Blood glucose control algorithms for type 1 diabetic patients: A methodological review

Biomedical Signal Processing and Control

Volumn 8, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 107-119

  Lunze, Katrin ^a   Singh, Tarunraj ^b   Walter, Marian ^a   Brendel, Mathias D ^c   Leonhardt, Steffen ^a  

^a RWTH AACHEN UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

^b State University of New York   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL CARL GUSTAV CARUS   (Germany)

Author keywords

Artificial pancreas; Blood glucose control; Insulin therapy devices; Model predictive control; Patient model

Indexed keywords

ARTIFICIAL ORGANS; GLUCOSE; INSULIN; MODEL PREDICTIVE CONTROL; PATIENT TREATMENT; THREE TERM CONTROL SYSTEMS;

ARTIFICIAL PANCREAS; BLOOD GLUCOSE; BLOOD GLUCOSE CONCENTRATION; BLOOD GLUCOSE CONTROL ALGORITHMS; BLOOD GLUCOSE MEASUREMENTS; CONTINUOUS GLUCOSE MONITORING; INSULIN THERAPY; PATIENT MODELING;

BLOOD;

GLUCAGON; GLUCOSE; INSULIN;

ALGORITHM; ARTICLE; ARTIFICIAL PANCREAS; BLACK BOX MODEL; BLOOD GLUCOSE MONITORING; CLINICAL DECISION MAKING; DIABETIC PATIENT; FEASIBILITY STUDY; FEEDBACK SYSTEM; GLUCOSE BLOOD LEVEL; GLUCOSE METABOLISM; HUMAN; HYPERGLYCEMIA; HYPOGLYCEMIA; INSULIN DEPENDENT DIABETES MELLITUS; INSULIN PUMP; INSULIN SENSITIVITY; MATHEMATICAL MODEL; PHYSICAL ACTIVITY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITY OF LIFE;

EID: 84874529965     PISSN: 17468094     EISSN: 17468108     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bspc.2012.09.003     Document Type: Review

References (81)

