Integrating Mechanical and Ergonomic Research within Functional and Morphological Analyses of Lithic Cutting Technology: Key Principles and Future Experimental Directions

Ethnoarchaeology

Volumn 8, Issue 1, 2016, Pages 69-89

  Key, Alastair J M ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF KENT   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Efficiency; Ergonomics; Experiment; Fracture mechanics; Morphology; Stone tool

Indexed keywords

EID: 84971422142     PISSN: 19442890     EISSN: 19442904     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/19442890.2016.1150626     Document Type: Article

References (97)

1. N.W.Ackerly, Neal W. 1978. “Controlling Pressure in Experimental Lithics Research.” American Antiquity 43 (3): 480–482.
2. A.Agam, Avid, O.MarderOfer, and R.BarkaiRan. 2015. “Small Flake Production and Lithic Recycling at Late Acheulian Revadim, Israel.” Quaternary International 361: 46–60.
3. A.Aguilera, Alfredo, and P.MartinPatrik. 2001. “Machining Qualification of Solid Wood of Fagus Silvatica L. and Picea Excelsa L.: Cutting Forces, Power Requirements and Surface Roughness.” Holz als Roh-und Werkstoff 59: 483–488.
4. Y.Aldien,, D.Welcome, S.Rakheja, R.Dong, and P.-E.Boileau. 2005. “Contact Pressure Distribution at Hand-handle Interface: Role of Hand Forces and Handle Size.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 35 (3): 267–286.
5. K.Y.Ang, Kai Y., P.W.LucasPeter W., and H.T.W.TanHugh T. W. 2006. “Incisal Orientation and Biting Efficiency.” Journal of Human Evolution 50 (6): 663–672.
6. T.Atkins, Tony. 2006. “Optimum Blade Configurations for the Cutting of Soft Solids.” Engineering Fracture Mechanics 73 (16): 2523–2531.
7. T.Atkins, Tony. 2009. The Science and Engineering of Cutting: The Mechanics and Processes of Separating, Scratching and Puncturing Biomaterials, Metals and Non-metals. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.
8. A.G.Atkins, Anthony G., X.Xu, and G.JeronimidisGeorge. 2004. “Cutting, by “Pressing and Slicing’, of Thin Floppy Slices of Materials Illustrated by Experiments on Cheddar Cheese and Salami.” Journal of Materials Science 39 (8): 2761–2766.
9. L.R.Binford, Lewis R., and S.R.BinfordSally R. 1966. “A Preliminary Analysis of Functional Variability in the Mousterian of Levallois Facies.” American Anthropologist 68 (2): 238–295.
10. J.R.Blackwell, John R., K.W.KornatzKurt W., and E.M.HeathEdward M. 1999. “Effect of Grip Span on Maximal Grip Force and Fatigue of Flexor Digitorum Superficialis.” Applied Ergonomics 30 (5): 401–405.
11. P.Bleed, Peter, and A.BleedAnn. 1987. “Energetic Efficiency and Hand Tool Design: A Performance Comparison of Push and Pull Stroke Saws." Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 6: 189–197.
12. A.T.Boldurian, Anthony T. 1991. “Folsom Mobility and Organization of Lithic Technology: A View from Blackwater Draw, New Mexico.” Plains Anthropologist 36 (137): 281–295.
13. A.Borel, Antony, C.GaillardClaire, M.-H.MoncelMarie-Hélèn, R.SalaRobert, E.PouydebatEmmanuelle, T.SimanjuntakTruman, and F.SémahFrançois. 2013. “How to Interpret Informal Flakes Assemblages? Integrating Morphological Description, Usewear and Morphometric Analysis Gave Better Understanding of the Behaviours of Anatomically Modern Human from Song Terus (Indonesia).” Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 32 (4): 630–646.
14. D.R.Braun, David R., B.L.PobinerBriana L., and J.C.ThompsonJessica C. 2008. “An Experimental Investigation of cut Mark Production and Stone Tool Attrition.” Journal of Archaeological Science 35 (5): 1216–1223.
