A comparison of DNA-based methods for delimiting species in a Cretan land snail radiation reveals shortcomings of exclusively molecular taxonomy

Cladistics

Volumn 28, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 300-316

  Sauer, Jan ^a,b   Hausdorf, Bernhard ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF HAMBURG   (Germany)

^b BIELEFELD UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ADAPTIVE RADIATION; COMPARATIVE STUDY; GENETIC ANALYSIS; MITOCHONDRIAL DNA; MOLECULAR ANALYSIS; MORPHOLOGY; SNAIL; SPECIATION (BIOLOGY); SPECIES DIVERSITY; TAXONOMY;

AEGEAN ISLANDS; CRETE; GREECE;

GASTROPODA; STYLOMMATOPHORA;

EID: 84861198911     PISSN: 07483007     EISSN: 10960031     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1096-0031.2011.00382.x     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. Albertson, R.C., Markert, J.A., Danley, P.D., Kocher, T.D., 1999. Phylogeny of a rapidly evolving clade: the cichlid fishes of Lake Malawi, East Africa. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 96, 5107-5110.
2. Barraclough, T.G., Hughes, M., Ashford-Hodges, N., Fujisawa, T., 2009. Inferring evolutionarily significant units of bacterial diversity from broad environmental surveys of single-locus data. Biol. Lett. 5, 425-428.
3. Blaxter, M., Elsworth, B., Daub, J., 2004. DNA taxonomy of a neglected animal phylum: an unexpected diversity of tardigrades. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 271, S189-S192.
4. Blaxter, M., Mann, J., Chapman, T., Thomas, F., Whitton, C., Floyd, R., Abebe, E., 2005. Defining operational taxonomic units using DNA barcode data. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., B, Biol. Sci. 360, 1935-1943.
5. Boato, A., 1988. Microevolution in Solatopupa landsnails (Pulmonata, Chondrinidae) - Genetic diversity and founder effects. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. Lond. 34, 327-348.
6. Brower, A.V.Z., 1999. Delimitation of phylogenetic species with DNA sequences: a critique of Davis and Nixon's population aggregation analysis. Syst. Biol. 48, 199-213.
7. Castresana, J., 2000. Selection of conserved blocks from multiple alignments for their use in phylogenetic analysis. Mol. Biol. Evol. 17, 540-552.
8. Chiba, S., 1999. Accelerated evolution of land snails Mandarina in the oceanic Bonin Islands: evidence from mitochondrial DNA sequences. Evolution 53, 460-471.
9. Clement, M., Posada, D., Crandall, K.A., 2000. TCS: a computer program to estimate gene genealogies. Mol. Ecol. 9, 1657-1659.
10. Davis, J.I., Nixon, K.C., 1992. Populations, genetic variation, and the delimitation of phylogenetic species. Syst. Biol. 41, 421-435.
11. Davison, A., Blackie, R.L.E., Scothern, G.P., 2009. DNA barcoding of stylommatophoran land snails: a test of existing sequences. Mol. Ecol. Resour. 9, 1092-1101.
12. DeSalle, R., Egan, M.G., Siddall, M., 2005. The unholy trinity: taxonomy, species delimitation and DNA barcoding. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., B, Biol. Sci. 360, 1905-1916.
13. Dettman, J.R., Jacobson, D.J., Taylor, J.W., 2003. A multilocus genealogical approach to phylogenetic species recognition in the model eukaryote Neurospora. Evolution 57, 2703-2720.
14. Drummond, A.J., Rambaut, A., 2007. BEAST: Bayesian evolutionary analysis by sampling trees. BMC Evol. Biol. 7, 214.
15. Drummond, A.J., Ho, S.Y.W., Phillips, M.J., Rambaut, A., 2006. Relaxed phylogenetics and dating with confidence. PLoS Biol. 4, e88.
16. Edwards, C.E., Soltis, D.E., Soltis, P.S., 2008. Using patterns of genetic structure based on microsatellite loci to test hypotheses of current hybridization, ancient hybridization and incomplete lineage sorting in Conradina (Lamiaceae). Mol. Ecol. 17, 5157-5174.
