The effectiveness of psychosocial modalities in the treatment of alcohol problems in adults: A review of the evidence

Canadian Journal of Psychiatry

Volumn 57, Issue 6, 2012, Pages 350-358

  Martin, Garth W ^a   Rehm, Jur̈gen ^b,c,d  

^a Addiction Consultant Services   (Canada)

^b CENTRE FOR ADDICTION AND MENTAL HEALTH   (Canada)

^c UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^d DRESDEN UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Germany)

Author keywords

Alcohol; Cognitive behavioural therapy; Cost effectiveness; Effectiveness; Motivational enhancement therapy; Problems; Psychosocial interventions; Use disorders

Indexed keywords

ALCOHOLISM; CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS; COGNITIVE THERAPY; COMORBIDITY; COST EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS (TOPIC); OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PSYCHOSOCIAL CARE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW (TOPIC); TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84871131761     PISSN: 07067437     EISSN: 14970015     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/070674371205700604     Document Type: Review

References (118)

1. Berglund M, Thelander S, Jonsson E. Treating alcohol and drug abuse. An evidenced based review. Weinheim (DE): Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co KGaA; 2003.
2. Miller WR, Wilbourne P, Hetema JE. What works? A summary of alcohol treatment outcome research. In: Hester RK, Miller WR, editors. Handbook of alcoholism treatment approaches: effective alternatives. 3rd ed. Boston (MA): Allyn & Bacon; 2003. p 13-63.
3. UKATT Research Team. Effectiveness of treatment for alcohol problems: findings of the randomised alcohol treatment trial (UKATT). BMJ. 2005;331:541.
4. Raistrick D, Heather N, Godfrey C. Review of the effectiveness of treatment for alcohol problems. London (GB): National Treatment Agency for Substance Abuse; 2006.
5. Gordon L, Graves N, Hawkes A, et al. A review of the cost-effectiveness of face-to-face behavioural interventions for smoking, physical activity, diet and alcohol. Chronic Illn. 2007;3:101-129. (Pubitemid 47613182)
6. Miller WR, Wilbourne P. Mesa Grande: a methodological analysis of clinical trials of treatments for alcohol use disorders. Addiction. 2002;97:265-277. (Pubitemid 34250721)
7. Marinelli-Casey PJ, Domier C, Rawson RA. The gap between research and practice in substance abuse treatment. Psychiatr Serv. 2002;53:984-987. (Pubitemid 34816091)
8. Najavits LM, Crits-Christoph P, Dierberger B. Clinicians' impact on the quality of substance use treatment. Subst Use Misuse. 2000;35:2161-2190. (Pubitemid 32004740)
9. Australian Institute of Primary Care. Comorbidity treatment service model evaluation. Victoria (AU): Faculty of Health Sciences, La Trobe University; 2009.
10. Bandura A. Social foundations of thought and action: a social cognitive theory. Englewood Cliffs (NJ): Prentice Hall; 1986.
11. Proude E, Lopatko O, Lintzeris N, et al. The treatment of alcohol problems: a review of the evidence. Sydney (AU): Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing; 2009.
12. Miller WR, Rollnick S. Motivational interviewing: preparing people for change. 2nd ed. New York (NY): Guildford Press; 2002.
13. Miller W, Rolnick S. Motivational interviewing: preparing people to change addictive behavior. New York (NY): Guilford Press; 1991.
14. Humphreys K. Professional interventions that facilitate 12-step self-help group involvement. Alcohol Res Health. 1999;23:93-98.
15. Miller WR, Hester RK. The effectiveness of alcoholism treatment: what research reveals. In: Miller WR, Heather N, editors. Treating addictive behaviors: processes of change. New York (NY): Plenum Press; 1986. p 121-174.
16. Finney JW. Limitations in using existing alcohol treatment trials to develop practice guidelines. Addiction. 2000;35:1491-1500.
