Adhesion to tooth structure: A critical review of "micro" bond strength test methods

Dental Materials

Volumn 26, Issue 2, 2010, Pages

  Armstrong, Steve ^a   Geraldeli, Saulo ^a   Maia, Rodrigo ^b   Raposo, Luís Henrique Araújo ^c   Soares, Carlos José ^c   Yamagawa, Junichiro ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF IOWA   (United States)

^b Brazilian Air Force Hospital   (Brazil)

^c FEDERAL UNIVERSITY OF UBERLÂNDIA   (Brazil)

Author keywords

Bond strength; Dental adhesives; Finite element analysis; Microshear; Microtensile

Indexed keywords

ADHESION TEST; ADHESIVE BOND; BOND STRENGTH; BOND STRENGTH TESTS; CRITICAL REVIEW; DENTAL ADHESIVES; DENTAL RESINS; FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS; LOAD APPLICATION; MATERIAL PROPERTY; MICROTENSILE; RESEARCH DESIGNS; SINGLE TOOTH; STRESS DISTRIBUTION; TEST PROCEDURES; TEST SELECTION; TOOTH STRUCTURE;

ADHESION; ADHESIVES; ARCH BRIDGES; BOND (MASONRY); DENTAL COMPOSITES; DENTISTRY; ELASTICITY; FAILURE ANALYSIS; FINITE ELEMENT METHOD; FUNCTIONALLY GRADED MATERIALS; LOAD TESTING; RESINS; STRESS CONCENTRATION; TENSILE TESTING; TESTING;

BOND STRENGTH (MATERIALS);

DENTIN BONDING AGENT; RESIN; RESIN CEMENT;

DENTAL BONDING; DENTAL CARE; DENTAL SURGERY; DENTIN; ENAMEL; FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS; HUMAN; INSTRUMENTATION; MATERIALS TESTING; METHODOLOGY; REVIEW; SHEAR STRENGTH; SURFACE PROPERTY; TENSILE STRENGTH; YOUNG MODULUS;

COMPOSITE RESINS; DENTAL BONDING; DENTAL ENAMEL; DENTAL RESTORATION FAILURE; DENTAL STRESS ANALYSIS; DENTIN; DENTIN-BONDING AGENTS; ELASTIC MODULUS; FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS; HUMANS; MATERIALS TESTING; RESIN CEMENTS; SHEAR STRENGTH; SURFACE PROPERTIES; TENSILE STRENGTH;

