Modeling with uncertain science: Estimating mitigation credits from abating lead poisoning in Golden Eagles

Ecological Applications

Volumn 25, Issue 6, 2015, Pages 1518-1533

  Cochrane, Jean Fitts ^a,c   Lonsdorf, Eric ^b   Allison, Taber D ^a   Sanders Reed, Carol A ^a,c  

^a American Wind Energy Association   (United States)

^b FRANKLIN AND MARSHALL COLLEGE   (United States)

^c 29 Wood Mountain Road ^*  (United States)

Author keywords

Aquila chrysaetos; Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act; Compensatory mitigation; Decisions in response to uncertainty; Expert opinion; Incidental take; Lead abatement; Lead poisoning; Modeling with uncertainty; Simulation model

Indexed keywords

ABATEMENT COST; ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT; CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT; DECISION MAKING; ECOLOGICAL IMPACT; EXPERT SYSTEM; LEAD; MORTALITY; POISONING; RAPTOR; RENEWABLE RESOURCE; RISK ASSESSMENT; SPECIES CONSERVATION; STOCHASTICITY; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

UNITED STATES; WYOMING;

AQUILA; AQUILA CHRYSAETOS;

LEAD; POLLUTANT;

ANIMAL; BIOLOGICAL MODEL; COMPUTER SIMULATION; EAGLE; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; LEAD POISONING; POLLUTANT; TOXICITY; UNCERTAINTY; VETERINARY;

ANIMALS; COMPUTER SIMULATION; EAGLES; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTANTS; LEAD; LEAD POISONING; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL; UNCERTAINTY;

EID: 84941203934     PISSN: None     EISSN: 19395582     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1890/14-0996.1     Document Type: Article

References (65)

