Effect of Financial Relationships on the Behaviors of Health Care Professionals: A Review of the Evidence

Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics

Volumn 40, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 452-466

  Robertson, Christopher ^a   Rose, Susannah ^a   Kesselheim, Aaron S ^b  

^a HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b BRIGHAM AND WOMEN S HOSPITAL   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CLINICAL PRACTICE; CONFLICT OF INTEREST; DRUG INDUSTRY; ECONOMICS; ETHICS; HUMAN; LEGAL ASPECT; MOTIVATION; PATIENT REFERRAL; PHYSICIAN SELF-REFERRAL; POLICY; REIMBURSEMENT; UNITED STATES;

CONFLICT OF INTEREST; DRUG INDUSTRY; HUMANS; MOTIVATION; PHYSICIAN SELF-REFERRAL; PHYSICIAN'S PRACTICE PATTERNS; PUBLIC POLICY; REFERRAL AND CONSULTATION; REIMBURSEMENT, INCENTIVE; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84867618342     PISSN: 10731105     EISSN: 1748720X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2012.00678.x     Document Type: Article

References (89)

1. Gonzales v. Raich, 545 U.S. 1, 31, 125 S. Ct. 2195, 2214, 162 L. Ed. 2d 1 (2005) (citing United States v. Moore, 423 U.S. 122, 96 S.Ct. 335, 46 L.Ed.2d 333 (1975); United States v. Doremus, 249 U.S. 86, 39 S.Ct. 214, 63 L.Ed. 493 (1919)).
2. American Medical Association Code of Medical Ethics § 8.03, available at (last visited July 12, 2012) [hereinafter AMA CODE].
3. P. A. Ubel, "Commentary: How Did We Get into This Mess?" in D. A. Moore et al., eds., Conflicts of Interests: Challenges and Solutions in Business, Law, Medicine, and Public Policy ( New York : Cambridge University Press, 2005): 142-151, at 143-149
4. D. Katz, A. L. Caplan and J. F. Merz, "All Gifts Large and Small, "American Journal of Bioethics, 3, no. 3 (Summer 2003): 39-46
5. J. P. Orlowski and L. Wateska, "The Effects of Pharmaceutical Firm Enticements on Physician Prescribing Patterns, " Chest 102, no. 1 (1992): 270-273.
6. Research on the Comparative Effectiveness of Medical Treatments: Issues and Options for an Expanded Federal Role, "2007 CBO REPORT, "available at (last visited July 21, 2012) [citing Institute of Medicine, "Learning What Works Best: The Nation's Need for Evidence on Comparative Effectiveness in Health Care, "available at (last visited July 21, 2012)].
7. For an example of this broader literature, see e.g., J. Kosecoff et al., "Prospective Payment System and Impairment at Discharge: The "Quicker-and-Sicker" Story Revisited, " JAMA 264, no. 15 (1990): 1980-1983. (studying patients in 300 hospitals and finding that when Medicare switched to a prospective payment system in which hospitals were paid a fixed fee for each patient rather than based on the costs of care, patients were discharged sooner and in less stable condition); and M. Tickle et al., "Paying for the Wrong Kind of Performance? Financial Incentives and Behaviour Changes in National Health Service Dentistry, "Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology 39, no. 5 (2011): 465-473 (examining a conflict of interest situation for dentists).
8. For a discussion of these laws, see J. H. Krause, "Following the Money in Health Care Fraud: Reflections on a Modern-Day Yellow Brick Road, " American Journal of Law and Medicine 36, nos. 2 & 3 (2010): 365-369, at 343-69.
9. See J. F. Burris and W. J. Mroczek, "Letter to the Editor, " New England Journal of Medicine 324, no. 19 (1991): 1371-1373 (responding to the Hillman 1990 article discussed infra note at 12).
10. J. M. Mitchell, "The Prevalence of Physician Self-Referral Arrangements After Stark II: Evidence from Advanced Diagnostic Imaging, " Health Affairs 26, no. 3 (2007): 415.
11. B. J. Hillman et al., "Frequency and Cost of Diagnostic Imaging in Office Practice-A Comparison of Self-Referring and Radiologist-Referring Physicians, " New England Journal of Medicine 323, no. 23 (1990): 1604-1608.
12. This result was statistically significant at the .05 level, as are all other results discussed in this article, unless otherwise noted.
13. B. J. Hillman et al., "Physicians' Utilization and Charges for Outpatient Diagnostic Imaging in a Medicare Population, " JAMA 268, no. 15 (1992): 2050-2054.
