Constructing Turkish "exceptionalism" Discourses of liminality and hybridity in post-Cold War Turkish foreign policy

Political Geography

Volumn 30, Issue 2, 2011, Pages 80-89

  Yanik, Lerna K ^a  

^a BILKENT UNIVERSITY   (Turkey)

Author keywords

Discourse; Eurasia; Exceptionalism; Foreign policy; Hybridization; Liminality; Metaphors; Neo Ottomanism; Turkey

Indexed keywords

COLD WAR; ELITE POLITICS; FOREIGN POLICY; HISTORICAL GEOGRAPHY; MULTICULTURALISM; PEACEKEEPING; POLITICAL DISCOURSE; POLITICAL GEOGRAPHY; POLITICAL POWER; STATE BUILDING;

EURASIA; TURKEY;

EID: 79952439738     PISSN: 09626298     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.polgeo.2011.01.003     Document Type: Article

References (108)

1. Akçali E., Perinçek M. Kemalist Eurasianism: an emerging discourse in Turkey. Geopolitics 2009, 14(3):550-569.
2. Aktar A. Turkification policies in the early republican era. Turkish literature and cultural memory " multiculturalism" as a literary theme after 1980 2009, 29-62. Harrasowitz Verlag, Wiesbaden. C. Dufft (Ed.).
3. Angrist M. Party systems and regime formation in the modern Middle East: explaining Turkish exceptionalism. Comparative Politics 2004, 36(2):229-250.
4. Aybet G., Müftüler Baç M. Transformation of in security and identity: after the end of the cold war. International Journal 2000, 55(4):567-582.
5. Aydin M. Securitization of history and geography: understanding of security in Turkey. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 2003, 3(2):163-184.
6. Aykan M.B. Turkey and the OIC: 1984-1992. Turkish Yearbook of International Relations 1993, 23:101-131.
7. Barchard D. Turkey and the West 1985, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London, Boston and Henley.
8. Benli Altunişik M., Tür Ö Turkey: Challenges of continuity and change 2005, Routledge Curzon, Abingdon, Oxon and New York.
9. Benli Altunişik M. Worldviews and Turkish foreign policy in the Middle East. New Perspectives on Turkey 2009, 40:171-194.
10. Bhabha H.K. The location of culture 1994, Routledge, London and New York.
11. Bhabha H.K. Culture's in between. Questions of cultural identity 1996, 53-60. Sage Publications, London, Thousand Oaks, CA, New Delhi. S. Hall, P. Du Gay (Eds.).
12. Bilgin P. 'Only strong states can survive in Turkey's geography': the uses of " geopolitical truths" in Turkey. Political Geography 2007, 26(7):740-756.
13. Bilgin P. Securing Turkey through western-oriented foreign policy. New Perspectives on Turkey 2009, 40:105-125.
14. Bora T. Istanbul of the conqueror: the 'Alternative Global City' dreams of political Islam. Istanbul between global and the local 1999, 47-58. Rowman and Littlefield Publishers Inc., Lanham, Boulder, New York and Oxford. T. Keyder (Ed.).
15. Braude B. Foundation myths of the millet system. Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Empire: The functioning of a plural society 1982, 69-88. Holmes and Meier Publishers, Inc., New York and London. B. Braude, B. Lewis (Eds.).
16. Brummett P. Gender and empire in Late Ottoman Istanbul: caricature, models of empire and the case for Ottoman exceptionalism. Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East 2007, 27(2):283-302.
17. Cem İ Türkiye Avrupa Avrasya 2004, İstanbul Bilgi Üniversitesi Yayinlari, İstanbul.