1. Ayyub, B. M. 2001. Elicitation of expert opinions for uncertainty and risks. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, USA.
2. BBOP (Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme). 2012. Standard on biodiversity offsets. Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme, Washington, D.C., USA.
3. Bedrosian, B., D. Craighead, and R. Crandall. 2012. Lead exposure in Bald Eagles from big game hunting, the continental implications and successful mitigation efforts. PLoS ONE 7(12):e51978.
4. Beissinger, S. R., and M. I. Westphal. 1998. On the use of demographic models of population viability in endangered species management. Journal of Wildlife Management 62:821-841.
5. Bull, J. W., E. J. Milner-Gulland, K. B. Suttle, and N. J. Singh. 2014. Comparing biodiversity offset calculation methods with a case study in Uzbekistan. Biological Conservation 178:2-10.
6. Bull, J. W., K. B. Suttle, A. Gordon, N. J. Singh, and E. J. Milner-Gulland. 2013. Biodiversity offsets in theory and practice. Oryx 47(3):369-380.
7. Burgman, M. A. 2005. Risks and decisions for conservation and environmental management. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
8. Burgman, M. A., S. Ferson, and H. R. Akcakaya. 1993. Risk assessment in conservation biology. Chapman & Hall, London, UK.
9. Burgman, M. A., M. F. McBride, R. Ashton, A. Speirs-Bridge, L. Flander, B. Wintle, F. Fidler, L. Rumpff, and C. Twardy. 2011. Expert status and performance. PLoS ONE 6(7):e22998.
10. Cooke, R. M. 1991. Experts in uncertainty: opinion and subjective probability in science. Oxford University Press, New York, New York, USA.
11. Cruz-Martinez, L., P. T. Redig, and J. Deen. 2012. Lead from spent ammunition: a source of exposure and poisoning in bald eagles. Human-Wildlife Interactions 6:94-104.
12. Doherty, K. E., D. E. Naugle, and J. S. Evans. 2010. A currency for offsetting energy development impacts: horse-trading sage-grouse on the open market. PLoS ONE 5(4):e10339.
13. Drescher, M., A. H. Perera, C. J. Johnson, L. J. Buse, C. A. Drew, and M. A. Burgman. 2013. Toward rigorous use of expert knowledge in ecological research. Ecosphere 4(7):83.
14. Epps, C. W. 2014. Considering the switch: challenges of transitioning to non-lead hunting ammunition. The Condor: Ornithological Applications 116:429-434.
15. Finkelstein, M. E., D. F. Doak, D. George, J. Burnett, J. Brandt, M. Church, J. Grantham, and D. R. Smith. 2012. Lead poisoning and the deceptive recovery of the critically endangered California condor. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 109:11449-11454.
16. Fuller, T. K. 1990. Dynamics of a declining white-tailed deer population in north-central Minnesota. Wildlife Monograph 110.
17. Gardner, T. A., et al. 2013. Biodiversity offsets and the challenge of achieving no net loss. Conservation Biology 27(6):1254-1264.
18. Green, R. E., W. G. Hunt, C. N. Parish, and I. Newton. 2008. Effectiveness of action to reduce exposure of free-ranging California Condors in Arizona and Utah to lead from spent ammunition. PLoS ONE 3(12):e4022.
19. Haig, S., J. D'Elia, C. Eagles-Smith, J. M. Fair, J. Gervais, G. Herring, J. W. Rivers, and J. H. Schulz. 2014. The persistent problem of lead poisoning in birds from ammunition and fishing tackle. The Condor: Ornithological Applications 116:408-428.
20. Holling, C. S. 1959. The components of predation as revealed by a study of small-mammal predation of the European pine sawfly. Canadian Entomologist 91:293-320.
21. Hunt, W. G. 2012. Implications of sublethal lead exposure in avian scavengers. Journal of Raptor Research 46:389-393.
22. Hunt, W. G., W. Burnham, C. Parish, K. Burnham, B. Mutch, and J. L. Oaks. 2006. Bullet fragments in deer remains: implications for lead exposure in avian scavengers. Wildlife Society Bulletin 34:167-170.
23. Hunt, W. G., C. N. Parish, K. Orr, and R. F. Aguilar. 2009. Lead poisoning and the reintroduction of the California Condor in Northern Arizona. Journal of Avian Medicine and Surgery 23:145-150.
24. Kalmbach, E. R., R. H. Imler, and L. W. Arnold. 1964. The American eagles and their economic status, 1964. Circulars 27 and 30. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife, Washington, D.C., USA.
25. Kelly, T. R., P. H. Bloom, S. G. Torres, Y. Z. Hernandez, R. H. Poppenga, W. M. Boyce, and C. K. Johnson. 2011. Impact of the California lead ammunition ban on reducing lead exposure in Golden Eagles and Turkey Vultures. PLoS ONE 6(4):e17656.
