Competition drives specialization in pollination systems through costs to male fitness

American Naturalist

Volumn 176, Issue 6, 2010, Pages 732-743

  Muchhala, Nathan ^a   Brown, Zachary ^b   Armbruster, W Scott ^c,d,e   Potts, Matthew D ^f  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^b Department of Computer Science and Center for Computational Science   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF PORTSMOUTH   (United Kingdom)

^d UNIVERSITY OF ALASKA FAIRBANKS   (United States)

^e NORWEGIAN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY   (Norway)

^f UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

Community context; Competition through heterospecific pollen transfer; Generalization; Simulation model

Indexed keywords

ANGIOSPERM; COMPETITION (ECOLOGY); FITNESS; PLANT-POLLINATOR INTERACTION; POLLINATOR; SEX ALLOCATION; SPECIALIZATION;

ANIMAL; ARTICLE; BIOLOGICAL MODEL; EVOLUTION; FLOWER; GENETICS; HISTOLOGY; OVULE; PHYSIOLOGY; POLLEN; POLLINATION; SPECIES DIFFERENCE;

ANIMALS; BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION; FLOWERS; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL; OVULE; POLLEN; POLLINATION; SPECIES SPECIFICITY;

MAGNOLIOPHYTA;

EID: 78649707333     PISSN: 00030147     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1086/657049     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Aigner, P. A. 2001. Optimality modeling and fitness trade-offs: When should plants become pollinator specialists? Oikos 95:177-184.
2. Armbruster, W. S. 1993. Evolution of plant pollination systems: Hypotheses and tests with the Neotropical vine Dalechampia. Evolution 47:1480-1505.
3. -. 2006. Evolutionary and ecological aspects of specialized pollination: Views from the arctic to the tropics. Pages 260-282 in N. M. Waser and J. Ollerton, eds. Plant-pollinator interactions: From specialization to generalization. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
4. Armbruster, W. S., and A. L. Herzig. 1984. Partitioning and sharing of pollinators by four sympatric species of Dalechampia (Euphorbiaceae) in Panama. Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden 71: 1-16.
5. Armbruster, W. S., and A. D. McGuire. 1991. Experimental assessment of reproductive interactions between sympatric Aster and Erigeron (Asteraceae) in interior Alaska. American Journal of Botany 78:1449-1457.
6. Armbruster, W. S., and N. Muchhala. 2009. Associations between floral specialization and species diversity: Cause, effect, or correlation? Evolutionary Ecology 23:159-179.
7. Armbruster, W. S., M. E. Edwards, and E. M. Debevec. 1994. Floral character displacement generates assemblage structure of Western Australian triggerplants (Stylidium). Ecology 75:315-329.
8. Bell, G. 1985. On the function of flowers. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 224:223-265.
9. Blair, A.W., and P. S.Williamson. 2008. Effectiveness and importance of pollinators to the star cactus (Astrophytum asterias). Southwestern Naturalist 53:423-430.
10. Brunet, J. 1992. Sex allocation in hermaphroditic plants. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 7:79-84.
11. Campbell, D. R. 1985. Pollen and gene dispersal: The influences of competition for pollination. Evolution 39:418-431.
12. Campbell, D. R., and A. F. Motten. 1985. The mechanism of competition for pollination between two forest herbs. Ecology 66:554-563.
13. Caruso, C. M., and M. Alfaro. 2000. Interspecific pollen transfer as a mechanism of competition: Effect of Castilleja linariaefolia pollen on seed set of Ipomopsis aggregata. Canadian Journal of Botany 78:600-606.
14. Castellanos, M. C., P. Wilson, and J. D. Thomson. 2004. "Anti-bee" and "pro-bird" changes during the evolution of hummingbird pollination in Penstemon flowers. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 17:876-885.
15. Charlesworth, D., and B. Charlesworth. 1981. Allocation of resources to male and female functions in hermaphrodites. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 15:57-74.
16. Charnov, E. L. 1979. Simultaneous hermaphroditism and sexual selection. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 76:2480-2484.
17. -. 1982. The theory of sex allocation. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
18. Conner, J. K. 1997. Floral evolution in wild radish: The roles of pollinators, natural selection, and genetic correlations among traits. International Journal of Plant Sciences 158(suppl.):S108-S120.