18. Copeaux E. Otherness in the Turkish historical discourse: general considerations. Clio in the Balkans: The politics of history education 2002, 397-405. Center for Democracy and Reconciliation in Southeast Europe, Thessaloniki. C. Kouliri (Ed.).
19. Constantinides S. Turkey: the emergence of a new foreign policy the neo-Ottoman imperial model. Journal of Political and Military Sociology 1996, 24(Winter):323-334.
20. Çaǧaptay S. Islam, secularism and nationalism in modern Turkey: Who is a Turk? 2006, Routledge, London and New York.
21. Çandar C., Fuller G. Grand geopolitics for a New Turkey. Mediterranean Quarterly 2001, 12(1):22-38.
22. Çetinsaya G. Cumhuriyet Türkiye'sinde 'Osmanlicilik'. Modern Türkiye'de Siyasal Düşünce: Muhafazakarlik 2003, 363-401. İletişim Yayinlari, Istanbul.
23. Çiller T. Başbakan Sayin Tansu Çiller'in Avrupa Medya Birliǧi'nin 5. Avrupa Televizyon ve Film Forumunda Yaptiǧi Açiliş Konuşmasi, 4 Kasim 1993. DYP Genel Başkani ve Başbakan Tansu Çiller'in Konuşmalari (19 Haziran-5 Kasim 1993) 1993, 362-365. Başbakanlik Yayinevi, Ankara.
24. Çinar A. National history as a contested site: the conquest of Istanbul and Islamist negotiations of the nation. Comparative Studies in Society and History 2001, 43(2):364-391.
25. Çolak Y. Ottomanism vs. Kemalism: collective memory and cultural pluralism in 1990s Turkey. Middle Eastern Studies 2006, 42(4):587-602.
26. Daǧi I.D. Democratic transition in Turkey, 1980-1983: the impact of European diplomacy. Middle Eastern Studies 1996, 32(2):124-141.
27. Davutoǧlu A. Küresel Bunalim: 11 Eylül Konuşmalari 2002, Küre Yayinlari, Istanbul.
28. Davutoǧlu A. Stratejik Dernlik: Türkiye'nin Uluslararasi Konumu 2004, Küre Yayinlari, Istanbul.
29. Davutoǧlu A. Turkey's foreign policy vision: an assessment of 2007. Insight Turkey 2008, 10(1):77-96.
30. Demirel S. Başbakan Sayin Süleyman Demirel'in 24.12. 1992 Tarihli Basin Toplantisi 1992, Başbakanlik Yayinevi, Ankara.
31. Demirel S. Cumhurbaşkani Sayin Süleyman Demirel'in Cumhurbaşkanliǧi'nda Birinci Yili. Cumhurbaşkani Süleyman Demirel'in Söylev ve Demeçleri 2002, 158-223. np: np. C. Ergen (Ed.).
32. Demirel S. Diş Politika Enstitüsü Tarafindan Düzenlenen " 21'inci Yüzyil Eşiǧinde Türk Diş Politikasi" Konulu Konferansta Yaptiklari Konuşma, 23 Kasim 1994. Cumhurbaşkani Süleyman Demirel'in Söylev ve Demeçleri 2002, 683-692. np: np. C. Ergen (Ed.).
33. Diez T. Europe's others and the return of geopolitics. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 2004, 17(2):319-335.
34. Diez T. Constructing the self and changing others: reconsidering 'normative power of Europe'. Millennium: Journal of International Studies 2005, 33(3):613-636.
35. Dijkink G. National identity and geopolitical visions: Maps of pride and pain 1996, Routledge, London and New York.
36. Dominian L. Europe at Turkey's door. Geographical Review 1916, 1(3):286-294.
37. Ecevit B. Başbakan Sayin Bülent Ecevit'in Uluslararasi Avrupa Birliǧi Şurasi Açilişinda Yaptiǧi Konuşma, 3 Mayis 2000. Başbakan Bülent Ecevit'in Konuşmalari 2 Nisan-30 Haziran 2000 2000, 147-150. Başbakanlik Basimevi, Ankara.
38. Erdoǧan R.T. Speech by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey to the Istanbul conference on democracy and global security 2005, Available at, Accessed 9.11.10. http://www.istanbulconference.info/Pages/speecherdogan.aspx.
39. Ersanli B. The Ottoman Empire in the historiography of the Kemalist era: a theory of fatal decline. The Ottomans and the Balkans: A discussion of historiography 2002, 115-154. Brill, Leiden, Boston, Koln. F. Adanir, S. Faroqhi (Eds.).
