Why it is hard to find genes associated with social science traits: Theoretical and empirical considerations

American Journal of Public Health

Volumn 103, Issue SUPPL.1, 2013, Pages

  Chabris, Christopher F ^a   Lee, James J ^b   Benjamin, Daniel J ^c   Beauchamp, Jonathan P ^d   Glaeser, Edward L ^d   Borst, Gregoire ^b   Pinker, Steven ^b   Laibson, David I ^d  

^a UNION COLLEGE   (United States)

^b HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c Department of Obstetrics Gynecology   (United States)

^d HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; ARTICLE; BEHAVIOR; CELLULAR, SUBCELLULAR AND MOLECULAR BIOLOGICAL PHENOMENA AND FUNCTIONS; EYE COLOR; FEMALE; GENE; GENETIC ASSOCIATION; GENETIC SELECTION; GENETICS; HAIR COLOR; HUMAN; MALE; PERSONALITY; QUESTIONNAIRE; SINGLE NUCLEOTIDE POLYMORPHISM; SOCIOLOGY;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; BEHAVIOR; BIOLOGICAL PHENOMENA; EYE COLOR; FEMALE; GENES; GENETIC RESEARCH; GENOME-WIDE ASSOCIATION STUDY; HAIR COLOR; HUMANS; MALE; PERSONALITY; POLYMORPHISM, SINGLE NUCLEOTIDE; QUESTIONNAIRES; SELECTION, GENETIC; SOCIAL SCIENCES; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84884140919     PISSN: 00900036     EISSN: 15410048     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2105/AJPH.2013.301327     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Plomin R, DeFries JC, McClearn GE, McGuffin P. Behavioral Genetics. 5th ed. New York, NY: Worth Publishers; 2008.
2. Turkheimer E. Three laws of behavior genetics and what they mean. Curr Dir Psychol Sci. 2000;9(5): 160-164.
3. Pinker S. The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature. New York, NY: Viking; 2002.
4. Benjamin DJ, Cesarini D, Chabris CF, et al. The promises and pitfalls of genoeconomics. Annu Rev Econom. 2012;4(1): 627-662.
5. Cecil JE, Tavendale R, Watt P, Hetherington MM, Palmer CAN. An obesity-associated FTO gene variant and increased energy intake in children. N Engl J Med. 2008;359(24): 2558-2566.
6. Israel S, Lerer E, Shalev I, et al. The oxytocin receptor (OXTR) contributes to prosocial fund allocations in the dictator game and the social value orientations task. PLoS ONE. 2009;4(5):e5535.
7. Apicella CL, Cesarini D, Johannesson M, et al. No association between oxytocin receptor (OXTR) gene polymorphisms experimentally elicited social preferences. PLoS ONE. 2010;5(6):e11153.
8. Hirschhorn JN. Genomewide association studies - illuminating biologic pathways. N Engl J Med. 2009;360 (17): 1699-1701.
9. Chen L, Davey Smith G, Harbord R, Lewis S. Alcohol intake and blood pressure: a systematic review implementing Mendelian randomization approach. PLoS Med. 2008;5(3):e52.
10. Fletcher J, Lehrer S. The effects of adolescent health on educational outcomes: causal evidence using genetic lotteries between siblings. Forum Health Econ Policy. 2009;12(2): 1-33.
11. Chabris CF, Hebert BM, Benjamin DJ, et al. Most published genetic associations with general intelligence are probably false positives. Psychol Sci. 2012;23(11): 1314-1323.
12. Benjamin DJ, Cesarini D, van der Loos MJ, et al. The genetic architecture of economic and political preferences. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012;109(21): 8026-8031.
13. Beauchamp JP, Cesarini D, Johannesson M, et al. Molecular genetics and economics. J Econ Perspect. 2011; 25(4): 57-82.
14. Boomsma D, Busjahn A, Peltonen L. Classical twin studies and beyond. Nat Rev Genet. 2002;3(11): 872-882.
15. Visscher PM. Sizing up human height variation. Nat Genet. 2008;40(5): 489-490.
16. Bouchard TJ. Genetic influence on human psychological traits: a survey. Curr Dir Psychol Sci. 2004;13 (4): 148-151.
17. Cesarini D, Johannesson M, Magnusson PK, Wallace B. The behavioral genetics of behavioral anomalies. Manage Sci. 2012;58(1): 21-34.
