Motivations, challenges, and attitudes to self-management in kidney transplant recipients: A systematic review of qualitative studies

American Journal of Kidney Diseases

Volumn 67, Issue 3, 2016, Pages 461-478

  Jamieson, Nathan J ^a,b   Hanson, Camilla S ^a,b   Josephson, Michelle A ^c   Gordon, Elisa J ^d   Craig, Jonathan C ^a,b   Halleck, Fabian ^e   Budde, Klemens ^e   Tong, Allison ^a,b  

^a CHILDREN S HOSPITAL AT WESTMEAD   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY   (Australia)

^c UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO   (United States)

^d NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^e CHARITÉ UNIVERSITÄTSMEDIZIN BERLIN   (Germany)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

AMBIGUITY; ANXIETY; ATTITUDE; AVERSION; BEHAVIOR; CINAHL; COPING BEHAVIOR; DIALYSIS; EMBASE; EMPOWERMENT; FEAR; HUMAN; KIDNEY GRAFT; LEARNING; MEDLINE; MORBIDITY; MOTIVATION; PROBLEM SOLVING; PSYCINFO; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; RESPONSIBILITY; REVIEW; RISK; SELF CARE; SYNTHESIS; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; ADAPTIVE BEHAVIOR; ADVERSE EFFECTS; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; GRAFT REJECTION; GRAFT SURVIVAL; KIDNEY FAILURE, CHRONIC; KIDNEY TRANSPLANTATION; MEDICATION COMPLIANCE; PROCEDURES; PSYCHOLOGY; REHABILITATION;

ADAPTATION, PSYCHOLOGICAL; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; GRAFT REJECTION; GRAFT SURVIVAL; HUMANS; KIDNEY FAILURE, CHRONIC; KIDNEY TRANSPLANTATION; MEDICATION ADHERENCE; MOTIVATION; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; SELF CARE;

EID: 84958862311     PISSN: 02726386     EISSN: 15236838     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1053/j.ajkd.2015.07.030     Document Type: Article

References (103)

