Exceptions to the rule of informed consent for research with an intervention Ethics in Biomedical Research

BMC Medical Ethics

Volumn 17, Issue 1, 2016, Pages

  Rebers, Susanne ^a   Aaronson, Neil K ^a   Van Leeuwen, Flora E ^a   Schmidt, Marjanka K ^a  

^a NETHERLANDS CANCER INSTITUTE   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Consent waiver; Informed consent; Research ethics

Indexed keywords

ETHICS; HUMAN; INFORMED CONSENT; MEDICAL RESEARCH; PROFESSIONAL STANDARD; RESEARCH SUBJECT; SOCIAL CONTROL; STANDARDS;

BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH; ETHICAL REVIEW; ETHICS COMMITTEES, RESEARCH; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; RESEARCH SUBJECTS; SOCIAL CONTROL, FORMAL;

EID: 84957573253     PISSN: None     EISSN: 14726939     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1186/s12910-016-0092-6     Document Type: Article

References (125)

1. Biros M. Research without consent: Exception from and waiver of informed consent in resuscitation research. Sci Eng Ethics. 2007;13:361-9.
2. Dennis M, O'Rourke S, Slattery J, Staniforth T, Warlow C. Evaluation of a stroke family care worker: Results of a randomised controlled trial. BMJ. 1997;314:1071-6.
3. Bhagwanjee S, Muckart DJ, Jeena PM, Moodley P. Does HIV status influence the outcome of patients admitted to a surgical intensive care unit? A prospective double blind study. BMJ. 1997;314:1077-81.
4. Smith R. Should the BMJ reject all studies that do not include informed consent? BMJ. 1997;314:1059-60.
5. Biros M. Research without consent: Current status, 2003. Ann Emerg Med. 2003;42:550-64.
6. Biros MH, Fish SS, Lewis RJ. Implementing the Food and Drug Administration's final rule for waiver of informed consent in certain emergency research circumstances. Acad Emerg Med. 1999;6:1272-82.
7. Weijer C, Grimshaw JM, Taljaard M, Binik A, Boruch R, Brehaut JC, et al. Ethical issues posed by cluster randomized trials in health research. Trials. 2011;12:100.
8. Vermeulen E, Schmidt M, Aaronson N, Kuenen M, Baas-Vrancken Peeters MJ, Van der Poel H, et al. A trial of consent procedures for future research with clinically derived biological samples. Br J Cancer. 2009;101:1505-12.
9. Giraudeau B, Caille A, Le Gouge A, Ravaud P. Participant informed consent in cluster randomized trials: Review. PLoS ONE. 2012;7:e40436.
10. Adamson J, Cockayne S, Puffer S, Torgerson D. Review of randomised trials using the post-randomised consent (Zelen's) design. Contemp Clin Trials. 2006;27:305-19.
11. Beecher HK. Ethics and clinical research. New Engl J Med. 1966;274:1354.
12. Doyal L, Tobias J. Informed consent in medical research. London: BMJ Books; 2001.
13. High DM. Research with Alzheimer's disease subjects: Informed consent and proxy decision making. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1992;40:950-7.
14. Wendler D. Deception in medical and behavioral research: Is it ever acceptable? Milbank Q. 1996;74:87-114.
15. Zelen M. A new design for randomized clinical trials. New Engl J Med. 1979;300:1242-5.
16. Hutton J, Eccles M, Grimshaw J. Ethical issues in implementation research: A discussion of the problems in achieving informed consent. Implement Sci. 2008;3.
17. Little P, Williamson I. Ethics committees and the BMJ should continue to consider the overall benefit to patients. BMJ. 1997;314:1478.
18. Chanter DO. Informed consent in medical research. Risk of bias may be another reason not to seek consent. BMJ. 1997;314:1478.
19. Sutton G, Garvican L, Wilson R. Ethical principles may need to be adapted when research subject is not an individual subject. BMJ. 1997;315:251.
20. Campbell S, McCarvill E, Magee K, Cajee I, Crawford M. The Consent and Prescription Compliance (COPRECO) study: Does obtaining consent in the emergency department affect study results in a telephone follow-up study of medication compliance? Acad Emerg Med. 2008;15:932-8.
21. McRae A, Weijer C, Binik A, Grimshaw J, Boruch R, Brehaut J, et al. When is informed consent required in cluster randomized trials in health research? Trials. 2011;12:202-14.
22. Hollander J, Schears R, Shofer F, Baren J, Moretti L, Datner E. The effect of written informed consent on detection of violence in the home. Acad Emerg Med. 2001;8:974-9.