18. Cesarini D, Johannesson M, Lichtenstein P, Sandewall O, Wallace B. Genetic variation in financial decision-making. J Finance. 2010;65(5): 1725-1754.
19. Cesarini D, Dawes CT, Fowler J, Johannesson M, Lichtenstein P, Wallace B. Heritability of cooperative behavior in the trust game. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008;105(10): 3721-3726.
20. Taubman P. The determinants of earnings: Genetics, family, and other environments: A study of White male twins. Am Econ Rev. 1976;66(5): 858-870.
21. Plomin R, Owen MJ, McGuffin P. The genetic basis of complex human behaviors. Science. 1994;264(5166): 1733-1739.
22. Barnea A, Cronqvist H, Siegel S. Nature or Nurture: What Determines Investor Behavior? J Financ Econ. 2010;98(3): 583-604.
23. Manolio TA, Collins FS, Cox NJ, et al. Finding the missing heritability of complex diseases. Nature. 2009; 461(7265): 747-753.
24. Zuk O, Hechter E, Sunyaev SR, Lander ES. The mystery of missing heritability: genetic interactions create phantom heritability. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012; 109(4): 1193-1198.
25. Yang J, Benyamin B, McEvoy BP, et al. Common SNPs explain a large proportion of the heritability for human height. Nat Genet. 2010;42(7): 565-569.
26. Davies G, Tenesa A, Payton A, et al. Genome-wide association studies establish that human intelligence is highly heritable and polygenic. Mol Psychiatry. 2011;16 (10): 996-1005.
27. Dickson SP, Wang K, Krantz I, Hakonarson HH, Goldstein DB. Rare variants create synthetic genomewide associations. PLoS Biol. 2010;8(1):e1000294.
28. Wray NR, Purcell SM, Visscher PM. Synthetic associations created by rare variants do not explain most GWAS results. PLoS Biol. 2011;9(1):e1000579.
29. Sturm RA. Molecular genetics of human pigmentation diversity. Hum Mol Genet. 2009;18(R1):R9-R17.
30. Sturm RA, Duffy DL, Zhao ZZ, et al. A single SNP in an evolutionary conserved region within intron 86 of the HERC2 gene determines human blue-brown eye color. Am J Hum Genet. 2008;82(2): 424-431.
31. Fisher RA. The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection: A Complete Variorum Edition. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 1999.
32. Crow JF. Basic concepts in population, quantitative, and evolutionary genetics. New York, NY: Freeman; 1986.
33. Lande R. Quantitative genetic analysis of multivariate evolution, applied to brain: body size allometry. Evolution. 1979;33(1 pt 2): 402-416.
34. Lynch M, Walsh B. Genetics and the Analysis of Quantitative Traits. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer; 1998.
35. Wright S. The distribution of gene frequencies under irreversible mutation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1938;24(7): 253-259.
36. Hastings A. Second-order approximations for selection coefficients at polygenic loci. J Math Biol. 1990;28 (4): 475-483.
37. Eyre-Walker A. Genetic architecture of a complex trait and its implications for fitness and genome-wide association studies. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010;107 (suppl 1): 1752-1756.
38. Cesarini D, Dawes CT, Johannesson M, Lichtenstein P, Wallace B. Experimental game theory and behavior genetics. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2009;1167(1): 66-75.
39. Campbell CD, Ogburn EL, Lunetta KL, et al. Demonstrating stratification in a European American population. Nat Genet. 2005;37(8): 868-872.
40. Purcell S, Neale B, Todd-Brown K, et al. PLINK: a tool set for whole-genome association and populationbased linkage analyses. Am J Hum Genet. 2007;81(3): 559-575.
41. McCarthy MI, Abecasis GR, Cardon LR, et al. Genome-wide association studies for complex traits: consensus, uncertainty and challenges. Nat Rev Genet. 2008;9(5): 356-369.
42. Wellcome Trust Case Control Consortium. Genomewide association study of 14,000 cases of seven common diseases and 3,000 shared controls. Nature. 2007; 447(7145): 661-678.
43. Pearl J. Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference. 2nd ed. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press; 2009.
44. Lee JJ. Correlation and causation in the study of personality (with discussion). Eur J Pers. 2012;26(4): 379-412.
45. Geiger D, Pearl J. On the logic of causal models. In: Proceedings of the Fourth Workshop on Uncertainty in AI. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: North-Holland; 1988: 136-147.
