To be or not to be alive: How recent discoveries challenge the traditional definitions of viruses and life

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C :Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences

Volumn 59, Issue , 2016, Pages 100-108

  Forterre, Patrick ^a  

^a INSTITUT PASTEUR   (France)

Author keywords

Bacteriophage; Life definition; Organism; Virocell; Virus

Indexed keywords

EVOLUTION; PHILOSOPHY; VIRAL PHENOMENA AND FUNCTIONS; VIRUS REPLICATION;

BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION; PHILOSOPHY; VIRUS PHYSIOLOGICAL PHENOMENA; VIRUS REPLICATION;

EID: 84961231101     PISSN: 13698486     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.shpsc.2016.02.013     Document Type: Article

References (102)

1. Abrescia, N.G., Bamford, D.H., Grimes, J.M., Stuart, D.I., Structure unifies the viral universe. Annual Review of Biochemistry 81 (2012), 795–822.
2. Akita, F., Chong, K.T., Tanaka, H., Yamashita, E., Miyazaki, N., Nakaishi, Y., et al. The crystal structure of a virus-like particle from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrococcus furiosus provides insight into the evolution of viruses. Journal of Molecular Biology 368 (2007), 1469–1483.
3. Baltimore, D., Expression of animal virus genomes. Bacteriological Reviews 35 (1971), 235–241.
4. Bamford, D.H., Do viruses form lineages across different domains of life?. Research in Microbiology 154 (2003), 231–236.
5. Bandea, C.I., A new theory on the origin and the nature of viruses. The Journal of Theoretical Biology 105 (1983), 591–602.
6. Bandea, C.I., The origin and evolution of viruses as molecular organisms. Nature Precedings, 2009 http://hdl.handle.net/10101/npre.2009.3886.1.
7. Bos, L., Beijerinck's work on tobacco mosaic virus: historical context and legacy. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 354 (1999), 675–685.
8. Bos, L., 100 years of virology: from vitalism via molecular biology to genetic engineering. Trends in Microbiology 8 (2000), 82–87.
9. Boyer, M., Madoui, M.A., Gimenez, G., La Scola, B., Raoult, D., Phylogenetic and phyletic studies of informational genes in genomes highlight existence of a 4 domain of life including giant viruses. PLoS One, 5(12), 2010, e15530, 10.1371/journal.pone.0015530.
10. Brüssow, H., The not so universal tree of life or the place of viruses in the living world. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 364 (2009), 2263–2274.
11. Carvunis, A.-R., Rolland, T., Wapinski, I., Calderwood, M.A., Yildirim, M.A., Simonis, N., et al. Proto-genes and de novo gene birth. Nature 487 (2012), 370–374.
12. Cello, J., Paul, A.V., Wimmer, E., Chemical synthesis of poliovirus cDNA: generation of infectious virus in the absence of natural template. Science 297 (2002), 1016–1018.
13. Chauvier, Particuliers, individus et individuation. Ludwig, P., Pradeu, T., (eds.) L'Individu. Perspectives contemporaines, 2008, 11–35 Paris: Vrin.
14. Claverie, J.M., Viruses take center stage in cellular evolution. Genome Biology, 7(6), 2006, 110.
15. Claverie, J.M., Abergel, C., Open questions about giant viruses. Advances in Virus Research 85 (2013), 25–56.
16. Claverie, J.-M., Abergel, C., Giant Viruses: The Difficult Breaking of Multiple Epistemological Barriers. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 59 (2016), 89–99.
17. Comeau, A.M., Krisch, H.M., War is peace–dispatches from the bacterial and phage killing fields. Current Opinion in Microbiology 8 (2005), 488–494.
18. Cortez, D., Forterre, P., Gribaldo, S., A hidden reservoir of integrative elements is the major source of recently acquired foreign genes and ORFans in archaeal and bacterial genomes. Genome Biology, 10, 2009, R65.
19. Daubin, V., Ochman, H., Start-up entities in the origin of new genes. Current Opinion in Genetics and Development 14 (2004), 616–619.
20. Dolja, V.V., Koonin, E.V., Capsid-less Viruses. Encyclopedia of Life Sciences. 2012, John Wiley & Sons. Ltd, Chichester.
21. Dupre, J., O'Malley, M.A., Variety of living things: life at the intersection of lineages and metabolism. Philosophy and Theory in Biology, 1, 2009, e003.