1. E.J. Gordon, T. Prohaska, L.A. Siminoff, P.J. Minich, and A.R. Sehgal Can focusing on self-care reduce disparities in kidney transplant outcomes? Am J Kidney Dis 45 5 2005 935 940
2. L.-C. Weng, Y.-T. Dai, H.-L. Huang, and Y.-J. Chiang Self-efficacy, self-care behaviours and quality of life of kidney transplant recipients J Adv Nurs 66 4 2010 828 838
3. J.A. Butler, P. Roderick, M. Mullee, J.C. Mason, and R.C. Peveler Frequency and impact of nonadherence to immunosuppressants after renal transplantation: a systematic review Transplantation 77 5 2004 769 776
4. M.A. Chisholm-Burns, C.A. Spivey, J. Graff Zivin, J.K. Lee, E. Sredzinski, and E.A. Tolley Improving outcomes of renal transplant recipients with behavioral adherence contracts: a randomized controlled trial Am J Transplant 13 9 2013 2364 2373
5. M.A. Dew, A.F. DiMartini, A. De Vito Dabbs, and et al. Rates and risk factors for nonadherence to the medical regimen after adult solid organ transplantation Transplantation 83 7 2007 858 873
6. H. Vlaminck, B. Maes, G. Evers, and et al. Prospective study on late consequences of subclinical non-compliance with immunosuppressive therapy in renal transplant patients Am J Transplant 4 9 2004 1509 1513
7. C.A. Spivey, M.A. Chisholm-Burns, B. Damadzadeh, and D. Billheimer Determining the effect of immunosuppressant adherence on graft failure risk among renal transplant recipients Clin Transplant 28 1 2014 96 104
8. K. Adams, J.M. Corrigan, and A.C. Greiner 1st Annual Crossing the Quality Chasm Summit: A Focus on Communities 2004 National Academies Press Washington, DC
9. E.A. Engels, R.M. Pfeiffer, J.F. Fraumeni Jr., and et al. Spectrum of cancer risk among US solid organ transplant recipients JAMA 306 17 2011 1891 1901
10. F. Dobbels, P. Moons, I. Abraham, C.P. Larsen, L. Dupont, and S. De Geest Measuring symptom experience of side-effects of immunosuppressive drugs: the Modified Transplant Symptom Occurrence and Distress Scale Transplant Int 21 8 2008 764 773
11. C.M. Vajdic, S.P. McDonald, M.E. McCredie, and et al. Cancer incidence before and after kidney transplantation JAMA 296 23 2006 2823 2831
12. A.G. Jardine, R.S. Gaston, B.C. Fellstrom, and H. Holdaas Prevention of cardiovascular disease in adult recipients of kidney transplants Lancet 378 9800 2011 1419 1427
13. A. Coulter, A. Entwistle Vikki, A. Eccles, S. Ryan, S. Shepperd, and R. Perera Personalised care planning for adults with chronic or long-term health conditions Cochrane Database Syst Rev 3 2015 CD010523
14. E.K. Massey, M. Tielen, M. Laging, and et al. Discrepancies between beliefs and behavior: a prospective study into immunosuppressive medication adherence after kidney transplantation Transplantation 99 2 2015 375 380
15. M.A. Achille, A. Ouellette, S. Fournier, M. Vachon, and M.J. Hebert Impact of stress, distress and feelings of indebtedness on adherence to immunosuppressants following kidney transplantation Clin Transplant 20 3 2006 301 306
16. D. Cukor, D.S. Rosenthal, R.M. Jindal, C.D. Brown, and P.L. Kimmel Depression is an important contributor to low medication adherence in hemodialyzed patients and transplant recipients Kidney Int 75 11 2009 1223 1229
17. E.J. Gordon, T.R. Prohaska, and A.R. Sehgal The financial impact of immunosuppressant expenses on new kidney transplant recipients Clin Transplant 22 6 2008 738 748
18. K. Denhaerynck, F. Dobbels, I. Cleemput, and et al. Prevalence, consequences, and determinants of nonadherence in adult renal transplant patients: a literature review Transpl Int 18 10 2005 1121 1133
19. A. Tong, J.R. Chapman, A. Israni, E.J. Gordon, and J.C. Craig Qualitative research in organ transplantation: recent contributions to clinical care and policy Am J Transplant 13 6 2013 1390 1399
20. A. Tong, K. Flemming, E. McInnes, S. Oliver, and J. Craig Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the Synthesis of Qualitative Research: ENTREQ BMC Med Res Methodol 12 2012 181
