Nurse staffing and patient outcomes: Strengths and limitations of the evidence to inform policy and practice. A review and discussion paper based on evidence reviewed for the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence Safe Staffing guideline development

International Journal of Nursing Studies

Volumn 63, Issue , 2016, Pages 213-225

  Griffiths, Peter ^a   Ball, Jane ^a   Drennan, Jonathan ^a   Dall'Ora, Chiara ^a   Jones, Jeremy ^a   Maruotti, Antonello ^a,d   Pope, Catherine ^a   Recio Saucedo, Alejandra ^a   Simon, Michael ^b,c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF BERN   (Switzerland)

^c UNIVERSITY OF BASEL   (Switzerland)

^d LUMSA UNIVERSITY   (Italy)

Author keywords

Cost benefit analysis; Diagnosis related groups; Economics, nursing; Manpower; Medical staff; National health programs; Nursing personnel; Patient safety; Review, systematic

Indexed keywords

CASE MIX; CONSENSUS DEVELOPMENT; CONTROLLED STUDY; DOCTOR PATIENT RELATION; HUMAN; NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE; NURSING STAFF; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; QUANTITATIVE STUDY; SCIENTIST; UNITED KINGDOM; WARD; COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; ENGLAND; HEALTH CARE PLANNING; HEALTH ECONOMICS; HOSPITAL PATIENT; NURSING; PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT; STANDARDS; TRENDS;

COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; ECONOMICS, NURSING; ENGLAND; HEALTH PLANNING GUIDELINES; INPATIENTS; NURSING; NURSING STAFF, HOSPITAL; PERSONNEL STAFFING AND SCHEDULING;

EID: 84964637764     PISSN: 00207489     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2016.03.012     Document Type: Note

References (86)

