Uncertainty in structural interpretation: Lessons to be learnt

Journal of Structural Geology

Volumn 74, Issue , 2015, Pages 185-200

  Bond, Clare E ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ABERDEEN   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Interpretation; Models; Structure; Uncertainty

Indexed keywords

GEOLOGIC MODELS; MODELS; STRUCTURE (COMPOSITION);

EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE; GEOLOGICAL DATA; GEOLOGICAL MODELING; INTERPRETATION; INTERPRETATION ERRORS; LIMITED RESOLUTION; STRUCTURAL INTERPRETATION; UNCERTAINTY;

GEOLOGY;

DATA INTERPRETATION; DATA SET; REMOTE SENSING; SOFTWARE; STRUCTURAL GEOLOGY; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

EID: 84961289896     PISSN: 01918141     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jsg.2015.03.003     Document Type: Review

References (121)

1. Allan U.S. Model for hydrocarbon migration and entrapment within faulted structures. AAPG Bull. 1989, 73:803-811.
2. Allmendinger R.W. Inverse and forward numerical modeling of trishear fault-propagation folds. Tectonics 1998, 17:640-656.
3. Baddeley M.C., Curtis A., Wood R. An Introduction to Prior Information Derived from Probabilistic Judgements: Elicitation of Knowledge, Cognitive Bias and Herding 2004, 15-27. Geological Society, London, Special Publications 239.
4. Baker K.M., Libarkin J.C., Petcovic H. Geologic mapping strategies of novices and experts as evidenced through GPS track and map analysis. Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs 2007, vol. 39:557.
5. Bally A.W., Gordy P., Stewart G.A. Structure, seismic data, and orogenic evolution of southern Canadian rocky mountains. Bull. Can. Petrol. Geol. 1966, 14:337-381.
6. Beach A., Welbon A.I., Brockbank P.J., McCallum J.E. Reservoir damage around faults: outcrop examples from the Suez rift. Pet. Geosci. 1999, 5:109-116.
7. Billi A., Salvini F., Storti F. The damage zone-fault core transition in carbonate rocks: implications for fault growth, structure and permeability. J.Struct. Geol. 2003, 25:1779-1794.
8. Bistacchi A., Massironi M., Dal Piaz G.V., Dal Piaz G., Monopoli B., Schiavo A., Toffolon G. 3D fold and fault reconstruction with an uncertainty model: an example from an Alpine tunnel case study. Comput. Geosci. 2008, 34:351-372.
9. Black A.A. Spatial ability and earth science conceptual understanding. J.Geosci. Educ. 2005, 53:402.
10. Bond C.E., Shipton Z., Jones R., Butler R., Gibbs A. Knowledge transfer in a digital world: field data acquisition, uncertainty, visualization, and data management. Geosphere 2007, 3:568-576.
11. Bond C.E., Gibbs A., Shipton Z., Jones S. What do you think this is?"Conceptual uncertainty'in geoscience interpretation. GSA Today 2007, 17:4.
12. Bond C., Shipton Z., Gibbs A., Jones S. Structural models: optimizing risk analysis by understanding conceptual uncertainty. First Break 2008, 26:65-71.
13. Bond C.E., Philo C., Shipton Z.K. When there isn't a right answer: interpretation and reasoning, key skills for twenty-first century geoscience. Int. J. Sci. Educ. 2011, 33:629-652.
14. Bond C.E., Lunn R., Shipton Z., Lunn A. What makes an expert effective at interpreting seismic images?. Geology 2012, 40:75-78.
15. Bond C.E., Johnson G., Ellis J.F. Structural model creation: the impact of data type and creative space on geological reasoning and interpretation. Geol. Soc. Lond. Special Publ. 2015, 421. 10.1144/SP421.4.
16. Butler R.W.H. Area balancing as a test of models for the deep structure of mountain belts, with specific reference to the alps. J.Struct. Geol. 2013, 52:2-16.
17. Butler R., Paton D. Evaluating lateral compaction in deepwater fold and thrust belts: how much are we missing from "nature's sandbox"?. GSA Today 2010, 20:4-10.
18. Byers W. The Blind Spot: Science and the Crisis of Uncertainty 2011, Princeton University Press.
19. Caers J. Modeling Uncertainty in the Earth Sciences 2011, Wiley.