21. S. Taylor, H. Pinnock, E. Epiphanou, and et al. A rapid synthesis of the evidence on interventions supporting self-management for people with long-term conditions: PRISMS - Practical Systematic Review of Self-Management Support for long-term conditions Health Services and Delivery Research 2 53 2014
22. J. Thomas, and A. Harden Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews BMC Med Res Methodol 8 2008 45
23. K. Goldade, S. Sidhwani, S. Patel, and et al. Kidney transplant patients' perceptions, beliefs, and barriers related to regular nephrology outpatient visits Am J Kidney Dis 57 1 2011 11 20
24. A.L. Caress, K.A. Luker, and R.G. Owens A descriptive study of meaning of illness in chronic renal disease J Adv Nurs 33 6 2001 716 727
25. A. Ghadami, R. Memarian, E. Mohamadi, and S. Abdoli Patients' experiences from their received education about the process of kidney transplant: a qualitative study Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res 17 2 suppl 1 2012 S157 S164
26. R.L. Morton, J. Devitt, K. Howard, K. Anderson, P. Snelling, and A. Cass Patient views about treatment of stage 5 CKD: a qualitative analysis of semistructured interviews Am J Kidney Dis 55 3 2010 431 440
27. C. Nadel, and J.J. Clark Psychosocial adjustment after renal retransplants Gen Hosp Psychiatry 8 1 1986 41 48
28. M. Nilsson, L.-O. Persson, and A. Forsberg Perceptions of experiences of graft rejection among organ transplant recipients striving to control the uncontrollable J Clin Nurs 17 18 2008 2408 2417
29. A. Orr, D. Orr, S. Willis, M. Holmes, and P. Britton Patient perceptions of factors influencing adherence to medication following kidney transplant Psychol Health Med 12 4 2007 509 517
30. A. Orr, S. Willis, M. Holmes, P. Britton, and D. Orr Living with a kidney transplant: a qualitative investigation of quality of life J Health Psychol 12 4 2007 653 662
31. C.L. Russell, E. Kilburn, V.S. Conn, M.K. Libbus, and C. Ashbaugh Medication-taking beliefs of adult renal transplant recipients Clin Nurse Spec 17 4 2003 200 208
32. K. Schipper, and T.A. Abma Coping, family and mastery: top priorities for social science research by patients with chronic kidney disease Nephrol Dial Transplant 26 10 2011 3189 3195
33. G. Schmid-Mohler, P. Schafer-Keller, A. Frei, T. Fehr, and R. Spirig A mixed-method study to explore patients' perspective of self-management tasks in the early phase after kidney transplant Prog Transplant 24 1 2014 8 18
34. K.W. Scott, and G.M. Hollingsworth Perceptions of a multiple kidney transplant recipient: understanding a fragile life Nephrol Nurs J 37 2 2010 161 166
35. M. Tielen, J. van Exel, M. Laging, and et al. Attitudes to medication after kidney transplantation and their association with medication adherence and graft survival: a 2-year follow-up study J Transplant 2014 2014 675301
36. M. Tielen, N.J. van Exel, M.C. van Buren, L. Maasdam, and W. Weimar Attitudes towards medication non-adherence in elderly kidney transplant patients: a Q methodology study Nephrol Dial Transplant 26 5 2011 1723 1728
37. H.S. Abram The psychiatrist, the treatment of chronic renal failure, and the prolongation of life. 3 Am J Psychiatry 128 12 1972 1534 1539
38. K. Buldukoglu, O. Kulakac, N. Kececioglu, S. Alkan, M. Yilmaz, and L. Yucetin Recipients' perceptions of their transplanted kidneys Transplantation 80 4 2005 471 476
39. E.J. Gordon, T.R. Prohaska, M. Gallant, and L.A. Siminoff Self-care strategies and barriers among kidney transplant recipients: a qualitative study Chronic Illness 5 2 2009 75 91
40. M. Howell, A. Tong, G. Wong, J.C. Craig, and K. Howard Important outcomes for kidney transplant recipients: a nominal group and qualitative study Am J Kidney Dis 60 2 2012 186 196