EID: 75349103847     PISSN: 01095641     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2009.11.155     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. Okuno O. Micro-tensile testing machine. Tokyo Ika Shika Daigaku Iyo Kizai Kenkyusho Hokoku 4 (1970) 75-78 [Article in Japanese. PMID: 5285537]
2. Broom N.D. Simultaneous morphological and stress-strain studies of the fibrous components in wet heart valve leaflet tissue. Connect Tissue Res 6 (1978) 37-50
3. Missirlis Y.F., and Chong M. Aortic valve mechanics-Part I: material properties of natural porcine aortic valves. J Bioeng 2 (1978) 287-300
4. Silyn-Roberts H., and Broom N.D. A biomechanical profile across the patellar groove articular cartilage: implications for defining matrix health. J Anat 160 (1988) 175-188
5. Rho J.Y., Ashman R.B., and Turner C.H. Young's modulus of trabecular and cortical bone material: ultrasonic and microtensile measurements. J Biomech 26 (1993) 111-119
6. Sano H., Ciucchi B., Matthews W.G., and Pashley D.H. Tensile properties of mineralized and demineralized human and bovine dentin. J Dent Res 73 (1994) 1205-1211
7. Nakajima M., Sano H., Burrow M.F., Tagami J., Yoshiyama M., Ebisu S., et al. Tensile bond strength and SEM evaluation of caries-affected dentin using dentin adhesives. J Dent Res 74 (1995) 1679-1688
8. Yoshiyama M., Sano H., Ebisu S., Tagami J., Ciucchi B., Carvalho R.M., et al. Regional strengths of bonding agents to cervical sclerotic root dentin. J Dent Res 75 (1996) 1404-1413
9. Ciucchi B. Bonding characteristics of resin composite restorations on dentin Class II cavity walls, in vitro [thesis]. Geneva: University of Geneva, Switzerland; 1997.
10. Sano H., Yoshikawa T., Pereira P.N., Kanemura N., Morigami M., Tagami J., et al. Long-term durability of dentin bonds made with a self-etching primer, in vivo. J Dent Res 78 (1999) 906-911
11. Shono Y., Ogawa T., Terashita M., Carvalho R.M., Pashley E.L., and Pashley D.H. Regional measurement of resin-dentin bonding as an array. J Dent Res 78 (1999) 99-705
12. Yoshikawa T., Sano H., Burrow M.F., Tagami J., and Pashley D.H. Effects of dentin depth and cavity configuration on bond strength. J Dent Res 78 (1999) 898-905
13. Armstrong S., Jessop J., Vargas M., Zou Y., Qian F., Campbell J., et al. Effects of exogenous collagenase and cholesterol esterase on the durability of the resin-dentin bond. J Adhesiv Dent 8 (2006) 151-160
14. Cardoso P.E.C., Braga R., and Carrilho MRO. Evaluation of micro-tensile, shear and tensile tests determining the bond strength of three adhesive systems. Dent Mater 14 (1998) 394-398
15. Pashley D.H., Sano H., Ciucchi B., Yoshiyama M., and Carvalho R.M. Adhesion testing of dentin bonding agents: a review. Dent Mater 11 (1995) 117-125
16. Pashley D.H., Carvalho R.M., Sano H., Nakajima M., Yoshiyama M., Shono Y., et al. The microtensile bond test: a review. J Adhesiv Dent 1 (1999) 299-309
17. Sano H., Shono Tj, Sonoda H., takatsu T., ciucchi B., Carvalho R., et al. Relationship between surface area for adhesion and tensile bond strength-evaluation of a microtensile bond test. Dent Mater 10 (1994) 236-240
18. Phrukkanon S., Burrow M.F., and Tyas M. Effect of crosssectional surface area on bond strengths between resin and dentin. Dent Mater 14 (1998) 120-128
19. Placido E., Meira J.B.C., Lima R.G., Muench A., Souza R.M., and Ballester R.Y. Shear versus micro-shear bond strength test: a finite element stress analysis. Dent Mater 23 (2007) 1086-1092
20. Stanley H.R. An urgent plea for a standardized bonding (adhesion) test. J Dent Res 10 (1993) 1362-1363
21. Rueggeberg F.A. Substrate for adhesion testing to tooth structure-review of the literature. Dent Mater 7 (1991) 2-10
22. Olio G. Bond strength testing-what does it mean?. Int Dent J 43 (1993) 492-498
23. ISO/TS 11405: Dental materials-testing of adhesion to tooth structure. Switzerland; 2003.
24. Kinloch A.J. Adhesion and adhesives-science and technology. 4th ed. (1995), Chapman & Hall, London
25. McDonough W.G. Glass-fiber/resin interfacial strength: the microbond test and chemical evaluations. ADM Trans 17 (2003) 61-80
26. Griffith A.A. The phenomena of rupture and flow in solids. Phil Trans Roy Soc Lond A224 (1920) 163-198
27. Kelly J.R. Extrapolation from strength: Caveat Emptor. ADM Trans 7 (1994) 16-22
28. Sadr A., Ghasemi A., Shimada Y., and Tagami J. Effects of storage time and temperature on the properties of two self-etching systems. J Dent 35 (2007) 218-225
29. DeHoff P.H., Anusavice K.J., and Wang Z. Three-dimensional finite element analysis of the shear bond test. Dent Mater 11 (1995) 126-131
30. Tantbirojn D., Cheng Y.S., Versluis A., Hodges J.S., and Douglas W.H. Nominal shear or fracture mechanics in the assessment of composite-dentin adhesion?. J Dent Res 79 (2000) 41-48