46. Ball MP, Thakuria JV, Zaranek AW, et al. A public resource facilitating clinical use of genomes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012;109(30): 11920-11927.
47. Eriksson N, Macpherson JM, Tung JY, et al. Webbased, participant- driven studies yield novel genetic associations for common traits. PLoS Genet. 2010;6(6): e1000993.
48. Jackson DN. Multidimensional Aptitude Battery-II. Port Huron, MI: Sigma Assessment Systems; 1998.
49. Costa PT, McCrae RR. NEO Personality Inventory- Revised (NEO-PI-R) and NEO Five-Factor Inventory (NEO FFI) Professional Manual. Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources; 1992.
50. Aitken Harris J, Vernon PA, Jang KL. Testing the differentiation of personality by intelligence hypothesis. Pers Individ Dif. 2005;38(2): 277-286.
51. Stokowski RP, Pant PV, Dadd T, et al. A genomewide association study of skin pigmentation in a South Asian population. Am J Hum Genet. 2007;81(6): 1119-1132.
52. Sulem P, Gudbjartsson DF, Stacey SN, et al. Genetic determinants of hair, eye and skin pigmentation in Europeans. Nat Genet. 2007;39(12): 1443-1452.
53. Sulem P, Gudbjartsson DF, Stacey SN, et al. Two newly identified genetic determinants of pigmentation in Europeans. Nat Genet. 2008;40(7): 835-837.
54. Han J, Kraft P, Nan H, et al. A genome-wide association study identifies novel alleles associated with hair color and skin pigmentation. PLoS Genet. 2008;4(5):e1000074.
55. Liu F, Wollstein A, Hysi PG, et al. Digital quantification of human eye color highlights genetic association of three new loci. PLoS Genet. 2010;6(5):e1000934.
56. Lango Allen H, Estrada K, Lettre G, et al. Hundreds of variants clustered in genomic loci and biological pathways affect human height. Nature. 2010;467(7317): 832-838.
57. MacArthur DG, Seto JT, Raftery JM, et al. Loss of ACTN3 gene function alters mouse muscle metabolism and shows evidence of positive selection in humans. Nat Genet. 2007;39(10): 1261-1265.
58. Speliotes EK, Willer CJ, Berndt SI, et al. Association analyses of 249,796 individuals reveal 18 new loci associated with body mass index. Nat Genet. 2010;42 (11): 937-948.
59. Payton A, Holland F, Diggle P, et al. Cathepsin D exon 2 polymorphism associated with general intelligence in a healthy older population. Mol Psychiatry. 2003;8(1): 14-18.
60. Plomin R, Turic TM, Hill L, et al. A functional polymorphism in the succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase (aldehyde dehydrogenase 5 family, member A1) gene is associated with cognitive ability. Mol Psychiatry. 2004;9(6): 582-586.
61. Gosso MF, van Belzen M, de Geus EJC, et al. Association between the CHRM2 gene and intelligence in a sample of 304 Dutch families. Genes Brain Behav. 2006;5(8): 577-584.
62. Gosso MF, de Geus EJC, van Belzen MJ, et al. The SNAP-25 gene is associated with cognitive ability: evidence from a family-based study in two independent Dutch cohorts. Mol Psychiatry. 2006;11(9): 878-886.
63. Zinkstok JR, de Wilde O, van Amelsvoort TA, et al. Association between the DTNBP1 gene and intelligence: a case-control study in young patients with schizophrenia and related disorders and unaffected siblings. Behav Brain Funct. 2007;3(1): 19.
64. van den Oord EJ, Kuo PH, Hartmann AM, et al. Genomewide association analysis followed by a replication study implicates a novel candidate gene for neuroticism. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2008;65(9): 1062-1071.
65. de Moor MH, Costa PT, Terracciano A, et al. Metaanalysis of genome-wide association studies for personality. Mol Psychiatry. 2012;17(3): 337-349.
66. Egan MF, Goldberg TE, Kolachana BS, et al. Effect of COMT Val108/158 Met genotype on frontal lobe function and risk for schizophrenia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2001;98(12): 6917-6922.
67. Papassotiropoulos A, Stephan DA, Huentelman MJ, et al. Common Kibra alleles are associated with human memory performance. Science. 2006;314(5798): 475-478.
