A multi-stakeholder perspective on the use of alternative test strategies for nanomaterial safety assessment

ACS Nano

Volumn 7, Issue 8, 2013, Pages 6422-6433

  Nel, Andre E ^a,b   Nasser, Elina ^a   Godwin, Hilary ^a,b   Avery, David ^a   Bahadori, Tina ^c   Bergeson, Lynn ^d   Beryt, Elizabeth ^a   Bonner, James C ^e   Boverhof, Darrell ^f   Carter, Janet ^g   Castranova, Vince ^h   Deshazo, J R ^a   Hussain, Saber M ⁱ   Kane, Agnes B ^j   Klaessig, Frederick ^a,k   Kuempel, Eileen ^h   Lafranconi, Mark ^l   Landsiedel, Robert ^m   Malloy, Timothy ^a   Miller, Mary Beth ⁿ   Morris, Jeffery ^c   Moss, Kenneth ^c   Oberdorster, Gunter ^o   Pinkerton, Kent ^p   Pleus, Richard C ^q   Shatkin, Jo Anne ^a,r   Thomas, Russell ^s   Tolaymat, Thabet ^c   Wang, Amy ^c   Wong, Jeffrey ^t   more..

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^c U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

^d BERGESON AND CAMPBELL P C   (United States)

^e NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^f DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY   (United States)

^g Occupational Safety and Health Administration   (United States)

^h NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH   (United States)

ⁱ AIR FORCE RESEARCH LABORATORY   (United States)

^j BROWN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^k Pennsylvania Bio Nano Systems   (United States)

^l Tox Horizons   (United States)

^m BASF SE   (Germany)

ⁿ LOCKHEED MARTIN   (United States)

^o UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER   (United States)

^p UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^q Intertox Inc   (United States)

^r Vireo Advisors   (United States)

^s HAMNER INSTITUTES FOR HEALTH SCIENCES   (United States)

^t California Department of Toxic Substances Control   (United States)

more..

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS; ENGINEERED NANOMATERIALS; EXPONENTIAL INCREASE; HAZARD IDENTIFICATION; HIGH-CONTENT SCREENING; MULTI-STAKEHOLDER PERSPECTIVES; PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS; UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA , LOS ANGELES;

ANIMALS; BIOHAZARDS; NANOSTRUCTURED MATERIALS; RISK ASSESSMENT;

SAFETY ENGINEERING;

CARBON NANOTUBE; NANOMATERIAL;

ANIMAL; CHEMISTRY; HUMAN; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; MATERIALS TESTING; MOUSE; NANOTECHNOLOGY; ORGANIZATION; PROCEDURES; RISK ASSESSMENT; SAFETY; TOXICITY TESTING; ARTICLE; METHODOLOGY;

ANIMALS; CONGRESSES AS TOPIC; HUMANS; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; MATERIALS TESTING; MICE; NANOSTRUCTURES; NANOTECHNOLOGY; NANOTUBES, CARBON; RISK ASSESSMENT; SAFETY; TOXICITY TESTS;

EID: 84883226901     PISSN: 19360851     EISSN: 1936086X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1021/nn4037927     Document Type: Review

References (69)

