Ecological Equivalence Assessment Methods: What Trade-Offs between Operationality, Scientific Basis and Comprehensiveness?

Environmental Management

Volumn 60, Issue 2, 2017, Pages 216-230

  Bezombes, Lucie ^a,b   Gaucherand, Stéphanie ^a   Kerbiriou, Christian ^c   Reinert, Marie Eve ^d   Spiegelberger, Thomas ^a  

^a UNIV GRENOBLE ALPES   (France)

^b EDF R AND D   (France)

^c MUSÉUM NATIONAL D'HISTOIRE NATURELLE   (France)

^d KARLSRUHE INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (Germany)

Author keywords

Biodiversity offset; Compensation; Ecological equivalence; Ecological equivalence assessment methods; Mitigation hierarchy; No net loss

Indexed keywords

BIODIVERSITY; COMMERCE; COMPENSATION (PERSONNEL); ECOLOGY; ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL EFFECTS; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

DEVELOPMENT PROJECT; ECOLOGICAL EQUIVALENCE; ECOLOGICAL EQUIVALENCE ASSESSMENT METHODS; ECOLOGICAL MEASURES; GENERAL STRUCTURES; LANDSCAPE CONTEXT; MITIGATION HIERARCHY; NO NET LOSS;

EQUIVALENCE CLASSES;

ASSESSMENT METHOD; BIODIVERSITY; COMPENSATION; DEVELOPMENT PROJECT; ECOLOGICAL IMPACT; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; SYNERGISM; TRADE-OFF;

ACHIEVEMENT; BIODIVERSITY; COMPENSATION; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LANDSCAPE; UNCERTAINTY; ECOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; PROCEDURES;

BIODIVERSITY; CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; ECOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING;