19. Dieringer, G. 1992. Pollinator effectiveness and seed set in populations of Agalinis strictifolia (Scrophulariaceae). American Journal of Botany 79:1018-1023.
20. Fenster, C. B., W. S. Armbruster, P. Wilson, M. R. Dudash, and J. D. Thomson. 2004. Pollination syndromes and floral specialization. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 35: 375-403.
21. Flanagan, R. J., R. J. Mitchell, D. Knutowski, and J. D. Karron. 2009. Interspecific pollinator movements reduce pollen deposition and seed production in Mimulus ringens (Phrymaceae).American Journal of Botany 96:809-815.
22. Forrest, J., and J. D. Thomson. 2009. Background complexity affects colour preference in bumblebees. Naturwissenschaften 96:921-925.
23. Futuyma, D. J., and G. Moreno. 1988. The evolution of ecological specialization. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 19:207-233.
24. Gomez, J. M., and R. Zamora. 1999. Generalization vs. specialization in the pollination system of Hormathophylla spinosa (Cruciferae). Ecology 80:796-805.
25. -. 2006. Ecological factors that promote the evolution of generalization in pollination systems. Pages 145-166 in N. M. Waser and J. Ollerton, eds. Plant-pollinator interactions: From specialization to generalization. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
26. Grant, V. 1949. Pollination systems as isolating mechanisms in angiosperms. Evolution 3:82-97.
27. Harder, L. D. 2000. Pollen dispersal and the floral diversity of monocotyledons. Pages 243-257 in K. L. Wilson and D. Morris, eds. Monocots: Systematics and evolution. CSIRO, Melbourne.
28. Harder, L. D., and M. B. Routley. 2006. Pollen and ovule fates and reproductive performance by flowering plants. Pages 61-80 in L. D. Harder and S. C. H. Barrett, eds. Ecology and evolution of flowers. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
29. Hodges, S. A., and M. L. Arnold. 1995. Spurring plant diversification: Are floral nectar spurs a key innovation? Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 262:343-348.
30. Irwin, R. E., and A. K. Brody. 2000. Consequences of nectar robbing for realized male function in a hummingbird-pollinated plant. Ecology 81:2637-2643.
31. Johnson, S. D. 2006. Pollinator-driven speciation in plants. Pages 296-306 in L. D. Harder and S. C. H. Barrett, eds. The ecology and evolution of flowers. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
32. Johnson, S. D., and K. E. Steiner. 2000. Generalization versus specialization in plant pollination systems. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 15:140-143.
33. Johnson, S. D., L. F. Delph, and C. L. Elderkin. 1995. The effect of petal-size manipulation on pollen removal, seed set, and insectvisitor behavior in Campanula americana. Oecologia (Berlin) 102: 174-179.
34. Johnson, S. D., H. P. Linder, and K. E. Steiner. 1998. Phylogeny and radiation of the pollination systems in Disa (Orchidaceae). American Journal of Botany 85:402-411.
35. Johnson, S. D., P. R. Neal, and L. D. Harder. 2005. Pollen fates and the limits on male reproductive success in an orchid population. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 86:175-190.
36. Johnson, S. D., A. L. Hargreaves, and M. Brown. 2006. Dark, bittertasting nectar functions as a filter of flower visitors in a birdpollinated plant. Ecology 87:2709-2716.
37. Kay, K. M., and R. D. Sargent. 2009. The role of animal pollinators in plant speciation: Integrating ecology, geography, and genetics. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 40:637-656.
38. Kay, K. M., C. Voelckel, J. Y. Yang, K. M. Hufford, D. D. Kaska, and S. A. Hodges. 2006. Floral characters and species diversification. Pages 311-325 in L. D. Harder and S. C. H. Barrett, eds. Ecology and evolution of flowers. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
39. Kessler, D., G. Klaus, and I. T. Baldwin. 2008. Field experiments with transformed plants reveal the sense of floral scents. Science 321: 1200-1202.
40. Kiester, A. R., R. Lande, and D. W. Schemske. 1984. Models of coevolution and speciation in plants and their pollinators. American Naturalist 124:220-243.
41. Knight, T. M., J. A. Steets, J. C. Vamosi, S. J. Mazer, M. Burd, D. R. Campbell, M. R. Dudash, M. Johnston, R. J. Mitchell, and T.-L. Ashman. 2005. Pollen limitation of plant reproduction: Pattern and process. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 36:467-497.
42. Kudo, G., and L. D. Harder. 2005. Floral and inflorescence effects on variation in pollen removal and seed production among six legume species. Functional Ecology 19:245-254.
