Optimising measurement of health-related characteristics of the built environment: Comparing data collected by foot-based street audits, virtual street audits and routine secondary data sources

Health and Place

Volumn 43, Issue , 2017, Pages 75-84

  Pliakas, Triantafyllos ^a   Hawkesworth, Sophie ^a   Silverwood, Richard J ^a   Nanchahal, Kiran ^a   Grundy, Chris ^a   Armstrong, Ben ^a   Casas, Juan Pablo ^b   Morris, Richard W ^c   Wilkinson, Paul ^a   Lock, Karen ^a  

^a LONDON SCHOOL OF HYGIENE AND TROPICAL MEDICINE   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Built environment; Environment measurement; Health; Research design

Indexed keywords

DESIGN; EPIDEMIOLOGY; MEASUREMENT METHOD; NEIGHBORHOOD; OPTIMIZATION; PUBLIC HEALTH; RESEARCH;

ARTICLE; CLINICAL AUDIT; CONTROLLED STUDY; DATA COLLECTION METHOD; FOOT BASED STREET AUDIT; HEALTH BEHAVIOR; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE SYSTEM; HUMAN; INTERRATER RELIABILITY; NEIGHBORHOOD; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PUBLIC HEALTH; REMOTE SENSING; SECONDARY DATA SOURCE; SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT; VIRTUAL BASED STREET AUDIT; DEMOGRAPHY; ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING; INFORMATION PROCESSING; MANAGEMENT; METHODOLOGY; PROCEDURES; REPRODUCIBILITY;

UNITED KINGDOM;

DATA COLLECTION; ENVIRONMENT DESIGN; HEALTH BEHAVIOR; HUMANS; MANAGEMENT AUDIT; PUBLIC HEALTH; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; RESEARCH DESIGN; RESIDENCE CHARACTERISTICS;

EID: 85005975959     PISSN: 13538292     EISSN: 18732054     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2016.10.001     Document Type: Article

References (76)