22. Dupré, J., Guttinger, S., Viruses as Living Processes. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 59 (2016), 109–116.
23. Dyall, S.D., Johnson, P.J., Origins of hydrogenosomes and mitochondria: evolution and organelle biogenesis. Current Opinion in Microbiology 3 (2000), 404–411.
24. Engels, Dialectics of Nature. 2006, Wellred Publications, London, 1–410 (Translation Dialektik der Nature, 1883).
25. Feschotte, C., Jiang, N., Wessler, S.R., Plant transposable elements: where genetics meets genomics. Nature Reviews Genetics 3 (2002), 329–341.
26. Filée, J., Route of NCLDV evolution: the genomic accordion. Current Opinion in Virology 3 (2013), 595–599.
27. Fischer, M.G., Allen, M.J., Wilson, W.H., Suttle, C.A., Giant virus with a remarkable complement of genes infects marine zooplankton. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 107 (2010), 19508–19513.
28. Forterre, P., New hypotheses about the origins of viruses, prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Trân Thanh Vân, J.K., Mounolou, J.C., Shneider, J., Mc Kay, C., (eds.) Frontiers of Life, 1992, Editions Frontières, Gif-sur-Yvette -France, 221–234 http://archaea.u-psud.fr/Forterre-Virus92.pdf.
29. Forterre, P., The origin of DNA genomes and DNA replication proteins. Current Opinion in Microbiology 5 (2002), 525–532.
30. Forterre, P., The two ages of the RNA world, and the transition to the DNA world: a story of viruses and cells. Biochimie 87 (2005), 793–803.
31. Forterre, P., The origin of viruses and their possible roles in major evolutionary transitions. Virus Research 117 (2006), 5–16.
32. Forterre, P., Three RNA cells for ribosomal lineages and three DNA viruses to replicate their genomes: a hypothesis for the origin of cellular domain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of United States of America, 103, 2006 3669–3374.
33. Forterre, P., Manipulation of cellular syntheses and the nature of viruses: the virocell concept. Comptes Rendus Chimie 4 (2011), 392–399, 10.1016/j.crci.2010.06.007.
34. Forterre, P., Giant viruses: conflicts in revisiting the virus concept. Intervirology 53 (2010), 362–378.
35. Forterre, P., Darwin's goldmine is still open: variation and selection run the world. Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology, 2, 2012, 106, 10.3389/fcimb.2012.00106.
36. Forterre, P., The Virocell Concept, 2012, eLS. John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Chichester, 10.1002/9780470015902.a0023264.
37. Forterre, P., The virocell concept and environmental microbiology. The ISME Journal 7 (2013), 233–236.
38. Forterre, P., The universal tree of life: an update. Frontiers in Microbiology, 6, 2015, 717, 10.3389/fmicb.2015.00717.
39. Forterre, P., Krupovic, M., The origin of virions and virocells: the escape hypothesis revisited. Witzany, G., (eds.) Viruses: Essential Agents of Life, 2012, Springer.
40. Forterre, P., Krupovic, M., Prangishvili, D., Cellular domains and viral lineages. Trends in Microbiology 22 (2014), 554–558.
41. Forterre, P., Prangishvili, D., The great billion-year war between ribosome- and capsid-encoding organisms (cells and viruses) as the major source of evolutionary novelties. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1178 (2009), 65–77.
42. Forterre, P., Prangishvili, D., The origin of viruses. Research In Microbiology 160 (2009), 466–472.
43. Forterre, P., Prangishvili, D., The major role of viruses in cellular evolution: facts and hypotheses. Current Opinion in Virology 3 (2013), 558–565.
44. Gaudin, M., Krupovic, M., Marguet, E., Gauliard, E., Cvirkaite-Krupovic, V., Le Cam, E., et al. Extracellular membrane vesicles harbouring viral genomes. Environmental Microbiology 16 (2014), 1167–1175.
45. Helvoort, T.V., History of virus research in the twentieth century: the problem of conceptual continuity. History of Science 32 (1994), 185–235.
46. Hulo de Castro, E., Masson, P., Bougueleret, L., Bairoch, A., Xenarios, I., Le Mercier, P., ViralZone: a knowledge resource to understand virus diver- sity. Nucleic Acids Research 39 (2011), D576–D582, 10.1093/nar/gkq901.
47. Jacob, F., Wollman, E.L., Viruses and genes. Scientific American 204 (1961), 93–107.