20. Caine J.S., Evans J.P., Forster C.B. Fault zone architecture and permeability structure. Geology 1996, 24:1025-1028.
21. Cardozo N., Brandenburg J.P. Kinematic modeling of folding above listricpropagating thrusts. J. Struct. Geol. 2014, 60:1-12. 10.1016/j.jsg.2013.12.004.
22. Chadwick P. Apsychological analysis of observation in geology. Nature 1975, 256:570-573.
23. Chamberlin R.T. The appalachian folds of central Pennsylvania. J.Geol. 1910, 228-251.
24. Chamberlin T.C. The method of multiple working hypotheses. Science 1965, 148:754-759.
25. Chapman T.J., Williams G.D. Displacement-distance methods in the analysis of fold-thrust structures and linked-fault systems. J.Geol. Soc. 1984, 141:121-128.
26. Chiaruttini C., Roberto V., Buso M. Spatial and temporal reasoning techniques in geological modeling. Phys. Chem. Earth 1998, 23:261-266.
27. Childs C., Manzocchi T., Walsh J.J., Bonson C.G., Nicol A., Schöpfer M.P. Ageometric model of fault zone and fault rock thickness variations. J.Struct. Geol. 2009, 31:117-127.
28. Cowie P.A., Shipton Z.K. Fault tip displacement gradients and process zone dimensions. J.Struct. Geol. 1998, 20:983-997.
29. Geological Prior Information: Informing Science and Engineering 2004, Geological Society, London, Special Publications 239. A. Curtis, R. Wood (Eds.).
30. Curtis A., Wood R. Optimal Elicitation of Probabilistic Information from Experts 2004, 127-145. Geological Society, London, Special Publications 239.
31. Curtis A. The science of subjectivity. Geology 2012, 40:95-96.
32. Dahlstrom C. Balanced cross sections. Can. J. Earth Sci. 1969, 6:743-757.
33. Der Kiureghian A., Ditlevsen O. Aleatory or epistemic? Does it matter?. Special Workshop on Risk Acceptance and Risk Communication. March 26-27, 2007 2007, Stanford University, (accessed February 201). http://www.ripid.ethz.ch/Paper/DerKiureghian_paper.pdf.
34. Elliott D. The energy balance and deformation mechanisms of thrust sheets. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. A Math. Phys. Sci. 1976, 283:289-312.
35. Erslev E.A. Trishear fault-propagation folding. Geology 1991, 19:617-620.
36. Fischer M.P., Wilkerson M.S. Predicting the orientation of joints from fold shape: results of pseudo-three-dimensional modeling and curvature analysis. Geology 2000, 28:15-18.
37. Fletcher R.C., Pollard D.D. Can we understand structural and tectonic processes and their products without appeal to a complete mechanics?. J.Struct. Geol. 1999, 21:1071-1088.
38. Freeman B., Yielding G., Badley M. Fault correlation during seismic interpretation. First Break 1990, 8.
39. Freeman B., Boult P.J., Yielding G., Menpes S. Using empirical geological rules to reduce structural uncertainty in seismic interpretation of faults. J.Struct. Geol. 2010, 32:1668-1676.
40. Frodeman R. Geological reasoning: geology as an interpretive and historical science. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 1995, 107:960-968.
41. Gärling T., Selart M., Böök A. Investigating spatial choice and navigation in large-scale environments. Spatial Cognition in the Child and Adult 1997, vol. 1:153-176. Psychology in Press. N. Foreman, R. Gillet (Eds.).
42. Gigerenzer G., Gaissmaier W. Heuristic decision making. Annu. Rev. Psychol. 2011, 62:451-482. 10.1146/annurev-psych-120709-145346.
43. Gore A. An Inconvenient Truth: the Planetary Emergency of Global Warming and What We Can Do about it 2006, Rodale.
44. Groshong R.H., Bond C., Gibbs A., Ratliff R., Wiltschko D.V. Preface: structural balancing at the start of the 21st century: 100 years since Chamberlin. J.Struct. Geol. 2012, 41:1-5.
45. Hagen H., Hahmann S., Schreiber T., Nakajima Y., Wordenweber B., Hollemann-Grundstedt P. Surface interrogation algorithms. IEEE Comp Graph. Appl. 1992, 12(5):76-79. 10.1109/38.156013.