15. N.Broadbent, Noel, and K.KnutssonKjel. 1975. An Experimental Analysis of Quartz Scrapers: Results and Applications. Fornvännen 70 (3–4): 113–128.
16. L.Claudon, Laurent, and J.MarsotJacques. 2006. “Effect of Knife Sharpness on Upper Limb Biomechanical Stresses – A Laboratory Study.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 36 (3): 239–246.
17. S.Collins, Sophie. 2008. “Experimental Investigations Into Edge Performance and its Implications for Stone Artefact Reduction Modelling.” Journal of Archaeological Science 35 (8): 2164–2170.
18. B.Cotterell, Brian, and J.KammingaJohan. 1987. “The Formation of Flakes.” American Antiquity 52 (4): 675–708.
19. B.Cotterell, Brian, and J.KammingaJohan 1990. Mechanics of Pre-industrial Technology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20. D.E.Crabtree, Don E. 1977. “The Obtuse Angle as a Functional Edge.” In Experimental Archaeology, edited by D.IngersollDaniel, J.E.YellenJohn E., and W.MacdonaldWilliam, 38–51. New York: Columbia University Press.
21. D.E.Crabtree, Don E., and E.L.DavisEmma L. 1968. “Experimental Manufacture of Wooden Implements with Tools of Flaked Stone.” Science 159 (3813): 426–428.
22. R.H.Crompton, Robin H., and J.A.J.GowlettJohn A. J. 1993. “Allometry and Multidimensional Form in Acheulean Bifaces from Kilombe, Kenya.” Journal of Human Evolution 25 (3): 175–199.
23. A.G.Dewbury, Adam G., and N.RussellNerissa. 2007. “Relative Frequency of Butchering Cutmarks Produced by Obsidian and Flint: An Experimental Approach.” Journal of Archaeological Science 34 (3): 354–357.
24. H.L.Dibble, Harold L., and M.C.BernardMary C. 1980. “A Comparative Study of Basic Edge Angle Measurement Techniques.” American Antiquity 45 (4): 857–865.
25. H.L.Dibble, Harold L., and A.PelcinAndrew. 1995. “The Effect of Hammer Mass and Velocity on Flake Mass.” Journal of Archaeological Science 22 (3): 429–439.
26. C.S.Edgren, Cally S., R.G.RadwinRobert G. and C.B.IrwinCurtis B. 2004. “Grip Force Vectors for Varying Handle Diameters and Hand Sizes.” Human Factors 46 (2): 244–251.
27. M.Eksioglu, Mahmut. 2004. “Relative Optimum Grip Span as a Function of Hand Anthropometry.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 34 (1): 1–12.
28. M.I.Eren, Metin I. 2013. “The Technology of Stone Age Colonization: An Empirical, Regional-scale Examination of Clovis Unifacial Stone Tool Reduction, Allometry, and Edge Angle from the North American Lower Great Lakes Region.” Journal of Archaeological Science 40 (4): 2101–2112.
29. M.I.Eren, Metin I., A.GreenspanAaron, and C.Garth Sampson. 2008. “Are Upper Paleolithic Blade Cores More Productive Than Middle Paleolithic Discoidal Cores? A Replication Experiment.” Journal of Human Evolution 55 (6): 952–961.
30. M.I.Eren, Metin I., and S.J.LycettStephen J. in press. “A Statistical Examination of Flake Edge Angles Produced During Experimental Lineal Levallois Reductions and Consideration of Their Functional Implications.” Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory. doi:10.1007/s10816-015-9245-z.
31. N.K.Fowler,, C.Alexander B.C.Nicol, B. Condon, and D.Hadley. 2001. “Method of Determination of Three Dimensional Index Finger Moment Arms and Tendon Lines of Action using High Resolution MRI Scans.” Journal of Biomechanics 43: 791–797.
32. J.Freund, Jouni, R.ToivonenRisto, and E.-P.TakalaEsa-Pekka. 2002. “Grip Forces and Finger Tips.” Clinical Biomechanics 17 (7): 515–520.
