Responding to Pfiesteria piscicida (the fish killer): Phantomatic ontologies, indeterminacy, and responsibility in toxic microbiology

Social Studies of Science

Volumn 40, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 275-306

  Schrader, Astrid ^a  

^a SARAH LAWRENCE COLLEGE   (United States)

Author keywords

Causality; Indeterminacy; Intra activities; Iterability; Material agency; Phantomatic ontologies; Responsibility; Temporality; Toxic dinoflagellates

Indexed keywords

TOXIN; WATER;

ANIMAL; ANIMAL PARASITOSIS; ARTICLE; FISH; FISH DISEASE; KNOWLEDGE; MORTALITY; PARASITOLOGY; PATHOGENICITY; PFIESTERIA; SOCIAL BEHAVIOR; UNCERTAINTY;

ANIMALS; FISH DISEASES; FISHES; KNOWLEDGE; PFIESTERIA PISCICIDA; PROTOZOAN INFECTIONS, ANIMAL; SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY; TOXINS, BIOLOGICAL; UNCERTAINTY; WATER;

EID: 77949325277     PISSN: 03063127     EISSN: 14603659     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0306312709344902     Document Type: Article

References (86)

1. Barad, Karen (2007) Meeting the Universe Halfway: Quantum Physics and the Entanglement of Matter and Meaning (Durham, NC: Duke University Press).
2. Berry J.P., K.S. Reece, K.S. Rein, D.G. Baden, L.W. Haas,et al.(2002) Are Pfiesteria Species Toxicogenic? Evidence against Production of Ichthyotoxins by Pfiesteria shumwayae, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 99(17): 10970-75.
3. Blankenship, Karl (2002) Pfiesteria May or May Not Be Toxic, but the Dispute over the Issue Is, Chesapeake Bay Journal 12(7). Available at (accessed 8 August 2007).
4. Bowker, Geoffrey C. (2005) Memory Practices in the Sciences (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
5. Bowker, Geoffrey C. & Susan Leigh Star (1999) Sorting Things Out: Classification and Its Consequences (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
6. Burkholder, JoAnn M. (1998) Implications of Harmful Marine Microalgae and Heterotrophic Dinoflagellates in Management of Sustainable Marine Fisheries, Ecological Applications 8 (Supplement): 37S-62S.
7. Burkholder, JoAnn M. & Howard B. Glasgow (1997) Pfiesteria piscicida and Other Pfiesteria-Like Dinoflagellates: Behavior, Impacts, and Environmental Controls, Limnology and Oceanography 42(5): 1052-75.
8. Burkholder, JoAnn M., Howard B. Glasgow, N.J. Deamer-Melia, J. Springer, M.W. Parrow,et al.(2001a) Species of the Toxic Pfiesteria Complex, and the Importance of Functional Type in Data Interpretation, Environmental Health Perspectives 109(S5): 667-79.
9. Burkholder, JoAnn M., A.S. Gordon, P.D. Moeller, J.M. Law, K.J. Coyne,et al.(2005) Demonstration of Toxicity to Fish and to Mammalian Cells by Pfiesteria Species: Comparison of Assay Methods and Strains, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 102(9): 3471-76.
10. Burkholder, JoAnn M., H.G. Marshall, H.B. Glasgow, D.W. Seaborn & N.J. Deamer-Melia (2001b) The Standardized Fish Bioassay Procedure for Detecting and Culturing Actively Toxic Pfiesteria, Used by Two Reference Laboratories for Atlantic and Gulf Coast States, Environmental Health Perspectives 109: 745-56.
11. Burkholder, JoAnn M., E.J. Noga, C.H. Hobbs, Howard B. Glasgow J.r & S.A. Smith (1992) New Phantom Dinoflagellate Is the Causative Agent of Major Estuarine Fish Kills, Nature 358 (30 July): 407-10.
12. Burkholder, JoAnn M. & Howard B. Glasgow (2002) The Life Cycle and Toxicity of Pfiesteria piscicida Revisited, Journal of Phycology 38(6): 1261-67.
13. Burreson, Eugene (1998) Science, Uncertainty & Policy (Sea Grant Pfiesteria Briefing, 19 October 1998), Sea Grant News Media Center. Available at (accessed 18 December 2006).
14. Butler, Judith (1993) Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limits of 'Sex' (New York: Routledge).
15. Callon, Michel (1986) Some Elements of a Sociology of Translation: Domestication of the Scallops and the Fishermen of St. Brieuc Bay, in John Law (ed.), Power, Action and Belief: A New Sociology of Knowledge? (London: Routledge): 196-229.