1. Aanensen, D.M., Huntley, D.M., Feil, E.J., al-Own, Fa, Spratt, B.G., EpiCollect: linking smartphones to web applications for epidemiology, ecology and community data collection. PLoS One, 4, 2009, e6968.
2. Armstrong, B.K., White, E., Saracci, R., Principles of Exposure Measurement in Epidemiology. 1992, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
3. Bader, M.D., Ailshire, J.A., Morenoff, J.D., House, J.S., Measurement of the local food environment: a comparison of existing data sources. Am. J. Epidemiol. 171 (2010), 609–617.
4. Badland, H.M., Opit, S., Witten, K., Kearns, R.A., Mavoa, S., Can virtual streetscape audits reliably replace physical streetscape audits?. J. Urban Health 87 (2010), 1007–1016.
5. Ben-Joseph, E., Lee, J.S., Cromley, E.K., Laden, F., Troped, P.J., Virtual and actual: relative accuracy of on-site and web-based instruments in auditing the environment for physical activity. Health Place. 19 (2013), 138–150.
6. Bethlehem, J.R., Mackenbach, J.D., Ben-Rebah, M., Compernolle, S., Glonti, K., Bardos, H., Rutter, H.R., Charreire, H., Oppert, J.M., Brug, J., Lakerveld, J., The SPOTLIGHT virtual audit tool: a valid and reliable tool to assess obesogenic characteristics of the built environment. Int J. Health Geogr., 13, 2014, 52.
7. Brownson, R.C., Hoehner, C.M., Day, K., Forsyth, A., Sallis, J.F., Measuring the built environment for physical activity: state of the science. Am. J. Prev. Med., 36, 2009 (S99-123.e112).
8. Burgoine, T., Alvanides, S., Lake, A., Creating 'obesogenic realities'; do our methodological choices make a difference when measuring the food environment?. Int J. Health Geogr., 12, 2013, 33.
9. Burgoine, T., Harrison, F., Comparing the accuracy of two secondary food environment data sources in the UK across socio-economic and urban/rural divides. Int J. Health Geogr., 12, 2013, 2.
10. Calogiuri, G., Chroni, S., The impact of the natural environment on the promotion of active living: an integrative systematic review. BMC Public Health, 14, 2014, 873.
11. Caspi, C.E., Sorensen, G., Subramanian, S.V., Kawachi, I., The local food environment and diet: a systematic review. Health Place. 18 (2012), 1172–1187.
12. Charreire, H., Casey, R., Salze, P., Simon, C., Chaix, B., Banos, A., Badariotti, D., Weber, C., Oppert, J.M., Measuring the food environment using geographical information systems: a methodological review. Public Health Nutr. 13 (2010), 1773–1785.
13. Charreire, H., Mackenbach, J.D., Ouasti, M., Lakerveld, J., Compernolle, S., Ben-Rebah, M., McKee, M., Brug, J., Rutter, H., Oppert, J.M., Using remote sensing to define environmental characteristics related to physical activity and dietary behaviours: a systematic review (the SPOTLIGHT project). Health Place. 25 (2014), 1–9.
14. Checkoway, H., Pearce, N., Kriebel, D., Research Methods in Occupational Epidemiology, Second ed., 2004, Oxford University Press.
15. Christian, H., Zubrick, S.R., Foster, S., Giles-Corti, B., Bull, F., Wood, L., Knuiman, M., Brinkman, S., Houghton, S., Boruff, B., The influence of the neighborhood physical environment on early child health and development: a review and call for research. Health Place. 33 (2015), 25–36.
16. Cicchetti, D., Guidelines, criteria and rules of thumb for evaluating normed and standardized assessment instruments in psychology. Psychol. Assess. 6 (1994), 284–290.
17. Clarke, P., Ailshire, J., Melendez, R., Bader, M., Morenoff, J., Using Google Earth to conduct a neighborhood audit: reliability of a virtual audit instrument. Health Place. 16 (2010), 1224–1229.
18. Cummins, S., Curtis, S., Diez-Roux, A.V., Macintyre, S., Understanding and representing 'place' in health research: a relational approach. Soc. Sci. Med. 65 (2007), 1825–1838.
19. Cummins, S., Macintyre, S., Are secondary data sources on the neighbourhood food environment accurate? Case-study in Glasgow, UK. Prev. Med. 49 (2009), 527–528.
20. Cummins, S., Macintyre, S., Davidson, S., Ellaway, A., Measuring neighbourhood social and material context: generation and interpretation of ecological data from routine and non-routine sources. Health Place. 11 (2005), 249–260.
21. Curtis, J.W., Curtis, A., Mapes, J., Szell, A.B., Cinderich, A., Using google street view for systematic observation of the built environment: analysis of spatio-temporal instability of imagery dates. Int J. Health Geogr., 12, 2013, 53.
22. de Vet, E., de Ridder, D.T., de Wit, J.B., Environmental correlates of physical activity and dietary behaviours among young people: a systematic review of reviews. Obes. Rev. 12 (2011), e130–e142.
23. Department for Communities and Local Government, 2013. Index of Multiple Deprivation 2010, Local Authority District Rank of Average Rank. Available at: (http://opendatacommunities.org/data/societal-wellbeing/deprivation/imd-rank-la-2010) (accessed 27.01.16). Archived at: (http://www.webcitation.org/6eqnNh0Qm) on 27 January 2016.
24. Department for Transport, 2014. National Public Transport Access Node. Available at: (https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-public-transport-access-node-schema) (accessed 27.01.16). Archived at: (http://www.webcitation.org/6eqnduU44) on 27 January 2016.
25. Department for Transport, 2015. Annual Average Daily Traffic Flows. Available at: (http://www.dft.gov.uk/traffic-counts/) (accessed 27.01.16). Archived at: (http://www.webcitation.org/6eqo6hpmM) on 27 January 2016.