1. Aiken, L.H., Clarke, S.P., Sloane, D.M., Sochalski, J., Silber, J.H., Hospital nurse staffing and patient mortality, nurse burnout, and job dissatisfaction. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 288:16 (2002), 1987–1993.
2. Aiken, L.H., Sermeus, W., Van den Heede, K., Sloane, D.M., Busse, R., McKee, M., Bruyneel, L., Rafferty, A.M., Griffiths, P., Moreno-Casbas, M.T., Tishelman, C., Scott, A., Brzostek, T., Kinnunen, J., Schwendimann, R., Heinen, M., Zikos, D., Sjetne, I.S., Smith, H.L., Kutney-Lee, A., Patient safety, satisfaction, and quality of hospital care: cross sectional surveys of nurses and patients in 12 countries in Europe and the United States. BMJ, 344(7851), 2012, e1717.
3. Aiken, L.H., Sloane, D.M., Bruyneel, L., Van den Heede, K., Griffiths, P., Busse, R., Diomidous, M., Kinnunen, J., Kozka, M., Lesaffre, E., McHugh, M.D., Moreno-Casbas, M.T., Rafferty, A.M., Schwendimann, R., Scott, P.A., Tishelman, C., van Achterberg, T., Sermeus, W., consortium, R.C., Nurse staffing and education and hospital mortality in nine European countries: a retrospective observational study. Lancet 383:9931 (2014), 1824–1830.
4. Aiken, L.H., Sloane, D.M., Cimiotti, J.P., Clarke, S.P., Flynn, L., Seago, J.A., Spetz, J., Smith, H.L., Implications of the California nurse staffing mandate for other states. Health Serv. Res. 45:4 (2010), 904–921.
5. Antonakis, J., Bendahan, S., Jacquart, P., Lalive, R., On making causal claims: a review and recommendations. Leadersh. Q. 21:6 (2010), 1086–1120.
6. Ausserhofer, D., Schubert, M., Desmedt, M., Blegen, M.A., De, G.S., Schwendimann, R., The association of patient safety climate and nurse-related organizational factors with selected patient outcomes: a cross-sectional survey. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 50:2 (2013), 240–252.
7. Aylin, P., Bottle, A., Majeed, A., Use of administrative data or clinical databases as predictors of risk of death in hospital: comparison of models. BMJ, 334(7602), 2007, 1044.
8. Ball, J.E., Murrells, T., Rafferty, A.M., Morrow, E., Griffiths, P., ‘Care left undone’ during nursing shifts: associations with workload and perceived quality of care. BMJ Qual. Saf. 23:2 (2014), 116–125.
9. Blegen, M.A., Goode, C., Spetz, J., Vaughn, T., Park, S.H., Nurse Staffing effects on patient outcomes: safety-net and non-safety net hospitals. Med. Care 49:4 (2011), 406–414.
10. Blegen, M.A., Vaughn, T., A multisite study of nurse staffing and patient occurrences. Nurs. Econ. 16:4 (1998), 196–203.
11. Blegen, M.A., Vaughn, T., Vojir, C.P., Nurse staffing levels: impact of organizational characteristics and registered nurse supply. Health Serv. Res. 43:1 Pt 1 (2008), 154–173.
12. Bond, C., Raehl, C.L., Pitterle, M.E., Franke, T., Health care professional staffing, hospital characteristics, and hospital mortality rates. Pharmacotherapy 19:2 (1999), 130–138.
13. Bottle, A., Jarman, B., Aylin, P., Strengths and weaknesses of hospital standardised mortality ratios. BMJ, 342, 2011.
14. Bowers, L., Crowder, M., Nursing staff numbers and their relationship to conflict and containment rates on psychiatric wards—a cross sectional time series Poisson regression study. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 49:1 (2012), 15–20.
15. Bruyneel, L., Li, B., Ausserhofer, D., Lesaffre, E., Dumitrescu, I., Smith, H.L., Sloane, D.M., Aiken, L.H., Sermeus, W., Organization of hospital nursing, provision of nursing care, and patient experiences with care in Europe. Med. Care Res. Rev. 72:6 (2015), 643–664.
16. Chang, S.-J., van Witteloostuijn, A., Eden, L., From the editors: common method variance in international business research. J. Int. Bus. Stud. 41:2 (2010), 178–184.
17. Cho, S.H., Ketefian, S., Barkauskas, V.H., Smith, D.G., The effects of nurse staffing on adverse events, morbidity, mortality, and medical costs. Nurs. Res. 52:2 (2003), 71–79.
18. Clarke, S.P., Failure to rescue: lessons from missed opportunities in care. Nurs. Inq. 11:2 (2004), 67–71.
19. Claxton, K., Martin, S., Soares, M., Rice, N., Spackman, E., Hinde, S., Devlin, N., Smith, P.C., Sculpher, M., Methods for the estimation of the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence cost-effectiveness threshold. Health Technol. Assess., 19(14), 2015.
20. Cook, A., Gaynor, M., Stephens, M. Jr., Taylor, L., The effect of a hospital nurse staffing mandate on patient health outcomes: evidence from California's minimum staffing regulation. J. Health Econ. 31:2 (2012), 340–348.
21. Dall, T., Chen, Y., Seifert, R., Maddox, P., Hogan, P., The economic value of professional nursing. Med. Care 47:1 (2009), 97–104.