68. Need AC, Attix DK, McEvoy JM, et al. Failure to replicate effect of Kibra on human memory in two large cohorts of European origin. Am J Med Genet B Neuropsychiatr Genet. 2008;147B(5): 667-668.
69. Jost JT, Glaser J, Kruglanski AW, Sulloway FJ. Political conservatism as motivated social cognition. Psychol Bull. 2003;129(3): 339-375.
70. Hirsh JB, DeYoung CG, Xu X, Peterson JB. Compassionate liberals and polite conservatives: Associations of agreeableness with political ideology and moral values. Pers Soc Psychol Bull. 2010;36(5): 655-664.
71. Davis OS, Butcher LM, Docherty SJ, et al. A threestage genome-wide association study of general cognitive ability: hunting the small effects. Behav Genet. 2010; 40(6): 759-767.
72. Verweij KJH, Zietsch BP, Medland SE, et al. A genome-wide association study of Cloninger's temperament scales: implications for the evolutionary genetics of personality. Biol Psychol. 2010;85(2): 306-317.
73. Jablonski NG, Chaplin G. Human skin pigmentation as an adaptation to UV radiation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010;107(suppl 2): 8962-8968.
74. Cavalli-Sforza LL, Menozzi P, Piazza A. The History and Geography of Human Genes. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1994.
75. Frost P. European hair and eye color: A case of frequency-dependent sexual selection? Evol Hum Behav. 2006;27(2): 85-103.
76. Cochran G, Harpending H. The 10,000-Year Explosion: How Civilization Accelerated Human Evolution. New York, NY: Basic Books; 2009.
77. Rogers AR, Iltis D, Wooding S. Genetic variation at the MC1R locus and the time since loss of human body hair. Curr Anthropol. 2004;45(1): 105-108.
78. Williamson SH, Hubisz MJ, Clark AG, et al. Localizing recent adaptive evolution in the human genome. PLoS Genet. 2007;3(6):e90.
79. Pickrell JK, Coop G, Novembre J, et al. Signals of recent positive selection in a worldwide sample of human populations. Genome Res. 2009;19(5): 826-837.
80. Bajema CJ. Estimation of the direction and intensity of natural selection in relation to human intelligence by means of the intrinsic rate of natural increase. Eugen Q. 1963;10(4): 175-187.
81. Van Valen L. Brain size and intelligence in man. Am J Phys Anthropol. 1974;40(3): 417-423.
82. Blume M. The reproductive benefits of religious affiliation. In: Voland E, Schiefenhovel W, eds. The Biological Evolution of Religious Mind and Behavior. Berlin, Germany: Springer; 2009: 117-126.
83. Maynard Smith J, Price GR. The logic of animal conflict. Nature. 1973;246(5427): 15-18.
84. Penke L, Denissen JJA, Miller GF. The evolutionary genetics of personality. Eur J Pers. 2007;21(5): 549-587.
85. Kimura M. The Neutral Theory of Molecular Evolution. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 1983.
86. Simonson TS, Yang Y, Huff CD, et al. Genetic evidence for high-altitude adaptation in Tibet. Science. 2010;329(5987): 72-75.
87. Yi X, Liang Y, Huerta-Sanchez E, et al. Sequencing of 50 human exomes reveals adaptation to high altitude. Science. 2010;329(5987): 75-78.
88. Beall CM, Cavalleri GL, Deng L, et al. Natural selection on EPAS1 (HIF2) associated with low hemoglobin concentration in Tibetan highlanders. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010;107(25): 11459-11464.
89. Dolgin E. Personalized investigation. Nat Med. 2010;16(9): 953-955.
90. Lunshof JE, Bobe J, Aach J, et al. Personal genomes in progress: From the Human Genome Project to the Personal Genome Project. Dialogues Clin Neurosci. 2010;12(1): 47-60.
91. Barnett JH, Scoriels L, Munafò MR. Meta-analysis of the cognitive effects of the catechol-O-methyltransferase gene Val158/108Met polymorphism. Biol Psychiatry. 2008;64(2): 137-144.
92. Ioannidis JPA. Non-replication and inconsistency in the genome-wide association setting. Hum Hered. 2007;64(4): 203-213.
93. Carpenter S. Psychology's bold initiative. Science. 2012;335(6076): 1558-1561.