17. Evanno, G., Regnaut, S., Goudet, J., 2005. Detecting the number of clusters of individuals using the software STRUCTURE: a simulation study. Mol. Ecol. 14, 2611-2620.
18. Ezard, T., Fujisawa, T., Barraclough, T.G., 2009. Package 'splits: SPecies' LImits by Threshold Statistics' version 1.0-11/r29. Available from
19. Falush, D., Stephens, M., Pritchard, J.K., 2007. Inference of population structure using multilocus genotype data: dominant markers and null alleles. Mol. Ecol. Notes 7, 574-578.
20. Ferguson, J.W.H., 2002. On the use of genetic divergence for identifying species. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. Lond. 75, 509-516.
21. Floyd, R., Abebe, E., Papert, A., Blaxter, M., 2002. Molecular barcodes for soil nematode identification. Mol. Ecol. 11, 839-850.
22. Fontaneto, D., Herniou, E.A., Boschetti, C., Caprioli, M., Melone, G., Ricci, C., Barraclough, T.G., 2007. Independently evolving species in asexual bdelloid rotifers. PLoS Biol. 5, e87.
23. Fraley, C., Raftery, A.E., 1998. How many clusters? Which clustering method? Answers via model-based cluster analysis. Comput. J. 41, 578-588.
24. Funk, D.J., Omland, K.E., 2003. Species-level paraphyly and polyphyly: frequency, causes, and consequences, with insights from animal mitochondrial DNA. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 34, 397-423.
25. Good, J.M., Hird, S., Reid, N., Demboski, J.R., Steppan, S.J., Martin-Nims, T.R., Sullivan, J., 2008. Ancient hybridization and mitochondrial capture between two species of chipmunks. Mol. Ecol. 17, 1313-1327.
26. Goodacre, S.L., 2002. Population structure, history and gene flow in a group of closely related land snails: genetic variation in Partula from the Society Islands of the Pacific. Mol. Ecol. 11, 55-68.
27. Hausdorf, B., 2011. Progress toward a general species concept. Evolution 65, 923-931.
28. Hausdorf, B., Hennig, C., 2010. Species delimitation using dominant and codominant multilocus markers. Syst. Biol. 59, 491-503.
29. Hausdorf, B., Sauer, J., 2009. Revision of the Helicellinae of Crete (Gastropoda: Hygromiidae). Zool. J. Linn. Soc. 157, 373-419.
30. Hausdorf, B., Wilkens, H., Strecker, U., 2011. Population genetic patterns revealed by microsatellite data challenge the mitochondrial DNA based taxonomy of Astyanax in Mexico (Characidae, Teleostei). Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 60, 89-97.
31. Hayashi, M., Chiba, S., 2000. Intraspecific diversity of mitochondrial DNA in the land snail Euhadra peliomphala (Bradybaenidae). Biol. J. Linn. Soc. Lond. 70, 391-401.
32. Hebert, P.D.N., Cywinska, A., Ball, S.L., deWaard, J.R., 2003. Biological identifications through DNA barcodes. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 270, 313-321.
33. Hebert, P.D.N., Stoeckle, M.Y., Zemlak, T.S., Francis, C.M., 2004. Identification of birds through DNA barcodes. PLoS Biol. 2, e312.
34. Hendrich, L., Pons, J., Ribera, I., Balke, M., 2010. Mitochondrial cox1 sequence data reliably uncover patterns of insect diversity but suffer from high lineage-idiosyncratic error rates. PLoS ONE 5, e14448.
35. Hennig, C., 2010. Package 'fpc' version 2.0-3. Available from
36. Hennig, C., Hausdorf, B., 2007. Package 'prabclus' version 2.1-1. Available from
37. Hickerson, M.J., Meyer, C.P., Moritz, C., 2006. DNA barcoding will often fail to discover new animal species over broad parameter space. Syst. Biol. 55, 729-739.
38. Hubert, L., Arabie, P., 1985. Comparing partitions. J. Classif. 2, 193-218.
39. Huelsenbeck, J.P., Andolfatto, P., 2007. Inference of population structure under a Dirichlet process model. Genetics 175, 1787-1802.