26. Kochert, M. N., K. Steenhof, C. L. Mcintyre, and E. H. Craig. 2002. Golden Eagle (Aquila chrysaetos). In E. Poole, editor. The Birds of North America Online. Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology, Ithaca, New York, USA.
27. Kramer, J. L., and P. T. Redig. 1997. Sixteen years of lead poisoning in eagles, 1980-95: an epizootiologic view. Journal of Raptor Research 31:327-332.
28. Kuhnert, P. M., T. G. Martin, and S. P. Griffiths. 2010. A guide to eliciting and using expert knowledge in Bayesian ecological models. Ecology Letters 13:900-914.
29. Legagneux, P., P. Suffice, J.-S. Messier, F. Lelievre, J. A. Tremblay, C. Maisonneuve, R. Saint-Louis, and J. Bêty. 2014. High risk of lead contamination for scavengers in an area with high moose hunting success. PLoS ONE 9(11):e111546.
30. Low-Choy, S., R. A. O'Leary, and K. L. Mengersen. 2009. Elicitation by design in ecology: using expert opinion to inform priors for Bayesian statistical models. Ecology 90:265-277.
31. Marcot, B. G., J. D. Steventon, G. D. Sutherland, and R. K. McCann. 2006. Guidelines for developing and updating Bayesian belief networks applied to ecological modeling and conservation. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 36:3063-3074.
32. Maron, M., R. J. Hobbs, A. Moilanen, J. W. Matthews, K. Christie, T. A. Gardner, D. A. Keith, D. B. Lindenmayer, and C. A. McAlpine. 2012. Faustian bargains? Restoration realities in the context of biodiversity offset policies. Biological Conservation 155:141-148.
33. Martin, T. G., M. Burgman, F. Fidler, P. M. Kuhnert, S. Low-Choy, M. McBride, and K. Mengersen. 2012. Eliciting expert knowledge in conservation science. Conservation Biology 26:29-38.
34. Martin, T. G., P. M. Kuhnert, K. Mengersen, and H. P. Possingham. 2005. The power of expert opinion in ecological models using Bayesian methods: impact of grazing on birds. Ecological Applications 15:266-280.
35. McBride, M. F., and M. A. Burgman. 2012. What is expert knowledge, how is such knowledge gathered, and how do we use it to address questions in landscape ecology. Pages 11-38 in A. H. Perera, C. A. Drew, and C. J. Johnson, editors. Expert knowledge and its application in landscape ecology. Springer, New York, New York, USA.
36. McGowan, C. P., M. R. Ryan, M. C. Runge, J. J. Millspaugh, and J. F. Cochrane. 2011. The role of demographic compensation theory in incidental take assessments for endangered species. Biological Conservation 144:730-737.
37. Moilanen, A., A. J. A. Van Teeffelen, Y. Ben-Haim, and S. Ferrier. 2009. How much compensation is enough? A framework for incorporating uncertainty and time discounting when calculating offset ratios for impacted habitat. Restoration Ecology 17:470-478.
38. Morgan, M. G., and M. Henrion. 1990. Uncertainty: a guide to dealing with uncertainty in quantitative risk and policy analysis. Cambridge University Press, New York, New York, USA.
39. Nielson, R., L. McManus, T. Rintz, L. L. McDonald, R. K. Murphy, W. H. Howe, and R. E. Good. 2014. Monitoring abundance of Golden Eagles in the Western United States. Journal of Wildlife Management 78:721-730.
40. Nielson, R. M., and H. Sawyer. 2013. Estimating resource selection with count data. Ecology and Evolution 3:2233-2240.
41. Nixon, C. M., L. P. Hansen, P. A. Brewer, J. E. Chelsvig, T. L. Esker, D. Etter, J. B. Sullivan, R. G. Koerkenmeier, and P. C. Mankin. 2001. Survival of white-tailed deer in intensively farmed areas of Illinois. Canadian Journal of Zoology 79:581-588.
42. Pagel, J. E., K. J. Kritz, B. A. Millsap, R. K. Murphy, E. L. Kershner, and S. Covington. 2013. Bald Eagle and Golden Eagle mortalities at wind energy facilities in the contiguous United States. Journal of Raptor Research 47(3):311-315.
43. Pain, D. J., I. J. Fisher, and V. G. Thomas. 2009. A global update of lead poisoning in terrestrial birds from ammunition sources. Pages 99-118 in R. T. Watson, M. Fuller, M. Pokras, and W. G. Hunt, editors. Ingestion of lead from spent ammunition: implications for wildlife and humans. The Peregrine Fund, Boise, Idaho, USA.
44. Pattee, O. H., S. N. Wiemeyer, B. M. Mulhern, L. Sileo, and J. W. Carpenter. 1981. Experimental lead-shot poisoning in Bald Eagles. Journal of Wildlife Management 45:806-810.
