The neural correlates of moral decision-making: A systematic review and meta-analysis of moral evaluations and response decision judgements

Brain and Cognition

Volumn 108, Issue , 2016, Pages 88-97

  Garrigan, Beverley ^a   Adlam, Anna L R ^b   Langdon, Peter E ^c,d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EAST ANGLIA   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF KENT   (United Kingdom)

^d HERTFORDSHIRE PARTNERSHIP UNIVERSITY NHS FOUNDATION TRUST   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Activation likelihood estimate analysis (ALE); Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI); Meta analysis; Moral evaluation (ME); Moral response decision (MRD)

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BRAIN FUNCTION; CINGULATE GYRUS; DECISION MAKING; HUMAN; MENTAL TASK; META ANALYSIS; MIDDLE FRONTAL GYRUS; MIDDLE TEMPORAL GYRUS; MORALITY; NERVE CELL; PRECUNEUS; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TASK PERFORMANCE; BRAIN CORTEX; PHYSIOLOGY;

CEREBRAL CORTEX; DECISION MAKING; HUMANS; MORALS;

EID: 84983479242     PISSN: 02782626     EISSN: 10902147     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bandc.2016.07.007     Document Type: Article

References (66)

1. Avram, M., Gutyrchik, E., Bao, Y., Pöppel, E., Reiser, M., Blautzik, J., Neurofunctional correlates of esthetic and moral judgments. Neuroscience Letters 534 (2013), 128–132.
2. Avram, M., Hennig-Fast, K., Bao, Y., Pöppel, E., Reiser, M., Blautzik, J., et al. Neural correlates of moral judgments in first-and third-person perspectives: Implications for neuroethics and beyond. BMC Neuroscience, 15(1), 2014, 39.
3. Bahnemann, M., Dziobek, I., Prehn, K., Wolf, I., Heekeren, H.R., Sociotopy in the temporoparietal cortex: Common versus distinct processes. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 5:1 (2010), 48–58.
4. Blair, J., Marsh, A., Finger, E., Blair, K., Luo, J., Neuro-cognitive systems involved in morality. Philosophical Explorations 9:1 (2006), 13–27.
5. Borg, J.S., Hynes, C., Van Horn, J., Grafton, S., Sinnott-Armstrong, W., Consequences, action, and intention as factors in moral judgments: An fMRI investigation. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 18:5 (2006), 803–817.
6. Bzdok, D., Langner, R., Schilbach, L., Jakobs, O., Roski, C., Caspers, S., et al. Characterization of the temporo-parietal junction by combining data-driven parcellation, complementary connectivity analyses, and functional decoding. Neuroimage 81 (2013), 381–392.
7. Bzdok, D., Schilbach, L., Vogeley, K., Schneider, K., Laird, A., Langner, R., et al. Parsing the neural correlates of moral cognition: ALE meta-analysis on morality, theory of mind, and empathy. Brain Structure and Function 217:4 (2012), 783–796.
8. Cavanna, A.E., Trimble, M.R., The precuneus: A review of its functional anatomy and behavioural correlates. Brain 129:3 (2006), 564–583.
9. Chen, Q.-L., Xu, T., Yang, W.-J., Li, Y.-D., Sun, J.-Z., Wang, K.-C., et al. Individual differences in verbal creative thinking are reflected in the precuneus. Neuropsychologia 75 (2015), 441–449.
10. Chiong, W., Wilson, S.M., d'Esposito, M., Kayser, A.S., Grossman, S.N., Poorzand, P., et al. The salience network causally influences default mode network activity during moral reasoning. Brain: A Journal of Neurology 136:6 (2013), 1929–1941.
11. Christensen, J., Flexas, A., Calabrese, M., Gut, N.K., Gomila, A., Moral judgment reloaded: A moral dilemma validation study. Frontiers in Psychology, 5, 2014.
12. Christensen, J., Gomila, A., Moral dilemmas in cognitive neuroscience of moral decision-making: A principled review. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 36:4 (2012), 1249–1264.