40. Irwin, D.E., Rubtsov, A.S., Panov, E.N., 2009. Mitochondrial introgression and replacement between yellowhammers (Emberiza citrinella) and pine buntings (Emberiza leucocephalos) (Aves: Passeriformes). Biol. J. Linn. Soc. Lond. 98, 422-438.
41. Jobb, G., 2007. TREEFINDER version of November 2007. Available from
42. Jobb, G., von Haeseler, A., Strimmer, K., 2004. TREEFINDER: a powerful graphical analysis environment for molecular phylogenetics. BMC Evol. Biol. 4, 18.
43. Knowles, L.L., Carstens, B.C., 2007. Delimiting species without monophyletic gene trees. Syst. Biol. 56, 887-895.
44. Kruskal, J., 1964. Multidimensional scaling by optimizing goodness of fit to a nonmetric hypothesis. Psychometrika 29, 1-27.
45. Lee, M.S.Y., 2004. The molecularisation of taxonomy. Invertebr. Syst. 18, 1-6.
46. Lim, G.S., Balke, M., Meier, R., in press. Determining species boundaries in a world full of rarity: singletons, species delimitation methods. Syst. Biol.
47. Linnaeus, C., 1753. Species plantarum. 1-2. L. Salvius, Holmiae.
48. Linnaeus, C., 1758. Systema naturae.1. 10. ed. L. Salvius, Holmiae.
49. Little, D.P., Stevenson, D.W., 2007. A comparison of algorithms for the identification of specimens using DNA barcodes: examples from gymnosperms. Cladistics 23, 1-21.
50. Lohse, K., 2009. Can mtDNA barcodes be used to delimit species? A response to Pons et al. (2006). Syst. Biol. 58, 439-442.
51. Mallet, J., 1995. A species definition for the Modern Synthesis. Trends Ecol. Evol. 10, 294-299.
52. Marshall, J.C., Arévalo, E., Benavides, E., Sites, J.L., Sites., J.W. Jr, 2006. Delimiting species: comparing methods for Mendelian characters using lizards of the Sceloporus grammicus (Squamata: Phrynosomatidae) complex. Evolution 60, 1050-1065.
53. Martínez-Ortega, M., Delgado, L., Albach, D., Elena-Rosselló, J., Rico, E., 2004. Species boundaries and phylogeographic patterns in cryptic taxa inferred from AFLP markers: Veronica subgen. Pentasepalae (Scrophulariaceae) in the Western Mediterranean. Syst. Bot. 29, 965-986.
54. May, R.M., 1999. The dimensions of life on earth. In: Raven, P.H., Williams, T. (Eds), Nature and human society: the quest for a sustainable world. The National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, pp. 30-45.
55. May, R.M., Harvey, P.H., 2009. Species uncertainties. Science 323, 687.
56. Mayr, E., 1942. Systematics and the origin of species. Columbia University Press, New York.
57. Mayr, E., 1963. Animal species and evolution. Belknap Press, Cambridge, MA.
58. McGill, B.J., Etienne, R.S., Gray, J.S., Alonso, D., Anderson, M.J., Benecha, H.K., Dornelas, M., Enquist, B.J., Green, J.L., He, F., Hurlbert, A.H., Magurran, A.E., Marquet, P.A., Maurer, B.A., Ostling, A., Soykan, C.U., Ugland, K.I., White, E.P., 2007. Species abundance distributions: moving beyond single prediction theories to integration within an ecological framework. Ecol. Lett. 10, 995-1015.
59. Meier, R., Shiyang, K., Vaidya, G., Ng, P.K.L., 2006. DNA barcoding and taxonomy in Diptera: a tale of high intraspecific variability and low identification success. Syst. Biol. 55, 715-728.
60. Mendelson, T.C., Shaw, K.L., 2005. Rapid speciation in an arthropod. Nature 433, 375-376.
61. Meudt, H.M., Lockhart, P.J., Bryant, D., 2009. Species delimitation and phylogeny of a New Zealand plant species radiation. BMC Evol. Biol. 9, 111.