43. Kwak, M. M., and O. Jennersten. 1991. Bumblebee visitation and seed set in Melampyrum pratense and Viscaria vulgaris: Heterospecific pollen and pollen limitation. Oecologia (Berlin) 86:99-104.
44. Lau, J. A., R. E. Miller, and M. D. Rausher. 2008. Selection through male function favors smaller floral display size in the common morning glory Ipomoea purpurea (Convolvulaceae). American Naturalist 172:63-74.
45. Lazaro, A., R. Lundgren, and O. Totland. 2009. Co-flowering neighbors influence the diversity and identity of pollinator groups visiting plant species. Oikos 118:691-702.
46. Levin, D. A., and W.W. Anderson. 1970. Competition for pollinators between simultaneously flowering species. American Naturalist 104:455-467.
47. Lloyd, D. G. 1984. Gender allocations in outcrossing cosexual plants. Pages 277-300 in R. Dirzo and J. Sarukhán, eds. Perspectives in plant population ecology. Sinauer, Sunderland, MA.
48. Madjidian, J. A., C. L. Morales, and H. G. Smith. 2008. Displacement of a native by an alien bumblebee: Lower pollinator efficiency overcome by overwhelmingly higher visitation frequency. Oecologia (Berlin) 156:835-845.
49. Martén-Rodríguez, S., A. Almarales-Castro, and C. B. Fenster. 2009. Evaluation of pollination syndromes in Antillean Gesneriaceae: Evidence for bat, hummingbird and generalized flowers. Journal of Ecology 97:348-359.
50. Mayfield, M. M., N. M. Waser, and M. V. Price. 2001. Exploring the "most effective pollinator principle" with complex flowers: Bumblebees and Ipomopsis aggregata. Annals of Botany 88:591-596.
51. Maynard Smith, J. 1971. The origin and maintenance of sex. Pages 163-175 in G. C. Williams, ed. Group selection. Aldine Atherton, Chicago.
52. McGuire, A. D., and W. S. Armbruster. 1991. An experimental test for reproductive interactions between two sequentially blooming Saxifraga species (Saxifragaceae). American Journal of Botany 78: 214-219.
53. Mitchell, R. J., R. J. Flanagan, B. J. Brown, N. M. Waser, and J. D. Karron. 2009. New frontiers in competition for pollination. Annals of Botany 103:1403-1413.
54. Moeller, D. A. 2004. Facilitative interactions among plants via shared pollinators. Ecology 85:3289-3301.
55. Montgomery, B. R. 2009. Do pollen carryover and pollinator constancy mitigate effects of competition for pollination? Oikos 118: 1084-1092.
56. Morales, C. L., and A. Traveset. 2008. Interspecific pollen transfer: Magnitude, prevalence and consequences for plant fitness. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 27:221-238.
57. Morgan, M. T. 1992. The evolution of traits influencing male and female fertility in outcrossing plants. American Naturalist 139: 1022-1051.
58. Motten, A. F., D. R. Campbell, D. E. Alexander, and H. L. Miller. 1981. Pollination effectiveness of specialist and generalist visitors to a North Carolina population of Claytonia virginica. Ecology 62: 1278-1287.
59. Muchhala, N. 2003. Exploring the boundary between pollination syndromes: Bats and hummingbirds as pollinators of Burmeistera cyclostigmata and B. tenuiflora. Oecologia (Berlin) 134:373-380.
60. -. 2007. Adaptive trade-off in floral morphology mediates specialization for flowers pollinated by bats and hummingbirds. American Naturalist 169:494-504.
61. Muchhala, N., and M. D. Potts. 2007. Character displacement among bat-pollinated flowers of the genus Burmeistera: Analysis of mechanism, process and pattern. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 274:2731-2737.
62. Murcia, C., and P. Feinsinger. 1996. Interspecific pollen loss by hummingbirds visiting flower mixtures: Effects of floral architecture. Ecology 77:550-560.
63. Pijl, L. 1961. Ecological aspects of flower evolution. II. Zoophilous flower classes. Evolution 15:44-59.
64. Rathcke, B. J. 1983. Competition and facilitation among plants for pollination. Pages 305-329 in L. Real, ed. Pollination biology. Academic Press, New York.
65. Ree, R. H. 2005. Detecting the historical signature of key innovations using stochastic models of character evolution and cladogenesis. Evolution 59:257-265.
66. Rodríguez-Gironés, M. A., and A. L. Llandres. 2008. Resource competition triggers the co-evolution of long tongues and deep corolla tubes. PLoS ONE 3:e2992.
67. Rodríguez-Gironés, M. A., and L. Santamaría. 2005. Resource partitioning among flower visitors and evolution of nectar concealment in multi-species communities. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 272:187-192.
