Association between nonverbal communication during clinical interactions and outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Patient Education and Counseling

Volumn 86, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 297-315

  Henry, Stephen G ^a,b   Fuhrel Forbis, Andrea ^b,c   Rogers, Mary A M ^b   Eggly, Susan ^d  

^a DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN   (United States)

^d WAYNE STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Clinically relevant outcomes; Direct observation; Meta analysis; Nonverbal communication; Patient clinician communication; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL PRACTICE; COMMUNICATION SKILL; DATA BASE; DATA EXTRACTION; DOCTOR PATIENT RELATION; HEALTH CARE PRACTICE; HEALTH STATUS; HUMAN; MENTAL HEALTH; METHODOLOGY; NONVERBAL COMMUNICATION; NURSE PATIENT RELATIONSHIP; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PATIENT ATTITUDE; PATIENT SATISFACTION; PHYSICIAN ATTITUDE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SOCIAL INTERACTION; STUDY DESIGN;

HEALTH SERVICES NEEDS AND DEMAND; HUMANS; NONVERBAL COMMUNICATION; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT (HEALTH CARE); PATIENT SATISFACTION; PHYSICIAN-PATIENT RELATIONS;

EID: 84858058907     PISSN: 07383991     EISSN: 18735134     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.pec.2011.07.006     Document Type: Review

References (95)