48. Jalasvuori, M., Bamford, J.K., Structural co-evolution of viruses and cells in the primordial world. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 38 (2008), 165–181.
49. Jalasvuori, M., Koonin, E.V., Classification of prokaryotic genetic replicators: between selfishness and altruism. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1341 (2015), 96–105, 10.1111/nyas.12696.
50. Koonin, E.V., Dolja, V.V., A virocentric perspective on the evolution of life. Current Opinion in Virology 3 (2013), 546–557.
51. Koonin, E.V., Dolja, V.V., Virus world as an evolutionary network of viruses and capsidless selfish elements. Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews 78 (2014), 278–303.
52. Koonin, E.V., Senkevich, T.G., Dolja, V.V., The ancient virus world and evolution of cells. Biology Direct, 2006(1), 2006, 29.
53. Koonin, E.V., Starokadomskyy, P., Are Viruses Alive? The Replicator Paradigm Sheds Decisive Light on an Old but Misguided Question. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 59 (2016), 125–134.
54. Koonin, E.V., Wolf, Y.I., Evolution of microbes and viruses: a paradigm shift in evolutionary biology?. Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology, 13(2), 2012, 119.
55. Kostyrka, G., What Roles for Viruses in Origin of Life Scenarios?. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 59 (2016), 135–144.
56. Kristensen, D.M., Mushegian, A.R., Dolja, V.V., Koonin, E.V., New dimensions of the virus world discovered through metagenomics. Trends in Microbiology 18 (2010), 11–19.
57. Krupovic, M., Networks of evolutionary interactions underlying the polyphyletic origin of ssDNA viruses. Current Opinion in Virology 3:5 (2013), 578–586.
58. Krupovič, M., Bamford, D.H., Order to the viral universe. Journal of Virology 84 (2010), 12476–12479.
59. López-García, P., The place of viruses in biology in light of the metabolism- versus-replication-first debate. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 34 (2012), 391–406.
60. Lopez-Garcia, P., Moreira, D., Viruses in biology. Evolution: Education & Outreach 5 (2012), 389–398.
61. Lwoff, A., Lysogeny. Bacteriological Reviews 17 (1953), 269–337.
62. Lwoff, A., The concept of virus. Journal of General Microbiology 17 (1957), 239–253.
63. Lwoff, A., Interaction among virus, cell, and organism. Science 152 (1966), 1216–1220.
64. Makarova, K.S., Wolf, Y.I., Koonin, E.V., Comparative genomics of defense systems in archaea and bacteria. Nucleic Acids Research 41 (2013), 4360–4377.
65. Méthot, P.-O., Writing the History of Virology in the Twentieth Century: Discovery, Disciplines, and Conceptual Change. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 59 (2016), 145–153.
66. Moliner, C., Fournier, P.E., Raoult, D., Genome analysis of microorganisms living in amoebae reveals a melting pot of evolution. FEMS Microbiology Reviews 34 (2010), 281–294.
67. Morange, M., Problems raised by the definition of life. Gargaud, M., Lopez-Garcia, P., Martin, H., (eds.) Origins and evolution of life, 2011, Cambrige University press, New York, 3–13.
68. Moreira, D., López-García, P., Ten reasons to exclude viruses from the tree of life. Nature Reviews Microbiology 7 (2009), 306–311.
69. Nakabachi, A., Yamashita, A., Toh, H., Ishikawa, H., Dunbar, H., Moran, N., et al. The 160-kilobase genome of the bacterial endosymbiont Carsonella. Science, 314, 2006, 267.
70. Nasir, A., Forterre, P., Kim, K.M., Caetano-Anollés, G., The distribution and impact of viral lineages in domains of life. Frontiers in Microbiology, 5, 2014, 194, 10.3389/fmicb.2014.00194.
71. Nasir, A., Kim, K.M., Caetano-Anollés, G., Viral evolution: primordial cellular origins and late adaptation to parasitism. Mobile Genetic Elements 2 (2012), 247–252.
72. Ogata, H., Claverie, J.M., Unique genes in giant viruses: regular substitution pattern and anomalously short size. Genome Research 17 (2007), 1353–1361.
73. Pace, N.R., Time for a change. Nature, 441(7091), 2006, 289.
74. Philippe, N., Legendre, M., Doutre, G., Couté, Y., Poirot, O., Lescot, M., et al. Pandoraviruses: amoeba viruses with genomes up to 2.5 Mb reaching that of parasitic eukaryotes. Science 341 (2013), 281–286.