1. Available from http://www.epa.gov/ncct/toxcast/.
2. Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century: A Vision and a Strategy 2007; National Academy Press: Washington, DC, 2007.
3. Nel, A.; Xia, T.; Meng, H.; Wang, X.; Lin, S.; Ji, Z.; Zhang, H. Nanomaterial Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century: Use of a Predictive Toxicological Approach and High-Throughput Screening Acc. Chem. Res. 2012, 46, 607-621
4. Liu, R.; Rallo, R.; George, S.; Ji, Z.; Nair, S.; Nel, A.; Cohen, Y. Classification NanoSAR Development for Cytotoxicity of Metal Oxide Nanoparticles Small 2011, 7, 1118-1126
5. Liu, R.; Rallo, R.; Weissleder, R.; Tassa, C.; Shaw, S.; Cohen, Y. Nano-SAR Development for Bioactivity of Nanoparticles with Considerations of Decision Boundaries Small 2013, 9, 1842-1852
6. Meng, H.; Xia, T.; George, S.; Nel, A. E. A Predictive Toxicological Paradigm for the Safety Assessment of Nanomaterials ACS Nano 2009, 3, 1620-1627
7. Cote, I.; Anastas, P. T.; Birnbaum, L. S.; Clark, R. M.; Dix, D. J.; Edwards, S. W.; Preuss, P. W. Advancing the Next Generation of Health Risk Assessment Environ. Health Perspect. 2012, 120, 1499-1502
8. Oberdorster, G.; Maynard, A.; Donaldson, K.; Castranova, V.; Fitzpatrick, J.; Ausman, K.; Carter, J.; Karn, B.; Kreyling, W.; Lai, D. et al. Principles for Characterizing the Potential Human Health Effects from Exposure to Nanomaterials: Elements of a Screening Strategy Part. Fibre Toxicol. 2005, 2, 1-35
9. Kuempel, E. D.; Castranova, V.; Geraci, C. L.; Schulte, P. A. Development of Risk-Based Nanomaterial Groups for Occupational Exposure Control J. Nanopart. Res. 2012, 14, 1-15
10. Gangwal, S.; Brown, J. S.; Wang, A.; Houck, K. A.; Dix, D. J.; Kavlock, R. J.; Hubal, E. A. Informing Selection of Nanomaterial Concentrations for ToxCast In Vitro Testing Based on Occupational Exposure Potential Environ. Health Perspect. 2011, 119, 1539-1546
11. Klein, C. L.; Wiench, K.; Wiemann, M.; Ma-Hock, L.; van Ravenzwaay, B.; Landsiedel, R. Hazard Identification of Inhaled Nanomaterials: Making Use of Short-Term Inhalation Studies Arch. Toxicol. 2012, 86, 1137-1151
12. Martin, M. T.; Knudsen, T. B.; Reif, D. M.; Houck, K. A.; Judson, R. S.; Kavlock, R. J.; Dix, D. J. Predictive Model of Rat Reproductive Toxicity from ToxCast High Throughput Screening Biol. Reprod. 2011, 85, 327-339
13. Sipes, N. S.; Martin, M. T.; Reif, D. M.; Kleinstreuer, N. C.; Judson, R. S.; Singh, A. V.; Chandler, K. J.; Dix, D. J.; Kavlock, R. J.; Knudsen, T. B. Predictive Models of Prenatal Developmental Toxicity from ToxCast High-Throughput Screening Data Toxicol. Sci. 2011, 124, 109-127
14. Kleinstreuer, N. C.; Dix, D. J.; Houck, K. A.; Kavlock, R. J.; Knudsen, T. B.; Martin, M. T.; Paul, K. B.; Reif, D. M.; Crofton, K. M.; Hamilton, K. et al. In Vitro Perturbations of Targets in Cancer Hallmark Processes Predict Rodent Chemical Carcinogenesis Toxicol. Sci. 2013, 131, 40-55
15. Rotroff, D. M.; Dix, D. J.; Houck, K. A.; Knudsen, T. B.; Martin, M. T.; McLaurin, K. W.; Reif, D. M.; Crofton, K. M.; Singh, A. V.; Xia, M. et al. Using In Vitro High Throughput Screening Assays To Identify Potential Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals Environ. Health Perspect. 2013, 121, 7-14