1. S. Wild, R. Sicree, G. Roglic, H. King, and A. Green Global prevalence of diabetes: Estimates for the year 2000 and projections for 2030 Diabetes Care 27 5 2004 1047 1053
2. The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group The effect of intensive treatment of diabetes on the development and progression of long-term complications in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus New England Journal of Medicine 329 14 1993 977 986
3. The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group The effect of intensive diabetes therapy on the development and progression of neuropathy Annals of Internal Medicine 122 8 1995 561 568
4. The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group Early worsening of diabetic retinopathy in the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Archives of Ophthalmology 116 7 1998 874 896
5. R.M. Bergenstal, W.V. Tamborlande, A. Ahmann, J.B. Buse, G. Dailey, S.N. Davis, C. Joyce, T. Peoples, B.A. Perkins, J.B. Welsh, S.M. Willi, and M.A. Wood Effectiveness of sensor-augmented insulin-pump therapy in type 1 diabetes The New England Journal of Medicine 363 2010 311 320
6. R. Bellazzi, G. Nucci, and C. Cobelli The subcutaneous route to insulin-dependent diabetes therapy. closed-loop and partially closed-loop control strategies for insulin delivery and measuring glucose concentration IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology 20 1 2001 54 64
7. G.M. Steil, A.E. Panteleon, and K. Rebrin Closed-loop insulin delivery-the path to physiological glucose control Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews 56 2004 125 144
8. R. Hovorka Continuous glucose monitoring and closed-loop systems Diabetes Medicine 23 1 2006 1 12
9. C. Cobelli, C. Dalla Man, G. Sparacino, L. Magni, G. De Nicolao, and B.P. Kovatchev Diabetes: models, signals, and control IEEE Reviews in Biomedical Engineering 2 2009 54 96
10. R.A. Harvey, Y. Wang, B. Grosman, M.W. Percival, W. Bevier, D.A. Finan, H. Zisser, D.E. Seborg, L. Jovanovič, F.J. Doyle, and E. Dessau The quest for the artificial pancreas. combining technology with treatment IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Magazine 29 2 2010 53 63
11. G. Chee, and T. Fernando Closed-Loop Control of Blood Glucose, No. 368 in Lecture Notes in Control and Information Sciences 2007 Springer Verlag Berlin, Deutschland
12. O. Schnell Insulinpumpen und Sensoren: Aktuelle Entwicklungen 1st ed. 2007 UNI-MED Science Bremen, Germany
13. R. Hovorka, K. Kumareswaran, J. Harris, J.M. Allen, D. Elleri, D. Xing, C. Kollman, M. Nodale, H.R. Murphy, D.B. Dunger, S.A. Amiel, S.H. Heller, M.E. Wilinska, and M.L. Evans Overnight closed loop insulin delivery (artificial pancreas) in adults with type 1 diabetes: crossover randomised controlled studies British Medical Journal 342 2011 (online publication)
14. D. Elleri, J.M. Allen, M. Nodale, M.E. Wilinska, J.S. Mangat, A.M.F. Larsen, C.L. Acerini, D.B. Dunger, and R. Hovorka Automated overnight closed-loop glucose control in young children with type 1 diabetes Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics 13 4 2011 419 424
15. R. Hovorka, L.J. Chassin, M.E. Wilinska, V. Canonico, J. Akwe Akwi, M.O. Federici, I. Hutzli, C. Zaugg, H. Kaufmann, M. Both, T. Vering, H.C. Schaller, L. Schaupp, M. Bodenlenz, and T.R. Pieber Closing the loop: the adicol experience Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics 6 3 2004 307 318
16. T. Biester, S. Bläsig, K. Remus, E. Sadeghian, O. Kordonouri, and T. Danne Nächtliche Blutzuckerkontrolle mit einem Closed Loop-System: Ergebnis der internationalen Dream2-Studie Abstract-CD Diabetes Congress 2012 Stuttgart, Germany 2012 FV-33
17. G. Freckmann, B. Kalatz, B. Pfeiffer, U. Hoss, and C. Haug Recent advances in continuous glucose monitoring Experimental and Clinical Endocrinology & Diabetes 109 S2 2001 S347 S357
18. P.H. Kvist, and H.E. Jensen Recent advances in continuous glucose monitoring: biocompatibility of glucose sensors for implantation in subcutis Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 1 5 2007 746 752