1. Haskard-Zolnierek K., DiMatteo M.R. Physician communication and patient adherence to treatment: a meta-analysis. Med Care 2009, 47:826-834.
2. Mead N., Bower P. Patient-centred consultations and outcomes in primary care: a review of the literature. Patient Educ Couns 2002, 48:51-61.
3. Williams S., Weinman J., Dale J. Doctor-patient communication and patient satisfaction: a review. Fam Pract 1998, 15:480-492.
4. Knapp M.L., Hall J.A. Nonverbal communication in human interaction 2009, Wadsworth, Cengage Learning, Boston, MA. 7th ed.
5. The SAGE handbook of nonverbal communication 2006, SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks. V. Manusov, M.L. Patterson (Eds.).
6. Frankel R.M., Stein T., Krupat E. The Four Habits approach to effective clinical communication. Physician education and development 2003, Kaiser Permanente, Oakland, CA.
7. Roter D.L., Hall J.A. Doctors talking with patients/patients talking with doctors: improving communication in medical visits 2006, Praeger, Westport, CT. 2nd ed.
8. Levinson W., Lesser C.S., Epstein R.M. Developing physician communication skills for patient-centered care. Health Affair 2010, 29:1310-1318.
9. Jones S.E., LeBaron C.D. Research on the relationship between verbal and nonverbal communication: emerging integrations. J Commun 2002, 52:499-521.
10. Albrecht T.L., Penner L.A., Cline R.J.W., Eggly S.S., Ruckdeschel J.C. Studying the process of clinical communication: issues of context, concepts, and research directions. J Health Commun 2009, 14:47-56.
11. Hall J.A., Harrigan J.A., Rosenthal R. Nonverbal behavior in clinician-patient interaction. Appl Prev Psychol 1995, 4:21-37.
12. Street R.L., Gordon H., Haidet P. Physicians' communication and perceptions of patients: is it how they look, how they talk, or is it just the doctor?. Soc Sci Med 2007, 65:586-598.
13. Penner L.A., Dovidio J.F., West T.V., Gaertner S.L., Albrecht T.L., Dailey R.K., et al. Aversive racism and medical interactions with black patients: a field study. J Exp Soc Psychol 2010, 46:436-440.
14. Heath C. Body movement and speech in medical interaction 1986, Cambridge University Press & Editions de la Maison des Sciences de l'Homme, Cambridge, UK & Paris. P. Ekman, K.R. Scherer (Eds.).
15. Mast M.S. On the importance of nonverbal communication in the physician-patient interaction. Patient Educ Couns 2007, 67:315-318.
16. Cappella J.N., Schreiber D.M. The interaction management function of nonverbal cues. The SAGE handbook of nonverbal communication 2006, 361-379. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks. V. Manusov, M.L. Patterson (Eds.).
17. Robinson J.D. Nonverbal communication and physician-patient interaction: review and new directions. The sage handbook of nonverbal communication 2006, 437-460. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA. V. Manusov, M.L. Patterson (Eds.).
18. Roter D.L., Frankel R.M., Hall J.A., Sluyter D. The expression of emotion through nonverbal behavior in medical visits: mechanisms and outcomes. J Gen Intern Med 2006, 21:S28-S34.
19. Hall J.A., Roter D.L., Blanch D.C., Frankel R.M. Observer-rated rapport in interactions between medical students and standardized patients. Patient Educ Couns 2009, 76:323-327.
20. Hall J.A., Roter D.L., Blanch D.C., Frankel R.M. Nonverbal sensitivity in medical students: implications for clinical interactions. J Gen Intern Med 2009, 24:1217-1222.
21. Henry S.G. A Piece of my mind. Playing doctor. J Am Med Assoc 2005, 294:2138-2140.
22. Wear D., Varley J.D. Rituals of verification: the role of simulation in developing and evaluating empathic communication. Patient Educ Couns 2008, 71:153-156.
23. Malhotra A., Gregory I., Darvill E., Goble E., Pryce-Roberts A., Lundberg K., et al. Mind the gap: learners' perspectives on what they learn in communication compared to how they and others behave in the real world. Patient Educ Couns 2009, 76:385-390.
24. Ram P., van der Vleuten C., Rethans J.J., Grol R. Assessment of practicing family physicians: comparison of observation in a multiple station examination using standardized patients with observation of consultations in daily practice. Acad Med 1999, 74:62-69.
25. Griffith C.H., Wilson J.F., Langer S., Haist S.A. House staff nonverbal communication skills and standardized patient satisfaction. J Gen Intern Med 2003, 18:170-174.
26. Haskard K.B., Williams S.L., DiMatteo M.R., Heritage J., Rosenthal R. The provider's voice: patient satisfaction and the content-filtered speech of nurses and physicians in primary medical care. J Nonverbal Behav 2008, 32:1-20.
27. Baumann C., Rat A.C., Osnowycz G., Mainard D., Cuny C., Guillemin F. Satisfaction with care after total hip or knee replacement predicts self-perceived health status after surgery. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2009, 10:150.
28. Weisman C.S., Nathanson C.A. Professional satisfaction and client outcomes: a comparative organizational analysis. Med Care 1985, 23:1179-1192.
29. Street R.L., Makoul G., Arora N., Epstein R.M. How does communication heal? Pathways linking clinician-patient communication to health outcomes. Patient Educ Couns 2009, 74:295-301.
30. Performance Measurement. The Joint Commission; Available from: [accessed 20.8.2010].
31. HCAHPS. Patients' perspectives of care survey. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services; Available from: [accessed 20.8.2010]. http://www.cms.gov/HospitalQualityInits/30_HospitalHCAHPS.asp.
