A meta-analysis of mini-open versus standard open and laparoscopic living donor nephrectomy

Transplant International

Volumn 22, Issue 4, 2009, Pages 463-474

  Antcliffe, David ^b   Nanidis, Theodore G ^b   Darzi, Ara W ^b   Tekkis, Paris P ^b   Papalois, Vassilios E ^a  

^a HAMMERSMITH HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^b ST MARY S HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Laparoscopy; Meta analysis; Minimal incision; Nephrectomy; Open; Renal transplantation

Indexed keywords

MORPHINE;

ANALGESIA; ARTICLE; BLEEDING; CLINICAL TRIAL; GRAFT SURVIVAL; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY; LENGTH OF STAY; LIVING DONOR; META ANALYSIS; NEPHRECTOMY; OPERATION DURATION; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; URETER DISEASE; WORK RESUMPTION;

HUMANS; LAPAROSCOPY; LIVING DONORS; NEPHRECTOMY;

EID: 61849087765     PISSN: 09340874     EISSN: 14322277     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1432-2277.2008.00828.x     Document Type: Article

References (73)

1. Ratner LE, Ciseck LJ, Moore RG, Cigarroa FG, Kaufman HS, Kavoussi LR. Laparoscopic live donor nephrectomy. Transplantation 1995 60 : 1047.
2. United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS). 1996 Annual Report of the U.S Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients and the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network: Transplant Data: 1988-1995. Richmond, VA : UNOS, 1996.
3. Harper AM, Taranto SE, Edwards EB. The OPTN waiting list, 1988-2001. In : Cecka JM, Teasaki PI, eds. Clinical Transplantation. Los Angeles : UCLA Tissue Typical Laboratory, 2002 : 79 92.
4. Tooher RL, Rao MM, Scott DF, et al. A systematic review of laparoscopic live-donor nephrectomy. Transplantation 2004 78 : 404.
5. Merlin TL, Scott DF, Rao MM, et al. The safety and efficacy of laparoscopic live donor nephrectomy: a systematic review. Transplantation 2000 70 : 1659.
6. Nogueira JM, Cangro CB, Fink JC, et al. A comparison of recipient renal outcomes with laparoscopic versus open live donor nephrectomy. Transplantation 1999 67 : 722.
7. Kok NF, Lind MY, Hansson BM, et al. Comparison of laparoscopic and mini incision open donor nephrectomy: single blind, randomized controlled clinical trial. BMJ 2006 333 : 221.
8. Clarke M, Horton R. Bringing it all together: Lancet-Cochrane collaborate on systematic reviews. Lancet 2001 357 : 1728.
9. Stroup DF, Berlin JA, Morton SC, et al. Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology: a proposal for reporting. Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology (MOOSE) group. JAMA 2000 283 : 2008.
10. Hozo SP, Djulbegovic B, Hozo I. Estimating the mean and variance from the median, range, and size of a sample. BMC Med Res Methodol 2005 5 : 13.
11. DerSimonian R, Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials 1986 7 : 177.
12. Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M, Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 1997 315 : 629.
13. Yusuf S, Peto R, Lewis J, Collins R, Sleight P. Beta blockade during and after myocardial infarction: an overview of the randomized trials. Prog Cardiovasc Dis 1985 27 : 335.
14. Mantel N, Haenszel W. Statistical aspects of the analysis of data from retrospective studies of disease. J Natl Cancer Inst 1959 22 : 719.
15. Athanasiou T, Al-Ruzzeh S, Kumar P, et al. Off-pump myocardial revascularization is associated with less incidence of stroke in elderly patients. Ann Thorac Surg 2004 77 : 745.
16. Egger M, Smith GD. Misleading meta-analysis. BMJ 1995 311 : 753.
17. Melcher ML, Carter JT, Posselt A, et al. More than 500 consecutive laparoscopic donor nephrectomies without conversion or repeated surgery. Arch Surg 2005 140 : 835.
18. Salgado OJ, Chacon RE, Urdaneta B, Rosales BC, Garcia R. Complications of minimal incision open nephrectomy in living donors. Nephrol Dial Transplant 2005 20 : 1772.
19. Suzuki K, Ushiyama T, Ishikawa A, et al. Clinical experience with laparoscopy-assisted live donor nephrectomy. Hippon Hinyokika Gakkai Zasshi 1996 87 : 748.
20. Schnitzbauer AA, Loss M, Hornung M, et al. Pararectal mini-incision for strictly retroperitoneal nephrectomy in living kidney donation. Urologe A 2006 45 : 1170.