EID: 85019143463     PISSN: 0364152X     EISSN: 14321009     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00267-017-0877-5     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. Anderson P (1995) Ecological restoration and creation: a review. Biol J Linnean Soc 56:187–211
2. Andreasen JK, O’Neill RV, Noss R, Slosser NC (2001) Considerations for the development of a terrestrial index of ecological integrity. Ecol Indic 1:21–35
3. Bas A, Jacob C, Hay J, Pioch S, Thorin S (2016) Improving marine biodiversity offsetting: A proposed methodology for better assessing losses and gains. J Environ Manage 175:46–59
4. Beier P, Noss RF (1998) Do habitat corridors provide connectivity? Conser Biol 12:1241–1252
5. Bekessy SA, Wintle BA, Lindenmayer DB, McCarthy MA, Colyvan M, Burgman MA, Possingham HP (2010) The biodiversity bank cannot be a lending bank. Conser Lett 3:151–158
6. Bensettiti F, Puissauve R, Lepareur F, Touroult J, Maciejewski L (2012) Evaluation de l’état de conservation des habitats et des espèces d’intérêt communautaire–Guide méthodologique–DHFF article 17, 2007 - 2012. Version 1–Février 2012. Rapport SPN 2012-27. Service du patrimoine naturel, Mus Natl Hist Nat, Paris, 76 p.+annexes
7. Biggs R, Reyers B, Scholes RJ (2006) A biodiversity intactness score for South Africa. S Afr J Sci 102:277
8. Boulton AJ (1999) An overview of river health assessment: philosophies, practice, problems and prognosis. Freshw Biol 41:469–479
9. Brownlie S, Botha M (2009) Biodiversity offsets: adding to the conservation estate, or ‘no net loss’? Impact Assess Proj Appraisal 27:227–231
10. Bruggeman DJ, Jones ML, Lupi F, Scribner KT (2005) Landscape equivalency analysis: Methodology for estimating spatially explicit biodiversity credits. Environ Manage 36:518
11. Bull JW, Hardy MJ, Moilanen A, Gordon A (2015) Categories of flexibility in biodiversity offsetting, and their implications for conservation. Biol Conserv 192:522–532
12. Bull JW, Milner-Gulland EJ, Suttle KB, Singh NJ (2014) Comparing biodiversity offset calculation methods with a case study in Uzbekistan. Biol Conserv 178:2–10
13. Bull JW, Suttle KB, Gordon A, Singh NJ, Milner-Gulland EJ (2013) Biodiversity offsets in theory and practice. Oryx 47:369–380
14. Burrows L (2014). Somerset habitat evaluation procedure methodology. Somerset County Council
15. Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme (BBOP) (2009) Biodiversity Offset Design Handbook: Appendices. BBOP, Washington, DC
16. Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme (BBOP) (2012a) Biodiversity Offset Design Handbook Updated. BBOP, Washington, DC
17. Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme (BBOP) (2012b) Resource Paper: No Net Loss and Loss‐Gain Calculations in Biodiversity Offsets. BBOP, Washington, DC
18. Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme (BBOP) (2014a) Working towards NNL of Biodiversity and Beyond: Ambatovy, Madagascar–A Case Study. BBOP, Washington, DC
19. Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme (BBOP) (2014b) Working towards NNL of Biodiversity and Beyond: Strongman Mine–A Case Study. BBOP, Washington, DC
20. California Wetlands Monitoring Workgroup (CWMW) (2013). California Rapid Assessment Method (CRAM) for Wetlands Version 6.1. 67
21. Cochrane JF, Lonsdorf E, Allison TD, Sanders-Reed CA (2015) Modeling with uncertain science: estimating mitigation credits from abating lead poisoning in Golden Eagles. Ecol Appl 25:1518–1533
22. Commissariat Général au Développement Durable (CGDD) (2012). La compensation des atteintes à la biodiversité à l'étranger–Etude de parangonnage. Collection « Études et documents » du Service de l’Économie, de l’Évaluation et de l’Intégration du Développement Durable (SEEIDD) du Commissariat Général au Développement Durable (CGDD)
23. Cuperus R, Bakermans MMGJ, Udo de Haes HA, Canters KJ (2001) Ecological compensation in Dutch highways planning. Environ Manage 27:75–89
24. Curran M, Hellweg S, Beck J (2013) Is there any empirical support for biodiversity offset policy? Ecol Appl 24:617–632
25. Darbi M. & Tausch C. (2010). Loss-Gain calculations in German Impact Mitigation Regulation. Occasional paper contributed to BBOP
26. Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs D (2012) Biodiversity Offsetting Pilots Technical Paper the metric for the biodiversity offsetting pilot in England. Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs (DREFA), London
27. Duel H, Specken BPM, Denneman WD, Kwakernaak C (1995) The habitat evaluation procedure as a tool for ecological rehabilitation of wetlands in The Netherlands. Water Sci Technol 31:387–391
28. Dunford RW, Ginn TC, Desvousges WH (2004) The use of habitat equivalency analysis in natural resource damage assessments. Ecol Econ 48:49–70