16. Kleinstreuer, N. C.; Judson, R. S.; Reif, D. M.; Sipes, N. S.; Singh, A. V.; Chandler, K. J.; Dewoskin, R.; Dix, D. J.; Kavlock, R. J; Knudsen, T. B. Environmental Impact on Vascular Development Predicted by High-Throughput Screening Environ. Health Perspect. 2011, 119, 1596-1603
17. Li, R.; Wang, X.; Ji, Z.; Sun, B.; Zhang, H.; Chang, C. H.; Lin, S.; Meng, H.; Liao, Y. P.; Wang, M. et al. Surface Charge and Cellular Processing of Covalently Functionalized Multiwall Carbon Nanotubes Determine Pulmonary Toxicity ACS Nano 2013, 7, 2352-2368
18. Wang, X.; Xia, T.; Ntim, S. A.; Ji, Z. X.; George, S.; Meng, H.; Zhang, H.; Castranova, V.; Mitra, S.; Nel, A. E. Quantitative Techniques for Assessing and Controlling the Dispersion and Biological Effects of Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes in Mammalian Tissue Culture Cells ACS Nano 2010, 4, 7241-7252
19. Wang, X.; Xia, T.; Ntim, S. A.; Ji, Z.; Lin, S.; Meng, H.; Chung, C.; George, S.; Zhang, H.; Wang, M. et al. Dispersal State of Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes Elicits Pro-Fibrogenic Cellular Responses That Correlate with Fibrogenesis Biomarkers and Fibrosis in the Murine Lung ACS Nano 2011, 5, 9772-9787
20. Wang, X.; Xia, T.; Duch, M. C.; Ji, Z.; Zhang, H.; Li, R.; Sun, B.; Lin, S.; Meng, H.; Liao, Y. P. et al. Pluronic F108 Coating Decreases the Lung Fibrosis Potential of Multiwall Carbon Nanotubes by Reducing Lysosomal Injury Nano Lett. 2012, 12, 3050-3061
21. Zhang, H.; Ji, Z.; Xia, T.; Meng, H.; Low-Kam, C.; Liu, R.; Pokhrel, S.; Lin, S.; Wang, X.; Liao, Y. P. et al. Use of Metal Oxide Nanoparticle Band Gap To Develop a Predictive Paradigm for Oxidative Stress and Acute Pulmonary Inflammation ACS Nano 2012, 6, 4349-4368
22. Pauluhn, J. Subchronic 13-Week Inhalation Exposure of Rats to Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes: Toxic Effects are Determined by Density of Agglomerate Structures, Not Fibrillar Structures Toxicol. Sci. 2010, 113, 226-242
23. Ma-Hock, L.; Treumann, S.; Strauss, V.; Brill, S.; Luizi, F.; Mertler, M.; Wiench, K.; Gamer, A. O.; Van Ravenzwaay, B.; Landsiedel, R. Inhalation Toxicity of Multiwall Carbon Nanotubes in Rats Exposed for 3 Months Toxicol. Sci. 2009, 112, 468-481
24. Delorme, M. P.; Muro, Y.; Arai, T.; Banas, D. A.; Frame, S. R.; Reed, K. L.; Warheit, D. B. Nine-Day Inhalation Toxicity Study with a Vapor Grown Carbon Nanofiber in Rats Toxicol. Sci. 2012, 128, 449-460
25. Shvedova, A. A.; Kisin, E. R.; Mercer, R.; Murray, A. R.; Johnson, V. J.; Potapovich, A. I.; Tyurina, Y. Y.; Gorelik, O.; Arepalli, S.; Schwegler-Berry, D. et al. Unusual Inflammatory and Fibrogenic Pulmonary Responses to Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes in Mice Am. J. Physiol. Lung Cell Mol. Physiol. 2005, 289, L698-L708
26. Shvedova, A. A.; Kisin, E.; Murray, A. R.; Johnson, V. J.; Gorelik, O.; Arepalli, S.; Hubbs, A. F.; Mercer, R. R.; Keohavong, P.; Sussman, N. et al. Inhalation vs. Aspiration of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes in C57BL/6 Mice: Inflammation, Fibrosis, Oxidative Stress, and Mutagenesis Am. J. Physiol. Lung Cell Mol. Physiol. 2008, 295, L552-L565