32. Cooper L.A., Roter D.L. Patient-provider communication: the effect of race and ethnicity on process and outcomes of healthcare. Institute of Medicine (U.S.). Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care. Unequal treatment: confronting racial and ethnic disparities in health care 2003, 552-593. National Academy Press, Washington, DC. B.D. Smedley, A.Y. Stith, A.R. Nelson (Eds.).
33. Roter D.L., Hall J.A., Aoki Y. Physician gender effects in medical communication: a meta-analytic review. J Am Med Assoc 2002, 288:756-764.
34. Adelman R.D., Greene M.G., Ory M.G. Communication between older patients and their physicians. Clin Geriatr Med 2000, 16:1-24. vii.
35. Dovidio J.F., Hebl M., Richeson J.A., Shelton J.N. Nonverbal communication, race, and intergroup interaction. The SAGE handbook of nonverbal communication 2006, 481-500. SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks. V. Manusov, M.L. Patterson (Eds.).
36. Higgins J., Altman D.G. Assessing risk of bias in included studies. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 501: The Cochrane Collaboration 2008, p. Available from www.cochrane-handbook.org [accessed 29.7.2010]. J. Higgins, S. Green (Eds.).
37. Liberati A., Altman D.G., Tetzlaff J., Mulrow C., Gotzsche P.C., Ioannidis J.P.A., et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. Ann Intern Med 2009, 151:W65-W94.
38. Grimes D.A., Schulz K.F. Bias causal associations in observational research. Lancet 2002, 359:248-252.
39. Burgoon J.K. The relationship of verbal and nonverbal codes. Progress in communication sciences 1985, 263-298. Ablex Publishing, Norwood, NJ. B. Dervin, M.J. Voigt (Eds.).
40. LeBaron C.J. Considering the social and material surround: toward microethnographic understandings of nonverbal communication. The sourcebook of nonverbal measures 2005, 493-506. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. V. Manusov (Ed.).
41. Noller P. Standard content methodology: controlling the verbal channel. The sourcebook of nonverbal measures 2005, 417-430. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. V. Manusov (Ed.).
42. DerSimonian R., Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials 1986, 7:177-188.
43. Gilbert D.A., Hayes E. Communication and outcomes of visits between older patients and nurse practitioners. Nurs Res 2009, 58:283-293.
44. Ambady N., Koo J., Rosenthal R., Winograd C.H. Physical therapists' nonverbal communication predicts geriatric patients' health outcomes. Psychol Aging 2002, 17:443-452.
45. Hall J.A., Roter D.L., Rand C.S. Communication of affect between patient and physician. J Health Soc Behav 1981, 22:18-30.
46. Prkachin K.M., Schultz I.Z., Hughes E. Pain behavior and the development of pain-related disability: the importance of guarding. Clin J Pain 2007, 23:270-277.
47. van Dulmen A.M., Verhaak P.F.M., Bilo H.J.G. Shifts in doctor-patient communication during a series of outpatient consultations in non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Patient Educ Couns 1997, 30:227-237.
48. Merten J. Facial microbehavior and the emotional quality of the therapeutic relationship. Psychother Res 2005, 15:325-333.
49. Comstock L.M., Hooper E.M., Goodwin J.M., Goodwin J.S. Physician behaviors that correlate with patient satisfaction. J Med Educ 1982, 57:105-112.
50. Haskard K., DiMatteo M.R., Heritage J. Affective and instrumental communication in primary care interactions: predicting the satisfaction of nursing staff and patients. Health Commun. 2009, 24:21-32.
51. Street R.L., Buller D.B. Nonverbal response patterns in physician-patient interactions: a functional analysis. J Nonverbal Behav 1987, 11:234-253.
52. Bensing J. Doctor-patient communication and the quality of care. Soc Sci Med 1991, 32:1301-1310.
53. Hall J.A., Irish J.T., Roter D.L., Ehrlich C.M., Miller L.H. Satisfaction, gender, and communication in medical visits. Med Care 1994, 32:1216-1231.
54. Dalton J.A., Brown L., Carlson J., McNutt R., Greer S.M. An evaluation of facial expression displayed by patients with chest pain. Heart Lung 1999, 28:168-174.
55. Hall J.A., Roter D.L., Milburn M.A., Daltroy L.H. Patients' health as a predictor of physician and patient behavior in medical visits: a synthesis of four studies. Med Care 1996, 34:1205-1218.
56. Troisi A., Pompili E., Binello L., Sterpone A. Facial expressivity during the clinical interview as a predictor of functional disability in schizophrenia: a pilot study. Progr Neuro-Psychopharmacol Biol Psychiat 2007, 31:475-481.
57. Ambady N., LaPlante D., Nguyen T., Rosenthal R., Chaumeton N., Levinson W. Surgeons' tone of voice: a clue to malpractice history. Surgery 2002, 132:5-9.
58. Bos E.H., Bouhuys A.L., Geerts E., van Os T.W., Ormel J. Stressful life events as a link between problems in nonverbal communication and recurrence of depression. J Affect Disorders 2007, 97:161-169.
59. Geerts E., Bouhuys N., Van den Hoofdakker R.H. Nonverbal attunement between depressed patients and an interviewer predicts subsequent improvement. J Affect Disorders 1996, 40:15-21.
60. Bouhuys A.L., Sam M.M. Lack of coordination of nonverbal behaviour between patients and interviewers as a potential risk factor to depression recurrence: vulnerability accumulation in depression. J Affect Disorders 2000, 57:189-200.
61. Weinberger M., Greene J.Y., Mamlin J.J. The impact of clinical encounter events on patient and physician satisfaction. Soc Sci Med Part E: Med Psychol 1981, 15:239-244.
