Students and the consumer credit market: Towards a social policy Agenda

Social Policy and Administration

Volumn 44, Issue 5, 2010, Pages 598-619

  Szmigin, Isabelle ^a   O'Loughlin, Deirdre ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Capability; Credit; Debt; Marketing; Responsibility; Students

Indexed keywords

CONSUMPTION BEHAVIOR; CREDIT PROVISION; DEBT; MARKETING; QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS; SOCIAL POLICY; STUDENT;

EID: 77956632521     PISSN: 01445596     EISSN: 14679515     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-9515.2010.00731.x     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Ariely D, Huber J, Wertenbroch K. Why do losses loom larger than gains? Journal of Marketing Research 2005, 42:134-8. May
2. Atkinson A, Kempson E. Young People, Money Management, Borrowing and Saving: A Report to the Banking Code Standards Board (April). 2004, http://www.pfrc.bris.ac.uk, Personal Finance Research Centre. Available at: (accessed 10 June 2010
3. 2008, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7505117.stm, bbc.co.uk, Nudging the political debate along. Available at: (accessed 2 August 2009
4. Bergadaà M. Children and business: pluralistic ethics of marketers. Society and Business Review 2007, 2(1):53-73.
5. Bernthal M J, Crockett D, Rose R L. Credit cards as lifestyle facilitators. Journal of Consumer Research 2005, 32:130-45. June
6. Bhattacharya C B, Korschun D. Stakeholder marketing: beyond the four ps and the customer. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 2008, 27(1):113-16.
7. Braunsberger K, Lucas L A, Roach D. The effectiveness of credit-card regulation for vulnerable consumers. Journal of Services Marketing 2004, 18(4/5):358-70.
8. Burton D, Knights D, Leyson A, Alferoff C, Signoretta P. Making a market: the UK retail financial services industry and the rise of the complex sub-prime credit market. Competition and Change 2004, 8(1):3-25.
9. Safe, Sensible, Social: The Next Steps in the National Alcohol Strategy 2007, Cabinet Office, London, HMG Cabinet Office
10. Callender C. Beg, borrow, steal or save: FE students, tuition fees and the new Skills Strategy, CfBT Education Trust and LSDA. 2006, http://www.cfbt.com/PDF/payforlearnpolicy.pdf, Available at: (accessed 5 January 2010
11. Callender C, Jackson J. Does the fear of debt deter students from higher education. Journal of Social Policy 2005, 34(4):509-40.
12. Callender C, Kemp M. Changing student finances: income, expenditure and the take-up of student loans among full- and part-time higher education students in 1998/9, Department for Education and Employment. 2000, http://www.dcsf.gov.uk/rsgateway/DB/RRP/u012999/index.shtml, Available at: (accessed 5 January 2010
13. Chakravorti S, Emmons W. Who pays for credit cards? Journal of Consumer Affairs 2003, 37(2):208-30.
14. Chien Y-W, Devaney S A. The effects of credit attitude and socioeconomic factors on credit card and instalment debt. Journal of Consumer Affairs 2001, 35(1):162-79.
15. Christie H, Munro M, Rettig H. Making ends meet: student incomes and debt. Studies in Higher Education 2001, 26(3):363-83.
16. Clarke J. Dissolving the public realm? The logics and limits of neo-liberalism. Journal of Social Policy 2004, 33(1):27-48.
17. Cui G, Choudhury P. Consumer interests and the ethical implications of marketing: a contingency framework. Journal of Consumer Affairs 2003, 37(2):364-78.
18. Dalmeny K. Food marketing: the role of advertising in child health. Consumer Policy Review 2003, 13(1):2-7.
19. Rising Consumer Debt. 2004, http://www.datamonitor.com, Datamonitor, Datamonitor (May). Available at,
20. Credit Risk and Bad Debt Management in the UK Retail Lending Market. 2006, http://www.datamonitor.com, Datamonitor, Datamonitor (July). Available at:
21. Davies E, Lea S E G. Student attitudes to student debt. Journal of Economic Psychology 1995, 16:663-79.
22. Deacon A, Mann K. Agency, modernity and social policy. Journal of Social Policy 1999, 28(4):413-35.
23. De Meza D, Irlenbush B, Reyniers D. Financial Capability: A Behavioural Economics Perspective 2008, Consumer Research 69 (July, London, Financial Services Authority
24. Denzin N K, Lincoln Y S. Handbook of Qualitative Research 1994, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage
25. Modern Markets: Confident Consumers 1999, Department of Trade and Industry, London, Stationery Office
26. Tackling Over-indebtedness. 2006, http://www.berr.gov.uk/files/file33134.pdf, Department of Trade and Industry, Annual report. Available at: (accessed 9 January 2010