14. J. B. Shreibati and L. C. Baker, "The Relationship Between Low Back Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Surgery, and Spending: Impact of Physician Self-Referral Status, " Health Services Resource 46, no. 5 (2011): 1362-1381, available at (last visited July 21, 2012).
15. B. R. Shah et al. "Association Between Physician Billing and Cardiac Stress Testing Patterns Following Coronary Revascularization, " JAMA 306, no. 18 (2011): 1993-2000.
16. M. Jacobsen et al., "How Medicare's Payment Cuts for Cancer Chemotherapy Drugs Changed Patterns of Treatment, " Health Affairs 29, no. 7 (2010): 1391-1399.
17. J. Mitchell, "Urologists' Self-Referral for Pathology Of Biopsy Specimens Linked to Increased Use and Lower Prostate Cancer Detection, " Health Affairs 31, no. 7 (2012): 741.
18. For additional research examining self-referrals in the urology specialty see H. J. Tan, "Use of Ureteroscopy Before and After Expansion of Lithotripter Ownership in Michigan, "Urology 78, no. 6 (2011): 1287-1291 (finding that physician ownership of lithiotripters did not decrease utilization of the substitute procedure, ureteroscpy);
19. J. M. Hollingsworth, S. L. Krein, J. D. Birkmeyer et al., "Opening Ambulatory Surgery Centers and Stone Surgery Rates in Health Care Markets, " Journal of Urology 184, no. 3 (2010): 967-971;
20. J. M. Hollingsworth, Z. Ye, and S. A. Strope et al., "Urologist Ownership of Ambulatory Surgery Centers and Urinary Stone Surgery Use, " Health Service Research 44, no. 4 (2009): 1370-1384.
21. J. M. Mitchell and E. Scott, "Physician Ownership of Physical Therapy Services: Effects on Charges, Utilization, Profits, and Service Characteristics, " JAMA 268, no. 15 (1992): 2055-2059.
22. In another study, drawing from two surveys of physical therapists, Mitchell and Sass sought to explore two alternative explanations as to why physicians purchase shares in physical therapy providers - to control the quality of services provided to the patients they refer or to profit from the physician's ability to steer patients by artificially inflating demand for a particular provider. J. M. Mitchell and T. R. Sass, "Physician Ownership of Ancillary Services: Indirect Demand Inducement or Quality Assurance?"Journal of Health Economics 14, no. 3 (1995): 263-289. The researchers found that "a physical therapy clinic that receives all of its referrals from physician owners treats a patient for approximately 50 percent more visits than a clinic that receives no referrals from owners."Id., at 285. Mitchell and Sass also observed that the differential is directly related to "increases in physician density, decreases in population density, and increases in the total number of owners, " which they argued were factors facilitating demand inducement.
23. A. Swedlow et al., "Increased Costs and Rates of Use in the California Workers' Compensation System as a Result of Self-Referral by Physicians, " New England Journal of Medicine 327, no. 21 (1992): 1502-1506.
24. J. M. Mitchell, "Do Financial Incentives Linked to Ownership of Specialty Hospitals Affect Physicians' Practice Patterns?" Medical Care 46, no. 7 (2008): 732-737.
25. Similarly, in a 2005 article, Iglehart offered a case study documenting the impact of the opening of a specialty hospital in Oklahoma, near a university hospital. Iglehart reports that "the number of inpatients admitted for cardiac care plummeted at the university hospital after 16 surgeons and cardiologists on the clinical faculty began to refer all their patients to the specialty hospital as soon as it opened, " resulting over $11.6 million in lost income for the university hospital over two years. J. K. Iglehart, "The Emergence of Physician-Owned Specialty Hospitals, "New England Journal of Medicine 352, no. 1 (2005): 78-84.
26. J. R. Gabel et al., "Where Do I Send Thee? Does Physician-Ownership Affect Referral Patterns to Ambulatory Surgery Centers?" Health Affairs 27, no. 3 (2008): w165.
27. R. P. Ellis and T. G. McGuire, "Provider Behavior Under Prospective Reimbursement: Cost Sharing and Supply, " Journal of Health Economics 5, no. 2 (1986): 129-151.
28. T. McGuire, "Physician Agency, " in A. C. Cuyler and J. P. Newhouse, eds., Handbook of Health Economics (Amsterdam: North-Holland, 2000).