26. Digimap Ordnance Survey, 2015. Meridian 2 National. Available at: (http://digimap.edina.ac.uk/webhelp/os/data_information/os_products/meridian_2.htm) (accessed 27.01.16). Archived at: (http://www.webcitation.org/6eqo18lK6) on 27 January 2016.
27. Ding, D., Gebel, K., Built environment, physical activity, and obesity: what have we learned from reviewing the literature?. Health Place. 18 (2012), 100–105.
28. Ding, D., Sallis, J.F., Kerr, J., Lee, S., Rosenberg, D.E., Neighborhood environment and physical activity among youth a review. Am. J. Prev. Med. 41 (2011), 442–455.
29. Dunton, G.F., Kaplan, J., Wolch, J., Jerrett, M., Reynolds, K.D., Physical environmental correlates of childhood obesity: a systematic review. Obes. Rev. 10 (2009), 393–402.
30. ESRI, 2014. ArcGIS 10.3 for Desktop.
31. Evenson, K.R., Wen, F., Using geographic information systems to compare municipal, county, and commercial parks data. Prev. Chronic Dis., 10, 2013, E93.
32. Feng, J., Glass, T.A., Curriero, F.C., Stewart, W.F., Schwartz, B.S., The built environment and obesity: a systematic review of the epidemiologic evidence. Health Place. 16 (2010), 175–190.
33. Fleischhacker, S.E., Evenson, K.R., Sharkey, J., Pitts, S.B., Rodriguez, D.A., Validity of secondary retail food outlet data: a systematic review. Am. J. Prev. Med. 45 (2013), 462–473.
34. Fleiss, J.L., Statistical Methods for Rates and Proportions. 1981, Wiley, New York, NY.
35. Gasevic, D., Vukmirovich, I., Yusuf, S., Teo, K., Chow, C., Dagenais, G., Lear, S.A., A direct assessment of “obesogenic” built environments: challenges and recommendations. J. Environ. Public Health, 2011, 2011, 161574.
36. Giraudeau, B., Negative values of the intraclass correlation coefficient are not theoretically possible. J. Clin. Epidemiol., 49, 1996, 1205.
37. Glanz, K., Sallis, J.F., Saelens, B.E., Frank, L.D., Nutrition Environment Measures Survey in stores (NEMS-S): development and evaluation. Am. J. Prev. Med. 32 (2007), 282–289.
38. Goodwin, D.M., Cummins, S., Sautkina, E., Ogilvie, D., Petticrew, M., Jones, A., Wheeler, K., White, M., The role and status of evidence and innovation in the healthy towns programme in England: a qualitative stakeholder interview study. J. Epidemiol. Community Health 67 (2013), 106–112.
39. Gravlee, C.C., Zenk, S.N., Woods, S., Rowe, Z., Schulz, A.J., Handheld computers for direct observation of the social and physical environment. Field Methods 18 (2006), 382–397.
40. Griew, P., Hillsdon, M., Foster, C., Coombes, E., Jones, A., Wilkinson, P., Developing and testing a street audit tool using Google street View to measure environmental supportiveness for physical activity. Int J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act., 10, 2013, 103.
41. Hara, K., Le, V., Froehlich, J., 2013. Combining crowdsourcing and google street view to identify street-level accessibility problems. In: Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. ACM Conference paper, Paris, France, pp. 631–640.
42. Hara, K., Sun, J., Moore, R., Jacobs, D., Froehlich, J., 2014. Tohme: Detecting Curb Ramps in Google Street View Using Crowdsourcing, Computer Vision, and Machine Learning, SIGCHI Conference paper, pp. 189–204.
43. Hawkesworth, S., Silverwood, R., Pliakas, T., Nanchahal, K., Jefferis, B., Sartini, C., Amuzu, A., Armstrong, B., Casas, J.-P., Morris, R., Whincup, P., Lock, K., How the local built environment affects physical activity behaviour in older adults in the UK: a cross-sectional analysis linked to two national cohorts. Lancet, 386, 2015, S5.
44. King, K.E., A comparison of two methods for measuring land use in public health research: systematic social observation versus remote sensing–based coded aerial photography. SAGE Open 5 (2015), 1–9.
45. Krenn, P.J., Titze, S., Oja, P., Jones, A., Ogilvie, D., Use of global positioning systems to study physical activity and the environment: a systematic review. Am. J. Prev. Med. 41 (2011), 508–515.
46. Lake, A.A., Burgoine, T., Stamp, E., Grieve, R., The foodscape: classification and field validation of secondary data sources across urban/rural and socio-economic classifications in England. Int J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act., 9, 2012, 37.
47. Landis, J.R., Koch, G.G., The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 33 (1977), 159–174.
48. Lawlor, D.A., Bedford, C., Taylor, M., Ebrahim, S., Geographical variation in cardiovascular disease, risk factors, and their control in older women: british women's Heart and Health Study. J. Epidemiol. Community Health 57 (2003), 134–140.
49. Lee, R.E., Booth, K.M., Reese-Smith, J.Y., Regan, G., Howard, H.H., The physical activity resource assessment (para) instrument: evaluating features, amenities and incivilities of physical activity resources in urban neighborhoods. Int J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act., 2, 2005, 13.
50. Leslie, E., Coffee, N., Frank, L., Owen, N., Bauman, A., Hugo, G., Walkability of local communities: using geographic information systems to objectively assess relevant environmental attributes. Health Place. 13 (2007), 111–122.
51. Liese, A.D., Barnes, T.L., Lamichhane, A.P., Hibbert, J.D., Colabianchi, N., Lawson, A.B., Characterizing the food retail environment: impact of count, type, and geospatial error in 2 secondary data sources. J. Nutr. Educ. Behav. 45 (2013), 435–442.