22. Donaldson, N., Bolton, L.B., Aydin, C., Brown, D., Elashoff, J.D., Sandhu, M., Impact of California's licensed nurse-patient ratios on unit-level nurse staffing and patient outcomes. Policy Polit. Nurs. Pract. 6:3 (2005), 198–210.
23. Donaldson, N., Shapiro, S., Impact of California mandated acute care hospital nurse staffing ratios: a literature synthesis. Policy Polit. Nurs. Pract. 11:3 (2010), 184–201.
24. Duffield, C., Diers, D., O'Brien-Pallas, L., Aisbett, C., Roche, M., King, M., Aisbett, K., Nursing staffing, nursing workload, the work environment and patient outcomes. Appl. Nurs. Res. 24:4 (2011), 244–255.
25. Edwardson, S.R., Giovannetti, P.B., Nursing workload measurement systems. Annu. Rev. Nurs. Res. 12:1 (1994), 95–123.
26. Estabrooks, C.A., Midodzi, W.K., Cummings, G.G., Ricker, K.L., Giovannetti, P., The impact of hospital nursing characteristics on 30-day mortality. Nurs. Res. 54:2 (2005), 74–84.
27. Fasoli, D.R., Haddock, K.S., Results of an integrative review of patient classification systems. Annu. Rev. Nurs. Res. 28 (2010), 295–316.
28. Friese, C.R., Lake, E.T., Aiken, L.H., Silber, J.H., Julie Sochalski, Hospital nurse practice environments and outcomes for surgical oncology patients. Health Serv. Res. 43:4 (2008), 1145–1163.
29. Frith, K.H., Anderson, E.F., Caspers, B., Tseng, F., Sanford, K., Hoyt, N.G., Moore, K., Effects of nurse staffing on hospital-acquired conditions and length of stay in community hospitals. Qual. Manag. Health Care 19:2 (2010), 147–155.
30. Frith, K.H., Anderson, E.F., Tseng, F., Fong, E.A., Nurse staffing is an important strategy to prevent medication error in community hospitals. Nurs. Econ. 30:5 (2012), 288–294.
31. Goryakin, Y., Griffiths, P., Maben, J., Economic evaluation of nurse staffing and nurse substitution in health care: a scoping review. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 48:4 (2011), 501–512.
32. Griffiths, P., Ball, J., Drennan, J., James, L., Jones, J., Recio-Saucedo, A., Simon, M., The Association Between Patient Safety Outcomes and Nurse/Healthcare Assistant Skill Mix and Staffing Levels and Factors That May Influence Staffing Requirements (NICE Evidence Review). 2014, University of Southampton Centre for Innovation and Leadership in Health Sciences.
33. Griffiths, P., Dall'Ora, C., Simon, M., Ball, J., Lindqvist, R., Rafferty, A.M., Schoonhoven, L., Tishelman, C., Aiken, L.H., RN4Cast Consortium. Nurses’ shift length and overtime working in 12 European countries: the association with perceived quality of care and patient safety. Med. Care 52:11 (2014), 975–981.
34. Griffiths, P., Dawoud, D., Murrells, T., Jones, S., Hospital admissions for asthma, diabetes and COPD: is there an association with practice nurse staffing?. A cross sectional study using routinely collected data. BMC Health Serv. Res., 10(276), 2010, 10.1186/1472-6963-1110-1276.
35. Griffiths, P., Jones, S., Bottle, A., Is failure to rescue derived from administrative data in England a nurse sensitive patient safety indicator for surgical care? Observational study. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 50:2 (2013), 292–300.
36. Griffiths, P., Maben, J., Murrells, T., Organisational quality, nurse staffing and the quality of chronic disease management in primary care: observational study using routinely collected data. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 48:10 (2011), 1199–1210.
37. Griffiths, P., Murrells, T., Maben, J., Jones, S., Ashworth, M., Nurse staffing and quality of care in UK general practice: cross-sectional study using routinely collected data. Br. J. Gen. Pract. 60:1 (2010), e36–e48.
38. Griffiths, P., Simon, M., Richardson, A., Corner, J., Is a larger specialist nurse workforce in cancer care associated with better patient experience? Cross-sectional study. J. Health Serv. Res. Policy 18:Suppl. 1 (2013), 39–46.
39. Hart, P., Davis, N., Effects of nursing care and staff skill mix on patient outcomes within acute care nursing units. J. Nurs. Care Qual. 26:2 (2011), 161–168.
40. He, J., Almenoff, P.L., Keighley, J., Li, Y.-F., Impact of patient-level risk adjustment on the findings about nurse staffing and 30-day mortality in Veterans affairs acute care hospitals. Nurs. Res. 62:4 (2013), 226–232 210.1097/NNR.1090b1013e318295810c.
41. Hill, A.B., The environment and disease: association or causation?. Proc. R. Soc. Med. 58:5 (1965), 295–300.
42. Ibe, T., Ishizaki, T., Oku, H., Ota, K., Takabatake, Y., Iseda, A., Ishikawa, Y., Ueda, A., Predictors of pressure ulcer and physical restraint prevalence in Japanese acute care units. Jpn. J. Nurs. Sci. 5:2 (2008), 91–98.