29. M. A. Rodwin, Conflicts of Interest and the Future of Medicine: The United States, France, and Japan. ( Oxford : Oxford University Press, 2011).
30. J. Shen, R. A. Brook, G. Kominski, P. S. Albert, and N. Wenger, "The Effects of Payment Method on Clinical Decision-Making: Physician Responses to Clinical Scenarios, " Medical Care 42, no. 3 (2004): 297-302.
31. H. Hennig-Schmidt, R. Selten, and D. Wiesen, "How Payment Systems Affect Physicians' Provision Behaviour - An Experimental Investigation, " Journal of Health Economics 30, no. 4, (2011): 637-646.
32. D. Hemenway et al., "Physicians Responses to Financial Incentives-Evidence from a For-Profit Ambulatory Care Center, " New England Journal of Medicine 322, no. 15 (1990): 1059-1063.
33. R. A. Devlin and S. Sarmab, "Do Physician Remuneration Schemes Matter? The Case of Canadian Family Physicians, " Journal of Health Economics 27, no. 5 (2008): 1168-1181.
34. C. Chaiz-Couturier et al., "Effects of Financial Incentives on Medical Practice: Results from a Systematic Review of the Literature and Methodological Issues, " International Journal of Quality in Health Care 12, no. 2 (2000): 133-142.
35. R. Town et al., "Economic Incentives and Physicians' Delivery of Preventive Care, " American Journal of Preventive Medicine 28, no. 2 (2005): 234-240.
36. A. Scott et al., "The Effect of Financial Incentives on The Quality of Health Care Provided By Primary Care Physicians, " The Cochrane Collaboration, The Cochrane Library, Issue 9 (2011).
37. D. Echevin and B. Fortin, "Physician Payment Mechanisms, Hospital Length of Stay and Risk of Readmission: A Natural Experiment, " SSRN eLibrary (2011).
38. K. J. Mullen, R. G. Frank and M. B. Rosenthal, "Can You Get What You Pay for? Pay-for-Performance and the Quality of Healthcare Providers, " RAND Journal of Economics 41, no. 1 (2010): 64-91
39. Testimony of Meredith B. Rosenthal, Ph.D., Hearing on Examining Pay-for-Performance Measures and Other Trends in Employer-Sponsored Health Care, U.S. House Subcommittee on Employer-Employee Relations (2005).
40. Institute of Medicine, Rewarding Provider Performance: Aligning Incentives in Medicare, Washington D.C., 2006.
41. G. Flodgren et al., "An Overview of Reviews Evaluating the Effectiveness of Financial Incentives in Changing Healthcare Professional Behaviours and Patient outcomes, " Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, the Cochrane Library (2011)
42. P. Van Herck et al, "Systematic Review: Effects, Design Choices, and Context of Pay-For-Performance in Health Care, " Boston Medical Center Health Services Research 10 (2010): 247
43. B. Serumaga et al., "Effect of Pay for Performance on The Management and, Outcomes of Hypertension in the United Kingdom: Interrupted Time Series Study, " Boston Medical Journal 342 (2011): d108;
44. P. P. Barros, "Cream-Skimming, Incentives for Efficiency and Payment System, " Journal of Health Economics 22, no. 3 (2003): 419-443.
45. A. R. H. Dalton, R. Alshamsan, and A. Majeed et al., "Exclusion of Patients from Quality Measurement of Diabetes Care in the UK Pay-for-Performance Programme, " Diabetic Medicine 28, no. 5 (2011): 525-531.
46. R. Alshamsan, "Impact of Pay for Performance on Inequalities in Health Care: Systematic Review, " Journal of Health Services Research Policy 15, no. 3 (2010): 178-184.
47. In addition to the foregoing sources, see L. Peterson et al., "Does Pay-for-Performance Improve the Quality of Health Care?" Annals of Internal Medicine 145, no. 4 (2006): at 265-272.
48. P. A. Williams, R. Cockerill and F. H. Lowy, "The Physician as Prescriber: Relations Between Knowledge about Prescription Drugs, Encounters with Patients and the Pharmaceutical Industry, and Prescription Volume, " Health and Canadian Society 3 (1995): 135-164.
49. M. Y. Peay and E. R. Peay, "The Role of Commercial Sources in the Adoption of a New Drug, " Social Science in Medicine 26, no. 12 (1988): 1183-1189.
50. D. Berings, L. Blondeel, and H. Habraken, "The Effect of Industry-Independent Drug Information on the Prescribing of Benzodiazepines in General Practice, " European Journal of Clinical Pharmacolology 46, no. 6 (1994): 501-505.