13. de Achával, D., Villarreal, M.F., Salles, A., Bertomeu, M.J., Costanzo, E.Y., Goldschmidt, M., et al. Activation of brain areas concerned with social cognition during moral decisions is abnormal in schizophrenia patients and unaffected siblings. Journal of Psychiatric Research 47:6 (2013), 774–782.
14. Eickhoff, S.B., Bzdok, D., Laird, A.R., Kurth, F., Fox, P.T., Activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis revisited. Neuroimage 59:3 (2012), 2349–2361.
15. Eickhoff, S.B., Laird, A.R., Grefkes, C., Wang, L.E., Zilles, K., Fox, P.T., Coordinate-based activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis of neuroimaging data: A random-effects approach based on empirical estimates of spatial uncertainty. Human Brain Mapping 30:9 (2009), 2907–2926.
16. FeldmanHall, O., Sokol-Hessner, P., Van Bavel, J.J., Phelps, E.A., Fairness violations elicit greater punishment on behalf of another than for oneself. Nature Communications, 5, 2014.
17. Freton, M., Lemogne, C., Bergouignan, L., Delaveau, P., Lehéricy, S., Fossati, P., The eye of the self: Precuneus volume and visual perspective during autobiographical memory retrieval. Brain Structure and Function 219:3 (2014), 959–968.
18. Fumagalli, M., Priori, A., Functional and clinical neuroanatomy of morality. Brain 135:7 (2012), 2006–2021.
19. Gibbs, J.C., Moral development and reality: Beyond the theories of Kohlberg, Hoffman, and Haidt. 2013, Oxford University Press.
20. Greene, J.D., Sommerville, R.B., Nystrom, L.E., Darley, J.M., Cohen, J.D., An fMRI investigation of emotional engagement in moral judgment. Science 293:5537 (2001), 2105–2108.
21. Han, H., Glover, G.H., Jeong, C., Cultural influences on the neural correlate of moral decision making processes. Behavioural Brain Research 259 (2014), 215–228.
22. Harada, T., Itakura, S., Xu, F., Lee, K., Nakashita, S., Saito, D.N., et al. Neural correlates of the judgment of lying: A functional magnetic resonance imaging study. Neuroscience Research 63:1 (2009), 24–34.
23. Harenski, C.L., Antonenko, O., Shane, M.S., Kiehl, K.A., Gender differences in neural mechanisms underlying moral sensitivity. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 3:4 (2008), 313–321.
24. Harenski, C.L., Edwards, B.G., Harenski, K.A., Kiehl, K.A., Neural correlates of moral and non-moral emotion in female psychopathy. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 8, 2014.
25. Harenski, C.L., Harenski, K.A., Shane, M.S., Kiehl, K.A., Neural development of mentalizing in moral judgment from adolescence to adulthood. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience 2:1 (2012), 162–173.
26. Harrison, B.J., Pujol, J., Soriano-Mas, C., Hernández-Ribas, R., López-Solà, M., Ortiz, H., et al. Neural correlates of moral sensitivity in obsessive-compulsive disorder. JAMA Psychiatry 69:7 (2012), 741–749.
27. Heekeren, H.R., Wartenburger, I., Schmidt, H., Prehn, K., Schwintowski, H.-P., Villringer, A., Influence of bodily harm on neural correlates of semantic and moral decision-making. Neuroimage 24:3 (2005), 887–897.
28. Heekeren, H.R., Wartenburger, I., Schmidt, H., Schwintowski, H.-P., Villringer, A., An fMRI study of simple ethical decision-making. NeuroReport: For Rapid Communication of Neuroscience Research 14:9 (2003), 1215–1219.
29. Laird, A.R., Robinson, J.L., McMillan, K.M., Tordesillas-Gutiérrez, D., Moran, S.T., Gonzales, S.M., et al. Comparison of the disparity between Talairach and MNI coordinates in functional neuroimaging data: Validation of the Lancaster transform. Neuroimage 51:2 (2010), 677–683.
30. Lancaster, J., & Martinez, M. (Copyright 2006–2015). Mango. Research Imaging Institute: University of Texas Health Science Center.