33. B.Goislard de Monsabert, Benjamin, L.VigourouxLaurent, D.BendahanDavid, and E.BertonEric. 2014. “Quantification of Finger Joint Loadings using Musculoskeletal Modelling Clarifies Mechanical Risk Factors of Hand Osteoarthritis.” Medical Engineering and Physics 36 (2): 177–184.
34. R.A.Gould, Richard A., D.A.KosterDorothy A. and A.H.L.SontzAnn H. L. 1971. “The Lithic Assemblages of the Western Desert Aborigines of Australia.” American Antiquity 36 (2): 149–169.
35. J.A.J.Gowlett, John A. J. 2006. “The Elements of Design Form in Acheulian Bifaces: Modes, Modalities, Rules and Language.” In Axe Age: Acheulean Tool Making from Quarry to Discard, edited by N.Goren-InbarNaama and G.SharonGonen, 203–221. London: Equinox.
36. J.A.J.Gowlett, John A. J., and R.H.CromptonRobin H. 1994. “Kariandusi: Acheulean Morphology and the Question of Allometry.” African Archaeological Review 12 (1): 3–42.
37. K.A.Grant, Katharyn A., and D.J.HabesDaniel J. 1993. “Effectiveness of a Handle Flange for Reducing Manual Effort During Hand Tool use.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 12 (3): 199–207.
38. K.A.Grant, Katharyn A., and D.J.HabesDaniel J. 1997. “An Electromyographic Study of Strength and Upper Extremity Muscle Activity in Simulated Meat Cutting Tasks.” Applied Ergonomics 28 (2): 129–137.
39. C.Hall, Charlotte. 1997. “External Pressure at the Hand During Object Handling and Work with Tools.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 20 (3): 191–206.
40. S.Harmand, Sonia, J.E.LewisJason E., C.S.FeibelCraig S., C.J.LepreChristopher J., S.PratSandine, A.LenobleArnaud, X.BoësXavier, 2015. “3.3-million-year-old Stone Tools from Lomekwi 3, West Turkana, Kenya.” Nature 521 (7552): 310–315.
41. P.Hiscock, Peter. 2004. “Slippery and Billy: Intention, Selection and Equifinality in Lithic Artefacts.” Cambridge Archaeology Journal 14: 71–77.
42. S.Holdaway, Simon, and M.DouglassMatthew. 2012. “A Twenty-first Century Archaeology of Stone Artifacts.” Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 19 (1): 101–131.
43. W.K.Hutchings, W. Karl. 2015. “Finding the Paleoindian Spearthrower: Quantitative Evidence for Mechanically-assisted Propulsion of Lithic Armatures During the North American Paleoindian Period.” Journal of Archaeological Science 55: 34–41.
44. R.Iovita, Radu. 2014. “The Role of Edge Angle Maintenance in Explaining Technological Variation in the Production of Later Middle Paleolithic Bifacial and Unifacial Tools.” Quaternary International 350: 105–115.
45. T.A.Jennings, Thomas A. 2011. “Experimental Production of Bending and Radial Flake Fractures and Implications for Lithic Technologies.” Journal of Archaeological Science 38 (12): 3644–3651.
46. T.A.Jennings, Thomas A. 2013. “The Hogeye Clovis Cache, Texas: Quantifying Lithic Reduction Signatures.” Journal of Archaeological Science 40 (1): 649–658.
47. H.J.Jensen, Helle J. 1986. “Unretouched Blades in the Late Mesolithic of South Scandinavia. A Functional Study.” Oxford Journal of Archaeology 5 (1): 19–33.
48. R.J.Jeske, 1992. “Energetic Efficiency and Lithic Technology: An Upper Mississippian Example.” American Antiquity 57 (3): 467–481.
49. R.W.Jobson, Robert W. 1986. “Stone Tool Morphology and Rabbit Butchering.” Lithic Technology 15 (1): 9–20.
50. P.R.Jones, Peter R. 1980. “Experimental Butchery with Modern Stone Tools and its Relevance for Palaeolithic Archaeology.” World Archaeology 12 (2): 153–165.