40. Fisher Onar N. Echoes of a universalism lost: rival representations of the Ottomans in Today's Turkey. Middle Eastern Studies 2009, 45(2):229-241.
41. Forbes N., Toynbee A., Mitrany D., Hogarth D.G. The Balkans: A history of Bulgaria, Serbia, Greece, Rumania, Turkey 1915, The Clarendon Press, Oxford.
42. Fuller G. Turkey faces east: New orientations toward the Middle East and the Old Soviet Union 1992, Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, CA.
43. Fuller, G., Lesser, I. O., Henze, P. B., & Brown, J. F., (Eds.). (1993). Turkey's New Geopolitics: From the Balkans to Western China. Boulder: Westview Press.
44. Gül A. Ulusal Basin Kulübü'nde Yaptiklari Konuşma. Japonya. 05.06.2008 2008, Available at, Accessed 15.01.10. http://cankaya.gov.tr/sayfa/konusma_aciklama_mesajlar/index.html.
45. Gül A. Diyarbakir Soru Cevap: Sayin Cumhurbaşkanimizin Diyarbakir Valiliǧi Çikişinda Bir Soruya Yaniti 2010, Available at, Accessed 15.01.10. http://cankaya.gov.tr/sayfa/konusma_aciklama_mesajlar/index.html.
46. Haber10 Davutoǧlu'ndan 'Yeni Osmanli' Tepkisi. 19 March 2010.
47. Hale W. Turkey, the Middle East and the Gulf Crisis. International Affairs 1992, 68(4):679-692.
48. Heper M. The Ottoman legacy and Turkish politics. Journal of International Affairs 2000, 54(1):63-82.
49. Higgot R.A., Nossal K.R. The international politics of liminality: relocating Australia in the Asia Pacific. Australian Journal of Political Science 1997, 32(2):169-185.
50. Hodgson G. The myth of American exceptionalism 2009, Yale University Press, New Haven and London.
51. Jung D. The Sevres syndrome: Turkish foreign policy and its historical legacies 2003, American Diplomacy, Available at, Accessed 6.09.10. http://www.unc.edu/depts/diplomats/archives_roll/2003_07_09/jung_sevres/jung_sevres.
52. Karaosmanoǧlu A.L. The evolution of the national security culture and the military in Turkey. Journal of International Affairs 2000, 54(1):199-216.
53. Kazemipur A. A Canadian exceptionalism? Trust and diversity in Canadian cities. Journal of International Migration and Integration 2006, 7(2):219-240.
54. Keyman F. On the relation between global modernity and nationalism: the crisis of hegemony and the rise of (Islamic identity) in Turkey. New Perspectives on Turkey 1995, 13:93-120.
55. Lakoff G., Johnson M. Metaphors we live by 1980, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
56. Lipset S.M. American exceptionalism: A double edged sword 1996, W. W. Norton, New York.
57. Ludington N.S., Spain J.W. Turkey: the case for patience. Foreign Policy 1983, 50:150-168.
58. Landau J. Pan-Turkism: From irredentism to cooperation 1995, Hurst & Company, London.
59. Mahajan G. Indian exceptionalism or Indian model negotiating cultural diversity?. Multiculturalism in Asia 2005, 288-339. Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York. W. Kymlicka, B. He (Eds.).
60. Malksoo M. Liminality and contested Europeanness: conflicting memory politics and the Baltic space. Identity and foreign policy: Baltic-Russian relations and European integration 2009, 65-83. Ashgate, Farnham. E. Berg, P. Ehin (Eds.).
61. Mango A. Turkey in the Middle East. Journal of Contemporary History 1968, 3(3):225-236.