41. K. Schipper, T.A. Abma, C. Koops, I. Bakker, R. Sanderman, and M.J. Schroevers Sweet and sour after renal transplantation: a qualitative study about the positive and negative consequences of renal transplantation Br J Health Psychol 19 3 2014 580 591
42. K.H. Urstad, A.K. Wahl, M.H. Andersen, O. Oyen, and M.S. Fagermoen Renal recipients' educational experiences in the early post-operative phase - a qualitative study Scand J Caring Sci 26 4 2012 635 642
43. D. Wiederhold, G. Langer, and M. Landenberger Ambivalent lived experiences and instruction need of patients in the early period after kidney transplantation: a phenomenological study Nephrol Nurs J 38 5 2011 417 423 quiz 424
44. G.O. de Arruda, and R.D. Renovato [Drug utilization in renal transplant patients: medication practices and representations] Rev Gaucha Enferm 33 4 2012 157 164
45. E.J. Gordon, M. Gallant, A.R. Sehgal, D. Conti, and L.A. Siminoff Medication-taking among adult renal transplant recipients: barriers and strategies Transplant Int 22 5 2009 534 545
46. T.M. Ruppar, and C.L. Russell Medication adherence in successful kidney transplant recipients Prog Transplant 19 2 2009 167 172
47. C.L. Russell, and C. Ashbaugh The Experience of Immunosuppressive Medication Noncompliance: A Case Study 2004 Creative Age Publications Van Nuys, CA
48. A. Tong, R. Morton, K. Howard, S. McTaggart, and J.C. Craig "When I had my transplant, I became normal." Adolescent perspectives on life after kidney transplantation Pediatr Transplant 15 3 2011 285 293
49. A. Tong, P. Sainsbury, S. Chadban, and et al. Patients' experiences and perspectives of living with CKD Am J Kidney Dis 53 4 2009 689 700
50. P. Gill Stressors and coping mechanisms in live-related renal transplantation J Clin Nurs 21 11-12 2012 1622 1631
51. F. Kamran Living with a kidney transplant: perceptions and experiences Am J App Psychol 2 1 2014 5 12
52. P. Amerena, and P. Wallace Psychological experiences of renal transplant patients: a qualitative analysis Counsel Psychother Res 9 4 2009 273 279
53. L.S. Baines, J.T. Joseph, and R.M. Jindal Emotional issues after kidney transplantation: a prospective psychotherapeutic study Clin Transplant 16 6 2002 455 460
54. J. Beer Body image of patients with ESRD and following renal transplantation Br J Nurs 4 10 1995 591 598
55. J. Cerlen Problems of vocational rehabilitation for kidney transplant patients J Am Assoc Nephrol Nurses Tech 4 4 1977 167 170
56. M. Crowley-Matoka Desperately seeking "normal": the promise and perils of living with kidney transplantation Soc Sci Med 61 4 2005 821 831
57. C. Kierans Narrating kidney disease: the significance of sensation and time in the emplotment of patient experience Culture Med Psychiatry 29 3 2005 341 359
58. C.P. Kimball, and R.A. Famularo The experience of hemodialysis and renal transplantation Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2 1 1980 70 80
59. W.S.-C. Luk The HRQoL of renal transplant patients J Clin Nurs 13 2 2004 201 209
60. S.C. Martin, A.M. Stone, A.M. Scott, and D.E. Brashers Medical, personal, and social forms of uncertainty across the transplantation trajectory Qual Health Res 20 2 2010 182 196
61. M.A. Sanner Transplant recipients' conceptions of three key phenomena in transplantation: the organ donation, the organ donor, and the organ transplant Clin Transplant 17 4 2003 391 400
62. A. Stanfill, R. Bloodworth, and A. Cashion Lessons learned: experiences of gaining weight by kidney transplant recipients Prog Transplant 22 1 2012 71 78
63. R. Fisher, D. Gould, S. Wainwright, and M. Fallon Quality of life after renal transplantation J Clin Nurs 7 6 1998 553 563
64. J. Skiveren, E.L. Mortensen, and M. Haedersdal Sun protective behaviour in renal transplant recipients. A qualitative study based on individual interviews and the Health Belief Model J Dermatolog Treat 21 6 2010 331 336
65. N.C. Williams, A. Tong, K. Howard, J.R. Chapman, J.C. Craig, and G. Wong Knowledge, beliefs and attitudes of kidney transplant recipients regarding their risk of cancer Nephrology (Carlton) 17 3 2012 300 306