75. Pradeu, T., What is an organism? an immunological answer. History & Philosophy of the Life Sciences 32 (2010), 247–268.
76. Pradeu, T., Mutualistic Viruses and the Heteronomy of Life. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 59 (2016), 80–88.
77. Prangishvili, D., The wonderful world of archaeal viruses. Annual Review of Microbiology 67 (2013), 565–585.
78. Prangishvili, D., Garrett, R.A., Koonin, E.V., Evolutionary genomics of archaeal viruses: unique viral genomes in the third domain of life. Virus Research 117 (2006), 52–67.
79. Quax, T.E., Voet, M., Sismeiro, O., Dillies, M.A., Jagla, B., Coppée, J.Y., et al. Massive activation of archaeal defense genes during viral infection. The Journal of Virology 87 (2013), 8419–8428.
80. Rancurel, C., Khosravi, M., Dunker, A.K., Romero, P.R., Karlin, D., Overlapping genes produce proteins with unusual sequence properties and offer insight into de novo protein creation. The Journal of Virology 83 (2009), 10719–10736.
81. Raoult, D., Audic, S., Robert, C., Abergel, C., Renesto, P., Ogata, H., et al. The 1.2-megabase genome sequence of Mimivirus. Science 306 (2004), 1344–1350.
82. Raoult, D., Forterre, P., Redefining viruses: lessons from Mimivirus. Nature Reviews Microbiology 6 (2008), 315–319.
83. Rohwer, F., Barott, K., Viral information. Biology & Philosophy 28 (2013), 283–297.
84. Ryan, R.F., Viruses as symbionts. Symbiosis 44 (2007), 11–12.
85. Ryan, F.P., Virolution. 2009, Collins, London.
86. Sapp, J., The prokaryote-eukaryote dichotomy: meanings and mythology. Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews 69 (2005), 292–305.
87. Spang, A., Saw, J.H., Jørgensen, S.L., Zaremba-Niedzwiedzka, K., Martijn, J., Lind, A.E., et al. Complex archaea that bridge the gap between prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Nature 521 (2015), 173–179.
88. Stanier, R.Y., Van Niel, C.B., The concept of a bacterium. Archiv fuer Mikrobiologie 42 (1962), 17–35.
89. Stern, A., Sorek, R., The phage-host arms race: shaping the evolution of microbes. Bioessays 33 (2011), 43–51.
90. Suttle, C.A., Viruses: unlocking the greatest biodiversity on Earth. Genome 56 (2013), 542–544.
91. Temin, H.M., The protovirus hypothesis: speculations on the significance of RNA-directed DNA synthesis for normal development and for carcinogenesis. The Journal of the National Cancer Institute 46 (1971), 3–7.
92. Thompson, L.R., Zeng, Q., Kelly, L., Huang, K.H., Singer, A.U., Stubbe, J., et al. Phage auxiliary metabolic genes and the redirection of cyanobacterial host carbon metabolism. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 27:108 (2011), 757–764.
93. Van Regenmortel, M.H., Viruses are real, virus species are man-made, taxonomic constructions. Archives of Virology 148 (2003), 2481–2488.
94. Van Regenmortel, M.H., Logical puzzles and scientific controversies: the nature of species, viruses and living organisms. Systematic and Applied Microbiology 33 (2010), 1–6.
95. van Regenmortel, M., The Metaphor that Viruses are Living is Alive and Well, but it is No More than a Metaphor. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 59 (2016), 117–124.
96. Villarreal, L.P., Virus-host symbiosis mediated by persistence. Symbiosis 44 (2007), 1–9.
97. Villarreal, L.P., Witzany, G., Viruses are essential agents within the roots and stem of the tree of life. Journal of Theoretical Biology 262 (2010), 698–710.
98. Wimmer, E., The test-tube synthesis of a chemical called poliovirus. EMBO Reports 7 (2006), 53–59.
99. Witzany, G., Viruses: Essential Agents of Life. 2012, Springer.
100. Woese, C.R., Kandler, O., Wheelis, M.L., Towards a natural system of organisms: proposal for the domains archaea, bacteria, and eucarya. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 87 (1990), 4576–4579.
101. Yin, Y., Fisher, D., Identification and investigation of ORF-ans in the viral world. BMC Genomics, 9, 2008, 24.
102. Zhao, L., Saelao, P., Jones, C.D., Begun, D.J., Origin and spread of de novo genes in Drosophila melanogaster populations. Science 343 (2014), 769–772.