16. Cheah, Pheng (1996) Mattering, Diacritics 26(1): 108-39.
17. Coats, D.W. (2002) Dinoflagellate Life-cycle Complexities, Journal of Phycology 38(3): 417-19.
18. Daston, Lorraine (2002) Introduction: The Coming into Being of Scientific Objects, in Lorraine Daston (ed) Biographies of Scientific Objects (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press): 1-14.
19. Derrida, Jacques (1982) Différance, in Margins of Philosophy (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press): 3-27.
20. Derrida, Jacques (1988) Limited Inc (Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press).
21. Derrida, Jacques (1994) Specters of Marx: The State of the Debt, the Work of Mourning, and the New International (New York & London: Routledge).
22. Derrida, Jacques (2002) Marx & Sons, in Michael Sprinker (ed.), Ghostly Demarcations: A Symposium on Jacques Derrida's Specters of Marx (London: Verso): 249-56.
23. Dewar, Heather (2002) Scientists Challenge Theory on Toxicity of Pfiesteria, Baltimore Sun (21 June).
24. Drgon, Tomás, Keiko Saito, Patrick M. Gillevet, Masoumeh Sikaroodi & Gerardo R. Vasta (2005) Characterization of Pfiesteria Ichthyocidal Activity - Authors' Reply, Applied and Environmental Microbiology 71(10): 6463-64.
25. Evans, A.S. (1976) Causation and Disease: The Henle-Koch Postulates Revised, Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine 49: 175-95.
26. Fensome, Robert A., Juan F. Saldarriaga, F.J.R. Max Taylor (1999) Dinoflagellate Phylogeny Revisited: Reconciling Morphological and Molecular Based Phylogenies, Grana 38(2/3): 66-80.
27. Fortun, Kim & Mike Fortun (2005) Scientific Imaginaries and Ethical Plateaus in Contemporary U.S. Toxicology, American Anthropologist 107(1): 43-54.
28. Foucault, Michel (1970) The Order of Things: An Archaeology of the Human Sciences (New York: Pantheon).
29. Gawley, Robert E. & Daniel G. Baden (1998) Detection and Identification of the Toxins from Pfiesteria and Related Harmful Algal Blooms, EPA Grant Number: R826655. Available at (accessed 10 December 2007).
30. Gilbert, Scott F. (2002) The Genome in Its Ecological Context: Philosophical Perspectives on Interspecies Epigenesis New York Academy of Sciences 981: 202-18.
31. Glasgow, Howard B., JoAnn M. Burkholder, M.A. Mallin, N.J. Deamer-Melia & R.E. Reed (2001) Field Ecology of Toxic Pfiesteria Complex Species and a Conservative Analysis of Their Role in Estuarine Fish Kills, Environmental Health Perspectives 109: 715-30.
32. Glibert, Patricia M. & JoAnn M. Burkholder (2006) Toward an Emerging Consensus on the Ecology of Pfiesteria, Harmful Algae 5(4): 339.
33. Gordon, Andrew S. & B. Dyer (2005) Relative Contribution of Exotoxin and Micropredation to Icthyotoxicity of Two Strains of Pfiesteria shumwayae (Dinophyceae), Harmful Algae 4(2): 423-31.
34. Gordon, Andrew S., Harold G. Marshall, Sandra E. Shumway, Kathryn J. Coyne, Alan J. Lewituset al.(2005) Letter to the Editor: Characterization of Pfiesteria Ichthyocidal Activity, Applied and Environmental Microbiology 71(10): 6463-64.
35. Greer, Jack (1993) Alien in Our Midst? Phantom Algae Suspected in Bay, Maryland Marine Notes 11(3). Available at < www.mdsg.umd.edu/MarineNotes/Mar93/> (accessed 7 July 2007).
36. Hacking, Ian (1995) Rewriting the Soul: Multiple Personality and the Sciences of Memory (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
37. Haraway, Donna (1991) Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective, in D. Haraway, Simians, Cyborgs, and Women: The Reinvention of Nature (London: Routledge): 183-201.
38. Haraway, Donna (1997) Modest_Witness@Second_Millennium.Femaleman©_Meets_Oncomouse™: Feminism and Technoscience (New York: Routledge).
39. Hayden, Corinne (2003) Suspended Animation: A Brine Shrimp Essay, in S. Franklin & M. Lock (eds), Remaking Life and Death: Towards an Anthropology of the Biosciences (Santa Fe, NM: School of American Research Press): 193-226.
40. Helmreich, Stefan (2009) Alien Ocean: Anthropological Voyages in Microbial Seas (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press).