27. Mercer, R.; Scabilloni, J.; Wang, L.; Kisin, E.; Murray, A. D.; Shvedova, A. A.; Castranova, V. Alteration of Deposition Pattern and Pulmonary Response as a Result of Improved Dispersion of Aspirated Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes in a Mouse Model Am. J. Physiol. Lung Cell Mol. Physiol. 2008, 294, L87-L97
28. Wang, L.; Mercer, R. R.; Rojanasakul, Y.; Qiu, A.; Lu, Y.; Scabilloni, J. F.; Wu, N.; Castranova, V. Direct Fibrogenic Effects of Dispersed Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes on Human Lung Fibroblasts J. Toxicol. Environ. Health, Part A 2010, 73, 410-422
29. Sargent, L. M.; Shvedova, A. A.; Hubbs, A. F.; Salisbury, J. L.; Benkovic, S. A.; Kashon, M. L.; Lowry, D. T.; Murray, A. R.; Kisin, E. R.; Friend, S. et al. Induction of Aneuploidy by Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes Environ. Mol. Mutagen. 2009, 50, 708-717
30. Sargent, L. M.; Hubbs, A. F.; Young, S. H.; Kashon, M. L.; Dinu, C. Z.; Salisbury, J. L.; Benkovic, S. A.; Lowry, D. T.; Murray, A. R.; Kisin, E. R. et al. Single-Walled Carbon Nanotube-Induced Mitotic Disruption Mutat. Res. 2012, 745, 28-37
31. Current Intelligence Bulletin 65: Occupational Exposure to Carbon Nanotubes and Nanofibers; C.f.D.C.a.P. Department of Health and Human Services, National Occupational Safety and Health, Editor 2013.
32. Warshaw, J. The Trend towards Implementing the Precautionary Principle in U.S. Regulation of Nanomaterials Dose-Response 2012, 10, 384-396
33. Consent Order and Determinations Supporting Consent Order, U.S. EPA, Editor Aug 11, 2008.
34. Hamilton, R. F.; Buford, M.; Xiang, C.; Wu, N.; Holian, A. NLRP3 Inflammasome Activation in Murine Alveolar Macrophages and Related Lung Pathology Is Associated with MWCNT Nickle Contamination Inhal. Toxicol. 2012, 24, 995-1008
35. Porter, D. W.; Wu, N.; Hubbs, A. F.; Mercer, R. R.; Funk, K.; Meng, F.; Li, J.; Wolfarth, M. G.; Batteli, L.; Friend, S. et al. Differential Mouse Pulmonary Dose and Time Course Responses to Titanium Dioxide Nanospheres and Nanobelts Toxicol. Sci. 2013, 131, 179-193
36. Sager, T. M.; Wolfarth, M. W.; Andrew, M.; Hubbs, A.; Friend, S.; Chen, T. H.; Porter, D. W.; Wu, N.; Yang, F.; Hamilton, R. F. et al. Effect of Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotube Surface Modification on Bioactivity in the C57BL/6 Mouse Model Nanotoxicology 2013, dx.doi.org/10.3109/17435390.2013.779757
37. Hamilton, R. F.; Xiang, C.; Li, M.; Ka, I.; Yang, F.; Ma, D.; Porter, D. W.; Wu, N.; Holian, A. Purification and Sidewall Functionalization of Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes and Resulting Bioactivity in Two Macrophage Models Inhal. Toxicol. 2013, 25, 199-210
38. Hamilton, R. F.; Wu, N.; Porter, D.; Buford, M.; Wolfarth, M.; Holian, A. Particle Length-Dependent Titanium Dioxide Nanomaterials Toxicity and Bioactivity Part. Fibre Toxicol. 2009, 6, 35
39. Landsiedel, R.; Ma-Hock, L.; Kroll, A.; Hahn, D.; Schnekenburger, J.; Wiench, K.; Wohlleben, W. Testing Metal-Oxide Nanomaterials for Human Safety Adv. Mater. 2010, 22, 2601-2627
40. Duffin, R.; Tran, L.; Brown, D.; Stone, V.; Donaldson, K. Proinflammogenic Effects of Low-Toxicity and Metal Nanoparticles In Vivo and In Vitro: Highlighting the Role of Particle Surface Area and Surface Reactivity Inhal. Toxicol. 2007, 19, 849-856