27. European statistical data warehouse. 2007, http://sdw.escb.eu, ECB, Available at: . (accessed 25 March 2008
28. Eccles S, Bird D. Mental Budgeting: How Young People Manage Their Money, Credit and Debt. 2004, http://www.lums.co.uk/publications, Lancaster University Management School Working Paper. Available at, accessed 1 January 2010
29. Etzioni A. The Spirit of Community 1993, New York, Touchstone Books
30. Etzioni A. The New Golden Rule 1997, London, Profile Books
31. Evans P. Collective capabilities, culture, and Amartya Sen's Development as Freedom. Studies in Comparative International Development 2002, 37(2):54-60.
32. 2006, http://www.ifsra.ie/data/pub_files/Code_Doc_rollover-4-2.pdf, Financial Regulator, Consumer protection code (August). Available at: (accessed 20 July 2008
33. 2009, http://www.ifsra.ie/data/pub_files/Consumer%20Protection%20Code.pdf, Financial Regulator, Consumer protection code for moneylenders (January). Available at: (accessed 20 January 2009
34. Helping Young Adults Become More Financially Capable 2005, Financial Services Authority (FSA), London, FSA
35. Personal finance education in schools: a UK benchmark study. 2006, http://www.fsa.gov.uk/pubs/consumer-research/crpr50.pdf, Financial Services Authority (FSA), Available at, (accessed 4 January 2010
36. Fitchett J A, McDonagh P. A citizen's critique of relationship marketing in risk society. Journal of Strategic Marketing 2000, 8(2):209-22.
37. Fleet Street Letter. 2007, http://www.fspinvest.co.uk, Fleet Street Letter, Debt, the UK's epidemic, 27 November). Available at: (accessed 28 November 2008
38. Griffiths M. The sustainability of consumer credit growth in late twentieth century Australia. Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economics 2000, 24(1):23-33.
39. Hackley C, Bengry-Howell A, Griffin C, Mistral W, Szmigin I. The discursive constitution of the UK alcohol problem in Safe, Sensible Social: a discussion of policy implications. Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy 2008, 15(1):61-74.
40. Hanson J D, Kysar D A. Taking behaviourism seriously: the problem of market manipulation. New York University Law Review 1999, 74:632.
41. Hayhoe C, Leach L P, Turner P, Bruin M, Lawrence F. Differences in spending habits and credit use among college students. Journal of Consumer Affairs 2000, 34(1):113-33.
42. Heron E, Dwyer P. Doing the right thing: Labour's attempt to forge a new welfare deal between the individual and the state. Social Policy & Administration 1999, 33(1):91-104.
43. Hill R P, Kozup J C. Consumer experiences with predatory lending practices. Journal of Consumer Affairs 2007, 41(1):29-46.
44. Financial Capability: The Government's Long Term Approach 2007, HM Treasury, Norwich, Stationery Office
45. Hogg M K, Howells G, Miman D. Consumers in the knowledge-based economy (kbe): what creates and/or constitutes consumer vulnerability in the kbe. Journal of Consumer Policy 2007, 30:151-8.
46. Hoggett P. Agency, rationality and social policy. Journal of Social Policy 2001, 30(1):37-56.
47. 2009, http://www.parliament.uk/commons/lib/research/briefings/snsg-01327.pdf, House of Commons Library, Student and graduate debt statistics (5 May). Available at: (accessed 24 October 2009
48. Howells G. The potential and limits of consumer empowerment by information. Journal of Law and Society 2005, 32(3):349-70.
49. Central Bank Monthly Statistics. 2004, http://www.centralbank.ie/data/monthlystats/2004, Irish Central Bank, Irish Central Bank (April). Available at: (accessed 25 October 2005
50. Ironfield-Smith C, Keasey K, Summers B, Duxbury D, Hudson R. Consumer debt in the UK: attitudes and implications. Journal of Financial Regulation and Compliance 2005, 13(2):132-40.
51. Jones J. The future of banking: implications for branding and loyalty. Journal of Financial Services Marketing 1999, 3(1):53-66.
52. Jones J L, Middleton K L. Ethical decision-making by consumers: the roles of product harm and consumer vulnerability. Journal of Business Ethics 2007, 2:247-64.
53. Kempson E. Survey of Over-indebtedness 2002, London, Department of Trade and Industry
54. Kirby K, Herrnstein R. Preference reversals due to myopic discounting of delayed reward. Psychological Science 1995, 6(2):83-9.
55. Lapavitsas C. Information and trust as social aspects of credit. Economy and Society 2007, 36(3):416-36.
56. Lebens W, Lewis A. Are students serious bankers? The nature of the student-bank relationship in the UK and France. Student Debt: The Causes and Consequences of Undergraduate Borrowing in the UK 2001, 93-108. Scott A, Lewis ALea S. eds, Bristol, Policy Press, pp.
