Should entrepreneurs plan or just storm the castle? A meta-analysis on contextual factors impacting the business planning-performance relationship in small firms

Journal of Business Venturing

Volumn 25, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 24-40

  Brinckmann, Jan ^a   Grichnik, Dietmar ^b   Kapsa, Diana ^c  

^a LOYOLA UNIVERSITY CHICAGO   (United States)

^b WHU OTTO BEISHEIM SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT   (Germany)

^c UNIVERSITY OF WITTEN HERDECKE   (Germany)

Author keywords

Business planning; Cultural factors; Meta analysis; New firms; Small firms; Venture performance

Indexed keywords

EID: 70449630205     PISSN: 08839026     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jbusvent.2008.10.007     Document Type: Article

References (126)

1. Ackelsberg R., and Arlow P. Small businesses do plan and it pays off. Long Range Planning 18 5 (1985) 61-67
2. Aldrich H.E., and Fiol M.C. Fools rush in? The institutional context of industry creation. Academy of Management Review 19 4 (1994) 645-670
3. Andrews K.R. The Concept of Corporate Strategy (1971), Dow Jones-Irwin, Inc, Homewood, IL
4. Ansoff I.H. Corporate Strategy (1965), McGraw-Hill, New York, NY
5. Ansoff H.I. Critique of Henry Mintzberg's "The design school: reconsidering the basic premises of strategic planning". Strategic Management Journal 12 6 (1991) 449-461
6. Ardichvili A., Cardozo R., and Ray S. A theory of entrepreneurial opportunity identification and development. Journal of Business Venturing 18 1 (2003) 105-123
7. Armstrong J.S. The value of formal planning for strategic decisions: review of empirical research. Strategic Management Journal 3 3 (1982) 197-211
8. Baker G.A. Strategic planning and financial performance in the food processing sector. Review of Agricultural Economics 25 2 (2003) 470-482
9. Baker T., Miner A.S., and Eesley D.T. Fake It until You Make It: Improvisation and New Ventures. Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research (2001), Babson College, Wellesley, MA
10. Barringer B.R., Jones F.F., and Neubaum D.O. A quantitative content analysis of the characteristics of rapid-growth firms and their founders. Journal of Business Venturing 20 5 (2005) 663-687
11. Berman J.A., Gordon D.D., and Sussman G. A study to determine the benefits small business firms derive from sophisticated planning versus less sophisticated types of planning. Journal of Business and Economic Studies 3 3 (1997) 1-11
12. Berry M. Strategic planning in small high tech companies. Long Range Planning 31 3 (1998) 455-466
13. Bhide A.V. The Origin and Evolution of New Businesses (2000), Oxford University Press, New York, NY
14. Bird B., and Jelinek M. The operation of entrepreneurial intentions. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 13 2 (1988) 21-29
15. Borenstein M., and Rothstein H. Comprehensive Meta Analysis (Version 2.0) (2007), Biostat, Englewood, NJ, USA
16. Boyd B.K. Strategic planning and financial performance: a meta-analysis review. Journal of Management Studies 28 4 (1991) 353-374
17. Boyd B.K., and Reuning-Elliott E. Research notes and communications: a measurement model of strategic planning. Strategic Management Journal 19 2 (1998) 181-192
18. Bracker J.S., and Pearson J.N. Planning and financial performance of small, mature firms. Strategic Management Journal 7 6 (1986) 503-522
19. Bracker J.S., Keats B.W., and Pearson J.N. Planning and financial performance among small firms in a growth industry. Strategic Management Journal 9 6 (1988) 591-603
20. Brews P.J., and Hunt M.R. Learning to plan and planning to learn: resolving the planning school/learning school debate. Strategic Management Journal 20 10 (1999) 889-913
21. Brinckmann, J., 2006. Competence of top management teams and the success of new technology-based firms - A theoretical and empirical analysis concerning competencies of entrepreneurial teams and the development of their ventures, Dissertation, Institute of Technology and Innovation Management. Berlin: Technical University Berlin.
22. Brinckmann J. Competence of top management teams and success of new technology-based firms (2007), Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag, Wiesbaden, Germany
23. Calori R., Véry P., and Arrègle J.-L. Les PMI face á la planification stratégique. Revue française de gestion 112 1 (1997) 11-23