62. Meyer, C.P., Paulay, G., 2005. DNA Barcoding: error rates based on comprehensive sampling. PLoS Biol. 3, e422.
63. Monaghan, M.T., Wild, R., Elliot, M., Fujisawa, T., Balke, M., Inward, D.J., Lees, D.C., Ranaivosolo, R., Eggleton, P., Barraclough, T.G., Vogler, A.P., 2009. Accelerated species inventory on Madagascar using coalescent-based models of species delineation. Syst. Biol. 58, 298-311.
64. Nosil, P., Schluter, D., 2011. The genes underlying the process of speciation. Trends Ecol. Evol. 26, 160-167.
65. O'Meara, B.C., 2010. New heuristic methods for joint species delimitation and species tree inference. Syst. Biol. 59, 59-73.
66. Padial, J.M., Miralles, A., De la Riva, I., Vences, M., 2010. The integrative future of taxonomy. Front. Zool. 7, 16.
67. Palumbi, S., 1996. Nucleic acids II: the polymerase chain reaction. In: Hillis, D., Moritz, C., Mable, B. (Eds), Molecular Systematics. Sinauer, Sunderland, MA, pp. 205-247.
68. Parsons, Y.M., Shaw, K.L., 2001. Species boundaries and genetic diversity among Hawaiian crickets of the genus Laupala identified using amplified fragment length polymorphism. Mol. Ecol. 10, 1765-1772.
69. Pinceel, J., Jordaens, K., Backeljau, T., 2005. Extreme mtDNA divergences in a terrestrial slug (Gastropoda, Pulmonata, Arionidae): accelerated evolution, allopatric divergence and secondary contact. J. Evol. Biol. 18, 1264-1280.
70. Pons, J., Barraclough, T.G., Gomez-Zurita, J., Cardoso, A., Duran, D.P., Hazell, S., Kamoun, S., Sumlin, W.D., Vogler, A.P., 2006. Sequence-based species delimitation for the DNA taxonomy of undescribed insects. Syst. Biol. 55, 595-609.
71. Posada, D., Crandall, K., 1998. MODELTEST: testing the model of DNA substitution. Bioinformatics 14, 817-818.
72. Powell, J.R., Monaghan, M.T., Öpik, M., Rillig, M.C., 2011. Evolutionary criteria outperform operational approaches in producing ecologically relevant fungal species inventories. Mol. Ecol. 20, 655-666.
73. Presgraves, D.C., 2010. The molecular evolutionary basis of species formation. Nat. Rev. Genet. 11, 175-180.
74. Pritchard, J.K., Stephens, M., Donnelly, P., 2000. Inference of population structure using multilocus genotype data. Genetics 155, 945-959.
75. Quek, S.-P., Counterman, B.A., Albuquerque de Moura, P., Cardoso, M.Z., Marshall, C.R., McMillan, W.O., Kronforst, M.R., 2010. Dissecting comimetic radiations in Heliconius reveals divergent histories of convergent butterflies. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 107, 7365-7370.
76. R Development Core Team. 2007. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. Available from
77. Rambaut, A., Charleston, M., 2002. TreeEdit version 1.0a10. Available from
78. Rambaut, A., Drummond, A.J., 2007. Tracer version 1.5. Available from
79. Ratnasingham, S., Hebert, P.D.N., 2007. BOLD: The Barcode of Life Data System (). Mol. Ecol. Notes 7, 355-364.
80. van Riel, P., Jordaens, K., van Houtte, N., Martins, A.M.F., Verhagen, R., Backeljau, T., 2005. Molecular systematics of the endemic Leptaxini (Gastropoda: Pulmonata) on the Azores islands. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 37, 132-143.
81. Rieseberg, L.H., Blackman, B.K., 2010. Speciation genes in plants. Ann. Bot. 106, 439-455.
82. Sanderson, M.J., 2002. Estimating absolute rates of molecular evolution and divergence times: a penalized likelihood approach. Mol. Biol. Evol. 19, 101-109.
83. Sauer, J., Hausdorf, B., 2009. Sexual selection is involved in speciation in a land snail radiation on Crete. Evolution 63, 2535-2546.
84. Sauer, J., Hausdorf, B., 2010. Reconstructing the evolutionary history of the radiation of the land snail genus Xerocrassa on Crete based on mitochondrial sequences and AFLP markers. BMC Evol. Biol. 10, 299.