51. P.R.Jones, Peter R 1994. “Results of Experimental Work in Relation to the Stone Industries of Olduvai Gorge.” In Olduvai Gorge: Excavations in Beds III, IV and the Masek Beds 1968–1971, edited by M.D.LeakeyMary D. and D.A.RoeDerek A., 254–298. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
52. Keeley, Lawrence H. 1980. Experimental Determination of Stone Tool Uses: A Microwear Analysis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
53. A.J.M.Key, Alastair J. M. 2015. Form and Function in the Lower Palaeolithic: An Experimental Assessment of the Performance Attributes and Behavioural Consequences of Stone Tool Forms in the Lower Palaeolithic. PhD diss., University of Kent.
54. A.J.M.Key, Alastair J. M., and S.J.LycettStephen J. 2014. “Are Bigger Flakes Always Better? An Experimental Assessment of Flake Size Variation on Cutting Efficiency and Loading.” Journal of Archaeological Science 41 (1): 140–146.
55. A.J.M.Key, Alastair J. M., W.James Stemp, M.MorozovMikhail, T.ProffittTomos, and I.de la TorreIgnacio. 2015. “Is Loading a Significantly Influential Factor in the Development of Lithic Microwear? An Experimental Test using LSCM on Basalt from Olduvai Gorge.” Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 22 (4): 1193–1214.
56. A.J.M.Key, Alastair J. M., and S.J.LycettStephen J. 2011. “Technology Based Evolution? A Biometric Test of the Effects of Handsize Versus Tool Form on Efficiency in an Experimental Cutting Task.” Journal of Archaeological Science 38 (7): 1663–1670.
57. A.J.M.Key, Alastair J. M., and S.J.LycettStephen J. 2015. “Edge Angle as a Variably Influential Factor in Flake Cutting Efficiency: An Experimental Investigation of its Relationship with Tool Size and Loading.” Archaeometry 57 (5): 911–927.
58. A.J.M.Key, Alastair J. M., and S.J.LycettStephen J. in press. “Reassessing the Production of Handaxes Versus Flakes from a Functional Perspective.” Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences. doi:10.1007/s12520-0150300-1.
59. S.C.Lin, Sam C., Z.RezekZeljho, D.BraunDavid, and H.L.DibbleHarold L. 2013. “On the Utility and Economization of Unretouched Flakes: The Effects of Exterior Platform Angle and Platform Depth.” American Antiquity 78 (4): 724–745.
60. C.Lorenzo, Carlos, A.PablosAdrian, J.M.CarreteroJosé M., R.HuguetRosa, J.ValverduJosep, M.Martinón-TorresMaria, J.L.ArsuagaJuan L., E.CarbonellEudald, and J.B.de CastroJosé Bermúdez. 2015. “Early Pleistocene Human Hand Phalanx from the Sima del Elefante (TE) Cave Site in Sierra de Atapuerca (Spain).” Journal of Human Evolution 78: 114–121.
61. A.J.Machin, Anna J., R.T.HosfieldRobert T., and S.J.MithenSteven J. 2007. “Why are Some Handaxes Symmetrical? Testing the Influence of Handaxe Morphology on Butchery Effectiveness.” Journal of Archaeological Science 34 (6): 883–893.
62. M.Magnusson, Marianne, R.Ortengren, G.B.J.AnderssonGunnar B. J., I.Petersén, and B.Sabel. 1987. “An Ergonomic Study of Work Methods and Physical Disorders among Professional Butchers.” Applied Ergonomics 18 (1): 43–50.
63. Y.-W.Mai, Yiu-Wing, and A.G.AtkinsAnthony G. 1989. “Further Comments on J-shaped Stress-strain Curves and the Crack Resistance of Biological Materials.” Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 22 (1): 48–54.
64. M.W.Marzke, Mary W., L.F.MarchantLinda F., W.C.McGrewWilliam C., and S.P.ReeceSandra P. 2015. “Grips and Hand Movements of Chimpanzees During Feeding in Mahale Mountains National Park, Tanzania.” American Journal of Physical Anthropology 156 (3): 317–326.