24. Carter N.M., Gartner W.B., and Reynolds P.D. Exploring start-up event sequences. Journal of Business Venturing 11 3 (1996) 151-166
25. Castrogiovanni G.J. Pre-startup planning and the survival of new small businesses: theoretical linkages. Journal of Management 22 6 (1996) 801-822
26. Cooper A.C., Gimeno-Gascón F.J., and Woo C.Y. Initial human and financial capital as predictors of new venture performance. Journal of Business Venturing 9 5 (1994) 371-396
27. Cragg P.B., and King M. Organizational characteristics and small firms performance revisited. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 13 2 (1988) 48-64
28. Crusoe E.E. Planning in Small Firms: Extent and Effect, Wayne Huizenga Graduate School of Business and Entrepreneurship (2000), Nova Southeastern University, Fort Lauderdale, FL
29. Davidsson P. Researching Entrepreneurship (2004), Springer, Boston, MA
30. Davidsson P., and Honig B. The role of social and human capital among nascent entrepreneurs. Journal of Business Venturing 18 3 (2003) 301-331
31. Dean Jr. J.W., and Sharfman M.P. Does decision process matter? A study of strategic decision-making effectiveness. Academy of Management Journal 39 2 (1996) 368-396
32. Delmar F., and Shane S. Does business planning facilitate the development of new ventures?. Strategic Management Journal 24 12 (2003) 1165-1185
33. Forbes D.P. Reconsidering the strategic implications of decision comprehensiveness. Academy of Management Review 32 2 (2007) 361-376
34. Fredrickson J.W., and Mitchell T.R. Strategic decision processes: comprehensiveness and performance in an industry with an unstable environment. Academy of Management Journal 27 2 (1984) 399-423
35. Fredrickson J.W., and Iaquinto A.L. Inertia and creeping rationality in strategic decision processes. Academy of Management Journal 32 3 (1989) 516-542
36. French S.J., Kelly S.J., and Harrison J.L. The role of strategic planning in the performance of small, professional service firms - a research note. Journal of Management Development 23 8 (2004) 765-776
37. Frese M., Krauss S.I., Keith N., Escher S., Grabarkiewicz R., Luneng S.T., Heers C., Unger J., and Friedrich C. Business owners' action planning and its relationship to business success in three African countries. Journal of Applied Psychology 92 6 (2007) 1481
38. Gable M., and Topol M.T. Planning practices of small-scale retailers. American Journal of Small Business 12 2 (1987) 19-32
39. Gartner W.B. What are talking about when we talk about entrepreneurship?. Journal of Business Venturing 5 1 (1990) 15-28
40. Gartner W.B. Is there an elephant in entrepreneurship? Blind assumptions in theory development. Entrepreneurship: Theory & Practice 25 4 (2001) 27-40
41. Gartner W.B., and Liao J. Cents and Sense Making in Pre-venture Business Planning: Evidence from the Panel Study of Entrepreneurial Dynamics. Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research (2005), Babson College, Wellesley, MA
42. Gibson B., and Cassar G. Longitudinal analysis of relationships between planning and performance in small firms. Small Business Economics 25 (2005) 207-222
43. Goll I., and Rasheed A.M.A. Rational decision-making and firm performance: the moderating role of environment. Strategic Management Journal 18 7 (1997) 583-591
44. Gruber M. Uncovering the value of planning in new venture creation: a process and contingency perspective. Journal of Business Venturing 22 6 (2007) 782-807
45. Guzzo R.A., Jackson S.E., and Katzell R.A. Meta-analysis. In: Cummings L.L., and Staw B. (Eds). Research in Organizational Behavior (1987), JAI Press, Greenwich, CT
46. Haber S., and Reichel A. The cumulative nature of the entrepreneurial process: the contribution of human capital, planning and environment resources to small venture performance. Journal of Business Venturing 22 1 (2007) 119-145
47. Haveman. Between a rock and a hard place: organizational change and performance under conditions of fundamental environmental change. Administrative Science Quarterly 37 1 (1992) 48-75
48. Hedges L.V., and Olkin I. Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis (1985), Academic Press, San Diego, CA
49. Hills G. Variations in university entrepreneurship education: an empirical study of an evolving field. Journal of Business Venturing 3 2 (1988) 109-122