17. Howard MO. Assessing the comparative cost-effectiveness of alcoholism treatments: a comment on Holder, Longabaugh, Miller and Rubonis. J Stud Alcohol. 1993;54:667-675. (Pubitemid 23318737)
18. Finney JW, Monahan SC. The cost effectiveness of treatment for alcoholism: a second approximation. J Stud Alcohol. 1996;57:229-243. (Pubitemid 26117102)
19. Holder H, Longabaugh R, Miller WR, et al. The cost effectiveness of treatment for alcoholism: a first approximation. J Stud Alcohol. 1991;52:517-540.
20. Miller WR, Brown J, Simpson TL, et al. What works? A methodological analysis of the alcohol treatment outcome literature. In: Hester RK, Miller WR, editors. Handbook of alcoholism treatment approaches: effective alternatives. Boston (MA): Allyn & Bacon; 1995. p 12-44.
21. Hettema J, Steele J, Miller WR. Motivational interviewing. Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 2005;1:91-111. (Pubitemid 43843947)
22. Vasilaki EI, Hosier SG, Cox WM. The efficacy of motivational interviewing as a brief intervention for excessive drinking: a meta-analytic review. Alcohol Alcohol. 2006;41:328-335.
23. Magill M, Ray LA. Cognitive-behavioral treatment with adult alcohol and illicit drug users: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. J Stud Alcohol Drugs. 2009;70:516-527.
24. Roozen HG, Boulogne JJ, van Tulder MW, et al. A systematic review of the effectiveness of the community reinforcement approach in alcohol, cocaine and opioid addiction. Drug Alcohol Depend. 2004;74:1-13. (Pubitemid 38457048)
25. Powers MB, Vedel E, Emmelkamp PMG. Behavioral couples therapy (BCT) for alcohol and drug use disorders: a meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Rev. 2008;28:952-962.
26. Martin T, LaRowe SD, Malcolm R. Progress in cue exposure therapy for the treatment of addictive disorders: a review update. Open Addict J. 2010;3:92-101.
27. Project MATCH Research Group. Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: treatment main effects and matching effects on drinking during treatment. J Stud Alcohol. 1998;59:631-639.
28. Project MATCH Research Group. Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: Project MATCH three-year drinking outcomes. Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 1998;22:1300-1311.
29. Ouimette PC, Finney JW, Moos RH. Twelve-step and cognitive-behavioral treatment for substance abuse: a comparison of treatment effectiveness. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1997;65:230-240. (Pubitemid 27147441)
30. Ferri M, Amato L, Davoli M. Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programmes for alcohol dependence. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006;3:CD005032.
31. Kaskutas LA. Comments on the Cochrane Review on Alcoholics Anonymous effectiveness. Addiction. 2008;103:1402-1403. (Pubitemid 352009045)
32. Messer S, Wampold BE. Let's face facts, common factors are more potent than specific therapy ingredients. Clin Psychol Sci Pract. 2002;9:21-25. (Pubitemid 41288906)
33. Reisner AD. The common factors, empirically validated treatments and the recovery models of therapeutic change. Psychol Rec. 2005;55:377-399. (Pubitemid 41179905)
34. Najavits LM, Weiss R. Variations in therapist effectiveness in the treatment of patients with substance use disorders: an empirical review. Addiction. 1994;89:679-688. (Pubitemid 24183453)
35. Project MATCH Research Group. Therapist effects in three treatments for alcohol problems. Psychother Res. 1998;8:455-474.
36. McLellan AT, Woody G, Luborsky L, et al. Is the counselor an active ingredient in substance abuse rehabilitation? An examination of treatment success among four counsellors. J Nerv Ment Dis. 1988;176:423-430.
37. Okiishi JC, Lambert MJ, Eggett D, et al. An analysis of therapist effects: toward providing feedback to individual therapists on their clients' psychotherapy outcomes. J Clin Psychol. 2006;62:1157-1172. (Pubitemid 44320295)