65. C.T.McCarthy, Conor T., A.N.AnnaidhAisling N., and M.D.GilchristMichael D. 2010. “On the Sharpness of Straight Edge Blades in Cutting Soft Solids: Part II – Analysis of Blade Geometry.” Engineering Fracture Mechanics 77 (3): 437–451.
66. C.T.McCarthy, Conor T., M.Hussey, M.D.GilchristMichael D. 2007. “On the Sharpness of Straight Edge Blades in Cutting Soft Solids: Part I – Indentation Experiments.” Engineering Fracture Mechanics 74 (14): 2205–2224.
67. R.W.McGorry, Raymond W. 2001. “A System for the Measurement of Grip Forces and Applied Moments During Hand Tool use.” Applied Ergonomics 32 (3): 271–279.
68. R.W.McGorry, Raymond W., P.G.DempseyPatrick G., and N.V.O'BrienNiall V. 2004. “The Effect of Workstation and Task Variable on Forces Applied During Simulated Meat Cutting.” Ergonomics 47 (15): 1640–1656.
69. R.W.McGorry, Raymond W., P.C.DowdPeter C., and P.G.DempseyPatrick G. 2003. “Cutting Moments and Grip Forces in Meat Cutting Operations and the Effect of Knife Sharpness.” Applied Ergonomics 34 (4): 375–382.
70. R.W.McGorry, Raymond W., P.C.DowdPeter C., and P.G.DempseyPatrick G. 2005. “The Effect of Blade Finish and Blade Angle on Forces Used in Meat Cutting Operations.” Applied Ergonomics 36 (1): 71–77.
71. S.R.Merritt, Stephen R. 2012. “Factors Affecting Early Stone Age cut Mark Cross-sectional Size: Implications from Actualistic Butchery Trials.” Journal of Archaeological Science 39 (9): 2984–2994.
72. A.Ollé, Andreu, and J.M.VergèsJosep M. 2008. “SEM Functional Analysis and the Mechanisms of Microwear Formation.” Prehistoric Technology 40: 39–49.
73. A.Picin, Aandrea, M.PeresaniMarco, and M.VaqueroManuel. 2011. “Application of a New Typological Approach to Classifying Denticulate and Notched Tools: The Study of two Mousterian Lithic Assemblages.” Journal of Archaeological Science 38 (3): 711–722.
74. G.A.Reilly,, B.A.O.McCormack,, and D.Taylor, 2004. “Cutting Sharpness Measurement: A Critical Review.” Journal of Materials Processing Technology 153–154: 261–267.
75. S.A.Rosen, Steven A. 1982. “Flint Sickle-blades of the Late Protohistoric and Early Historic Periods in Israel.” Tel Aviv 9 (2): 139–145.
76. J.Rossi,, B.G.de MonsabertBenjamin Goislard, E.BertonEric, and L.VigourouxLaurent. 2014. “Does Handle Shape Influence Prehensile Capabilities and Muscle Coordination?” Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering 17 (1): 172–173.
77. S.Schuldt, Stefan, G.ArnoldGunther, J.RoschyJohannes, Y.SchneiderYvonne, and H.RohmHarold. 2013. “Defined Abrasion Procedures for Cutting Blades and Comparative Mechanical and Geometrical Wear Characterization.” Wear 300 (1–2): 38–43.
78. N.J.Seo, Na J., and T.J.ArmstrongThomas J. 2008. “Investigation of Grip Force, Normal Force, Contact Area, Hand Size, and Handle Size for Cylindrical Handles.” Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 50 (5): 734–744.
79. J.J.Shea, John J. 2006. “The Origins of Lithic Projectile Point Technology: Evidence from Africa, the Levant, and Europe.” Journal of Archaeological Science 33 (6): 823–846.
80. J.J.Shea, John J. 2007. “Lithic Archaeology, or, What Stone Tools can (and Can't) Tell us About Early Hominin Diets.” In Evolution of the Human Diet: The Known, the Unknown, and the Unknowable, edited by P.S.UngarPeter S., 212–229. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
81. P.H.Shelley, Phillip H. 1990. “Variation in Lithic Assemblages: An Experiment.” Journal of Field Archaeology 17 (2): 187–193.