50. Hofstede G., and Hofstede G.J. Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind (2005), McGraw-Hill, New York, NY
51. Honig B. Entrepreneurship education: toward a model of contingency-based business planning. Academy of Management Learning & Education 3 3 (2004) 258-273
52. Honig B., and Karlsson T. Institutional forces and the written business plan. Journal of Management 30 1 (2004) 29-48
53. Hough J.R., and White M.A. Environmental dynamism and strategic decision making rationality: an examination at the decision level. Strategic Management Journal 24 5 (2003) 481-489
54. Hunter J.E., and Schmidt F.L. Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings (2004), Sage Publications Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA
55. Jones D. Characteristics of planning in small firms. Journal of Small Business Management 20 3 (1982) 15-19
56. Jungbauer-Gans M., and Preisendörfer P. Verbessern eine gründliche Vorbereitung und sorgfältige Planung die Erfolgschancen neugegründeter Betriebe? (Do in-depth preparation and careful planning improve survival chances of newly founded firms?). Schmalenbachs Zeitschrift für betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung 43 11 (1991) 987-996
57. Karlsson T., and Honig B. Norms Surrounding Business Plans and Their Effect on Entrepreneurial Behavior (2007), Babson College, Wellesley, MA
58. Kirkman B.L., Lowe K.B., and Gibson C.B. A quarter century of "Culture's Consequences": a review of empirical research incorporating Hofstede's cultural values framework. Journal of International Business Studies 37 3 (2006) 285-320
59. Lange J.E., Mollov A., Pearlmutter M., Singh S., and Bygrave W.D. Pre-start-up formal business plans and post-start-up performance: a study of 116 new ventures. Venture Capital 9 4 (2007) 237-256
60. Lipsey M.W., and Wilson D.B. Practical Meta-Analysis (2001), Sage Publications Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA
61. Lumpkin G.T., Shrader R.C., and Hills G.E. Does Formal Business Planning Enhance the Performance of New Ventures? Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research (1998), Babson College, Wellesley, MA
62. Matthews C.H. Small Firm Strategic Planning: Strategy, Environment, and Performance, Department of Management of the College of Business Administration (1990), University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH
63. Matthews C., and Scott S. Uncertainty and planning in small and entrepreneurial firms: an empirical assessment. Journal of Small Business Management 33 4 (1995) 34-52
64. McKiernan P., and Morris C. Strategic planning and financial performance in UK SMEs: does formality matter?. British Journal of Management 5 2 (1994) 31-41
65. McMullen J.S., and Shepherd D.A. Entrepreneurial action and the role of uncertainty in the theory of the entrepreneur. Academy of Management Review 31 1 (2006) 132-152
66. McSweeney B. Hofstede's model of national cultural differences and their consequences: a triumph of faith - a failure of analysis. Human Relations 55 1 (2002) 89-118
67. Miller D., and Friesen P.H. Strategy-making in context: ten empirical archetypes. Journal of Management Studies 14 3 (1977) 253-280
68. Miller D., and Toulouse J.-M. Strategy, structure, CEO personality and performance in small firms. American Journal of Small Business 10 3 (1986) 47-62
69. Miller C.C., and Cardinal L.B. Strategic planning an firm performance: a synthesis of more than two decades of research. Academy of Management Journal 37 6 (1994) 1649
70. Milliken F.J. Three types of perceived uncertainty about the environment: state, effect, and response uncertainty. Academy of Management Review 12 1 (1987) 133-143
71. Mintzberg H. The Rise and Fall of Strategic Planning (1994), The Free Press, New York, NY
72. Mintzberg H., and Waters J.A. Of strategies, deliberate and emergent. Strategic Management Journal 6 3 (1985) 257-272
73. Morrison D.F. Multivariate Statistical Methods (1990), McGraw-Hill Inc., NY
74. Mosakowski E. Strategy making under causal ambiguity: conceptual issues and empirical evidence. Organization Science 8 4 (1997) 414-442
75. Olson P.D., and Bokor D.W. Strategy process-content interaction: effects on growth performance in small, start-up firms. Journal of Small Business Management 33 1 (1995) 34-44
