Is it Trauma- or Fantasy-based? Comparing dissociative identity disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, simulators, and controls

Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica

Volumn 134, Issue 2, 2016, Pages 111-128

  Vissia, E M ^a   Giesen, M E ^a   Chalavi, S ^a,b   Nijenhuis, E R S ^c   Draijer, N ^d   Brand, B L ^e   Reinders, A A T S ^a,f  

^a UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER GRONINGEN   (Netherlands)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LEUVEN   (Belgium)

^c Psychiatrische Klinik   (Switzerland)

^d VU UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

^e TOWSON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^f KING'S COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

dissociative identity disorder; etiology; patient simulation; post traumatic stress disorder

Indexed keywords

ADULT; AGED; ARTICLE; CLINICAL ARTICLE; CLINICAL ASSESSMENT TOOL; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CONTROLLED STUDY; EMPIRICAL RESEARCH; FALSE MEMORY; FANTASY; FEMALE; HUMAN; MALINGERING; MULTIPLE PERSONALITY; NEUTRAL PERSONALITY STATE; POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PSYCHOLOGIC TEST; PSYCHOTRAUMA; QUESTIONNAIRE; SCORING SYSTEM; TRAUMA RELATED PERSONALITY STATE;

EID: 84977657068     PISSN: 0001690X     EISSN: 16000447     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/acps.12590     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: DSM 5. 2013.
2. Spiegel D, Loewenstein RJ, Lewis-Fernandez R et al. Dissociative disorders in DSM-5. Depress Anxiety 2011;28:E17–E45.
3. Lanius RA, Vermetten E, Loewenstein RJ et al. Emotion modulation in PTSD: clinical and neurobiological evidence for a dissociative subtype. Am J Psychiatry 2010;167:640–647.
4. Lanius RA, Brand B, Vermetten E, Frewen PA, Spiegel D. The dissociative subtype of posttraumatic stress disorder: rationale, clinical and neurobiological evidence, and implications. Depress Anxiety 2012;29:701–708.
5. Wolf EJ, Miller MW, Reardon AF, Ryabchenko KA, Castillo D, Freund R. A latent class analysis of dissociation and posttraumatic stress disorder: evidence for a dissociative subtype. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2012;69:698–705.
6. Wolf EJ, Lunney CA, Miller MW, Resick PA, Friedman MJ, Schnurr PP. The dissociative subtype of PTSD: a replication and extension. Depress Anxiety 2012;29:679–688.
7. Boon S, Draijer N. Multiple personality disorder in The Netherlands: a clinical investigation of 71 patients. Am J Psychiatry 1993;150:489–494.
8. Putnam FW, Guroff JJ, Silberman EK, Barban L, Post RM. The clinical phenomenology of multiple personality disorder: review of 100 recent cases. J Clin Psychiatry 1986;47:285–293.
9. Ross CA, Norton GR, Wozney K. Multiple personality disorder: an analysis of 236 cases. Can J Psychiatry 1989;34:413–418.
10. Giesbrecht T, Lynn SJ, Lilienfeld SO, Merckelbach H. Cognitive processes in dissociation: an analysis of core theoretical assumptions. Psychol Bull 2008;134:617–647.
11. Lynn SJ, Lilienfeld SO, Merckelbach H, Giesbrecht T, Kloet DVD. Dissociation and dissociative disorders: challenging conventional wisdom. Curr Direct Psychol Sci 2012;21:48–53.
12. Dalenberg CJ, Brand BL, Gleaves DH et al. Evaluation of the evidence for the trauma and fantasy models of dissociation. Psychol Bull 2012;138:550–588.
13. Reinders AATS. Cross-examining dissociative identity disorder: neuroimaging and etiology on trial. Neurocase 2008;14:44–53.
14. Boysen GA, Vanbergen A. A review of published research on adult dissociative identity disorder: 2000–2010. J Nerv Ment Dis 2013;201:5–11.
15. Dorahy MJ, Brand BL, Sar V et al. Dissociative identity disorder: an empirical overview. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2014;48:402–417.
16. Chalavi S, Vissia EM, Giesen ME et al. Abnormal hippocampal morphology in dissociative identity disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder correlates with childhood trauma and dissociative symptoms. Hum Brain Mapp 2015;36:1692–1704.
