weber to Reveal the-Past-as-History in Management and Organization Studies.Organization. 2014;21 (2): 225-243
71. Mueller F.,Sillince J.,Harvey C., et al.“A Rounded Picture Is What We Need”: Rhetorical Strategies, Arguments, and the Negotiation of Change in a UK Hospital Trust.Organization Studies. 2003;25 (1): 75-93
72. Nissley N.,Casey A.The Politics of the Exhibition: Viewing Corporate Museums through the Paradigmatic Lens of Organizational Memory.British Journal of Management. 2002;13:S35-45
73. ARA (Annual Reports and Accounts series): N.H. McElroy, ‘President’s report to shareholders for year ended 30 June 1954’. 1954;:
74. ARA: H.J. Morgens, ‘President’s report to shareholders for year ended 30 June 1959’. 1959;:
75. EXS (Executive Speech Series): W.L. [Jake] Lingle, ‘The character of the company’, 15 December 1960. 1960;:
76. ARA: H.J. Morgens, ‘President’s report to shareholders for year ended 30 June 1969’. 1969;:
77. EXS: H.J. Morgens, ‘Excerpts from Howard Morgens’ year-end management dinner talks, 1963-1973’. 1973;:
78. ARA: Special feature on history and values, ‘Procter & Gamble—A company built on individual freedom and initiative’. 1976;:
79. ARA: Special feature introduced by J.G. Smale, Chairman and CEO, ‘Procter & Gamble—Celebrating 150 years of excellence, 1837–1987’. 1987a;:
80. EXS: J.G. Smale, ‘Remarks to shareholders’ meeting’, 13 October 1987. 1987b;:
81. EXS: J.G. Smale, ‘Worldwide management meeting’, 18 April 1988. 1988;:
82. ARA: E.L. Artzt, ‘President’s report to shareholders for year ended 30 June 1990’. 1990;:
83. W.L. Lingle’. Oral history interview, conducted c. 1993. 1993;:
84. D.P. Fite’. Oral history interview, conducted 15 June 1994. 1994a;:
85. O.B. Butler’. Oral history interview, conducted 26–27 September 1994. 1994b;:
86. T.C. Bower’. Oral history interview, conducted 2 November 1994. 1994c;:
87. EXS: E.L. Artzt, ‘Unchanging values in changing times’, November 1993, reproduced in P&G World, January–March 1994. 1994d;:
88. EXS: J.E. Pepper, ‘Keys to P&G’s success’, 21 March 1995. 1995;:
89. EXS: J.E. Pepper, ‘P&G: A personal perspective’, 30 May 1996. 1996;:
90. EXS: J.E. Pepper, ‘Creating our future: The evolution of Procter & Gamble’, 20 August 1998. 1998a;:
91. EXS: J.E. Pepper and D.I. Jager, ‘Address to shareholders’, 13 October 1998. 1998b;:
92. ARA: A.G. Lafley and J.E. Pepper, ‘To our shareholders’, 7 August 2001. 2001;:
93. ARA: A.G. Lafley, Financial review, 5 August 2002. 2002;:
94. EXS: J.E. Pepper, ‘P&G—More than a company: An institution and community’, 2003 P&G alumni meeting, Cincinnati, undated. 2003;:
95. Building for the future: Procter & Gamble organizational evolution’. Timeline, 1837–2010. 2010;:
96. Procter & Gamble Corporate Website (P&GCW) (2012a) ‘Dear son William’. Letter from Procter Sr to William Procter, 11 January 1832. Retrieved December 30, from http://www.pg.com/en_US/company/heritage/featured_stories.shtml
97. Procter & Gamble Corporate Website (P&GCW) (2012b) ‘William Procter’s pilgrimage to Cincinnati’, Retrieved December 30, from http://news.pg.com/blog/childrens-safe-drinking-water/william-procters-pilgrimage-cincinnati
98. Parker M.Contesting Histories: Unity and Division in a Building Society.Journal of Organizational Change Management. 2002;15 (6): 589-605
99. Pemer F.,Näslund L.Dominant Stories as a Source of Organizational Inertia.Human Relations. 2012;65 (1): 89-110
100. Pepper J.What Really Matters: Reflections on My Career at Procter & Gamble with Guiding Principles for Success in the Marketplace and in Life. Cincinnati, OH: P&G; 2005:
101. Pettigrew A.The Awakening Giant: Continuity and Change in ICI. Oxford: Blackwell; 1985:
102. Prasad P.,Prasad A.The Ideology of Professionalism and Work Computerization: An Institutionalist Study of Technological Change.Human Relations. 1994;47 (12): 1433-58
103. Pratt M. G.Building an Ideological Fortress: The Role of Spirituality, Encapsulation and Sensemaking.Studies in Cultures, Organizations and Societies. 2000a;6 (1): 35-69
104. Pratt M. G.The Good, the Bad and the Ambivalent: Managing Identification among Amway Distributors.Administrative Science Quarterly. 2000b;45 (3): 456-93
105. Reay T.,Hinings C. R.Managing the Rivalry of Competing Institutional Logics.Organization Studies. 2009;30 (6): 629-52
106. Rennstam J.Object-Control: A Study of Technologically Dense Knowledge Work.Organization Studies. 2012;33 (8): 1071-90
107. Ricoeur P.Phenomenology and the Social Sciences. Bien J., ed. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff; 1978:44-59.