52. Local Government Association, 2013. A Guide to INSPIRE compliance in Local Government. Available at: (http://www.local.gov.uk/c/document_library/get_file?Uuid=ba19b779-eb8d-404c-af07-25ecd921aed9) (accessed 27.01.16). Archived at: (http://www.webcitation.org/6eqpOu6Gn) on 27 January 2016.
53. Lucan, S.C., Concerning limitations of food-environment research: a narrative review and commentary framed around obesity and diet-related diseases in youth. J. Acad. Nutr. Diet. 115 (2015), 205–212.
54. Lucan, S.C., Maroko, A.R., Bumol, J., Torrens, L., Varona, M., Berke, E.M., Business list vs ground observation for measuring a food environment: saving time or waste of time (or worse)?. J. Acad. Nutr. Diet. 113 (2013), 1332–1339.
55. Macintyre, S., Deprivation amplification revisited; or, is it always true that poorer places have poorer access to resources for healthy diets and physical activity?. Int J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act., 4, 2007, 32.
56. Macintyre, S., Ellaway, A., Cummins, S., Place effects on health: how can we conceptualise, operationalise and measure them?. Soc. Sci. Med. 55 (2002), 125–139.
57. Milton, S., Pliakas, T., Hawkesworth, S., Nanchahal, K., Grundy, C., Amuzu, A., Casas, J.-P., Lock, K., A qualitative geographical information systems approach to explore how older people over 70 years interact with and define their neighbourhood environment. Health Place. 36 (2015), 127–133.
58. Office for National Statistics, 2015. Neighbourhood Statistics. Available at: (http://www.neighbourhood.statistics.gov.uk/dissemination/LeadHome.do) (accessed 27.01.16). Archived at: (http://www.webcitation.org/6eqqor1dR) on 27 January 2016.
59. Paquet, C., Daniel, M., Kestens, Y., Leger, K., Gauvin, L., Field validation of listings of food stores and commercial physical activity establishments from secondary data. Int J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act., 5, 2008, 58.
60. Pikora, T.J., Bull, F.C., Jamrozik, K., Knuiman, M., Giles-Corti, B., Donovan, R.J., Developing a reliable audit instrument to measure the physical environment for physical activity. Am. J. Prev. Med. 23 (2002), 187–194.
61. Pliakas, T., Wilkinson, P., Tonne, C., Contribution of the physical environment to socioeconomic gradients in walking in the Whitehall II study. Health Place. 27 (2014), 186–193.
62. Saelens, B.E., Glanz, K., Sallis, J.F., Frank, L.D., Nutrition Environment Measures Study in restaurants (NEMS-R): development and evaluation. Am. J. Prev. Med. 32 (2007), 273–281.
63. Saelens, B.E., Handy, S.L., Built environment correlates of walking: a review. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc 40 (2008), S550–S566.
64. Sallis, J.F., Cervero, R.B., Ascher, W., Henderson, K.A., Kraft, M.K., Kerr, J., An ecological approach to creating active living communities. Annu Rev. Public Health 27 (2006), 297–322.
65. Sampson, R.J., Raudenbush, S.W., Systematic Social Observation of Public Spaces: a New Look at Disorder in Urban Neighborhoods. Am. J. Sociol. 105 (1999), 603–651.
66. Schaefer-McDaniel, N., Caughy, M.O., O'Campo, P., Gearey, W., Examining methodological details of neighbourhood observations and the relationship to health: a literature review. Soc. Sci. Med 70 (2010), 277–292.
67. Shareck, M., Dassa, C., Frohlich, K.L., Improving the measurement of neighbourhood characteristics through systematic observation: inequalities in smoking as a case study. Health Place. 18 (2012), 671–682.
68. Shrout, P.E., Fleiss, J.L., Intraclass correlations: uses in assessing rater reliability. Psychol. Bull. 86 (1979), 420–428.
69. StataCorp LP, 2015. Stata/IC 14.1.
70. Thornton, L.E., Pearce, J.R., Kavanagh, A.M., Using Geographic Information Systems (GIS) to assess the role of the built environment in influencing obesity: a glossary. Int J. Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act., 8, 2011, 71.
71. Van Cauwenberg, J., De Bourdeaudhuij, I., De Meester, F., Van Dyck, D., Salmon, J., Clarys, P., Deforche, B., Relationship between the physical environment and physical activity in older adults: a systematic review. Health Place. 17 (2011), 458–469.
72. Walker, M., Whincup, P.H., Shaper, A.G., The British regional heart study 1975–2004. Int J. Epidemiol. 33 (2004), 1185–1192.
73. Wilson, J.S., Kelly, C.M., Schootman, M., Baker, E.A., Banerjee, A., Clennin, M., Miller, D.K., Assessing the built environment using omnidirectional imagery. Am. J. Prev. Med 42 (2012), 193–199.
74. World Health Organization, 2010. Urban planning, environment and health. Available at: (http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/114448/E93987.pdf) (accessed 27.01.16). Archived at: (http://www.webcitation.org/6eqpesahM) on 27 January 2016.
75. Wu, Y.T., Nash, P., Barnes, L.E., Minett, T., Matthews, F.E., Jones, A., Brayne, C., Assessing environmental features related to mental health: a reliability study of visual streetscape images. BMC Public Health, 14, 2014, 1094.
76. Zenk, S.N., Schulz, A.J., Mentz, G., House, J.S., Gravlee, C.C., Miranda, P.Y., Miller, P., Kannan, S., Inter-rater and test-retest reliability: methods and results for the neighborhood observational checklist. Health Place. 13 (2007), 452–465.