19. M.M. Ahmadi, and G.A. Jullien A wireless-implantable microsystem for continuous blood glucose monitoring IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems 3 3 2009 169 180
20. C.M. Girardin, C. Huot, M. Gonthier, and E. Delvin Continuous glucose monitoring: a review of biochemical perspectives and clinical use in type 1 diabetes Clinical Biochemistry 42 2009 136 142
21. S.T. Fard, L. Chrostowski, E. Kwok, and M.-C. Amann Chemometric approach for improving VCSEL-based glucose predictions IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 57 3 2010 578 585
22. E. Renard, and P. Schaepelynck-Bélicar Implantable insulin pump: a position statement about their clinical use Diabetes & Metabolism 33 2007 158 166
23. N. Hernjak, and F.J. Doyle III Glucose control design using nonlinearity assessment techniques American Institute of Chemical Engineers 51 2 2005 544 554
24. E. Dassau, C.C. Palerm, H. Zisser, B.A. Buckingham, L. Jovanovič, and F.J. Doyle III In silico evaluation platform for artificial pancreatic β-cell development-a dynamic simulator for closed-loop control with hardware-in-the-loop Journal of Diabetes Science an Technology 11 3 2009 187 194
25. A.C. Guyton, and J.E. Hall Textbook of Medical Physiology 12th ed. 2010 Saunders, Elsevier Philadelphia
26. R.N. Bergman, L.S. Phillips, and C. Cobelli Physiologic evaluation of factors controlling glucose tolerance in man. Measurement of insulin sensitivity and β-cell glucose sensitivity from the response to intravenous glucose Journal of Clinical Investigations 68 1981 1456 1467
27. G.M. Steil, K. Rebrin, R. Janowski, C. Darwin, and M.F. Saad Modeling beta-cell insulin secretion: implications for closed-loop glucose homeostasis Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics 5 6 2003 953 964
28. R. Klinke, H.C. Pape, A. Kurtz, S. Silbernagl (Eds.), Physiologie, 6th ed., Georg Thieme Verlag, Stuttgart, Deutschland, 2009, pp. 554-561 (Ch. Endokines System).
29. K. Alexander, W.G. Daniel, H.-C. Diener, M. Freund, H. Köhler, S. Matern, H.H. Maurer, B.A. Michel, D. Nowak, T. Risler, A. Schaffner, W.A. Scherbaum, G.W. Sybrecht, G. Wolfram, M. Zeitz, and M. Flasnoecker Thieme's Innere Medizin-TIM 1999 Georg Thieme Verlag Stuttgart, Deutschland
30. J.T. Sorensen, A physiological model of glucose metabolism in man and its use to design and assess improved insulin therapies for diabetes, Ph.D. thesis, Dept. Chem. Eng., Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Cambridge, MA, USA, 1985.
31. R.S. Parker, F.J.I. Doyle, and N.A. Peppas A model-based algorithm for blood glucose control in type I diabetic patients IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 46 2 1999 148 157
32. G.M. Steil, K. Rebrin, C. Darwin, F. Hariri, and M.F. Saad Feasibility of automating insulin delivery for the treatment of type 1 diabetes American Diabetes Association 55 2006 3344 3350
33. D.A. Finan, H. Zisser, L. Jovanovic, W.C. Bevier, and D.E. Seborg Identification of linear dynamic models for type 1 diabetes: a simulation study ADCHEM 2006, International Symposium on Advanced Control of Chemical Processes Gramado, Brazil 2006
34. D.A. Finan, C.C. Palerm, F. Doyle, and D.E. Seborg Effect of input excitation on the quality of empirical dynamic models for type 1 diabetes AIChE Journal 55 5 2009 1135 1146
35. C. Cobelli, and E. Carson Introduction to Modeling in Physiology and Medicine 1st ed. 2007 Academic Press Series in Biomedical Engineering, Academic Press London, England
36. C. Cobelli, G. Toffolo, and E. Ferrannini A model of glucose kinetics and their control by insulin, compartmental and noncompartmental approaches Mathematical Biosciences 72 1984 291 315
37. S.M. Lynch, and B.W. Bequette Estimation-based model predictive control of blood glucose in type I diabetics: a simulation study 27th IEEE Annual Northeast Bioengineering Conference Storrs, Connecticut 2001 79 80
38. S.M. Lynch, and B.W. Bequette Model predictive control of blood glucose in type I diabetics using subcutaneous glucose measurements American Control Conference, Anchorage, Alaska, vol. 5 2002 4039 4043