41. Herzig, Rebecca (2004) On Performance, Productivity, and Vocabulary of Motive in Recent Studies of Science, Feminist Theory 5(2): 127-47.
42. Hinchliffe, Steve (2001) Indeterminacy In-decisions: Science, Policy and Politics in the BSE (Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy) Crisis, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 26(2): 182-204.
43. Jasanoff, Sheila (1987) Contested Boundaries in Policy-relevant Science, Social Studies of Science 17(2): 195-230.
44. Jasanoff, Sheila (2004) Ordering Knowledge, Ordering Society, in S. Jasanoff (ed.), States of Knowledge:The Co-production of Science and the Social Order (New York: Routledge): 13-45.
45. Jasanoff, Sheila (2005) In the Democracies of DNA: Ontological Uncertainties and Political Order in Three States, New Genetics and Society 24(2): 139-155.
46. Kaiser, Jocelyn (2004) The Pfiesteria Conundrum: More Study, Less Certainty, Science 303 (2 January): 25-26.
47. Kirby, Vicki (1997) Telling Flesh: The Substance of the Corporeal (New York: Routledge).
48. Krieger, Nancy (1997) Epidemiology and the Web of Causation: Has Anyone Seen the Spider?, Social Science & Medicine 39(7): 887-903.
49. Landecker, Hannah (2005) 'Living Differently in Time: Plasticity, Temporality and Cellular Biotechnologies', Culture Machine 7. Available at (accessed 10 December 2007).
50. Latour, Bruno (1987) Science in Action: How to Follow Scientists and Engineers through Society (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
51. Latour, Bruno (1999) Pandora's Hope: Essays on the Reality of Science Studies (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
52. Latour, Bruno (2002) On the Partial Existence of Existing and Nonexisting Objects, in Lorraine Daston (ed.), Biographies of Scientific Objects (Chicago, IL, & London: University of Chicago Press): 247-69.
53. Latour, Bruno (2004) Why Has Critique Run out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern, Critical Inquiry 30(2): 225-48.
54. Law, John & Vicky Singleton (2005) Object Lessons, Organization 12(3): 331-55.
55. Litaker, R.W., M.W. Vandersea, S.R. Kibler, V.J. Madden, E.J. Noga,et al.(2002a) Life Cycle of the Heterotrophic Dinoflagellate Pfiesteria piscicida (Dinophyceae), Journal of Phycology 38(3): 442-63.
56. Litaker, R.W., M.W. Vandersea, S.R. Kibler, E.J. Noga & P.A. Tester (2002b) Reply to Comment on the Life Cycle and Toxicity of Pfiesteria piscicida Revisited, Journal of Phycology 38(6): 1268-72.
57. Lynch, Michael (1998) The Discursive Production of Uncertainty: The OJ Simpson Dream Team and the Sociology of Knowledge Machine, Social Studies of Science 28(5/6): 829-68.
58. Macilwain, Colin (1997) Scientists Close in on Cell from Hell Lurking in Chesapeake Bay, Nature 389 (25 September): 317-18.
59. Maurer, Bill (2000) A Fish Story: Rethinking Globalization on Virgin Gorda, British Virgin Islands, American Ethnologist 27(3): 670-701.
60. Moeller, Peter D.R., K.R. Beauchesne, Kevin M. Huncik, W. Clay Davis, Steven J. Christopher,et al.(2007) Metal Complexes and Free Radical Toxins Produced by Pfiesteria piscicida, Environmental Science & Technology 41(4): 1166-72.
61. Mol, Annemarie (1999) Ontological Politics: A Word and Some Questions, in John Law & John Hassard (eds), Actor Network Theory and After (Oxford: Blackwell): 74-89.
62. Mol, Annemarie (2002) The Body Multiple: Ontology in Medical Practice (Durham, NC & London: Duke University Press).
63. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Legislative Informer (1997) NOAA Issue 25 (December).
64. Oyama, Susan (1985) The Ontogeny of Information: Developmental Systems and Evolution (Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press).
65. Park, Tae-Gyu, Elanor M. Bell, Imojen Pearce, Parke A. Rublee, Christopher J.S. Belchet al.(2007) Detection of a Novel Ecotype of Pfiesteria piscicida (Dinophyceae) in an Antarctic Saline Lake by Real-time PCR, Polar Biology 30(7): 843-48.
