A comparison of nonlinear observers for output feedback model-based control of seeded batch crystallization processes

Journal of Process Control

Volumn 21, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 652-666

  Mesbah, Ali ^a,b   Huesman, Adrie E M ^a   Kramer, Herman J M ^b   Van Den Hof, Paul M J ^a  

^a DELFT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Netherlands)

^b DELFT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Batch crystallization; Kalman filters; Moving horizon estimator; Nonlinear model based control; Population balance equation; State estimation

Indexed keywords

BATCH CRYSTALLIZATION; BATCH CRYSTALLIZATION PROCESS; BATCH PROCESS; CLOSED-LOOP BEHAVIOR; CLOSED-LOOP CONTROL; COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS; COMPUTATIONAL BURDEN; CONTROL OBJECTIVES; DISTURBANCE MODELS; FED BATCHES; LUENBERGER OBSERVERS; MOVING HORIZON ESTIMATOR; NON-LINEAR ESTIMATION; NON-LINEAR MODEL; NON-LINEAR OBSERVER; OUTPUT FEEDBACK; POPULATION BALANCE EQUATION; PROCESS UNCERTAINTIES; SEEDED BATCH CRYSTALLIZATION; SIMULATION RESULT; STATE ESTIMATES; STATE VARIABLES; TIME-VARYING PROCESS; TUNING METHOD; UNCERTAIN INITIAL CONDITION; UNSCENTED KALMAN FILTER;

BATCH DATA PROCESSING; BEARINGS (MACHINE PARTS); CLOSED LOOP CONTROL SYSTEMS; COVARIANCE MATRIX; CRYSTALLIZATION; EQUATIONS OF STATE; ESTIMATION; EXTENDED KALMAN FILTERS; MEASUREMENT ERRORS; NONLINEAR ANALYSIS; NONLINEAR EQUATIONS; NONLINEAR FEEDBACK; NONLINEAR FILTERING; NONLINEAR SYSTEMS; POSITION CONTROL; STATE ESTIMATION; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

PROCESS CONTROL;

EID: 79953829945     PISSN: 09591524     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jprocont.2010.11.013     Document Type: Article

References (76)