68. -. 2007. Resource competition, character displacement, and the evolution of deep corolla tubes. American Naturalist 170:455-464.
69. Rush, S., J. K. Conner, and P. Jennetten. 1995. The effects of natural variation in pollinator visitation on rates of pollen removal in wild radish, Raphanus raphanistrum (Brassicaceae). American Journal of Botany 82:1522-1526. (Pubitemid 3023149)
70. Sahli, H. F., and J. K. Conner. 2007. Visitation, effectiveness, and efficiency of 15 genera of visitors to wild radish, Raphanus raphanismum (Brassicaceae). American Journal of Botany 94:203-209.
71. Sargent, R. D. 2004. Floral symmetry affects speciation rates in angiosperms. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 271:603-608.
72. Sargent, R. D., and D. D. Ackerly. 2008. Plant-pollinator interactions and the assembly of plant communities. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 23:123-130.
73. Sargent, R. D., and S. P. Otto. 2006. The role of local species abundance in the evolution of pollinator attraction in flowering plants. American Naturalist 167:67-80.
74. Schiestl, F. P., and P. M. Schluter. 2009. Floral isolation, specialized pollination, and pollinator behavior in orchids. Annual Review of Entomology 54:425-446.
75. Schluter, D. 2000. Ecological character displacement in adaptive radiation. American Naturalist 156(suppl.):S4-S16.
76. Schoen, D. J., and T.-L. Ashman. 1995. The evolution of floral longevity: Resource-allocation to maintenance versus construction of repeated parts in modular organisms. Evolution 49:131-139.
77. Shuttleworth, A., and S. D. Johnson. 2009. The importance of scent and nectar filters in a specialized wasp-pollination system. Functional Ecology 23:931-940.
78. Smith, S. D., C. Ane, and D. A. Baum. 2008. The role of pollinator shifts in the floral diversification of Iochroma (Solanaceae). Evolution 62:793-806.
79. Stanton, M., H. J. Young, N. C. Ellstrand, and J. M. Clegg. 1991. Consequences of floral variation for male and female reproduction in experimental populations of wild radish, Raphanus sativus L. Evolution 45:268-280.
80. Stebbins, G. L. 1970. Adaptive radiation of reproductive characteristics in angiosperms. I. Pollination mechanisms. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 1:307-326.
81. Stone, G. N., P. Willmer, and J. A. Rowe. 1998. Partitioning of pollinators during flowering in an African Acacia community. Ecology 79:2808-2827.
82. Strauss, S. Y., and R. E. Irwin. 2004. Ecological and evolutionary consequences of multispecies plant-animal interactions. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 35:435-466.
83. Strauss, S. Y., J. K. Conner, and K. P. Lehtila. 2001. Effects of foliar herbivory by insects on the fitness of Raphanus raphanistrum: Damage can increase male fitness. American Naturalist 158:496-504.
84. Thomson, J. D. 2003. When is it mutualism? American Naturalist 162(suppl.):S1-S9.
85. Thomson, J. D., B. J. Andrews, and R. C. Plowright. 1981. The effect of foreign pollen on ovule development in Diervilla lonicera (Caprifoliaceae). New Phytologist 90:777-783.
86. Tripp, E. A., and P. S. Manos. 2008. Is floral specialization an evo lutionary dead-end? pollination system transitions in Ruellia (Acanthaceae). Evolution 62:1712-1737.
87. Vaughton, G., and M. Ramsey. 1998. Floral display, pollinator visitation and reproductive success in the dioecious perennial herb Wurmbea dioica (Liliaceae). Oecologia (Berlin) 115:93-101.
88. Waser, N. M. 1983. Competition for pollination and floral character differences among sympatric plant species: A review of the evidence. Pages 277-293 in C. E. Jones and R. J. Little, eds. Handbook of experimental pollination biology. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.
89. Waser, N. M., and M. L. Fugate. 1986. Pollen precedence and stigma closure: A mechanism of competition for pollination between Delphinium nelsonii and Ipomopsis aggregata. Oecologia (Berlin) 70: 573-577.
90. Waser, N. M., L. Chittka, M. V. Price, N. M.Williams, and J. Ollerton. 1996. Generalization in pollination systems, and why it matters. Ecology 77:1043-1060.
91. Whittall, J. B., and S. A. Hodges. 2007. Pollinator shifts drive increasingly long nectar spurs in columbine flowers. Nature 447: 706-710.
92. Wilson, P., and J. D. Thomson. 1996. How do flowers diverge? Pages 88-111 in D. G. Lloyd and S. C. H. Barrett, eds. Floral biology: Studies on floral evolution in animal-pollinated plants. Chapman & Hall, New York.