21. Shenoy S, Lowell JA, Ramachandran A, Jendrisak M. The ideal living donor nephrectomy "mini-nephrectomy" through a posterior transcostal approach. J Am Coll Surg 2002 194 : 240.
22. Hemal AK, Singh I. Minimally invasive retroperitoneoscopic live donor nephrectomy: point of technique. Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech 2001 11 : 341.
23. Yang SC, Rha KH, Kim YS, Kim SI, Park K. Retroperitoneoscopy-assisted living donor nephrectomy: 109 cases. Transplant Proc 2001 33 : 1104.
24. Yang SC, Park DS, Lee DH, Lee JM, Park K. Retroperitoneal endoscopic live donor nephrectomy: report of 3 cases. J Urol 1995 153 : 1884.
25. Jones KW, Peters TG, Walker GW. Anterior-retroperitoneal living donor nephrectomy: techniques and outcomes. Am Surg 1999 65 : 197.
26. Repassy DL, Frang D, Kopa Z, Jako GJ. Retractorscopic nephrectomy: initial report. Int Urol Nephrol 1996 28 : 465.
27. Kumar A, Dubey D, Gogoi S, Arvind NK. Laparoscopy-assisted live donor nephrectomy; A modified cost-effective approach for developing countries. J Endourol 2002 16 : 155.
28. Lind MY, Liem YS, Bemelman WA, et al. Live donor nephrectomy and return to work: does the operative tequnique matter? Surg Endosc 2003 17 : 591.
29. Iinuma M, Satoh S, Tsuchiya N, et al. Retroperitoneoscopic hand-assisted nephrectomy for live donor: Akita University experience. Nippon Hinyokika Gakkai Zasshi 2002 93 : 721.
30. Bayazit Y, Aridogan IA, Tansug Z, Unsal I, Erken U. Morbidity of flank incision in 100 renal donors. Int Urol Nephrol 2001 32 : 709.
31. Ottelin MC, Bueschen AJ, Lloyd LK, Joseph DB, Diethelm AG, Burns JR. Review of 333 living donor nephrectomies. South Med J 1994 87 : 61.
32. Peyromaure M, Cappele O, Desgrandchamps F, et al. Kidney harvesting in living donors with manually assisted laparoscopy; technique and results. Prog Urol 2000 10 : 1127.
33. Borer JG, Cisek LJ, Atala A, Diamond DA, Retik AB, Peters CA. Pediatric retroperitoneoscopic nephrectomy using 2 mm instrumentation. J Urol 1999 162 : 1725.
34. Hoznek A, Olsson LE, Salomon L, et al. Retroperitoneal laparoscopic living -donor nephrectomy. Preliminary results. Eur Urol 2001 40 : 614.
35. Ratner LE, Kavoussi LR, Sroka M, et al. Laparoscopic assisted live donor nephrectomy: a comparison with the open approach. Transplantation 1997 63 : 229.
36. Montgomery RA, Kavoussi LR, Su L, et al. Improved recipient results after 5 years of performing laparoscopic donor nephrectomy. Transplant Proc 2001 33 : 1108.
37. Redman JF. An anterior extraperitoneal incision for donor nephrectomy that spares the rectus abdominis muscle and anterior abdominal wall nerves. J Urol 2000 164 : 1898.
38. Greenstein MA, Harkaway R, Badosa F, Ginsberg P, Yang SL. Minimal incision living donor nephrectomy compared to the hand-assisted laparoscopic living donor nephrectomy. World J Urol 2003 20 : 356.
39. Mital D, Coogan CL, Jensik SC. Microinvasive donor nephrectomy. Transplant Proc 2003 35 : 835.
40. Kumar A, Zaman W, Srivastava A, Tripathi DM. A prospective comparison of three techniques of live donor nephrectomy: can mini flank incision be an alternative to laparoscopic surgery. J Urol 2002 167 : 21.
41. Smith JA Jr. Anterior extra peritoneal approach for living donor nephrectomy. Contemp Urol 1992 4 : 12.
42. Yang SC, Ryu JK, Kha KH. Gasless laparoscopy-assisted extraperitoneal surgery in urology. J Endourol 1996 10 : 186.
43. Srivastava A, Tripathi DM, Zaman W, Kumar A. Subcostal versus transcostal mini donor nephrectomy: is rib resection responsible for pain related donor morbidity. J Urol 2003 170 : 738.
44. Kok NFM, Alwayn IPJ, Hansson BME, et al. A blinded, multicenter, randomized controlled trial of laparoscopic versus mini-incision open donor nephrectomy. American Journal of Transplantation 2006 6 (S2 450 Abs 1138.
45. Nicholson ML, Brook NR, Elwell R, et al. Randomised controlled trial of open versus laparoscopic live donor nephrectomy. American Journal of Transplantation 2006 6 (S2 798 Abs 2214.
46. Perry KT, Freedland SJ, Hu JC, et al. Quality of life, pain and return to normal activities following laparoscopic donor nephrectomy versus open mini-incision donor nephrectomy. J Urol 2003 169 : 2018.
47. Schnitzbauer AA, Hornung M, Seidel U, et al. Does mini-incision donor nephrectomy improve quality of life in living kidney donors? Clin Transplant 2007 21 : 235.
