Template-Based Models for Genome-Wide Analysis of Next-Generation Sequencing Data at Base-Pair Resolution

Journal of the American Statistical Association

Volumn 111, Issue 515, 2016, Pages 967-987

  Blocker, Alexander W ^a   Airoldi, Edoardo M ^a  

^a HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Calibrated Bayesian detection; Deconvolution; Hamiltonian Monte Carlo; Massive data; Measurement error; Nucleosomes; Parallel computation; Yeast

Indexed keywords

EID: 84991624985     PISSN: 01621459     EISSN: 1537274X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01621459.2016.1141095     Document Type: Article

References (49)

1. I.Albert, T.N.Mavrich, L.P.Tomsho, J.Qi, S.J.Zanton, S.C.Schuster, and B.F.Pugh, (2007), “Translational and Rotational Settings of H2A.Z Nucleosomes Across the Saccharomyces Cerevisiae Genome,” Nature, 446, 572–576.
2. A.Barski, and K.Zhao, (2009), “Genomic Location Analysis by ChIP-Seq,” Journal of Cellular Biochemistry, 107, 11–18.
3. K.Brogaard, L.Xi, J.-P.Wang, and J.Widom, (2012), “A Map of Nucleosome Positions in Yeast at Base-Pair Resolution,” Nature, 486, 496–501.
4. J.Cairns, C.Spyrou, R.Stark, M.L.Smith, A.G.Lynch, and S.Tavaré, (2011), “BayesPeak–an R Package for Analysing ChIP-seq Data,” Bioinformatics, 27, 713–714.
5. G.E.Crawford, S.Davis, P.C.Scacheri, G.Renaud, M.J.Halawi, M.R.Erdos, R.Green, P.S.Meltzer, T.G.Wolfsberg, and F.S.Collins, (2006a), “Dnase-chip:A High-resolution Method to Identify Dnase i Hypersensitive Sites Using Tiled Microarrays,” Nature Methods, 3, 503–509.
6. G.E.Crawford, I.E.Holt, J.Whittle, B.D.Webb, D.Tai, S.Davis, E.H.Margulies, Y.D.Chen, J.A.Bernat, D.Ginsburg, D.Zhou, S.Luo, T.J.Vasicek, M.J.Daly, T.G.Wolfsberg, and F.S.Collins, (2006b), “Genome-Wide Mapping of Dnase Hypersensitive Sites Using Massively Parallel Signature Sequencing (mpss),” Genome Research, 16, 123–131.
7. O.Flores, and M.Orozco, (2011), “nucleR:A Package for Non-Parametric Nucleosome Positioning,” Bioinformatics, 27, 2149–2150.
8. A.C.Frazee, S.Sabunciyan, K.D.Hansen, R.A.Irizarry, and J.T.Leek, (2014), “Differential Expression Analysis of Rna-seq Data at Single-Base Resolution,” Biostatistics, 15, 413–426.
9. K.Fu, Q.Tang, J.Feng, X.S.Liu, and Y.Zhang, (2012), “DiNuP:A Systematic Approach to Identify Regions of Differential Nucleosome Positioning,” Bioinformatics, 28, 1965–1971.
10. D.J.Gaffney, G.McVicker, A.A.Pai, Y.N.Fondufe-Mittendorf, N.Lewellen, K.Michelini, J.Widom, Y.Gilad, and J.K.Pritchard, (2012), “Controls of Nucleosome Positioning in the Human Genome,” PLoS Genetics, 8, e1003036, 11.
11. T.Gkikopoulos, P.Schofield, V.Singh, M.Pinskaya, J.Mellor, M.Smolle, J.L.Workman, G.J.Barton, and T.Owen-Hughes, (2011), “A Role for Snf2-Related Nucleosome-Spacing Enzymes in Genome-Wide Nucleosome Organization,” Science, 333, 1758–1760.
12. M.Gupta, (2007), “Generalized Hierarchical Markov Models for the Discovery of Length-Constrained Sequence Features From Genome Tiling Arrays,” Biometrics, 63, 797–805.
13. A.Jansen, and K.J.Verstrepen, (2011), “Nucleosome Positioning in Saccharomyces cerevisiae,” Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews:MMBR, 75, 301–320.
14. Y.Katz, E.T.Wang, E.M.Airoldi, and C.B.Burge, (2010), “Analysis and Design of RNA Sequencing Experiments for Identifying Isoform Regulation,” Nature Methods, 7, 1009–1015.