41. Rushton, E. K.; Jiang, J.; Leonard, S. S.; Eberly, S.; Castranova, V.; Biswas, P.; Elder, A.; Han, X.; Gelein, R.; Finkelstein, J. et al. Concept of Assessing Nanoparticle Hazards Considering Nanoparticle Dosemetric and Chemical/Biological Response Metrics J. Toxicol. Environ. Health, Part A 2010, 73, 445-461
42. Monteiller, C.; Tran, L.; MacNee, W.; Faux, S.; Jones, A.; Miller, B.; Donaldson, K. The Pro-Inflammatory Effects of Low-Toxicity Low Solubility Particles, Nanoparticles and Fine Particles, on Epithelial Cells in Vitro: The Role of Surface Area Occup. Environ. Med. 2007, 64, 609-615
43. Donaldson, K.; Borm, P. J.; Oberdorster, G.; Pinkerton, K. E.; Stone, V.; Tran, C. L. Concordance between In Vitro and In Vivo Dosimetry in the Proinflammatory Effects of Low-Toxicity, Low-Solubility Particles: The Key Role of the Proximal Alveolar Region Inhal. Toxicol. 2008, 20, 53-62
44. Xia, T.; Kovochich, M.; Liong, M.; Madler, L.; Gilbert, B.; Shi, H.; Yeh, J.; Zink, J.; Nel, A. E. Comparison of the Mechanism of Toxicity of Zinc Oxide and Cerium Oxide Nanoparticles Based on Dissolution and Oxidative Stress Properties ACS Nano 2008, 2, 2121-2134
45. Xia, T.; Zhao, Y.; Sager, T.; George, S.; Pokhrel, S.; Li, N.; Schoenfeld, D.; Meng, H.; Lin, S.; Wang, X. et al. Decreased Dissolution of ZnO by Iron Doping Yields Nanoparticles with Reduced Toxicity in the Rodent Lung and Zebrafish Embryos ACS Nano 2011, 5, 1223-1235
46. Leist, M.; Hartung, T. Inflammatory Findings on Species Extrapolations: Humans Are Definitely No 70-kg Mice Arch. Toxicol. 2013, 87, 563-567
47. Slikker, W.; Andersen, M. E.; Bogdanffy, M. S.; Bus, J. S.; Cohen, S. D.; Conolly, R. B.; David, R. M.; Doerrer, N. G.; Dorman, D. C.; Gaylor, D. W. et al. Dose-Dependent Transitions in Mechanisms of Toxicity Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 2004, 201, 203-225
48. ARA, Multiple-Path Particle Deposition (MPPD 2.1): A Model for Human and Rat Airway Particle Dosimetry; Applied Research Associates, Inc: Raleigh, NC, 2011.
49. Hinderliter, P. M.; Minard, K. R.; Orr, G.; Chrisler, W. B.; Thrall, B. D.; Pounds, J. G.; Teeguarden, J. G. ISDD: A Computational Model of Particle Sedimentation, Diffusion and Target Cell Dosimetry for In Vitro Toxicity Studies Part. Fibre Toxicol. 2010, 7, 36
50. Oberdorster, G. Nanotoxicology: In Vitro-In Vivo Dosimetry Environ. Health Perspect. 2012, 120, A13
51. Science and Decisions: Advancing Risk Assessment; National Academy Press: Washington, DC, 2009.
52. Judson, R. S.; Martin, M.; Reif, D.; Houck, K.; Knudsen, T.; Rotroff, D.; Xia, M.; Sakamuru, S.; Huang, R.; Shinn, P. et al. Analysis of Eight Oil Spill Dispersants Using Rapid, In Vitro Tests for Endocrine and Other Biological Activity Environ. Sci. Technol. 2010, 44, 5979-5985
53. Quintero, F. A.; Patel, S. J.; Munoz, F.; Mannan, M. S. Review of Existing QSAR/QSPR Models Developed for Properties Used in Hazardous Chemicals Classification System Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2012, 51, 16101-16115
54. Current Intelligence Bulletin 63: Occupational Exposure to Titanium Dioxide; C.f.D.C.a.P. Department of Health and Human Services, National Occupational Safety and Health, Editor 2011, Cincinnati, Ohio.
