Milk production from silage: Comparison of grass, legume and maize silages and their mixtures

Agricultural and Food Science

Volumn 22, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 57-69

  Dewhurst, Richard J ^a  

^a ANIMAL AND GRASSLAND RESEARCH AND INNOVATION CENTRE   (Ireland)

Author keywords

Clover silage; Feed intake; Grass silage; Maize silage; Milk quality

Indexed keywords

TRIFOLIUM; ZEA MAYS;

EID: 84878698655     PISSN: 14596067     EISSN: 17951895     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.23986/afsci.6673     Document Type: Review

References (82)

1. Abrahamse, P.A., Vlaeminck, B., Tamminga, B. & Dijkstra, J. 2008. The effect of silage and concentrate type on intake behaviour, rumen function, and milk production in dairy cows in early and late lactation. Journal of Dairy Science 91: 4778-4792.
2. Albrecht, K.A. & Muck, R.E. 1991. Proteolysis in ensiled forage legumes that vary in tannin concentration. Crop Science 31: 464-469.
3. Allen, M.S. 2000. Effects of diet on short-term regulation of feed intake by lactating dairy cattle. Journal of Dairy Science 83: 1598-1624.
4. Al-Mabruk, R.M., Beck, N.F.G. & Dewhurst, R.J. 2004. Effects of silage species and supplemental vitamin E on oxidative stability of milk. Journal of Dairy Science 87: 406-412.
5. Arvidsson, K., Gustavsson, A.-M., Fievez, V. & Martinsson, K. 2012. The effect of N-fertilisation rate or inclusion of red clover to timothy leys on fatty acid composition in milk of dairy cows fed a commercial silage: concentrate ratio. Animal 6: 1178-1186.
6. Auldist, D.E., Atkinson, K.L., Silvapulle, M.J., Dellow, D.W. & McDowell, G.H. 1999. Utilisation of white clover silage fed alone or with maize silage by lactating dairy cows. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 39: 237-246.
7. Baumont, R. & Deswysen, A.G. 1991. [Mixing and propulsion of the contents of the reticulo-rumen]. Reproduction, Nutrition et Development 31: 335-359.
8. Beauchemin, K.A., Kreuzer, M., O'Mara, F. & McAllister, T. A. 2008. Nutritional management for enteric methane abatement: A review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48: 21-27.
9. Beever, D.E., Dhanoa, M.S., Losada, H.R., Evans, R.T., Cammell, S.B. and France J. 1986. The effect of forage species and stage of harvest on the process of digestion occurring in the rumen of cattle. British Journal of Nutrition 56: 439-454.
10. Beever, D.E. & Thorp, C. 1996. Advances in the understanding of factors influencing the nutritive value of legumes. In: Younie, D. (ed.). Legumes in Sustainable Farming Systems. British Grassland Society Occasional Symposium No. 30. p. 194-207.
11. Bertilsson, J. & Murphy, M. 2003. Effects of feeding clover silages on feed intake, milk production and digestion in dairy cows. Grass and Forage Science 58: 309-322.
12. Bhandari, S.K., Li, S., Ominski, K.H., Wittenberg, K.M. & Plazier, J.C. 2008. Effects of chop length of alfalfa silage and oat silage on feed intake, milk production, feeding behaviour, and rumen fermentation of dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 91: 1942-1958.
13. Bhandari, S.K., Ominski, K.H., Wittenberg, K.M. & Plazier, J.C. 2007. Effects of chop length of alfalfa and corn silage on milk production and rumen fermentation of dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 90: 2355-2366.
14. Blaxter, K.L. & Clapperton, J.L. 1965. Prediction of the amount of methane produced by ruminants. British Journal of Nutrition 19: 511-522.
15. Bosch, M.W. & Bruining, M. 1995. Passage rate and total clearance rate from the rumen of cows fed on grass silage differing in cell-wall content. British Journal of Nutrition 73: 41-49.