66. E.J. Gordon, T. Prohaska, M. Gallant, and L. Siminoff Adherence to immunosuppression: a prospective diary study Transplant Proc 39 10 2007 3081 3085
67. C.R. George, D.J. Tiller, S.M. Burrows, and L.M. Percival Life with a transplanted kidney Med J Aust 1 10 1970 461 466
68. P. Gill, and L. Lowes Gift exchange and organ donation: donor and recipient experiences of live related kidney transplantation Int J Nurs Stud 45 11 2008 1607 1617
69. H. Mead, E. Andres, C. Ramos, B. Siegel, and M. Regenstein Barriers to effective self-management in cardiac patients: the patient's experience Patient Educ Couns 79 1 2010 69 76
70. J.M. Cooper, J. Collier, V. James, and C.J. Hawkey Beliefs about personal control and self-management in 30-40 year olds living with inflammatory bowel disease: a qualitative study Int J Nurs Stud 47 12 2010 1500 1509
71. N. Jamieson, D. Fitzgerald, D. Singh-Grewal, C.S. Hanson, J.C. Craig, and A. Tong Children's experiences of cystic fibrosis: a systematic review of qualitative studies Pediatrics 133 6 2014 e1683 1697
72. E.A. Halm, P. Mora, and H. Leventhal No symptoms, no asthma∗: the acute episodic disease belief is associated with poor self-management among inner-city adults with persistent asthma Chest 129 3 2006 573 580
73. K.H. Chen, M.L. Chen, S. Lee, H.Y. Cho, and L.C. Weng Self-management behaviours for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a qualitative study J Adv Nurs 64 6 2008 595 604
74. J.K. Low, A. Williams, E. Manias, and K. Crawford Interventions to improve medication adherence in adult kidney transplant recipients: a systematic review Nephrol Dial Transplant 30 5 2014 752 761
75. L. De Bleser, M. Matteson, F. Dobbels, C. Russell, and S. De Geest Interventions to improve medication-adherence after transplantation: a systematic review Transpl Int 22 8 2009 780 797
76. E. Gordon, and M. Wolf Health literacy skills of kidney transplant recipients Prog Transplant 19 1 2009 25 34
77. E. Shemesh, R.A. Annunziato, B.L. Shneider, and et al. Improving adherence to medications in pediatric liver transplant recipients Pediatr Transplant 12 3 2008 316 323
78. O'Hare AM, Rodriguez RA, Bowling CB. Caring for patients with kidney disease: shifting the paradigm from evidence-based medicine to patient-centered care [published online ahead of print January 29, 2015]. Nephrol Dial Transplant. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfv003.
79. B. Lundahl, T. Moleni, B.L. Burke, and et al. Motivational interviewing in medical care settings: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials Patient Educ Couns 93 2 2013 157 168
80. A. Bandura Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory 1986 Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ
81. X. Bosch-Capblanch, K. Abba, M. Prictor, and P. Garner Contracts between patients and healthcare practitioners for improving patients' adherence to treatment, prevention and health promotion activities Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2 2007 CD004808
82. S. Dharancy, M. Giral, R. Tetaz, M. Fatras, L. Dubel, and G.P. Pageaux Adherence with immunosuppressive treatment after transplantation: results from the French trial PREDICT Clin Transplant 26 3 2012 E293 E299
83. D. Tsapepas, A. Langone, L. Chan, A. Wiland, K. McCague, and M. Chisholm-Burns A longitudinal assessment of adherence with immunosuppressive therapy following kidney transplantation from the Mycophenolic Acid Observational REnal Transplant (MORE) study Ann Transplant 19 2014 174 181
84. N. Ichimaru, Y. Kakuta, T. Abe, and et al. Treatment adherence in renal transplant recipients: a questionnaire survey on immunosuppressants Transplant Proc 40 5 2008 1362 1365
85. E.M. Fredericks, and D. Dore-Stites Adherence to immunosuppressants: how can it be improved in adolescent organ transplant recipients? Curr Opin Organ Transplant 15 5 2010 614 620