46. Hambrick D.Z., Libarkin J.C., Petcovic H.L., Baker K.M., Elkins J., Callahan C.N., Turner S.P., Rench T.A., LaDue N.D. Atest of the circumvention-of-limits hypothesis in scientific problem solving: the case of geological bedrock mapping. J.Exp. Psychol. General 2012, 141(3):397-403.
47. Hennings P.H., Olson J.E., Thompson L.B. Combining outcrop data and three-dimensional structural models to characterize fractured reservoirs: an example from Wyoming. AAPG Bull. 2000, 84:830-849.
48. Huang J., Turcotte D. Evidence for chaotic fault interactions in the seismicity of the San Andreas fault and Nankai trough. Nature 1990, 348:234-236.
49. Humphreys L.G., Lubinski D., Yao G. Utility of predicting group membership and the role of spatial visualization in becoming an engineer, physical scientist, or artist. J.Appl. Psychol. 1993, 78:250.
50. Hutton J. X.Theory of the earth; or an investigation of the laws observable in the composition, dissolution, and restoration of land upon the globe. Trans. R. Soc. Edinb. 1788, 1:209-304.
51. Iacopini D., Butler R.W. Imaging deformation in submarine thrust belts using seismic attributes. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 2011, 302:414-422.
52. Jackson M. Retrospective Salt Tectonics 1995.
53. Jamison W.R. Geometric analysis of fold development in overthrust terranes. J.Struct. Geol. 1987, 9:207-219.
54. Janssen P.H., Petersen A.C., van der Sluijs Jeroen P., Risbey J.S., Ravetz J.R. Aguidance for assessing and communicating uncertainties. Water Sci. Technol. 2005, 52:125-134.
55. Jessell M., Aillères L., de Kemp E., Lindsay M., Wellmann F., Hillier M., Martin R., Laurent G., Carmichael T., Martin R. Next Generation Three-dimensional Geologic Modeling and Inversion 2014, 261-272. Society of Economic Geologists, Inc, Special Publication 18.
56. Judge P.A., Allmendinger R.W. Assessing uncertainties in balanced cross sections. J.Struct. Geol. 2011, 33:458-467.
57. Earth and Mind II: a Synthesis of Research on Thinking and Learning in the Geosciences 2012, Geological Society of America Special Paper, 486. K. Kastens, C. Manduca (Eds.).
58. Kahneman D., Slovic P., Tversky A. Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases 1982, CUP, Cambridge.
59. Kim Y., Peacock D., Sanderson D.J. Mesoscale strike-slip faults and damage zones at Marsalforn, Gozo Island, Malta. J.Struct. Geol. 2003, 25:793-812.
60. Kim Y., Sanderson D.J. The relationship between displacement and length of faults: a review. Earth-Sci. Rev. 2005, 68:317-334.
61. Kostenko O.V., Naruk S.J., Hack W., Poupon M., Meyer H., Mora-Glukstad M., Anowai C., Mordi M. Structural evaluation of column-height controls at a toe-thrust discovery, deep-water Niger Delta. AAPG Bull. 2008, 92:1615-1638.
62. Krantz R.W. Multiple fault sets and three-dimensional strain: theory and application. J.Struct. Geol. 1988, 10:225-237.
63. Krueger J.I., Funder D.C. Social psychology: a field in search of a center. Behav. Brain Sci. 2004, 27:361-367.
64. Kuhn T.S. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (Chicago, 1962). KuhnThe Structure of Scientific Revolutions1962 1976.
65. Lark R.M., Mathers S.J., Thorpe S., Arkley S., Morgan D., Lawrence D. Astatistical assessment of the uncertainty in a 3-D geological framework model. Proc. Geol. Assoc. 2013, 124:946-958.
66. Lark R.M., Mathers S.J., Marchant A., Hulbert A. An index to represent lateral variation of the confidence of experts in a 3-D geological model. Proc. Geol. Assoc. 2014, 125(3):267-278. 10.1016/j.pgeola.2014.05.002.
67. Leahy G., Skorstad A. Uncertainty in subsurface interpretation: a new workflow. First Break 2013, 31.
68. Lelliott M., Cave M., Wealthall G. Astructured approach to the measurement of uncertainty in 3D geological models. Q.J. Eng. Geol. Hydrogeol. 2009, 42:95-105.
69. Libarkin J., Brick C. Research methodologies in science education: visualization and the geosciences. J.Geosci. Educ. 2002, 50:449-455.