16. Broderick, G.A. & Albrecht, K.A. 1997. Ruminal in vitro degradation of protein in tannin-free and tannin-containing forage legume species. Crop Science 37: 1884-1891.
17. Broderick, G.A., Albrecht, K.A., Owens, V.N. & Smith, R.R. 2004. Genetic variation in red clover for rumen protein degradability. Animal Feed Science and Technology 113: 157-167.
18. Broderick, G.A., Brito, A.F. & Olmos Colmenero, J.J. 2007. Effects of feeding formate-treated alfalfa silage or red clover silage on the production of lactating dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 90: 1378-1391.
19. Broderick, G.A., Walgenbach, R.P. & Maignan, S. 2001. Production of lactating dairy cows fed alfalfa or red clover silage at equal dry matter or crude protein contents in the diet. Journal of Dairy Science 84: 1728-1737.
20. Broderick, G. A., Walgenbach, R.P. & Sterrenburg, E. 2000. Performance of lactating dairy cows fed alfalfa or red clover silage as the sole forage. Journal of Dairy Science 83:1543-1551.
21. Butler, G., Stergiadis, S., Seal, C., Eyre, M. & Leifert, C. 2011. Fat composition of organic and conventional retail in northeast England. Journal of Dairy Science 94: 24-36.
22. Cammell, S.B. Sutton, J.D., Beever, D.E., Humphries, D.J. & Phipps, R.H. 2000. The effect of crop maturity on the nutritional value of maize silage for lactating dairy cows. 1. Energy and nitrogen utilization. Animal Science 71: 381-390.
23. Cassida, K.A., Griffin, T.S., Rodriguez, J., Patching, S.C., Hesterman, O.B. & Rust, S.R. 2000. Protein degradability and forage quality in maturing alfalfa, red clover and birdsfoot trefoil. Crop Science 40: 209-215.
24. Castle, M.E. 1982. Feeding high-quality silage. In: Rook J.A.F. & Thomas, P.C. (eds.). Silage for Milk Production. National Institute for Research in Dairying/Hannah Research Institute Technical Bulletin 2. p. 127-150.
25. Castle, M.E., Reid, D. & Watson, J.N. 1983. Silage and milk production: studies with diets containing white clover silage. Grass and Forage Science 38: 193-200.
26. Castle, M.E., Reid, D. & Watson, J.N. 1984. Silage and milk production: a comparison between supplements of barley and soybean meal offered with white clover silage. Grass and Forage Science 39: 287-289.
27. Cheng, L., Kim, E.J., Merry, R.J. & Dewhurst, R.J. 2011. Nitrogen partitioning and isotopic fractionation in dairy cows consuming diets based on a range of contrasting forages. Journal of Dairy Science 94: 2031-2041.
28. Cohen, D.C., Stockdale, C.R. & Doyle, P.T. 2006. Feeding an energy supplement with white clover silage improves rumen fermentation, metabolisable protein utilisation, and milk production in dairy cows. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 57: 367-375.
29. Cushnahan, A., Mayne, C.S. & Unsworth, E.F. 1995. Effects of ensilage of grass on performance and nutrient utilization by dairy cattle. 2. Nutrient metabolism and rumen fermentation. Animal Science 60: 347-359.
30. Dewhurst, R.J. 2003. Fatty acids in milk fat from organic dairy farms. Elm Farm Research Centre Bulletin, October, 11. Organic Research Centre, Elm Farm, Newbury, UK.
31. Dewhurst, R.J., Davies, L.J. & Kim, E.J. 2010. Effects of mixtures of red clover and maize silages on the partitioning of dietary nitrogen between milk and urine by dairy cows. Animal 4: 732-738.
32. Dewhurst, R.J., Delaby, L., Moloney, A., Boland, T. & Lewis, E. 2009. Nutritive value of forage legumes used for grazing and silage. Irish Journal of Agricultural and Food Research 48: 167-187.