43. Jarman, B., Gault, S., Alves, B., Hider, A., Dolan, S., Cook, A., Hurwitz, B., Iezzoni, L.I., Explaining differences in English hospital death rates using routinely collected data. BMJ 318:7197 (1999), 1515–1520.
44. Johnson, M.L., Crown, W., Martin, B.C., Dormuth, C.R., Siebert, U., Good research practices for comparative effectiveness research: analytic methods to improve causal inference from nonrandomized studies of treatment effects using secondary data sources: the ISPOR Good Research Practices for Retrospective Database Analysis Task Force Report—Part III. Value Health 12:8 (2009), 1062–1073.
45. Joint Commission, Issues and Strategies for Nurse Leaders: Meeting Hospital Challenges Today. 2005, The Joint Commission, Oakbrook Terrace, IL.
46. Jones, T.L., Hamilton, P., Murry, N., Unfinished nursing care, missed care, and implicitly rationed care: state of the science review. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 52:6 (2015), 1121–1137.
47. Kane, R.L., Shamliyan, T.A., Mueller, C., Duval, S., Wilt, T.J., The association of registered nurse staffing levels and patient outcomes: systematic review and meta-analysis. Med. Care 45:12 (2007), 1195–1204 1110.1097/MLR.1190b1013e3181468ca3181463.
48. Keogh, B., Review into the quality of care and treatment provided by 14 hospital trusts in England: overview report. 2013, NHS.
49. Kutney-Lee, A., Sloane, D.M., Aiken, L.H., An increase in the number of nurses with baccalaureate degrees is linked to lower rates of postsurgery mortality. Health Aff. 32:3 (2013), 579–586.
50. Lake, E., Shang, J., Klaus, S., Dunton, N., Patient falls: association with hospital Magnet status and nursing unit staffing. Res. Nurs. Health 33:5 (2010), 413–425.
51. Lintern, S., Revealed: NICE safe staffing work cost £1m. Health Serv. J.(June), 2015 http://www.hsj.co.uk/news/revealed-nice-safe-staffing-work-cost-1m/5086796.article#.VctqGflVikp.
52. Mark, B.A., Harless, D.W., Spetz, J., Reiter, K.L., Pink, G.H., California's minimum nurse staffing legislation: results from a natural experiment. Health Serv. Res. 48:2 Pt 1 (2013), 435–454.
53. McGillis Hall, L., Doran, D., Pink, G.H., Nurse staffing models, nursing hours, and patient safety outcomes. J. Nurs. Adm. 34:1 (2004), 41–45.
54. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, Developing NICE Guidelines: The Manual. 2014, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, London.
55. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), Safe Staffing for Nursing in Adult Inpatient Wards in Acute Hospitals (Guidance). 2014, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, London.
56. National Nursing Research Unit, Is it time to set minimum nurse staffing levels in English hospitals?. Policy+(34), 2012.
57. Needleman, J., Buerhaus, P., Pankratz, V.S., Leibson, C.L., Stevens, S.R., Harris, M., Nurse staffing and inpatient hospital mortality. N. Engl. J. Med. 364:11 (2011), 1037–1045.
58. Needleman, J., Buerhaus, P., Stewart, M., Zelevinsky, K., Stewart, M., Nurse staffing in hospitals: is there a business case for quality?. Health Aff. 25:1 (2006), 204–211.
59. O'Brien-Pallas, L., Li, X.M., Wang, S., Meyer, R.M., Thomson, D., Evaluation of a patient care delivery model: system outcomes in acute cardiac care. Can. J. Nurs. Res. 42:4 (2010), 98–120.
60. Ozdemir, B.A., Sinha, S., Karthikesalingam, A., Poloniecki, J.D., Pearse, R.M., Grocott, M.P.W., Thompson, M.M., Holt, P.J.E., Mortality of emergency general surgical patients and associations with hospital structures and processes. Br. J. Anaesth. 116:1 (2016), 54–62.
61. Park, S.H., Blegen, M.A., Spetz, J., Chapman, S.A., De Groot, H., Patient turnover and the relationship between nurse staffing and patient outcomes. Res. Nurs. Health 35:3 (2012), 277–288.
62. Patrician, P.A., Loan, L., McCarthy, M., Fridman, M., Donaldson, N., Bingham, M., Brosch, L.R., The association of shift-level nurse staffing with adverse patient events. J. Nurs. Adm. 41:2 (2011), 64–70.
63. Potter, P., Barr, N., McSweeney, M., Sledge, J., Identifying nurse staffing and patient outcome relationships: a guide for change in care delivery. Nurs. Econ. 21:4 (2003), 158–166.
64. Rafferty, A.M., Clarke, S.P., Coles, J., Ball, J., James, P., McKee, M., Aiken, L.H., Outcomes of variation in hospital nurse staffing in English hospitals: cross-sectional analysis of survey data and discharge records. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 44:2 (2007), 175–182.