38. Miller WR, Taylor C, West J. Focused versus broad spectrum behavior therapy for problem drinkers. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1980;48:590-601. (Pubitemid 11245891)
39. Lebow J, Kelly J, Knobloch-Fedder LM, et al. Relationship factors in treating substance use disorders. In: Castonguay LG, Beutler LE, editors. Principles of therapeutic change that work. New York (NY): Oxford Press Inc; 2006. p 293-318.
40. DiClemente CC, Carroll KM, Miller WR, et al. A look inside treatment: therapist effects, the therapeutic alliance, and the process of intentional behavior change. In: Babor TF, Del Boca FK, editors. Treatment Matching in Alcoholism. Cambridge (GB): Cambridge University Press; 2003. p 166-183.
41. Luborsky L, O'Brien CP. Therapist success and its determinants. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1985;42:602-611. (Pubitemid 15058338)
42. Crits-Christoph P. Meta-analysis of therapist effects in psychotherapy outcome studies. Psychother Res. 1991;1:81-91.
43. Miller WR, Benefield RG, Tonigan J. Enhancing motivation for change in problem drinking: a controlled comparison of two therapist styles. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1993;61:455-461. (Pubitemid 23179698)
44. Wilson GT. Manual-based treatments: the clinical application of research findings. Behav Res Ther. 1996;34:295-314. (Pubitemid 26108360)
45. Addis ME, Cardemil EV. Does manualization improve therapy outcomes? In: Norcross JC, Beutler LE, Levant RF, editors. Evidence-based practices in mental health: debate and dialogue on the fundamental questions. Washington (DC): American Psychological Association; 2006. p 131-160.
46. Regier D, Farmer M, Rae D, et al. Comorbidity of mental disorders with alcohol and other drug abuse: results from the Epidemiological Catchment Area (ECA) Study. JAMA. 1990;264:2511-2518.
47. Degenhardt L, Hall W. Patterns of co-morbidity between alcohol use and other substance use in the Australian population. Drug Alcohol Rev. 2003;22:7-13. (Pubitemid 36419836)
48. Stinson FS, Grant BF, Dawson DA, et al. Comorbidity between DSM-IV alcohol and specific drug use disorders in the United States: results from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions. Drug Alcohol Depend. 2005;80:105-116. (Pubitemid 41266966)
49. Chan Y, Dennis ML, Funk RR. Prevalence and comorbidity of major internalizing and externalizing problems among adolescents and adults presenting to substance abuse treatment. J Subst Abuse Treat. 2008;34:14-24. (Pubitemid 350216349)
50. Australian Government Department of Health and Aging. Guidelines for the treatment of alcohol problems. Sydney (AU): Commonwealth of Australia: Department of Health and Aging; 2009.
51. Gossop M, Carroll KM. Disulfiram, cocaine, and alcohol: two outcomes for the price of one? Alcohol Alcohol. 2006;41:119-120.
52. Prendergast M, Podus D, Finney J, et al. Contingency management for treatment of substance use disorders: a meta-analysis. Addiction. 2006;101:1546-1560. (Pubitemid 44527186)
53. Petrakis IL, Gonzalez G, Rosenheck R, et al. Comorbidity of alcoholism and psychiatric disorders. Alcohol Res Health. 2002;26:81-89.
54. Trull TJ, Jahng S, Tomko RL, et al. Revised NESARC personality disorder diagnoses: gender, prevalence, and comorbidity with substance dependence disorders. J Pers Disord. 2010;24:412-426.
55. Rush BR, Castel S. Validation and comparison of screening tools for mental disorders in the substance abuse treatment population. Presented at the International Conference on Outcomes Measurement (ICOM); Bethesda (MA); 2008.
56. Rush BR. On the screening and assessment of mental disorders among clients seeking help from specialized substance abuse treatment services: an international symposium. (Editorial). Int J Ment Health Addiction. 2008;6:1-6.
57. Health Canada. Best practices: concurrent mental health and substance use disorders. Ottawa (ON): Health Canada; 2002.