33. Dewhurst, R.J., Evans, R.T., Scollan, N.D., Moorby, J.M., Merry, R.J. & Wilkins, R.J. 2003a. Comparison of grass and legume silages for milk production. 2. In vivo and in sacco evaluations of rumen function. Journal of Dairy Science 86: 2612-2621.
34. Dewhurst, R.J., Fisher, W.J., Tweed, J.K.S. & Wilkins, R.J. 2003b. Comparison of grass and legume silages for milk production. 1. Production responses with different levels of concentrate. Journal of Dairy Science 86: 2598-2611.
35. Dewhurst, R.J., Shingfield, K.J., Lee, M.R.F. & Scollan, N.D. 2006. Increasing the concentrations of beneficial polyunsaturated fatty acids in milk produced by dairy cows in high-forage systems. Animal Feed Science and Technology 131: 168-206.
36. Ellis, K.A., Innocent, G., Grove-White, D., Cripps, P., McLean, W.G., Howard, C.V. & Mihm, M. 2006. Comparing the fatty acid composition of organic and conventional milk. Journal of Dairy Science 89: 1938-1950.
37. Hetta, M., Gustavsson, A-M., Cone, J.W. & Martinsson, K. 2004. In vitro degradation characteristics of timothy and red clover at different times. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section A-Animal Sciences 54: 20-29.
38. Hoffman, P.C., Combs, D.K., Brehm, N.M. & Welch, D.A. 1997. Performance of lactating dairy cows fed red clover or alfalfa silage. Journal of Dairy Science 80: 3308-3315.
39. Hoffman, P.C., Combs, D.K. & Casler, M.D. 1998. Performance of lactating dairy cows fed alfalfa silage or perennial ryegrass silage. Journal of Dairy Science 81: 162-168.
40. Hoffman, P.C., Sievert, S.J., Shaver, R.D., Welch, D.A. & Combs, D.K. 1993. In situ dry matter, protein, and fiber degradation of perennial forages. Journal of Dairy Science 76: 2632-2643.
41. Huhtanen P., Nousiainen, J.I., Rinne, M., Kytölä, K. & Khalili, H. 2008. Utilisation and partition of dietary nitrogen in dairy cows fed grass silage-based diets. Journal of Dairy Science 91: 3589-3599.
42. Huhtanen, P., Rinne, M. & Nousiainen, J. 2007. Evaluation of the factors affecting silage intake of dairy cows: a revision of the relative silage dry-matter intake index. Animal 1: 758-770.
43. INRA, 2007. Alimentation des bovins, ovins et caprins. Quae Eds, Versailles, France, 330 p.
44. Jamot, J. & Grenet, E. 1991. Microscopic investigation of changes in histology and digestibility in the rumen of a forage grass and forage legume during the first growth stage. Reproduction, Nutrition, Développement 31: 441-450.
45. Kebreab, E., France, J., Beever, D.E. & Castillo, A.R. 2001. Nitrogen pollution by dairy cows and its mitigation by dietary manipulation. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 60: 275-285.
46. Kingston-Smith, A.H., Marshall, A.H. & Moorby, J.M. 2013. Breeding for genetic improvement of forage plants in relation to increasing animal production with reduced environmental footprint. Animal doi:10.1017/S17517311120000961.
47. Kuoppala, K., Ahvenjärvi, S., Rinne, M. & Vanhatalo, A. 2009. Effects of feeding grass or red clover silage cut at two maturity stages in dairy cows. 2. Dry matter intake and cell wall digestion kinetics. Journal of Dairy Science 92: 5634-5644.
48. Kuoppala, K., Rinne, M. Ahvenjärvi, S., Nousiainen, J. & Huhtanen, P. 2010. The effect of harvesting strategy of grass silage on digestion and nutrient supply in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 93: 3253-3263.
49. Lee, M.R.F., Olmos Colmenero, J.D.J., Winters, A.L., Scollan, N.D. & Minchin, F.R. 2006. Polyphenol oxidase activity in grass and its effect on plant-mediated lipolysis and proteolysis of Dactylis glomerata (cocksfoot) in a simulated rumen environment. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 86: 1503-1511.