1. S. Arulampalam, S. Maskell, N. Gordon, and T. Clapp A tutorial on particle filters for online nonlinear/non-Gaussian Bayesian tracking IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing 50 2002 174 188 (Pubitemid 34291500)
2. T. Bakir, S. Othman, G. Fevotte, and H. Hammouri Nonlinear observer of crystal-size distribution during batch crystallization AIChE Journal 52 2006 2188 2197 (Pubitemid 43837618)
3. G. Bastin, and D. Dochain On-line Estimation and Adaptive Control of Bioreactors 1990 Elsevier Amsterdam
4. S. Biagiola, and J. Figueroa Application of state estimation based NMPC to an unstable nonlinear process Chemical Engineering Science 59 2004 4601 4612 (Pubitemid 39300785)
5. S. Biagiola, and J. Solsona State estimation in batch processes using a nonlinear observer Mathematical and Computer Modelling 44 2006 1009 1024 (Pubitemid 44189785)
6. P. Bogaerts A hybrid asymptotic-Kalman observer for bioprocesses Bioprocess Engineering 20 1999 101 113
7. R. Braatz Advanced control of crystallization processes Annual Reviews in Control 26 2002 87 99 (Pubitemid 35170482)
8. P. Brown, A. Hindmarsh, and L. Petzold Using krylov methods in the solution of large-scale differential algebraic systems SIAM Journal Scientific Computing 15 1994 1467 1488
9. G. Burgers, P. Leeuwen, and G. Evensen Analysis scheme in the ensemble Kalman filter Monthly Weather Review 126 1998 1719 1724 (Pubitemid 128597660)
10. T. Chen, J. Morris, and E. Martin Particle filters for state and parameter estimation in batch processes Journal of Process Control 15 2005 665 673 (Pubitemid 40574537)
11. G. Ciccarella, M.D. Mora, and A. Germani A luenberger-like observer for nonlinear systems International Journal of Control 57 1993 537 556
12. P. Daudey, G. van Rosmalen, and E.D. Jong Secondary nucleation kinetics of ammonium sulphate in a cmsmpr crystallizer Journal of Crystal Growth 99 1990 1076 1081 (Pubitemid 20687490)
13. F. Daum Nonlinear filters: beyond the Kalman filter IEEE A&E Systems Magazine 20 2005 57 69
14. F. Deza, D. Bossanne, E. Busvelle, J. Gauthier, and D. Rakotopara Exponential observers for nonlinear systems IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 38 1993 482 484
15. D. Dochain State and parameter estimation in chemical and biochemical processes: a tutorial Journal of Process Control 13 2003 801 818
16. G. Evensen Advanced data assimilation for strongly nonlinear dynamics Monthly Weather Review 125 1997 1342 1354
17. R. Franke, E. Arnold, H. Linke, HQP: a solver for nonlinearly constrained optimization, 2005. http://hqp.sourceforge.net.
18. E. Gatzke, and F. Doyle Use of multiple models and qualitative knowledge for on-line moving horizon disturbance estimation and fault diagnosis Journal of Process Control 12 2002 339 352 (Pubitemid 33110479)
19. J. Gauthier, and A. Kupka Observability and observers for nonlinear systems SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization 32 1992 975 994
20. S. Gillijns, O.B. Mendoza, J. Chandrasekar, B.D. Moor, D. Bernstein, and A. Ridley What is the ensemble Kalman filter and how well does it work? Proceedings of the American Control Conference Minnesota, USA 2006 4448 4453 (Pubitemid 46531519)
21. N. Gordon, D. Salmond, and A. Smith Novel approach to nonlinear/non-Gaussian Bayesian state estimation IEE Proceedings F-Radar and Signal Processing 140 1993 107 113
22. Y. Hao, Z. Xiong, F. Sun, and X. Wang Comparison of unscented Kalman filters Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Mechatronics and Automation Harbin, China 2007 895 899 (Pubitemid 350244750)
23. E. Haseltine, and J. Rawlings Critical evaluation of extended Kalman filtering and moving-horizon estimation Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research 44 2005 2451 2460 (Pubitemid 40622242)
24. M. Hermanto, M. Chiu, and R. Braatz Nonlinear model predictive control for the polymorphic transformation of l-glutamic acid crystals AIChE Journal 55 2009 2631 2645
25. P. Houtekamer, and H. Mitchell Ensemble Kalman filtering The Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society 131 2005 3269 3290
26. X. Hulhoven, A.V. Wouwer, and P. Bogaerts Hybrid extended Luenberger-asymptotic observer for bioprocess state estimation Chemical Engineering Science 61 2006 7151 7160 (Pubitemid 44415743)
27. J. Jansen, O. Bosgra, and P.V. den Hof Model-based control of multiphase flow in subsurface oil reservoirs Journal of Process Control 18 2008 846 855