48. Byun YJ, Yang SC. Laparoscopy-assisted urologic surgery through mini-laparoscopy. Yonsei Med J 1999 40 : 596.
49. th rib incision for open partial or radical nephrectomy. BJU Int 2006 97 : 149.
50. th rib incision for open partial or radical nephrectomy. BJU Int 2006 97 : 867.
51. th rib incision for open partial or radical nephrectomy. BJU Int 2006 98 : 690.
52. Kok NF, Alwayn IP, Tran KT, Hop WC, Weimar W, Ijzermans JN. Psychosocial and physical impairment after mini-incision open and laparoscopic donor nephrectomy: a prospective study. Clin Transplant 2006 82 : 1291.
53. Suzuki K, Ushiyama T, Ishikawa A, Mugiya S, Fujita K. Retroperitoneoscopy assisted live donor nephrectomy: initial 2 cases. J Urol 1997 158 : 1353.
54. Neipp M, Jackobs S, Becker T, et al. Living donor nephrectomy: flank incision versus anterior vertical mini-incision. Transplantation 2004 78 : 1356.
55. Jackobs S, Becker T, Lück R, et al. Quality of life following living donor nephrectomy comparing classical flank incision and anterior vertical mini-incision. World J Urol 2005 23 : 343.
56. Kok NF, Alwayn IP, Lind MY, Tran KT, Weimar W, IJzermans JN. Donor nephrectomy; mini-incision muscle-splitting open approach versus laparoscopy. Transplantation 2006 81 : 881.
57. Kok NF, Lind MY, Hansson BM, et al. Donor nephrectomy: less fatigue and better quality of life following laparoscopic kidney removal compared with an open procedure by mini-incision: blind randomised study. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd 2007 151 : 1352.
58. Watanabe R, Saitoh K, Kurumada S, Komeyama T, Takahashi K. Gasless laparoscopy-assisted live donor nephrectomy. Transplant Proc 2002 34 : 2578.
59. Watanabe R, Saitoh K, Kurumada S, Komeyama T, Tsutsui T, Takahashi K. Gasless laparoscopy-assisted live donor nephrectomy. Nippon Hinyokika Gakkai Zasshi 2002 93 : 627.
60. Ishikawa A, Suzuki K, Saisu K, Kageyama S, Ushiyama T, Fujita K. Endoscopy-assisted live donor nephrectomy: comparison between laparoscopic and retroperitoneoscopic procedures. Transplant Proc 1998 30 : 165.
61. Suzuki K, Ishikawa A, Ushiyama T, Ohta N, Suzuki A, Fujita K. Gasless laparoscopy-assisted live donor nephrectomy; the initial 23 cases. Transplant Proc 2000 32 : 788.
62. Yang SC, Ko WJ, Byun YJ, Rha KH. Retroperitoneoscopy assisted live donor nephrectomy: the Yonsei experience. J Urol 2001 165 : 1099.
63. Lewis GRR, Brook NR, Waller JR, Bains JC, Veitch PS, Nicholson ML. A comparison of traditional open, minimal-incision donor nephrectomy and laparoscopic donor nephrectomy. Transpl Int 2004 17 : 589.
64. Morrissey PE, Gautam A, Amaral JF, Monaco AP. Keeping up with the Jones's: open donor nephrectomy in the laparoscopic era. Transplant Proc 2004 36 : 1285.
65. Yang SL, Harkaway R, Badosa F, Ginsberg P, Greenstein MA. Minimal incision living donor nephrectomy: improvement in patient outcome. Urology 2002 59 : 673.
66. Kok NF, Alwayn IP, Schouten O, Tran KT, Weimar W, Ijzermans JN. Mini-incision open donor nephrectomy as an alternative to classic lumbotomy: evolution of the open approach. Transpl Int 2006 19 : 500.
67. Kumar A, Tripathi DM, Srivastava A. Mini incision live donor nephrectomy; an optimal approach for the developing countries. Clin Transplant 2003 17 : 498.
68. Schnitzbauer AA, Loss M, Hornung M, et al. Mini-incision for strictly retroperitoneal nephrectomy in living kidney donation vs flank incision. Nephrol Dial Transplant 2006 21 : 2948.
69. Muthu C, McCall J, Windsor J, et al. The Auckland experience with laparoscopic donor nephrectomy. N Z Med J 2003 116 : U516.
70. Berends FJ, den Hoed PT, Bonjer HJ, et al. Technical considerations and pitfalls in laparoscopic live donornephrectomy. Surg Endosc 2002 16 : 893.
71. Rawlins MC, Hefty TL, Brown SL, Biehl TR. Learning laparoscopic donor nephrectomy safely. Arch Surg 2002 137 : 531.
72. Seo SI, Kim JC, Hwangbo K, Park YH, Hwang TK. Comparison of hand-assisted laparoscopic and open donor nephrectomy: a single-center experience from South Korea. J Endourol 2005 19 : 58.
73. Tanabe K, Miyamoto N, Tokumoto T, et al. Retroperitoneoscopic live donor nephrectomy: extended experience in a single center. Transplant Proc 2004 36 : 1917.