50. Lee, M.R.F., Scott, M.B., Tweed, J.K.S., Minchin, F.R. & Davies, D.R. 2008. Effects of polyphenol oxidase on lipolysis and proteolysis of red clover silage with and without a silage inoculant (Lactobacillus plantarum L54). Animal Feed Science and Technology 144: 125-136.
51. Margan, D.E., Moran, J.B. & Spence, F.B. 1994. Energy and protein value of combinations of maize silage and red clover hay for ruminants, using adult sheep as a model. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 34: 319-329.
52. th March, 2012, Tullamore, Ireland.
53. McCaughey, W.P., Wittenberg, K. & Corrigan, D. 1999. Impact of pasture type on methane production by lactating beef cows. Canadian Journal Animal Science 79: 221-226.
54. Moorby, J.M., Lee, M.R.F., Davies, D.R., Kim, E.J., Nute, G.R., Ellis, N.M. & Scollan, N.D. 2009. Assessment of dietary ratios of red clover and grass silages on milk production and milk quality in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 92: 1148-1160.
55. Moseley, G. & Jones, J.R. 1984. The physical digestion of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) and white clover (Trifolium repens) in the foregut of sheep. British Journal of Nutrition 52: 381-390.
56. Owens, V.N., Albrecht, K.A. & Muck, R.E. 1999. Protein degradation and ensiling characteristics of red clover and alfalfa wilted under varying levels of shade. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 79: 209-222.
57. Phipps, R.H., 1990. Maize: a review of research findings in relation to animal production. In: Milk and Meat from Forage Crops. G. E Pollott (ed.). British Grassland Society Occasional Publication Number 24. p.107-119.
58. Phipps, R.H., Sutton, J.D., Beever, D.E. & Jones, A.K. 2000. The effect of crop maturity on the nutritional value of maize silage for lactating dairy cows 3. Food intake and milk production. Animal Science 71: 401-409.
59. Phipps, R.H., Weller, R.F., Elliot, R.J., & Sutton, J.D. 1988. The effect of level and type of concentrate and type of conserved forage on dry matter intake and milk production of lactating dairy cows. Journal of Agricultural Science (Cambridge) 111: 179-186.
60. Phipps, R.H., Weller, R.F. & Rook, A.J. 1992. Forage mixtures for dairy cows: the effect on dry matter intake and milk production of incorporating different proportions of maize silage into diets based on grass silage of differing energy value. Journal of Agricultural Science (Cambridge) 118: 379-382.
61. Rae, R.C., Thomas, C., Reeve, A., Golightly, A.J., Hodson, R.G. & Baker, R.D. 1987. The potential of an all-grass diet for the latewinter calving dairy cow. Grass and Forage Science 42: 249-257.
62. Randby, Å.T., Selmer-Olsem, I. & Baevre, L. 1999. Effect of Ethanol in Feed on Milk Flavor and Chemical Composition. Journal of Dairy Science 82: 420-428.
63. Rinne, M., Huhtanen, P. & Jaakkola, S. 2002. Digestive processes of dairy cows fed silages harvested at four stages of grass maturity. Journal of Dairy Science 80: 1986-1998.
64. Rinne, M. & Nykänen, A. 2000. Timing of primary growth harvest affects the yield and nutritive value of timothy-red clover mixtures. Agricultural and Food Science in Finland 9: 121-134.
65. Rustas, B.-O., Nørgaard, P., Jalali, A.R. & Nadeau, E. 2010. Effects of physical form and stage of maturity at harvest of whole-crop barley silage on intake, chewing activity, diet selection and faecal particle size of dairy steers. Animal 4: 67-75.