57. Lewis B R, Spyrakopoulos S. Service failures and recovery of retail banking: the customers' perspective. International Journal of Bank Marketing 2001, 19(1):37-47.
58. Lincoln Y S, Guba E G. Naturalistic Inquiry 1985, Beverly Hills, CA, Sage
59. McAleese D. The Celtic tiger, origins and prospects. Policy Options 2000, 46-50. July/August
60. Mann K. Three steps to heaven? Tensions in the management of welfare: retirement pensions and active consumers. Journal of Social Policy 2005, 35(1):77-96.
61. Marriott P. An analysis of first experience students' financial awareness and attitude to debt in post-1992 UK university. Higher Education Quarterly 2007, 61(4):498-519.
62. Measham F, Brain K. Binge drinking, British alcohol policy and the new culture of intoxication. Crime, Media, Culture 2005, 1(3):262-83.
63. Miles M B, Huberman A M. An Expanded Sourcebook of Qualitative Data Analysis 1994, 2nd edn, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage
64. Mueller B. Just where does corporate responsibility end and consumer responsibility begin? The case of marketing food to kids around the globe. International Journal of Advertising 2007, 26(4):561-4.
65. Murphy K. Living on the edge. Irish Times 2005, 13. 27 April
66. Nicoulaud B M. Consumerism and marketing management's responsibility. European Journal of Marketing 1987, 21(3):7-16.
67. O'Loughlin D, Szmigin I. 'I'll always be in debt': Irish and UK student behaviour in a credit-led environment. Journal of Consumer Marketing 2006, 23(6):335-53.
68. O'Loughlin D, Szmigin I. The challenge of sustaining the relationship approach: financial supplier perspectives. Australasia Marketing Journal 2008, 15(3):35-48.
69. Implementing an Integrated Package of Pension Reforms 2006, Pensions Commission, London, Pensions Commission
70. Richards M, Palmer P, Bogdanova M. Irresponsible lending? A case study of a UK credit industry reform initiative. Journal of Business Ethics 2008, 81(3):499-512.
71. Ringold D J. Social criticisms of target marketing: process or product? American Behaviorial Scientist 1995, 38(4):578-92.
72. Rittenburg T L, Parthasarathy M. Ethical implications of target market selection. Journal of Macromarketing 1997, 17(2):49-64.
73. Roberts J A, Jones E. Money attitudes, credit card use and compulsive buying among American college students. Journal of Consumer Affairs 2001, 35(2):213-40.
74. Rowlingson K. Private pension planning: the rhetoric of responsibility, the reality of insecurity. Journal of Social Policy 2002, 31(4):623-42.
75. Rowlingson K, McKay S. Buy now, pay later? British Social Attitudes Survey 2002, 27-41. Park A, Curtice JThomson KJarvis LBromley C. eds, 19th Report, London, Sage, pp.
76. 2008, http://news.scotsman.com/education/Parents-urged-to--.4769082.jp, Scotsman.com, available at: (accessed 23 October 2008
77. Silverman D. Doing Qualitative Research: A Practical Handbook 2000, London, Sage
78. Smith C N, Cooper-Martin E. Ethics and target marketing: the role of product harm and consumer vulnerability. Journal of Marketing 1997, 61:1-20. July
79. Smith N C, Quelch J A. Ethics in Marketing 1993, Homewood, IL, Irwin
80. Sutherland M. Advertising and the Mind of the Consumer 1993, St Leonards, NSW, Allen and Unwin
81. Szmigin I, O'Loughlin D. Exposing the credogenic environment: where does responsibility lie? Advances in Consumer Research 2009, 36:1-7.
82. Taylor-Gooby P. Markets and motives: trust and egoism in welfare markets. Journal of Social Policy 1999, 28(1):97-114.
83. Taylor-Gooby P. Choice and values: individualised rational action and social goals. Journal of Social Policy 2008, 37(2):167-85.
84. Thaler R H. Mental accounting matters. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 1998, 12:183-206.
85. Thaler R H, Benartzi S. Save More Tomorrow™. Journal of Political Economy 2004, 112(1):S164-S187.
86. Thaler R H, Sunstein C R. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness 2008, Newhaven, CT, Yale University Press
87. Second Report: Credit Card Charges and Marketing. 2005, Treasury Report, Session 2004-5, HC 2
88. Varey R J. Relationship Marketing, Dialogue and Networks in an E-Commerce Era 2002, Chichester, Wiley
89. Viscusi W K. Using warnings to extend the boundaries of consumer sovereignty. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 1999, 23:211-31.
90. Warwick J, Mansfield P. Credit card consumers: college students' knowledge and attitude. Journal of Consumer Marketing 2000, 17(7):617-26.
91. Zaltman G. Rethinking market research, putting people back. Journal of Marketing Research 1997, 34(4):424-37.
92. Zuckerman G. Borrowing levels reach a record. Wall Street Journal 2000, C18. 5 July