29. (EEC) E.E.C. (1992) Council Directive 92/43/EEC of 21 May 1992 on the conservation of natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora. Off J Eur Union 206:7–50
30. (EEC) E.E.C. (2009) Directive 2009/147/EC of the european parliament and of the council of 30 november 2009 on the conservation of wild birds on the conservation of wild birds (codified version). Off J L20:7–25
31. Foltête J-C, Clauzel C, Vuidel G (2012) A software tool dedicated to the modelling of landscape networks. Environ Model Softw 38:316–327
32. Freckleton RP (2002) On the misuse of residuals in ecology: regression of residuals vs. multiple regression. J Animal Ecol 71:542–545
33. Gardner TA, Von Hase A, Brownlie S, Ekstrom JMM, Pilgrim JD, Savy CE, Stephens RTT, Treweek J, Ussher GT, Ward G, Ten Kate K (2013) Biodiversity offsets and the challenge of achieving no net loss. Conser Biol 27:1254–1264
34. Gaucherand S, Schwoertzig E, Clement JC, Johnson B, Quetier F (2015) The cultural dimensions of freshwater wetland assessments: lessons learned from the application of US rapid assessment methods in France. Environ Manage 56(1):245–259
35. Gibbons P, Briggs SV, Ayers D, Seddon J, Doyle S, Cosier P, McElhinny C, Pelly V, Roberts K (2009) An operational method to assess impacts of land clearing on terrestrial biodiversity. Ecol Indic 9:26–40
36. Gibbons P, Lindenmayer DB (2007) Offsets for land clearing: No net loss or the tail wagging the dog? Ecol Manage Restor 8:26–31
37. Gonçalves B, Marques A, Soares AMVDM, Pereira HM (2015) Biodiversity offsets: from current challenges to harmonized metrics. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 14:61–67
38. Gordon A, Bull JW, Wilcox C, Maron M (2015) Perverse incentives risk undermining biodiversity offset policies. J Appl Ecol 52:532–537
39. Hooper DU, Adair EC, Cardinale BJ, Byrnes JE, Hungate BA, Matulich KL, O’Connor MI (2012) A global synthesis reveals biodiversity loss as a major driver of ecosystem change. Nature 486(7401):105–108
40. Husson F, Josse J, Le S, Mazet J, Husson MF (2015) Package ‘FactoMineR’
41. Jaunatre R, Buisson E, Dutoit T (2014) Can ecological engineering restore Mediterranean rangeland after intensive cultivation? A large-scale experiment in southern France. Ecol Eng 64:202–212
42. Kiesecker JM, Copeland H, Pocewicz A, Nibbelink N, McKenney B, Dahlke J, Holloran M, Stroud D (2009) A Framework for Implementing Biodiversity Offsets: Selecting Sites and Determining Scale. BioScience 59:77–84
43. Koen EL, Bowman J, Sadowski C, Walpole AA (2014) Landscape connectivity for wildlife: development and validation of multispecies linkage maps. Methods Ecol Evol 5:626–633
44. Laitila J, Moilanen A, Pouzols FM (2014) A method for calculating minimum biodiversity offset multipliers accounting for time discounting, additionality and permanence. Methods Ecol Evol 5:1247–1254
45. Laycock HF, Moran D, Raffaelli DG, White PCL (2013) Biological and operational determinants of the effectiveness and efficiency of biodiversity conservation programs. Wildlife Res 40:142–152
46. Levrel H, Pioch S, Spieler R (2012) Compensatory mitigation in marine ecosystems: which indicators for assessing the “no net loss” goal of ecosystem services and ecological functions? Marine Policy 36:1202–1210
47. Madsen B, Moore Brands K, Carroll N (2010). State of biodiversity markets: offset and compensation programs worldwide
48. Maron M, Dunn PK, McAlpine CA, Apan A, Maron M, Dunn PK, McAlpine CA, Apan A, Maron M, Dunn PK, McAlpine CA, Apan A (2010) Can offsets really compensate for habitat removal? The case of the endangered red-tailed black-cockatoo. J Appl Ecol 47:348
49. Maron M, Hobbs RJ, Moilanen A, Matthews JW, Christie K, Gardner TA, Keith DA, Lindenmayer DB, McAlpine CA (2012) Faustian bargains? Restoration realities in the context of biodiversity offset policies. Biol Conserv 155:141–148
50. McCarthy MA, Parris KM, Van Der Ree R, McDonnell MJ, Burgman MA, Williams NSG, McLean N, Harper MJ, Meyer R, Hahs A, Coates T (2004) The habitat hectares approach to vegetation assessment: an evaluation and suggestions for improvement. Ecol Manage Restor 5:24–27
51. McKenney B, Kiesecker J (2010) Policy development for biodiversity offsets: a review of offset frameworks. Environ Manage 45:165–176
52. Meineri E, Deville AS, Gremillet D, Gauthier-Clerc M, Bechet A (2015) Combining correlative and mechanistic habitat suitability models to improve ecological compensation. Biol Rev 90:314–329
53. Minns CK, Moore JE, Stoneman M, Cudmore-Vokey B (2001) Defensible methods of assessing fish habitat: lacustrine habitats in the great lakes basin-conceptual basis and approach using a habitat suitability matrix (hsm) method. Canadian Manuscript Report of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 2559
54. Moilanen A, Van Teeffelen AJA, Ben-Haim Y, Ferrier S (2009) How much compensation is enough? A framework for incorporating uncertainty and time discounting when calculating offset ratios for impacted habitat. Restor Ecol 17:470–478