31. van Noort R., Noroozi S., Howard I.C., and Cardew G. A critique of bond strength measurements. J Dent 17 (1989) 61-67
32. Versluis A., Tantbirojn D., and Douglas W.H. Why do shear bond tests pull out dentin?. J Dent Res 76 (1997) 1298-1307
33. McDonough W.G., Antonucci J.M., He J., Shimada Y., Chiang M.Y.M., Schumacher G.E., et al. A microshear test to measure bond strengths of dentin-polymer interfaces. Biomaterials 23 (2002) 3603-3608
34. van Noort R., Cardew G.E., Howard I.C., and Noroozi S. The effect of local interfacial geometry on the measurement of the tensile bond strength to dentin. J Dent Res 70 (1991) 889-893
35. El Zohairy A.A., de Gee A.J., de Jager N., van Ruijven L.J., and Feilzer A.J. The influence of specimen attachment and dimension on microtensile strength. J Dent Res 83 (2004) 420-424
36. Goracci C., Sadek F.T., Monticelli F., Cardoso P.E., and Ferrari M. Influence of substrate, shape, and thickness on microtensile specimens' structural integrity and their measured bond strengths. Dent Mater 20 (2004) 643-654
37. Silva N.R., Calamia C.S., Harsono M., Carvalho R.M., Pegoraro L.F., Fernandes C.A., et al. Bond angle effects on microtensile bonds: laboratory and FEA comparison. Dent Mater 22 (2006) 314-324
38. Soares C.J., Soares P.V., Santos-Filho P.C., and Armstrong S.R. Microtensile specimen attachment and shape-finite element analysis. J Dent Res 87 (2008) 89-93
39. Ghassemieh E. Evaluation of sources of uncertainties in microtensile bond strength of dental adhesive system for different specimen geometries. Dent Mater 24 (2008) 536-547
40. Pereira P.N.R., Okuda M., Sano H., Yoshikawa T., Burrow M.F., and Tagami J. Effect of intrinsic wetness and regional differences on dentin bond strength. Dent Mater 15 (1999) 46-53
41. Shono Y., Terashita M., Pashley E.L., Brewer P.D., and Pashley D.H. Effects of cross-sectional area on resin enamel tensile bond strength. Dent Mater 13 (1997) 290-296
42. Poitevin A., De Munck J., Van Landuyt K., Coutinho E., Peumans M., Lambrechts P., et al. Critical analysis of the influence of different parameters on the microtensile bond strength of adhesives to dentin. J Adhesiv Dent 10 (2008) 7-16
43. Armstrong S.R., Boyer D.B., and Keller J.C. Microtensile bond strength testing and failure analysis of two dentin adhesives. Dent Mater 14 (1998) 44-50
44. Gamborgi G.P., Loguercio A.D., and Resi A. Influence of enamel border and regional variability on durability of resin-dentin bonds. J Dent 35 (2007) 371-376
45. Bouillaguet S., Ciucchi B., Jacoby T., Wataha J.C., and Pashley D. Bonding characteristics to dentin walls of Class II cavities, in vitro. Dent Mater 17 (2001) 316-321
46. Purk J.H., Dusevich V., Glaros A., Spencer P., and Eick J.D. In vivo versus in vitro microtensile bond strength of axial versus gingival cavity preparation walls in Class II resin-based composite restorations. J Am Dent Assoc 135 (2004) 185-193
47. Armstrong S.R., Keller J.C., and Boyer D.B. The influence of water storage and C-factor on the dentin-resin composite microtensile bond strength and debond pathway utilizing a filled and unfilled adhesive resin. Dent Mater 17 (2001) 268-276
48. Loguercio A.D., Uceda-Gomez N., Carrilho M.R., and Reis A. Influence of specimen size and regional variation on long-term resin-dentin strength. Dent Mater 21 (2005) 224-231
49. Ibarra G., Vargas M.A., Armstrong S.R., and Cobb D.S. Microtensile bond strength of self-etching adhesives to ground and unground enamel. J Adhesiv Dent 4 (2002) 115-124
50. Reis A., Moura K., Pellizzaro A., Dal-Bianco K., de Andrade A.M., and Loguercio A.D. Durability of enamel bonding using one-step self-etch systems on ground and unground enamel. Oper Dent 34 (2009) 181-191
51. Stamatacos-Mercer C., and Hottel T.L. The validity of reported tensile bond strength utilizing non-standardized specimen surface areas. An analysis of in vitro studies. Am J Dent 18 (2005) 105-108
52. Carrillho M.R., Carvalho R.M., de Goes M.F., di Hipolito V., Geraldeli S., Tay F.R., et al. Chlorhexidine preserves dentin bond in vitro. J Dent Res 86 (2007) 90-94
53. Hashimoto M., Ohno H., Kaga M., Endo K., Sano H., and Oguchi H. In vivo degradation of resin-dentin bonds in humans over 1-3 years. J Dent Res 79 (2000) 1385-1391
54. Hashimoto M., De Munck J., Ito S., Sano H., Kaga M., Oguchi H., et al. In vitro effect of nanoleakage expression on resin-dentin bond strengths analyzed by microtensile bond test, SEM/EDX and TEM. Biomaterials 25 (2004) 5565-5574
55. Spencer P., and Wieliczka D.M. A review of the chemical and morphologic characterization of the dentin/adhesive interface. Recent Res Dev Appl Spectrosc 2 (1999) 183-193
56. Perdigao J., Geraldeli S., Carmo A., and Dutra H. In vivo influence of residual moisture on microtensile bond strengths of one-bottle adhesives. J Esthet Restor Dent 14 (2002) 31-38