39. R. Hovorka, F. Shojaee-Moradie, P.C. Carroll, L.J. Chassin, I.J. Gowrie, N.C. Jackson, R.S. Tudor, A.M. Umpleby, and R.H. Jones Partitioning glucose distribution/transport, disposal and endogenous production during IVGTT American Journal of Physiology 282 2002 E992 1007
40. R. Hovorka, V. Canonico, L.J. Chassin, U. Haueter, M. Massi-Benedetti, M.O. Federici, T.R. Pieber, H.C. Schaller, L. Schaupp, T. Vering, and M.E. Wilinska Nonlinear model predictive control of glucose concentration in subjects with type 1 diabetes Physiological Measurement 25 2004 905 920
41. P.G. Fabietti, V. Canonico, M.O. Federici, M.M. Cenedetti, and E. Sarti Control oriented model of insulin and glucose dynamics in type 1 diabetes Medical and Biological Engineering and Computing 44 1-2 2006 69 78
42. C. Dalla Man, R.A. Rizza, and C. Cobelli Meal simulation model of the glucose-insulin system IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 54 10 2007 1740 1749
43. C. Dalla Man, D.M. Raimondo, R.A. Rizza, and C. Cobelli GIM simulation software of meal glucose-insulin model Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 1 3 2007 323 330
44. B.P. Kovatchev, M. Breton, C. Dalla Man, and C. Cobelli In Silico preclinical trials: a proof of concept in closed-loop control of type 1 diabetes Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 3 1 2009 44 55
45. R.S. Parker, and F.J.I. Doyle Control-relevant modeling in drug delivery Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews 28 2001 211 228
46. A.H. Clemens, P.H. Chang, and R.W. Myers The development of biostator, a glucose-controlled insulin infusion system (gciis) Hormone and Metabolic Research Supplement 7 1977 23 33
47. S.M. Furler, E.W. Kraegen, R.H. Smallwood, and D.J. Chisholm Blood glucose control by intermittent loop closure in the basal mode: Computer simulation studies with a diabetic model Diabetes Care 8 6 1985 553 561
48. R.L. Ollerton Application of optimal control therapy to diabetes mellitus International Journal of Control 50 6 1989 2503 2522
49. Y. Wang, M.W. Percival, E. Dassau, H.C. Zisser, L. Jovanovič, and F.J. Doyle III A novel adaptive basal therapy based on the value and rate of change of blood glucose Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 3 5 2009 1099 1108
50. J.A. Gantt, K.A. Rochelle, and E.P. Gatzke Type 1 diabetic patient insulin delivery using asymmetric pi control Chemical Engineering Communications 194 5 2007 586 602
51. G. Marchetti, M. Barolo, L. Jovanovič, H. Zisser, and D.E. Seborg An improved PID switching control strategy for type 1 diabetes IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 55 3 2008 857 865
52. C.C. Palerm, H. Zisser, L. Jovanovič, and J.F.I. Doyle A run-to-run control strategy to adjust basal insulin infusion rates in type 1 diabetes Journal of Process Control 18 3-4 2008 258 265
53. G. Steil, K. Rebrin, and J.J. Mastrototaro Metabolic modelling and the closed-loop insulin delivery problem Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice 74 2006 183 186
54. M.E. Wilinska, L.J. Chassin, H.C. Schaller, L. Schaupp, T.R. Pieber, and R. Hovorka Insulin kinetics in type-1 diabetes: continuous and bolus delivery of rapid acting insulin IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 52 1 2005 3 12
55. B. Srinivasan, C.J. Primus, D. Bonvin, and N.L. Ricker Run-to-run optimization via control of generalized constraints Control Engineering Practice 9 2001 911 919
56. ∞ problem Control Engineering Practice 12 2004 1179 1195
57. ∞ glucose control in diabetes using a physiological model American Institute of Chemical Engineers 46 12 2000 2537 2549
58. ∞ insulin injection control for blood glucose regulation in diabetic patients IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 52 10 2005 1625 1631
59. W. García-Gabín, J. Vehí, J. Bondia, C. Tarín, and R. Calm Robust sliding mode closed-loop glucose control with meal compensation in type 1 diabetes mellitus Proceedings of the 17th IFAC World Congress, vol. 1 2008 4240 4245
60. P. Kaveh, and Y.B. Shtessel Blood glucose regulation using higher-order sliding mode control International Journal of Robust and Nonlinear Control 18 4-5 2008 557 569