55. NOAA (1995) Habitat equivalency analysis: An overview. Prepared by the damage assessment and restoration program, March 21st 1995. Revised October 4th 2000. NOAA, Washington, DC
56. NOAA (1997) Scaling compensatory restoration action: Guidance document for natural resource damage assessment under the Oil Pollution Act of 1990. Damage Assessment and Restoration Program. NOAA, Washington, DC
57. Norton DA (2009) Biodiversity offsets: two New Zealand case studies and an assessment framework. Environ Manage 43:698–706
58. Noss RF (1990) Indicators for monitoring biodiversity: a hierarchical approach. Conserv Biol 4(4):355–364
59. Parkes D, Newell G, Cheal D (2003) Assessing the quality of native vegetation: The ‘habitat hectares’ approach. Ecol Manage Restor 4:S29–S38
60. Pereira HM, Ferrier S, Walters M, Geller GN, Jongman RHG, Scholes RJ, Bruford MW, Brummitt N, Butchart SHM, Cardoso AC, Coops NC, Dulloo E, Faith DP, Freyhof J, Gregory RD, Heip C, Höft R, Hurtt G, Jetz W, Karp DS, McGeoch MA, Obura D, Onoda Y, Pettorelli N, Reyers B, Sayre R, Scharlemann JPW, Stuart SN, Turak E, Walpole M, Wegmann M (2013) Essential biodiversity variables. Science 339:277–278
61. Pöll CE, Willner W, Wrbka T (2016) Challenging the practice of biodiversity offsets: ecological restoration success evaluation of a large-scale railway project. Landsc Ecol Eng 12(1):85–97
62. Quétier F, Lavorel S (2011) Assessing ecological equivalence in biodiversity offset schemes: Key issues and solutions. Biol Conserv 144:2991–2999
63. Quétier F, Regnery B, Levrel H (2014) No net loss of biodiversity or paper offsets? A critical review of the French no net loss policy. Environ Sci Policy 38:120–131
64. Race MS, Fonseca MS (1996) Fixing compensatory mitigation: what will it take? Ecol Appl 6:94–101
65. Regnery B, Couvet D, Kerbiriou C (2013a) Offsets and conservation of the species of the eu habitats and birds directives. Conserv Biol 27(6):1335–1343
66. Regnery B, Kerbiriou C, Julliard R, Vandevelde JC, Le Viol I, Burylo M, Couvet D (2013b) Sustain common species and ecosystem functions through biodiversity offsets: response to Pilgrim et al. Conserv Lett 6:385–386
67. Regnery B, Couvet D, Kubarek L, Julien J-F, Kerbiriou C (2013c) Tree microhabitats as indicators of bird and bat communities in Mediterranean forests. Ecol Indic 34:221–230
68. Roach B, Wade WW (2006) Policy evaluation of natural resource injuries using habitat equivalency analysis. Ecol Econ 58:421–433
69. Saenz S, Walschburger T, Gonzalez JC, Leon J, McKenney B, Kiesecker J (2013) A framework for implementing and valuing biodiversity offsets in colombia: a landscape scale perspective. Sustainability 5:4961–4987
70. Sala OE, Stuart Chapin III F, Armesto JJ, Berlow E, Bloomfield J, Dirzo R, Huber-Sanwald E, Huenneke LF, Jackson RB, Kinzig A, Leemans R, Lodge DM, Mooney HA, Oesterheld Mn, Poff NL, Sykes MT, Walker BH, Walker M, Wall DH (2000) Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100. Science 287:1770–1774
71. Specht A, Guru S, Houghton L, Keniger L, Driver P, Ritchie EG, Lai K, Treloar A (2015) Data management challenges in analysis and synthesis in the ecosystem sciences. Sci Total Environ 534:144–158
72. State of Florida (2004). F-DEP UMAM Chapter 62–345
73. ten Kate K, Bishop J, Bayon R (2004) Biodiversity offsets: Views, experience, and the business case. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK and Insight Investment, London, UK
74. Tischew S, Baasch A, Conrad MK, Kirmer A (2010) Evaluating Restoration Success of Frequently Implemented Compensation Measures: Results and Demands for Control Procedures. Restor Ecol 18:467–480
75. Tischew S, Kirmer A (2007) Implementation of Basic Studies in the Ecological Restoration of Surface‐Mined Land. Restor Ecol 15:321–325
76. Treweek J, Butcher B, Temple H (2010) Biodiversity offsets: possible methods for measuring biodiversity losses and gains for use in the UK. Practice 69:29–32
77. US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) (1980). Habitat Evaluation Procedure
78. Virah-Sawmy M, Ebeling J, Taplin R (2014) Mining and biodiversity offsets: A transparent and science-based approach to measure “no-net-loss”. J Environ Manage 143:61–70
79. Vitousek PM, Mooney HA, Lubchenco J, Melillo JM (1997) Human Domination of Earth’s Ecosystems. Science 277:494–499
80. Wende W, Herberg A, Herzberg A (2005) Mitigation banking and compensation pools: improving the effectiveness of impact mitigation regulation in project planning procedures. Impact Assess Proj Appraisal 23:101–111
81. Walker KJ, Stevens PA, Stevens DP, Mountford JO, Manchester SJ, Pywell RF (2004) The restoration and re-creation of species-rich lowland grassland on land formerly managed for intensive agriculture in the UK. Biol Conserv 119:1–18