23. Parvizi J, Chakravarty R, Og B, Rodriguez-Paez A. Informed consent: Is it always necessary? Injury. 2008;39:651-5.
24. Homer C. Using the Zelen design in randomized controlled trials: Debates and controversies. J Adv Nurs. 2002;38:200-7.
25. Foëx BA. The problem of informed consent in emergency medicine research. Emerg Med J. 2001;18:198-204.
26. Dennis M. Why we didn't ask patients for their consent (commentary). BMJ. 1997;314:1077.
27. Watson R, Wilson P. Informed consent. Rigorous studies are needed to determine values of interventions. BMJ. 1997;315:250-1.
28. Schellings R, Kessels A, Ter Riet G, Knottnerus JA, Sturmans F. Randomized consent designs in randomized controlled trials: Systematic literature search. Contemp Clin Trials. 2006;27:320-32.
29. Schellings R, Kessels A, Ter Riet G, Kleijnen J, Leffers P, Knottnerus JA, et al. Members of research ethics committees accepted a modification of the randomized consent design. J Clin Epidemiol. 2005;58:589-94.
30. Turner DD. Just another drug? A philosophical assessment of randomised controlled studies on intercessory prayer. J Med Ethics. 2006;32:487-90.
31. House A, Knapp P. Informed consent. Trials that use Zelen's procedure should be acceptable. BMJ. 1997;315:251.
32. Nichol G, Powell J, Van Ottingham L, Maier R, Rea T, Christenson J, et al. Consent in resuscitation trials: Benefit or harm for patients and society? Resuscitation. 2006;70:360-8.
33. Nichol G, Huszti E. Design and implementation of resuscitation research: Special challenges and potential solutions. Resuscitation. 2007;73:337-46.
34. Kompanje EJO. No time to be lost! Ethical considerations on consent for inclusion in emergency pharmacological research in severe traumatic brain injury in the European Union. Sci Eng Ethics. 2007;13:371-81.
35. Seedat YK. No simple and absolute ethical rule exists for every conceivable situation (commentary). BMJ. 1997;314:1083-4.
36. Gammelgaard A. Informed consent in acute myocardial infarction research. J Med Philos. 2004;29:417-34.
37. Lemaire F. Informed consent for and regulation of critical care research. Curr Opin Crit Care. 2008;14:696-9.
38. Clifton G, Knudson P, McDonald M. Waiver of consent in studies of acute brain injury. J Neurotrauma. 2002;19:1121-6.
39. Kompanje EJO, Maas AIR, Hillhorst MT, Slieker FJA, Teasdale GM. Ethical considerations on consent procedures for emergency research in severe and moderate traumatic brain injury. Acta Neurochir. 2005;147:633-40.
40. Kane I, Lindley R, Lewis S, Sandercock P. Impact of stroke syndrome and stroke severity on the process of consent in the third international stroke trial. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2006;21:348-52.
41. Tobias J. BMJ's present policy (sometimes approving research in which patients have not given fully informed consent) is wholly correct. BMJ. 1997;314:1111-4.
42. Hawkins JS. The ethics of Zelen consent. J Thromb Haemost. 2004;2:882-3.
43. Berg R, Moller K, Rossel P. European legislation impedes critical care research and fails to protect patients' rights. Crit Care. 2011;15:148-9.
44. Barer D. Informed consent. Respect for autonomy may conflict with principle of beneficence. BMJ. 1997;315:254.
45. Ellenberg SS. Informed consent: Protection or obstacle? Some emerging issues. Control Clin Trials. 1997;18:628-36.
46. Nio Y, Koike M, Omori H, Hashimoto K, Itakura M, Yano S, et al. A randomized consent design trial of neoadjuvant chemotherapy with tegafur plus uracil (UFT) for gastric cancer-a single institute study. Anticancer Res. 2004;24:1879-88.
47. Dougherty A. Letter to the Editor: In defense of the PolyHeme© Trial. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:W35-7.
48. Bigatello L, George E, Hurford W. Ethical considerations for research in critically ill patients. Crit Care Med. 2003;31:S178-81.
49. Lemaire F, Brun-Buisson C. Are institutional review boards effective in safeguarding patients in intensive care units? Curr Opin Anaesthesiol. 2000;13:195-201.
50. McManus J, Mehta S, McClinton A, De Lorenzo R, Baskin T. Informed consent and ethical issues in military medical research. Acad Emerg Med. 2005;12:1120-6.