66. Parrow, Matthew, JoAnn M. Burkholder, Nora J. Deamer & Cheng Zhang (2002) Vegetative and Sexual Reproduction in Pfiesteria spp. (Dinophyceae) Cultured with Algal Prey, and Inferences for Their Classification, Harmful Algae 1: 5-33.
67. Parrow, Matthew W., JoAnn M. Burkholder, Nora J. Deamer & John S. Ramsdell (2005) Contaminant-free Cultivation of Pfiesteria shumwayae (Dinophyceae) on a Fish Cell Line, Aquatic Microbial Ecology 39(1): 97-105.
68. Pickering, Andrew (1995) The Mangle of Practice: Time, Agency, and Science (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press).
69. Pfiesteria Interagency Coordination Workgroup (2000) Glossary of Pfiesteria-Related Terms, Pfiesteria Interagency Coordination Workgroup. Available at (accessed 8 August 2007).
70. Plotnitsky, Arkady (2003 [1995]) Complementarity, Idealization, and the Limits of Classical Conceptions of Reality, in Christopher Norris & David Roben (ed.), Jacques Derrida Vol. 3 (London: Sage Publications).
71. Raleigh Report (1998) 'Pfiesteria Research Needs and Management Actions', The Raleigh Report, Report No. SRS-19 (Raleigh, NC: The Water Resources Research Institute of The University of North Carolina Raleigh). Available at (accessed 15 September 2007).
72. Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg (1997) Towards a History of Epistemic Things: Synthesizing Proteins in the Test Tube (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press).
73. Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg (1999 [1994]) Experimental Systems: Historiality, Narration, and Deconstruction, in Mario Biagioli (ed.), The Science Studies Reader (New York: Routledge): 417-29.
74. Ritvo, Harriet (1997) The Platypus and the Mermaid, and Other Figments of the Classifying Imagination (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
75. Rouse, Joseph (2002) How Scientific Practices Matter: Reclaiming Philosophical Naturalism (Chicago, IL & London: University of Chicago Press).
76. Samet, Jonathan, Gary S. Bignami, Robert Feldman, William Hawkins, Jerry Neff,et al.(2001) Pfiesteria: Review of the Science and Identification of Research Gaps. Report for the National Center for Environmental Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Environmental Health Perspectives 109(S5): 639-59.
77. Shackley, Simon & Brian Wynne (1996) Representing Uncertainty in Global Climate Change Science and Policy: Boundary-ordering Devices and Authority, Science, Technology, & Human Values 21(3): 275-302.
78. Shackley, Simon & Brian Wynne (1995) 'Integrating Knowledges for Climate Change: Pyramids, Nets and Uncertainties', Global Environmental Change 5(5): 113-26.
79. Sommerlund, Julie (2006) Classifying Microorganisms: The Multiplicity of Classifications and Research Practices in Molecular Microbial Ecology, Social Studies of Science 36(6): 909-28.
80. Star, Susan Leigh (1985) Scientific Work and Uncertainty, Social Studies of Science 15(3): 391-427.
81. Steidinger, K.A., J.M. Burkholder, H.B. Glasgow, C.W. Hobbs, J.K. Garrett,et al.(1996) Pfiesteria piscicida gen. et sp. nov. (Pfiesteriaceae fam. nov.), a New Toxic Dinoflagellate with a Complex Life Cycle and Behavior, Journal of Phycology 32(1): 157-64.
82. Tengs, Torstein, Holly A. Bowers, Howard B. Glasgow, JoAnn M. Burkholder & David W. Oldach (2003) Identical Ribosomal DNA Sequence Data from Pfiesteria piscicida (Dinophyceae) Isolates with Different Toxicity Phenotypes, Environmental Research 93(1): 88-91.
83. Warrick, Joby (1997) 'The Feeding Frenzy of a Morphing Cell from Hell', The Washington Post (9 June): A03.
84. Waterton, Claire (2002) From Field to Fantasy: Classifying Nature, Constructing Europe, Social Studies of Science 32(2): 177-204.
85. Weston, Kath & Stefan Helmreich (2006) Kath Weston's Gender in Real Time: Power and Transience in a Visual Age, Body & Society 12(3): 103-21.
86. Wynne, Brian (1996) May the Sheep Safely Graze? A Reflexive View on the Expert-Lay Divide, in S. Lash, B. Szerszynski & B. Wynne (eds), Risk, Environment and Modernity: Towards a New Ecology (London: Sage Publications): 44-83.