76. Orpen C. The effects of long-range planning on small business performance: a further examination. Journal of Small Business Management 23 1 (1985) 16-23
77. Orser B.J., Hogarth-Scott S., and Riding A.L. Performance, firm size, and management problem solving. Journal of Small Business Management 38 4 (2000) 42-58
78. Pearce J.A., Freeman E.B., and Robinson R.B. The tenuous link between formal strategic planning and financial performance. Academy of Management Review 12 4 (1987) 658-675
79. Pearce J.A., Robbins K., and Robinson R.B. The impact of grand strategy and planning formality on financial performance. Strategic Management Journal 8 2 (1987) 15-134
80. Penrose E.T. The Theory of the Growth of the Firm (1996), Oxford University Press, New York, NY
81. Perry S.C. The relationship between written business plans and the failure of small businesses in the U.S. Journal of Small Business Management 39 3 (2001) 201-208
82. Porter M.E. Competitive Advantage (1985), Free Press, Boston, MA
83. Powell T.C. Research notes and communications: strategic planning as competitive advantage. Strategic Management Journal 13 7 (1992) 551-558
84. Priem R.L., Rasheed A.M.A., and Kotulic A.G. Rationality in strategic decision process, environmental dynamism and firm performance. Journal of Management 21 5 (1995) 913-929
85. Quinn J. Strategies for Change: Logical Incrementalism (1980), Dow-Jones-Irwin, Homewood, IL
86. Ramanujam V., Venkatraman N., and Camillus J. Multi-objective assessment of effectiveness of strategic planning: a discriminant analysis approach. Academy of Management Journal 29 2 (1986) 347-372
87. Rauch A., and Frese M. A Contingency Approach to Small Scale Business Success: A Longitudinal Study on the Effects of Environmental Hostility and Uncertainty on the Relationship of Planning and Success (1998), Babson College, Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research, Wellesley, MA
88. Rauch A., and Frese M. Meta-analysis as a tool for developing entrepreneurship research and theory. In: Wiklund J., Dimov D., Katz J.A., and Shephard D. (Eds). Entrepreneurship: Frameworks and Empirical Investigations from Forthcoming Leaders of European Research. Advances in Entrepreneurship, Firm Emergence and Growth (2006), Elsevier, Amsterdam
89. Rauch A., Frese M., and Sonnentag S. Cultural differences in planning-success relationship: a comparison of small enterprises in Ireland, West Germany, and East Germany. Journal of Small Business Management 38 4 (2000) 28-41
90. Reynolds P.D., Hay M., Bygrave W.D., Camp S.M., and Autio E. Global Entrepreneurship Monitor: 2000 executive report. Wellesley, MA: Arthur M. Blank Centre for Entrepreneurship (2000) 1-59
91. Robinson Jr. R.B. The importance of "outsiders" in small firm strategic planning. Academy of Management Journal 25 1 (1982) 80-93
92. Robinson R.B., and Pearce J.A. The impact of formalized strategic planning on financial performance in small organizations. Strategic Management Journal 4 3 (1983) 197-207
93. Robinson R.B., and Pearce J.A. Research thrusts in small firm strategic planning. Academy Management Review 9 1 (1984) 128-137
94. Robinson Jr. R.B., Pearce J.A., Vozikis G.S., and Mescon T.S. The relationship between stage of development and small firm planning and performance. Journal of Small Business Management 22 2 (1984) 45-52
95. Rosenberg W., and Donald A. Evidence based medicine: an approach to clinical problem-solving. British Medical Journal 310 6987 (1995)
96. Rosenthal R. The "file drawer problem" and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin 86 1 (1979) 638-641
97. Rosenthal R. Meta-Analytic Procedures for Social Research (1984), Sage, Beverly Hills, CA
98. Rosenthal R., and DiMatteo M.R. Meta-analysis: recent developments in quantitative methods for literature research. Annual Review of Psychology 52 1 (2001) 59-82
99. Rue L.W., and Ibrahim N.A. The relationship between planning sophistication and performance in small firms. Journal of small business management 36 4 (1998) 24-32
100. Russell R., Atchison M., and Brooks R. Business plan competitions in tertiary institutions: encouraging entrepreneurship education. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 30 2 (2008) 123-138