51. McCullough L. Toward ethical best practives in community consultation for research conducted with waiver of informed consent. Crit Care Med. 2008;36:993-4.
52. Morris M, Nelson R. Randomized, controlled trials as minimal risk: An ethical analysis. Crit Care Med. 2007;35:940-4.
53. Sanders A, Hiller K, Duldner J. Researchers' understanding of the federal guidelines for waiver of and exception from informed consent. Acad Emerg Med. 2005;12:1045-9.
54. Vanpee D, Gillet JB, Dupuis M. Clinical trials in an emergency setting: Implications from the fifth version of the declaration of Helsinki. J Emerg Med. 2004;26:127-31.
55. Triner W, Jacoby L, Shelton W, Burk M, Imarenakhue S, Watt J, et al. Exception from informed consent enrollment in emergency medical research: Attitudes and awareness. Acad Emerg Med. 2007;14:187-91.
56. Spence J, Notarangelo V, Frank J, Long J, Morrison L. Responses to written notification during out-of-hospital care trials using waiver of informed consent. Acad Emerg Med. 2005;12:1099-103.
57. Shamoo A. Letter to the editor: Emergency research consent waiver-a proper way. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:W48-51.
58. Ali K, Roffe C, Crome P. What patients want: consumer involvement in the design of a randomized controlled trial of routine oxygen supplementation after acute stroke. Stroke. 2006;37:865-71.
59. Cooper J. Responsible conduct of radiology research part II. Regulatory requirements for human research. Radiology. 2005;236:748-52.
60. Brown J. The spectrum of informed consent in emergency psychiatric research. Ann Emerg Med. 2006;47:68-74.
61. Contant C, McCullough L, Mangus L, Robertson C, Valadka A, Brody B. Community consultation in emergency research. Crit Care Med. 2006;34:2049-52.
62. Cummings ML. Informed consent and investigational new drug abuses in the U.S. military. Account Res. 2002;9:93-103.
63. Cone DC, O'Connor RE. Are US informed consent requirements driving resuscitation research overseas? Resuscitation. 2005;66:141-8.
64. Spellecy R. Unproven or unsatisfactory versus equipoise in emergency research with waived consent. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:44-5.
65. Schmidt TA, Delorio NM, McClure KB. The meaning of community consultation. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:30-2.
66. Derse AR. Emergency research and consent: keeping the exception from undermining the rule. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:36-7.
67. Elger CE, Hoppe C. Informed consent in off-label use and incapacitated persons. Epilepsia. 2009;50 Suppl 12:79-80.
68. Liddell K, Bion J, Chamberlain D, Druml C, Kompanje E, Lemaire F, et al. Medical research involving incapacitated adults: Implications of the EU Clinical Trials Directive 2001/20/EC. Med Law Rev. 2006;14:367-417.
69. Kipnis K, King NM, Nelson RM. Trials and errors: barriers to oversight of research conducted under the emergency research consent waiver. IRB. 2006;28:16-9.
70. Goldstein J, Delaney K, Pelletier A, Fisher J, Blanc P, Halsey M, et al. A brief educational intervention may increase public acceptance of emergency research without consent. J Emerg Med. 2010;39:419-35.
71. Case P. Confidence matters: The rise and fall of informational autonomy in medical law. Med Law Rev. 2003;11:208-36.
72. Flanagan B, Philpott S, Strosberg M. Protecting participants of clinical trials conducted in the intensive care unit. J Intensive Care Med. 2011;26:237-49.
73. Merchant R, Rubright J, Pryor J, Karlawish J. Who can speak for the emergently ill? Testing a method to identify communities and their leaders. Acad Emerg Med. 2008;15:581-3.
74. Lynch C, Houry D, Dai D, Wright D. Evidence-based community consultation for traumatic brain injury. Acad Emerg Med. 2011;18:972-6.
75. Iwanowski P. Informed consent procedure for clinical trials in emergency setting: The Polish perspective. Sci Eng Ethics. 2007;13:333-6.
76. Lemaire F. Emergency research: only possible if consent is waived? Curr Opin Crit Care. 2007;13:122-5.