58. Flynne P, Brown B. Co-occurring disorders in substance abuse treatment: issues and prospects. J Subst Abuse Treat. 2008;34:36-47. (Pubitemid 350216354)
59. Reedy AR, Hall JA. Treatment issues with substance use disorder clients who have mood or anxiety disorders. Ment Health Subst Use. 2008;1:44-53.
60. Zikos E, Gill KJ, Charney DA. Personality disorders among alcoholic outpatients: prevalence and course in treatment. Can J Psychiatry. 2010;55:65-73.
61. Sullivan LE, Fiellin DA, O'Connor PG. The prevalence and impact of alcohol problems in major depression: a systematic review. Am J Med. 2005;118:330-341. (Pubitemid 40460990)
62. Kavanagh DJ, Mueser KT. Current evidence on integrated treatment for serious mental disorder and substance misuse. Tidsskrift for Norsk Psykologforening [Journal of the Norwegian Psychological Association]. 2007;44:618-637.
63. Rush BR, Nadeau L. On the integration of mental health and substance use services and systems. In: Cooper D, editor. Responding in mental health. Oxford (GB): Radcliffe Publishing Ltd; 2011. Chapter 13, p 148-175. Mental Health-Substance Use series. Book 3.
64. Hesse M. Integrated psychological treatment for substance use and co-morbid anxiety or depression vs treatment for substance use alone. A systematic review of the published literature. BMC Psychiatry. 2009;20:1-8.
65. Tiet QQ, Mausbach B. Treatments for patients with dual diagnosis: a review. Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2007;31:513-536. (Pubitemid 46434889)
66. Horsfall J, Cleary M, Hunt GE, et al. Psychosocial treatments for people with co-occurring severe mental illnesses and substance use disorders (dual diagnosis): a review of empirical evidence. Harv Rev Psychiatry. 2009;17:24-34.
67. Cleary M, Hunt GE, Matheson S, et al. Psychosocial treatment programs for people with both severe mental illness and substance misuse. Schizophr Bull. 2008;34:226-228. (Pubitemid 351323344)
68. Drake RE, O'Neal EL, Wallach MA. A systematic review of psychosocial research on psychosocial interventions for people with co-occurring severe mental and substance use disorders. J Subst Abuse Treat. 2008;34:123-138. (Pubitemid 350216356)
69. Swinson RP, Antony MM, Bleau P, et al. Clinical practice guidelines: management of anxiety disorders. Can J Psychiatry. 2006;51:S1-S93.
70. Parikh SV, Sega ZV, Grigoriadis S, et al. Canadian Network for Mood and Anxiety Treatments (CANMAT) clinical guidelines for the management of major depressive disorder in adults. II. Psychotherapy alone or in combination with antidepressant medication. J Affect Disord; 2009.
71. Glaser F. Anybody got a match? Treatment research and the matching hypothesis. In: Edwards G, Grant M, editors. Alcoholism treatment in transition. Baltimore (MD): University Park Press; 1980.
72. Pattison EM. A systems approach to alcoholism treatment. In: Pattison EM, Kaufman E, editors. Encyclopedic handbook of alcoholism. New York (NY): Gardner Press; 1982. p 1080-1108.
73. Buhringer G. Allocating treatment options to patient profiles: clinical art or science. Addiction. 2006;101:646-652.
74. Finney JW. Enhancing substance abuse treatment evaluations: examining mediators and moderators of treatment effects. J Subst Abuse. 1995;7:135-150.
75. Witkiewitz K, Hartzler B, Donovan D. Matching motivation enhancement treatment to client motivation: re-examining the Project MATCH motivation-matching hypothesis. Addiction. 2010;105:1403-1413.
76. UKATT Research Team. UK Alcohol Treatment Trial client-treatment matching effects. Addiction. 2008;103:228-238.
77. Ouimette PC, Finney JW, Gima K, et al. A comparative evaluation of substance abuse treatment: III. Examining mechanisms underlying patient-treatment matching hypotheses for 12-step and cognitive-behavioral treatments for substance abuse. Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 1999;23:545-551. (Pubitemid 29144853)