55. Naumann, B. D.; Sargent, E. V.; Starkman, B. S.; Fraser, W. J.; Becker, G. T.; Kirk, G. D. Performance-Based Exposure Control Limits for Pharmaceutical Active Ingredients Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J. 1996, 57, 33-42
56. Ader, A. W.; Farris, J. P.; Ku, R. H. Occupational Health Categorization and Compound Handling Practice Systems-Roots, Application and Future. Chem. Health Safety 2005, July/August, 20-26.
57. Zalk, D. M.; Nelson, D. I. History and Evolution of Control Banding: Review J. Occup. Environ. Hyg. 2008, 5, 330-346
58. Kuempel, E. D.; Geraci, C. L.; Schulte, P. A. Risk Assessment Approaches and Research Needs for Nanoparticles: An Examination of Data and Information from Current Studies. Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Nanotechnology: Toxicological Issues and Environmental Safety, Varna, Bulgaria, August 12-17, 2006. In Nanotechnology: Toxicological Issues and Environmental Safety; Simeonova, N.; Luster, M., Eds.; Springer: New York, 2007; pp 119-145.
59. Sobels, F. H. Some Problems Associated with the Testing for Environmental Mutagens and a Perspective for Studies in "Comparative Mutagenesis" Mutat. Res., Environ. Mutagen. Relat. Subj. 1977, 46, 245-260
60. Maier, M. S. Setting Occupational Exposure Limits for Unstudied Pharmaceutical Intermediates Using an In Vitro Parallelogram Approach Toxicol. Mech. Methods 2011, 21, 76-85
61. Erdely, A.; Liston, A.; Salmen-Muniz, R.; Hulderman, T.; Young, S. H.; Zeidler-Erdely, P.; Castranova, V.; Simeonova, P. Identification of Systemic Markers from a Pulmonary Carbon Nanotube Exposure J. Occup. Environ. Med. 2011, 53, S80-86
62. Schubauer-Berigan, M. K.; Dahm, M. M.; Yenchen, M. S. Engineered Carbonaceous Nanomaterials Manufacturers in the United States: Workforce Size, Characteristics, and Feasibility of Epidemiologic Studies J. Occup. Environ. Med. 2011, 53, S62-67
63. Bonner, J. C.; Silva, R. M.; Taylor, A. J.; Brown, J. M.; Hilderbrand, S. C.; Castranova, V.; Porter, D.; Elder, A.; Oberdorster, G.; Harkema, J. R. et al. Interlaboratory Evaluation of Rodent Pulmonary Responses to Engineered Nanomaterials: The NIEHS Nano Go Consortium Environ. Health Perspect. 2013, 121, 676-682
64. Judson, R.; Kavlock, R.; Martin, M.; Reif, D.; Houck, K.; Knudsen, T.; Richard, A.; Tice, R. R.; Whelan, M.; Xia, M. et al. Perspectives on Validation of High-Throughput Assays Supporting 21st Century Toxicity Testing Altex 2013, 30, 51-56
65. A Research Strategy for Environmental, Health, and Safety Aspects of Engineered Nanomaterials; National Academy Press: Washington, DC, 2012.
66. (ISO) I.O.f.S. ISO Guide 35:2006: Reference Materials-General and Statistical Principles for Certification; International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland, 2006.
67. Guidelines for Carcinogen Risk Assessment. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Editor 2005, Washington, D.C.
68. Schulte, P. A.; Murashov, V.; Zumwalde, R.; Kuempel, E. D.; Geraci, C. L. Occupational Exposure Limits for Nanomaterials: State of the Art J. Nanopart. Res. 2010, 12, 1971-1987
69. Expert Panel on the Integrated Testing of Pesticides, Integrating Emerging Technologies into Chemical Safety Assessment. C.o.C. Academies, Editor 2012, Council of Canadian Academies, Ottawa, Canada.