31. Lancaster, J., Rainey, L., Summerlin, J., Freitas, C., Fox, P., Evans, A., et al. Automated labeling of the human brain: A preliminary report on the development and evaluation of a forward-transform method. Human Brain Mapping, 5(4), 1997, 238.
32. Lancaster, J., Tordesillas-Gutiérrez, D., Martinez, M., Salinas, F., Evans, A., Zilles, K., et al. Bias between MNI and Talairach coordinates analyzed using the ICBM-152 brain template. Human Brain Mapping 28:11 (2007), 1194–1205.
33. Lancaster, J., Woldorff, M.G., Parsons, L.M., Liotti, M., Freitas, C.S., Rainey, L., et al. Automated Talairach atlas labels for functional brain mapping. Human Brain Mapping 10:3 (2000), 120–131.
34. Maddock, R.J., Garrett, A.S., Buonocore, M.H., Posterior cingulate cortex activation by emotional words: fMRI evidence from a valence decision task. Human Brain Mapping 18:1 (2003), 30–41.
35. Marazziti, D., Baroni, S., Landi, P., Ceresoli, D., Dell'Osso, L., The neurobiology of moral sense: Facts or hypotheses?. Annals of General Psychiatry, 12(1), 2013, 6.
36. Mashal, N., Vishne, T., Laor, N., The role of the precuneus in metaphor comprehension: evidence from an fMRI study in people with schizophrenia and healthy participants. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 8, 2014, 818.
37. Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D.G., Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. Annals of Internal Medicine 151:4 (2009), 264–269.
38. Moll, J., de Oliveira-Souza, R., Eslinger, P.J., Bramati, I.E., Mourão-Miranda, J., Andreiuolo, P.A., et al. The neural correlates of moral sensitivity: A functional magnetic resonance imaging investigation of basic and moral emotions. The Journal of Neuroscience 22:7 (2002), 2730–2736.
39. Moll, J., Eslinger, P.J., de Oliveira-Souza, R., Frontopolar and anterior temporal cortex activation in a moral judgment task. Arquivos de Neuro-Psiquiatria 59:3-B (2001), 657–664.
40. Nieuwenhuis, I.L.C., Takashima, A., The role of the ventromedial prefrontal cortex in memory consolidation. Behavioural Brain Research 218:2 (2011), 325–334.
41. Parkinson, C., Sinnott-Armstrong, W., Koralus, P.E., Mendelovici, A., McGeer, V., Wheatley, T., Is morality unified? Evidence that distinct neural systems underlie moral judgments of harm, dishonesty, and disgust. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 23:10 (2011), 3162–3180.
42. Poldrack, R.A., Fletcher, P.C., Henson, R.N., Worsley, K.J., Brett, M., Nichols, T.E., Guidelines for reporting an fMRI study. Neuroimage 40:2 (2008), 409–414.
43. Prehn, K., Wartenburger, I., Mériau, K., Scheibe, C., Goodenough, O.R., Villringer, A., et al. Individual differences in moral judgment competence influence neural correlates of socio-normative judgments. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 3:1 (2008), 33–46.
44. Pujol, J., Reixach, J., Harrison, B.J., Timoneda-Gallart, C., Vilanova, J.C., Pérez-Alvarez, F., Posterior cingulate activation during moral dilemma in adolescents. Human brain mapping 29:8 (2008), 910–921.
45. Pujol, J., Batalla, I., Contreras-Rodríguez, O., Harrison, B.J., Pera, V., Hernández-Ribas, R., et al. Breakdown in the brain network subserving moral judgment in criminal psychopathy. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 7:8 (2012), 917–923.
46. Raine, A., Yang, Y., Neural foundations to moral reasoning and antisocial behavior. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 1:3 (2006), 203–213.
47. Reniers, R.L.E.P., Corcoran, R., Völlm, B.A., Mashru, A., Howard, R., Liddle, P.F., Moral decision-making, ToM, empathy and the default mode network. Biological Psychology 90:3 (2012), 202–210.
48. Robertson, D., Snarey, J., Ousley, O., Harenski, K., Bowman, F.D., Gilkey, R., et al. The neural processing of moral sensitivity to issues of justice and care. Neuropsychologia 45:4 (2007), 755–766.