65. Recio-Saucedo, A., Pope, C., Dall'Ora, C., Griffiths, P., Jones, J., Crouch, R., Drennan, J., Safe staffing for nursing in emergency departments: evidence review. Emerg. Med. J. 32:11 (2015), 888–894.
66. Royal College of Nursing, Guidance on Safe Nurse Staffing Levels in the UK. 2010, RCN, London.
67. Sales, A., Sharp, N., Li, Y.F., Lowy, E., Greiner, G., Liu, C.F., Alt-White, A., Rick, C., Sochalski, J., Mitchell, P.H., Rosenthal, G., Stetler, C., Cournoyer, P., Needleman, J., The association between nursing factors and patient mortality in the Veterans Health Administration: the view from the nursing unit level. Med. Care 46:9 (2008), 938–945.
68. Sasichay-Akkadechanunt, T., Scalzi, C.C., Jawad, A.F., The relationship between nurse staffing and patient outcomes. J. Nurs. Adm., 33(9), 2003, 478.
69. Seago, J.A., Williamson, A., Atwood, C., Longitudinal analyses of nurse staffing and patient outcomes: more about failure to rescue. J. Nurs. Adm. 36:1 (2006), 13–21.
70. Shamliyan, T.A., Kane, R.L., Mueller, C., Duval, S., Wilt, T.J., Cost savings associated with increased RN staffing in acute care hospitals: simulation exercise. Nurs. Econ. 27:5 (2009), 302–314.
71. Shekelle, P.G., Nurse–patient ratios as a patient safety strategy: a systematic review. Ann. Intern. Med. 158:5 Pt 2 (2013), 404–409.
72. Simon, M., Ball, J., Drennan, J., Jones, J., Recio-Saucedo, A., Griffiths, P., Effectiveness of Management Approaches and Organisational Factors on Nurse Sensitive Outcomes (NICE Evidence Review). 2014, University of Southampton Centre for Innovation and Leadership in Health Sciences.
73. Sochalski, J., Konetzka, R.T., Zhu, J., Volpp, K., Will mandated minimum nurse staffing ratios lead to better patient outcomes?. Med. Care 46:6 (2008), 606–613.
74. Spetz, J., Harless, D.W., Herrera, C.-N., Mark, B.A., Using minimum nurse staffing regulations to measure the relationship between nursing and hospital quality of care. Med. Care Res. Rev. 70:4 (2013), 380–399.
75. Spilsbury, K., Hewitt, C., Stirk, L., Bowman, C., The relationship between nurse staffing and quality of care in nursing homes: a systematic review. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 48:6 (2011), 732–750.
76. State of California, AB 394: an act to add Section 2725.3 to the Business and Professions Code and to add Section 1276.4 to the Health and Safety Code, relating to health care. AB 394, 1999 California.
77. The Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Inquiry chaired by Robert Francis QC, Independent Inquiry into Care Provided by Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust January 2005–March 2009. 2010, The Stationary Office, London.
78. The Shelford Group, Safer Nursing Care Tool Implementation Resource Pack. 2014, The Shelford Group.
79. Tschannen, D., Kalisch, B.J., Lee, K.H., Missed nursing care: the impact on intention to leave and turnover. Can. J. Nurs. Res. 42:4 (2010), 22–39.
80. Twigg, D., Duffield, C., Bremner, A., Rapley, P., Finn, J., The impact of the nursing hours per patient day (NHPPD) staffing method on patient outcomes: a retrospective analysis of patient and staffing data. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 48:5 (2011), 540–548.
81. Twigg, D.E., Geelhoed, E.A., Bremner, A.P., Duffield, C.M., The economic benefits of increased levels of nursing care in the hospital setting. J. Adv. Nurs. 69:10 (2013), 2253–2261.
82. Twigg, D.E., Myers, H., Duffield, C., Giles, M., Evans, G., Is there an economic case for investing in nursing care – what does the literature tell us?. J. Adv. Nurs. 71:5 (2015), 975–990.
83. Unruh, L., Joseph, L., Strickland, M., Nurse absenteeism and workload: negative effect on restraint use, incident reports and mortality. J. Adv. Nurs. 60:6 (2007), 673–681.
84. Weiss, M.E., Yakusheva, O., Bobay, K.L., Quality and cost analysis of nurse staffing, discharge preparation, and postdischarge utilization. Health Serv. Res. 46:5 (2011), 1473–1494.
85. West, M.A., Borrill, C., Dawson, J., Scully, J., Carter, M., Anelay, S., Patterson, M., Waring, J., The link between the management of employees and patient mortality in acute hospitals. Int. J. Hum. Resour. Manag. 13:8 (2002), 1299–1310.
86. You, L.-m., Aiken, L.H., Sloane, D.M., Liu, K., He, G.-p., Hu, Y., Jiang, X.-l., Li, X.-h., Li, X.-m., Liu, H.-p., Shang, S.-m., Kutney-Lee, A., Sermeus, W., Hospital nursing, care quality, and patient satisfaction: cross-sectional surveys of nurses and patients in hospitals in China and Europe. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 50:2 (2013), 154–161.