108. Ricoeur P.Time and Narrative. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 1984:
109. Rowlinson M.,Carter C.Foucault and History in Organization Studies.Organization. 2002;9 (4): 527-47
110. Rowlinson M.,Hassard J.The Invention of Corporate Culture: A History of the Histories of Cadbury.Human Relations. 1993;46 (3): 299-326
111. Rowlinson M.,Procter S.Organizational Culture and Business History.Organization Studies. 1999;20 (3): 369-96
112. Rowlinson M.,Booth C.,Clark P., et al.Social Remembering and Organizational Memory.Organization Studies. 2010;31 (1): 69-87
113. Schultz M.,Hernes T.A Temporal Perspective on Organizational Identity.Organization Science. 2013;24 (1): 1-21
114. Selznick P.Leadership in Administration: A Sociological Interpretation. Evanston, IL: Row, Peterson & Co; 1957:
115. Seo M.-G.,Creed W. E. D.Institutional Contradictions, Praxis, and Institutional Change: A Dialectical Perspective.Academy of Management Review. 2002;27 (2): 222-47
116. Simons T.,Ingram P.Organization and Ideology: Kibbutzim and Hired Labour, 1951–1965.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1997;42:784-813
117. Sonenshein S.The Role of Construction, Intuition, and Justification in Responding to Ethical Issues at Work: The Sensemaking-Intuition Model.Academy of Management Review. 2007;22 (4): 1022-40
118. Sonenshein S.We’re Changing—Or are We? Untangling the Role of Progressive, Regressive, and Stability Narratives during Strategic Change Implementation.Academy of Management Journal. 2010;53 (3): 477-512
119. Suddaby R.,Greenwood R.Rhetorical Strategies of Legitimacy.Administrative Science Quarterly. 2005;50:35-67
120. Suddaby R.,Foster W. M.,Mills A. J.Organizations in Time: History, Theory, Methods. Bucheli M.Wadhwani R. D., ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2014:100-23.
121. Suddaby R.,Foster W. M.,Trank C. Q.Globalization of Strategy Research. Baum J. A. C.Lampel J., ed. London: Emerald Group Publishing; 2010:147-73.
122. Taylor S.,Bell E.,Cooke B.Business History and the Historiographical Operation.Management & Organizational History. 2009;4 (2): 151-66
123. Tsoukas H.,Chia R.On Organizational Becoming: Rethinking Organizational Change.Organization Science. 2002;13 (5): 567-82
124. Vaara E.,Kleymann B.,Seristö H.Strategies as Discursive Constructions: The Case of Airline Alliances.Journal of Management Studies. 2004;41 (1): 1-35
125. Walsh J. P.,Ungson P.Organizational Memory.Academy of Management Review. 1991;16:57-90
126. Watson T. J.Group Ideologies and Organizational Change.Journal of Management Studies. 1982;19 (3): 259-75
127. Watson T. J.Rhetoric, Discourse and Argument in Organizational Sense Making: A Reflexive Tale.Organization Studies. 1995;16 (5): 805-21
128. Weick K. E.Misconceptions about Managerial Productivity.Business Horizons. 1983;26 (4): 47-52
129. Weick K. E.Enacted Sensemaking in Crisis Situations.Journal of Management Studies. 1988;24 (4): 305-17
130. Weick K. E.Sensemaking in Organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 1995:
131. Weick K. E.Dear Editor: A Response to Basbøll and Graham.Ephemera. 2006;6 (2): 193
132. Weick K. E.Making Sense of the Organization, vol.2: The Impermanent Organization. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons; 2009:
133. Weick K. E.,Sutcliffe K. M.,Obstfeld D.Organizing and the Process of Sensemaking.Organization Science. 2005;16 (4): 409-21
134. Weiss J.,Miller L.The Concept of Ideology in Organizational Analysis.Academy of Management Review. 1987;12:104-16
135. Whittington R.Strategy as Practice.Long Range Planning. 1996;29 (5): 731-35
136. Whittle A.,Mueller F.Bankers in the Dock: Moral Storytelling in Action.Human Relations. 2012;65 (1): 111-39
137. Ybema S.Talk of Change: Temporal Contrasts and Collective Identities.Organization Studies. 2010;31 (4): 481-503