15. Katz, Y., Li, F., Lambert, N. J., Sokol, E. S., Tam, W.-L., Cheng, A. W., Airoldi, E. M., Lengner, C. J., Gupta, P. B., Yu, Z., Jaenisch, R., Burge, C. B. (2014), “Musashi Proteins are Post-Transcriptional Regulators of the Epithelial-Luminal Cell State,” eLife, 3, e03915.
16. Katz, Y., Wang, E. T., Silterra, J., Schwartz, S., Wong, B., Thorvaldsdóttir, H., Robinson, J. T., Mesirov, J. P., Airoldi, E. M., Burge, C. B. (2015), “Quantitative Visualization of Alternative Exon Expression from RNA-Seq Data,” Bioinformatics, 31, 2400--2402.
17. B.Langmead, C.Trapnell, M.Pop, and S.L.Salzberg, (2009), “Ultrafast and Memory-Efficient Alignment of Short DNA Sequences to the Human Genome,” Genome Biology, 10, R25.
18. W.Lee, D.Tillo, N.Bray, R.H.Morse, R.W.Davis, T.R.Hughes, and C.Nislow, (2007), “A High-Resolution Atlas of Nucleosome Occupancy in Yeast,” Nature Genetics, 39, 1235–1244.
19. Q.Li, J.B.Brown, H.Huang, and P.J.Bickel, (2011), “Measuring Reproducibility of High-Throughput Experiments,” The Annals of Applied Statistics, 5, 1752–1779.
20. R.Mitra, and M.Gupta, (2011), “A Continuous-Index Bayesian Hidden Markov Model for Prediction of Nucleosome Positioning in Genomic DNA,” Biostatistics, 12, 462–477.
21. Q.Mo, (2012), “A Fully Bayesian Hidden Ising Model for Chip-seq Data Analysis,” Biostatistics, 13, 113–128.
22. O.Mueller, (2000), “High Precision Restriction Fragment Sizing With the Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer:Application Note,” available at http://www.chem-agilent.com/pdf/5968-7501EN.pdf.
23. M.A.Newton, A.Noueiry, D.Sarkar, and P.Ahlquist, (2004), “Detecting Differential Gene Expression With a Semiparametric Hierarchical Mixture Method,” Biostatistics, 5, 155–176.
24. P.J.Park, (2009), “ChIP-Seq:Advantages and Challenges of a Maturing Technology,” Nature Reviews Genetics, 10, 669–680.
25. S.Pepke, B.Wold, and A.Mortazavi, (2009), “Computation for ChIP-seq and RNA-seq Studies,” Nature Methods, 6, S22–S32.
26. A.Polishko, S.Lonardi, N.Ponts, and K.G.Le Roch, (2014), “PuFFIN:A Parameter-Free Method to Build Nucleosome Maps From Paired-End Reads,” in Proceedings of the Fourth Annual RECOMB Satellite Workshop on Massively Parallel Sequencing (RECOMB-seq), Pittsburgh, PA.
27. A.Polishko, N.Ponts, K.G.Le Roch, and S.Lonardi, (2012), “NORMAL:Accurate Nucleosome Positioning Using a Modified Gaussian Mixture Model,” Bioinformatics, 28, 242–249.
28. N.U.Rashid, P.G.Giresi, J.G.Ibrahim, W.Sun, and J.D.Lieb, (2011), “ZINBA Integrates Local Covariates With DNA-seq Data to Identify Broad and Narrow Regions of Enrichment, Even Within Amplified Genomic Regions,” Genome Biology, 12, R67.
29. Roadmap Epigenomics Consortium, A.Kundaje, W.Meuleman, J.Ernst, M.Bilenky, A.Yen, A.Heravi-Moussavi, P.Kheradpour, Z.Zhang, J.Wang, M.J.Ziller, V.Amin, J.W.Whitaker, M.D.Schultz, L.D.Ward, A.Sarkar, G.Quon, R.S.Sandstrom, M.L.Eaton, Y.-C.Wu, A.R.Pfenning, X.Wang, M.Claussnitzer, Y.Liu, C.Coarfa, R.A.Harris, N.Shoresh, C.B.Epstein, E.Gjoneska, D.Leung, W.Xie, R.D.Hawkins, R.Lister, C.Hong, P.Gascard, A.J.Mungall, R.Moore, E.Chuah, A.Tam, T.K.Canfield, R.S.Hansen, R.Kaul, P.J.Sabo, M.S.Bansal, A.Carles, J.R.Dixon, K.-H.Farh, S.Feizi, R.Karlic, A.-R.Kim, A.Kulkarni, D.Li, R.Lowdon, G.N.Elliott, T.R.Mercer, S.J.Neph, V.Onuchic, P.Polak, N.Rajagopal, P.Ray, R.C.Sallari, and K.T.Siebe, (2015), “Integrative Analysis of 111 Reference Human Epigenomes,” Nature, 518, 317–330.
30. R.Schöpflin, V.B.Teif, O.Müller, C.Weinberg, K.Rippe, and G.Wedemann, (2013), “Modeling Nucleosome Position Distributions From Experimental Nucleosome Positioning Maps,” Bioinformatics, 29, 2380–2386.