77. Lewis R, Berry D, Cryer III H, Fost N, Krome R, Washington G, et al. Monitoring a clinical trial conducted under the Food and Drug Administration regulation allowing a waiver of prospective informed consent: The diaspirin cross-linked hemoglobin traumatic hemorrhagic shock efficacy trial. Ann Emerg Med. 2001;38:397-404.
78. Maitland K, Molyneux S, Boga M, Kiguli S, Lang T. Use of deferred consent for severely ill children in a multi-phase III trial. Trials. 2011;12:90-5.
79. McRae A, Ackroyd-Stolarx S, Weijer C. Risk in emergency research using a waiver of/exception from consent: Implications of a structured approach for institutional review board review. Acad Emerg Med. 2005;12:1104-12.
80. Vaslef S, Cairns C, Falletta J. Ethical and regulatory challenges associated with the exception from informed consent requirements for emergency research. From experimental design to institutional review board approval. Arch Surg. 2006;141:1019-23.
81. Ernst A, Weiss S, Nick T, Iserson K, Biros M. Minimal-risk waiver of informed consent and exception from informed consent (final rule) studies at institutional review boards nationwide. Acad Emerg Med. 2005;12:1134-7.
82. Blixen CE, Agich GJ. Stroke patients' preferences and values about emergency research. J Med Ethics. 2005;31:608-11.
83. Richardson LD, Rhodes R, Ragin DF, Wilets I. The role of community consultation in the ethical conduct of research without consent. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:33-5.
84. Silbergleit R, Watters D, Sayre MR. What treatments are "satisfactory?" divining regulatory intent and an ethical basis for exception to informed consent for emergency research. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:24-6.
85. Weiskopf RB. Food and Drug Administration public hearing on the draft guidance for exception from informed consent requirements for emergency research: Testimony of Novo Nordisk. Acad Emerg Med. 2007;14:e71-3.
86. Marshall PA, Berg JW. Protecting communities in biomedical research. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:28-30.
87. Jansen TC, Kompanje EJ, Druml C, Menon DK, Wiedermann CJ, Bakker J. Deferred consent in emergency intensive care research: What if the patient dies early? Use the data or not? Intensive Care Med. 2007;33:894-900.
88. Holloway KF. Accidental communities: Race, emergency medicine, and the problem of polyheme. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:7-17.
89. Ezeome ER, Simon C. Ethical problems in conducting research in acute epidemics: The Pfizer meningitis study in Nigeria as an illustration. Dev World Bioeth. 2010;10:1-10.
90. Bhagwanjee S, Muckart DJ, Jeena PM, Moodley P. Why we did not seek informed consent before testing patients for HIV (commentary). BMJ. 1997;314:1082-3.
91. Doyal L. Journals should not publish research to which patients have not given fully informed consent-with three exceptions. BMJ. 1997;314:1107-11.
92. Bland M. Informed consent in medical research. Let readers judge for themselves. BMJ. 1997;314:1477-8.
93. Morley C. Informed consent in medical research. Consent is not always practical in emergency treatments. BMJ. 1997;314:1480.
94. Power L. Trial subjects must be fully involved in design and approval of trials. BMJ. 1998;316:1003-4.
95. Biros MH, Runge JW, Lewis RJ, Doherty C. Emergency medicine and the development of the Food and Drug Administration's final rule on informed consent and waiver of informed consent in emergency research circumstances. Acad Emerg Med. 1998;5:359-68.
96. Clifton G, Drever P, Valadka A, Zygun D, Okonkwo D. Multicenter trial of early hypothermia in severe brain injury. J Neurotrauma. 2009;26:393-7.
97. Damsa C, Adam E, Lazignac C, Mihai A, De Gregorio F, Lejeune J, et al. A naturalistic study of consecutive agitated emergency department patients treated with intramuscular olanzapine prior to consent. Am J Psychiatry. 2008;165:535-6.
98. Kipnis K, King N, Nelson R. An open letter to institutional review boards considering Northfield Laboratories' Polyheme© trial. Am J Bioeth. 2006;6:18-21.
99. Annane D, Outin H, Fisch C, Bellissant E. The effect of waiving consent on enrollment in a sepsis trial. Intensive Care Med. 2004;30:321-4.
100. Lemaire F. A waiver of consent for intensive care research? Intensive Care Med. 2004;30:177-9.