82. O.A.Shergold, Oliver A., and N.A.FleckNorman A. 2004. “Mechanisms of Deep Penetration of Soft Solids, with Application to the Injection and Wounding of Skin.” Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 460 (2050): 3037–3058.
83. R.W.Shumaker, Robert W., K.R.WalkupKristina R., and B.B.BeckBenjamin B. 2011. Animal Tool Use Behaviour: The Use and Manufacture of Tools by Animals. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
84. P.E.Siegel, Peter E. 1985. “Edge Angle Analysis as a Functional Indicator: A Test.” Lithic Technology 14 (2): 90–94.
85. M.L.Sisk, Matthew L., and J.J.SheaJohn J. 2009. “Experimental use and Quantitative Performance Analysis of Triangular Flakes (Levallois Points) Used as Arrowheads.” Journal of Archaeological Science 36 (9): 2039–2047.
86. W.J.Stemp, W. James, M.MorozovMikhail, and A.J.M.KeyAlastair J. M. 2015. “Quantifying Lithic Microwear with Load Variation on Experimental Basalt Flakes using LSCM and Area-scale Fractal Complexity (Asfc).” Surface Topography: Metrology and Properties 3 (3): 034006.
87. W.J.Stemp, W. James, and M.StempMichael. 2003. “Documenting Stages of Polish Development on Experimental Stone Tools: Surface Characterization by Fractal Geometry using UBM Laser Profilometry.” Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (3): 287–296.
88. D.Stout, Dietrich, S.SemawSileshi, M.J.RogersMichael J., and D.CaucheDominique. 2010. “Technological Variation in the Earliest Oldowan from Gona, Afar, Ethiopia.” Journal of Human Evolution 58 (6): 474–491.
89. S.A.Tomka, Steven A. 2001. “The Effect of Processing Requirements on Reduction Strategies and Tool Form: A New Perspective.” In Lithic Debitage: Context, Form, Meaning, edited by W.AndrefskyWilliam, 207–224. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
90. R.Torrence, Robin. 1989. “Re-tooling: Towards a Behavioural Theory of Stone Tools.” In Time, Energy, and Stone Tools, edited by R.TorrenceRobin, 57–66. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
91. N.Toth, Nicholas. 1985. “The Oldowan Reassessed: A Close Look at Early Stone Artifacts.” Journal of Archaeological Science 12 (2): 101–120.
92. R.Tringham, Ruth, G.CooperGlenn, G.OdellGeorge, B.VoytekBarbara, and A.WhitmanAnne. 1974. “Experimentation in the Formation of Edge Damage: A New Approach to Lithic Analysis.” Journal of Field Archaeology 1 (1–2): 171–196.
93. C.D.Vaughan, C. David. 2001. “A Million Years of Style and Function: Regional and Temporal Variation in Acheulean Handaxes.” In Style and Function: Conceptual Issues in Evolutionary Archaeology, edited by T.D.HurtTeresa D. and G.F.M.RakitaGordon F. M., 141–163. Westport: Bergin and Garvey.
94. L.Vigouroux, Laurent, M.DomalainMathieu, and E.BertonEric. 2011. “Effect of Object Width on Muscle and Joint Forces During Thumb-index Finger Grasping.” Journal of Applied Biomechanics 27 (3): 173–180.
95. P.L.Walker, Philip L. 1978. “Butchering and Stone Tool Function.” American Antiquity 43 (4): 710–715.
96. C.V.Ward, Carol V., M.W.TocheriMatthew W., J.Michael Plavcan, F.H.BrownFrancis H., and F.K.ManthiFredrick K. 2014. “Early Pleistocene Third Metacarpal from Kenya and the Evolution of Modern Human-like Hand Morphology.” PNAS 111 (1): 121–124.
97. E.N.Wilmsen, Edwin N. 1968. ‘Functional Analysis of Flaked Stone Artifacts.’ American Antiquity 33 (2): 156–161.