62. Mardin Ş Turkish Islamic exceptionalism yesterday and today: continuity, rupture and reconstruction in operational codes. Turkish Studies 2005, 6(2):145-166.
63. Merom G. Israel's national security and the myth of exceptionalism. Political Science Quarterly 1999, 114(3):409-434.
64. Michael M.S. Navigating through the Bosphorus: relocating Turkey's European/Western fault line. Global Change, Peace and Security 2008, 20(1):71-85.
65. Milliyet. (2009). Dişişleri Bakani Prof. Dr. Ahmet Davutoǧlu " Şu Anda Çevremizdeki Bölgelerde, Türkiye'nin İradesi, Haberi, Onayi Olmadan Herhangi Bir Gelişme Yaşanmaz" Dedi. 21 May.
66. Murnison A. The strategic depth doctrine of Turkish foreign policy. Middle Eastern Studies 2006, 42(6):945-964.
67. Müftüler Baç M. The never-ending story: Turkey and the European Union. Middle Eastern Studies 1998, 34(4):240-258.
68. Müftüler Baç M. Through the looking glass: Turkey in Europe. Turkish Studies 2000, 1(1):21-35.
69. Müftüler Baç M. The impact of the European Union on Turkish politics. East European Quarterly 2000, 34(2):159-179.
70. Müftüler Baç M. Turkey's accession to the European Union: institutional and security challenges. Perceptions 2004, 9(3):29-44.
71. Neumann I.B. Self and other in international relations. European Journal of International Relations 1996, 2(2):139-174.
72. Neumann I.B. European identity, EU expansion and integration/exclusion nexus. Alternatives 1998, 23(3):397-417.
73. O'Tuathail G., Dalby S. Introduction: rethinking geopolitics. Towards a critical geopolitics. Rethinking Geopolitics 1998, 1-15. Routledge, London. G. O'Tuathail, S. Dalby (Eds.).
74. Öniş Z., Güven A.B. Global crisis, national responses: The political economy of Turkish exceptionalism 2010, Available at, Accessed 10.05.10. http://econpapers.repec.org/paper/kocwpaper/1013.htm.
75. Öncü A. The politics of Istanbul's Ottoman heritage in the era of globalism. Cities of the south: Poverty, citizenship and exclusion in the 21st century 2007, 233-264. Saqi Books, London. H. Wimmen, F. Mermier, B. Drieskens (Eds.).
76. Özal T. Turkey in Europe, Europe in Turkey 1991, K. Rustem & Brother, Nicosia, N. Cyprus.
77. Özal T. Cumhurbaşkani Turgut Özal'in III. İzmir İktisat Kongresinden Konuşmalar 1992, Başbakanlik Basimevi, Ankara.
78. Özal T. Özal: Türkiye'nin Önünde Hacet Kapilari Açilmiştir. Interview by M. Çalik. Türkiye Günlüǧü 1992, 19:5-23.
79. Parker, N. (Ed.). (2008). The Geopolitics of Europe's Identity: Centers, boundaries and margins. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
80. Ricento T. The discursive construction of Americanism. Discourse and Society 2003, 14(5):611-637.
81. Robins K. Interrupting identities: Turkey/Europe. Questions of cultural identity 1996, 61-86. Sage Publications, London, Thousand Oaks, CA, New Delhi. S. Hall, P. Du Gay (Eds.).
82. Rumelili B. Liminality and perpetuation of conflicts: Turkish-Greek relations in the context of community building by the EU. European Journal of International Relations 2003, 9(2):213-248.
83. Rumelili B. Constructing identity and relating to difference: understanding the EU's mode of differentiation. Review of International Studies 2004, 30(1):27-47.
84. Rumelili B. Constructing regional community and order in Europe and Southeast Asia 2007, Palgrave MacMillan, New York, NY.
85. Sander O. Türkiye'nin Diş Politikasinda Sürekliliǧin Nedenleri. Türkiye'nin Diş Politikasi 2006, İmge Kitabevi, Ankara.