51. M. Y. Peay and E. R. Peay, "Innovation in High Risk Drug Therapy, "Social Science in Medicine 39, no. 1, (1994): 39-52.
52. A. Wazana, "Physicians and The Pharmaceutical Industry: Is A Gift Ever Just A Gift?" JAMA 283, no. 3 (2000): 373-380.
53. P. Manchanda and E. Honka, "The Effects and Role of Direct-to-Physician Marketing in the Pharmaceutical Industry: An Integrative Review, " Yale Journal of Health Policy, Law and Ethics 5, no. 2 (2005): 785-812;
54. J. Lexchin, "Interactions Between Physicians and the Pharmaceutical Industry: What Does the Literature Say?" Canadian Medical Association Journal 149, no. 10 (1993): 1401-1407.
55. E. E. Roughead, K. J. Harvey and A. L. Gilbert, "Commercial Detailing Techniques Used by Pharmaceutical Representatives to Influence Prescribing, " Australia New Zealand Journal of Medicine 28, no. 3 (1998): 306-310.
56. J. Dana and G. Loewenstein, "A Social Science Perspective on Gifts to Physicians from Industry, " JAMA 290, no. 2 (2003): 252-255.
57. E. G. Campbell, S. R. Rao, C. M. DesRoches, L. I. Iezzoni, C. Vogeli, D. Bolcic-Jankovic, and P. D. Miralles, "Physician Professionalism and Changes in Physician-Industry Relationships from 2004 to 2009, " Archives of Internal Medicine 170, no. 20 (2010): 1820-1826.
58. E. C. Halperin, P. Hutchison and R. C. Barrier, Jr., "A Population-Based Study of the Prevalence and Influence of Gifts to Radiation Oncologists from Pharmaceutical Companies and Medical Equipment Manufacturers, " International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics 59, no. 5 (2004): 1477-1483.
59. P. M. McNeill, I. H. Kerridge, D. A. Henry, B. Stokes, S. R. Hill, D. Newby et al., "Giving and Receiving of Gifts between Pharmaceutical Companies and Medical Specialists in Australia, " Internal Medicine Journal 36, no. 9 (2006): 571-578.
60. S. Saito, K. Mukohara, and S. Bito, "Japanese Practicing Physicians' Relationships with Pharmaceutical Representatives: A National Survey, " PLoS 5 (2010).
61. M. M. Chren and C. S. Landefeld, "Physicians' Behavior and Their Interactions with Drug Companies: A Controlled Study of Physicians Who Requested Additions to a Hospital Drug Formulary, " JAMA 271 (1994): 684-689.
62. N. Lurie, E. C. Rich, and D. E. Simpson et al., "Pharmaceutical Representatives in Academic Medical Centers, " Journal of General Internal Medicine 5, no. 3 (1990): 240-243.
63. P. Rutledge, D. Crookes, B. McKinstry, and S. R. Maxwell, "Do Doctors Rely on Pharmaceutical Industry Funding to Attend Conferences and Do They Perceive That This Creates a Bias in Their Drug Selection? Results from A Questionnaire Survey, " Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Safety 12, no. 8 (2003): 663-667.
64. K. Campo, O. De Staebel, E. Gijsbrechts, and W. van Waterschoot, "Physicians' Decision Process for Drug Prescription and the Impact of Pharmaceutical Marketing Mix Instruments, " Health Marketing Quarterly 22, no. 4 (2005): 73-107.
65. M. A. Bowman and D. L. Pearle, "Changes in Drug Prescribing Patterns Related to Commercial Company Funding of Continuing Medical Education, " Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions 8 no. 1 (1988): 13-20.
66. J. P. Orlowski and L. Wateska, "The Effects of Pharmaceutical Firm Enticements on Physician Prescribing Patterns, " Chest 102, no. 1 (1992): 270-273.
67. K. E. Austad, J. Avorn, and A. S. Kesselheim, "Medical Students' Exposure to and Attitudes About the Pharmaceutical Industry: A Systematic Review, " PLoS Medicine 8, no. 5 (2011): e1001037.
68. W. S. Sandberg, R. Carlos, E. H. Sandberg and M. F. Roizen, "The Effect of Educational Gifts from Pharmaceutical Firms on Medical Students' Recall of Company Names or Products, " Academic Medicine 72, no. 10 (1997): 916-918.