101. Dutton R, Stansbury L, Hemlock B, Hess J, Scalea T. Impediments to obtaining informed consent for clinical research in trauma patients. J Trauma. 2008;64:1106-12.
102. Baren J, Nathanson P. Recruitment and communication process for participation in the 2005 AEM consensus conference on the ethical conduct of resuscitation research: Methodology, challenges, lessons learned. Acad Emerg Med. 2005;12:1027-30.
103. Kowey P, Ornato J. Resuscitation research and emergency waiver of informed consent. Resuscitation. 2000;47:307-10.
104. Perkins G, Woollard M, Cooke M, Deakin C, Horton J, Lall R, et al. Prehospital randomised assessment of a mechanical compression device in cardiac arrest (PaRAMeDIC) trial protocol. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2010;18:58-65.
105. Hassiotis A. Informed consent in medical research. Research in patients with mental retardation poses special problems. BMJ. 1997;314:1480-1.
106. Robinson K, Andrews P. '(More) trials and tribulations': The effect of the EU directive on clinical trials in intensive care and emergency medicine, five years after its implementation. J Med Ethics. 2010;36:322-5.
107. O'Neil C, Miller F. When scientists deceive: Applying the federal regulations. J Law Med Ethics. 2009;37:344-50.
108. Morrison CA, Horwitz I, Carrick M. Ethical and legal issues in emergency research: Barriers to conducting prospective randomized trials in an emergency setting. J Surg Res. 2009;157:115-22.
109. Shah A, Sugarman J. Protecting research subjects under the waiver of informed consent for emergency research: Experiences with efforts to inform the community. Ann Emerg Med. 2003;41:72-8.
110. Baren J, Biros M. The research on community consultation: An annotated bibliography. Acad Emerg Med. 2007;14:346-52.
111. Squire SB, Gray N, Hawley R, Hayward C, Ali A, Macfarlane S, et al. Informed consent. British institutions collaborating in projects overseas may face dilemma. BMJ. 1997;315:248.
112. Baren JM, Anicetti JP, Ledesma S, Biros MH, Mahabee-Gittens M, Lewis RJ. An approach to community consultation prior to initiating an emergency research study incorporating a waiver of informed consent. Acad Emerg Med. 1999;6:1210-5.
113. Joseph KS. Ethics in clinical research: Searching for absolutes. Can Med Assoc J. 1998;158:1303-5.
114. Evans HM. Should patients be allowed to veto their participation in clinical research? J Med Ethics. 2004;30:198-203.
115. Donner A, Klar N. Pitfalls and controversies in cluster randomization trials. Am J Public Health. 2004;94:416-22.
116. Ellwood P, Asher MI, Stewart AW, Group IPIS. The impact of the method of consent on response rates in the ISAAC time trends study. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2010;14:1059-65.
117. Rhodes R. Unsafe presumptions in clinical research. Am J Bioeth. 2002;2:49-51.
118. Soutter P. Informed consent in medical research. No one has a monopoly on deciding what is ethical. BMJ. 1997;314:1477.
119. Stewart-Brown S. Informed consent in medical research. Clinicians are being disingenuous with themselves. BMJ. 1997;314:1478-9.
120. Hulbert MF. Informed consent in medical research. Studies with important conclusions but without patient consent should be published. BMJ. 1997;314:1481.
121. Counsell CE, Sandercock PA. Informed consent in medical research. Failure to publish completed randomised controlled trials is unethical in itself. BMJ. 1997;314:1481.
122. Altman DG, Whitehead J, Parmar MK, Stenning SP, Fayers PM, Machin D. Randomised consent designs in cancer clinical trials. Eur J Cancer. 1995;31A:1934-44.
123. Sims CA, Isserman JA, Holena D, Sundaram LM, Tolstoy N, Greer S, et al. Exception from informed consent for emergency research: consulting the trauma community. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2013;74:157-65.
124. Dickert NW, Kass NE. Patients' perceptions of research in emergency settings: A study of survivors of sudden cardiac death. Soc Sci Med. 2009;68:183-91.
125. Lecouturier J, Rodgers H, Ford GA, Rapley T, Stobbart L, Louw SJ, et al. Clinical research without consent in adults in the emergency setting: A review of patient and public views. BMC Med Ethics. 2008;9:9.