28. S. Julier, and J. Uhlmann A new extension of the Kalman filter to nonlinear systems Proceedings of the 11th International Symposium on Aerospace/Defense Sensing, Simulation and Controls Orlando, USA 1997 182 193
29. S. Julier, and J. Uhlmann Unscented filtering and nonlinear estimation Proceedings of the IEEE 92 2004 401 422 (Pubitemid 40890750)
30. S. Kadam, E. van der Windt, P. Daudy, and H. Kramer A comparative study of ATR-FTIR and FT-NIR spectroscopy for the in-situ concentration monitoring during batch cooling crystallization processes Crystal Growth & Design 10 2010 2629 2640
31. A. Kalbasenka, Model-based control of industrial batch crystallizers: experiments on enhanced controllability by seeding actuation. Ph.D. Thesis, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands, 2009.
32. A. Kalbasenka, L. Spierings, A. Huesman, and H. Kramer Application of seeding as a process actuator in a model predictive control framework for fed-batch crystallization of ammonium sulphate Particle and Particle Systems Characterization 24 2007 40 48 (Pubitemid 46959582)
33. R. Kalman, and R. Bucy New results in linear filtering and prediction Journal of Basic Engineering (ASME) 83 1961 98 108
34. R. Kandepu, B. Foss, and L. Imsland Applying the unscented Kalman filter for nonlinear state estimation Journal of Process Control 18 2008 753 768
35. A. Krener, and A. Isidori Linearization by output injection and nonlinear observers Systems and Control Letters 3 1983 47 52
36. J. Landlust, A. Mesbah, J. Wildenberg, A. Kalbasenka, H. Kramer, and J. Ludlage An industrial model predictive control architecture for batch crystallization Proceedings of the 17th International Symposium on Industrial Crystallization Maastricht, The Netherlands 2008 35 42
37. J. Lee, and L. Ricker Extended Kalman filter based nonlinear model predictive control Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research 33 1994 1530 1541
38. K. Lee, J. Lee, D. Yang, and A. Mahoney Integrated run-to-run and on-line model based control of particle size distribution for a semi-batch precipitation reactor Computers and Chemical Engineering 26 2002 1117 1131 (Pubitemid 36076785)
39. V. Lemesle, and J. Gouze A bounded error observer for a class of bioreactor models Proceedings of the 8th IFAC Conference on Computer Applications in Biotechnology (CAB8) Quebec, Canada 2001 24 27
40. M. Leskens, L. van Kessel, P.V. den Hof, and O. Bosgra Nonlinear model predictive control with moving horizon state and disturbance estimation with application to MSW combustion Proceedings of the 16th IFAC World Congress Prague, Czech Republic 2005
41. M. Mangold, A. Buck, R. Schenkendorf, C. Steyer, A. Voigt, and K. Sundmacher Two state estimators for the barium sulfate precipitation in a semi-batch reactor Chemical Engineering Science 64 2009 646 660
42. A. Mesbah, A. Huesman, H. Kramer, Z. Nagy, P.V. den Hof, Real-time control of a semi-industrial fed-batch evaporative crystallizer using different direct optimization strategies. AIChE Journal, doi:10.1002/aic.12366.
43. A. Mesbah, A. Kalbasenka, A. Huesman, H. Kramer, and P.V. den Hof Real-time dynamic optimization of batch crystallization processes Proceedings of the 17th IFAC World Congress Seoul, Korea 2008 3246 3251
44. A. Mesbah, J. Landlust, A. Huesman, H. Kramer, P. Jansens, and P.V. den Hof A model-based control framework for industrial batch crystallization processes Chemical Engineering Research and Design 88 2010 1223 1233
45. S. Motz, S. Mannal, and E. Gilles State estimation in batch crystallization using reduced population models Journal of Process Control 18 2008 361 374
46. Z. Nagy Model based robust control approach for batch crystallization product design Computers and Chemical Engineering 33 2009 1685 1691
47. Z. Nagy, F. Allgower, R. Franke, A. Frick, and B. Mahn Efficient tool for nonlinear model predictive control of batch processes Proceedings of the 12th Mediterranean Conference on Control and Automation Kusadasi, Turkey 2004
48. Z. Nagy, and R. Braatz Robust nonlinear model predictive control of batch processes AIChE Journal 49 2003 1776 1786 (Pubitemid 36871177)
49. Z. Nagy, B. Mahn, R. Franke, and F. Allgower Evaluation study of an efficient output feedback nonlinear model predictive control for temperature tracking in an industrial batch reactor Control Engineering Practice 15 2007 839 850 (Pubitemid 46567748)
50. A. Neumann, and H. Kramer A comparative study of various size distribution measurement systems Particle & Particle Systems Characterization 19 2002 17 27 (Pubitemid 34520020)