31. A.Schwartzman, A.Jaffe, Y.Gavrilov, and C.A.Meyer, (2013), “Multiple Testing of Local Maxima for Detection of Peaks in ChIP-Seq Data,” The Annals of Applied Statistics, 7, 471–494.
32. E.Segal, Y.Fondufe-Mittendorf, L.Chen, A.Thastrom, Y.Field, I.K.Moore, J.Z.Wang, and J.Widom, (2006), “A Genomic Code for Nucleosome Positioning,” Nature, 42, 772–778.
33. S.Shivaswamy, A.Bhinge, Y.Zhao, S.Jones, M.Hirst, and V.R.Iyer, (2008), “Dynamic Remodeling of Individual Nucleosomes Across a Eukaryotic Genome in Response to Transcriptional Perturbation,” PLoS Biology, 6, e65.
34. E.C.Small, L.Xi, J.-P.Wang, J.Widom, and J.D.Licht, (2014), “Single-Cell Nucleosome Mapping Reveals the Molecular Basis of Gene Expression Heterogeneity,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111, E2462–E2471.
35. J.D.Storey, and R.Tibshirani, (2003), “Statistical Significance for Genomewide Studies,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 100, 9440.
36. W.Sun, M.J.Buck, M.Patel, and I.J.Davis, (2009a), “Improved ChIP-chip Analysis by a Mixture Model Approach,” BMC Bioinformatics, 10, 173.
37. W.Sun, W.Xie, F.Xu, M.Grunstein, and K.Li, (2009b), “Dissecting Nucleosome Free Regions by a Segmental Semi-Markov Model,” PloS One, 4, e4721.
38. The ENCODE Project Consortium. (2011), “A User’s Guide to the Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (ENCODE),” PLoS Biol, 9, e1001046.
39. I.Tirosh, (2012), “Computational Analysis of Nucleosome Positioning,” Methods in Molecular Biology, 833, 443–449.
40. A.M.Tsankov, D.A.Thompson, A.Socha, A.Regev, and O.J.Rando, (2010), “The Role of Nucleosome Positioning in the Evolution of Gene Regulation,” PLoS Biology, 8, e1000414.
41. A.Valouev, J.Ichikawa, T.Tonthat, J.Stuart, S.Ranade, H.Peckham, K.Zeng, J.A.Malek, G.Costa, K.McKernan, A.Sidow, A.Fire, and S.M.Johnson, (2008), “A High-Resolution, Nucleosome Position Map of C. elegans Reveals a Lack of Universal Sequence-Dictated Positioning,” Genome Research, 18, 1051–1063.
42. A.Weiner, A.Hughes, M.Yassour, O.J.Rando, and N.Friedman, (2010), “High-Resolution Nucleosome Mapping Reveals Transcription-Dependent Promoter Packaging,” Genome Research, 20, 90–100.
43. M.Yassour, T.Kaplan, A.Jaimovich, and N.Friedman, (2008), “Nucleosome Positioning From Tiling Microarray Data,” Bioinformatics, 24, i139–i146.
44. G.-C.Yuan, and J.S.Liu, (2008), “Genomic Sequence is Highly Predictive of Local Nucleosome Depletion,” PLoS Computational Biology, 4, e13.
45. G.-C.Yuan, Y.-J.Liu, M.F.Dion, M.D.Slack, L.F.Wu, S.J.Altschuler, and O.J.Rando, (2005), “Genome-Scale Identification of Nucleosome Positions in S. cerevisiae,” Science, 309, 626–630.
46. X.Zhang, G.Robertson, S.Woo, B.G.Hoffman, and R.Gottardo, (2012), “Probabilistic Inference for Nucleosome Positioning With MNase-Based or Sonicated Short-Read Data,” PloS One, 7, e32095.
47. Y.Zhang, T.Liu, C.A.Meyer, J.Eeckhote, D.S.Johnson, B.E.Bernstein, C.Nusbaum, R.M.Myers, M.Brown, W.Li, and X.S.Liu, (2008), “Model-Based Analysis of ChIP-Seq (MACS),” Genome Biology, 9, R137.
48. X.Zhou, A.W.Blocker, E.M.Airoldi, and E.K.O’Shea, (2016), “A Computational Approach to Map Nucleosome Positions and Alternative Chromatin States with Base Pair Resolution,” eLife, in press.
49. C.Zhu, R.H.Byrd, P.Lu, and J.Nocedal, (1997), “Algorithm 778:L-bfgs-b:Fortran Subroutines for Large-Scale Bound-Constrained Optimization,” ACM Transactions on Mathematical Software, 23, 550–560.