70. Liben L.S., Titus S.J. The importance of spatial thinking for geoscience education: Insights from the crossroads of geoscience and cognitive science. Geol. Soc. Am. Special Pap. 2012, 486:51-70.
71. Liben L.S. Perceiving and representing horizontals: from laboratories to natural environments and back again. Ecol. Psychol. 2014, 26:158-166.
72. Lindsay M.D., Aillères L., Jessell M.W., de Kemp E.A., Betts P.G. Locating and quantifying geological uncertainty in three-dimensional models: analysis of the Gippsland Basin, southeastern Australia. Tectonophysics 2012, 546:10-27.
73. Lubinski D. Spatial ability and STEM: a sleeping giant for talent identification and development. Personal. Individ. Differ. 2010, 49:344-351.
74. MacEachren A.M. Visualizing uncertain information. Cartogr. Perspect. 1992, 10-19.
75. MacEachren A.M. Time as a cartographic variable. Vis. Geogr. Inform. Syst. 1994, 243.
76. MacEachren A.M., Robinson A., Hopper S., Gardner S., Murray R., Gahegan M., Hetzler E. Visualizing geospatial information uncertainty: what we know and what we need to know. Cartogr. Geogr. Inform. Sci. 2005, 32:139-160.
77. Macrae E.J. Uncertainty in Geoscience Interpretation: Statistical Quantification of the Factors that Affect Interpretational Ability and Their Application to the Oil and Gas Industry 2013, Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Strathclyde.
78. Maerten L., Pollard D.D., Maerten F. Digital mapping of three-dimensional structures of the chimney rock fault system, central Utah. J.Struct. Geol. 2001, 23:585-592.
79. Manduca C.A., Mogk D.W. Earth and Mind: How Geologists Think and Learn about the Earth 2006, Geological Society of America Special Paper 413.
80. Munier R., Stenberg L., Stanfors R., Milnes A.G., Hermanson J., Triumf C. Geological site descriptive model. A strategy for the model development during site investigations 2003, SKB Rapport R-03-07. 1402-3091.
81. Needham T., Yielding G., Fox R. Fault population description and prediction using examples from the offshore UK. J.Struct. Geol. 1996, 18:155-167.
82. Newell B.R., McDonald R.I., Brewer M., Hayes B.K. The Psychology of Environmental Decisions. Ann. Rev. Environ. Resour. 2014, 39:443-467. 10.1146/annurev-environ-010713-094623.
83. Pang A.T., Wittenbrink C.M., Lodha S.K. Approaches to uncertainty visualization. Vis. Comput. 1997, 13:370-390.
84. Peacock D. Displacements and segment linkage in strike-slip fault zones. J.Struct. Geol. 1991, 13:1025-1035.
85. Peacock D., Sanderson D. Displacements, segment linkage and relay ramps in normal fault zones. J.Struct. Geol. 1991, 13:721-733.
86. Pollack H.N. Uncertain Science... Uncertain World 2005, Cambridge University Press.
87. Polson D., Curtis A. Dynamics of uncertainty in geological interpretation. J.Geol. Soc. 2010, 167:5-10.
88. Rankey E., Mitchell J. That's why it's called interpretation: impact of horizon uncertainty on seismic attribute analysis. Lead. Edge 2003, 22:820-828.
89. Rapp D.N., Uttal D.H. Understanding and enhancing visualizations: two models of collaboration between earth science and cognitive science. Geol. Soc. Am. Special Pap. 2006, 413:121-127.
90. Refsgaard J.C., van der Sluijs Jeroen P., Højberg A.L., Vanrolleghem P.A. Uncertainty in the environmental modelling process-a framework and guidance. Environ. Model. Softw. 2007, 22:1543-1556.
91. Riggs E.M., Lieder C.C., Balliet R. Geologic problem solving in the field: analysis of field navigation and mapping by advanced undergraduates. J.Geosci. Educ. 2009, 57:48-63.
92. Rowbotham P., Kane P., Bentley M. Bias in geophysical interpretation-the case for multiple deterministic scenarios. Lead. Edge 2010, 29:590-595.
93. Rumsfeld D. DoD News Briefing-Secretary Rumsfeld and Gen 2002, vol. 12. Myers. US Department of Defense.
94. Shipton Z., Cowie P. Damage zone and slip-surface evolution over μm to km scales in high-porosity Navajo sandstone, Utah. J.Struct. Geol. 2001, 23:1825-1844.