17. Reinders AATS, Willemsen AT, den Boer JA, Vos HP, Veltman DJ, Loewenstein RJ. Opposite brain emotion-regulation patterns in identity states of dissociative identity disorder: a PET study and neurobiological model. Psychiatry Res 2014;223:236–243.
18. Chalavi S, Vissia EM, Giesen ME et al. Similar cortical but not subcortical gray matter abnormalities in women with posttraumatic stress disorder with versus without dissociative identity disorder. Psychiatry Res 2015;231:308–319.
19. Schlumpf YR, Nijenhuis ERS, Chalavi S et al. Dissociative part-dependent biopsychosocial reactions to backward masked angry and neutral faces: an fMRI study of dissociative identity disorder. Neuroimage Clin 2013;3:54–64.
20. Schlumpf YR, Reinders AATS, Nijenhuis ERS, Luechinger R, van Osch MJ, Jancke L. Dissociative part-dependent resting-state activity in dissociative identity disorder: a controlled FMRI perfusion study. PLoS ONE 2014;9:e98795.
21. Nijenhuis ERS. The trinity of trauma: ignorance, fragility, and control the evolving concept of trauma/the concept and facts of dissociation in trauma. 1st edn. Goettingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2015.
22. Spanos NP. Multiple identity enactments and multiple personality disorder: a sociocognitive perspective. Psychol Bull 1994;116:143–165.
23. Reinders AATS, Willemsen AT, Vos HP, den Boer JA, Nijenhuis ERS. Fact or factitious? A psychobiological study of authentic and simulated dissociative identity states. PLoS ONE 2012;7:e39279.
24. Brand BL, McNary SW, Loewenstein RJ, Kolos AC, Barr SR. Assessment of genuine and simulated dissociative identity disorder on the structured interview of reported symptoms. J Trauma Dissociation 2006;7:63–85.
25. Huntjens RJ, Verschuere B, McNally RJ. Inter-identity autobiographical amnesia in patients with dissociative identity disorder. PLoS ONE 2012;7:e40580.
26. Brand BL, Tursich M, Tzall D, Loewenstein RJ. Utility of the SIRS-2 in distinguishing genuine from simulated dissociative identity disorder. 2014.
27. Brand BL, Chasson GS. Distinguishing simulated from genuine dissociative identity disorder on the MMPI-2. Psychol Trauma 2015;7:93–101.
28. Lynn SJ, Lilienfeld SO, Merckelbach H et al. The trauma model of dissociation: inconvenient truths and stubborn fictions. Comment on Dalenberg et al. (2012). Psychol Bull 2014;140:896–910.
29. Dalenberg CJ, Brand BL, Loewenstein RJ et al. Reality versus fantasy: reply to Lynn et al. (2014). Psychol Bull 2014;140:911–920.
30. Janet P. L'amnesie et la dissociation des souvenirs par l’ émotion. 1904;I:417–453.
31. Hilgard ER. Divided consciousness: multiple controls in human thought and action. New York: Wiley, 1977.
32. Draijer N, Boon S. Imitation of dissociative identity disorder: patients at risk, therapists at risk. J Psychiatry & Law 1999;27:423–458.
33. Merckelbach H, À Campo J, Hardy S, Giesbrecht T. Dissociation and fantasy proneness in psychiatric patients: a preliminary study. Compr Psychiatry 2005;46:181–185.
34. Chalavi S, Simmons A, Dijkstra H, Barker GJ, Reinders AATS. Quantitative and qualitative assessment of structural magnetic resonance imaging data in a two-center study. BMC Med Imaging 2012;12:27.
35. Reinders AATS, Nijenhuis ERS, Quak J et al. Psychobiological characteristics of dissociative identity disorder: a symptom provocation study. Biol Psychiatry 2006;60:730–740.
36. Van Der Hart O, Nijenhuis ERS, Steele K. The haunted self: structural dissociation and the treatment of chronic traumatization. 2006.
37. Steinberg M. Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV dissociative disorders (SCID-D). 1993.
38. Boon S, Draijer N. Gestructureerd klinisch interview voor de vaststelling van DSM-IV Dissociatieve stoornissen (SCID-D). 1994.
39. Reinders AATS, Nijenhuis ERS, Paans AM, Korf J, Willemsen AT, den Boer JA. One brain, two selves. NeuroImage 2003;20:2119–2125.
40. Bernstein EM, Putnam FW. Development, reliability and validity of a dissociation scale. J Nerv Ment Dis 1986;174:727–735.
41. Nijenhuis ER, Spinhoven P, van Dyck R, van der Hart O, Vanderlinden J. The development and psychometric characteristics of the Somatoform Dissociation Questionnaire (SDQ-20). J Nerv Ment Dis 1996;184:688–694.