101. Sarason Y., and Tegarden L.F. The erosion of the competitive advantage of strategic planning: a configuration theory and resource based view. Journal of Business and Management 9 1 (2003) 1-20
102. Sarasvathy S.D. Causation and effectuation: towards a theoretical shift from economic inevitability to entrepreneurial contingency. Academy of Management Review 26 2 (2001) 243-263
103. Sarasvathy S.D. Effectuation: Elements of Entrepreneurial Expertise (2007), Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd, Forthcoming
104. Sarasvathy S.D., Simon H., and Lave L. Perceiving and managing business risks: differences between entrepreneurs and bankers. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 33 (1998) 207-225
105. SBA. Table of Small Business Size Standards (2007), U.S. Small Business Administration. http://www.sba.gov/size Retrieved 12-27-2007 from http://www.sba.gov/size
106. Schneider S.C., and De Meyer A. Interpreting and responding to strategic issues: the impact of national culture. Strategic Management Journal 12 4 (1991) 307-320
107. Schwenk C.B., and Shrader C.B. Effects of formal strategic planning on financial performance in small firms: a meta-analysis. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 17 3 (1993) 53-64
108. Sexton D.L., and Auken P.V. A longitudinal study of small business strategic planning. Journal of Small Business Management 23 1 (1985) 7-15
109. Sexton D.L., and Bowman-Upton N. Entrepreneurship: Creativity and Growth (1991), Macmillan, New York, NY
110. Shane S. Cultural influences on national rates of innovation. Journal of Business Venturing 8 1 (1993) 59-73
111. Shea-Van Fossen R.J., Rothstein H.R., and Korn H.J. Thirty-five years of strategic planning and firm performance research: a meta-analysis. Academy of Management Proceedings (2006) 1-6
112. Shepherd D.A., Zacharakis A., and Baron R.A. VCs' decision processes - evidence suggesting more experience may not always be better. Journal of Business Venturing 18 3 (2003) 381-401
113. Shrader C.L., Mulford C.B., and Blackburn V.L. Strategic and operational planning, uncertainty, and performance in small firms. Journal of Small Business Management 27 4 (1989) 45-60
114. Shuman J.C., Sussman J., and Shaw G. Business Plans and the Start-up of Rapid Growth Companies (1985), Babson College, Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research, Wellesley, MA
115. Smith J.A. Strategies for start-ups. Long Range Planning 31 6 (1998) 857-872
116. Smith M.L., and Glass G.V. Meta-analysis of psychotherapies outcome studies. American Psychologist 32 9 (1977) 752-760
117. Stewart K.S. The Relationship between Strategic Planning and Growth in Small Firms, Wayne Huizenga School of Business and Entrepreneurship (2003), Nova Southeastern University, Fort Lauderdale, FL
118. Stinchcombe A.L. Social structure and organizations. In: March J.G. (Ed). Handbook of Organizations (1965), Rand McNally, Chicago, IL
119. Stone M.M., and Brush C.G. Planning in ambiguous contexts: the dilemma of meeting needs for commitment and demands for legitimacy. Strategic Management Journal 17 8 (1996) 633-652
120. Van Geldern M., Frese M., and Thurik R. Strategies, uncertainty and performance of small business startups. Small Business Economics 15 3 (2000) 164-181
121. Vesper K.H. New Venture Mechanics (1993), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
122. Wijewardena H., Zoysa A.D., Fonseka T., and Perera B. The impact of planning and control sophistication on performance of small and medium-sized enterprises: evidence from Sri Lanka. Journal of Small Business Management 42 2 (2004) 209-217
123. Wiltbank R., Dew N., Read S., and Sarasvathy S.D. What to do next? The case for non-predictive strategy. Strategic Management Journal 27 10 (2006) 981-998
124. Yusuf A., and Saffu K. Planning and performance of small and medium enterprise operators in a country in transition. Journal of Small Business Management 43 4 (2005) 480-497
125. Zahra S. Technology strategy and new venture performance: a study of corporate-sponsored and independent. Journal of Business Venturing 11 4 (1996) 289
126. Ziegler R., Preisendörfer P., and Wilsdorf S.H. Leipzig founder study: self-employment in the newly-formed German states. GESIS-ZA Central Archive for Empirical Social Research, Cologne, Germany (1995)