49. Saxe, R., Powell, L.J., It's the thought that counts specific brain regions for one component of theory of mind. Psychological Science 17:8 (2006), 692–699.
50. Schleim, S., Spranger, T.M., Erk, S., Walter, H., From moral to legal judgment: The influence of normative context in lawyers and other academics. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 6:1 (2011), 48–57.
51. Schneider, K., Pauly, K. D., Gossen, A., Mevissen, L., Michel, T. M., Gur, R. C., et al. (2012). Neural correlates of moral reasoning in autism spectrum disorder. Social cognitive and affective neuroscience, nss051.
52. Sevinc, G., & Spreng, R. N. (2014). Contextual and perceptual brain processes underlying moral cognition: a quantitative meta-analysis of moral reasoning and moral emotions.
53. Smetana, J.G., Social-cognitive domain theory: Consistencies and variations in children's moral and social judgments. Killen, M., Smetana, J.G., (eds.) Handbook of moral development, 2006, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey London, 119–155.
54. Sommer, M., Meinhardt, J., Rothmayr, C., Döhnel, K., Hajak, G., Rupprecht, R., et al. Me or you? Neural correlates of moral reasoning in everyday conflict situations in adolescents and adults. Social Neuroscience 9:5 (2014), 452–470.
55. Sommer, M., Rothmayr, C., Döhnel, K., Meinhardt, J., Schwerdtner, J., Sodian, B., et al. How should I decide? The neural correlates of everyday moral reasoning. Neuropsychologia 48:7 (2010), 2018–2026.
56. Springer, J.A., Binder, J.R., Hammeke, T.A., Swanson, S.J., Frost, J.A., Bellgowan, P.S., et al. Language dominance in neurologically normal and epilepsy subjects. Brain 122:11 (1999), 2033–2046.
57. Takahashi, H., Kato, M., Matsuura, M., Koeda, M., Yahata, N., Suhara, T., et al. Neural correlates of human virtue judgment. Cerebral Cortex 18:8 (2008), 1886–1891.
58. Talati, A., Hirsch, J., Functional specialization within the medial frontal gyrus for perceptual go/no-go decisions based on “what”, “when”, and “where” related information: An fMRI study. Journal of cognitive neuroscience 17:7 (2005), 981–993.
59. Tassy, S., Oullier, O., Mancini, J., Wicker, B., Discrepancies between judgment and choice of action in moral dilemmas. Frontiers in Psychology, 4, 2013.
60. Turiel, E., The development of social knowledge: Morality and convention. 1983, Cambridge University Press.
61. Turkeltaub, P.E., Eickhoff, S.B., Laird, A.R., Fox, M., Wiener, M., Fox, P., Minimizing within-experiment and within-group effects in activation likelihood estimation meta-analyses. Human Brain Mapping 33:1 (2012), 1–13.
62. Verdejo-Garcia, A., Contreras-Rodriguez, O., Fonseca, F., Cuenca, A., Soriano-Mas, C., Rodriguez, J., et al. Functional alteration in frontolimbic systems relevant to moral judgment in cocaine-dependent subjects. Addiction Biology 19:2 (2014), 272–281.
63. Visser, M., Jefferies, E., Embleton, K.V., Ralph, M.A.L., Both the middle temporal gyrus and the ventral anterior temporal area are crucial for multimodal semantic processing: Distortion-corrected fMRI evidence for a double gradient of information convergence in the temporal lobes. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 24:8 (2012), 1766–1778.
64. Wei, T., Liang, X., He, Y., Zang, Y., Han, Z., Caramazza, A., et al. Predicting conceptual processing capacity from spontaneous neuronal activity of the left middle temporal gyrus. The Journal of Neuroscience 32:2 (2012), 481–489.
65. Wellman, H.M., Cross, D., Watson, J., Meta-analysis of theory-of-mind development: The truth about false belief. Child Development 72:3 (2001), 655–684.
66. Young, L., Dungan, J., Where in the brain is morality? Everywhere and maybe nowhere. Social Neuroscience 7:1 (2012), 1–10.