86. Sayari S. Turgut Özal. Political leaders of the contemporary Middle East and North Africa 1990, 395-403. Greenwood Press, Westport, CT. B. Reich (Ed.).
87. Studlar D. Canadian exceptionalism: explaining differences over time in provincial and federal voter turnout. Canadian Journal of Political Science 2001, 34(2):299-319.
88. Tank P. Dressing for the occasion: reconstructing Turkey's identity. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 2006, 6(4):463-478.
89. Tassinari F. Variable geometries, institutions, power and ideas in Turkey's European integration process. The Geopolitics of Europe's identity: Centers, boundaries and margins 2008, 207-224. Palgrave Macmillan, New York. N. Parker (Ed.).
90. Tellal E. Rusya İle İlişkiler. Türk Diş Politikasi: Kurtuluş Savaşindan Bugüne Olaylar, Belgeler, Yorumlar 2005, 540-550. İletişim Yayinlari, Istanbul. B. Oran (Ed.).
91. Today's Zaman Erdoǧan: Alliance may become century's peace project 2008, 19 November.
92. Todorova M. Balkanlardaki Osmanli Mirasi. İmparatorluk Mirasi: Balkanlar'da ve Ortadoǧu'da Osmanli Damgasi 2000, 74-110. İletişim Yayinlari, Istanbul. C.L. Brown (Ed.).
93. Tonra B. Global citizen and European Republic: Irish foreign policy in transition 2006, Manchester University Press, Manchester.
94. Turner V.W. Forrest of symbols: Aspects of Ndembu ritual 1967, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY.
95. Turner V.W. The ritual process: Structure and anti-structure 1969, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
96. Turner V.W. Dramas. Fields and metaphors: Symbolic action in human society 1974, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY.
97. Tulander O. A New Ottoman empire? The choice for Turkey: Euro-Asian centre vs. national frontiers. Security Dialogue 1995, 26(4):413-426.
98. Tyrrell I. American exceptionalism in an age of international history. American Historical Review 1991, 96(4):1031-1055.
99. Vali F.A. Bridge across the Bosporus: The foreign policy of Turkey 1971, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore and London.
100. Van Gennep A. [1908]. The rites of passage 1968, They University of Chicago Press/Routledge and Kegan Paul, Chicago/London.
101. Waever O. Europe's three empires: a Watsonian interpretation of post-wall European security. International society after the cold war: Anarchy and order reconstructed 1996, 220-260. St. Martin's Press, Hampshire and London. R. Fawn, J. Larkins (Eds.).
102. Walker J. Turkey's imperial legacy: understanding contemporary Turkey through its Ottoman past. Perspectives on Global Development and Technology 2009, 8(2):494-508.
103. Yanik L.K. Metamorphosis of metaphors of vision: 'bridging' turkey's location, role and identity. Geopolitics 2009, 14(3):531-549.
104. Yanik, L. K. (2009b). Bridges that connect. Paper presented at ECPR joint sessions, Lisbon, Portugal.
105. Yavuz H. Turkish identity and foreign policy in flux: the rise of neo-Ottomanism. Middle East Critique 1998, 7(12):19-41.
106. Yeǧen M. Turkish nationalism and the Kurdish question. Ethnic and Racial Studies 2007, 30(1):119-151.
107. Yilmaz E., Bilgin P. Constructing Turkey's 'western' identity during the cold war. International Journal 2005-2006, 61(1):39-59.
108. Yilmaz Ş., Yosmaoǧlu İ.K. Fighting the spectres of the past: dilemmas of Ottoman legacy in the Balkans and the Middle East. Middle Eastern Studies 2008, 44(5):677-693.