62. Smith C.K., Polis E., Hadac R.R. Characteristics of the initial medical interview associated with patient satisfaction and understanding. J Fam Pract 1981, 12:283-288.
63. Kurtz S. Physician nonverbal behavior and patient satisfaction in physician-patient interviews 1975, University of Denver, PhD diss. Denver, CO.
64. Koss T., Rosenthal R. Interactional synchrony, positivity, and patient satisfaction in the physician-patient relationship. Med Care 1997, 35:1158-1163.
65. Giles H., Ogay T. Communication accommodation theory. Explaining communication: Contemporary theories and exemplars 2007, 325-344. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. B.B. Whaley, W. Santer (Eds.).
66. Ekman P., Friesen W.V. Unmasking the face: a guide to recognizing emotions from facial clues 2003, Malor Books, Cambridge, MA.
67. Rasting M., Beutel M.E. Dyadic affective interactive patterns in the intake interview as a predictor of outcome. Psychother Res 2005, 15:188-198.
68. Dickersin K. Publication bias: recognising the problem, understanding its origin and scope, and preventing harm. Publication bias in meta-analysis: prevention, assessment, and adjustments 2005, 11-34. John Wiley & Sons, West Sussex, UK. H.R. Rothstein, A.J. Sutton, M. Borenstein (Eds.).
69. Hall J.A., Coats E.J., LeBeau L.S. Nonverbal behavior and the vertical dimension of social relations: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull 2005, 131:898-924.
70. Kenny D.A., Kashy D.A., Cook W.L. Dyadic data analysis 2006, Guilford Press, New York.
71. Lipsitz S.R., Fitzmaurice G.M., Orav E.J., Laird N.M. Performance of generalized estimating equations in practical situations. Biometrics 1994, 50:270-278.
72. Raudenbush S.W., Bryk A.S. Hierarchical linear models: applications and data analysis methods 2002, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks. 2nd ed.
73. Larsen K.M., Smith C.K. Assessment of nonverbal communication in the patient-physician Interview. J Fam Pract 1981, 12:481-488.
74. Greene M.G., Adelman R.D., Friedmann E., Charon R. Older patient satisfaction with communication during an initial medical encounter. Soc Sci Med 1994, 38:1279-1288.
75. von Baeyer C.L. Social and pain behavior in the first 3min of a pain clinic medical interview. Pain Clin 1994, 7:169-177.
76. Buller M.K., Buller D.B. Physicians' communication style and patient satisfaction. J Health Soc Behav 1987, 28:375-388.
77. Ware J.E., Kosinski M., Keller S.D. How to score version 2 of the SF-12 health survey 2000, Quality Metric Inc., Lincoln, RI.
78. Bernieri F.J., Reznick J.S., Rosenthal R. Synchrony, pseudosynchrony, and dissynchrony: measuring the entrainment process in mother infant interactions. J Pers Soc Psychol 1988, 54:243-253.
79. Yesavage J.A., Brink T.L., Rose T.L., Lum O., Huang V., Adey M., et al. Development and validation of a geriatric depression screening scale: a preliminary report. J Psychiat Res 1983, 17:37-49.
80. Stewart A., Kamberg C. Physical functioning. Measuring functional status and physical well-being: the medical outcomes study approach 1989, 86-101. Duke University Press, Durham, NC. A. Stewart, J.E. Ware (Eds.).
81. Hays R.D., Sherbourne C.D., Mazel R.M. The RAND 36-item health survey 1.0. Health Econ 1993, 2:217.
82. Ware J. SF-36 health survey update. Use of psychological testing for treatment planning and outcomes assessment: instruments for adults 2004, 693-718. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. 3rd ed. M. Maruish (Ed.).
83. Wolf M.H., Putnam S.M., James S.A., Stiles W.B. The medical interview satisfaction scale: development of a scale to measure patient perceptions of physician behavior. J Behav Med 1978, 1:391-401.
84. Ekman P., Friesen W.V., Hager J.C. Facial action coding system: the manual [CD ROM] 2002, A Human Face, Salt Lake City, Utah.
85. Friesen, WV, Ekman, P., Emotion Facial Action Coding System, 1984. Available at . Accessed 22 July 2011. http://www.face-and-emotion.com/dataface/facs/emfacs.jsp.
86. Fahrenberg J. Die freiburger beschwerdenliste FBL [freiburger symptom list]. Zeitschrift für Klinische Psychologie 1995, 4:79-100.
87. Franke G. SCL-90-R die symptom checklist von derogatis: deutsche version 1995, Beltz-Verlag, Weinheim.
88. Troisi A. Ethological research in clinical psychiatry: the study of nonverbal behavior during interviews. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 1999, 23:905-913.
89. Hilsenroth M.J., Ackerman S.J., Blagys M.D., Baumann B.D., Baity M.R., Smith S.R., et al. Reliability and validity of DSM-IV axis V. Am J Psychiat 2000, 157:1858-1863.
90. Marshall GN, Hays RD. The patient satisfaction questionnaire short-form (PSQ-18): RAND Corporation, 1994 Contract No.: P-7865.
91. Bertakis K.D., Roter D., Putnam S.M. The relationship of physician medical interview style to patient satisfaction. J Fam Pract 1991, 32:175-181.
92. Dimatteo M.R., Sherbourne C.D., Hays R.D., Ordway L., Kravitz R.L., Mcglynn E.A., et al. Physicians' characteristics influence patients' adherence to medical treatment: results from the Medical Outcomes Study. Health Psychol 1993, 12:93-102.
93. Suchman A.L., Roter D., Green M., Lipkin M., Bertakis K., Charon R., et al. Physician satisfaction with primary-care office visits. Med Care 1993, 31:1083-1092.
94. Mehrabian A. Nonverbal communication 1972, Aldine-Atherton, Chicago.
95. Rosenthal R., DiMatteo M.R. Meta-analysis. Recent developments in quantitative methods for literature reviews. Ann Rev Psychol 2001, 52:59-82.