66. Smith, L.W., Goering, H.K. & Gordon, C.H. 1972. Relationships of forage compositions with rates of cell wall digestion and cell wall indigestibility. Journal of Dairy Science 55: 1140-1147.
67. Steinshamn, H., Purup, S., Thuen, E. & Hansen-Møller, J. 2008. Effects of clover-grass silages and concentrate supplementation on the content of phytoestrogens in dairy cow milk. Journal of Dairy Science 91: 2715-2725.
68. Steinshamn, H. & Thuen, E. 2008. White or red clover-grass silage in organic dairy milk production: Grassland productivity and milk production responses with different levels of concentrate. Livestock Science 119: 202-215.
69. Theodoridou, K., Aufrère, J., Andueza, D., Le Morvan, A., Picard, F., Porrat, J. & Baumont, R. 2012. Effects of condensed tannins in wrapped silage bales of sainfoin (Onobrychis viciifolia) on in vivo and in situ digestion in sheep. Animal 6: 245-253.
70. Thomas, C., Aston, K. & Daley, S.R. 1985. Milk production from silage. 3. A comparison of red clover with grass silage. Animal Production 41: 23-31.
71. Thomas, C., Gibbs, B.G. & Tayler, J.C. 1981. Beef production for silage. 2. The performance of beef cattle given silages of either perennial ryegrass or red clover. Animal Production 32: 149-153.
72. Ulyatt, M.J. 1970. Evaluation of pasture quality under New Zealand conditions. Proceedings of the New Zealand Grassland Association 32: 61-68.
73. Van Dorland, H.A., Kreuzer, M., Leuenberger, H. & Wettstein, H.-R. 2008. Comparative potential of white and red clover to modify the milk fatty acid profile of cows fed ryegrass-based diets from zero-grazing and silage systems. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 88: 77-85.
74. Van Dorland, H.A., Wettstein, H.-R., Leuenberger, H. & Kreuzer, M. 2007. Effect of supplementation of fresh and ensiled clovers to ryegrass on nitrogen loss and methane emissions in dairy cows. Livestock Science 111: 57-69.
75. Vanhatalo, A., Kuoppala, K., Ahvenjärvi, S. & Rinne, M. 2009. Effects of feeding grass or red clover silage cut at two maturity stages in dairy cows. 1. Nitrogen metabolism and supply of amino acids. Journal of Dairy Science 92: 5620-5633.
76. Vanhatalo, A.S., Kuoppala. K., Toivonen, V. & Shingfield, K.J. 2007. Effects of forage species and stage of maturity on bovine milk fatty acid composition. European Journal of Lipid Science and Technology 109: 856-867.
77. Vanhatalo, A., Pursiainen, P., Kuoppala, K., Rinne, M. & Tuori, M. 2008. Effects of harvest time of red clover silage on milk production and composition. Grassland Science in Europe 13: 391-393.
78. Vellinga, T.V. & Hoving, I.E. 2011. Maize silage for dairy cows: mitigation of methane emissions can be offset by land use change. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 89: 413-426.
79. Waghorn, G.C., Shelton, I.D. & Thomas, V.J. 1989. Particle breakdown and rumen digestion of fresh ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) and lucerne (Medicago sativa L.) fed to cows during a restricted feeding period. British Journal of Nutrition 61: 409-423.
80. Waghorn, G.C., Woodward, S.L., Tavendale, M. & Clark, D.A. 2006. Inconsistencies in rumen methane production-effects of forage composition and animal genotype. International Congress Series 1293: 115-118.
81. Wilman, D., Mtengeti, E.J. & Moseley, G. 1996. Physical structure of twelve forage species in relation to intake by sheep. Journal of Agricultural Science (Cambridge) 126: 277-285.
82. Wilson, J.R. & Kennedy, P.M. 1996. Plant and animal constraints to voluntary feed intake associated with fibre characteristics and particle breakdown and passage in ruminants. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 47: 199-225.