61. R. Gillis, C.C. Palerm, H.Z.L. Javonovič, D.E. Seborg, and F.J.I. Doyle Glucose estimation and prediction through meal responses using ambulatory subject data for advisory mode model predictive control Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 1 6 2007 825 833
62. P. Dua, F.J. Doyle III, and E.N. Pistikopoulos Model-based blood glucose control for type 1 diabetes via parametric programming IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 53 8 2006 1478 1491
63. J.M. Maciejowski Predictive Control with Constraints 1st ed. 2001 Pearson Education, Prentice Hall Harlow, England
64. R.S. Parker, F.J.I. Doyle, and N.A. Peppas The intravenous route to blood glucose control. a review of control algorithms for noninvasive monitoring and regulation in type i diabetic patients IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Magazine 20 1 2001 65 73
65. E.D. Lehmann, and T. Deutsch A physiological model of glucose-insulin interaction in type I diabetes mellitus Journal of Biomedical Engineering 14 1992 235 242
66. M.E. Fisher A semi closed-loop algorithm for the control of blood-glucose levels in diabetics IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 38 1 1991 57 61
67. L. Magni, D.M. Raimondo, L. Bossi, C. Dalla Man, G. De Nicolao, B. Kovatchev, and C. Cobelli Model predictive control of type 1 diabetes: an in silico trial Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 1 6 2006 804 812
68. L. Magni, D.M. Raimondo, C. Dalla Man, G. De Nicolao, B. Kovatchev, and C. Cobelli Model predictive control of glucose concentration in subjects with type 1 diabetes: an in silico trial 17th IFAC World Congress, Seoul, Korea 2008
69. L.J. Chassin, M.E. Wilinska, and R. Hovorka Evaluation of glucose controllers in virtual environment: methodology and sample application Artificial Intelligence in Medicine 32 3 2004 171 181
70. G. Marchetti, M. Barolo, L. Jovanovič, H. Zisser, and D.E. Seborg A feedforward-feedback glucose control strategy for type 1 diabetes mellitus Journal of Process Control 18 2 2008 149 162
71. F.H. El-Khatib, S.J. Russell, D.M. Nathan, R.G. Sutherlin, and E.R. Damiano A bihormonal closed-loop artificial pancreas for type 1 diabetes Science Translational Medicine 2 27 2010 27ra27
72. E. Renard, J. Place, M. Cantwell, H. Chevassus, and C.C. Palerm Closed-loop insulin delivery using a subcutaneous glucose sensor and intraperitoneal insulin delivery Diabetes Care 33 1 2010 121 127
73. M. Derouich, and A. Boutayeb The effect of physical exercise on the dynamics of glucose and insulin Journal of Biomechanics 35 7 2002 911 917
74. M.D. Breton Physical activity-the major unaccounted impediment to closed loop control Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 2 1 2008 169 174
75. C. Dalla Man, M.D. Breton, and C. Cobelli Physical activity into the meal glucose-insulin model of type 1 diabetes: in silico studies Journal of Diabetes Science an Technology 3 1 2009 56 67
76. D. Nagi Exercise and Sport in Diabetes, Diabetes in Practice 2nd ed. 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. England
77. R. Basu, C.D. Man, M.A.B. Campioni, G. Klee, F. Toffolo, C. Cobelli, and R.A. Rizza Differences in glucose turnover, insulin secretion, insulin action and hepatic insulin extraction Diabetes 55 2006 2001 2014
78. F.H. El-Khatib, J. Jiang, and E.R. Damiano Adaptive closed-loop control provides blood-glucose regulation using dual subcutaneous insulin and glucagon infusion in diabetic swine Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 1 2 2007 181 192
79. F.H. El-Khatib, J. Jiang, and E.R. Damiano A feasibility study of bihormonal closed-loop blood glucose control using dual subcutaneous infusion of insulin and glucagon in ambulatory diabetic swine Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 3 4 2009 789 803
80. B. Kovatchev, D.M. Raimondo, M. Breton, S. Patek, and C. Cobelli In silico testing and in vivo experiments with closed-loop control of blood glucose in diabetes 17th IFAC World Congress, Seoul, Korea 2008
81. F.H. El-Khatib, J. Jiang, R.G. Gerrity, and E.R. Damiano Pharmacodynamics and stability of subcutaneously infused glucagon in a type 1 diabetic swine model in vivo Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics 9 2 2007 135 144