95. Shipton Z.K., Cowie P.A. Aconceptual model for the origin of fault damage zone structures in high-porosity sandstone. J.Struct. Geol. 2003, 25:333-344.
96. Shipton Z.K., Soden A.M., Kirkpatrick J.D., Bright A.M., Lunn R.J. How thick is a fault? Fault displacement-thickness scaling revisited. Earthquakes Radiated Energy Phys. Fault. 2006, 193-198.
97. Sibson R. Fault rocks and fault mechanisms. J.Geol. Soc. 1977, 133:191-213.
98. Sifuentes W.F., Giddins M.A., Blunt M.J. Modeling CO2 Storage in Aquifers: Assessing the Key Contributors to Uncertainty 2009, Offshore Europe.
99. Sloman S.A., Fernbach P.M. Human representation and reasoning about complex causal systems. Inf. Knowl. Syst. Manag. 2011, 10:85-99.
100. Stewart S. Vertical exaggeration of reflection seismic data in geoscience publications 2006-2010. Mar. Petrol. Geol. 2011, 28:959-965.
101. Stewart S. Interpretation validation on vertically exaggerated reflection seismic sections. J.Struct. Geol. 2012, 41:38-46.
102. Stirling M.W., Wesnousky S.G., Shimazaki K. Fault trace complexity, cumulative slip, and the shape of the magnitude-frequency distribution for strike-slip faults: a global survey. Geophys. J. Int. 1996, 124:833-868.
103. Suppe J. Geometry and kinematics of fault-bend folding. Am. J. Sci. 1983, 283:684-721.
104. Tacher L., Pomian-Srzednicki I., Parriaux A. Geological uncertainties associated with 3-D subsurface models. Comput. Geosci. 2006, 32:212-221.
105. Tannert C., Elvers H.D., Jandrig B. The Ethics of Uncertainty 2007, vol. 8:892-896.
106. Teixell A., Koyi H.A. Experimental and field study of the effects of lithological contrasts on thrust-related deformation. Tectonics 2003, 22.
107. Titus S., Horsman E. Characterizing and improving spatial visualization skills. J.Geosci. Educ. 2009, 57:242-254.
108. Torvela T., Bond C.E. Do experts use idealised structural models? Insights from a deepwater fold-thrust belt. J.Struct. Geol. 2011, 33:51-58.
109. Tversky A., Kahneman D. Availability: a heuristic for judging frequency and probability. Cogn. Psychol. 1973, 5:207-232.
110. Tversky A., Kahneman D. Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases. Sci. (New York, N.Y 1974, 185:1124-1131.
111. Uttal D.H., Meadow N.G., Tipton E., Hand L.L., Alden A.R., Warren C., Newcombe N.S. The malleability of spatial skills: a meta-analysis of training studies. Psychol. Bull. 2013, 139(2):352-402.
112. Vasco D.W., Karasaki K., Doughty C. Using surface deformation to image reservoir dynamics. Geophysics 2000, 65:132-147.
113. Wai J., Lubinski D., Benbow C.P. Spatial ability for STEM domains: aligning over 50 years of cumulative psychological knowledge solidifies its importance. J.Educ. Psychol. 2009, 101:817.
114. Walker W.E., Harremoës P., Rotmans J., van der Sluijs Jeroen P., van Asselt M.B., Janssen P., Krayer von Krauss Martin P. Defining uncertainty: a conceptual basis for uncertainty management in model-based decision support. Integr. Assess. 2003, 4:5-17.
115. Wellmann J.F., Horowitz F.G., Schill E., Regenauer-Lieb K. Towards incorporating uncertainty of structural data in 3D geological inversion. Tectonophysics 2010, 490:141-151.
116. Wellmann J.F., Regenauer-Lieb K. Uncertainties have a meaning: information entropy as a quality measure for 3-D geological models. Tectonophysics 2012, 526:207-216.
117. Wilkerson S.M. Differential transport and continuity of thrust sheets. J.Struct. Geol. 1992, 14:749-751.
118. Williams G., Powell C., Cooper M. Geometry and Kinematics of Inversion Tectonics 1989, 3-15. Geological Society, London, Special Publications 44.
119. Wood R., Curtis A. Geological Prior Information and its Applications to Geoscientific Problems 2004, 1-14. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 293.
120. Woodcock N.H., Fischer M. Strike-slip duplexes. J.Struct. Geol. 1986, 8:725-735.
121. Woodward N.B. Evaluation, analysis and prediction of geologic structures. J.Struct. Geol. 2012, 41:76-85.