45. Perera, A. H., C. A. Drew, and C. H. Johnson, editors. 2012. Expert knowledge and its application in landscape ecology. Springer, New York, New York, USA.
46. Pilgrim, J. D., et al. 2013. A process for assessing offsetability of biodiversity impacts. Conservation Letters 6:376-384.
47. Quetier, F., and S. Lavorel. 2011. Assessing ecological equivalence in biodiversity offset schemes: key issues and solutions. Biological Conservation 144(12):2991-2999.
48. Regnery, B., D. Couvet, and C. Kerbiriou. 2013. Offsets and conservation of the species of the EU habitats and birds directives. Conservation Biology 27(6):1335-1343.
49. Restani, M., A. R. Harmata, and E. A. Madden. 2000. Numerical and functional responses of migrant bald eagles exploiting a seasonally concentrated food source. The Condor 102:561-568.
50. Ruhl, J. B. 2012. Harmonizing commercial wind power and the Endangered Species Act through administrative reform. Vanderbilt Law Review 65(6):1769-1799.
51. Runge, M. C., S. J. Converse, and J. E. Lyons. 2011. Which uncertainty? Using expert elicitation and expected value of information to design an adaptive program. Biological Conservation 144:1214-1223.
52. Scheuhammer, A. M., and S. L. Norris. 1996. The ecotoxicol-ogy of lead shot and lead fishing weights. Ecotoxicology 5:279-295.
53. Sieg, R., K. A. Sullivan, and C. N. Parish. 2009. Voluntary lead reduction efforts within the northern Arizona range of the California Condor. Pages 341-349 in R. T. Watson, M. Fuller, M. Pokras, and W. G. Hunt, editors. Ingestion of lead from spent ammunition: implications for wildlife and humans. The Peregrine Fund, Boise, Idaho, USA.
54. Speirs-Bridge, A., F. Fidler, M. McBride, L. Flander, G. Cumming, and M. Burgman. 2010. Reducing overconfidence in the interval judgments of experts. Risk Analysis 30:512-523.
55. Starfield, A. M. 1997. A pragmatic approach to modeling for wildlife management. Journal of Wildlife Management 61(2):261-270.
56. Starfield, A. M., and A. L. Bleloch. 1991. Building models for conservation and wildlife management. Second edition. Burgess International Group, Edina, Minnesota, USA.
57. Stauber, E., N. Finch, P. A. Talcott, and J. M. Gay. 2010. Lead poisoning of bald (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) and golden (Aquila chrysaetos) eagles in the US inland Pacific Northwest region-an 18-year retrospective study: 1991-2008. Journal of Avian Medicine and Surgery 24:279-287.
58. USFWS (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service). 2009a. Final Environment Assessment-Proposal to Take Provided Under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Division of Migratory Bird Management, Branch of Policy, Permits and Regulations, Arlington, Virginia, USA. April 2009.
59. USFWS (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service). 2009b. Amended guidance on determining mitigation for the Florida scrub jay. March 16, 2009. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Jacksonville Ecological Services Field Office, Jacksonville, Florida, USA.
60. USFWS (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service). 2009c. Guidelines for the establishment, management, and operation of gopher tortoise conservation banks. Alabama, Louisiana, and Mississippi. January 27, 2009. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Mississippi Ecological Services Field Office, Jackson, Mississippi, USA.
61. USFWS (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service). 2013. Eagle Conservation Plan Guidance. Module 1-Land-based Wind Energy Version 2. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Division of Migratory Bird Management, Branch of Policy, Permits and Regulations, Arlington, Virginia, USA.
62. Warner, S., E. Britton, D. Becker, and M. Coffey. 2014. Bald eagle lead exposure in the Upper Midwest. Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management 5(2):208-216.
63. Watson, J. 2010. The Golden Eagle. Second edition. A & C Black, London, UK.
64. Williams, B. K., and E. D. Brown. 2012. Adaptive management: the U.S. Department of the Interior applications guide. U.S. Department of the Interior, Adaptive Management Working Group, Washington, D.C., USA.
65. Wilmers, C. C., R. L. Crabtree, D. Smith, K. M. Murphy, and W. M. Getz. 2003. Trophic facilitation by introduced top predators: gray wolf subsidies to scavengers in Yellowstone National Park. Journal of Animal Ecology 72:909-916.