42. Nijenhuis ER, Spinhoven P, van Dyck R, van der Hart O, Vanderlinden J. The development of the somatoform dissociation questionnaire (SDQ-5) as a screening instrument for dissociative disorders. Acta Psychiatr Scand 1997;96:311–318.
43. Nijenhuis ERS, Van Der Hart O, Kruger K. The psychometric characteristics of the Traumatic Experiences Questionnaire (TEC): first findings among psychiatric outpatients. Clin Psychol Psychother 2002;9:200–210.
44. Spielberger CD, Gorsuch RL, Lushene R, Vagg PR, Jacobs GA. Manual for the state-trait anxiety inventory. 1983.
45. Huntjens RJ, Peters ML, Woertman L, Bovenschen LM, Martin RC, Postma A. Inter-identity amnesia in dissociative identity disorder: a simulated memory impairment? Psychol Med 2006;36:857–863.
46. Boysen GA, Vanbergen A. Simulation of multiple personalities: a review of research comparing diagnosed and simulated dissociative identity disorder. Clin Psychol Rev 2014;34:14–28.
47. Mierendorf M. Surviving with a split personality. 1993.
48. Petrie D. Sybil. 1976.
49. Blake DD, Weathers FW, Nagy LM et al. A clinician rating scale for assessing current and lifetime PTSD: the CAPS-1. J Behav Ther 1990;13:187–188.
50. Blake DD, Weathers FW, Nagy LM et al. The development of a clinician-administered PTSD Scale. J Trauma Stress 1995;8:75–90.
51. Hovens JE, Luinge B, Van Minnen A. Het klinisch interview voor PTSS (KIP). 2005.
52. Bernstein DP, Fink L. Childhood trauma questionnaire. A retrospective self-report. 1998.
53. Beck AT, Ward CH, Mendelson M, Mock J, Erbaugh J. An inventory for measuring depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1961;4:561–571.
54. Parker G, Tupling H, Brown LB. A parental bonding instrument. Brit J Med Psychol 1979;52:1–10.
55. Bernstein DP, Fink L, Handelsman L et al. Initial reliability and validity of a new retrospective measure of child abuse and neglect. Am J Psychiatry 1994;151:1132–1136.
56. Watson D. Dissociations of the night: individual differences in sleep-related experiences and their relation to dissociation and schizotypy. J Abnorm Psychol 2001;110:526–535.
57. Merckelbach H, Horselenberg R, Muris P. The Creative Experiences Questionnaire (CEQ): a brief self-report measure of fantasy proneness. Pers Individ Dif 2001;31:987–995.
58. Smith GP. Assessment of malingering with self-report instruments. In: Rogers R, ed. Clinical assessment of malingering and deception. New York: Guilford, 1997:351–370.
59. Smith GP, Bruger GK. Detection of malingering: validation of the Structured Inventory of Malingered Symptomatology (SIMS). J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 1997;25:180–183.
60. Gudjonsson GH. A new scale of interrogative suggestibility. Pers Individ Dif 1984;5:303–314.
61. Deese J. On the prediction of occurrence of particular verbal intrusions in immediate recall. J Exp Psychol 1959;58:17–22.
62. Roediger HL, McDermott KB. Creating false memories: remembering words not presented in lists. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 1995;24:803–814.
63. Duijsens IJ, Eurelings-Bontekoe EHM, Diekstra RFW. The VKP, a self-report instrument for DSM-III-R and CD-10 personality disorders: construction and psychometric properties. Pers Individ Dif 1996;20:171–182.
64. Dell PF. Axis II pathology in outpatients with dissociative identity disorder. J Nerv Ment Dis 1998;186:352–356.
65. Kay SR, Fiszbein A, Opler LA. The positive and negative syndrome scale (PANSS) for schizophrenia. Schizophr Bull 1987;13:261–276.
66. Moskowitz A, Schafer I, Dorahy MJ. Psychosis, Trauma and dissociation: emerging perspectives on severe psychopathology. West Sussex: John Wiley and Sons Ltd, 2008.
67. Perona-Garcelan S, Carrascoso-Lopez F, Garcia-Montes JM et al. Dissociative experiences as mediators between childhood trauma and auditory hallucinations. J Trauma Stress 2012;25:323–329.
68. Varese F, Barkus E, Bentall RP. Dissociation mediates the relationship between childhood trauma and hallucination-proneness. Psychol Med 2012;42:1025–1036.
69. Van Heugten-Van Der Kloet D, Huntjens R, Giesbrecht T, Merckelbach H. Self-reported sleep disturbances in patients with dissociative identity disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder and how they relate to cognitive failures and fantasy proneness. Front Psychiatry 2014;5:19.