51. H. Nijmeijer, and A. van der Schaft Nonlinear Dynamical Control Systems 1990 Springer New York
52. R. Oliveira, E. Ferreira, and S.F. de Azevedo Stability dynamics of convergence and tuning of observer-based kinetic estimators Journal of Process Control 12 2002 311 323 (Pubitemid 33110478)
53. M. Perrier, S.F. de Azevedo, E. Ferreira, and D. Dochain Tuning of observer-based estimators: theory and application to the on-line estimation of kinetic parameters Control Engineering Practice 8 2000 377 388 (Pubitemid 30255085)
54. J. Prakash, S. Patwardhan, and S. Shah Constrained state estimation using the ensemble Kalman filter Proceedings of the American Control Conference Seattle, USA 2008 3542 3547
55. C. Qu, and J. Hahn Process monitoring and parameter estimation via unscented Kalman filtering Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 22 2009 703 709
56. A. Randolph, and M. Larson Theory of Particulate Processes 2nd ed. 1988 Academic Press San Diego
57. C. Rao, and J. Rawlings Constrained process monitoring: moving-horizon approach AIChE Journal 48 2002 97 109 (Pubitemid 36858929)
58. C. Rao, J. Rawlings, and D. Mayne Constrained state estimation for nonlinear discrete-time systems: Stability and moving horizon approximations IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 48 2003 246 258
59. J. Rawlings, and B. Bakshi Particle filtering and moving horizon estimation Computers and Chemical Engineering 30 2006 1529 1541 (Pubitemid 44292278)
60. D. Robertson, J. Lee, and J. Rawlings A moving horizon-based approach for least-squares state estimation AIChE Journal 42 1996 2209 2224
61. R. Roman, Z. Nagy, M. Cristea, and S. Agachi Dynamic modelling and nonlinear model predictive control of a fluid catalytic cracking unit Computers and Chemical Engineering 33 2009 605 617
62. A. Romanenko, and J. Castro The unscented filter as an alternative to the EKF for nonlinear state estimation: a simulation case study Computers and Chemical Engineering 28 2004 347 355 (Pubitemid 38156260)
63. A. Romanenko, L. Santos, and P. Afonso Unscented Kalman filtering of a simulated pH system Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research 43 2004 7531 7538 (Pubitemid 39482827)
64. D. Rozier, F. Birol, E. Cosme, P. Brasseur, J. Brankart, and J. Verron A reduced order Kalman filter for data assimilation in physical oceanography SIAM Review 49 2007 449 465 (Pubitemid 47377694)
65. T. Schei On-line estimation for process control and optimization applications Journal of Process Control 18 2008 821 828
66. D. Shi, P. Mhaskar, N. El-Farra, and P. Christofides Predictive control of crystal size distribution in protein crystallization Nanotechnology 16 2005 S562 S574
67. L. Simon, Z. Nagy, and K. Hungerbuhler Model based control of a liquid swelling constrained batch reactor subject to recipe uncertainties Chemical Engineering Journal 153 2009 151 158
68. M. Soroush State and parameter estimations and their applications in process control Computers and Chemical Engineering 23 1998 229 245 (Pubitemid 29130685)
69. M. Srinivasarao, S. Patwardhan, and R. Gudi From data to nonlinear predictive control. 2. Improving regulatory performanace using identified observers Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research 45 2006 3593 3603 (Pubitemid 43812794)
70. M. Tenny, and J. Rawlings Efficient moving horizon estimation and nonlinear model predictive control Proceedings of the American Control Conference 2002 4475 4480
71. J. Valappil, and C. Georgakis Systematic estimation of state noise statistics for extended Kalman filters AIChE Journal 46 2000 292 308 (Pubitemid 30110936)
72. R. van der Merwe, and E. Wan The square-root unscented Kalman filter for state and parameter estimation Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing Salt Lake City, USA 2001 3461 3464 (Pubitemid 32838365)
73. D. Wilson, M. Agarwal, and D. Rippin Experiences implementing the extended Kalman filter on an industrial batch reactor Computers and Chemical Engineering 22 1998 1653 1672 (Pubitemid 29041099)
74. W. Xie, S. Rohani, and A. Phoenix Extended Kalman filter based nonlinear geometric control of a seeded batch cooling crystallizer Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering 80 2002 167 172 (Pubitemid 36285599)
75. M. Zeitz Extended Luenberger observer for nonlinear systems Systems and Control Letters 9 1987 149 156 (Pubitemid 17633106)
76. G. Zhang, and S. Rohani On-line optimal control of a seeded batch cooling crystallizer Chemical Engineering Science 58 2003 1887 1896 (Pubitemid 36544043)