69. S. L. Cutrona, S. Woolhandler, K. E. Lasser, D. H. Bor, D. McCormick, and D. U. Himmelstein, "Characteristics of Recipients of Free Prescription Drug Samples: A Nationally Representative Analysis, " American Journal of Public Health 98, no. 2 (2008): 284-289.
70. D. Morelli and M. R. Koenigsberg, "Sample Medication Dispensing in a Residency Practice, " Journal of Family Practitioners 34, no. 1 (1992): 42-48
71. J. M. Westfall, J. McCabe, and R. A. Nicholas, "Personal Use of Drug Samples by Physicians and Office Staff, " JAMA 278, no. 2 (1997): 141-143.
72. G. C. Alexander, J. Zhang, and A. Basu, "Characteristics of Patients Receiving Pharmaceutical Samples and Association between Sample Receipt and Out-of-Pocket Prescription Costs, " Medical Care 46, no. 4 (2008): 394-402.
73. A. N. Thomson, B. J. Craig, and P. M. Barham, "Attitudes of General Practitioners in New Zealand to Pharmaceutical Representatives, " British Journal of General Practice 44, no. 382 (1994): 220-223.
74. A. Fugh-Berman and S. Ahari, "Following the Script: How Drug Reps Make Friends and Influence Doctors, " PLoS Medicine 4 (2007): e150.
75. R. F. Adair and L. R. Holmgren, "Do Drug Samples Influence Resident Prescribing Behavior? A Randomized Trial, " American Journal of Medicine 118, no. 8 (2005): 881-884.
76. D. M. Hartung, D. Evans, D. G. Haxby, D. F. Kraemer, G. Andeen, and L. J. Fagnan, "Effect of Drug Sample Removal on Prescribing in a Family Practice Clinic, " Annals of Family Medicine 8, no. 5 (2010): 402-409.
77. J. M. Boltri, E. R. Gordon, and R. L. Vogel, "Effect of Antihypertensive Samples on Physician Prescribing Patterns, " Family Medicine 34, no. 10 (2002): 729-731.
78. D. Brewer, "The Effect of Drug Sampling Solicits on Residents' Prescribing, " Family Medicine 30, no. 7 (1998): 482-486.
79. L. D. Chew, T. S. O'Young, T. K. Hazlet, K. A. Bradley, C. Maynard and D. S. Lessler, "A Physician Survey on Effect of Drug Sample Availability on Physicians' Behavior, " Journal of General Internal Medicine 15, no. 7 (2000): 478-483.
80. R. G. Pinckney, A. S. Helminski, A. G. Kennedy, C. D. MacLean, L. Hurowitz, and E. Cote, "The Effect of Medication Samples on Self-Reported Prescribing Practices: A Statewide, Cross-Sectional Survey, " Journal of General Internal Medicine 26, no. 1 (2011): 40-44.
81. M. Y. Peay and E. R. Peay, "The Role of Commercial Sources in the Adoption of a New Drug, " Social Science in Medicine 26, no. 12 (1998): 1183-1189.
82. J. Avorn, M. Chen, and R. Hartley, "Scientific Versus Commercial Sources of Influence on the Prescribing Behavior of Physicians, " American Journal of Medicine 73, no. 1 (1982): 4-8.
83. M. G. Ziegler, P. Lew, and B. C. Singer, "The Accuracy of Drug Information from Pharmaceutical Sales Representatives, " JAMA 273, no. 16 (1995): 1296-1298.
84. B. Hodges, "Interactions with the Pharmaceutical Industry, " CMAJ 153, no. 5 (1995): 553-559.
85. D. Blumenthal, "Doctors and Drug Companies, " New England Journal of Medicine 351, no. 18 (2004): 1885-1890.
86. S. Sohn, "Intrinsic Motivational Drivers in Medical Networks from a Neuroscientific Perspective, " Journal of Neuroscience Psychology and Economics 4 no. 3, (2011): 192 (studying physicians and finding four different primary motivational factors).
87. For an analysis of this dynamic in the context of legal professionalism, see W. Bradley Wendell, "Nonlegal Regulation of the Legal Profession: Social Norms in Professional Communities, " Vanderbilt Law Review 54, no. 5 (2001): 1955.
88. D. Mechanic and M. Schlesinger, "The Impact of Managed Care on Patients'Trust in Medical Care and Their Physicians, " JAMA 275, no. 21 (1996): 1693-1697.
89. C. T. Robertson, "Biased Advice, " Emory Law Journal 60, no. 3 (2011): 653.