78. Finney JW, Noyes CA, Coutts AJ, et al. Evaluating substance abuse treatment process models: I. Changes on proximal outcome variables during 12-step and cognitive-behavioral treatment. J Stud Alcohol. 1998;59:371-380. (Pubitemid 28272657)
79. Finney JW, Moos RH, Humphreys K. A comparative evaluation of substance abuse treatment: II. Linking proximal outcomes of 12-step and cognitive-behavioral treatment to substance use outcomes. Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 1999;23:537-544. (Pubitemid 29144852)
80. Morgenstern J, Longabaugh R. Cognitive-behavioral treatment for alcohol dependence: a review of evidence for its hypothesized mechanisms of action. Addiction. 2000;95:1475-1490.
81. Rehm J. Key future research questions on mediators and moderators of behaviour change processes for substance abuse. Int J Methods Psychiatr Res. 2008;17:S83-S87.
82. Buhringer G, Wittchen HU, Gottlebe K, et al. Why people change? The role of cognitive-control processes in the onset and cessation of substance abuse disorders. Int J Methods Psychiatr Res. 2008;17:S4-S15.
83. Havassy B, Alvidrez J, Owen K. Comparisons of patients with comorbid psychiatric and substance use disorders: implications for treatment and service delivery. Am J Psychiatry. 2004;161:139-145. (Pubitemid 38419319)
84. Babor T. Treatment for persons with substance use disorders: mediators, moderators, and the need for a new research approach. Int J Methods Psychiatr Res. 2008;17:S45-S49.
85. Health Canada. Best practices: substance abuse treatment and rehabilitation. Ottawa (ON): Health Canada; 1999.
86. Tiet QQ, Ilgan MA, Byrnes HF, et al. Treatment setting and baseline substance use severity interact to predict patients' outcome. Addiction. 2007;102:432-440. (Pubitemid 46239369)
87. Miller WR, Hester RK. Inpatient alcoholism treatment: who benefits? Am Psychol. 1986;41:794-805.
88. Martin GW, Koski-Jannes A, Weber T. Rethinking the role of residential treatment for individuals with substance use problems. Can J Commun Ment Health. 1998;17:61-78.
89. Godfrey C. Assessing the cost-effectiveness of alcohol services. J Ment Health. 1994;3:3-21.
90. Rychtarik RG, Connors GJ, Whitney RB, et al. Treatment settings for persons with alcoholism: evidence for matching clients to inpatient versus outpatient care. J Consult Clin Psychology. 2000;68:277-289.
91. Finney JW, Moos RH, Wilbourne PL. Effects of treatment setting duration and amount on patient outcomes. In: Ries RK, Miller SC, Fiellin DA, editors. Principles of addiction medicine. 4th ed. Philadelphia (PA): Wolters Flewers Health; 2009. p 379-386.
92. Bien TH, Miller WR, Tonigan JS. Brief interventions for alcohol problems: a review. Addiction. 1993;88:315-336.
93. Raylu N, Oei T, Loo J. The current status and future direction of self-help treatments for problem gamblers. Clin Psychol Rev. 2008;28:1372-1385.
94. Moyer A, Finney JW, Swearingen CE, et al. Brief interventions for alcohol problems: a meta-analytic review of controlled investigations in treatment-seeking and non-treatment-seeking populations. Addiction. 2002;97:279-292. (Pubitemid 34250722)
95. Koski-Jannes A, Cunningham J. Interest in different forms of self-help in a general population sample of drinkers. Addict Behav. 2001;26:91-99.
96. Kaner EF, Dickinson HO, Beyer FR, et al. Effectiveness of brief alcohol interventions in primary care populations. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007;(2):CD004148.
97. Nilsen P, Kaner E, Babor T. Brief interventions three decades on: an overview of research findings and strategies for more widespread implementation. Nordic Studies on Alcohol and Drugs. 2008;25:453-467. Nordisk Alkohol Nark has an annual supplement in English: Nordic Studies on Alcohol and Drugs.
98. Gastfriend DR, Mee-Lee D. The ASAM patient placement criteria: context, concepts and continuing development. J Addict Dis. 2003;22(Suppl 1):1-8.