70. Kluft RP. First-rank symptoms as a diagnostic clue to multiple personality disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1987;144:293–298.
71. Ross CA, Miller SD, Reagor P, Bjornson L, Fraser GA, Anderson G. Schneiderian symptoms in multiple personality disorder and schizophrenia. Compr Psychiatry 1990;31:111–118.
72. Ellason JW, Ross CA. Positive and negative symptoms in dissociative identity disorder and schizophrenia: a comparative analysis. J Nerv Ment Dis 1995;183:236–241.
73. Ohayon MM, Shapiro CM. Sleep disturbances and psychiatric disorders associated with posttraumatic stress disorder in the general population. Compr Psychiatry 2000;41:469–478.
74. Agargun MY, Kara H, Ozer OA, Selvi Y, Kiran U, Kiran S. Nightmares and dissociative experiences: the key role of childhood traumatic events. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2003;57:139–145.
75. Koffel E, Watson D. Unusual sleep experiences, dissociation, and schizotypy: evidence for a common domain. Clin Psychol Rev 2009;29:548–559.
76. Holmes EA, Brown RJ, Mansell W et al. Are there two qualitatively distinct forms of dissociation? A review and some clinical implications. Clin Psychol Rev 2005;25:1–23.
77. Roediger HL, McDermott KB, Robinson KJ. The role of associative processes in creating false memories. In: Conway MA, Gathercole SE, Cornoldi C, eds. Theories of memory, vol. II. Hove, Sussex, UK: Psychological Press, 1998:187–245.
78. van der Hart O, Nijenhuis ER, Steele K. Dissociation: an insufficiently recognized major feature of complex posttraumatic stress disorder. J Trauma Stress 2005;18:413–423.
79. Boon S, Draijer N. Multiple personality disorder in the Netherlands. 1993.
80. Spiegel D. Multiple personality as a post-traumatic stress disorder. Psychiatr Clin North Am 1984;7:101–110.
81. Sar V, Akyuz G, Kundakci T, Kiziltan E, Dogan O. Childhood trauma, dissociation, and psychiatric comorbidity in patients with conversion disorder. Am J Psychiatry 2004;161:2271–2276.
82. Draijer N, Langeland W. Childhood trauma and perceived parental dysfunction in the etiology of dissociative symptoms in psychiatric inpatients. Am J Psychiatry 1999;156:379–385.
83. Dorahy MJ, Shannon C, Seagar L et al. Auditory hallucinations in dissociative identity disorder and schizophrenia with and without a childhood trauma history: similarities and differences. J Nerv Ment Dis 2009;197:892–898.
84. Read J, van Os J, Morrison AP, Ross CA. Childhood trauma, psychosis and schizophrenia: a literature review with theoretical and clinical implications. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2005;112:330–350.
85. Daalman K, Diederen KM, Derks EM, van Lutterveld R, Kahn RS, Sommer IE. Childhood trauma and auditory verbal hallucinations. Psychol Med 2012;42:2475–2484.
86. Ellason JW, Ross CA, Fuchs DL. Lifetime axis I and II comorbidity and childhood trauma history in dissociative identity disorder. Psychiatry 1996;59:255–266.
87. Allen JG, Huntoon J, Evans RB. Complexities in complex posttraumatic stress disorder in inpatient women: evidence from cluster analysis of MCMI-III personality disorder scales. J Pers Assess 1999;73:449–471.
88. Herman JL, Perry JC, van der Kolk BA. Childhood trauma in borderline personality disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1989;146:490–495.
89. Elzinga BM, van Dyck R, Spinhoven P. Three controversies about dissociative identity disorder. Clin Psychol Psychother 1998;5:13–23.
90. Galbraith PM, Neubauer PJ. Underwriting considerations for dissociative disorders. J Insur Med 2000;32:71–78.
91. Bozkurt H, Duzman Mutluer T, Kose C, Zoroglu S. High psychiatric comorbidity in adolescents with dissociative disorders. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2015;69:369–374.
92. Ross CA, Norton GR. Differences between men and women with multiple personality disorder. Hosp Community Psychiatry 1989;40:186–188.
93. Loewenstein RJ, Putnam FW. The clinical phenomenology of males with MPD: A report of 21 cases. Dissociation: Progress Dissociative Disorders 1990;3:135–143.