86. A. Brar, A. Babakhani, M.O. Salifu, and R.M. Jindal Evaluation of non-adherence in patients undergoing dialysis and kidney transplantation: United States transplantation practice patterns survey Transplant Proc 46 5 2014 1340 1346
87. A. Williams, K. Crawford, E. Manias, and et al. Examining the preparation and ongoing support of adults to take their medications as prescribed in kidney transplantation J Eval Clin Pract 21 2 2014 180 186
88. K. Griva, A. Davenport, M. Harrison, and S.P. Newman Non-adherence to immunosuppressive medications in kidney transplantation: intent vs. forgetfulness and clinical markers of medication intake Ann Behav Med 44 1 2012 85 93
89. G. Schmid-Mohler, M.P. Thut, R.P. Wüthrich, K. Denhaerynck, and S. De Geest Non-adherence to immunosuppressive medication in renal transplant recipients within the scope of the integrative model of behavioral prediction: a cross-sectional study Clin Transplant 24 2 2010 213 222
90. J.W. McGillicuddy, A.K. Weiland, R.M. Frenzel, and et al. Patient attitudes toward mobile phone-based health monitoring: questionnaire study among kidney transplant recipients J Med Internet Res 15 1 2013 e6
91. P. Schäfer-Keller, J. Steiger, A. Bock, K. Denhaerynck, and S. De Geest Diagnostic accuracy of measurement methods to assess non-adherence to immunosuppressive drugs in kidney transplant recipients Am J Transplant 8 3 2008 616 626
92. A.D. Williams, R.G. Fassett, and J.S. Coombes Exercise in CKD: why is it important and how should it be delivered? Am J Kidney Dis 64 3 2014 329 331
93. S. Heiwe, and S.H. Jacobson Exercise training in adults with CKD: a systematic review and meta-analysis Am J Kidney Dis 64 3 2014 383 393
94. E.J. Gordon, T. Prohaska, L.A. Siminoff, P.J. Minich, and A.R. Sehgal Needed: tailored exercise regimens for kidney transplant recipients Am J Kidney Dis 45 4 2005 769 774
95. S.D. Halpern, B. French, D.S. Small, and et al. Randomized trial of four financial-incentive programs for smoking cessation N Engl J Med 372 22 2015 2108 2117
96. M.E. Hilliard, A. Hahn, A.K. Ridge, M.N. Eakin, and K.A. Riekert User preferences and design recomendaiton for an mHealth App to promote cystic fibrosis self-management JMIR MHealth Uhealth 2 4 2014 e44
97. Miller AS, Cafazzo JA, Seto E. A game plan: gamification design principles in mHealth applications for chronic disease management [published online ahead of print July 1, 2014]. Health Informatics J. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1460458214537511.
98. C.-C. Lin, C.-C. Wu, R.M. Anderson, and et al. The Chronic Kidney Disease Self-efficacy (CKD-SE) instrument: development and psychometric evaluation Nephrol Dial Transplant 27 10 2012 3828 3834
99. Kosaka S, Tanaka M, Sakai T, et al. Development of self-management scale for kidney transplant recipients, including management of post-transplantation chronic kidney disease [published online ahead of print July 17, 2013]. International Scholarly Research Notices. http://dx.doi.org/10.5402/2013/619754.
100. A. Haspeslagh, K. De Bondt, D. Kuypers, M. Naesens, C. Breunig, and F. Dobbels Completeness and satisfaction with the education and information received by patients immediately after kidney transplant: a mixed-models study Prog Transplant 23 1 2013 12 22
101. G. Heck, J. Schweitzer, and M. Seidel-Wiesel Psychological effects of living related kidney transplantation - risks and chances Clin Transplant 18 6 2004 716 721
102. C. Kierans, C. Padilla-Altamira, G. Garcia-Garcia, M. Ibarra-Hernandez, and F.J. Mercado When health systems are barriers to health care: challenges faced by uninsured Mexican kidney patients PLoS One 8 1 2013 e54380
103. E.J. Gordon, and D. Conti The quality of health insurance service delivery for kidney transplant recipients: a patient perspective Am J Transplant 10 10 2010 2208 2214