57. Poitevin A., De Munck J., Van Landuyt K., Coutinho E., Peumans M., Lambrechts P., et al. Influence of three specimen fixation modes on the micro-tensile bond strength of adhesives to dentin. Dent Mater J 26 (2007) 694-699
58. Staninec M., Marshall G.W., Hilton J.F., Pashley D.H., Gansky S.A., Marshall S.J., et al. Ultimate tensile strength of dentin: evidence for a damage mechanics approach to dentin failure. Biomaterials 63 (2002) 342-345
59. Zheng L., Pereira P.N., Nakajima M., Sano H., and Tagami J. Relationship between adhesive thickness and microtensile bond strength. Oper Dent 26 (2001) 97-104
60. Sattabanasuk V., Vachiramon V., Qian F., and Armstrong S.R. Resin-dentin bond strength as related to different surface preparation methods. J Dent 35 (2007) 467-475
61. Phrukkanon S., Burrow M.F., and Tyas M.J. The influence of cross-sectional shape and surface area on the microtensile bond test. Dent Mater 14 (1998) 212-221
62. Neves Ade A., Coutinho E., Cardoso M.V., Jaecques S., Lambrechts P., Sloten J.V., et al. Influence of notch geometry and interface on stress concentration and distribution in micro-tensile bond strength specimens. J Dent 36 (2008) 808-815
63. Eckert G., and Platt J. A statistical evaluation of microtensile bond strength methodology for dental adhesives. Dent Mater 23 (2007) 385-391
64. Volinsky A.A., Nelson J.C., and Gerberich W.W. Macroscopic modeling of fine line adhesion tests. Mater Res Soc Proc 563 (1999) 1-6
65. Armstrong S.R., Keller J.C., and Boyer D.B. Mode of failure in the dentin-adhesive resin-resin composite bonded joint as determined by strength-based (mμTBS) and fracture-based (CNSB) mechanical testing. Dent Mater 17 (2001) 201-210
66. Betamar N., Cardew G., and van Noort R. The effect of variations in hourglass specimen design on microtensile bond strength to dentin. J Adhes Dent 9 5 (2007) 427-436
67. Meira J.B., Souza R.M., Driemeier L., and Ballester R.Y. Stress concentration in microtensile tests using uniform material. J Adhesiv Dent 6 (2004) 267-273
68. Vachiramon V., Vargas M.A., Pashley D.H., Tay F.R., Geraldeli S., Qian F., et al. Effects of oxalate on dentin bond after 3-month simulated pulpal pressure. J Dent 36 (2008) 178-185
69. Hibbeler R.C. Mechanics of materials. Upper Saddle river. 3rd ed. (1997), Prentice Hall, NJ
70. In: Richards R. (Ed). Principles of solid mechanics (2001), CRC Press, Boca Raton 99-126
71. Betamar N., Cardew G., and van Noort R. Influence of specimen designs on the microtensile bond strength to dentin. J Adhesiv Dent 9 (2007) 159-168
72. Sadek F.T., Monticelli F., Muench A., Ferrari M., and Cardoso P.E. A novel method to obtain microtensile specimens minimizing cut flaws. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 78 (2006) 7-14
73. Carvalho R.M., Santiago S.L., Fernandes A.O., Suh B.I., and Pashley D.H. Effects of prism orientation on tensile strength of enamel. J Adhesiv Dent 2 (2000) 251-257
74. Ferrari M., Goracci C., Sadek F., and Cardoso P.E.C. Microtensile bond strength tests: scanning electron microscopy evaluation of sample integrity before testing. Eur J Oral Sci 110 (2002) 385-391
75. Buschang P.H., Hayasaki Y., and Throckmorton G.S. Quantification of human chewing-cycle kinematics. Arch Oral Biol 45 (2000) 461-474
76. Eliades T., Katsavrias E., Zinelis S., and Eliades G. Effect of loading rate on bond strength. J Orofac Orthop 65 (2004) 336-342
77. Reis A., de Oliveira Baurer J.R., and Loguercio A.D. Influence of crosshead speed on resin-dentin microtensile bond strength. J Adhesiv Dent 6 (2004) 275-278
78. Yamaguchi K., Miyazaki M., Takimizawa T., Tsubota K., and Rikuta A. Influence of crosshead speed on micro-tensile bond strength of two-step adhesive systems. Dent Mater 22 (2006) 420-425
79. Pocious AV. Adhesion and adhesives technology-an introduction (1997), Hanser/Gardner Publications, Inc., Cincinnati, OH
80. Misra A., Spencer P., Marangos O., Wang Y., and Katz J.L. Parametric study of phase anisotropy on the micromechanical behavior of dentin-adhesive interfaces. J R Soc Interface 2 (2005) 145-157
81. Neves Ade A., Coutinho E., Poitevin A., Van der Sloten J., Van Meerbeek B., and Van Oosterwyck H. Influence of joint component mechanical properties and adhesive layer thickness on stress distribution in micro-tensile bond strength specimens. Dent Mater 25 (2009) 4-12
82. Versluis A., Messer H.H., and Pintado M.R. Changes in compaction stress distributions in roots resulting from canal preparation. Int Endod J 39 (2006) 931-939
83. Craig R.G., and Powers J.M. Restorative dental materials. 11th ed. (2002), Mosby, St. Louis, MO
84. Sudsangiam S., and van Noort R. Do dentin bond strength tests serve a useful purpose?. J Adhesiv Dent 1 (1999) 57-67