99. Deck D, Gabriel R, Knudsen J, et al. Impact of patient placement criteria on substance abuse treatment under the Oregon Health Plan. J Addict Dis. 2003;22:27-44.
100. Kosanke N, Magura S, Staines G, et al. Feasibility of matching alcohol patients to ASAM levels of care. Am J Addict. 2002;11:124-134. (Pubitemid 34538649)
101. Magura S, Staines G, Kosanke N, et al. Predictive validity of the ASAM Patient Placement Criteria for naturalistically matched vs mismatched alcoholism patients. Am J Addict. 2003;12:386-397. (Pubitemid 37449025)
102. Greenfield SF, Brooks AJ, Gordon SM, et al. Substance abuse treatment entry, retention, and outcome in women: a review of the literature. Drug Alcohol Depend. 2007;86:1-21. (Pubitemid 44708526)
103. Ashley SO, Marsden ME, Brady TM. Effectiveness of substance abuse treatment programming for women: a review. Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse. 2003;29:19-53. (Pubitemid 36469292)
104. McLellan AT, Grissom GR, Zanis D, et al. Problem-service 'matching' in addiction treatment: a prospective study in 4 programs. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1997;54:730-735. (Pubitemid 27344100)
105. Hser YI, Polinsky ML, Maglione M, et al. Matching clients' needs with drug treatment services. J Subst Abuse Treat. 1999;16:299-305. (Pubitemid 29235195)
106. McLellan AT, Lewis D, O'Brien C, et al. Drug dependence, a chronic medical illness: implications for treatment, insurance, and outcomes evaluation. JAMA. 2000;284:1689-1695.
107. Dennis ML, Scott CK, Funk RR, et al. The duration and correlates of addiction and treatment. J Subst Abuse Treat. 2005;28:S51-S62.
108. McKay JR. Is there a case for extended interventions for alcohol and drug disorders? Addict. 2005;100:1594-1610. (Pubitemid 41626823)
109. Ritter A, Cameron J. A review of the efficacy and effectiveness of harm reduction strategies for alcohol, tobacco and illicit drugs. Drug Alcohol Rev. 2006;25:611-624. (Pubitemid 44837649)
110. Dennis ML, Scott CK, Funk RR. An experimental evaluation of recovery management checkups (RMC) for people with chronic substance use disorders. Eval Program Plann. 2003;26:339-352. (Pubitemid 36978472)
111. Scott CK, Dennis ML. Results from two randomized clinical trials evaluating the impact of quarterly recovery management checkups with adult chronic substance users. Addiction. 2009;104:959-971.
112. UKATT Research Team. Effectiveness of treatment for alcohol problems: findings of the randomised UK alcohol treatment trial (UKATT). BMJ. 2005;331:531-541.
113. Rush BR, Corea L, Martin GW. Monitoring alcohol and other drug treatment: what would an optimal system look like? Contemp Drug Probl. 2009;36:545-574.
114. Ontario Substance Abuse Bureau. Setting the course: a framework for integrating addiction treatment services in Ontario. Toronto (ON): Government of Ontario; 1999.
115. Sobell MB, Sobell LC. Stepped care as a heuristic approach to the treatment of alcohol problems. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2000;68:573-579.
116. Institute of Medicine. Broadening the base of treatment for alcohol problems. Washington (DC): National Academy Press; 1990.
117. Miller WR, Carroll KM. Drawing the science together: ten principles, ten recommendations. In: Miller WR, Carroll KM, editors. Rethinking substance abuse: what the science shows and what we should do about it. New York (NY): Guildford Press; 2006. p 293-312.
118. National Treatment Strategy Working Group. A systems approach to substance use in Canada: recommendations for a national treatment strategy [Internet]. Ottawa (ON): National Framework for Action to Reduce the Harms Associated with Alcohol and Other Drugs and Substances in Canada; 2008. Available from: http://www.nationalframework-cadrenational.ca/uploads/files/TWS- Treatment/nts-report-eng.pdf.