85. Schilthuizen, M., Lombaerts, M., 1994. Population structure and levels of gene flow in the Mediterranean land snail Albinaria corrugata (Pulmonata: Clausiliidae). Evolution 48, 577-586.
86. Shaffer, H.B., Thomson, R.C., 2007. Delimiting species in recent radiations. Syst. Biol. 56, 896-906.
87. Sites, J.W. Jr, Marshall, J.C., 2004. Operational criteria for delimiting species. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 35, 199-227.
88. Sokolov, E.P., 2000. An improved method for DNA isolation from mucopolysaccharide-rich molluscan tissues. J. Mollus. Stud. 66, 573-575.
89. Swofford, D.L., 2002. PAUP*: Phylogenetic analysis using parsimony *and other methods, version 4.0b10. Sunderland, MA, Sinauer Associates.
90. Tamura, K., Dudley, J., Nei, M., Kumar, S., 2007. MEGA4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 4.0. Mol. Biol. Evol. 24, 1596-1599.
91. Tautz, D., Arctander, P., Minelli, A., Thomas, R.H., Vogler, A.P., 2003. A plea for DNA taxonomy. Trends Ecol. Evol. 18, 70-74.
92. Templeton, A.R., Crandall, K.A., Sing, C.F., 1992. A cladistic analysis of phenotypic associations with haplotypes inferred from restriction endonuclease mapping and DNA sequence data. III. Cladogram estimation. Genetics 132, 619-633.
93. Thacker, R.W., Hadfield, M.G., 2000. Mitochondrial phylogeny of extant Hawaiian tree snails (Achatinellinae). Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 16, 263-270.
94. Thomaz, D., Guiller, A., Clarke, B., 1996. Extreme divergence of mitochondrial DNA within species of pulmonate land snails. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 263, 363-368.
95. Thompson, J.D., Higgins, D.G., Gibson, T.J., 1994. CLUSTAL W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence weighting, position-specific gap penalties and weight matrix choice. Nucleic Acids Res. 22, 4673-4680.
96. Ursenbacher, S., Alvarez, C., Armbruster, G., Baur, B., 2010. High population differentiation in the rock-dwelling land snail (Trochulus caelatus) endemic to the Swiss Jura Mountains. Conserv. Genet. 11, 1265-1271.
97. Wakeley, J., 2000. The effects of subdivision on the genetic divergence of populations and species. Evolution 54, 1092-1101.
98. Watanabe, Y., Chiba, S., 2001. High within-population mitochondrial DNA variation due to microvicariance and population mixing in the land snail Euhadra quaesita (Pulmonata: Bradybaenidae). Mol. Ecol. 10, 2635-2645.
99. Weisrock, D.W., Shaffer, H.B., Storz, B.L., Storz, S.R., Voss, S.R., 2006. Multiple nuclear gene sequences identify phylogenetic species boundaries in the rapidly radiating clade of Mexican ambystomatid salamanders. Mol. Ecol. 15, 2489-2503.
100. Wiemers, M., Fiedler, K., 2007. Does the DNA barcoding gap exist? A case study in blue butterflies (Lepidoptera: Lycaenidae). Front. Zool. 4, 8.
101. Wiens, J.J., 2007. Species delimitation: new approaches for discovering diversity. Syst. Biol. 56, 875-878.
102. Wiens, J.J., Penkrot, T.A., 2002. Delimiting species using DNA and morphological variation and discordant species limits in spiny lizards (Sceloporus). Syst. Biol. 51, 69-91.
103. Will, K.W., Rubinoff, D., 2004. Myth of the molecule: DNA barcodes for species cannot replace morphology for identification and classification. Cladistics 20, 47-55.
104. Will, K.W., Mishler, B.D., Wheeler, Q.D., 2005. The perils of DNA barcoding and the need for integrative taxonomy. Syst. Biol. 54, 844-851.
105. Wu, C.-I., 2001. The genic view of the process of speciation. J. Evol. Biol. 14, 851-865.
106. Wu, C.-I., Ting, C.-T., 2004. Genes and speciation. Nat. Rev. Genet. 5, 114-122.
107. Yang, Z., Rannala, B., 2010. Bayesian species delimitation using multilocus sequence data. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 107, 9264-9269.